James Daniel Munday
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
James Daniel Munday has a total of 148 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sebastian Funk
London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
21 shared publications - Sam Abbott
Centre for Mathematical Modelling of Infectious Diseases, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine
10 shared publications - William John Edmunds
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine
10 shared publications - Joel Hellewell
London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK
9 shared publications - Tanja Stadler
Department of Biosystems Science and Engineering, ETH Zurich, Basel, Switzerland
9 shared publications - Amy Gimma
Centre for Mathematical Modelling of Infectious Diseases, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine
8 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 11 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1) , 8563
Real-time estimation of pathogen transmission dynamics from wastewater
Wastewater monitoring proved effective for tracking SARS-CoV-2 transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, estimating transmission parameters for other pathogens remains difficult due to lower concentrations in sewage, uncertain shedding kinetics, and limited clinical validation data. Here we present EpiSewer, a Bayesian semi-mechanistic wastewater model that jointly accounts for infection dynamics, pathogen shedding, and measurement noise, including outliers and non-detects. This enables direct inference of the effective reproduction number ( R t ) and epidemic growth rate ( r t ) from raw concentration and flow data, eliminating the need for prior smoothing, imputation, or outlier removal. We assessed EpiSewer across three seasons of multi-pathogen wastewater surveillance (Nov 2022 – May 2025) at 6–14 treatment plants in Switzerland, tracking SARS-CoV-2, influenza A virus (IAV), and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) transmission in real time. R t estimates were consistent and robust to measurement noise, even with IAV and RSV concentrations 10–50 times lower than SARS-CoV-2. The model provided well-calibrated fourteen-day concentration forecasts, with minimal bias across epidemic phases. Under reduced sampling frequencies, EpiSewer maintained unbiased forecasts while accurately reflecting uncertainty. Our approach enables robust inference of transmission dynamics for lower-abundance pathogens with limited clinical surveillance, using only a few wastewater samples per week.
- 11 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1) , 8563
Open AccessReal-time estimation of pathogen transmission dynamics from wastewater
Wastewater monitoring proved effective for tracking SARS-CoV-2 transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, estimating transmission parameters for other pathogens remains difficult due to lower concentrations in sewage, uncertain shedding kinetics, and limited clinical validation data. Here we present EpiSewer, a Bayesian semi-mechanistic wastewater model that jointly accounts for infection dynamics, pathogen shedding, and measurement noise, including outliers and non-detects. This enables direct inference of the effective reproduction number ( R t ) and epidemic growth rate ( r t ) from raw concentration and flow data, eliminating the need for prior smoothing, imputation, or outlier removal. We assessed EpiSewer across three seasons of multi-pathogen wastewater surveillance (Nov 2022 – May 2025) at 6–14 treatment plants in Switzerland, tracking SARS-CoV-2, influenza A virus (IAV), and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) transmission in real time. R t estimates were consistent and robust to measurement noise, even with IAV and RSV concentrations 10–50 times lower than SARS-CoV-2. The model provided well-calibrated fourteen-day concentration forecasts, with minimal bias across epidemic phases. Under reduced sampling frequencies, EpiSewer maintained unbiased forecasts while accurately reflecting uncertainty. Our approach enables robust inference of transmission dynamics for lower-abundance pathogens with limited clinical surveillance, using only a few wastewater samples per week.
- Open Access
Modelling the impact of climate variability on the effectiveness of seasonal indoor residual spraying
Malaria transmission is strongly modulated by climate, yet most mechanistic models used for health policy evaluation do not explicitly account for climate-driven variability in mosquito dynamics. Here, we present a novel modelling framework that couples VECTRI, a climate-sensitive model for malaria, with OpenMalaria, a detailed individual-based model of malaria epidemiology and intervention impact. This integrated approach enables simulation of transmission processes that respond to interannual climate fluctuations while retaining the capacity to evaluate realistic intervention strategies. We apply this framework to Mozambique, a high-burden country for malaria, with pronounced climatic seasonality and extensive routine surveillance data. Using district-level incidence time series from the ten highest-incidence districts, we validate the modelling framework and compare its performance with the standalone versions of VECTRI and OpenMalaria. The joint modelling framework reproduces malaria seasonality more accurately than the two single models, with improved timing of incidence peaks in 7 out of 10 districts and a closer representation of evolution of transmission throughout the season, as measured by the seasonality index, in 7 out of 10 districts. We then use the coupled system to assess how climate-driven interannual variability affects the predicted effectiveness of indoor residual spraying, a key seasonal malaria control intervention in Mozambique. Integrating climate-driven interannual variability into OpenMalaria substantially impacts the modeled effectiveness of indoor residual spraying. The joint modelling framework increases the estimated protective effectiveness of indoor residual spraying in reducing incidence by up to 11% and delayed the optimal deployment window by two weeks. Our results demonstrate that climate-informed mechanistic models can meaningfully alter estimates of intervention impact and improve the realism of malaria predictions. The joint OpenMalaria-VECTRI modelling framework provides a flexible tool for national malaria programs seeking to evaluate seasonal interventions under varying climatic scenarios. Author summary: Malaria transmission in Mozambique changes from year to year because mosquito populations strongly depend on rainfall and temperature. However, most models used to guide malaria control planning do not fully capture these climate-driven fluctuations. We developed a new modelling approach that links two existing tools: VECTRI, which simulates climate-sensitive mosquito and malaria dynamics, and OpenMalaria, which simulates malaria infections and the effects of interventions. We validated this joint modelling framework using routine surveillance malaria data from Mozambique and found that it better captures observed seasonal and interannual patterns than standalone models. We then used it to explore how climate variability influences the effectiveness of indoor residual spraying, an important seasonal malaria control strategy. Accounting for climate-driven mosquito dynamics reduced the predicted protective effectiveness of indoor residual spraying by 11% and shifted the optimal deployment timing by approximately two weeks. These results show that integrating climate information into malaria models can improve the accuracy and usefulness of intervention planning.
Open AccessModelling the impact of climate variability on the effectiveness of seasonal indoor residual spraying
Malaria transmission is strongly modulated by climate, yet most mechanistic models used for health policy evaluation do not explicitly account for climate-driven variability in mosquito dynamics. Here, we present a novel modelling framework that couples VECTRI, a climate-sensitive model for malaria, with OpenMalaria, a detailed individual-based model of malaria epidemiology and intervention impact. This integrated approach enables simulation of transmission processes that respond to interannual climate fluctuations while retaining the capacity to evaluate realistic intervention strategies. We apply this framework to Mozambique, a high-burden country for malaria, with pronounced climatic seasonality and extensive routine surveillance data. Using district-level incidence time series from the ten highest-incidence districts, we validate the modelling framework and compare its performance with the standalone versions of VECTRI and OpenMalaria. The joint modelling framework reproduces malaria seasonality more accurately than the two single models, with improved timing of incidence peaks in 7 out of 10 districts and a closer representation of evolution of transmission throughout the season, as measured by the seasonality index, in 7 out of 10 districts. We then use the coupled system to assess how climate-driven interannual variability affects the predicted effectiveness of indoor residual spraying, a key seasonal malaria control intervention in Mozambique. Integrating climate-driven interannual variability into OpenMalaria substantially impacts the modeled effectiveness of indoor residual spraying. The joint modelling framework increases the estimated protective effectiveness of indoor residual spraying in reducing incidence by up to 11% and delayed the optimal deployment window by two weeks. Our results demonstrate that climate-informed mechanistic models can meaningfully alter estimates of intervention impact and improve the realism of malaria predictions. The joint OpenMalaria-VECTRI modelling framework provides a flexible tool for national malaria programs seeking to evaluate seasonal interventions under varying climatic scenarios. Author summary: Malaria transmission in Mozambique changes from year to year because mosquito populations strongly depend on rainfall and temperature. However, most models used to guide malaria control planning do not fully capture these climate-driven fluctuations. We developed a new modelling approach that links two existing tools: VECTRI, which simulates climate-sensitive mosquito and malaria dynamics, and OpenMalaria, which simulates malaria infections and the effects of interventions. We validated this joint modelling framework using routine surveillance malaria data from Mozambique and found that it better captures observed seasonal and interannual patterns than standalone models. We then used it to explore how climate variability influences the effectiveness of indoor residual spraying, an important seasonal malaria control strategy. Accounting for climate-driven mosquito dynamics reduced the predicted protective effectiveness of indoor residual spraying by 11% and shifted the optimal deployment timing by approximately two weeks. These results show that integrating climate information into malaria models can improve the accuracy and usefulness of intervention planning.
- Open Access
- 27 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 16 (1)
The relative contribution of close-proximity contacts, shared classroom exposure and indoor air quality to respiratory virus transmission in schools
Close-proximity interactions are considered a key risk factor for respiratory virus transmission, but their importance relative to shared space and air quality remains unclear. We conducted a six-week longitudinal study in a Swiss secondary school (67 students, aged 14–15). We detected 87 infections in saliva samples and recorded absences to identify plausible transmissions, excluding implausible ones through genomic analysis. Time in close proximity (within 1.5 metres) was measured using wearable sensors and air quality via CO 2 monitors. Students spent 21.2 minutes per day in close proximity (interquartile range 7.8–44.2) and 5.3 hours in shared classrooms (IQR 3.8–6.2), during which air quality was suboptimal for 1.9 hours (IQR 1.2–3.0). Using pairwise survival models, we found that transmission was more likely within than between classes. Close proximity was modestly associated with higher transmission risk overall (rate ratio 1.16 per doubling daily time, 95%-CI 1.01–1.33), while time in shared classrooms (RR 3.17, 95%-CI 1.96–5.17) and suboptimal air quality (RR 1.90 95%-CI 1.23–2.94) also predicted within-class risk. Prolonged exposure in shared, poorly ventilated spaces, which potentially includes several infectious sources, drives respiratory virus transmission more than close contact.
- 27 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 16 (1)
Open AccessThe relative contribution of close-proximity contacts, shared classroom exposure and indoor air quality to respiratory virus transmission in schools
Close-proximity interactions are considered a key risk factor for respiratory virus transmission, but their importance relative to shared space and air quality remains unclear. We conducted a six-week longitudinal study in a Swiss secondary school (67 students, aged 14–15). We detected 87 infections in saliva samples and recorded absences to identify plausible transmissions, excluding implausible ones through genomic analysis. Time in close proximity (within 1.5 metres) was measured using wearable sensors and air quality via CO 2 monitors. Students spent 21.2 minutes per day in close proximity (interquartile range 7.8–44.2) and 5.3 hours in shared classrooms (IQR 3.8–6.2), during which air quality was suboptimal for 1.9 hours (IQR 1.2–3.0). Using pairwise survival models, we found that transmission was more likely within than between classes. Close proximity was modestly associated with higher transmission risk overall (rate ratio 1.16 per doubling daily time, 95%-CI 1.01–1.33), while time in shared classrooms (RR 3.17, 95%-CI 1.96–5.17) and suboptimal air quality (RR 1.90 95%-CI 1.23–2.94) also predicted within-class risk. Prolonged exposure in shared, poorly ventilated spaces, which potentially includes several infectious sources, drives respiratory virus transmission more than close contact.
- Open Access
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Infectious Diseases
- Vol. 163, 108240
Projected increase in risk of large measles outbreaks in The Netherlands as susceptible children enter secondary school in 2025/26
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Infectious Diseases
- Vol. 163, 108240
Open AccessProjected increase in risk of large measles outbreaks in The Netherlands as susceptible children enter secondary school in 2025/26
- Open Access
- 3 November 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Water
- Vol. 4 (11) , e0000453
Determinants and spatio-temporal structure of variability in wastewater SARS-CoV-2 viral load measurements in Switzerland: Key insights for future surveillance efforts
Background: Wastewater-based surveillance (WBS) has emerged as a valuable tool for monitoring the circulation of infectious pathogens in the population, offering a complement to classical surveillance methods. However, the interpretation of WBS data is often challenged by substantial variability and bias in viral load measurements, which can stem from differences in laboratory protocols, population demographics, and in-sewer fate and transport processes. Methods and findings: We analysed 23,025 wastewater samples collected between February 2022 and November 2023 from 118 wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) across Switzerland. Samples of influent wastewater were processed by 8 independent laboratories using distinct concentration, extraction and quantification methods to estimate SARS-CoV-2 concentrations. Concentrations were converted to daily viral loads using wastewater flow rates, and normalized by the size of the population served by the treatment plant. To characterise the contributions of different sources of variation, we applied a Bayesian modelling framework, incorporating fixed effects and spatio–temporal random effects to separate the contributions of laboratory protocols, demographic factors, and geographic structure to the observed variability in SARS-CoV-2 viral loads. Our analysis revealed that laboratory-specific biases were substantial, and that local demographic characteristics (particularly the age structure of the catchment population) also influenced viral load estimates. Adjusting for these sources of bias improved the reliability of interpretations based on viral loads, as indicated by an increased correlation with regional COVID-19 hospitalization data (from 0.55 for raw data to 0.77 for adjusted temporal trends). Dynamic time warping clustering of the adjusted temporal trends uncovered distinct geographic clusters, highlighting persistent spatial structures that evolved over successive epidemic phases. Conclusions: Our study demonstrates that variability in WBS data during the 2022-2023 Swiss national SARS-CoV-2 surveillance campaign is driven by a complex interplay of laboratory methods, population demographics, and spatio-temporal dynamics. Standardization of laboratory protocols and the implementation of robust statistical adjustment methods such as the one demonstrated here can enhance the reliability of WBS as a public health surveillance tool. These findings provide underscore the importance of advanced data processing methods for enhancing future surveillance efforts and for the effective integration of wastewater data into public health decision-making frameworks.
- 3 November 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Water
- Vol. 4 (11) , e0000453
Open AccessDeterminants and spatio-temporal structure of variability in wastewater SARS-CoV-2 viral load measurements in Switzerland: Key insights for future surveillance efforts
Background: Wastewater-based surveillance (WBS) has emerged as a valuable tool for monitoring the circulation of infectious pathogens in the population, offering a complement to classical surveillance methods. However, the interpretation of WBS data is often challenged by substantial variability and bias in viral load measurements, which can stem from differences in laboratory protocols, population demographics, and in-sewer fate and transport processes. Methods and findings: We analysed 23,025 wastewater samples collected between February 2022 and November 2023 from 118 wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) across Switzerland. Samples of influent wastewater were processed by 8 independent laboratories using distinct concentration, extraction and quantification methods to estimate SARS-CoV-2 concentrations. Concentrations were converted to daily viral loads using wastewater flow rates, and normalized by the size of the population served by the treatment plant. To characterise the contributions of different sources of variation, we applied a Bayesian modelling framework, incorporating fixed effects and spatio–temporal random effects to separate the contributions of laboratory protocols, demographic factors, and geographic structure to the observed variability in SARS-CoV-2 viral loads. Our analysis revealed that laboratory-specific biases were substantial, and that local demographic characteristics (particularly the age structure of the catchment population) also influenced viral load estimates. Adjusting for these sources of bias improved the reliability of interpretations based on viral loads, as indicated by an increased correlation with regional COVID-19 hospitalization data (from 0.55 for raw data to 0.77 for adjusted temporal trends). Dynamic time warping clustering of the adjusted temporal trends uncovered distinct geographic clusters, highlighting persistent spatial structures that evolved over successive epidemic phases. Conclusions: Our study demonstrates that variability in WBS data during the 2022-2023 Swiss national SARS-CoV-2 surveillance campaign is driven by a complex interplay of laboratory methods, population demographics, and spatio-temporal dynamics. Standardization of laboratory protocols and the implementation of robust statistical adjustment methods such as the one demonstrated here can enhance the reliability of WBS as a public health surveillance tool. These findings provide underscore the importance of advanced data processing methods for enhancing future surveillance efforts and for the effective integration of wastewater data into public health decision-making frameworks.
- Open Access
Robust real-time estimation of pathogen transmission dynamics from wastewater
Wastewater monitoring has proven effective for tracking SARS-CoV-2 transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, estimating transmission parameters for other pathogens remains difficult due to lower concentrations in sewage, uncertain shedding kinetics, and limited clinical validation data. Here we present a Bayesian semi-mechanistic wastewater model, called EpiSewer, which jointly accounts for uncertainty in infection dynamics, pathogen shedding, and measurement noise, including outliers and non-detects. This framework enables direct inference of transmission dynamics from raw concentration and flow data, eliminating the need for preprocessing such as smoothing, imputation, or outlier removal. It also provides short-term concentration forecasts for out-of-sample validation. We assessed EpiSewer across three seasons of multi-pathogen wastewater surveillance at 6–14 treatment plants in Switzerland, estimating the effective reproduction number ( R t ) for SARS-CoV-2, influenza A virus (IAV), and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) in real time. R t estimates were consistent and robust to measurement noise, even with IAV and RSV concentrations 10–50 times lower than SARS-CoV-2. Fourteen-day concentration forecasts were well-calibrated, with minimal bias during both epidemic growth and decline. Under reduced sampling frequencies, EpiSewer maintained unbiased forecasts while accurately reflecting increased uncertainty. Our approach enables robust inference of transmission dynamics for lower-abundance pathogens with limited clinical surveillance, using only a few wastewater samples per week.
Open AccessRobust real-time estimation of pathogen transmission dynamics from wastewater
Wastewater monitoring has proven effective for tracking SARS-CoV-2 transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, estimating transmission parameters for other pathogens remains difficult due to lower concentrations in sewage, uncertain shedding kinetics, and limited clinical validation data. Here we present a Bayesian semi-mechanistic wastewater model, called EpiSewer, which jointly accounts for uncertainty in infection dynamics, pathogen shedding, and measurement noise, including outliers and non-detects. This framework enables direct inference of transmission dynamics from raw concentration and flow data, eliminating the need for preprocessing such as smoothing, imputation, or outlier removal. It also provides short-term concentration forecasts for out-of-sample validation. We assessed EpiSewer across three seasons of multi-pathogen wastewater surveillance at 6–14 treatment plants in Switzerland, estimating the effective reproduction number ( R t ) for SARS-CoV-2, influenza A virus (IAV), and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) in real time. R t estimates were consistent and robust to measurement noise, even with IAV and RSV concentrations 10–50 times lower than SARS-CoV-2. Fourteen-day concentration forecasts were well-calibrated, with minimal bias during both epidemic growth and decline. Under reduced sampling frequencies, EpiSewer maintained unbiased forecasts while accurately reflecting increased uncertainty. Our approach enables robust inference of transmission dynamics for lower-abundance pathogens with limited clinical surveillance, using only a few wastewater samples per week.
- Open Access
- 10 October 2025
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife
- Vol. 13
Forecasting the spatial spread of an Ebola epidemic in real time: Comparing predictions of mathematical models and experts
Background: Ebola virus disease outbreaks can often be controlled, but require rapid response efforts frequently with profound operational complexities. Mathematical models can be used to support response planning, but it is unclear if models improve the prior understanding of experts. Methods: We performed repeated surveys of Ebola response experts during an outbreak. From each expert, we elicited the probability of cases exceeding four thresholds between 2 and 20 cases in a set of small geographical areas in the following calendar month. We compared the predictive performance of these forecasts to those of two mathematical models with different spatial interaction components. Results: An ensemble combining the forecasts of all experts performed similarly to the two models. Experts showed stronger bias than models forecasting two-case threshold exceedance. Experts and models both performed better when predicting exceedance of higher thresholds. The models also tended to be better at risk-ranking areas than experts. Conclusions: Our results support the use of models in outbreak contexts, offering a convenient and scalable route to a quantified situational awareness, which can provide confidence in or to call into question existing advice of experts. There could be value in combining expert opinion and modelled forecasts to support the response to future outbreaks. Funding: This study was partly funded by the Department of Health and Social Care using UK Aid funding 47 and is managed by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (VEEPED: PR-OD-1017- 48 20002; AR and WJE). This study was partly funded by the Wellcome Trust (210758/Z/18/Z : JDM 49 and SF). The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and not necessarily 50 those of the funders.
- 10 October 2025
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife
- Vol. 13
Open AccessForecasting the spatial spread of an Ebola epidemic in real time: Comparing predictions of mathematical models and experts
Background: Ebola virus disease outbreaks can often be controlled, but require rapid response efforts frequently with profound operational complexities. Mathematical models can be used to support response planning, but it is unclear if models improve the prior understanding of experts. Methods: We performed repeated surveys of Ebola response experts during an outbreak. From each expert, we elicited the probability of cases exceeding four thresholds between 2 and 20 cases in a set of small geographical areas in the following calendar month. We compared the predictive performance of these forecasts to those of two mathematical models with different spatial interaction components. Results: An ensemble combining the forecasts of all experts performed similarly to the two models. Experts showed stronger bias than models forecasting two-case threshold exceedance. Experts and models both performed better when predicting exceedance of higher thresholds. The models also tended to be better at risk-ranking areas than experts. Conclusions: Our results support the use of models in outbreak contexts, offering a convenient and scalable route to a quantified situational awareness, which can provide confidence in or to call into question existing advice of experts. There could be value in combining expert opinion and modelled forecasts to support the response to future outbreaks. Funding: This study was partly funded by the Department of Health and Social Care using UK Aid funding 47 and is managed by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (VEEPED: PR-OD-1017- 48 20002; AR and WJE). This study was partly funded by the Wellcome Trust (210758/Z/18/Z : JDM 49 and SF). The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and not necessarily 50 those of the funders.
- Open Access
Projected sudden step-wise increase in risk of large measles outbreaks in the Netherlands as susceptible children enter secondary school in 2025/26
Background Many unvaccinated children were naturally immunised through infection during the last national Measles epidemic in the Netherlands (2013/14). Over time susceptibility amongst school aged children in key under-vaccinated populations is likely to increase and warrants investigation. Methods We constructed a network to reflect the risk of transmission within and between schools in the Netherlands. Estimating school-level susceptibility rates using historical estimates and vaccine uptake. We evaluated the annual outbreak risk since 2014 projecting to 2030. Results As children born since the 2013/14 outbreak enter secondary school, the connectedness of the school-mediated contact network between susceptible children will increase sharply, resulting in a sudden increase in the risk of large measles outbreaks. Conclusions We anticipate a substantial increase in the risk of large measles outbreaks mediated by school-based transmission in 2025 and 2026 as larger numbers of susceptible children enter secondary school.
Open AccessProjected sudden step-wise increase in risk of large measles outbreaks in the Netherlands as susceptible children enter secondary school in 2025/26
Background Many unvaccinated children were naturally immunised through infection during the last national Measles epidemic in the Netherlands (2013/14). Over time susceptibility amongst school aged children in key under-vaccinated populations is likely to increase and warrants investigation. Methods We constructed a network to reflect the risk of transmission within and between schools in the Netherlands. Estimating school-level susceptibility rates using historical estimates and vaccine uptake. We evaluated the annual outbreak risk since 2014 projecting to 2030. Results As children born since the 2013/14 outbreak enter secondary school, the connectedness of the school-mediated contact network between susceptible children will increase sharply, resulting in a sudden increase in the risk of large measles outbreaks. Conclusions We anticipate a substantial increase in the risk of large measles outbreaks mediated by school-based transmission in 2025 and 2026 as larger numbers of susceptible children enter secondary school.
- Open Access
The relative contribution of close-proximity contacts, shared classroom exposure and indoor air quality to respiratory virus transmission in schools.
Close-proximity interactions are considered a key risk factor for respiratory virus transmission, but their importance relative to shared space and air quality remains unclear. We conducted a six-week longitudinal study in a Swiss secondary school (67 students, aged 14–15). We detected 87 infections in saliva samples and recorded absences to identify plausible transmissions, excluding implausible ones through genomic analysis. Time in close proximity (within 1.5 metres) was measured using wearable sensors and air quality via CO2 monitors. Students spent 21.2 minutes per day in close proximity (interquartile range 7.8–44.2) and 5.3 hours in shared classrooms (IQR 3.8–6.2), during which air quality was suboptimal for 1.9 hours (IQR 1.2–3.0). Using pairwise survival models, we found that transmission was more likely within than between classes. Close proximity was modestly associated with higher transmission risk overall (rate ratio 1.16 per doubling daily time, 95%-CI 1.01–1.33), while time in shared classrooms (RR 8.96, 95%-CI 4.85–16.88) and suboptimal air quality (RR 5.59 95%-CI 3.25–9.83) also predicted within-class risk. Prolonged exposure in shared, poorly ventilated spaces drives respiratory virus transmission more than close contact. Supplementary Information Supplementary methods and results for the genetic and pairwise survival analysis as well as genomic sequence accession codes.
Open AccessThe relative contribution of close-proximity contacts, shared classroom exposure and indoor air quality to respiratory virus transmission in schools.
Close-proximity interactions are considered a key risk factor for respiratory virus transmission, but their importance relative to shared space and air quality remains unclear. We conducted a six-week longitudinal study in a Swiss secondary school (67 students, aged 14–15). We detected 87 infections in saliva samples and recorded absences to identify plausible transmissions, excluding implausible ones through genomic analysis. Time in close proximity (within 1.5 metres) was measured using wearable sensors and air quality via CO2 monitors. Students spent 21.2 minutes per day in close proximity (interquartile range 7.8–44.2) and 5.3 hours in shared classrooms (IQR 3.8–6.2), during which air quality was suboptimal for 1.9 hours (IQR 1.2–3.0). Using pairwise survival models, we found that transmission was more likely within than between classes. Close proximity was modestly associated with higher transmission risk overall (rate ratio 1.16 per doubling daily time, 95%-CI 1.01–1.33), while time in shared classrooms (RR 8.96, 95%-CI 4.85–16.88) and suboptimal air quality (RR 5.59 95%-CI 3.25–9.83) also predicted within-class risk. Prolonged exposure in shared, poorly ventilated spaces drives respiratory virus transmission more than close contact. Supplementary Information Supplementary methods and results for the genetic and pairwise survival analysis as well as genomic sequence accession codes.
- Open Access
- 30 July 2025
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife preprints
- Vol. 13
Forecasting the spatial spread of an Ebola epidemic in real-time: comparing predictions of mathematical models and experts
Ebola virus disease outbreaks can often be controlled, but require rapid response efforts frequently with profound operational complexities. Mathematical models can be used to support response planning, but it is unclear if models improve the prior understanding of experts. We performed repeated surveys of Ebola response experts during an outbreak. From each expert we elicited the probability of cases exceeding four thresholds between two and 20 cases in a set of small geographical areas in the following calendar month. We compared the predictive performance of these forecasts to those of two mathematical models with different spatial interaction components. An ensemble combining the forecasts of all experts performed similarly to the two models. Experts showed stronger bias than models forecasting two-case threshold exceedance. Experts and models both performed better when predicting exceedance of higher thresholds. The models also tended to be better at risk-ranking areas than experts. Our results support the use of models in outbreak contexts, offering a convenient and scalable route to a quantified situational awareness, which can provide confidence in or to call into question existing advice of experts. There could be value in combining expert opinion and modelled forecasts to support the response to future outbreaks.
- 30 July 2025
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife preprints
- Vol. 13
Open AccessForecasting the spatial spread of an Ebola epidemic in real-time: comparing predictions of mathematical models and experts
Ebola virus disease outbreaks can often be controlled, but require rapid response efforts frequently with profound operational complexities. Mathematical models can be used to support response planning, but it is unclear if models improve the prior understanding of experts. We performed repeated surveys of Ebola response experts during an outbreak. From each expert we elicited the probability of cases exceeding four thresholds between two and 20 cases in a set of small geographical areas in the following calendar month. We compared the predictive performance of these forecasts to those of two mathematical models with different spatial interaction components. An ensemble combining the forecasts of all experts performed similarly to the two models. Experts showed stronger bias than models forecasting two-case threshold exceedance. Experts and models both performed better when predicting exceedance of higher thresholds. The models also tended to be better at risk-ranking areas than experts. Our results support the use of models in outbreak contexts, offering a convenient and scalable route to a quantified situational awareness, which can provide confidence in or to call into question existing advice of experts. There could be value in combining expert opinion and modelled forecasts to support the response to future outbreaks.