BPBarbara Prediger

Barbara Prediger

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Barbara Prediger has a total of 81 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:

  • Dawid Pieper

    Faculty of Health Sciences Brandenburg, Brandenburg Medical School Theodor Fontane, Institute for Health Services and Health System Research, Rüdersdorf, Germany

    8 shared publications
  • Dawid Pieper

    Institut für Forschung in der Operativen Medizin (IFOM), Universitat Witten/Herdecke Fakultat fur Gesundheit, Köln, Germany

    7 shared publications
  • Nadja Könsgen

    Institut für Forschung in der Operativen Medizin (IFOM), Universitat Witten/Herdecke Fakultat fur Gesundheit, Köln, Germany

    7 shared publications
  • Tim Mathes

    Department of Medical Statistics, University Medical Center Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany

    6 shared publications
  • Edmund Neugebauer

    Campus Neuruppin, Medizinische Hochschule Brandenburg (MHB), Neuruppin, Germany

    5 shared publications
  • Susann May

    German Heart Center of the Charité - Department of Cardiology, Angiology and Intensive Care Medicine, Berlin, Germany

    4 shared publications

Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Simulated patient methodology applied in health services research: a scoping review

    by Alexander Pachanov, Nadja Könsgen, Jessica Breuing, Barbara Prediger, Anna-Maria Zeitler, Dawid Pieper

    Background: The simulated patient (SP) methodology is a valuable tool in health services research, allowing for the assessment of healthcare providers’ (HCPs) real-world behavior and performance through covert interactions. Although several evidence syntheses have examined its application in pharmaceutical settings, there is a gap in synthesizing recent research findings in other healthcare disciplines. Therefore, we aimed to map the application of the SP method in non-pharmaceutical healthcare settings. Methods: We conducted a scoping review, following the updated JBI (formerly Joanna Briggs Institute) guidance for scoping reviews. In October 2023, we searched MEDLINE (PubMed) and Embase (Elsevier) databases. We focused on peer-reviewed journal reports of primary studies of any design, published from May 2004 onwards, in English or German, that covertly utilized SPs in non-pharmaceutical healthcare settings. Two reviewers independently screened records and reports. Data extraction was conducted by one reviewer and validated by another one. We presented findings in table and diagram formats, accompanied by a narrative summary. Results: Our search identified 1,796 records, with 163 reports meeting the eligibility criteria. Between 2004 and 2023, the use of SP methodology in non-pharmaceutical healthcare settings increased, with nearly twice as many reports published between 2014 and 2023 compared to the previous decade. The median number of SP-HCP contacts was 202.5, with a median of eight SPs per study. Most reports originated from North America (63.8%), followed by Africa and Asia (each 12.9%). Interactions primarily occurred in clinics (39.9%) and practices (36.8%), with face-to-face (58.9%) and telephone (42.9%) being the most common modes of interaction. 48.5% of reports indicated that HCPs were informed of covert assessments by SPs before the study began. Many reports lacked details on HCP specialties (41.1%) and professions (46.0%). Post-study feedback to HCPs was rarely reported (7.4%), and ethics approval processes varied, with 12.3% of reports not addressing them at all. Conclusions: Over the past two decades, the SP methodology has been widely adopted across various regions and settings. However, inconsistent reporting and varying ethical considerations highlight the need for clearer guidelines to enhance the reliability and educational value of SP studies, ultimately leading to improved HCP practices and patient care quality. Scoping review registration: https://osf.io/8z9tn .

  • Wartezeit auf einen Zweitmeinungstermin für Tonsillektomie/Tonsillotomie – eine Simulated Patients Studie

    by Barbara Prediger, Louis Traxel, Nadja Könsgen, Niklas Schäfer, Dawid Pieper

    Zusammenfassung: Seit Dezember 2018 können sich gesetzlich Krankenversicherte mit Indikation zur Tonsillektomie/Tonsillotomie eine Zweitmeinung (ZM) im Rahmen der ZM-Richtlinie einholen. Es ist vorgeschrieben, dass die Aufklärung über das Recht zur ZM-Einholung „in der Regel mindestens 10 Tage vor dem geplanten Eingriff zu erfolgen [hat], in jedem Fall aber so rechtzeitig, dass die Patientin oder der Patient die Entscheidung über die Einholung einer Zweitmeinung wohlüberlegt treffen kann“. Das Ziel war die Erhebung, wie lange Patient*innen auf einen Termin zur ZM warten müssen. Im Rahmen dieser Simulated Patients Studie wurden alle Praxen mit Zweitmeiner*innen im Bereich der Hals-Nasen-Ohren Heilkunde der Kassenärztlichen Vereinigungen Nordrhein und Westfalen-Lippe (N=53 Praxen) telefonisch zwischen Januar und Februar 2022 bis zu dreimal kontaktiert. Anhand eines standardisierten und pilotierten Protokolls wurde angegeben, dass eine Indikation zur Tonsillektomie/Tonsillotomie vorliege und man einen Termin für eine ZM vereinbaren wolle. Dabei wurde die Wartezeit auf einen Termin erhoben, die Möglichkeit zur ZM-Einholung per Videosprechstunde und ob weitere Fragen oder Angaben in diesem Telefonat gemacht wurden (z. B. Verweis auf mitzubringende Unterlagen). Insgesamt konnten 94,4% (50/53) der Praxen erreicht werden. Bei der überwiegenden Mehrheit (92% (46/50)) wurde für die ZM ein Termin vereinbart, bei drei anderen Praxen gab es offene Sprechstunden und eine Praxis bot beide Möglichkeiten an. Vormittagstermine bis 12 Uhr konnten im Mittel innerhalb von 8,1 (Standardabweichung 5,4) Werktagen und Nachmittagstermine ab 15 Uhr innerhalb von 10,1 (Standardabweichung 5,9) Werktagen vereinbart werden. Die Erreichbarkeit der Praxen war hoch. Die ZM-Einholung dauerte in 31% der vorgeschlagenen Termine länger als 10 Werktage, sodass insgesamt von geringen Wartezeiten gesprochen werden kann. Grundsätzlich sollte den Patient*innen ein zeitnaher Termin für eine ZM zur Verfügung gestellt werden, was innerhalb der Kassenärztlichen Vereinigung Nordrhein und Westfalen-Lippe möglich ist. Sehr selten wird die ZM per Videosprechstunde angeboten. Möglicherweise könnte dies aber die ländliche Versorgung durch Zweitmeiner*innen steigern.

  • Open Access

    Initial surgical management of injuries to the lower extremities in patients with multiple and/or severe injuries – A systematic review and clinical practice guideline update

    by Kai Oliver Jensen, Barbara Prediger, Nadja Könsgen, Michel Paul Johan Teuben

    Purpose: Our aim was to develop new evidence-based and consensus-based recommendations for the initial inhospital management of lower-extremity injuries in patients with multiple and/or severe trauma. This guideline topic is part of the 2022 update of the German Guideline on the Treatment of Patients with multiple and/or severe Injuries. Methods: MEDLINE and Embase were systematically searched to May 2021. Randomised controlled trials, prospective cohort studies, and comparative registry studies were included if they compared interventions for the initial surgical and non-surgical management of fractures, dislocations or vascular injuries of the lower extremities in patients with multiple and/or severe trauma. We considered patient-relevant clinical outcomes such as mortality, complication rates, length of stay, and function. Risk of bias was assessed using NICE 2012 checklists. The evidence was synthesised narratively, and expert consensus was used to develop recommendations and determine their strength. Results: Eleven studies were identified. They addressed time to definitive fixation (n = 10 studies) and amputation (n = 1). Two new recommendations were developed, one was modified. All recommendations achieved strong consensus. Conclusion: This systematic literature review and subsequent expert consensus process resulted in the following new key recommendations. It is recommended that isolated and multiple lower-extremity fractures are managed with primary definitive fixation in patients whose condition is stable. Patients condition is not considered stable should be managed with primary temporary fixation. In addition, it is recommended that dislocations of the lower extremities are reduced and immobilised as early as possible.


  • Inanspruchnahme von Zweitmeinungen in Deutschland – eine Analyse von Abrechnungsdaten der AOK Nordost

    by Dunja Bruch, Olga Resch, Stephanie Sehlen, Barbara Prediger, Filip Schröter, Achim Franzen, Cecile Ronckers, Edmund Neugebauer, Susann May

    Zusammenfassung: Ziel Das Ziel dieser Abrechnungsdatenanalyse ist es, die Umsetzung der Zweitmeinungsrichtlinie (ZM-RL) in Deutschland zu untersuchen und zu analysieren, wie häufig die Aufklärung über das Recht auf eine Zweitmeinung (ZM) und die Erbringung einer ZM dokumentiert werden. Methodik Es wurden Versicherte eingeschlossen, für die in 2019 oder 2020 die Aufklärung über das Recht auf eine ZM oder die Inanspruchnahme einer ZM für die Indikationen Tonsillektomie, Tonsillotomie, Hysterektomie oder in Q2-Q3 2020 für Schulterarthroskopie abgerechnet wurde. Die Daten wurden deskriptiv ausgewertet. Ergebnisse Im untersuchten Zeitraum wurden 5307 Eingriffe bei den betrachteten Indikationen durchgeführt. Insgesamt wurde bei 121 Patient:innen mit einem Eingriff die Aufklärung über das Recht auf ZM dokumentiert und bei 12 Patient:innen mit einem Eingriff eine ZM abgerechnet. Der Anteil der dokumentierten Aufklärungen im Vergleich zur OP-Zahl war bei Tonsillektomie/Tonsillotomie<18 Jahre am höchsten (4%) und bei Schulterarthroskopie am niedrigsten (0,6%). Bei keinem Versicherten wurde im definierten Zeitraum sowohl die Aufklärung als auch die Inanspruchnahme einer ZM abgerechnet. Schlussfolgerung Die vorliegende Abrechnungsdatenanalyse zeigt, dass die Aufklärung über das Recht auf eine ZM nach Richtlinie sowie die Einholung einer solchen ZM noch nicht wie gesetzlich vorgesehen in der Regelversorgung implementiert ist.

  • Open Access

    Decision for elective surgery - how well informed are patients and how easy is the decision for them?

    by Barbara Prediger, Nadja Könsgen, Fabian Schlumberger, Lena Heinen, Anna Schlimbach, Simone Hess, Susann May, Dunja Bruch, Sebastian Liersch, Stephanie Sehlen, et al.

    Background: Decisions for elective surgery are difficult for many patients and some regret them afterwards. The aim of this survey of patients who have undergone elective tonsillectomy/tonsillotomy (TE/TT), hysterectomy (HE) or shoulder arthroscopy (SA) was to investigate the decision process, need for information and need for second opinion. Methods: In October 2020, n=8,862 persons insured at AOK Nordost who had undergone TE/TT, HE and SA were invited by post to participate. A reminder was sent in November 2020. Results were analysed descriptively. Results: A total of n=1,633 responses were received (participation rate 18%). Around half (54 %) of the participants felt that the decision to undergo surgery was (very) easy. Overall, the participants felt (very) well informed about the benefits of surgery (79%), the disease (76%), treatment alternatives (66%) and the risks/ side effects of surgery (67%) after the consultation with the physician recommending surgery, 29 % sought a second opinion. Conclusion: The majority of respondents seemed well informed after the consultation with the physician recommending surgery. Information about treatment alternatives and risks/ side effects of the surgery might be improvable. Prospective studies looking at the decision process before surgery would allow a clearer statement about contribution of aspects to an informed decision.

  • Open Access

    Prehospital management of chest injuries in severely injured patients—a systematic review and clinical practice guideline update

    by Christian Waydhas, Barbara Prediger, Oliver Kamp, Christian Kleber, André Nohl, Stefan Schulz-Drost, Christof Schreyer, Robert Schwab, Manuel Florian Struck, Jessica Breuing, et al.

    Purpose: Our aim was to review and update the existing evidence-based and consensus-based recommendations for the management of chest injuries in patients with multiple and/or severe injuries in the prehospital setting. This guideline topic is part of the 2022 update of the German Guideline on the Treatment of Patients with Multiple and/or Severe Injuries. Methods: MEDLINE and Embase were systematically searched to May 2021. Further literature reports were obtained from clinical experts. Randomised controlled trials, prospective cohort studies, cross-sectional studies, and comparative registry studies were included if they compared interventions for the detection and management of chest injuries in severely injured patients in the prehospital setting. We considered patient-relevant clinical outcomes such as mortality and diagnostic test accuracy. Risk of bias was assessed using NICE 2012 checklists. The evidence was synthesised narratively, and expert consensus was used to develop recommendations and determine their strength. Results: Two new studies were identified, both investigating the accuracy of in-flight ultrasound in the detection of pneumothorax. Two new recommendations were developed, one recommendation was modified. One of the two new recommendations and the modified recommendation address the use of ultrasound for detecting traumatic pneumothorax. One new good (clinical) practice point (GPP) recommends the use of an appropriate vented dressing in the management of open pneumothorax. Eleven recommendations were confirmed as unchanged because no new high-level evidence was found to support a change. Conclusion: Some evidence suggests that ultrasound should be considered to identify pneumothorax in the prehospital setting. Otherwise, the recommendations from 2016 remained unchanged.


  • Open Access

    Does the second opinion directive in Germany reach the patient? A parallel-convergent mixed-methods study

    by Susann May, Nadja Könsgen, Angelina Glatt, Dunja Bruch, Felix Muehlensiepen, Sonja Mählmann, Sebastian von Peter, Dawid Pieper, Edmund Neugebauer, Barbara Prediger

    Background: A Second Opinion Directive (SOD) was introduced in Germany in December 2018 for elective surgeries such as hysterectomy, tonsillotomy, tonsillectomy, and shoulder arthroscopy. The aim of the SOD is to avoid surgeries which are not medically induced and to support patients in their decision-making process. A physician who indicates an SOD-relevant procedure must inform the patient about the SOD and its specifications. At this time, it is not clear whether physicians provide information about the SOD to patients and whether and how the SOD is implemented in daily practice. Furthermore, nothing is known about how patients react when they are told that they have the right to seek a second opinion according to the SOD. Methods: To assess this, we undertook a parallel-convergent mixed-methods study with a qualitative and quantitative phase. Qualitative data were analysed by structured qualitative content analysis and survey data were analysed descriptively. Results: 26 interviews were conducted with patients for whom one of the above-mentioned surgeries was indicated. In parallel, a questionnaire survey with 102 patients was conducted. The results show that the SOD is not implemented in Germany for the selected indications because patients were not informed as intended. At the same time, when the right to obtain a second opinion was explained, it seemed to have a positive effect on the physician-patient relationship from patients` perspective. Conclusions: It is possible that there is a lack of information for physicians, which in turn leads to an information deficit for patients. Better information for physicians might be part of the solution, but a negative attitude towards the SOD might also result in the low education rate. Therefore, in addition, potential patients or even the general population should be better informed about the possibility of obtaining a second opinion.


  • Open Access

    Consideration of the information needs of pregnant women with elective caesarean section in antenatal classes – a qualitative study from the perspective of midwives v1

    by Sandra Jaax, Barbara Prediger, Nadja Könsgen

    Background: Qualitative studies show that pregnant women often feel inadequately prepared for a caesarean section (CS) in antenatal classes. To date, no data have been published in Germany on the attendance of antenatal classes by women with elective CS, nor are the reasons for their attendance or non-attendance known. Antenatal classes offer pregnant women a lot of valuable information beyond the topic of vaginal birth, therefore they are also important for pregnant women with elective CS. The study will explore the demand for antenatal classes among pregnant women with elective CS from the midwives perspective, along with factors that either hinder or promote their attendance. Additionally, the study aims to assess the information needs of pregnant women with elective CS in antenatal classes from the midwives' perspective and how these information needs could be addressed better in antenatal classes as well as the extent to which (elective) CS is covered in antenatal classes. Methods: The study population consists of midwives who practice in Germany, currently provide antenatal classes and are experienced in giving antenatal classes. In their antenatal classes, they should have experience with pregnant women withelective CS, if possible. The study will be conducted as semi-structured expert interviews and the data will be evaluated using Mayring’s qualitative content analysis. Discussion: This study is an opportunity to gain a comprehensive picture from the midwives’ perspective. It will be complemented by a mixed-methods study exploring the topic from the perspective of pregnant women with elective CS. The midwives’ perspective allows for an overarching perspective including whether suggestions for improvement can be implemented. A possible selection bias in the study population may limit the results. Midwives who value CS education are more likely to participate in the study than those who do not. Ethics: Ethical approval for the study was obtained by the Medical Ethics Committee of the University of Witten/Herdecke. Results will be published in a relevant scientific journal and communicated to interested participants (when demanded). Ethical approval date: October 04, 2023Estimated start of the study: October 2023Detailed information on our protocol can be found in the attached PDF file.


  • Open Access

    Online Survey Among Pregnant Women With Medical Indication Or Wish For Elective Caesarean Section On Second Opinions In Germany: Study Protocol v1

    by Nadja Könsgen, Anke Kaulbert, Barbara Prediger

    Background: Caesarean section (CS) rates have been continuously rising worldwide over the last decade without being accompanied by significant health benefits. Various approaches are discussed internationally to limit the proportion of caesarean deliveries to the necessary cases. The proposed study aims to assess the perspective of pregnant women with medical indication or wish for elective CS on second opinions The goal is to examine whether they consider a second opinion useful to facilitate their decision-making and/or certainty for the mode of delivery, and under which circumstances they would seek a second opinion. Methods: The study population will comprise adult pregnant women (18 years or older) with medical indication or wish for elective CS (both currently pregnant women and persons for whom the indication was given in a past pregnancy). The survey will be conducted online and the data will be evaluated using quantitative descriptive analysis. Discussion: The survey is an opportunity to get a comprehensive picture from the perspective of pregnant women. In combination with our survey of health professionals it paves the way for following research in this area.The results might be limited by a possible selection bias of the study population.

  • Open Access

    Second opinion opportunity declined: patient typology and experiences regarding the decision-making process preceding elective surgeries in Germany

    by Susann May, Dunja Bruch, Felix Muehlensiepen, Barbara Prediger, Dawid Pieper, Cecile Ronckers, Sebastian von Peter, Edmund Neugebauer

    To address the problem of overuse of elective surgery and to support patients in their decision-making process, a Second Opinion Directive was introduced in Germany, which enables patients with statutory health insurance to obtain a second opinion for certain surgical indications. The study aims to identify, based on the experiences of patients who have undergone elective surgery, the role of seeking a second opinion in reaching their decision. Sixty-two patients who had undergone an elective surgery (hysterectomy, tonsillectomy, shoulder arthroscopy) were recruited using purposive sampling and interviewed during October to December 2020. The transcribed interviews were analysed using a framework analysis to create a typology from the patient’s perspective. The time spent by patients in making the decision to undergo surgery varies between individuals, and is influenced by factors such as the type of physician-patient relationship, individual patient aspects, prior experiences in the health care system, as well as information needs. Within the framework of the analysis, we were able to identify three patterns of patient types based on the three different time-points or phases when decisions were typically made, with one type being divided into two subtypes: Type 1a: Quick decision making, Type 1b: Overwhelmed quick decision making, Type 2: Time to consider, Type 3: Struggling with the decision. Patients who followed a recommendation for elective surgery appreciate having the possibility to seek a second opinion. However, various factors influenced their opting for a second opinion during the decision-making process. Patients have differing information needs, such that a one-size-fits-all second opinion service may not fit adequately for all patients.