Katherine J. Evans
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Katherine J. Evans has a total of 393 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Min Xu
24 shared publicationsSalil Mahajan
24 shared publicationsWei Zhang
23 shared publications- Hamish Gordon
Department of Chemical Engineering and Center for Atmospheric Particle Studies, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
22 shared publications Hyun-Gyu Kang
22 shared publications- Pratapaditya Ghosh
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, 7000 East Avenue, Livermore, CA, USA
22 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 21 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-53
A Multi-Criteria Framework for CORDEX-CORE2 GCM Selection
We present a structured multi-criteria framework for the sub-selection of CMIP6 global climate models (GCMs) to support CORDEX-CORE2 dynamical downscaling. The framework integrates five key criteria: historical performance, model independence, regional temperature sensitivity, precipitation spread, and data availability, and is designed to identify a single, consistent subset of GCMs across all CORDEX domains to improve the comparability and interpretability of regional projections. A total of 45 GCMs are evaluated over the historical period (1981–2014), with 31 models further assessed for projected changes over 2015–2100. Application of the framework shows that model performance is systematically higher for large-scale circulation and thermodynamic fields than for precipitation seasonality and monsoon-related processes, which remain a dominant source of uncertainty across regions. Despite the diversity of climates represented across CORDEX domains, model rankings are broadly consistent, with top-performing models exhibiting stable performance across both tropical and extratropical regions, while lower-ranked models show more pervasive deficiencies rather than region-specific weaknesses. Sensitivity analyses demonstrate that rankings are largely insensitive to the choice of aggregation method but depend strongly on the breadth of evaluation metrics, with robust and reproducible rankings emerging only when a large fraction of the full metric suite is retained. Assessment of model independence reveals substantial clustering within the ensemble, indicating that many models share similar performance characteristics, while a smaller subset provides distinct and complementary information. Regional temperature sensitivity exhibits a coherent ordering across domains, suggesting that differences in projected warming are primarily governed by intrinsic model characteristics rather than region-specific effects. In contrast, precipitation spread shows strong regional variability, with both the magnitude and temporal structure of precipitation change differing widely across models. The relationship between precipitation and warming further highlights that, in some regions, precipitation responses scale with temperature, while in others they are dominated by circulation variability. By combining these criteria with data availability constraints, the framework identifies a reduced set of models that retains key aspects of performance, diversity, and projected change. This approach provides a transparent and reproducible basis for GCM selection within CORDEX-CORE2 and offers a generalizable strategy for coordinated regional climate modeling efforts.
- 21 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-53
Open AccessA Multi-Criteria Framework for CORDEX-CORE2 GCM Selection
We present a structured multi-criteria framework for the sub-selection of CMIP6 global climate models (GCMs) to support CORDEX-CORE2 dynamical downscaling. The framework integrates five key criteria: historical performance, model independence, regional temperature sensitivity, precipitation spread, and data availability, and is designed to identify a single, consistent subset of GCMs across all CORDEX domains to improve the comparability and interpretability of regional projections. A total of 45 GCMs are evaluated over the historical period (1981–2014), with 31 models further assessed for projected changes over 2015–2100. Application of the framework shows that model performance is systematically higher for large-scale circulation and thermodynamic fields than for precipitation seasonality and monsoon-related processes, which remain a dominant source of uncertainty across regions. Despite the diversity of climates represented across CORDEX domains, model rankings are broadly consistent, with top-performing models exhibiting stable performance across both tropical and extratropical regions, while lower-ranked models show more pervasive deficiencies rather than region-specific weaknesses. Sensitivity analyses demonstrate that rankings are largely insensitive to the choice of aggregation method but depend strongly on the breadth of evaluation metrics, with robust and reproducible rankings emerging only when a large fraction of the full metric suite is retained. Assessment of model independence reveals substantial clustering within the ensemble, indicating that many models share similar performance characteristics, while a smaller subset provides distinct and complementary information. Regional temperature sensitivity exhibits a coherent ordering across domains, suggesting that differences in projected warming are primarily governed by intrinsic model characteristics rather than region-specific effects. In contrast, precipitation spread shows strong regional variability, with both the magnitude and temporal structure of precipitation change differing widely across models. The relationship between precipitation and warming further highlights that, in some regions, precipitation responses scale with temperature, while in others they are dominated by circulation variability. By combining these criteria with data availability constraints, the framework identifies a reduced set of models that retains key aspects of performance, diversity, and projected change. This approach provides a transparent and reproducible basis for GCM selection within CORDEX-CORE2 and offers a generalizable strategy for coordinated regional climate modeling efforts.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Enhancing Cloud Droplet Number Concentration Representation in Global Climate Simulations
Aerosol-cloud interactions are currently the largest uncertainty in climate simulations of how Earth's radiation budget is changing. Consequently, significant effort has gone into improving the representation of these interactions in weather and climate models alike. One of the most critical controlling variables for aerosol-cloud interactions is cloud droplet number concentration (CDNC). Here we develop the representation of CDNC in the UK Met Office Unified Model (UM) global model and explore how simulated CDNC should be evaluated using satellite retrievals.In unified weather and climate prediction systems, it is desirable to represent cloud microphysics using consistent code across scales. Consequently, we implement the UM’s regional double-moment microphysics scheme into the global model, which by default uses a single-moment scheme. Although this increases computational cost, the double-moment scheme can be evaluated more precisely against pixel-level satellite retrievals in high-resolution regional simulations, and it enables a more robust treatment of cloud droplets. Therefore, we describe how we develop and assess it in the global UM.However, the evaluation of cloud droplets in a global model is difficult as comparisons must be made with satellite-derived, and typically masked, cloud top CDNC. We address this issue through the analysis of various masking strategies, along with evaluating the performance of the Cloud Feedback Model Intercomparison Project (CFMIP) Observation Simulator Package (COSP) satellite simulator as implemented in the UM. In doing so, we improve protocols for global model-satellite comparisons of CDNC.Through the implementation of double-moment cloud microphysics into the UM’s global model, we find systematic improvements in simulated cloud droplet representation. The annual root mean squared error (RMSE) decreases by 4 cm-3 globally, with a substantially larger reduction of 16 cm-3 in the tropics, as the enhanced representation of microphysical processes (e.g., accretion and autoconversion) is particularly beneficial for convective systems. Outside of the tropics, a low droplet bias exists regardless of the microphysics scheme. We find this bias is partially explained by a ~ 50% underprediction of simulated aerosol concentration when compared with in situ measurements from the NASA Atmospheric Tomography (ATom) Mission. Applying an aerosol scaling factor reduces this droplet bias by half, showing that errors in aerosol and activation are comparable.We further find that COSP improves model agreement with remotely sensed cloud optical depth (τc) and effective radius (re). However, COSP-derived CDNC has an RMSE 16 cm-3 higher than that of CDNC calculated directly from the microphysics scheme, as biases in τc and re propagate through the simulator. Overall, we expect that our improvements to the representation of CDNC in the UM’s global model can meaningfully reduce the uncertainty in simulated aerosol-cloud interactions, and by extension, improve radiative forcing estimates.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessEnhancing Cloud Droplet Number Concentration Representation in Global Climate Simulations
Aerosol-cloud interactions are currently the largest uncertainty in climate simulations of how Earth's radiation budget is changing. Consequently, significant effort has gone into improving the representation of these interactions in weather and climate models alike. One of the most critical controlling variables for aerosol-cloud interactions is cloud droplet number concentration (CDNC). Here we develop the representation of CDNC in the UK Met Office Unified Model (UM) global model and explore how simulated CDNC should be evaluated using satellite retrievals.In unified weather and climate prediction systems, it is desirable to represent cloud microphysics using consistent code across scales. Consequently, we implement the UM’s regional double-moment microphysics scheme into the global model, which by default uses a single-moment scheme. Although this increases computational cost, the double-moment scheme can be evaluated more precisely against pixel-level satellite retrievals in high-resolution regional simulations, and it enables a more robust treatment of cloud droplets. Therefore, we describe how we develop and assess it in the global UM.However, the evaluation of cloud droplets in a global model is difficult as comparisons must be made with satellite-derived, and typically masked, cloud top CDNC. We address this issue through the analysis of various masking strategies, along with evaluating the performance of the Cloud Feedback Model Intercomparison Project (CFMIP) Observation Simulator Package (COSP) satellite simulator as implemented in the UM. In doing so, we improve protocols for global model-satellite comparisons of CDNC.Through the implementation of double-moment cloud microphysics into the UM’s global model, we find systematic improvements in simulated cloud droplet representation. The annual root mean squared error (RMSE) decreases by 4 cm-3 globally, with a substantially larger reduction of 16 cm-3 in the tropics, as the enhanced representation of microphysical processes (e.g., accretion and autoconversion) is particularly beneficial for convective systems. Outside of the tropics, a low droplet bias exists regardless of the microphysics scheme. We find this bias is partially explained by a ~ 50% underprediction of simulated aerosol concentration when compared with in situ measurements from the NASA Atmospheric Tomography (ATom) Mission. Applying an aerosol scaling factor reduces this droplet bias by half, showing that errors in aerosol and activation are comparable.We further find that COSP improves model agreement with remotely sensed cloud optical depth (τc) and effective radius (re). However, COSP-derived CDNC has an RMSE 16 cm-3 higher than that of CDNC calculated directly from the microphysics scheme, as biases in τc and re propagate through the simulator. Overall, we expect that our improvements to the representation of CDNC in the UM’s global model can meaningfully reduce the uncertainty in simulated aerosol-cloud interactions, and by extension, improve radiative forcing estimates.
- Open Access
- 24 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 25 (18) , 11157-11182
Adiabatic and radiative cooling are both important causes of aerosol activation in simulated fog events in Europe
Aerosol–fog interactions affect the visibility in, and life cycle of, fog and are difficult to represent in weather and climate models. Here we explore processes that impact the simulation of fog droplet number concentrations (Nd) at sub-kilometer scale horizontal grid resolutions in the UK Met Office Unified Model. We modify the parameterization of aerosol activation to include droplet activation by radiative cooling in addition to adiabatic cooling and determine the relative importance of the two cooling mechanisms. We further test the sensitivity of simulated Nd to: (a) interception of droplets by trees and buildings, (b) overestimation of updrafts in temperature inversions (which leads to artificially high Nd values), and (c) potential mechanisms for droplet deactivation due to downward fluctuations in supersaturation. We evaluate our model against observations from the ParisFog and LANFEX field campaigns, building on evaluation described in the companion paper. Including radiative cooling in the activation mechanism improves how accurately we represent the liquid water path and the vertical structure of the fog in our LANFEX case study. However, with radiative cooling, the Nd are overestimated for most of the ParisFog cases and for the LANFEX case. The time-averaged overestimate exceeds a factor of three (the normalized mean bias factor exceeds 2.0) in 4 out of 11 ParisFog cases. Our sensitivity studies demonstrate how these overestimates can be mitigated. Assuming the overestimate affects both radiative and adiabatic cooling, we find that although radiative cooling is more often the dominant source, both cooling sources can sometimes dominate activation.
- 24 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 25 (18) , 11157-11182
Open AccessAdiabatic and radiative cooling are both important causes of aerosol activation in simulated fog events in Europe
Aerosol–fog interactions affect the visibility in, and life cycle of, fog and are difficult to represent in weather and climate models. Here we explore processes that impact the simulation of fog droplet number concentrations (Nd) at sub-kilometer scale horizontal grid resolutions in the UK Met Office Unified Model. We modify the parameterization of aerosol activation to include droplet activation by radiative cooling in addition to adiabatic cooling and determine the relative importance of the two cooling mechanisms. We further test the sensitivity of simulated Nd to: (a) interception of droplets by trees and buildings, (b) overestimation of updrafts in temperature inversions (which leads to artificially high Nd values), and (c) potential mechanisms for droplet deactivation due to downward fluctuations in supersaturation. We evaluate our model against observations from the ParisFog and LANFEX field campaigns, building on evaluation described in the companion paper. Including radiative cooling in the activation mechanism improves how accurately we represent the liquid water path and the vertical structure of the fog in our LANFEX case study. However, with radiative cooling, the Nd are overestimated for most of the ParisFog cases and for the LANFEX case. The time-averaged overestimate exceeds a factor of three (the normalized mean bias factor exceeds 2.0) in 4 out of 11 ParisFog cases. Our sensitivity studies demonstrate how these overestimates can be mitigated. Assuming the overestimate affects both radiative and adiabatic cooling, we find that although radiative cooling is more often the dominant source, both cooling sources can sometimes dominate activation.
- Open Access
- 24 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 25 (18) , 11129-11156
High sensitivity of simulated fog properties to parameterized aerosol activation in case studies from ParisFog
Aerosols influence fog properties such as visibility and lifetime by affecting fog droplet number concentrations (Nd). Numerical weather prediction (NWP) models often represent aerosol–fog interactions using highly simplified approaches. Incorporating prognostic size-resolved aerosol microphysics from climate models could allow them to simulate Nd and aerosol–fog interactions without incurring excessive computational expense. However, microphysics code designed for coarse spatial resolution may struggle with sub-kilometer-scale grid spacings. Here, we test the ability of the UK Met Office Unified Model to simulate aerosol and fog properties during case studies from the ParisFog field campaign in 2011. We examine the sensitivity of fog properties to variations in Nd caused by modifications to simulated aerosol activation. Our model, with a 500 m horizontal resolution and interactive aerosol and cloud microphysics, significantly underpredicts Nd, although it only slightly underestimates the cloud condensation nuclei concentration. With an updated version of the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (2000) activation scheme, we produce Nd that are more consistent with those predicted by a cloud parcel model under fog-like conditions. We activate droplets only by adiabatic cooling. We incorporate more realistic hygroscopicities for sulfate and organic aerosols and explore the sensitivity of simulated Nd to unresolved updrafts. We find that both Nd and simulated fog liquid water content are very sensitive to the updated activation scheme but remain less affected by the update to hygroscopicities. Our improvements offer insights into the physical processes regulating Nd in stable conditions, potentially laying foundations for improved operational fog forecasts that incorporate interactive aerosol simulations or aerosol climatologies.
- 24 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 25 (18) , 11129-11156
Open AccessHigh sensitivity of simulated fog properties to parameterized aerosol activation in case studies from ParisFog
Aerosols influence fog properties such as visibility and lifetime by affecting fog droplet number concentrations (Nd). Numerical weather prediction (NWP) models often represent aerosol–fog interactions using highly simplified approaches. Incorporating prognostic size-resolved aerosol microphysics from climate models could allow them to simulate Nd and aerosol–fog interactions without incurring excessive computational expense. However, microphysics code designed for coarse spatial resolution may struggle with sub-kilometer-scale grid spacings. Here, we test the ability of the UK Met Office Unified Model to simulate aerosol and fog properties during case studies from the ParisFog field campaign in 2011. We examine the sensitivity of fog properties to variations in Nd caused by modifications to simulated aerosol activation. Our model, with a 500 m horizontal resolution and interactive aerosol and cloud microphysics, significantly underpredicts Nd, although it only slightly underestimates the cloud condensation nuclei concentration. With an updated version of the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (2000) activation scheme, we produce Nd that are more consistent with those predicted by a cloud parcel model under fog-like conditions. We activate droplets only by adiabatic cooling. We incorporate more realistic hygroscopicities for sulfate and organic aerosols and explore the sensitivity of simulated Nd to unresolved updrafts. We find that both Nd and simulated fog liquid water content are very sensitive to the updated activation scheme but remain less affected by the update to hygroscopicities. Our improvements offer insights into the physical processes regulating Nd in stable conditions, potentially laying foundations for improved operational fog forecasts that incorporate interactive aerosol simulations or aerosol climatologies.
- Open Access
- 11 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 18 (15) , 4899-4913
Assessing modifications to the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan aerosol activation parameterization (version ARG2000) to improve simulated aerosol–cloud radiative effects in the UK Met Office Unified Model (UM version 13.0)
The representation of aerosol activation is a key source of uncertainty in global composition-climate model simulations of aerosol–cloud interactions. The Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (ARG) activation parameterization is used in several global and regional models that employ modal aerosol microphysics schemes. In this study, we investigate the ability of the ARG parameterization to reproduce simulations with a cloud parcel model and find its performance is sensitive to the geometric standard deviations (widths) of the lognormal aerosol modes. We recommend adjustments to three constant parameters in the ARG equations, which improve the performance of the parameterization for small mode widths and its ability to simulate activation in polluted conditions. For the accumulation mode width of 1.4 used in the Met Office Unified Model (UM), the modifications decrease the mean bias in the activated fraction of aerosols compared to a cloud parcel model from −6.6 % to +1.2 %. We implemented the improvements in the UM and compared simulated global cloud droplet concentrations with satellite observations. The simulated cloud radiative effect changes by −1.43 W m−2 (6 %) and aerosol indirect radiative forcing over the industrial period changes by −0.10 W m−2 (10 %).
- 11 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 18 (15) , 4899-4913
Open AccessAssessing modifications to the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan aerosol activation parameterization (version ARG2000) to improve simulated aerosol–cloud radiative effects in the UK Met Office Unified Model (UM version 13.0)
The representation of aerosol activation is a key source of uncertainty in global composition-climate model simulations of aerosol–cloud interactions. The Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (ARG) activation parameterization is used in several global and regional models that employ modal aerosol microphysics schemes. In this study, we investigate the ability of the ARG parameterization to reproduce simulations with a cloud parcel model and find its performance is sensitive to the geometric standard deviations (widths) of the lognormal aerosol modes. We recommend adjustments to three constant parameters in the ARG equations, which improve the performance of the parameterization for small mode widths and its ability to simulate activation in polluted conditions. For the accumulation mode width of 1.4 used in the Met Office Unified Model (UM), the modifications decrease the mean bias in the activated fraction of aerosols compared to a cloud parcel model from −6.6 % to +1.2 %. We implemented the improvements in the UM and compared simulated global cloud droplet concentrations with satellite observations. The simulated cloud radiative effect changes by −1.43 W m−2 (6 %) and aerosol indirect radiative forcing over the industrial period changes by −0.10 W m−2 (10 %).
- Open Access
- 16 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-43
Comment on egusphere-2024-3376
Aerosols influence fog properties such as visibility and lifetime by affecting fog droplet number concentrations (Nd). Numerical weather prediction (NWP) models often represent aerosol-fog interactions using highly simplified approaches. Incorporating prognostic size-resolved aerosol microphysics from climate models could allow them to simulate Nd and aerosol-fog interactions without incurring excessive computational expense. However, microphysics code designed for coarse spatial resolution may struggle with sub-kilometer-scale grid spacings. Here we test the ability of the UK Met Office Unified Model to simulate aerosol and fog properties during case studies from the ParisFog field campaign in 2011. We examine the sensitivity of fog properties to variations in Nd caused by modifications to simulated aerosol activation. Our model with 500 m horizontal resolution and interactive aerosol and cloud microphysics significantly underpredicts Nd, although only slightly underestimates the cloud condensation nuclei concentration. With an updated version of the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (2000) activation scheme, we produce Nd that are more consistent with those predicted by a cloud parcel model under fog-like conditions. We activate droplets only by adiabatic cooling. We incorporate more realistic hygroscopicities for sulfate and organic aerosols and explore the sensitivity of simulated Nd to unresolved updrafts. We find that both Nd and simulated fog liquid water content are very sensitive to the updated activation scheme but remain unaffected by the update to hygroscopicities. Our improvements offer insights into the physical processes regulating Nd in stable conditions, potentially laying foundations for improved operational fog forecasts that incorporate interactive aerosol simulations or aerosol climatologies.
- 16 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-43
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3376
Aerosols influence fog properties such as visibility and lifetime by affecting fog droplet number concentrations (Nd). Numerical weather prediction (NWP) models often represent aerosol-fog interactions using highly simplified approaches. Incorporating prognostic size-resolved aerosol microphysics from climate models could allow them to simulate Nd and aerosol-fog interactions without incurring excessive computational expense. However, microphysics code designed for coarse spatial resolution may struggle with sub-kilometer-scale grid spacings. Here we test the ability of the UK Met Office Unified Model to simulate aerosol and fog properties during case studies from the ParisFog field campaign in 2011. We examine the sensitivity of fog properties to variations in Nd caused by modifications to simulated aerosol activation. Our model with 500 m horizontal resolution and interactive aerosol and cloud microphysics significantly underpredicts Nd, although only slightly underestimates the cloud condensation nuclei concentration. With an updated version of the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (2000) activation scheme, we produce Nd that are more consistent with those predicted by a cloud parcel model under fog-like conditions. We activate droplets only by adiabatic cooling. We incorporate more realistic hygroscopicities for sulfate and organic aerosols and explore the sensitivity of simulated Nd to unresolved updrafts. We find that both Nd and simulated fog liquid water content are very sensitive to the updated activation scheme but remain unaffected by the update to hygroscopicities. Our improvements offer insights into the physical processes regulating Nd in stable conditions, potentially laying foundations for improved operational fog forecasts that incorporate interactive aerosol simulations or aerosol climatologies.
- Open Access
- 16 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-37
Comment on egusphere-2024-3397
Aerosol-fog interactions affect the visibility in, and life cycle of, fog and are difficult to represent in weather and climate models. Here we explore processes that impact the simulation of fog droplet number concentrations (Nd) at sub-kilometer scale horizontal grid resolutions in the UK Met Office Unified Model. We modify the parameterization of aerosol activation to include droplet activation by radiative cooling in addition to adiabatic cooling, and determine the relative importance of the two cooling mechanisms. We further test the sensitivity of simulated Nd to: (a) interception of droplets by trees and buildings, (b) overestimation of updrafts in temperature inversions, which leads to artificially high Nd values; and (c) potential mechanisms for droplet deactivation due to downward fluctuations in supersaturation. We evaluate our model against observations from the ParisFog and LANFEX field campaigns, building on evaluation described in the companion paper. Including radiative cooling in the activation mechanism improves how accurately we represent the liquid water path and the vertical structure of the fog in our LANFEX case study. However, with radiative cooling the Nd are overestimated for most of the ParisFog cases, and the LANFEX case. The time-averaged overestimate exceeds a factor of four (the normalized mean bias factor exceeds 3.0) in four out of eleven ParisFog cases. Our sensitivity studies demonstrate how these overestimates can be mitigated. Assuming the overestimate affects both radiative and adiabatic cooling, we find that although radiative cooling is more often the dominant source, both cooling sources can sometimes dominate activation.
- 16 June 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-37
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3397
Aerosol-fog interactions affect the visibility in, and life cycle of, fog and are difficult to represent in weather and climate models. Here we explore processes that impact the simulation of fog droplet number concentrations (Nd) at sub-kilometer scale horizontal grid resolutions in the UK Met Office Unified Model. We modify the parameterization of aerosol activation to include droplet activation by radiative cooling in addition to adiabatic cooling, and determine the relative importance of the two cooling mechanisms. We further test the sensitivity of simulated Nd to: (a) interception of droplets by trees and buildings, (b) overestimation of updrafts in temperature inversions, which leads to artificially high Nd values; and (c) potential mechanisms for droplet deactivation due to downward fluctuations in supersaturation. We evaluate our model against observations from the ParisFog and LANFEX field campaigns, building on evaluation described in the companion paper. Including radiative cooling in the activation mechanism improves how accurately we represent the liquid water path and the vertical structure of the fog in our LANFEX case study. However, with radiative cooling the Nd are overestimated for most of the ParisFog cases, and the LANFEX case. The time-averaged overestimate exceeds a factor of four (the normalized mean bias factor exceeds 3.0) in four out of eleven ParisFog cases. Our sensitivity studies demonstrate how these overestimates can be mitigated. Assuming the overestimate affects both radiative and adiabatic cooling, we find that although radiative cooling is more often the dominant source, both cooling sources can sometimes dominate activation.
- Open Access
- 21 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Reply on RC1
The representation of aerosol activation is a key source of uncertainty in global composition-climate model simulations of aerosol-cloud interactions. The Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (ARG) activation parameterization is used in several global and regional models that employ modal aerosol microphysics schemes. In this study, we investigate the ability of the ARG parameterization to reproduce simulations with a cloud parcel model, and find its performance is sensitive to the geometric standard deviations (widths) of the lognormal aerosol modes. We recommend adjustments to three constant parameters in the ARG equations, which improve the performance of the parameterization for small mode widths and its ability to simulate activation in polluted conditions. For the accumulation mode width of 1.4 used in the Met Office Unified Model (UM), our modifications decrease the mean bias in the activated fraction of aerosols compared to a cloud parcel model from -6.6 % to +1.2 %. We implemented our improvements in the UM and compared simulated global cloud droplet concentrations with satellite observations. The simulated cloud radiative effect changes by -1.43 Wm-2 and aerosol indirect radiative forcing over the industrial period changes by -0.10 Wm-2.
- 21 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessReply on RC1
The representation of aerosol activation is a key source of uncertainty in global composition-climate model simulations of aerosol-cloud interactions. The Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (ARG) activation parameterization is used in several global and regional models that employ modal aerosol microphysics schemes. In this study, we investigate the ability of the ARG parameterization to reproduce simulations with a cloud parcel model, and find its performance is sensitive to the geometric standard deviations (widths) of the lognormal aerosol modes. We recommend adjustments to three constant parameters in the ARG equations, which improve the performance of the parameterization for small mode widths and its ability to simulate activation in polluted conditions. For the accumulation mode width of 1.4 used in the Met Office Unified Model (UM), our modifications decrease the mean bias in the activated fraction of aerosols compared to a cloud parcel model from -6.6 % to +1.2 %. We implemented our improvements in the UM and compared simulated global cloud droplet concentrations with satellite observations. The simulated cloud radiative effect changes by -1.43 Wm-2 and aerosol indirect radiative forcing over the industrial period changes by -0.10 Wm-2.
- Open Access
- 21 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Reply on RC2
The representation of aerosol activation is a key source of uncertainty in global composition-climate model simulations of aerosol-cloud interactions. The Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (ARG) activation parameterization is used in several global and regional models that employ modal aerosol microphysics schemes. In this study, we investigate the ability of the ARG parameterization to reproduce simulations with a cloud parcel model, and find its performance is sensitive to the geometric standard deviations (widths) of the lognormal aerosol modes. We recommend adjustments to three constant parameters in the ARG equations, which improve the performance of the parameterization for small mode widths and its ability to simulate activation in polluted conditions. For the accumulation mode width of 1.4 used in the Met Office Unified Model (UM), our modifications decrease the mean bias in the activated fraction of aerosols compared to a cloud parcel model from -6.6 % to +1.2 %. We implemented our improvements in the UM and compared simulated global cloud droplet concentrations with satellite observations. The simulated cloud radiative effect changes by -1.43 Wm-2 and aerosol indirect radiative forcing over the industrial period changes by -0.10 Wm-2.
- 21 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-20
Open AccessReply on RC2
The representation of aerosol activation is a key source of uncertainty in global composition-climate model simulations of aerosol-cloud interactions. The Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (ARG) activation parameterization is used in several global and regional models that employ modal aerosol microphysics schemes. In this study, we investigate the ability of the ARG parameterization to reproduce simulations with a cloud parcel model, and find its performance is sensitive to the geometric standard deviations (widths) of the lognormal aerosol modes. We recommend adjustments to three constant parameters in the ARG equations, which improve the performance of the parameterization for small mode widths and its ability to simulate activation in polluted conditions. For the accumulation mode width of 1.4 used in the Met Office Unified Model (UM), our modifications decrease the mean bias in the activated fraction of aerosols compared to a cloud parcel model from -6.6 % to +1.2 %. We implemented our improvements in the UM and compared simulated global cloud droplet concentrations with satellite observations. The simulated cloud radiative effect changes by -1.43 Wm-2 and aerosol indirect radiative forcing over the industrial period changes by -0.10 Wm-2.
- Open Access
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-43
Comment on egusphere-2024-3376
Aerosols influence fog properties such as visibility and lifetime by affecting fog droplet number concentrations (Nd). Numerical weather prediction (NWP) models often represent aerosol-fog interactions using highly simplified approaches. Incorporating prognostic size-resolved aerosol microphysics from climate models could allow them to simulate Nd and aerosol-fog interactions without incurring excessive computational expense. However, microphysics code designed for coarse spatial resolution may struggle with sub-kilometer-scale grid spacings. Here we test the ability of the UK Met Office Unified Model to simulate aerosol and fog properties during case studies from the ParisFog field campaign in 2011. We examine the sensitivity of fog properties to variations in Nd caused by modifications to simulated aerosol activation. Our model with 500 m horizontal resolution and interactive aerosol and cloud microphysics significantly underpredicts Nd, although only slightly underestimates the cloud condensation nuclei concentration. With an updated version of the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (2000) activation scheme, we produce Nd that are more consistent with those predicted by a cloud parcel model under fog-like conditions. We activate droplets only by adiabatic cooling. We incorporate more realistic hygroscopicities for sulfate and organic aerosols and explore the sensitivity of simulated Nd to unresolved updrafts. We find that both Nd and simulated fog liquid water content are very sensitive to the updated activation scheme but remain unaffected by the update to hygroscopicities. Our improvements offer insights into the physical processes regulating Nd in stable conditions, potentially laying foundations for improved operational fog forecasts that incorporate interactive aerosol simulations or aerosol climatologies.
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-43
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3376
Aerosols influence fog properties such as visibility and lifetime by affecting fog droplet number concentrations (Nd). Numerical weather prediction (NWP) models often represent aerosol-fog interactions using highly simplified approaches. Incorporating prognostic size-resolved aerosol microphysics from climate models could allow them to simulate Nd and aerosol-fog interactions without incurring excessive computational expense. However, microphysics code designed for coarse spatial resolution may struggle with sub-kilometer-scale grid spacings. Here we test the ability of the UK Met Office Unified Model to simulate aerosol and fog properties during case studies from the ParisFog field campaign in 2011. We examine the sensitivity of fog properties to variations in Nd caused by modifications to simulated aerosol activation. Our model with 500 m horizontal resolution and interactive aerosol and cloud microphysics significantly underpredicts Nd, although only slightly underestimates the cloud condensation nuclei concentration. With an updated version of the Abdul-Razzak and Ghan (2000) activation scheme, we produce Nd that are more consistent with those predicted by a cloud parcel model under fog-like conditions. We activate droplets only by adiabatic cooling. We incorporate more realistic hygroscopicities for sulfate and organic aerosols and explore the sensitivity of simulated Nd to unresolved updrafts. We find that both Nd and simulated fog liquid water content are very sensitive to the updated activation scheme but remain unaffected by the update to hygroscopicities. Our improvements offer insights into the physical processes regulating Nd in stable conditions, potentially laying foundations for improved operational fog forecasts that incorporate interactive aerosol simulations or aerosol climatologies.