Frank W. Smith
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Frank W. Smith has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Mandy Game
University of Connecticut, Department of Ecology & Evolutionary Biology, United States
6 shared publications- Bob Goldstein
Department of Biology, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA
2 shared publications Marc A. Mapalo
Museum of Comparative Zoology, Department of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA
2 shared publicationsRaul A. Chavarria
Biology Department University of North Florida Jacksonville Florida USA
2 shared publicationsBriana Arbelaez
Biology Department, University of North Florida, Jacksonville, USA
1 shared publicationChloe Ramnarine
Biology Department, University of North Florida, Jacksonville, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 13 August 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Arthropod Structure & Development
- Vol. 88, 101471
An Sp6-9 ortholog is expressed in developing legs in the tardigrade Hypsibius exemplaris
- 13 August 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Arthropod Structure & Development
- Vol. 88, 101471
Open AccessAn Sp6-9 ortholog is expressed in developing legs in the tardigrade Hypsibius exemplaris
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Current Biology
- Vol. 34 (24) , R1225-R1227
Evolution: Molting regulation by ecdysone is conserved in Tardigrada
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Current Biology
- Vol. 34 (24) , R1225-R1227
Evolution: Molting regulation by ecdysone is conserved in Tardigrada
- Open Access
- 13 November 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in EvoDevo
- Vol. 15 (1) , 1-15
Expression of distal limb patterning genes in Hypsibius exemplaris indicate regionalization and suggest distal identity of tardigrade legs
Panarthropods, a major group of invertebrate animals comprised of arthropods, onychophorans, and tardigrades, are the only limb-bearing members of Ecdysozoa. The complexity and versatility of panarthropod paired limbs has prompted great interest in their development to better understand the formation of these structures and the genes involved in this process. However, studies of limb patterning and development are overwhelmingly focused on arthropods, followed by select work on onychophorans but almost entirely lacking for tardigrades. This model organism bias is inherently limited and precludes a comparative analysis of how panarthropod legs originated, have evolved, and the likely limb patterning genes present in the earliest panarthropod ancestors. In this study, we investigated tardigrade homologs of seven arthropod distal limb patterning genes (apterous, aristaless, BarH1, clawless, Lim1, rotund, and spineless) to better characterize tardigrade limb development in a comparative context. We detected homologs of all seven genes in the eutardigrade Hypsibius exemplaris and heterotardigrade Echiniscoides cf. sigismundi suggesting their conservation in both tardigrade lineages. Hybridization chain reaction experiments in H. exemplaris reveal a regionalized expression pattern for the genes aristaless, BarH1, clawless, rotund and spineless. The observed regionalized expression of the distal limb patterning genes in H. exemplaris might reflect the external morphological features of tardigrade legs, such as the distal claws, sensory organs in the proximal region, and specific muscle attachment sites. The comparison between the expression of these limb patterning genes in H. exemplaris relative to other panarthropods suggests their conserved role in the last common panarthropod ancestor, such as establishing the distal limb end and the distribution of sensory structures. Our results support the hypothesis that tardigrade legs are homologous to the distal region of other panarthropod limbs, as suggested by previous work on the expression of leg gap genes in H. exemplaris.
- 13 November 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in EvoDevo
- Vol. 15 (1) , 1-15
Open AccessExpression of distal limb patterning genes in Hypsibius exemplaris indicate regionalization and suggest distal identity of tardigrade legs
Panarthropods, a major group of invertebrate animals comprised of arthropods, onychophorans, and tardigrades, are the only limb-bearing members of Ecdysozoa. The complexity and versatility of panarthropod paired limbs has prompted great interest in their development to better understand the formation of these structures and the genes involved in this process. However, studies of limb patterning and development are overwhelmingly focused on arthropods, followed by select work on onychophorans but almost entirely lacking for tardigrades. This model organism bias is inherently limited and precludes a comparative analysis of how panarthropod legs originated, have evolved, and the likely limb patterning genes present in the earliest panarthropod ancestors. In this study, we investigated tardigrade homologs of seven arthropod distal limb patterning genes (apterous, aristaless, BarH1, clawless, Lim1, rotund, and spineless) to better characterize tardigrade limb development in a comparative context. We detected homologs of all seven genes in the eutardigrade Hypsibius exemplaris and heterotardigrade Echiniscoides cf. sigismundi suggesting their conservation in both tardigrade lineages. Hybridization chain reaction experiments in H. exemplaris reveal a regionalized expression pattern for the genes aristaless, BarH1, clawless, rotund and spineless. The observed regionalized expression of the distal limb patterning genes in H. exemplaris might reflect the external morphological features of tardigrade legs, such as the distal claws, sensory organs in the proximal region, and specific muscle attachment sites. The comparison between the expression of these limb patterning genes in H. exemplaris relative to other panarthropods suggests their conserved role in the last common panarthropod ancestor, such as establishing the distal limb end and the distribution of sensory structures. Our results support the hypothesis that tardigrade legs are homologous to the distal region of other panarthropod limbs, as suggested by previous work on the expression of leg gap genes in H. exemplaris.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in Evolution & Development
- Vol. 26 (4)
Developmental and genomic insight into the origin of the tardigrade body plan
Tardigrada is an ancient lineage of miniaturized animals. As an outgroup of the well‐studied Arthropoda and Onychophora, studies of tardigrades hold the potential to reveal important insights into body plan evolution in Panarthropoda. Previous studies have revealed interesting facets of tardigrade development and genomics that suggest that a highly compact body plan is a derived condition of this lineage, rather than it representing an ancestral state of Panarthropoda. This conclusion was based on studies of several species from Eutardigrada. We review these studies and expand on them by analyzing the publicly available genome and transcriptome assemblies of Echiniscus testudo, a representative of Heterotardigrada. These new analyses allow us to phylogenetically reconstruct important features of genome evolution in Tardigrada. We use available data from tardigrades to interrogate several recent models of body plan evolution in Panarthropoda. Although anterior segments of panarthropods are highly diverse in terms of anatomy and development, both within individuals and between species, we conclude that a simple one‐to‐one alignment of anterior segments across Panarthropoda is the best available model of segmental homology. In addition to providing important insight into body plan diversification within Panarthropoda, we speculate that studies of tardigrades may reveal generalizable pathways to miniaturization.
- 18 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in Evolution & Development
- Vol. 26 (4)
Open AccessDevelopmental and genomic insight into the origin of the tardigrade body plan
Tardigrada is an ancient lineage of miniaturized animals. As an outgroup of the well‐studied Arthropoda and Onychophora, studies of tardigrades hold the potential to reveal important insights into body plan evolution in Panarthropoda. Previous studies have revealed interesting facets of tardigrade development and genomics that suggest that a highly compact body plan is a derived condition of this lineage, rather than it representing an ancestral state of Panarthropoda. This conclusion was based on studies of several species from Eutardigrada. We review these studies and expand on them by analyzing the publicly available genome and transcriptome assemblies of Echiniscus testudo, a representative of Heterotardigrada. These new analyses allow us to phylogenetically reconstruct important features of genome evolution in Tardigrada. We use available data from tardigrades to interrogate several recent models of body plan evolution in Panarthropoda. Although anterior segments of panarthropods are highly diverse in terms of anatomy and development, both within individuals and between species, we conclude that a simple one‐to‐one alignment of anterior segments across Panarthropoda is the best available model of segmental homology. In addition to providing important insight into body plan diversification within Panarthropoda, we speculate that studies of tardigrades may reveal generalizable pathways to miniaturization.
- Open Access
- 3 July 2023
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 120 (28)
Cambrian lobopodians shed light on the origin of the tardigrade body plan
Phylum Tardigrada (water bears), well known for their cryptobiosis, includes small invertebrates with four paired limbs and is divided into two classes: Eutardigrada and Heterotardigrada. The evolutionary origin of Tardigrada is known to lie within the lobopodians, which are extinct soft-bodied worms with lobopodous limbs mostly discovered at sites of exceptionally well-preserved fossils. Contrary to their closest relatives, onychophorans and euarthropods, the origin of morphological characters of tardigrades remains unclear, and detailed comparison with the lobopodians has not been well explored. Here, we present detailed morphological comparison between tardigrades and Cambrian lobopodians, with a phylogenetic analysis encompassing most of the lobopodians and three panarthropod phyla. The results indicate that the ancestral tardigrades likely had a Cambrian lobopodian–like morphology and shared most recent ancestry with the luolishaniids. Internal relationships within Tardigrada indicate that the ancestral tardigrade had a vermiform body shape without segmental plates, but possessed cuticular structures surrounding the mouth opening, and lobopodous legs terminating with claws, but without digits. This finding is in contrast to the long-standing stygarctid-like ancestor hypothesis. The highly compact and miniaturized body plan of tardigrades evolved after the tardigrade lineage diverged from an ancient shared ancestor with the luolishaniids.
- 3 July 2023
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 120 (28)
Open AccessCambrian lobopodians shed light on the origin of the tardigrade body plan
Phylum Tardigrada (water bears), well known for their cryptobiosis, includes small invertebrates with four paired limbs and is divided into two classes: Eutardigrada and Heterotardigrada. The evolutionary origin of Tardigrada is known to lie within the lobopodians, which are extinct soft-bodied worms with lobopodous limbs mostly discovered at sites of exceptionally well-preserved fossils. Contrary to their closest relatives, onychophorans and euarthropods, the origin of morphological characters of tardigrades remains unclear, and detailed comparison with the lobopodians has not been well explored. Here, we present detailed morphological comparison between tardigrades and Cambrian lobopodians, with a phylogenetic analysis encompassing most of the lobopodians and three panarthropod phyla. The results indicate that the ancestral tardigrades likely had a Cambrian lobopodian–like morphology and shared most recent ancestry with the luolishaniids. Internal relationships within Tardigrada indicate that the ancestral tardigrade had a vermiform body shape without segmental plates, but possessed cuticular structures surrounding the mouth opening, and lobopodous legs terminating with claws, but without digits. This finding is in contrast to the long-standing stygarctid-like ancestor hypothesis. The highly compact and miniaturized body plan of tardigrades evolved after the tardigrade lineage diverged from an ancient shared ancestor with the luolishaniids.
- Open Access
The Embryonic Origin of Primordial Germ Cells in the Tardigrade Hypsibius exemplaris
Primordial germ cells (PGCs) give rise to gametes – cells necessary for the propagation and fertility of diverse organisms. Current understanding of PGC development is limited to the small number of organisms whose PGCs have been identified and studied. Expanding the field to include little-studied taxa and emerging model organisms is important to understand the full breadth of the evolution of PGC development. In the phylum Tardigrada, no early cell lineages have been identified to date using molecular markers. This includes the PGC lineage. Here, we describe PGC development in the model tardigrade Hypsibius exemplaris . The four earliest-internalizing cells (EICs) exhibit PGC-like behavior and nuclear morphology. The location of the EICs is enriched for mRNAs of conserved PGC markers wiwi1 (water bear piwi 1) and vasa . At early stages, both wiwi1 and vasa mRNAs are detectable uniformly in embryos, which suggests that these mRNAs do not serve as localized determinants for PGC specification. Only later are wiwi1 and vasa enriched in the EICs. Finally, we traced the cells that give rise to the four PGCs. Our results reveal the embryonic origin of the PGCs of H. exemplaris and provide the first molecular characterization of an early cell lineage in the tardigrade phylum. We anticipate that these observations will serve as a basis for characterizing the mechanisms of PGC development in this animal.
Open AccessThe Embryonic Origin of Primordial Germ Cells in the Tardigrade Hypsibius exemplaris
Primordial germ cells (PGCs) give rise to gametes – cells necessary for the propagation and fertility of diverse organisms. Current understanding of PGC development is limited to the small number of organisms whose PGCs have been identified and studied. Expanding the field to include little-studied taxa and emerging model organisms is important to understand the full breadth of the evolution of PGC development. In the phylum Tardigrada, no early cell lineages have been identified to date using molecular markers. This includes the PGC lineage. Here, we describe PGC development in the model tardigrade Hypsibius exemplaris . The four earliest-internalizing cells (EICs) exhibit PGC-like behavior and nuclear morphology. The location of the EICs is enriched for mRNAs of conserved PGC markers wiwi1 (water bear piwi 1) and vasa . At early stages, both wiwi1 and vasa mRNAs are detectable uniformly in embryos, which suggests that these mRNAs do not serve as localized determinants for PGC specification. Only later are wiwi1 and vasa enriched in the EICs. Finally, we traced the cells that give rise to the four PGCs. Our results reveal the embryonic origin of the PGCs of H. exemplaris and provide the first molecular characterization of an early cell lineage in the tardigrade phylum. We anticipate that these observations will serve as a basis for characterizing the mechanisms of PGC development in this animal.
- Open Access
- 27 December 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-21
Extensive loss of Wnt genes in Tardigrada
Background: Wnt genes code for ligands that activate signaling pathways during development in Metazoa. Through the canonical Wnt (cWnt) signaling pathway, these genes regulate important processes in bilaterian development, such as establishing the anteroposterior axis and posterior growth. In Arthropoda, Wnt ligands also regulate segment polarity, and outgrowth and patterning of developing appendages. Arthropods are part of a lineage called Panarthropoda that includes Onychophora and Tardigrada. Previous studies revealed potential roles of Wnt genes in regulating posterior growth, segment polarity, and growth and patterning of legs in Onychophora. Unlike most other panarthropods, tardigrades lack posterior growth, but retain segmentation and appendages. Here, we investigated Wnt genes in tardigrades to gain insight into potential roles that these genes play during development of the highly compact and miniaturized tardigrade body plan.Results: We analyzed published genomes for two representatives of Tardigrada,Hypsibius exemplarisandRamazzottius varieornatus. We identified single orthologs ofWnt4,Wnt5,Wnt9,Wnt11, andWntA, as well as twoWnt16paralogs in both tardigrade genomes. We only found aWnt2ortholog inH. exemplaris. We could not identify orthologs ofWnt1,Wnt6,Wnt7,Wnt8, orWnt10. We identified most other components of cWnt signaling in both tardigrade genomes. However, we were unable to identify an ortholog ofarrow/Lrp5/6, a gene that codes for a Frizzled co-receptor of Wnt ligands. Additionally, we found that some other animals that have lost several Wnt genes and are secondarily miniaturized, like tardigrades, are also missing an ortholog ofarrow/Lrp5/6. We analyzed the embryonic expression patterns of Wnt genes inH. exemplarisduring developmental stages that span the establishment of the AP axis through segmentation and leg development. We detected expression of all Wnt genes inH. exemplarisbesides one of theWnt16paralogs. During embryo elongation, expression of several Wnt genes was restricted to the posterior pole or a region between the anterior and posterior poles. Wnt genes were expressed in distinct patterns during segmentation and development of legs inH. exemplaris, rather than in broadly overlapping patterns.Conclusions: Our results indicate that Wnt signaling has been highly modified in Tardigrada. While most components of cWnt signaling are conserved in tardigrades, we conclude that tardigrades have lostWnt1,Wnt6,Wnt7,Wnt8, andWnt10, along witharrow/Lrp5/6. Our expression data may indicate a conserved role of Wnt genes in specifying posterior identities during establishment of the AP axis. However, the loss of several Wnt genes and the distinct expression patterns of Wnt genes during segmentation and leg development may indicate that combinatorial interactions among Wnt genes are less important during tardigrade development compared to many other animals. Based on our results, and comparisons to previous studies, we speculate that the loss of several Wnt genes in Tardigrada may be related to a reduced number of cells and simplified development that accompanied miniaturization and anatomical simplification in this lineage.
- 27 December 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-21
Open AccessExtensive loss of Wnt genes in Tardigrada
Background: Wnt genes code for ligands that activate signaling pathways during development in Metazoa. Through the canonical Wnt (cWnt) signaling pathway, these genes regulate important processes in bilaterian development, such as establishing the anteroposterior axis and posterior growth. In Arthropoda, Wnt ligands also regulate segment polarity, and outgrowth and patterning of developing appendages. Arthropods are part of a lineage called Panarthropoda that includes Onychophora and Tardigrada. Previous studies revealed potential roles of Wnt genes in regulating posterior growth, segment polarity, and growth and patterning of legs in Onychophora. Unlike most other panarthropods, tardigrades lack posterior growth, but retain segmentation and appendages. Here, we investigated Wnt genes in tardigrades to gain insight into potential roles that these genes play during development of the highly compact and miniaturized tardigrade body plan.Results: We analyzed published genomes for two representatives of Tardigrada,Hypsibius exemplarisandRamazzottius varieornatus. We identified single orthologs ofWnt4,Wnt5,Wnt9,Wnt11, andWntA, as well as twoWnt16paralogs in both tardigrade genomes. We only found aWnt2ortholog inH. exemplaris. We could not identify orthologs ofWnt1,Wnt6,Wnt7,Wnt8, orWnt10. We identified most other components of cWnt signaling in both tardigrade genomes. However, we were unable to identify an ortholog ofarrow/Lrp5/6, a gene that codes for a Frizzled co-receptor of Wnt ligands. Additionally, we found that some other animals that have lost several Wnt genes and are secondarily miniaturized, like tardigrades, are also missing an ortholog ofarrow/Lrp5/6. We analyzed the embryonic expression patterns of Wnt genes inH. exemplarisduring developmental stages that span the establishment of the AP axis through segmentation and leg development. We detected expression of all Wnt genes inH. exemplarisbesides one of theWnt16paralogs. During embryo elongation, expression of several Wnt genes was restricted to the posterior pole or a region between the anterior and posterior poles. Wnt genes were expressed in distinct patterns during segmentation and development of legs inH. exemplaris, rather than in broadly overlapping patterns.Conclusions: Our results indicate that Wnt signaling has been highly modified in Tardigrada. While most components of cWnt signaling are conserved in tardigrades, we conclude that tardigrades have lostWnt1,Wnt6,Wnt7,Wnt8, andWnt10, along witharrow/Lrp5/6. Our expression data may indicate a conserved role of Wnt genes in specifying posterior identities during establishment of the AP axis. However, the loss of several Wnt genes and the distinct expression patterns of Wnt genes during segmentation and leg development may indicate that combinatorial interactions among Wnt genes are less important during tardigrade development compared to many other animals. Based on our results, and comparisons to previous studies, we speculate that the loss of several Wnt genes in Tardigrada may be related to a reduced number of cells and simplified development that accompanied miniaturization and anatomical simplification in this lineage.
- 1 December 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Ecology & Evolution
- Vol. 4 (12) , 1580-1581
Into the body wall and back out again
- 1 December 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Ecology & Evolution
- Vol. 4 (12) , 1580-1581
Into the body wall and back out again
- 29 July 2020
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 287 (1931) , 20201135
Loss of intermediate regions of perpendicular body axes contributed to miniaturization of tardigrades
Tardigrades have a miniaturized body plan. Miniaturization in tardigrades is associated with the loss of several organ systems and an intermediate region of their anteroposterior (AP) axis. However, how miniaturization has affected tardigrade legs is unclear. In arthropods and in onychophorans, the leg gap genes are expressed in regionalized proximodistal (PD) patterns in the legs. Functional studies indicate that these genes regulate growth in their respective expression domains and establish PD identities, partly through mutually antagonistic regulatory interactions. Here, we investigated the expression patterns of tardigrade orthologs of the leg gap genes. Rather than being restricted to a proximal leg region, as in arthropods and onychophorans, we detected coexpression of orthologues ofhomothoraxandextradenticlebroadly across the legs of the first three trunk segments in the tardigradeHypsibius exemplaris. We could not identify adachshundorthologue in tardigrade genomes, a gene that is expressed in an intermediate region of developing legs in arthropods and onychophorans, suggesting that this gene was lost in the tardigrade lineage. We detectedDistal-lessexpression broadly across all developing leg buds inH. exemplarisembryos, unlike in arthropods and onychophorans, in which it exhibits a distally restricted expression domain. The broad expression patterns of the remaining leg gap genes inH. exemplarislegs may reflect the loss ofdachshundand the accompanying loss of an intermediate region of the legs in the tardigrade lineage. We propose that the loss of intermediate regions of both the AP and PD body axes contributed to miniaturization of Tardigrada.
- 29 July 2020
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 287 (1931) , 20201135
Loss of intermediate regions of perpendicular body axes contributed to miniaturization of tardigrades
Tardigrades have a miniaturized body plan. Miniaturization in tardigrades is associated with the loss of several organ systems and an intermediate region of their anteroposterior (AP) axis. However, how miniaturization has affected tardigrade legs is unclear. In arthropods and in onychophorans, the leg gap genes are expressed in regionalized proximodistal (PD) patterns in the legs. Functional studies indicate that these genes regulate growth in their respective expression domains and establish PD identities, partly through mutually antagonistic regulatory interactions. Here, we investigated the expression patterns of tardigrade orthologs of the leg gap genes. Rather than being restricted to a proximal leg region, as in arthropods and onychophorans, we detected coexpression of orthologues ofhomothoraxandextradenticlebroadly across the legs of the first three trunk segments in the tardigradeHypsibius exemplaris. We could not identify adachshundorthologue in tardigrade genomes, a gene that is expressed in an intermediate region of developing legs in arthropods and onychophorans, suggesting that this gene was lost in the tardigrade lineage. We detectedDistal-lessexpression broadly across all developing leg buds inH. exemplarisembryos, unlike in arthropods and onychophorans, in which it exhibits a distally restricted expression domain. The broad expression patterns of the remaining leg gap genes inH. exemplarislegs may reflect the loss ofdachshundand the accompanying loss of an intermediate region of the legs in the tardigrade lineage. We propose that the loss of intermediate regions of both the AP and PD body axes contributed to miniaturization of Tardigrada.
- 10 December 2019
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 127-174
Theme and Variation in the Development of Insect Mouthparts
- 10 December 2019
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 127-174
Theme and Variation in the Development of Insect Mouthparts