Zoe Porter
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Zoe Porter has a total of 38 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ibrahim Habli
University of York, York, UK
8 shared publications - John McDermid
University of York
4 shared publications - Phillip Morgan
York Law School, University of York, UK
4 shared publications - Marten H. L. Kaas
Institute for Safe Autonomy, University of York, Heslington, UK
3 shared publications - Philippa Ryan
University of York
3 shared publications - Tom Lawton
Improvement Academy, Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Bradford, UK
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 August 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Autonomous and Adaptive Systems
INSYTE: A Classification Framework for Traditional to Agentic AI Systems
Existing classification frameworks for artificial intelligence (AI) and autonomous systems are being outpaced by recent advancements in AI technologies. This limits their applicability to modern intelligent systems, particularly agentic AI systems (autonomous systems that leverage foundation models to achieve wide-ranging, multi-layered goals). To address this deficiency, we introduce INSYTE, a multi-faceted framework that supports the classification of AI systems ranging from traditional rule-based systems to cutting-edge embodied AI and agentic systems. To that end, INSYTE considers the essential characteristics of an AI system across eight key dimensions grouped into four categories: system design ( underspecification and adaptiveness ); functionality ( breadth and depth ); operating environment ( diversity and dynamism ); and independence from human operational control ( intervention and oversight ). Different AI systems (or versions of systems) yield different “patterns” on an eight-axis radar chart that INSYTE uses to provide an immediate visual summary of an AI system's overall capability, and a detailed representation of its individual characteristics. The INSYTE framework aligns with OECD's definition of deployed AI systems, which is becoming the standard definition used by legislators and developers worldwide.
- 20 August 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Autonomous and Adaptive Systems
Open AccessINSYTE: A Classification Framework for Traditional to Agentic AI Systems
Existing classification frameworks for artificial intelligence (AI) and autonomous systems are being outpaced by recent advancements in AI technologies. This limits their applicability to modern intelligent systems, particularly agentic AI systems (autonomous systems that leverage foundation models to achieve wide-ranging, multi-layered goals). To address this deficiency, we introduce INSYTE, a multi-faceted framework that supports the classification of AI systems ranging from traditional rule-based systems to cutting-edge embodied AI and agentic systems. To that end, INSYTE considers the essential characteristics of an AI system across eight key dimensions grouped into four categories: system design ( underspecification and adaptiveness ); functionality ( breadth and depth ); operating environment ( diversity and dynamism ); and independence from human operational control ( intervention and oversight ). Different AI systems (or versions of systems) yield different “patterns” on an eight-axis radar chart that INSYTE uses to provide an immediate visual summary of an AI system's overall capability, and a detailed representation of its individual characteristics. The INSYTE framework aligns with OECD's definition of deployed AI systems, which is becoming the standard definition used by legislators and developers worldwide.
- Open Access
- 23 July 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Responsible Technology
- Vol. 23
Unravelling responsibility for AI
- 23 July 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Responsible Technology
- Vol. 23
Open AccessUnravelling responsibility for AI
- Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1607-1619
Development and translation of human-AI interaction models into working prototypes for clinical decision-making
In the standard interaction model of clinical decision support systems, the system makes a recommendation, and the clinician decides whether to act on it. However, this model can compromise the patient-centeredness of care and the level of clinician involvement. There is scope to develop alternative interaction models, but we need methods for exploring and comparing these to assess how they may impact clinical decision-making. Through collaborating with clinical, AI safety, and HCI experts, and patient representatives, we co-designed a number of alternative human-AI interaction models for clinical decision-making. We then translated these models into ‘Wizard of Oz’ prototypes, where we created clinical scenarios and designed user interfaces with different types of AI output. In this paper, we present alternative models of human-AI interaction and illustrate how we used a co-design approach to translate them into functional prototypes that can be tested with users to explore potential impacts on clinical decision-making.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1607-1619
Open AccessDevelopment and translation of human-AI interaction models into working prototypes for clinical decision-making
In the standard interaction model of clinical decision support systems, the system makes a recommendation, and the clinician decides whether to act on it. However, this model can compromise the patient-centeredness of care and the level of clinician involvement. There is scope to develop alternative interaction models, but we need methods for exploring and comparing these to assess how they may impact clinical decision-making. Through collaborating with clinical, AI safety, and HCI experts, and patient representatives, we co-designed a number of alternative human-AI interaction models for clinical decision-making. We then translated these models into ‘Wizard of Oz’ prototypes, where we created clinical scenarios and designed user interfaces with different types of AI output. In this paper, we present alternative models of human-AI interaction and illustrate how we used a co-design approach to translate them into functional prototypes that can be tested with users to explore potential impacts on clinical decision-making.
- Open Access
- 3 April 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in Computer
- Vol. 57 (4) , 16-25
The Safety of Autonomy: A Systematic Approach
Autonomy does not subvert existing safety processes, but they must be supplemented with methods that address autonomy’s challenges, especially where perception and decision-making tasks are implemented with machine learning. We present an approach to address the safety of autonomous systems, building on and complementing established safety engineering methods.
- 3 April 2024
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in Computer
- Vol. 57 (4) , 16-25
Open AccessThe Safety of Autonomy: A Systematic Approach
Autonomy does not subvert existing safety processes, but they must be supplemented with methods that address autonomy’s challenges, especially where perception and decision-making tasks are implemented with machine learning. We present an approach to address the safety of autonomous systems, building on and complementing established safety engineering methods.
- Open Access
- 11 July 2023
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1-13
Ethics in conversation
- 11 July 2023
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1-13
Open AccessEthics in conversation
- Open Access
- 11 July 2023
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1-10
Safety engineering, role responsibility and lessons from the Uber ATG Tempe Accident
- 11 July 2023
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1-10
Open AccessSafety engineering, role responsibility and lessons from the Uber ATG Tempe Accident
- Open Access
- 6 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in AI and Ethics
- Vol. 4 (2) , 593-616
A principles-based ethics assurance argument pattern for AI and autonomous systems
An assurance case is a structured argument, typically produced by safety engineers, to communicate confidence that a critical or complex system, such as an aircraft, will be acceptably safe within its intended context. Assurance cases often inform third party approval of a system. One emerging proposition within the trustworthy AI and autonomous systems (AI/AS) research community is to use assurance cases to instil justified confidence that specific AI/AS will be ethically acceptable when operational in well-defined contexts. This paper substantially develops the proposition and makes it concrete. It brings together the assurance case methodology with a set of ethical principles to structure a principles-based ethics assurance argument pattern. The principles are justice, beneficence, non-maleficence, and respect for human autonomy, with the principle of transparency playing a supporting role. The argument pattern—shortened to the acronym PRAISE—is described. The objective of the proposed PRAISE argument pattern is to provide a reusable template for individual ethics assurance cases, by which engineers, developers, operators, or regulators could justify, communicate, or challenge a claim about the overall ethical acceptability of the use of a specific AI/AS in a given socio-technical context. We apply the pattern to the hypothetical use case of an autonomous ‘robo-taxi’ service in a city centre.
- 6 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in AI and Ethics
- Vol. 4 (2) , 593-616
Open AccessA principles-based ethics assurance argument pattern for AI and autonomous systems
An assurance case is a structured argument, typically produced by safety engineers, to communicate confidence that a critical or complex system, such as an aircraft, will be acceptably safe within its intended context. Assurance cases often inform third party approval of a system. One emerging proposition within the trustworthy AI and autonomous systems (AI/AS) research community is to use assurance cases to instil justified confidence that specific AI/AS will be ethically acceptable when operational in well-defined contexts. This paper substantially develops the proposition and makes it concrete. It brings together the assurance case methodology with a set of ethical principles to structure a principles-based ethics assurance argument pattern. The principles are justice, beneficence, non-maleficence, and respect for human autonomy, with the principle of transparency playing a supporting role. The argument pattern—shortened to the acronym PRAISE—is described. The objective of the proposed PRAISE argument pattern is to provide a reusable template for individual ethics assurance cases, by which engineers, developers, operators, or regulators could justify, communicate, or challenge a claim about the overall ethical acceptability of the use of a specific AI/AS in a given socio-technical context. We apply the pattern to the hypothetical use case of an autonomous ‘robo-taxi’ service in a city centre.
- Open Access
Ethics in conversation: Building an ethics assurance case for autonomous AI-enabled voice agents in healthcare
The deployment and use of AI systems should be both safe and broadly ethically acceptable. The principles-based ethics assurance argument pattern is one proposal in the AI ethics landscape that seeks to support and achieve that aim. The purpose of this argument pattern or framework is to structure reasoning about, and to communicate and foster confidence in, the ethical acceptability of uses of specific real-world AI systems in complex socio-technical contexts. This paper presents the interim findings of a case study applying this ethics assurance framework to the use of Dora, an AI-based telemedicine system, to assess its viability and usefulness as an approach. The case study process to date has revealed some of the positive ethical impacts of the Dora platform, as well as unexpected insights and areas to prioritise for evaluation, such as risks to the frontline clinician, particularly in respect of clinician autonomy. The ethics assurance argument pattern offers a practical framework not just for identifying issues to be addressed, but also to start to construct solutions in the form of adjustments to the distribution of benefits, risks and constraints on human autonomy that could reduce ethical disparities across affected stakeholders. Though many challenges remain, this research represents a step in the direction towards the development and use of safe and ethically acceptable AI systems and, ideally, a shift towards more comprehensive and inclusive evaluations of AI systems in general.
Open AccessEthics in conversation: Building an ethics assurance case for autonomous AI-enabled voice agents in healthcare
The deployment and use of AI systems should be both safe and broadly ethically acceptable. The principles-based ethics assurance argument pattern is one proposal in the AI ethics landscape that seeks to support and achieve that aim. The purpose of this argument pattern or framework is to structure reasoning about, and to communicate and foster confidence in, the ethical acceptability of uses of specific real-world AI systems in complex socio-technical contexts. This paper presents the interim findings of a case study applying this ethics assurance framework to the use of Dora, an AI-based telemedicine system, to assess its viability and usefulness as an approach. The case study process to date has revealed some of the positive ethical impacts of the Dora platform, as well as unexpected insights and areas to prioritise for evaluation, such as risks to the frontline clinician, particularly in respect of clinician autonomy. The ethics assurance argument pattern offers a practical framework not just for identifying issues to be addressed, but also to start to construct solutions in the form of adjustments to the distribution of benefits, risks and constraints on human autonomy that could reduce ethical disparities across affected stakeholders. Though many challenges remain, this research represents a step in the direction towards the development and use of safe and ethically acceptable AI systems and, ideally, a shift towards more comprehensive and inclusive evaluations of AI systems in general.
- 22 September 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Machine Intelligence
- Vol. 4 (9) , 734-736
Distinguishing two features of accountability for AI technologies
- 22 September 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Machine Intelligence
- Vol. 4 (9) , 734-736
Distinguishing two features of accountability for AI technologies
- 21 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 487-493
The Moral Responsibility Gap and the Increasing Autonomy of Systems
- 21 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 487-493
The Moral Responsibility Gap and the Increasing Autonomy of Systems