Nik Lomax
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Nik Lomax has a total of 115 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Michelle A. Morris
University of Leeds
9 shared publications - Stephen Clark
University of Leeds
7 shared publications - Paul Norman
University of Leeds
6 shared publications - Alison Heppenstall
University of Glasgow
4 shared publications - Andreas Höhn
University of Glasgow
4 shared publications Mark Birkin
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 7 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science
COMPASS – An open-source software package for creating multi-level representative nested synthetic populations for small areas
Simulation models, such as agent-based or microsimulation models capturing urban contexts, increasingly draw on spatially explicit, attribute-rich synthetic population datasets as real-world data inputs. Despite their growing relevance, the creation of such datasets via simulated annealing still faces significant limitations. Addressing these limitations, we present the open-source software package Combinatorial Optimisation for Microdata Population Assembly and Spatial Synthesis (COMPASS) . The algorithm implemented in COMPASS enables: aggregate-level representativeness at different levels of counts (e.g., households and individuals); the processing of nested input data (e.g., retaining survey household and kinship structures); and systematic monitoring of uncertainty arising at creation stage. We provide COMPASS as a compiled multi-platform software package, suitable for reproducible workflows via R and Python. This paper introduces COMPASS and illustrates one potential workflow using open access data created to reflect an artificial population – transferable to many national contexts.
- 7 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science
Open AccessCOMPASS – An open-source software package for creating multi-level representative nested synthetic populations for small areas
Simulation models, such as agent-based or microsimulation models capturing urban contexts, increasingly draw on spatially explicit, attribute-rich synthetic population datasets as real-world data inputs. Despite their growing relevance, the creation of such datasets via simulated annealing still faces significant limitations. Addressing these limitations, we present the open-source software package Combinatorial Optimisation for Microdata Population Assembly and Spatial Synthesis (COMPASS) . The algorithm implemented in COMPASS enables: aggregate-level representativeness at different levels of counts (e.g., households and individuals); the processing of nested input data (e.g., retaining survey household and kinship structures); and systematic monitoring of uncertainty arising at creation stage. We provide COMPASS as a compiled multi-platform software package, suitable for reproducible workflows via R and Python. This paper introduces COMPASS and illustrates one potential workflow using open access data created to reflect an artificial population – transferable to many national contexts.
- 30 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Geographical Analysis
- Vol. 58 (3)
Advancing Spatial Health Inequalities Research: Innovations in Data, Methods, and Theory—Special Issue Introduction
Inequalities in population health outcomes, often captured between or within areas, remain a widespread feature of societies around the world. Many of these inequalities are deeply rooted in structural mechanisms, stemming from long‐standing disparities in the distribution of and access to key resources impacting health. Despite extensive research and policy efforts to reduce these spatial health inequalities, many have proven persistent—and some have further widened within recent years. This special issue seeks to deepen our understanding of spatial health inequalities by showcasing a range of innovations in an increasingly interdisciplinary field. All included contributions are novel and often extend well‐established approaches within their respective core disciplines either analytically or conceptually. Despite a high degree of innovation, causality remains a central challenge. Most contributions highlight these persistent difficulties in causal inference explicitly, calling for integrative frameworks that combine quantitative, qualitative, and participatory methods. Collectively, this special issue demonstrates how interdisciplinary collaboration can deepen our understanding of spatial health inequalities and their determinants. At the same time, findings highlight clearly that a real‐world narrowing of spatial health inequalities will very likely also depend on the effective translation of evidence into actionable policy recommendations and political will.
- 30 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Geographical Analysis
- Vol. 58 (3)
Advancing Spatial Health Inequalities Research: Innovations in Data, Methods, and Theory—Special Issue Introduction
Inequalities in population health outcomes, often captured between or within areas, remain a widespread feature of societies around the world. Many of these inequalities are deeply rooted in structural mechanisms, stemming from long‐standing disparities in the distribution of and access to key resources impacting health. Despite extensive research and policy efforts to reduce these spatial health inequalities, many have proven persistent—and some have further widened within recent years. This special issue seeks to deepen our understanding of spatial health inequalities by showcasing a range of innovations in an increasingly interdisciplinary field. All included contributions are novel and often extend well‐established approaches within their respective core disciplines either analytically or conceptually. Despite a high degree of innovation, causality remains a central challenge. Most contributions highlight these persistent difficulties in causal inference explicitly, calling for integrative frameworks that combine quantitative, qualitative, and participatory methods. Collectively, this special issue demonstrates how interdisciplinary collaboration can deepen our understanding of spatial health inequalities and their determinants. At the same time, findings highlight clearly that a real‐world narrowing of spatial health inequalities will very likely also depend on the effective translation of evidence into actionable policy recommendations and political will.
- Open Access
- 27 May 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 63 (15) , 3399-3418
A multilevel analysis of pupils’ travel distance to primary school: Simultaneously modelling origins and destinations
Understanding children’s travel distance to school is essential for promoting educational equity and well-being. In China, the hukou (household registration) system, which regulates access to education and other public services by place of official registration, shapes the distribution of educational resources. Yet little research has examined school travel distance in this context or the individual and contextual sources of its variation. This study employs nested and cross-classified multilevel models to analyse how individual and contextual factors affect pupils’ travel distances, as well as exploring interactions between these factors, and link these findings to hukou-based enrolment. By simultaneously considering multiple geographies, this study reveals that children’s travel distance is shaped by both individual-level factors and contextual-level determinants at both origins and destinations. Individual and contextual variables are not isolated in this process, with hukou status as a key individual factor, school type mediating the relationship between hukou and travel distance, and a cross-level interaction also existing between neighbourhood population density and hukou status. Those findings indicate that hukou-based school enrolment plays an important role in shaping pupils’ travel distances, making reform of related enrolment policies a priority for advancing educational equity and guiding future planning.
- 27 May 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 63 (15) , 3399-3418
Open AccessA multilevel analysis of pupils’ travel distance to primary school: Simultaneously modelling origins and destinations
Understanding children’s travel distance to school is essential for promoting educational equity and well-being. In China, the hukou (household registration) system, which regulates access to education and other public services by place of official registration, shapes the distribution of educational resources. Yet little research has examined school travel distance in this context or the individual and contextual sources of its variation. This study employs nested and cross-classified multilevel models to analyse how individual and contextual factors affect pupils’ travel distances, as well as exploring interactions between these factors, and link these findings to hukou-based enrolment. By simultaneously considering multiple geographies, this study reveals that children’s travel distance is shaped by both individual-level factors and contextual-level determinants at both origins and destinations. Individual and contextual variables are not isolated in this process, with hukou status as a key individual factor, school type mediating the relationship between hukou and travel distance, and a cross-level interaction also existing between neighbourhood population density and hukou status. Those findings indicate that hukou-based school enrolment plays an important role in shaping pupils’ travel distances, making reform of related enrolment policies a priority for advancing educational equity and guiding future planning.
- Open Access
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Geographical Analysis
- Vol. 58 (2)
Do Welfare Regimes Matter? A Comparative Analysis of Area‐Level Inequalities in Life Expectancy in Germany and the United Kingdom, 2003–2021
While area‐level inequalities in life expectancy are well documented within individual countries, cross‐national comparisons remain rare. We estimated and compared the magnitude of area‐level life expectancy inequalities across districts in the UK and Germany, representing two distinct welfare regimes. We used mortality data from national statistical offices to estimate life expectancy for all districts between 2003 and 2021. Based on employment data, we assigned a deprivation decile to each district within both countries and calculated life expectancy for each decile. Using the slope index of inequality, we compared temporal trends in life expectancy inequalities across deciles in both countries. We found that, although life expectancy was similar in both countries, the UK consistently showed higher levels of area‐level inequality than Germany. While district‐level life expectancy inequalities increased in both countries over time, they rose more sharply in the UK, particularly during the first years of the Covid‐19 pandemic. These findings are likely to reflect deeply rooted differences in governmental approaches to ensuring equitable living conditions across two distinct welfare regimes.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Geographical Analysis
- Vol. 58 (2)
Open AccessDo Welfare Regimes Matter? A Comparative Analysis of Area‐Level Inequalities in Life Expectancy in Germany and the United Kingdom, 2003–2021
While area‐level inequalities in life expectancy are well documented within individual countries, cross‐national comparisons remain rare. We estimated and compared the magnitude of area‐level life expectancy inequalities across districts in the UK and Germany, representing two distinct welfare regimes. We used mortality data from national statistical offices to estimate life expectancy for all districts between 2003 and 2021. Based on employment data, we assigned a deprivation decile to each district within both countries and calculated life expectancy for each decile. Using the slope index of inequality, we compared temporal trends in life expectancy inequalities across deciles in both countries. We found that, although life expectancy was similar in both countries, the UK consistently showed higher levels of area‐level inequality than Germany. While district‐level life expectancy inequalities increased in both countries over time, they rose more sharply in the UK, particularly during the first years of the Covid‐19 pandemic. These findings are likely to reflect deeply rooted differences in governmental approaches to ensuring equitable living conditions across two distinct welfare regimes.
- Open Access
- 25 November 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
The “AIP” Framework: Sharing learnings from a case study of a successful Academic Industry data sharing Partnership
There is a "data revolution" where data are generated by many aspects of public life, and though not originally intended for research, these data can be repurposed for research applications. However, in social research relating to nutrition and health, academic-industry data sharing partnerships are rare. This exploratory research uses insights from a case study of a successful academic-industry data sharing partnership in social research to produce a pilot framework to aid the generation of industry-academia data sharing collaborations. Ten participants were interviewed: six from the University of Leeds, and four from a large UK supermarket, Sainsbury’s Plc, from different roles across the partnership. We used semi-structured interviews and analysed data using deductive reflexive thematic analysis. The resultant themes were organised into a preliminary framework based on the Data Sharing Pyramid (how raw data is transformed into wisdom through processing and interpretation). Our preliminary insights form the - Academia-Industry Partnership (AIP) framework - which constitutes four components: 1) the Research Infrastructure Foundation, where participants emphasised the importance of investing time and resources before starting research; 2) the Data Sharing Process, which involves applying principles of the research infrastructure foundation and robust data governance to enable sharing of novel commercially sensitive data; 3) the Research Process, which captured how shared data is used and the resulting outputs and impacts; and 4) the Partnership Strategy which focused on nurturing the partnership across all areas of the framework. This study uniquely uses a real-world case study to develop a preliminary framework, facilitating shared learnings for the development of data sharing partnerships in social research to further the use of commercial data for public good.
- 25 November 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessThe “AIP” Framework: Sharing learnings from a case study of a successful Academic Industry data sharing Partnership
There is a "data revolution" where data are generated by many aspects of public life, and though not originally intended for research, these data can be repurposed for research applications. However, in social research relating to nutrition and health, academic-industry data sharing partnerships are rare. This exploratory research uses insights from a case study of a successful academic-industry data sharing partnership in social research to produce a pilot framework to aid the generation of industry-academia data sharing collaborations. Ten participants were interviewed: six from the University of Leeds, and four from a large UK supermarket, Sainsbury’s Plc, from different roles across the partnership. We used semi-structured interviews and analysed data using deductive reflexive thematic analysis. The resultant themes were organised into a preliminary framework based on the Data Sharing Pyramid (how raw data is transformed into wisdom through processing and interpretation). Our preliminary insights form the - Academia-Industry Partnership (AIP) framework - which constitutes four components: 1) the Research Infrastructure Foundation, where participants emphasised the importance of investing time and resources before starting research; 2) the Data Sharing Process, which involves applying principles of the research infrastructure foundation and robust data governance to enable sharing of novel commercially sensitive data; 3) the Research Process, which captured how shared data is used and the resulting outputs and impacts; and 4) the Partnership Strategy which focused on nurturing the partnership across all areas of the framework. This study uniquely uses a real-world case study to develop a preliminary framework, facilitating shared learnings for the development of data sharing partnerships in social research to further the use of commercial data for public good.
- Open Access
Estimating quality-adjusted life expectancy (QALE) for local authorities in Great Britain and its association with indicators of the inclusive economy: a cross-sectional study
Objectives: Quantifying area-level inequalities in population health can help to inform policy responses. We describe an approach for estimating quality-adjusted life expectancy (QALE), a comprehensive health expectancy measure, for local authorities (LAs) in Great Britain (GB). To identify potential factors accounting for LA-level QALE inequalities, we examined the association between inclusive economy indicators and QALE. Setting: 361/363 LAs in GB (lower tier/district level) within the period 2018–2020. Data and methods: We estimated life tables for LAs using official statistics and utility scores from an area-level linkage of the Understanding Society survey. Using the Sullivan method, we estimated QALE at birth in years with corresponding 80% CIs. To examine the association between inclusive economy indicators and QALE, we used an open access data set operationalising the inclusive economy, created by the System Science in Public Health and Health Economics Research consortium. Results: Population-weighted QALE estimates across LAs in GB were lowest in Scotland (females/males: 65.1 years/64.9 years) and Wales (65.0 years/65.2 years), while they were highest in England (67.5 years/67.6 years). The range across LAs for females was from 56.3 years (80% CI 45.6 to 67.1) in Mansfield to 77.7 years (80% CI 65.11 to 90.2) in Runnymede. QALE for males ranged from 57.5 years (80% CI 40.2 to 74.7) in Merthyr Tydfil to 77.2 years (80% CI 65.4 to 89.1) in Runnymede. Indicators of the inclusive economy accounted for more than half of the variation in QALE at the LA level (adjusted R 2 females/males: 50%/57%). Although more inclusivity was generally associated with higher levels of QALE at the LA level, this association was not consistent across all 13 inclusive economy indicators. Conclusions: QALE can be estimated for LAs in GB, enabling further research into area-level health inequalities. The associations we identified between inclusive economy indicators and QALE highlight potential policy priorities for improving population health and reducing health inequalities.
Open AccessEstimating quality-adjusted life expectancy (QALE) for local authorities in Great Britain and its association with indicators of the inclusive economy: a cross-sectional study
Objectives: Quantifying area-level inequalities in population health can help to inform policy responses. We describe an approach for estimating quality-adjusted life expectancy (QALE), a comprehensive health expectancy measure, for local authorities (LAs) in Great Britain (GB). To identify potential factors accounting for LA-level QALE inequalities, we examined the association between inclusive economy indicators and QALE. Setting: 361/363 LAs in GB (lower tier/district level) within the period 2018–2020. Data and methods: We estimated life tables for LAs using official statistics and utility scores from an area-level linkage of the Understanding Society survey. Using the Sullivan method, we estimated QALE at birth in years with corresponding 80% CIs. To examine the association between inclusive economy indicators and QALE, we used an open access data set operationalising the inclusive economy, created by the System Science in Public Health and Health Economics Research consortium. Results: Population-weighted QALE estimates across LAs in GB were lowest in Scotland (females/males: 65.1 years/64.9 years) and Wales (65.0 years/65.2 years), while they were highest in England (67.5 years/67.6 years). The range across LAs for females was from 56.3 years (80% CI 45.6 to 67.1) in Mansfield to 77.7 years (80% CI 65.11 to 90.2) in Runnymede. QALE for males ranged from 57.5 years (80% CI 40.2 to 74.7) in Merthyr Tydfil to 77.2 years (80% CI 65.4 to 89.1) in Runnymede. Indicators of the inclusive economy accounted for more than half of the variation in QALE at the LA level (adjusted R 2 females/males: 50%/57%). Although more inclusivity was generally associated with higher levels of QALE at the LA level, this association was not consistent across all 13 inclusive economy indicators. Conclusions: QALE can be estimated for LAs in GB, enabling further research into area-level health inequalities. The associations we identified between inclusive economy indicators and QALE highlight potential policy priorities for improving population health and reducing health inequalities.
- 1 September 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Smart Infrastructure and Construction
- Vol. 176 (3) , 108-116
DAFNI: a computational platform to support infrastructure systems research
Research into the engineering of infrastructure systems is increasingly data intensive. Researchers build computational models to explore scenarios such as investigating the merits of infrastructure plans, analysing historical data to inform system operations or assessing the impacts of infrastructure on the environment. Models are more complex, at higher resolution and with larger coverage. Researchers also require a ‘multi-systems’ approach to explore interactions between systems, such as energy and water with urban development, and across scales, from buildings and streets to regions or nations. Consequently, researchers need enhanced computational resources to support cross-institutional collaboration and sharing at scale. The Data and Analytics Facility for National Infrastructure (DAFNI) is an emerging computational platform for infrastructure systems research. It provides high-throughput compute resources so larger data sets can be used, with a data repository to upload data and share these with collaborators. Users’ models can also be uploaded and executed using modern containerisation techniques, giving platform independence, scaling and sharing. Further, models can be combined into workflows, supporting multi-systems modelling and generating visualisations to present results. DAFNI forms a central resource accessible to all infrastructure systems researchers in the UK, supporting collaboration and providing a legacy, keeping data and models available beyond the lifetime of a project.
- 1 September 2023
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Smart Infrastructure and Construction
- Vol. 176 (3) , 108-116
DAFNI: a computational platform to support infrastructure systems research
Research into the engineering of infrastructure systems is increasingly data intensive. Researchers build computational models to explore scenarios such as investigating the merits of infrastructure plans, analysing historical data to inform system operations or assessing the impacts of infrastructure on the environment. Models are more complex, at higher resolution and with larger coverage. Researchers also require a ‘multi-systems’ approach to explore interactions between systems, such as energy and water with urban development, and across scales, from buildings and streets to regions or nations. Consequently, researchers need enhanced computational resources to support cross-institutional collaboration and sharing at scale. The Data and Analytics Facility for National Infrastructure (DAFNI) is an emerging computational platform for infrastructure systems research. It provides high-throughput compute resources so larger data sets can be used, with a data repository to upload data and share these with collaborators. Users’ models can also be uploaded and executed using modern containerisation techniques, giving platform independence, scaling and sharing. Further, models can be combined into workflows, supporting multi-systems modelling and generating visualisations to present results. DAFNI forms a central resource accessible to all infrastructure systems researchers in the UK, supporting collaboration and providing a legacy, keeping data and models available beyond the lifetime of a project.
- Open Access
- 25 July 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Briefing note: A dynamic model of disposable income impacts on mental health
This note provides an overview of the provisional results from a dynamic microsimulation model called MINOS which assesses the impact on an individual's mental health (measured as SF-12 Mental Component Score) that result because of changes to household disposable income. There are five pathways that link household disposable income to mental heath (housing quality, neighbourhood safety, nutritional quality, tobacco use, and loneliness). We estimate change in SF-12 under three different scenarios: an uplift to the living wage for low earning employees; an uplift to child benefit, applied universally as £25 per child translated to household disposable income; and the impact that the new energy price `cap' will have on household disposable income. As well as the change in SF-12 MCS at the whole population level, we present the change in the sub-populations impacted by each policy experiment and assess the spatial distribution of each policy in the city of Glasgow, Scotland. We find that raising disposable income through the living wage and child benefit uplift scenarios have a modest positive impact on overall mental health and a larger impact in the intervention groups. The impact of increased energy prices has the effect of reducing household disposable income, and so has a negative impact on overall mental health. This note represents work in progress: further detailed methodology, reproducible code and latest results can be accessed via the project github page at https://github.com/Leeds-MRG/Minos.
- 25 July 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessBriefing note: A dynamic model of disposable income impacts on mental health
This note provides an overview of the provisional results from a dynamic microsimulation model called MINOS which assesses the impact on an individual's mental health (measured as SF-12 Mental Component Score) that result because of changes to household disposable income. There are five pathways that link household disposable income to mental heath (housing quality, neighbourhood safety, nutritional quality, tobacco use, and loneliness). We estimate change in SF-12 under three different scenarios: an uplift to the living wage for low earning employees; an uplift to child benefit, applied universally as £25 per child translated to household disposable income; and the impact that the new energy price `cap' will have on household disposable income. As well as the change in SF-12 MCS at the whole population level, we present the change in the sub-populations impacted by each policy experiment and assess the spatial distribution of each policy in the city of Glasgow, Scotland. We find that raising disposable income through the living wage and child benefit uplift scenarios have a modest positive impact on overall mental health and a larger impact in the intervention groups. The impact of increased energy prices has the effect of reducing household disposable income, and so has a negative impact on overall mental health. This note represents work in progress: further detailed methodology, reproducible code and latest results can be accessed via the project github page at https://github.com/Leeds-MRG/Minos.
- Open Access
- 26 April 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Studies
- Vol. 45 (2) , 159-182
Using e-petition data to quantify public concerns during the COVID-19 pandemic: a case study of England
The COVID-19 pandemic has had a profound impact on society and many governments and politicians were required to make quick decisions to protect public health. In reaching these decisions they needed to weigh advice from experts in many fields and then “sell” these decisions. However little was known at the time about the desires and aspirations of their electorates. Here we identify one such source of public opinion, signatures to various COVID-19 related Parliamentary e-petitions Whilst there were over 1,500 such e-petitions, we identify 27 common and meaningful topics and show how the strength of these topics varies between individual parliamentary constituencies. Using a measure of support for each topic in the constituencies we identify five constituency groupings. There are two Conservative voting groups, “Middle England” and “Equity of Support”, the former are located largely in southern England whilst the latter are in the midlands and northern England. The groups that show strong support in Labour voting constituencies are ones around education and funding issues. This article shows how a targeted range of e-petitions can be grouped into topics and the popularity of topics established, and thereby function as a useful way of augmenting democracy and democratic institutions.
- 26 April 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Studies
- Vol. 45 (2) , 159-182
Open AccessUsing e-petition data to quantify public concerns during the COVID-19 pandemic: a case study of England
The COVID-19 pandemic has had a profound impact on society and many governments and politicians were required to make quick decisions to protect public health. In reaching these decisions they needed to weigh advice from experts in many fields and then “sell” these decisions. However little was known at the time about the desires and aspirations of their electorates. Here we identify one such source of public opinion, signatures to various COVID-19 related Parliamentary e-petitions Whilst there were over 1,500 such e-petitions, we identify 27 common and meaningful topics and show how the strength of these topics varies between individual parliamentary constituencies. Using a measure of support for each topic in the constituencies we identify five constituency groupings. There are two Conservative voting groups, “Middle England” and “Equity of Support”, the former are located largely in southern England whilst the latter are in the midlands and northern England. The groups that show strong support in Labour voting constituencies are ones around education and funding issues. This article shows how a targeted range of e-petitions can be grouped into topics and the popularity of topics established, and thereby function as a useful way of augmenting democracy and democratic institutions.
- Open Access
- 16 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Nutrition
- Vol. 8 (1) , 1-18
Targeted policy intervention for reducing red meat consumption: conflicts and trade-offs
Background: There are a range of policies and guidelines focused on meat consumption which aim to tackle health and environmental issues. Policies are often siloed in nature and propose universal limits on consumption. Despite this, there will be a number of conflicts and trade-offs between interest groups. This study explores secondary impacts associated with guidelines issued by the World Cancer Research Fund and assesses the utility of a targeted policy intervention strategy for reducing red meat consumption. Methods: We used highly detailed consumption data of over 5,000 individuals from the National Diet and Nutrition Survey. We firstly compared individual consumption against the policy guidelines to identify demographic groups most likely to consume above recommended levels. We then synthetically modified the food diary data to investigate the secondary impacts of adherence to the recommendations by all individuals. We assessed changes in overall consumption, nutrient intake (iron, zinc, vitamin B12, vitamin B3, fat and saturated fat) and global warming potential. We also projected future impacts under various population projections. Results: We found that certain demographic groups are much more likely to exceed the recommendations and would therefore benefit from a targeted intervention approach. Our results provide a baseline for which the impacts of any meat substitute diets can be assessed against. Whilst secondary health benefits may be realised by reducing intake of certain nutrients (e.g. fats), negative impacts may occur due to the reduced intake of other nutrients (e.g. iron, zinc). Reduced overall consumption is likely to have implications for the wider meat industry whilst complementary impacts would occur in terms of reduced greenhouse gas emissions. Impacts will be counteracted or maybe even reversed by any substitute products, highlighting the need to carefully consider the suitability and impacts of meat-replacements. Conclusion: The future structure of the meat industry will depend on how conflicts and trade-offs are addressed and how more holistic policy ideas are implemented. This research provides a framework for using demographic and consumption data to reduce negative trade-offs and improve policy effectiveness.
- 16 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Nutrition
- Vol. 8 (1) , 1-18
Open AccessTargeted policy intervention for reducing red meat consumption: conflicts and trade-offs
Background: There are a range of policies and guidelines focused on meat consumption which aim to tackle health and environmental issues. Policies are often siloed in nature and propose universal limits on consumption. Despite this, there will be a number of conflicts and trade-offs between interest groups. This study explores secondary impacts associated with guidelines issued by the World Cancer Research Fund and assesses the utility of a targeted policy intervention strategy for reducing red meat consumption. Methods: We used highly detailed consumption data of over 5,000 individuals from the National Diet and Nutrition Survey. We firstly compared individual consumption against the policy guidelines to identify demographic groups most likely to consume above recommended levels. We then synthetically modified the food diary data to investigate the secondary impacts of adherence to the recommendations by all individuals. We assessed changes in overall consumption, nutrient intake (iron, zinc, vitamin B12, vitamin B3, fat and saturated fat) and global warming potential. We also projected future impacts under various population projections. Results: We found that certain demographic groups are much more likely to exceed the recommendations and would therefore benefit from a targeted intervention approach. Our results provide a baseline for which the impacts of any meat substitute diets can be assessed against. Whilst secondary health benefits may be realised by reducing intake of certain nutrients (e.g. fats), negative impacts may occur due to the reduced intake of other nutrients (e.g. iron, zinc). Reduced overall consumption is likely to have implications for the wider meat industry whilst complementary impacts would occur in terms of reduced greenhouse gas emissions. Impacts will be counteracted or maybe even reversed by any substitute products, highlighting the need to carefully consider the suitability and impacts of meat-replacements. Conclusion: The future structure of the meat industry will depend on how conflicts and trade-offs are addressed and how more holistic policy ideas are implemented. This research provides a framework for using demographic and consumption data to reduce negative trade-offs and improve policy effectiveness.