DMDiana Mazzarella

Diana Mazzarella

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Diana Mazzarella has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    When irony is (mis)understood: Vigilance cues affect irony comprehension in written discourse

    by Ana Milosavljevic, Nausicaa Pouscoulous, Diana Mazzarella

    Irony comprehension requires going beyond literal meaning to infer a speaker’s dissociative stance. Pragmatic accounts propose that this entails evaluating a speaker’s vigilance towards the falsity or irrelevance of the literal proposition, a cognitively demanding process even for adults. Yet, previous research often presupposes successful irony comprehension, focusing on processing measures rather than directly testing interpretive accuracy. This study adopts a theory-driven approach by manipulating speaker cues as pragmatic markers of epistemic vigilance and assessing their impact on irony processing and comprehension. Participants read vignettes with ironical or literal utterances produced by speakers described as epistemically vigilant or non-vigilant. Online processing was assessed through reading times, while irony understanding was measured with polar questions probing interpretations of the speaker’s belief and communicative intent. Results showed that participants often misinterpreted ironical statements but were significantly more accurate when speakers were described as vigilant, indicating that speaker-based epistemic cues guide pragmatic interpretation. This effect emerged in comprehension but not in online processing, suggesting that evaluations of speaker intent occur later during more reflective stages of interpretation. These findings underscore the interpretive complexity of irony, challenge assumptions about its automatic understanding in adults, and highlight the socially situated nature of pragmatic inference, with implications for theories of communication and language processing.

  • Open Access

    Speakers’ responsibility for evidential claims

    by Mélinda Pozzi, Diana Mazzarella

    People are vigilant toward the risk of misinformation and assess speakers’ trustworthiness to calibrate their trust accordingly. This assessment can target speakers’ epistemic commitments, conveyed through evidential claims. Speakers may take responsibility for the truth of a proposition by reporting first-hand evidence (“I saw that p ”) or defer responsibility by referring to second-hand evidence (“somebody told me that p ”). This pre-registered study experimentally investigates whether trust calibration is sensitive to the accuracy of these evidential claims. Our findings show that when a speaker shared accurate information p but provided an inaccurate evidential claim, the negative impact on perceived trustworthiness was greater for the strong perceptual evidential claim than the weak hearsay claim. These results provide new evidence that overcommitting by claiming direct visual evidence for information acquired second-hand is more reputationally damaging than appealing to hearsay despite having direct evidence. We discuss the implications for designing more trustworthy artificial agents.

  • Open Access

    Redescribing early pragmatics

    by Edoardo Vaccargiu, Diana Mazzarella

    Developmental work on ostensive communication calls for reconsidering existing theoretical accounts within a comprehensive framework of early pragmatics and its development. In this paper, we propose a new perspective on the ontogeny and development of ostensive communication as underpinned by a process of knowledge and representational redescription. By discussing relevant empirical data, we ground early pragmatics on in‐built principles of implicit knowledge that are redescribed during communicative development, shedding new light on the representations underlying infant ostensive communication and its development into rich pragmatic knowledge involving complex intentions and metarepresentations.

  • Open Access

    Children’s vigilance towards others’ gullibility

    by Marie Aguirre, Nausicaa Pouscoulous, Diana Mazzarella

    Humans are endowed with a suite of cognitive mechanisms that enable them to mitigate the risk of misinformation and underlie their epistemic vigilance. When direct access to the initial source of information is unavailable, individuals often rely on the vigilance of others to acquire beliefs. Moreover, monitoring the critical alertness of one’s interlocutors is essential for interpreting their communicative intentions, particularly in cases of deliberately conveying false information, such as lies or verbal irony. However, little is known about the human capacity to track others’ epistemic vigilance and use this information to guide belief formation and pragmatic interpretation. This study investigates whether children aged from 4 to 8 selectively trust vigilant over gullible informants. Our findings suggest that selective trust based on informant vigilance towards inaccuracy begins to emerge around the age of 6.

  • Attitude understanding and irony development

    by Ana Milosavljevic, Diana Mazzarella

    A distinctive feature of verbal irony is the expression of a dissociative attitude. Although attitude understanding represents a key element of irony comprehension and its development, the experimental research in this area remains fragmented and often yields mixed findings. This paper reviews the measures employed to target distinct aspects of irony understanding, including attitude recognition, and examines inconsistencies in their application. Furthermore, it explores how features of experimental stimuli — including contextual, verbal, and paraverbal cues — can affect children’s performance. Our analysis lays the foundation for refining the conceptualisation of the dissociation expressed by the ironical attitude and overcoming methodological challenges such as ensuring consistency in the design of measures and their alignment with experimental stimuli. Adopting a more rigorous and integrative approach has the potential to illuminate the developmental trajectory of ironical attitude comprehension and support the establishment of more systematic and reliable research in this domain.

  • Open Access

    Kidding kids

    by Diana Mazzarella, Nausicaa Pouscoulous

    Young children are notoriously bad at understanding ironical statements, with irony comprehension emerging around the age of 6 and appearing resistant to task manipulation. What can explain this late emergence? We propose that children’s epistemic vigilance is a pivotal component of the constellation of socio-cognitive abilities underpinning irony comprehension. Epistemic vigilance enables children to detect the contextual incongruity of an ironical statement, discern that the ironical speaker is neither mistaken nor deceptive, and infer the critical, dissociative attitude expressed through verbal irony. By highlighting the role of epistemic vigilance, this account provides insight into the developmental puzzle of irony comprehension. It elucidates why its developmental trajectory diverges from that of other forms of figurative or humorous language and why it is closely linked to lie understanding and second-order false belief reasoning.

    • 13 March 2026
      • Vol. 265, 106497

    Trusting the vigilant: How children value others' vigilance against deception.

    by Diana Mazzarella, Marie Aguirre, Thomas Castelain, Nausicaa Pouscoulous

    Humans rely extensively on communicated information, yet communication exposes receivers to the risk of misinformation. To manage this risk, individuals must not only be vigilant against dishonest informants but also monitor others' vigilance towards deception, especially when information is transmitted across social chains. The present study investigates children's vigilance towards dishonesty ('first-order vigilance'), as well as their ability to monitor others' vigilance and to make trust decisions accordingly ('second-order vigilance'). Children aged four to seven years completed three tasks assessing first-order vigilance towards dishonest informants and three tasks using a novel second-order vigilance paradigm, measuring their tendency to trust informants who had previously shown vigilance or gullibility towards deception. Our findings show that children's first-order vigilance towards dishonesty improves between the ages of four and seven, and is modulated by how deceptive informants are characterised. Children are less likely to trust informants described as lying or having antisocial intentions (epistemic and intentional dimensions of deception) than those described simply as mean (moral dimension of deception). Furthermore, from the age of four to five, children are more likely to trust an informant who has previously demonstrated vigilance towards dishonesty than one who has shown gullibility, based on observational evidence of their past trust towards a dishonest source. These findings shed light on children's emerging sensitivity to the social history of communicated information and point to the role of second-order vigilance mechanisms in mitigating the risk of misinformation through transmission.

  • A Socio-Epistemic Theory of Attachment: Part I. Secure Attachment as Epistemic Trust and Its Place in Development

    by Alessandro Talia, Robbie Duschinsky, Diana Mazzarella, Katarina Begus, Johann R. Kleinbub, Madeleine Miller-Bottome, Svenja Taubner, Jeremy Holmes, Peter Fonagy

  • A Socio-Epistemic Theory of Attachment: Part III. A Relevance-Based Taxonomy for the Adult Attachment Interview (AAI) Coding System

    by Alessandro Talia, Robbie Duschinsky, Diana Mazzarella, Katarina Begus, Johann R. Kleinbub, Madeleine Miller-Bottome, Svenja Taubner, Jeremy Holmes, Peter Fonagy

  • A Socio-Epistemic Theory of Attachment: Part II. Adult Attachment Classifications as Differences in Fostering Epistemic Trust

    by Alessandro Talia, Robbie Duschinsky, Diana Mazzarella, Katarina Begus, Johann R. Kleinbub, Madeleine Miller-Bottome, Svenja Taubner, Jeremy Holmes, Peter Fonagy