Diego Panici
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Diego Panici has a total of 63 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Georgina L. Bennett
Department of Geography University of Exeter Exeter UK
10 shared publications - Alan Puttock
Centre for Resilience in Environment, Water and Waste University of Exeter Exeter UK
7 shared publications Richard Brazier
7 shared publicationsRichard E. Brazier
5 shared publications- Benjamin Jackson
Lancaster Environment Centre, Lancaster University , Lancaster
4 shared publications - Prakash Kripakaran
University of Exeter
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Ecological Indicators
- Vol. 190
A multi-index hysteresis approach reveals competing pollution pathways and sediment connectivity shifts in a mixed land use chalk stream
- 5 September 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Ecological Indicators
- Vol. 190
Open AccessA multi-index hysteresis approach reveals competing pollution pathways and sediment connectivity shifts in a mixed land use chalk stream
- 21 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 51 (8) , e70397
A Commentary on ‘Runoff Generative Process and Runoff Yield From Arid Talus Mantled Slopes’ (Yair and Lavee 1976)
- 21 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 51 (8) , e70397
A Commentary on ‘Runoff Generative Process and Runoff Yield From Arid Talus Mantled Slopes’ (Yair and Lavee 1976)
- Open Access
- 20 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Hydrology
- Vol. 678
Hydrological effectiveness of multiple natural flood management interventions in rapid responses catchments
- 20 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Hydrology
- Vol. 678
Open AccessHydrological effectiveness of multiple natural flood management interventions in rapid responses catchments
- Open Access
- 29 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in River Research and Applications
- Vol. 42 (8) , 1654-1672
Validation of a Particle Image Velocimetry Algorithm Through Comparative Field and Laboratory Analysis
Flow velocity measurement is fundamental to hydrological and hydraulic studies, providing essential data for streamflow estimation and river dynamics analysis. Traditional in situ methods like propeller gauges and acoustic Doppler current profilers are accurate but intrusive and labour‐intensive, while non‐intrusive image processing methods like large‐scale particle image velocimetry (LSPIV) offer a safer, more efficient alternative for measuring flow in challenging environments. Through a combination of controlled flume experiments and field deployments, the method's accuracy, sensitivity, and operational limitations were assessed in this study. Field experiments demonstrated the influence of environmental factors such as wind, reflections, and tracer distribution on velocity estimation. Laboratory tests provided controlled conditions to evaluate software performance across different flow regimes. Across both controlled flume experiments and multiple field deployments, LSPIV performance was found to be most consistent under medium flow conditions within the tested range. By evaluating identical workflows across scales and environments, the analysis demonstrates how tracer type and distribution, key software parameters (particularly interrogation and search area settings), and post‐processing and filtering strategies jointly influence velocity estimation accuracy. Within this multi‐scale framework, wood‐chip tracers provided more robust surface coverage and visibility than biodegradable cornstarch under both laboratory and field conditions. While the method performed well in both laboratory and natural settings, further research is needed to refine image processing under challenging field conditions and to develop capabilities for fully tracer‐free velocity estimation. Overall, the LSPIV method represents a robust and adaptable solution for non‐contact flow monitoring, with strong potential for broader application in hydrological research and river management.
- 29 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in River Research and Applications
- Vol. 42 (8) , 1654-1672
Open AccessValidation of a Particle Image Velocimetry Algorithm Through Comparative Field and Laboratory Analysis
Flow velocity measurement is fundamental to hydrological and hydraulic studies, providing essential data for streamflow estimation and river dynamics analysis. Traditional in situ methods like propeller gauges and acoustic Doppler current profilers are accurate but intrusive and labour‐intensive, while non‐intrusive image processing methods like large‐scale particle image velocimetry (LSPIV) offer a safer, more efficient alternative for measuring flow in challenging environments. Through a combination of controlled flume experiments and field deployments, the method's accuracy, sensitivity, and operational limitations were assessed in this study. Field experiments demonstrated the influence of environmental factors such as wind, reflections, and tracer distribution on velocity estimation. Laboratory tests provided controlled conditions to evaluate software performance across different flow regimes. Across both controlled flume experiments and multiple field deployments, LSPIV performance was found to be most consistent under medium flow conditions within the tested range. By evaluating identical workflows across scales and environments, the analysis demonstrates how tracer type and distribution, key software parameters (particularly interrogation and search area settings), and post‐processing and filtering strategies jointly influence velocity estimation accuracy. Within this multi‐scale framework, wood‐chip tracers provided more robust surface coverage and visibility than biodegradable cornstarch under both laboratory and field conditions. While the method performed well in both laboratory and natural settings, further research is needed to refine image processing under challenging field conditions and to develop capabilities for fully tracer‐free velocity estimation. Overall, the LSPIV method represents a robust and adaptable solution for non‐contact flow monitoring, with strong potential for broader application in hydrological research and river management.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Hydrological Effectiveness of Multiple Natural Flood Management Interventions in Rapid Responses Catchments
Highlights- Hydrological monitoring across five rapid-response catchments where NFMs installed- NFM approaches reduced Event Maximum Flow by ~30–62% at all study catchments- Flood event lag times increased by 0.17–1.08 h following NFM implementation- Seasonal NFM performance depended on antecedent moisture and hydraulic thresholds- Peak-flow reduction (20–80%) observed across all events classified by exceedance ranges
- 18 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessHydrological Effectiveness of Multiple Natural Flood Management Interventions in Rapid Responses Catchments
Highlights- Hydrological monitoring across five rapid-response catchments where NFMs installed- NFM approaches reduced Event Maximum Flow by ~30–62% at all study catchments- Flood event lag times increased by 0.17–1.08 h following NFM implementation- Seasonal NFM performance depended on antecedent moisture and hydraulic thresholds- Peak-flow reduction (20–80%) observed across all events classified by exceedance ranges
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
High-frequency data reveal complex water quality processes in a mixed land use, groundwater dominated catchment in England
Rapid-response, mixed land-use, groundwater-dominated catchments represent a unique yet highly complex class of river systems, where the identification of multiple pollution sources is hindered by the coexistence of several competing hydrological and biogeochemical processes. Traditional regulatory water-quality monitoring typically captures baseline conditions but often fails to resolve short-lived, rainfall-driven pollution dynamics. In this context, concentration–discharge (C–Q) analysis applied to high-frequency datasets provides a powerful framework for disentangling event-scale processes and pollutant sources.Here, we analyse high-frequency water-quality data from a series of high-flow events in the Pix Brook, a groundwater-dominated chalk stream in Hertfordshire and Central Bedfordshire (England) characterised by flashy hydrological behaviour and heterogeneous land use (approximately 40% agricultural and 60% urban). The C–Q relationships of four parameters (ammonium, turbidity, conductivity, and dissolved oxygen) were examined across 18 rainfall-generated events. Event dynamics were quantified using established hysteresis metrics (Hysteresis Index, HI; Flush Index, FI) alongside a newly developed Complexity Index (CI) to characterise source proximity and process interactions.Results reveal consistent buffering of hydrological responses by groundwater contributions, while ammonium, conductivity, and dissolved oxygen frequently exhibit dilution during high flows, suggesting limited in-stream sources or rapid dilution by surface runoff. In contrast, turbidity consistently shows accretion, indicating systematic sediment mobilisation during events. Notably, a temporal shift from distal to proximal sediment sources is observed midway through the monitoring period, pointing to the potential emergence of new, faster sediment delivery pathways. Overall, this study demonstrates how high-frequency C–Q hysteresis analysis can effectively resolve event-based water-quality processes and disentangle multiple pollution sources in complex mixed-use catchments, supporting targeted monitoring and pollution mitigation strategies.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessHigh-frequency data reveal complex water quality processes in a mixed land use, groundwater dominated catchment in England
Rapid-response, mixed land-use, groundwater-dominated catchments represent a unique yet highly complex class of river systems, where the identification of multiple pollution sources is hindered by the coexistence of several competing hydrological and biogeochemical processes. Traditional regulatory water-quality monitoring typically captures baseline conditions but often fails to resolve short-lived, rainfall-driven pollution dynamics. In this context, concentration–discharge (C–Q) analysis applied to high-frequency datasets provides a powerful framework for disentangling event-scale processes and pollutant sources.Here, we analyse high-frequency water-quality data from a series of high-flow events in the Pix Brook, a groundwater-dominated chalk stream in Hertfordshire and Central Bedfordshire (England) characterised by flashy hydrological behaviour and heterogeneous land use (approximately 40% agricultural and 60% urban). The C–Q relationships of four parameters (ammonium, turbidity, conductivity, and dissolved oxygen) were examined across 18 rainfall-generated events. Event dynamics were quantified using established hysteresis metrics (Hysteresis Index, HI; Flush Index, FI) alongside a newly developed Complexity Index (CI) to characterise source proximity and process interactions.Results reveal consistent buffering of hydrological responses by groundwater contributions, while ammonium, conductivity, and dissolved oxygen frequently exhibit dilution during high flows, suggesting limited in-stream sources or rapid dilution by surface runoff. In contrast, turbidity consistently shows accretion, indicating systematic sediment mobilisation during events. Notably, a temporal shift from distal to proximal sediment sources is observed midway through the monitoring period, pointing to the potential emergence of new, faster sediment delivery pathways. Overall, this study demonstrates how high-frequency C–Q hysteresis analysis can effectively resolve event-based water-quality processes and disentangle multiple pollution sources in complex mixed-use catchments, supporting targeted monitoring and pollution mitigation strategies.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Evaluating Natural Flood Management Effectiveness Across Fast-Responding Catchments Using High-Resolution Monitoring
Flooding remains the most frequent and damaging natural hazard globally, causing significant loss of life and socio-economic disruption each year. In response, flood risk management policies have increasingly embraced nature-based solutions, particularly Natural Flood Management strategies (NFMs), which seek to preserve, restore, or mimic natural hydrological and geomorphological processes across catchments as interconnected systems. While growing evidence supports the hydrological implications of individual NFM interventions (Bagheri et al., 2025), comparative assessments of multiple NFM strategies in rapid-response catchments remain limited. This study, led by Devon County Council in partnership with 19 organisations and aiming to enhance community flood resilience through NFMs, evaluates the hydrological effectiveness of multi-intervention NFM approaches across five fast-responding catchments in Devon, UK. Utilising a robust Before-After-Control-Impact (BACI) experimental design, we collected high-resolution hydrological data at five-minute intervals using water level loggers, rain gauges, soil moisture probes, and time-lapse cameras. 545 flood events were identified and analysed. Preliminary results from the completed catchments confirm that NFMs collectively contribute to reductions in flood peak magnitude and increases in flow travel time, with the magnitude of effect varying by intervention type and catchment characteristics.ReferenceBagheri‐Gavkosh, M., Panici, D., Puttock, A., Dauben, T., & Brazier, R. E. (2025). Hydrological Analysis and Impacts of Natural Flood Management Strategies: A Systematic Review. Journal of Flood Risk Management, 18(3), e70112.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessEvaluating Natural Flood Management Effectiveness Across Fast-Responding Catchments Using High-Resolution Monitoring
Flooding remains the most frequent and damaging natural hazard globally, causing significant loss of life and socio-economic disruption each year. In response, flood risk management policies have increasingly embraced nature-based solutions, particularly Natural Flood Management strategies (NFMs), which seek to preserve, restore, or mimic natural hydrological and geomorphological processes across catchments as interconnected systems. While growing evidence supports the hydrological implications of individual NFM interventions (Bagheri et al., 2025), comparative assessments of multiple NFM strategies in rapid-response catchments remain limited. This study, led by Devon County Council in partnership with 19 organisations and aiming to enhance community flood resilience through NFMs, evaluates the hydrological effectiveness of multi-intervention NFM approaches across five fast-responding catchments in Devon, UK. Utilising a robust Before-After-Control-Impact (BACI) experimental design, we collected high-resolution hydrological data at five-minute intervals using water level loggers, rain gauges, soil moisture probes, and time-lapse cameras. 545 flood events were identified and analysed. Preliminary results from the completed catchments confirm that NFMs collectively contribute to reductions in flood peak magnitude and increases in flow travel time, with the magnitude of effect varying by intervention type and catchment characteristics.ReferenceBagheri‐Gavkosh, M., Panici, D., Puttock, A., Dauben, T., & Brazier, R. E. (2025). Hydrological Analysis and Impacts of Natural Flood Management Strategies: A Systematic Review. Journal of Flood Risk Management, 18(3), e70112.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Evidence Based Hydraulic and Geomorphic Complexity of Large Wood Interventions for Habitat Creation
Large wood (LW) has become an essential tool in river restoration due to its ability to enhance habitat heterogeneity and restore natural processes disrupted by human activities such as channelisation. This work presents findings from 2-year field monitoring across 4 restoration sites in the UK, aimed at quantifying the effects of various LW interventions on geomorphic changes and hydraulic complexity.The sites including in our monitoring have been selected for the diverse type of interventions, catchment type (ranging from stream orders 3rd to 6th), and LW complexity that has been used for restoration, for example, Stage-0 (Holnicote, Somerset, UK and Tattiscombe, Devon, UK), complex dams and deflectors (Magdalen Farm, Somerset, UK), simple deflectors (Mosterton, Somerset). The monitoring process encompassed the quantification of surface velocity variations around LW installations through a drone-based large scale particle image velocimetry (LSPIV) method coupled with the structural complexity and type of LW, and measurement of LW-induced geomorphic changes using high-resolution RTK drone surveys and walk-overs using Leica GNSS unite. To identify the impact of LW on restoration, we employed a control (unwooded) versus impact (restored) design for Magdalen and Mosterton farms combined with a before‑and‑after monitoring approach for Holnicote and Tattiscombe.For the first objective, LSPIV was employed to acquire spatially continuous velocity fields across selected rivers reaches within the sites, mitigating the methodological limitations of traditional point-measurement techniques near complex LW structures. LSPIV surveys were conducted during contrasting low (Q90-Q99) and high (Q10-Q4) flow conditions at intervention and upstream control reaches. Velocity analyses quantified spatial heterogeneity using coefficient of variation in velocity, revealing consistent formation of distinct wake zones (reduced velocity) and acceleration zones near wood features. For example, in LW jams in Mosterton, a cross-section with 33.34% wood cover exhibited a velocity coefficient of variation 195.82% higher than the control reach (unwooded), with P value equal to 3.9×10⁻⁴⁴ (Wilcoxon test) confirming that LW significantly drives flow variability. The observed hydraulic heterogeneity defines three functional zones: high‑energy, erosion‑ or scour‑prone reaches; low‑energy, depositional zones; and intermediate turbulent‑mixing areas. By overlaying these flow‑zone maps onto concurrent drone‑derived orthophotos, we can relate flow patterns to specific geomorphic responses such as pool development, bar migration, or bank erosion. This will allow us to predict where erosional and depositional processes are most likely to occur under different LW configurations and flow conditions.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessEvidence Based Hydraulic and Geomorphic Complexity of Large Wood Interventions for Habitat Creation
Large wood (LW) has become an essential tool in river restoration due to its ability to enhance habitat heterogeneity and restore natural processes disrupted by human activities such as channelisation. This work presents findings from 2-year field monitoring across 4 restoration sites in the UK, aimed at quantifying the effects of various LW interventions on geomorphic changes and hydraulic complexity.The sites including in our monitoring have been selected for the diverse type of interventions, catchment type (ranging from stream orders 3rd to 6th), and LW complexity that has been used for restoration, for example, Stage-0 (Holnicote, Somerset, UK and Tattiscombe, Devon, UK), complex dams and deflectors (Magdalen Farm, Somerset, UK), simple deflectors (Mosterton, Somerset). The monitoring process encompassed the quantification of surface velocity variations around LW installations through a drone-based large scale particle image velocimetry (LSPIV) method coupled with the structural complexity and type of LW, and measurement of LW-induced geomorphic changes using high-resolution RTK drone surveys and walk-overs using Leica GNSS unite. To identify the impact of LW on restoration, we employed a control (unwooded) versus impact (restored) design for Magdalen and Mosterton farms combined with a before‑and‑after monitoring approach for Holnicote and Tattiscombe.For the first objective, LSPIV was employed to acquire spatially continuous velocity fields across selected rivers reaches within the sites, mitigating the methodological limitations of traditional point-measurement techniques near complex LW structures. LSPIV surveys were conducted during contrasting low (Q90-Q99) and high (Q10-Q4) flow conditions at intervention and upstream control reaches. Velocity analyses quantified spatial heterogeneity using coefficient of variation in velocity, revealing consistent formation of distinct wake zones (reduced velocity) and acceleration zones near wood features. For example, in LW jams in Mosterton, a cross-section with 33.34% wood cover exhibited a velocity coefficient of variation 195.82% higher than the control reach (unwooded), with P value equal to 3.9×10⁻⁴⁴ (Wilcoxon test) confirming that LW significantly drives flow variability. The observed hydraulic heterogeneity defines three functional zones: high‑energy, erosion‑ or scour‑prone reaches; low‑energy, depositional zones; and intermediate turbulent‑mixing areas. By overlaying these flow‑zone maps onto concurrent drone‑derived orthophotos, we can relate flow patterns to specific geomorphic responses such as pool development, bar migration, or bank erosion. This will allow us to predict where erosional and depositional processes are most likely to occur under different LW configurations and flow conditions.
- Open Access
- 11 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Flood Risk Management
- Vol. 18 (3)
Hydrological Analysis and Impacts of Natural Flood Management Strategies: A Systematic Review
Natural flood management strategies (NFMs) encompass a variety of measures implemented across catchments to mitigate flood risks while providing multiple benefits. In recent years, NFMs have gained increasing attention from researchers and policymakers. However, despite the growing body of research, there remains a lack of a critical review that quantitatively synthesises the reported performance of different NFMs by analysing their effects on key hydrological parameters. To address this gap, we conducted a systematic review of NFMs based on 145 peer‐reviewed papers covering 216 case studies across 37 countries, following the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta‐analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Our analysis moves from a descriptive overview of the evidence base to a novel, quantitative investigation of three critical themes: the characteristics of studied NFM schemes, the methodologies used for their assessment, and their quantitative hydrological performance and its influencing factors. Results indicate that 31% of the studies identified flood peak reduction as the most commonly targeted hydrological objective. A significant positive correlation was found between intervention diversity and intensity (Spearman's ρ = 0.53). Furthermore, our methodological analysis reveals a critical trade‐off in the literature, with empirical monitoring typically used in small catchments over shorter durations, while modelling is used to assess a greater diversity of interventions at larger scales, with truly combined approaches being notably rare (11%). Notably, river and floodplain management (RFM) demonstrated higher effectiveness, achieving an average flood peak reduction of 30%, particularly in larger catchments. Bearing the often multi‐faceted aims of NFMs in mind, this paper provides key suggestions for future research.
- 11 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Flood Risk Management
- Vol. 18 (3)
Open AccessHydrological Analysis and Impacts of Natural Flood Management Strategies: A Systematic Review
Natural flood management strategies (NFMs) encompass a variety of measures implemented across catchments to mitigate flood risks while providing multiple benefits. In recent years, NFMs have gained increasing attention from researchers and policymakers. However, despite the growing body of research, there remains a lack of a critical review that quantitatively synthesises the reported performance of different NFMs by analysing their effects on key hydrological parameters. To address this gap, we conducted a systematic review of NFMs based on 145 peer‐reviewed papers covering 216 case studies across 37 countries, following the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta‐analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Our analysis moves from a descriptive overview of the evidence base to a novel, quantitative investigation of three critical themes: the characteristics of studied NFM schemes, the methodologies used for their assessment, and their quantitative hydrological performance and its influencing factors. Results indicate that 31% of the studies identified flood peak reduction as the most commonly targeted hydrological objective. A significant positive correlation was found between intervention diversity and intensity (Spearman's ρ = 0.53). Furthermore, our methodological analysis reveals a critical trade‐off in the literature, with empirical monitoring typically used in small catchments over shorter durations, while modelling is used to assess a greater diversity of interventions at larger scales, with truly combined approaches being notably rare (11%). Notably, river and floodplain management (RFM) demonstrated higher effectiveness, achieving an average flood peak reduction of 30%, particularly in larger catchments. Bearing the often multi‐faceted aims of NFMs in mind, this paper provides key suggestions for future research.
- Open Access
- 20 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Flood Risk Management
- Vol. 18 (3)
Rethinking Hydrodynamic Assessments for River Infrastructures: Are Simplified Methods Leaving Bridges Exposed?
Bridge owners and regulatory agencies have a duty to assess risks derived from hydraulic actions including scour, uplift, drag, debris impact, deck displacement, and other consequences that can lead to a loss in the load carrying capacity of a bridge. In the UK, the CS469 (Management of scour and other hydraulic actions at highway structures) is the standard for the assessment of hydraulic actions to highway bridges. The methodology in CS469 for the calculation of the hydraulic characteristics of the flow at critical cross‐sections within the channel and the bridge crossing, although simplistic by design to minimize computational effort, is intrinsically inaccurate since it makes use of unrealistic (i.e., non‐physically based) approximations. This results in estimations of risk and vulnerability levels that could include high levels of uncertainty. In this paper, we propose to bypass these approximated hydraulic calculations by harnessing the computational power of 2D hydraulic models, which would not require any additional field data collection than needed for the original CS469 method. We recommend a fully 2D HEC‐RAS model with the inclusion of bridges as 1D elements within the flow areas and only requiring publicly available data or data obtained from existing assessments in order to future‐proof the approaches and adhere to an open‐source/open‐access philosophy, but also imposing only a marginal increase in cost for bridge management teams. Results from the two models—2D HEC‐RAS and the existing approach in CS469, are compared for a number of real‐world bridges. The comparisons show that the estimations by HEC‐RAS are substantially higher for water depth (up to 138%) and lower for flow velocity (down by 58%). When these values are applied to the estimation of hydraulic vulnerability and scour risk, the differences are significant. Scour depths with the use of HEC‐RAS models are typically much lower (up to 3.9 m, and on average 1.7 m) than with simplified hydraulic equations, and this translates into lower (yet, more appropriate) scour risk levels. Hydraulic vulnerability to submergence of the assessed bridges is also assessed very differently, typically higher by the 2D model method. Overall, the results show that 2D numerical hydraulic simulations present a much more accurate estimation than existing methods, better balancing risks deriving from scour and hydrodynamic actions and with comparable effort and data requirements. The model displays consistency across an exhaustive set of simulations for a range of variables and bridges, showing limited variability and proneness to errors, whilst values estimated by CS469 are in most cases significantly different. Future versions of CS469 and similar documents should prioritize this methodology to provide a more accurate and realistic risk estimation.
- 20 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Flood Risk Management
- Vol. 18 (3)
Open AccessRethinking Hydrodynamic Assessments for River Infrastructures: Are Simplified Methods Leaving Bridges Exposed?
Bridge owners and regulatory agencies have a duty to assess risks derived from hydraulic actions including scour, uplift, drag, debris impact, deck displacement, and other consequences that can lead to a loss in the load carrying capacity of a bridge. In the UK, the CS469 (Management of scour and other hydraulic actions at highway structures) is the standard for the assessment of hydraulic actions to highway bridges. The methodology in CS469 for the calculation of the hydraulic characteristics of the flow at critical cross‐sections within the channel and the bridge crossing, although simplistic by design to minimize computational effort, is intrinsically inaccurate since it makes use of unrealistic (i.e., non‐physically based) approximations. This results in estimations of risk and vulnerability levels that could include high levels of uncertainty. In this paper, we propose to bypass these approximated hydraulic calculations by harnessing the computational power of 2D hydraulic models, which would not require any additional field data collection than needed for the original CS469 method. We recommend a fully 2D HEC‐RAS model with the inclusion of bridges as 1D elements within the flow areas and only requiring publicly available data or data obtained from existing assessments in order to future‐proof the approaches and adhere to an open‐source/open‐access philosophy, but also imposing only a marginal increase in cost for bridge management teams. Results from the two models—2D HEC‐RAS and the existing approach in CS469, are compared for a number of real‐world bridges. The comparisons show that the estimations by HEC‐RAS are substantially higher for water depth (up to 138%) and lower for flow velocity (down by 58%). When these values are applied to the estimation of hydraulic vulnerability and scour risk, the differences are significant. Scour depths with the use of HEC‐RAS models are typically much lower (up to 3.9 m, and on average 1.7 m) than with simplified hydraulic equations, and this translates into lower (yet, more appropriate) scour risk levels. Hydraulic vulnerability to submergence of the assessed bridges is also assessed very differently, typically higher by the 2D model method. Overall, the results show that 2D numerical hydraulic simulations present a much more accurate estimation than existing methods, better balancing risks deriving from scour and hydrodynamic actions and with comparable effort and data requirements. The model displays consistency across an exhaustive set of simulations for a range of variables and bridges, showing limited variability and proneness to errors, whilst values estimated by CS469 are in most cases significantly different. Future versions of CS469 and similar documents should prioritize this methodology to provide a more accurate and realistic risk estimation.