Wouter Halfwerk
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Wouter Halfwerk has a total of 168 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Hans Slabbekoorn
Institute of Biology Leiden (IBL), Leiden University
12 shared publications- Jacintha Ellers
Amsterdam Institute for Life and Environment, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, 1081 HV Amsterdam, The Netherlands
10 shared publications - Ralph Simon
Nuremberg Zoo, Nuremberg, Germany
9 shared publications - Judith Aukje Hendrika Smit
Amsterdam Institute for Life and Environment , Ecology and Evolution, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam
7 shared publications Michael J. Ryan
Department of Integrative Biology, University of Texas, Austin, USA
7 shared publications- Matias I. Munoz
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 6 November 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
Heritable differences in sexual signaling and morphology between urban and forest túngara frogs
Urbanization drastically changes our planet, and persistence in urban areas requires species to adapt. Sexual signaling has been argued to be a driver of population divergence between urban and non-urban populations, but it is often unclear whether population divergence is adaptive and caused by plastic and/or genetic processes. Calling behavior of urban and forest túngara frogs (Engystomops pustulosus) provides a well-known example of urban adaptation. However, we lack insight into the underlying genetic divergence between populations and heritability of calling behavior. Our aim was to examine the relative contributions of plastic and genetic components to urban-forest differences in sexual signaling and associated morphological traits. We reared frogs of urban and forest descent in a common garden using a paternal half-sib breeding design and used quantitative genetic approaches informed by whole-genome sequencing to estimate heritability. We show heritable urban-forest differences in call rate and amplitude (depending on the social environment), and in body size and condition. Moreover, behavioral as well as morphological traits had low to moderate heritability estimates. Our study provides insights into the underlying mechanisms of urban versus forest phenotypic divergence and suggests that sexual signaling and associated morphological traits in túngara frogs have the potential to adaptively evolve.
- 6 November 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
Heritable differences in sexual signaling and morphology between urban and forest túngara frogs
Urbanization drastically changes our planet, and persistence in urban areas requires species to adapt. Sexual signaling has been argued to be a driver of population divergence between urban and non-urban populations, but it is often unclear whether population divergence is adaptive and caused by plastic and/or genetic processes. Calling behavior of urban and forest túngara frogs (Engystomops pustulosus) provides a well-known example of urban adaptation. However, we lack insight into the underlying genetic divergence between populations and heritability of calling behavior. Our aim was to examine the relative contributions of plastic and genetic components to urban-forest differences in sexual signaling and associated morphological traits. We reared frogs of urban and forest descent in a common garden using a paternal half-sib breeding design and used quantitative genetic approaches informed by whole-genome sequencing to estimate heritability. We show heritable urban-forest differences in call rate and amplitude (depending on the social environment), and in body size and condition. Moreover, behavioral as well as morphological traits had low to moderate heritability estimates. Our study provides insights into the underlying mechanisms of urban versus forest phenotypic divergence and suggests that sexual signaling and associated morphological traits in túngara frogs have the potential to adaptively evolve.
- Open Access
- 7 October 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 13 (10)
Soil moisture enhances the vibrations induced by moving earthworms, especially of detritivores
Earthworms (Lumbricidae) are moisture-loving soil-dwellers that can be categorized into two feeding guilds with distinct behaviours: detritivores and geophages. Detritivores feed on litter fragments and geophages on smaller litter particles mixed with soil. When earthworms move within and across soil layers to forage, soil characteristics might influence the scale of these movements and their detectability to predators. To investigate the extent to which the detection of earthworm movements and the vibrations they thereby generate is affected by soil moisture, we used an innovative method to detect and quantify vibrations of moving earthworms emitted through the soil. We designed a mesocosm experiment in which we recorded, with a geophone, the movement-induced vibrations of detritivores and geophages in drier and wetter soils. Earthworm vibrations were detected best at 200 Hz and were detected significantly more in wetter than in drier soils. Moreover, in wetter soils, vibrations induced by detritivores were detected more frequently and at higher intensities than those of geophages. These findings suggest differences in activity levels between detritivores and geophages, as a function of soil moisture content. The observed activity patterns are likely to have food web consequences because earthworm consumers relying on mechanoreceptors to detect prey might detect detritivores more often, specifically in wetter soils.
- 7 October 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 13 (10)
Open AccessSoil moisture enhances the vibrations induced by moving earthworms, especially of detritivores
Earthworms (Lumbricidae) are moisture-loving soil-dwellers that can be categorized into two feeding guilds with distinct behaviours: detritivores and geophages. Detritivores feed on litter fragments and geophages on smaller litter particles mixed with soil. When earthworms move within and across soil layers to forage, soil characteristics might influence the scale of these movements and their detectability to predators. To investigate the extent to which the detection of earthworm movements and the vibrations they thereby generate is affected by soil moisture, we used an innovative method to detect and quantify vibrations of moving earthworms emitted through the soil. We designed a mesocosm experiment in which we recorded, with a geophone, the movement-induced vibrations of detritivores and geophages in drier and wetter soils. Earthworm vibrations were detected best at 200 Hz and were detected significantly more in wetter than in drier soils. Moreover, in wetter soils, vibrations induced by detritivores were detected more frequently and at higher intensities than those of geophages. These findings suggest differences in activity levels between detritivores and geophages, as a function of soil moisture content. The observed activity patterns are likely to have food web consequences because earthworm consumers relying on mechanoreceptors to detect prey might detect detritivores more often, specifically in wetter soils.
- 11 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Acoustics
- Vol. 252
High-resolution air-coupled ultrasound imaging of small objects using filtered back-projection based on cross-correlation
- 11 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Acoustics
- Vol. 252
High-resolution air-coupled ultrasound imaging of small objects using filtered back-projection based on cross-correlation
- Open Access
- 11 October 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 80 (1) , 40-55
Tetrapod vocal evolution reveals faster rates and higher-pitched sounds for mammals
Using the voice to produce sound is a widespread form of communication and plays an important role across diverse species and contexts. Variation in the rate and mode of sound production has been extensively studied within orders or classes, but understanding vocal signal evolution ultimately requires comparison across all major lineages involved. Here, we used phylogenetic comparative methods to investigate the evolution of dominant frequency and its association with body mass across a set of 873 species of mammals, birds, and frogs. Our results show that all vocal systems share the same general feature of the negative allometric relationship between body mass and dominant frequency, but that mammals clearly deviate compared to frogs and birds. We found mammals to vocalize at much higher frequencies and their signals evolved four- to sixfold faster compared to other tetrapod clades. Although all three groups strongly rely on vocal communication, our findings show that only mammals have extensively explored the spectral acoustic space. We argue that such high vocal diversity of mammals is made possible by their unique hearing system, and discuss the functional drivers that allowed their shared ancestors to evolve a richer array of frequencies than other tetrapods.
- 11 October 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 80 (1) , 40-55
Open AccessTetrapod vocal evolution reveals faster rates and higher-pitched sounds for mammals
Using the voice to produce sound is a widespread form of communication and plays an important role across diverse species and contexts. Variation in the rate and mode of sound production has been extensively studied within orders or classes, but understanding vocal signal evolution ultimately requires comparison across all major lineages involved. Here, we used phylogenetic comparative methods to investigate the evolution of dominant frequency and its association with body mass across a set of 873 species of mammals, birds, and frogs. Our results show that all vocal systems share the same general feature of the negative allometric relationship between body mass and dominant frequency, but that mammals clearly deviate compared to frogs and birds. We found mammals to vocalize at much higher frequencies and their signals evolved four- to sixfold faster compared to other tetrapod clades. Although all three groups strongly rely on vocal communication, our findings show that only mammals have extensively explored the spectral acoustic space. We argue that such high vocal diversity of mammals is made possible by their unique hearing system, and discuss the functional drivers that allowed their shared ancestors to evolve a richer array of frequencies than other tetrapods.
- Open Access
Optimal tuning not required: birds communicate effectively with mismatched auditory filters
Birds have one of the most remarkable vocal capacities of vertebrates. Yet we know little about the relationship between their hearing and their vocal capacities at large phylogenetic scales, and whether these traits coevolve in a tight or loose fashion. Here we collected vocal and auditory data for 72 bird species from 15 different orders, and tested if hearing is finely tuned to the spectral composition of their vocalizations (i.e., the matched-filter hypothesis). We found bird audition not to be predictive of vocal frequency, and mismatches between hearing and vocalizations to be widespread. We show that the source of these mismatches is allometric: the auditory tuning and the spectral composition of vocalizations scale with body weight to different degrees. Despite the general frequency mismatches, bird hearing remains remarkably sensitive to the main spectral component of their vocalizations. Our results challenge the view that sensory systems must be finely tuned only to conspecific signals for communication to be effective. Our results suggest that selection for a broad auditory tuning has allowed birds to effectively communicate with conspecifics while at the same time permitting general environmental awareness using auditory cues. We argue that the relationship between hearing and vocalizations in birds is better described by the concept of diffuse coevolution, where organism evolve in relation to their broader ecological context instead than on a strictly dyadic fashion. Significance Statement: Animal communication theory often states that signalers and perceivers coevolve, yet the spread and nature of this relationship remains unclear. We tested whether the auditory tuning of birds is tightly matched to the frequency content of their vocalizations -an expected outcome of strong coevolution and the matched-filter hypothesis. We show that although birds hearing does not precisely align with their vocalizations, birds are still highly sensitive to the sounds they produce. This is due to the broad tuning of the avian auditory systems, which supports effective conspecific communication while also allowing the detection of other ecologically relevant sounds. Thus, birds exemplify diffuse rather than tightly coupled coevolution in communication systems.
Open AccessOptimal tuning not required: birds communicate effectively with mismatched auditory filters
Birds have one of the most remarkable vocal capacities of vertebrates. Yet we know little about the relationship between their hearing and their vocal capacities at large phylogenetic scales, and whether these traits coevolve in a tight or loose fashion. Here we collected vocal and auditory data for 72 bird species from 15 different orders, and tested if hearing is finely tuned to the spectral composition of their vocalizations (i.e., the matched-filter hypothesis). We found bird audition not to be predictive of vocal frequency, and mismatches between hearing and vocalizations to be widespread. We show that the source of these mismatches is allometric: the auditory tuning and the spectral composition of vocalizations scale with body weight to different degrees. Despite the general frequency mismatches, bird hearing remains remarkably sensitive to the main spectral component of their vocalizations. Our results challenge the view that sensory systems must be finely tuned only to conspecific signals for communication to be effective. Our results suggest that selection for a broad auditory tuning has allowed birds to effectively communicate with conspecifics while at the same time permitting general environmental awareness using auditory cues. We argue that the relationship between hearing and vocalizations in birds is better described by the concept of diffuse coevolution, where organism evolve in relation to their broader ecological context instead than on a strictly dyadic fashion. Significance Statement: Animal communication theory often states that signalers and perceivers coevolve, yet the spread and nature of this relationship remains unclear. We tested whether the auditory tuning of birds is tightly matched to the frequency content of their vocalizations -an expected outcome of strong coevolution and the matched-filter hypothesis. We show that although birds hearing does not precisely align with their vocalizations, birds are still highly sensitive to the sounds they produce. This is due to the broad tuning of the avian auditory systems, which supports effective conspecific communication while also allowing the detection of other ecologically relevant sounds. Thus, birds exemplify diffuse rather than tightly coupled coevolution in communication systems.
- Open Access
Effects of Anthropogenic Vibratory Noise on Plant Development and Herbivory
Anthropogenic infrastructure, such as inland wind turbines commonly found in agricultural fields, has substantially increased subterranean vibratory noise in the past decades. Plants, being rooted in soil, are continuously exposed to these vibrations, yet we have little understanding of how vibrational noise affects plant development and, consequently, plant–insect interactions. Here, we examine the impact of windmill-like vibrational noise on the growth of Pisum sativum and its full-factorial interaction with the generalist herbivore Spodoptera exigua. Plants were exposed to either high or low vibrational noise from seed germination to the seed production stage. We recorded germination, flowering, fruiting time, and daily shoot length. Additionally, we measured herbivory intensity by Spodoptera exigua caterpillars placed on a subset of plants. Plants exposed to high vibrational noise grew significantly faster and taller than those in the low-noise treatment. Additionally, we found a marginally significant trend for earlier flowering in plants exposed to high noise. We did not find a significant effect of vibrational noise on herbivory. Our results suggest that underground vibrational noise can influence plant growth rates, which may potentially have ecological and agricultural implications. Faster growth may alter interspecific competition and shift trade-offs between growth and defense. Understanding these effects is important in assessing the broader ecological consequences of renewable energy infrastructure.
Open AccessEffects of Anthropogenic Vibratory Noise on Plant Development and Herbivory
Anthropogenic infrastructure, such as inland wind turbines commonly found in agricultural fields, has substantially increased subterranean vibratory noise in the past decades. Plants, being rooted in soil, are continuously exposed to these vibrations, yet we have little understanding of how vibrational noise affects plant development and, consequently, plant–insect interactions. Here, we examine the impact of windmill-like vibrational noise on the growth of Pisum sativum and its full-factorial interaction with the generalist herbivore Spodoptera exigua. Plants were exposed to either high or low vibrational noise from seed germination to the seed production stage. We recorded germination, flowering, fruiting time, and daily shoot length. Additionally, we measured herbivory intensity by Spodoptera exigua caterpillars placed on a subset of plants. Plants exposed to high vibrational noise grew significantly faster and taller than those in the low-noise treatment. Additionally, we found a marginally significant trend for earlier flowering in plants exposed to high noise. We did not find a significant effect of vibrational noise on herbivory. Our results suggest that underground vibrational noise can influence plant growth rates, which may potentially have ecological and agricultural implications. Faster growth may alter interspecific competition and shift trade-offs between growth and defense. Understanding these effects is important in assessing the broader ecological consequences of renewable energy infrastructure.
- Open Access
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 38 (10) , 1410-1420
Noise pollution and artificial light at night alter selection pressures on sexual signals in an urban adapter
Human-induced environmental changes can have major impacts on how individuals communicate. Species using sexual signals may experience especially rapid shifts in their interactions with both intended receivers (mates) and eavesdroppers (predators). Artificial light at night and anthropogenic noise represent 2 major environmental features of human-dominated habitats which may alter selection pressures imposed on sexual signalers. In this study, we used a full factorial design to investigate individual and combined effects of experimentally added light and noise pollution on the attraction of female frogs and bat predators to speakers broadcasting male túngara frog (Engystomops pustulosus) calls. We conducted 2-choice tests in the field to examine whether predatory and mating preferences for signals differing in conspicuousness change in response to noise and light pollution. Light pollution reduced the number of approaches from predators and mates attracted to our playbacks. The addition of noise pollution enhanced this effect on predators but decreased it for female frogs. Light also lowered female frog preference for conspicuous calls, but this effect was counteracted when noise pollution was added. Reduced numbers of predators and female frogs found under lit conditions suggest light pollution can both reduce natural selection and increase sexual selection pressures on male signals. These findings indicate that light pollution could be responsible for the reduced numbers of predatory bats and female frogs found in urban environments, providing a causal explanation for more conspicuous and attractive sexual signalling in males from urban populations.
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 38 (10) , 1410-1420
Open AccessNoise pollution and artificial light at night alter selection pressures on sexual signals in an urban adapter
Human-induced environmental changes can have major impacts on how individuals communicate. Species using sexual signals may experience especially rapid shifts in their interactions with both intended receivers (mates) and eavesdroppers (predators). Artificial light at night and anthropogenic noise represent 2 major environmental features of human-dominated habitats which may alter selection pressures imposed on sexual signalers. In this study, we used a full factorial design to investigate individual and combined effects of experimentally added light and noise pollution on the attraction of female frogs and bat predators to speakers broadcasting male túngara frog (Engystomops pustulosus) calls. We conducted 2-choice tests in the field to examine whether predatory and mating preferences for signals differing in conspicuousness change in response to noise and light pollution. Light pollution reduced the number of approaches from predators and mates attracted to our playbacks. The addition of noise pollution enhanced this effect on predators but decreased it for female frogs. Light also lowered female frog preference for conspicuous calls, but this effect was counteracted when noise pollution was added. Reduced numbers of predators and female frogs found under lit conditions suggest light pollution can both reduce natural selection and increase sexual selection pressures on male signals. These findings indicate that light pollution could be responsible for the reduced numbers of predatory bats and female frogs found in urban environments, providing a causal explanation for more conspicuous and attractive sexual signalling in males from urban populations.
- Open Access
- 29 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 94 (9) , 1707-1719
Urban developmental environments alter tadpole phenotypes depending on origin
Urbanisation is rapidly altering environments with severe impacts on life on earth. While impacts from urbanisation are widespread, organisms with metamorphic life cycles are particularly likely to be affected, as they often undergo a major shift in lifestyle and habitat across life stages. Early life stages also likely undergo exceptionally high selection due to elevated mortality rates. Despite the potential importance of these early stages, we often lack insight into how urban conditions influence individuals early in their development. This study examined how exposure to urban environmental conditions alters developmental phenotypes in interaction with origin. We studied túngara frog tadpoles (Engystomops pustulosus) from urban and forest populations and conducted a reciprocal transplant between forest and urban treatments. Wild collected breeding pairs from urban and forest populations created clutches produced in the lab. Clutches were then split in two and exposed for 2 weeks to urban or forest developmental conditions. Tadpole developmental timing, morphology and vigilance behaviour were subsequently measured to assess the effects of origin and treatment, as well as their interaction. Urban developmental environments differ in water quality, are warmer, and have fewer predators compared to forest environments. Our findings demonstrate that tadpoles originating from urban populations have a faster developmental rate regardless of the environmental treatment. Tadpoles exposed to the urban environment have constrained growth compared to tadpoles exposed to the forest environment, independent of origin. Additionally, we find that urban origin tadpoles demonstrate increased behavioural plasticity in response to disturbance compared to forest origin tadpoles. Our results show effects of urban conditions on developmental phenotypes both within and across generations, most likely as an adaptive response to higher aquatic temperature regimes in urban areas. Divergence in juvenile growth and development may underlie divergence in adult phenotypes typical of adult túngara frogs found in urban and forest areas. These findings demonstrate the need to integrate early developmental stages to fully understand the evolutionary and ecological implications of urbanisation.
- 29 June 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 94 (9) , 1707-1719
Open AccessUrban developmental environments alter tadpole phenotypes depending on origin
Urbanisation is rapidly altering environments with severe impacts on life on earth. While impacts from urbanisation are widespread, organisms with metamorphic life cycles are particularly likely to be affected, as they often undergo a major shift in lifestyle and habitat across life stages. Early life stages also likely undergo exceptionally high selection due to elevated mortality rates. Despite the potential importance of these early stages, we often lack insight into how urban conditions influence individuals early in their development. This study examined how exposure to urban environmental conditions alters developmental phenotypes in interaction with origin. We studied túngara frog tadpoles (Engystomops pustulosus) from urban and forest populations and conducted a reciprocal transplant between forest and urban treatments. Wild collected breeding pairs from urban and forest populations created clutches produced in the lab. Clutches were then split in two and exposed for 2 weeks to urban or forest developmental conditions. Tadpole developmental timing, morphology and vigilance behaviour were subsequently measured to assess the effects of origin and treatment, as well as their interaction. Urban developmental environments differ in water quality, are warmer, and have fewer predators compared to forest environments. Our findings demonstrate that tadpoles originating from urban populations have a faster developmental rate regardless of the environmental treatment. Tadpoles exposed to the urban environment have constrained growth compared to tadpoles exposed to the forest environment, independent of origin. Additionally, we find that urban origin tadpoles demonstrate increased behavioural plasticity in response to disturbance compared to forest origin tadpoles. Our results show effects of urban conditions on developmental phenotypes both within and across generations, most likely as an adaptive response to higher aquatic temperature regimes in urban areas. Divergence in juvenile growth and development may underlie divergence in adult phenotypes typical of adult túngara frogs found in urban and forest areas. These findings demonstrate the need to integrate early developmental stages to fully understand the evolutionary and ecological implications of urbanisation.
- Open Access
- 26 October 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Behavioral Ecology
- Vol. 35 (6) , arae088
Urban sensory conditions alter rival interactions and mate choice in urban and forest túngara frogs
Sexual communication often takes place in networks with multiple competing signalers being simultaneously assessed by mate choosers. Altered sensory conditions, such as noise and light pollution, can affect communication by altering signal production and perception. While evidence of sensory pollution affecting sexual signaling is widespread, few studies assess impacts on sexual signaling during rival interactions as well as mate choice, let alone whether urban and non-urban populations have diverged in their response. Here, we investigate the effects of urban sensory conditions on sexual communication in urban and forest túngara frogs (Engystomops pustulosus). We recorded dyadic vocal rival interactions and assessed mate choice with and without noise and light pollution in the lab. We show that urban sensory conditions can directly impact the intensity of rival interactions, differences between rivals and mate choice, though changes were often in opposite directions for frogs of urban and forest origins. Moreover, we demonstrate that urban-induced changes in rival interactions can also indirectly affect how females choose between potential mates. Our study reveals origin-dependent direct and indirect effects of noise and light pollution, and suggests local adaptation of sexual communication in urban populations.
- 26 October 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Behavioral Ecology
- Vol. 35 (6) , arae088
Open AccessUrban sensory conditions alter rival interactions and mate choice in urban and forest túngara frogs
Sexual communication often takes place in networks with multiple competing signalers being simultaneously assessed by mate choosers. Altered sensory conditions, such as noise and light pollution, can affect communication by altering signal production and perception. While evidence of sensory pollution affecting sexual signaling is widespread, few studies assess impacts on sexual signaling during rival interactions as well as mate choice, let alone whether urban and non-urban populations have diverged in their response. Here, we investigate the effects of urban sensory conditions on sexual communication in urban and forest túngara frogs (Engystomops pustulosus). We recorded dyadic vocal rival interactions and assessed mate choice with and without noise and light pollution in the lab. We show that urban sensory conditions can directly impact the intensity of rival interactions, differences between rivals and mate choice, though changes were often in opposite directions for frogs of urban and forest origins. Moreover, we demonstrate that urban-induced changes in rival interactions can also indirectly affect how females choose between potential mates. Our study reveals origin-dependent direct and indirect effects of noise and light pollution, and suggests local adaptation of sexual communication in urban populations.
- Open Access
- 25 January 2024
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Entomology
- Vol. 69 (1) , 21-40
The Evolutionary Importance of Intraspecific Variation in Sexual Communication Across Sensory Modalities
The evolution of sexual communication is critically important in the diversity of arthropods, which are declining at a fast pace worldwide. Their environments are rapidly changing, with increasing chemical, acoustic, and light pollution. To predict how arthropod species will respond to changing climates, habitats, and communities, we need to understand how sexual communication systems can evolve. In the past decades, intraspecific variation in sexual signals and responses across different modalities has been identified, but never in a comparative way. In this review, we identify and compare the level and extent of intraspecific variation in sexual signals and responses across three different modalities, chemical, acoustic, and visual, focusing mostly on insects. By comparing causes and possible consequences of intraspecific variation in sexual communication among these modalities, we identify shared and unique patterns, as well as knowledge needed to predict the evolution of sexual communication systems in arthropods in a changing world.
- 25 January 2024
- Published by Annual Reviews in Annual Review of Entomology
- Vol. 69 (1) , 21-40
Open AccessThe Evolutionary Importance of Intraspecific Variation in Sexual Communication Across Sensory Modalities
The evolution of sexual communication is critically important in the diversity of arthropods, which are declining at a fast pace worldwide. Their environments are rapidly changing, with increasing chemical, acoustic, and light pollution. To predict how arthropod species will respond to changing climates, habitats, and communities, we need to understand how sexual communication systems can evolve. In the past decades, intraspecific variation in sexual signals and responses across different modalities has been identified, but never in a comparative way. In this review, we identify and compare the level and extent of intraspecific variation in sexual signals and responses across three different modalities, chemical, acoustic, and visual, focusing mostly on insects. By comparing causes and possible consequences of intraspecific variation in sexual communication among these modalities, we identify shared and unique patterns, as well as knowledge needed to predict the evolution of sexual communication systems in arthropods in a changing world.