Matthew E. Craig
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Matthew E. Craig has a total of 176 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anthony P. Walker
Environmental Sciences Division and Climate Change Science Institute Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oak Ridge Tennessee USA
6 shared publications - Richard P. Phillips
Department of Biology Indiana University Bloomington Indiana USA
5 shared publications - Melanie A. Mayes
Environmental Sciences Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN, USA
4 shared publications Richard P. Phillips
Department of Biology Indiana University Bloomington Indiana USA
4 shared publications- Katilyn Victoria Beidler
Department of Biology, Indiana University, Bloomington, USA
3 shared publications - Rose Z. Abramoff
School of Forest Resources, University of Maine, Orono, USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 8 (5) , 1389-1393
Anthromes and terrestrial carbon
This article is the Editorial for the Special Collection ‘Anthromes and terrestrial carbon: From the deep past to net‐zero’. See https://nph.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/hub/anthromes-and-terrestrial-carbon for more details.
- 18 December 2025
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 8 (5) , 1389-1393
Open AccessAnthromes and terrestrial carbon
This article is the Editorial for the Special Collection ‘Anthromes and terrestrial carbon: From the deep past to net‐zero’. See https://nph.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/hub/anthromes-and-terrestrial-carbon for more details.
- Open Access
- 24 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 114 (1)
Seeing the forest for all the trees: Mycorrhizal‐associated nutrient economies are modulated by stem density and the synchrony between overstorey and understorey communities
Identifying relationships between plant communities and soil characteristics is a critical step in understanding the consequences of species gains and losses in ecosystems. The mycorrhizal associated nutrient economy (MANE) hypothesis predicts that the degree to which tree species and their mycorrhizal associates affect soil properties is driven by the relative dominance of different mycorrhizal types (often measured by relative basal area). While this approach emphasizes the importance of canopy trees, it does not account for how other factors (e.g. the density and composition of understorey trees) may alter tree–soil relationships. We analysed tree–soil data from an eastern deciduous forest in southern Indiana, USA that contains >29,000 georeferenced stems, including 21 species that associate with arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi and 14 that associate with ectomycorrhizal (ECM) fungi. We sampled soils (upper 5 cm) from across the plot and modelled soil characteristics to tree communities. Given differences in soil characteristics among AM‐dominated and ECM‐dominated neighbourhoods, we hypothesized that relationships between tree‐mycorrhizal dominance and soils would be affected by both the density of stems in the plot (owing to ‘Zinke’ individual plant effects) and composition of the understorey trees (owing to ‘trait divergence effects’) In support of our Zinke hypothesis, we found that the relationships between tree‐mycorrhizal dominance and soil variables (soil pH, nitrification rates and carbon to nitrogen ratio) were strengthened as stand density increased. In support of the trait divergence hypothesis, we found that as the mismatch between overstorey and understorey composition increased (e.g. AM‐dominated understories beneath ECM‐dominated overstories and vice versa), the relationship between tree dominance and soil variables weakened. We were able to use these insights to create mycorrhizal metrics to predict soil variables that were sensitive to the structural composition of neighbourhoods. Synthesis . Our results indicate that relationships between plants and soils in forests are not only shaped by dominant overstorey trees but also the density and composition of understorey trees. Thus, efforts to predict the ecosystem consequences of species gains and losses may benefit from considering these elements of forest structure and not only the basal area of the dominant trees.
- 24 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 114 (1)
Open AccessSeeing the forest for all the trees: Mycorrhizal‐associated nutrient economies are modulated by stem density and the synchrony between overstorey and understorey communities
Identifying relationships between plant communities and soil characteristics is a critical step in understanding the consequences of species gains and losses in ecosystems. The mycorrhizal associated nutrient economy (MANE) hypothesis predicts that the degree to which tree species and their mycorrhizal associates affect soil properties is driven by the relative dominance of different mycorrhizal types (often measured by relative basal area). While this approach emphasizes the importance of canopy trees, it does not account for how other factors (e.g. the density and composition of understorey trees) may alter tree–soil relationships. We analysed tree–soil data from an eastern deciduous forest in southern Indiana, USA that contains >29,000 georeferenced stems, including 21 species that associate with arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi and 14 that associate with ectomycorrhizal (ECM) fungi. We sampled soils (upper 5 cm) from across the plot and modelled soil characteristics to tree communities. Given differences in soil characteristics among AM‐dominated and ECM‐dominated neighbourhoods, we hypothesized that relationships between tree‐mycorrhizal dominance and soils would be affected by both the density of stems in the plot (owing to ‘Zinke’ individual plant effects) and composition of the understorey trees (owing to ‘trait divergence effects’) In support of our Zinke hypothesis, we found that the relationships between tree‐mycorrhizal dominance and soil variables (soil pH, nitrification rates and carbon to nitrogen ratio) were strengthened as stand density increased. In support of the trait divergence hypothesis, we found that as the mismatch between overstorey and understorey composition increased (e.g. AM‐dominated understories beneath ECM‐dominated overstories and vice versa), the relationship between tree dominance and soil variables weakened. We were able to use these insights to create mycorrhizal metrics to predict soil variables that were sensitive to the structural composition of neighbourhoods. Synthesis . Our results indicate that relationships between plants and soils in forests are not only shaped by dominant overstorey trees but also the density and composition of understorey trees. Thus, efforts to predict the ecosystem consequences of species gains and losses may benefit from considering these elements of forest structure and not only the basal area of the dominant trees.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (9) , e70450
Which Plant Traits Increase Soil Carbon Sequestration? Empirical Evidence From a Long‐Term Poplar Genetic Diversity Trial
Plants play a key role in mediating soil response to global change, and breeding or engineering crops to increase soil organic carbon (SOC) storage is a potential route to land‐based carbon dioxide removal in agricultural systems. However, due to limited observational datasets plus shifting paradigms of SOC stabilization, it is unclear which plant traits are most important for enhancing different types of soil organic matter. Existing long‐term common gardens of genetically diverse plant populations may provide an opportunity to evaluate biological controls on SOC, separate from environmental or management variability. Here we report on soil and root chemical data collected for 24 genotypes within a 13‐year‐old common garden in northwestern Oregon planted with a large natural variant population of Populus trichocarpa . Fractionating surface soil (0–15 cm) revealed substantial variation in stocks of mineral‐associated organic matter (MAOM; 18–67 t C/ha) and particulate organic matter (POM; 2–22 t C/ha). Tree genotype explained 24% and 26% of the MAOM and POM stock variability, respectively, after controlling for background variability. We found minimal association between SOC concentration and either aboveground tree productivity or root biomass recalcitrance (C/N ratios and lignin content). In contrast, root elemental content appeared influential for MAOM‐C concentration, which showed a strong positive association with root aluminum (Al) and a strong negative association with root boron (B) and magnesium (Mg). Furthermore, root concentrations of these elements were highly heritable (57%–78%) and not simply a reflection of background variation in soil elemental concentrations. We estimate that surface SOC stocks under these 24 genotypes have diverged at rates of up to 1.2–4.3 t C/ha/year. These results suggest that long‐term genetic diversity trials have value for elucidating biological controls on soil organic matter dynamics, and that traits associated with root elemental content may be a useful target for enhancing biosequestration.
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (9) , e70450
Open AccessWhich Plant Traits Increase Soil Carbon Sequestration? Empirical Evidence From a Long‐Term Poplar Genetic Diversity Trial
Plants play a key role in mediating soil response to global change, and breeding or engineering crops to increase soil organic carbon (SOC) storage is a potential route to land‐based carbon dioxide removal in agricultural systems. However, due to limited observational datasets plus shifting paradigms of SOC stabilization, it is unclear which plant traits are most important for enhancing different types of soil organic matter. Existing long‐term common gardens of genetically diverse plant populations may provide an opportunity to evaluate biological controls on SOC, separate from environmental or management variability. Here we report on soil and root chemical data collected for 24 genotypes within a 13‐year‐old common garden in northwestern Oregon planted with a large natural variant population of Populus trichocarpa . Fractionating surface soil (0–15 cm) revealed substantial variation in stocks of mineral‐associated organic matter (MAOM; 18–67 t C/ha) and particulate organic matter (POM; 2–22 t C/ha). Tree genotype explained 24% and 26% of the MAOM and POM stock variability, respectively, after controlling for background variability. We found minimal association between SOC concentration and either aboveground tree productivity or root biomass recalcitrance (C/N ratios and lignin content). In contrast, root elemental content appeared influential for MAOM‐C concentration, which showed a strong positive association with root aluminum (Al) and a strong negative association with root boron (B) and magnesium (Mg). Furthermore, root concentrations of these elements were highly heritable (57%–78%) and not simply a reflection of background variation in soil elemental concentrations. We estimate that surface SOC stocks under these 24 genotypes have diverged at rates of up to 1.2–4.3 t C/ha/year. These results suggest that long‐term genetic diversity trials have value for elucidating biological controls on soil organic matter dynamics, and that traits associated with root elemental content may be a useful target for enhancing biosequestration.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 9 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (5) , e70197
Soil Carbon Saturation: What Do We Really Know?
Managing soils to increase organic carbon storage presents a potential opportunity to mitigate and adapt to global change challenges, while providing numerous co‐benefits and ecosystem services. However, soils differ widely in their potential for carbon sequestration, and knowledge of biophysical limits to carbon accumulation may aid in informing priority regions. Consequently, there is great interest in assessing whether soils exhibit a maximum capacity for storing organic carbon, particularly within organo–mineral associations given the finite nature of reactive minerals in a soil. While the concept of soil carbon saturation has existed for over 25 years, recent studies have argued for and against its importance. Here, we summarize the conceptual understanding of soil carbon saturation at both micro‐ and macro‐scales, define key terminology, and address common concerns and misconceptions. We review methods used to quantify soil carbon saturation, highlighting the theory and potential caveats of each approach. Critically, we explore the utility of the principles of soil carbon saturation for informing carbon accumulation, vulnerability to loss, and representations in process‐based models. We highlight key knowledge gaps and propose next steps for furthering our mechanistic understanding of soil carbon saturation and its implications for soil management.
- 9 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (5) , e70197
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessSoil Carbon Saturation: What Do We Really Know?
Managing soils to increase organic carbon storage presents a potential opportunity to mitigate and adapt to global change challenges, while providing numerous co‐benefits and ecosystem services. However, soils differ widely in their potential for carbon sequestration, and knowledge of biophysical limits to carbon accumulation may aid in informing priority regions. Consequently, there is great interest in assessing whether soils exhibit a maximum capacity for storing organic carbon, particularly within organo–mineral associations given the finite nature of reactive minerals in a soil. While the concept of soil carbon saturation has existed for over 25 years, recent studies have argued for and against its importance. Here, we summarize the conceptual understanding of soil carbon saturation at both micro‐ and macro‐scales, define key terminology, and address common concerns and misconceptions. We review methods used to quantify soil carbon saturation, highlighting the theory and potential caveats of each approach. Critically, we explore the utility of the principles of soil carbon saturation for informing carbon accumulation, vulnerability to loss, and representations in process‐based models. We highlight key knowledge gaps and propose next steps for furthering our mechanistic understanding of soil carbon saturation and its implications for soil management.
- 29 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in New Phytologist
- Vol. 246 (6) , 2495-2505
Tree root nutrient uptake kinetics vary with nutrient availability, environmental conditions, and root traits: a global analysis
Summary: Root nutrient uptake by trees is a critical process that couples carbon and nutrient cycling in forest ecosystems. Yet, root nutrient uptake traits are poorly constrained, and the dynamics of this process are often not represented in models reflecting sparse measurements and understanding of root nutrient uptake physiology that lags those of aboveground physiology in forest ecosystems. Here, we present a global dataset of published nutrient uptake capacity and affinity values for tree species, with the goal of describing global patterns and evaluating responses to environmental drivers and associations with root traits. The dataset contains observations for ammonium, nitrate, and phosphate uptake spanning 77 tree species. Nutrient uptake capacity and affinity varied by more than an order of magnitude for each nutrient. Notably, tropical forests are underrepresented in these observations. Nutrient uptake capacity was generally diminished under nutrient enrichment but enhanced with soil warming and root–mycorrhizal colonization. The magnitude and direction of these effects can depend on the duration of exposure to a given treatment. Species with thinner roots had a tendency toward greater uptake capacity and affinity. Overall, root nutrient uptake traits are highly variable across tree species, yet they depend on environmental drivers and life‐history strategies.
- 29 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in New Phytologist
- Vol. 246 (6) , 2495-2505
Tree root nutrient uptake kinetics vary with nutrient availability, environmental conditions, and root traits: a global analysis
Summary: Root nutrient uptake by trees is a critical process that couples carbon and nutrient cycling in forest ecosystems. Yet, root nutrient uptake traits are poorly constrained, and the dynamics of this process are often not represented in models reflecting sparse measurements and understanding of root nutrient uptake physiology that lags those of aboveground physiology in forest ecosystems. Here, we present a global dataset of published nutrient uptake capacity and affinity values for tree species, with the goal of describing global patterns and evaluating responses to environmental drivers and associations with root traits. The dataset contains observations for ammonium, nitrate, and phosphate uptake spanning 77 tree species. Nutrient uptake capacity and affinity varied by more than an order of magnitude for each nutrient. Notably, tropical forests are underrepresented in these observations. Nutrient uptake capacity was generally diminished under nutrient enrichment but enhanced with soil warming and root–mycorrhizal colonization. The magnitude and direction of these effects can depend on the duration of exposure to a given treatment. Species with thinner roots had a tendency toward greater uptake capacity and affinity. Overall, root nutrient uptake traits are highly variable across tree species, yet they depend on environmental drivers and life‐history strategies.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Biogeochemistry
- Vol. 168 (2) , 1-15
The Freundlich isotherm equation best represents phosphate sorption across soil orders and land use types in tropical soils of Puerto Rico
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Biogeochemistry
- Vol. 168 (2) , 1-15
Open AccessThe Freundlich isotherm equation best represents phosphate sorption across soil orders and land use types in tropical soils of Puerto Rico
- Open Access
Which plant traits increase soil carbon sequestration? Empirical evidence from a long-term poplar genetic diversity trial
Breeding or engineering crops to increase soil organic carbon (SOC) storage is a potential route to land-based carbon dioxide removal on working agricultural lands. However, due to limited observational datasets plus shifting paradigms of SOC stabilization, there is a lack of understanding of which plant traits to target for SOC enhancement or the ultimate sequestration potential of such measures. Existing long-term common gardens of genetically diverse plant populations may provide an opportunity to evaluate biological controls on SOC outcomes, separate from environmental or management variability. Here we report on soil carbon and root chemical data collected for 24 genotypes within a 13-year-old common garden in northwestern Oregon planted with over a thousand natural variants of Populus trichocarpa. Fractionating surface soil (0-15 cm) revealed substantial variation in stocks of mineral-associated organic matter (MAOM; 18-67 tonnes C/ha) and particulate organic matter (POM; 2-22 tonnes C/ha). Tree genotype explained 24 and 26% of the MAOM and POM stock variability, respectively, after controlling for background variability. We found minimal association between SOC concentration and either aboveground tree productivity or conventional metrics of root biomass recalcitrance (C/N ratios and lignin content). However, root elemental content appeared influential for MAOM-C, which showed a strong positive association with root aluminum (Al), and strong negative association with root boron (B) and magnesium (Mg). Furthermore, root concentrations of these elements were highly heritable (57-78%) and not simply a reflection of background variation in bulk soil elemental concentrations. We estimate that surface SOC stocks under these 24 genotypes have diverged at rates of up to 1.2-4.3 tonnes C/ha/yr. These results suggest that genetic diversity trials have value for elucidating biological controls on SOC dynamics, and that traits associated with root elemental content may be an important target for enhancing SOC.
Open AccessWhich plant traits increase soil carbon sequestration? Empirical evidence from a long-term poplar genetic diversity trial
Breeding or engineering crops to increase soil organic carbon (SOC) storage is a potential route to land-based carbon dioxide removal on working agricultural lands. However, due to limited observational datasets plus shifting paradigms of SOC stabilization, there is a lack of understanding of which plant traits to target for SOC enhancement or the ultimate sequestration potential of such measures. Existing long-term common gardens of genetically diverse plant populations may provide an opportunity to evaluate biological controls on SOC outcomes, separate from environmental or management variability. Here we report on soil carbon and root chemical data collected for 24 genotypes within a 13-year-old common garden in northwestern Oregon planted with over a thousand natural variants of Populus trichocarpa. Fractionating surface soil (0-15 cm) revealed substantial variation in stocks of mineral-associated organic matter (MAOM; 18-67 tonnes C/ha) and particulate organic matter (POM; 2-22 tonnes C/ha). Tree genotype explained 24 and 26% of the MAOM and POM stock variability, respectively, after controlling for background variability. We found minimal association between SOC concentration and either aboveground tree productivity or conventional metrics of root biomass recalcitrance (C/N ratios and lignin content). However, root elemental content appeared influential for MAOM-C, which showed a strong positive association with root aluminum (Al), and strong negative association with root boron (B) and magnesium (Mg). Furthermore, root concentrations of these elements were highly heritable (57-78%) and not simply a reflection of background variation in bulk soil elemental concentrations. We estimate that surface SOC stocks under these 24 genotypes have diverged at rates of up to 1.2-4.3 tonnes C/ha/yr. These results suggest that genetic diversity trials have value for elucidating biological controls on SOC dynamics, and that traits associated with root elemental content may be an important target for enhancing SOC.
- Open Access
- 8 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 7 (4) , 1027-1042
Anthromes and forest carbon responses to global change
Societal Impact Statement: Forest ecosystems absorb and store about 25% of global carbon dioxide emissions annually and are increasingly shaped by human land use and management. Climate change interacts with land use and forest dynamics to influence observed carbon stocks and the strength of the land carbon sink. We show that climate change effects on modeled forest land carbon stocks are strongest in tropical wildlands that have limited human influence. Global forest carbon stocks and carbon sink strength may decline as climate change and anthropogenic influences intensify, with wildland tropical forests, especially in Amazonia, likely being especially vulnerable.Summary: Human effects on ecosystems date back thousands of years, and anthropogenic biomes—anthromes—broadly incorporate the effects of human population density and land use on ecosystems. Forests are integral to the global carbon cycle, containing large biomass carbon stocks, yet their responses to land use and climate change are uncertain but critical to informing climate change mitigation strategies, ecosystem management, and Earth system modeling. Using an anthromes perspective and the site locations from the Global Forest Carbon (ForC) Database, we compare intensively used, cultured, and wildland forest lands in tropical and extratropical regions. We summarize recent past (1900‐present) patterns of land use intensification, and we use a feedback analysis of Earth system models from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 to estimate the sensitivity of forest carbon stocks to CO2 and temperature change for different anthromes among regions. Modeled global forest carbon stock responses are positive for CO2 increase but neutral to negative for temperature increase. Across anthromes (intensively used, cultured, and wildland forest areas), modeled forest carbon stock responses of temperate and boreal forests are less variable than those of tropical forests. Tropical wildland forest areas appear especially sensitive to CO2 and temperature change, with the negative temperature response highlighting the potential vulnerability of the globally significant carbon stock in tropical forests. The net effect of anthropogenic activities—including land‐use intensification and environmental change and their interactions with natural forest dynamics—will shape future forest carbon stock changes. These interactive effects will likely be strongest in tropical wildlands.
- 8 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Plants, People, Planet
- Vol. 7 (4) , 1027-1042
Open AccessAnthromes and forest carbon responses to global change
Societal Impact Statement: Forest ecosystems absorb and store about 25% of global carbon dioxide emissions annually and are increasingly shaped by human land use and management. Climate change interacts with land use and forest dynamics to influence observed carbon stocks and the strength of the land carbon sink. We show that climate change effects on modeled forest land carbon stocks are strongest in tropical wildlands that have limited human influence. Global forest carbon stocks and carbon sink strength may decline as climate change and anthropogenic influences intensify, with wildland tropical forests, especially in Amazonia, likely being especially vulnerable.Summary: Human effects on ecosystems date back thousands of years, and anthropogenic biomes—anthromes—broadly incorporate the effects of human population density and land use on ecosystems. Forests are integral to the global carbon cycle, containing large biomass carbon stocks, yet their responses to land use and climate change are uncertain but critical to informing climate change mitigation strategies, ecosystem management, and Earth system modeling. Using an anthromes perspective and the site locations from the Global Forest Carbon (ForC) Database, we compare intensively used, cultured, and wildland forest lands in tropical and extratropical regions. We summarize recent past (1900‐present) patterns of land use intensification, and we use a feedback analysis of Earth system models from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 to estimate the sensitivity of forest carbon stocks to CO2 and temperature change for different anthromes among regions. Modeled global forest carbon stock responses are positive for CO2 increase but neutral to negative for temperature increase. Across anthromes (intensively used, cultured, and wildland forest areas), modeled forest carbon stock responses of temperate and boreal forests are less variable than those of tropical forests. Tropical wildland forest areas appear especially sensitive to CO2 and temperature change, with the negative temperature response highlighting the potential vulnerability of the globally significant carbon stock in tropical forests. The net effect of anthropogenic activities—including land‐use intensification and environmental change and their interactions with natural forest dynamics—will shape future forest carbon stock changes. These interactive effects will likely be strongest in tropical wildlands.
- 17 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in New Phytologist
- Vol. 241 (5) , 1922-1926
Tropical forests and global change: biogeochemical responses and opportunities for cross‐site comparisons, an organized INSPIRE session at the 108th Annual Meeting, Ecological Society of America, Portland, Oregon, USA, August 2023
- 17 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in New Phytologist
- Vol. 241 (5) , 1922-1926
Tropical forests and global change: biogeochemical responses and opportunities for cross‐site comparisons, an organized INSPIRE session at the 108th Annual Meeting, Ecological Society of America, Portland, Oregon, USA, August 2023
- Open Access
Intraspecies variability in plant and soil chemical properties in a common garden plantation of the energy crop Populus
Optimizing crops for synergistic soil carbon (C) sequestration represents a frontier approach toward CO 2 removal in food and bioenergy production systems. While the central roles of plants in biological C capture and storage belowground in soils is well known, we lack an understanding of how intraspecies variation in bioenergy plants affects soil biogeochemistry. This knowledge gap is exacerbated by spatial heterogeneity in soil and plant systems, and by the difficulty of characterizing belowground plant traits. Here, we sought to obtain first insights on the spatial variation of C and nutrients in soil and plant tissues from a common garden field site of diverse, natural variant, Populus trichocarpa genotypes—grown and characterized previously for aboveground biomass-to-biofuels research. Such field sites represent a potential resource for evaluating genotype-specific effects on soil C, but this usage may be complicated due to dense plantings of intermixed genotypes. Thus, we sampled soils at the scale of individual trees to determine whether it is feasible to detect soil property variation with different plant genotypes in this system. We additionally sampled stem and root tissues to evaluate the potential for inferring important belowground traits based on aboveground-belowground correlations. We found that substantial variation in soil properties could be explained at the scale of individual trees, suggesting that genetically diverse plantations can be used to assess plant-soil correlations. Though we did not observe genotype-specific patterns in soil C, other properties such as soil acid-base chemistry (soil pH and base cations) and bulk density showed genotype-specific correlations. Stem and root nutrient levels were generally not correlated, suggesting that belowground traits should be measured directly. In conclusion, our pilot study suggests that long-term common gardens of genome-wide association study populations represent useful resources for understanding plant genotypic relationships with soil properties in Populus field study test plots. These resources could be used to develop verified plant species, geographic region-specific standardized sampling methods, and baseline data. Such context-specific, empirically verified data and models will be necessary for informing applied research strategies in selecting high aboveground productivity genotypes for enhanced soil C storage in managed, commercial scale, woody bioenergy crop plantation systems.
Open AccessIntraspecies variability in plant and soil chemical properties in a common garden plantation of the energy crop Populus
Optimizing crops for synergistic soil carbon (C) sequestration represents a frontier approach toward CO 2 removal in food and bioenergy production systems. While the central roles of plants in biological C capture and storage belowground in soils is well known, we lack an understanding of how intraspecies variation in bioenergy plants affects soil biogeochemistry. This knowledge gap is exacerbated by spatial heterogeneity in soil and plant systems, and by the difficulty of characterizing belowground plant traits. Here, we sought to obtain first insights on the spatial variation of C and nutrients in soil and plant tissues from a common garden field site of diverse, natural variant, Populus trichocarpa genotypes—grown and characterized previously for aboveground biomass-to-biofuels research. Such field sites represent a potential resource for evaluating genotype-specific effects on soil C, but this usage may be complicated due to dense plantings of intermixed genotypes. Thus, we sampled soils at the scale of individual trees to determine whether it is feasible to detect soil property variation with different plant genotypes in this system. We additionally sampled stem and root tissues to evaluate the potential for inferring important belowground traits based on aboveground-belowground correlations. We found that substantial variation in soil properties could be explained at the scale of individual trees, suggesting that genetically diverse plantations can be used to assess plant-soil correlations. Though we did not observe genotype-specific patterns in soil C, other properties such as soil acid-base chemistry (soil pH and base cations) and bulk density showed genotype-specific correlations. Stem and root nutrient levels were generally not correlated, suggesting that belowground traits should be measured directly. In conclusion, our pilot study suggests that long-term common gardens of genome-wide association study populations represent useful resources for understanding plant genotypic relationships with soil properties in Populus field study test plots. These resources could be used to develop verified plant species, geographic region-specific standardized sampling methods, and baseline data. Such context-specific, empirically verified data and models will be necessary for informing applied research strategies in selecting high aboveground productivity genotypes for enhanced soil C storage in managed, commercial scale, woody bioenergy crop plantation systems.