Sean Harrington
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Sean Harrington has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Daniel J. Paluh
Department of Biology University of Dayton Dayton Ohio USA
2 shared publications Tod W. Reeder
Department of Biology San Diego State University San Diego CA USA
2 shared publications- Aaron H. Griffing
Department of Chemical & Biological Engineering Princeton University Princeton New Jersey USA
1 shared publication - Alexander C. Cameron
Museum of Southwestern Biology and Department of Biology, University of New Mexico , Albuquerque, NM 87131 , USA
1 shared publication - Alexander Haas
Leibniz Institute for the Analysis of Biodiversity Change, Hamburg, Germany
1 shared publication Andrew Capitosti
Department of Biology, University of Dayton, Department of Biology, Dayton, Ohio, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
The molecular basis of hard cornification in the keratinized jaw sheaths and keratodonts of anuran tadpoles
Hard cornification is the developmental process that produces the hardened epidermal structures that characterize tetrapod diversity, including scales, feathers, hair, and claws. This process relies on keratin proteins and additional reinforcing proteins that assemble, cross-link, and strengthen tissues to become mechanically resilient. Although the molecular composition of hard cornified tissues is known to vary among tetrapods, the program is least understood in amphibians. Within frogs, hard cornification occurs in the mouthparts of most tadpoles and in the nuptial pads, hindfoot claws, and foot tubercles of some adults. We characterized transcriptomic profiles of Bombina orientalis tadpoles at three developmental stages before, during, and after mouthpart cornification. We identified 25 keratin genes orthologous to amniote hard keratins in the B. bombina genome, 18 of which are upregulated in cornifying larval mouthparts. Furthermore, two of these hard keratin paralogs and an amphibian epidermal differentiation gene exhibit distinct spatial expression patterns within the jaw sheaths and keratodonts evidenced by in situ hybridization, suggesting they have discrete functional roles. The newly discovered diversity of the hard keratin repertoire in Bombina , and the concurrent expression of many of these paralogs in tadpole mouthparts, suggests that anuran hard cornification is much more complex than adult cornified traits thus far characterized in Xenopus frogs. Our results also challenge the notion that the diversification of keratins in Amphibia is primarily associated with the transition to more terrestrial habits, and may instead be shaped, in part, by the novel feeding apparatus of aquatic tadpoles.
Open AccessThe molecular basis of hard cornification in the keratinized jaw sheaths and keratodonts of anuran tadpoles
Hard cornification is the developmental process that produces the hardened epidermal structures that characterize tetrapod diversity, including scales, feathers, hair, and claws. This process relies on keratin proteins and additional reinforcing proteins that assemble, cross-link, and strengthen tissues to become mechanically resilient. Although the molecular composition of hard cornified tissues is known to vary among tetrapods, the program is least understood in amphibians. Within frogs, hard cornification occurs in the mouthparts of most tadpoles and in the nuptial pads, hindfoot claws, and foot tubercles of some adults. We characterized transcriptomic profiles of Bombina orientalis tadpoles at three developmental stages before, during, and after mouthpart cornification. We identified 25 keratin genes orthologous to amniote hard keratins in the B. bombina genome, 18 of which are upregulated in cornifying larval mouthparts. Furthermore, two of these hard keratin paralogs and an amphibian epidermal differentiation gene exhibit distinct spatial expression patterns within the jaw sheaths and keratodonts evidenced by in situ hybridization, suggesting they have discrete functional roles. The newly discovered diversity of the hard keratin repertoire in Bombina , and the concurrent expression of many of these paralogs in tadpole mouthparts, suggests that anuran hard cornification is much more complex than adult cornified traits thus far characterized in Xenopus frogs. Our results also challenge the notion that the diversification of keratins in Amphibia is primarily associated with the transition to more terrestrial habits, and may instead be shaped, in part, by the novel feeding apparatus of aquatic tadpoles.
- Open Access
Painting the evolutionary history of a multicompartmentalized syngameon in North American Castilleja (Orobanchaceae)
Understanding the evolutionary history of recent rapidly radiating groups remains a major challenge in systematics, especially when incomplete reproductive isolation and rampant interspecific gene flow obscure phylogenetic signal. Here, we present a comprehensive phylogenomic study of the genus Castilleja (the paintbrushes, Orobanchaceae), integrating nuclear and chloroplast data to investigate patterns of diversification, hybridization, and geographic structure across its range. Our results provide the first evidence that Castilleja functions as a multicompartmentalized syngameon-a network of closely related species with ongoing or historical gene flow among non-sister lineages within and between geographically structured compartments. High nuclear gene tree discordance, coupled with strong cpDNA geographic compartment structuring and nuclear network analysis, supports the hypothesis that recent rapid radiation and Plio-Pleistocene climatic fluctuations created alternating periods of range expansion and contraction. These dynamics likely promoted localized hybridization within isolated compartments during contraction and further introgression between compartments during range expansion. Our findings not only clarify the evolutionary relationships within Castilleja but also demonstrate the importance of genome-scale data and syngameon theory in understanding diversification in lineages where hybridization is rampant.
Open AccessPainting the evolutionary history of a multicompartmentalized syngameon in North American Castilleja (Orobanchaceae)
Understanding the evolutionary history of recent rapidly radiating groups remains a major challenge in systematics, especially when incomplete reproductive isolation and rampant interspecific gene flow obscure phylogenetic signal. Here, we present a comprehensive phylogenomic study of the genus Castilleja (the paintbrushes, Orobanchaceae), integrating nuclear and chloroplast data to investigate patterns of diversification, hybridization, and geographic structure across its range. Our results provide the first evidence that Castilleja functions as a multicompartmentalized syngameon-a network of closely related species with ongoing or historical gene flow among non-sister lineages within and between geographically structured compartments. High nuclear gene tree discordance, coupled with strong cpDNA geographic compartment structuring and nuclear network analysis, supports the hypothesis that recent rapid radiation and Plio-Pleistocene climatic fluctuations created alternating periods of range expansion and contraction. These dynamics likely promoted localized hybridization within isolated compartments during contraction and further introgression between compartments during range expansion. Our findings not only clarify the evolutionary relationships within Castilleja but also demonstrate the importance of genome-scale data and syngameon theory in understanding diversification in lineages where hybridization is rampant.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 35 (13) , e70450
Ancient Divergences of the Maritime Alpine Tree Larix lyallii (Pinaceae) Contrasts With Patterns in Other Pacific Northwest Coastal Disjuncts
The disjunct mesic forests of the Pacific Northwest, occurring on the west side of North America's Coastal Ranges as well as in the Northern Rocky Mountains, have emerged as a model system for comparative phylogeography. Less well‐known, however, are the alpine and subalpine plants that mirror this distribution—here referred to as the Maritime Alpine Disjuncts. The phylogeographic histories of lowland coastal disjunct species are the result of either the Cascade orogeny, which separated once‐contiguous mesic habitats, post‐Pleistocene dispersal of species between the northern Interior and coastal forests, or a complex mix of these two processes. In the current study, we investigate the phylogeographic history of Larix lyalii (subalpine larch)—a narrowly distributed Maritime Alpine Disjunct species—to determine whether these geographically related disjunct communities are the result of processes similar to other Pacific Northwest disjuncts. We sample the entire range of L. lyalii and use ddRAD data to explore hypotheses on the timing of these disjunctions. Using a dataset of 28 individuals and 30,425 loci we find three major clades within the species: a Cascade Mountain clade sister to northern and southern Interior clades. We estimate the major clade divergences to be on the order of one to three million years with evidence of population admixture between the two Rocky Mountain clades surrounding the Flathead Valley in Northwestern Montana, USA. L. lyallii 's present phylogenetic structure has origins predating the Pleistocene. While the timing of this structure is largely consistent with an ancient vicariance event present in some lowland coastal disjunct species, the mechanisms for this are likely different in this high elevation tree species.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 35 (13) , e70450
Ancient Divergences of the Maritime Alpine Tree Larix lyallii (Pinaceae) Contrasts With Patterns in Other Pacific Northwest Coastal Disjuncts
The disjunct mesic forests of the Pacific Northwest, occurring on the west side of North America's Coastal Ranges as well as in the Northern Rocky Mountains, have emerged as a model system for comparative phylogeography. Less well‐known, however, are the alpine and subalpine plants that mirror this distribution—here referred to as the Maritime Alpine Disjuncts. The phylogeographic histories of lowland coastal disjunct species are the result of either the Cascade orogeny, which separated once‐contiguous mesic habitats, post‐Pleistocene dispersal of species between the northern Interior and coastal forests, or a complex mix of these two processes. In the current study, we investigate the phylogeographic history of Larix lyalii (subalpine larch)—a narrowly distributed Maritime Alpine Disjunct species—to determine whether these geographically related disjunct communities are the result of processes similar to other Pacific Northwest disjuncts. We sample the entire range of L. lyalii and use ddRAD data to explore hypotheses on the timing of these disjunctions. Using a dataset of 28 individuals and 30,425 loci we find three major clades within the species: a Cascade Mountain clade sister to northern and southern Interior clades. We estimate the major clade divergences to be on the order of one to three million years with evidence of population admixture between the two Rocky Mountain clades surrounding the Flathead Valley in Northwestern Montana, USA. L. lyallii 's present phylogenetic structure has origins predating the Pleistocene. While the timing of this structure is largely consistent with an ancient vicariance event present in some lowland coastal disjunct species, the mechanisms for this are likely different in this high elevation tree species.
- 13 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 34 (11) , e17625
Pleistocene Glaciation Drove Shared Population Coexpansion in Eastern North American Snakes
Glacial cycles during the Pleistocene had profound impacts on local environments and climatic conditions. In North America, some regions that currently support diverse biomes were entirely covered by ice sheets, while other regions were environmentally unsuitable for the organisms that live there now. Organisms that occupy these regions in the present day must have expanded or dispersed into these regions since the last glacial maximum, leading to the possibility that species with similar geographic distributions may show temporally concordant population size changes associated with these warming trends. We examined 17 lineages from 9 eastern North American snake species and species complexes to test for a signal of temporally concordant coexpansion using a machine learning approach. We found that the majority of lineages show population size increases towards the present, with evidence for coexpansion in five out of fourteen lineages, while expansion in others was idiosyncratic. We also examined relationships between genetic distance and current environmental predictors and showed that genomic responses to environmental predictors are not consistent among species. We, therefore, conclude that Pleistocene warming resulted in population size increases in most eastern North American snake species, but variation in environmental preferences and other species‐specific traits results in variance in the exact timing of expansion.
- 13 December 2024
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology
- Vol. 34 (11) , e17625
Pleistocene Glaciation Drove Shared Population Coexpansion in Eastern North American Snakes
Glacial cycles during the Pleistocene had profound impacts on local environments and climatic conditions. In North America, some regions that currently support diverse biomes were entirely covered by ice sheets, while other regions were environmentally unsuitable for the organisms that live there now. Organisms that occupy these regions in the present day must have expanded or dispersed into these regions since the last glacial maximum, leading to the possibility that species with similar geographic distributions may show temporally concordant population size changes associated with these warming trends. We examined 17 lineages from 9 eastern North American snake species and species complexes to test for a signal of temporally concordant coexpansion using a machine learning approach. We found that the majority of lineages show population size increases towards the present, with evidence for coexpansion in five out of fourteen lineages, while expansion in others was idiosyncratic. We also examined relationships between genetic distance and current environmental predictors and showed that genomic responses to environmental predictors are not consistent among species. We, therefore, conclude that Pleistocene warming resulted in population size increases in most eastern North American snake species, but variation in environmental preferences and other species‐specific traits results in variance in the exact timing of expansion.
- Open Access
- 21 December 2022
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 18 (12) , 20220403
Colour scales with climate in North American ratsnakes: a test of the thermal melanism hypothesis using community science images
Animal colour is a complex trait shaped by multiple selection pressures that can vary across geography. The thermal melanism hypothesis predicts that darker coloration is beneficial to animals in colder regions because it allows for more rapid solar absorption. Here, we use community science images of three closely related species of North American ratsnakes (genusPantherophis) to examine if climate predicts colour variation across range-wide scales. We predicted that darker individuals are found in colder regions and higher elevations, in accordance with the thermal melanism hypothesis. Using an unprecedented dataset of over 8000 images, we found strong support for temperature as a key predictor of darker colour, supporting thermal melanism. We also found that elevation and precipitation are predictive of colour, but the direction and magnitude of these effects were more variable across species. Our study is the first to quantify colour variation inPantherophisratsnakes, highlighting the value of community science images for studying range-wide colour variation.
- 21 December 2022
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 18 (12) , 20220403
Open AccessColour scales with climate in North American ratsnakes: a test of the thermal melanism hypothesis using community science images
Animal colour is a complex trait shaped by multiple selection pressures that can vary across geography. The thermal melanism hypothesis predicts that darker coloration is beneficial to animals in colder regions because it allows for more rapid solar absorption. Here, we use community science images of three closely related species of North American ratsnakes (genusPantherophis) to examine if climate predicts colour variation across range-wide scales. We predicted that darker individuals are found in colder regions and higher elevations, in accordance with the thermal melanism hypothesis. Using an unprecedented dataset of over 8000 images, we found strong support for temperature as a key predictor of darker colour, supporting thermal melanism. We also found that elevation and precipitation are predictive of colour, but the direction and magnitude of these effects were more variable across species. Our study is the first to quantify colour variation inPantherophisratsnakes, highlighting the value of community science images for studying range-wide colour variation.
- 23 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 50 (2) , 341-351
Complex cycles of divergence and migration shape lineage structure in the common kingsnake species complex
Aim: The Nearctic is a complex patchwork of habitats and geologic features that form barriers to gene flow resulting in phylogeographic structure and speciation in many lineages. Habitats are rarely stable over geologic time, and the Nearctic has undergone major climatic changes in the past few million years. We use the common kingsnake species complex to study how climate, geography, and history influence lineage formation over a large, complex landscape.Location: Nearctic/North America.Taxon: Common kingsnake, Lampropeltis getula, species complex.Methods: We analysed genome‐wide sequence data from 51 snakes spanning the majority of the species complex's range. We used population clustering, generalized dissimilarity modelling and coalescent methods to identify the number of genetic clusters within the L. getula complex, infer the environmental correlates of genetic differentiation, and estimate models of divergence and gene flow among lineages.Results: We identified three major lineages within the L. getula complex and further continuous spatial structure within lineages. The most important ecological correlates of genetic distance in the complex are related to aridity and precipitation, consistent with lineage breaks at the Great Plains/Desert ecotone and the Cochise filter barrier. Lineages are estimated to have undergone multiple rounds of isolation and secondary contact, with highly asymmetric migration occurring at present.Main conclusions: Changing climates combined with a large and geologically complex landscape have resulted in a mosaic of discrete and spatially continuous genetic structure. Multiple rounds of isolation and secondary contact as climate fluctuated over the past ~4.4 My have likely driven the evolution of discrete lineages that maintain high levels of gene flow. Continuous structure is strongly shaped by aridity and precipitation, suggesting roles for major precipitation gradients in helping to maintain lineage identity in the face of gene flow when lineages are in geographic contact.
- 23 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 50 (2) , 341-351
Complex cycles of divergence and migration shape lineage structure in the common kingsnake species complex
Aim: The Nearctic is a complex patchwork of habitats and geologic features that form barriers to gene flow resulting in phylogeographic structure and speciation in many lineages. Habitats are rarely stable over geologic time, and the Nearctic has undergone major climatic changes in the past few million years. We use the common kingsnake species complex to study how climate, geography, and history influence lineage formation over a large, complex landscape.Location: Nearctic/North America.Taxon: Common kingsnake, Lampropeltis getula, species complex.Methods: We analysed genome‐wide sequence data from 51 snakes spanning the majority of the species complex's range. We used population clustering, generalized dissimilarity modelling and coalescent methods to identify the number of genetic clusters within the L. getula complex, infer the environmental correlates of genetic differentiation, and estimate models of divergence and gene flow among lineages.Results: We identified three major lineages within the L. getula complex and further continuous spatial structure within lineages. The most important ecological correlates of genetic distance in the complex are related to aridity and precipitation, consistent with lineage breaks at the Great Plains/Desert ecotone and the Cochise filter barrier. Lineages are estimated to have undergone multiple rounds of isolation and secondary contact, with highly asymmetric migration occurring at present.Main conclusions: Changing climates combined with a large and geologically complex landscape have resulted in a mosaic of discrete and spatially continuous genetic structure. Multiple rounds of isolation and secondary contact as climate fluctuated over the past ~4.4 My have likely driven the evolution of discrete lineages that maintain high levels of gene flow. Continuous structure is strongly shaped by aridity and precipitation, suggesting roles for major precipitation gradients in helping to maintain lineage identity in the face of gene flow when lineages are in geographic contact.
- Open Access
- 13 November 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Molecular Biology and Evolution
- Vol. 38 (4) , 1627-1640
Properties of Markov Chain Monte Carlo Performance across Many Empirical Alignments
Nearly all current Bayesian phylogenetic applications rely on Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods to approximate the posterior distribution for trees and other parameters of the model. These approximations are only reliable if Markov chains adequately converge and sample from the joint posterior distribution. Although several studies of phylogenetic MCMC convergence exist, these have focused on simulated data sets or select empirical examples. Therefore, much that is considered common knowledge about MCMC in empirical systems derives from a relatively small family of analyses under ideal conditions. To address this, we present an overview of commonly applied phylogenetic MCMC diagnostics and an assessment of patterns of these diagnostics across more than 18,000 empirical analyses. Many analyses appeared to perform well and failures in convergence were most likely to be detected using the average standard deviation of split frequencies, a diagnostic that compares topologies among independent chains. Different diagnostics yielded different information about failed convergence, demonstrating that multiple diagnostics must be employed to reliably detect problems. The number of taxa and average branch lengths in analyses have clear impacts on MCMC performance, with more taxa and shorter branches leading to more difficult convergence. We show that the usage of models that include both Γ-distributed among-site rate variation and a proportion of invariable sites is not broadly problematic for MCMC convergence but is also unnecessary. Changes to heating and the usage of model-averaged substitution models can both offer improved convergence in some cases, but neither are a panacea.
- 13 November 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Molecular Biology and Evolution
- Vol. 38 (4) , 1627-1640
Open AccessProperties of Markov Chain Monte Carlo Performance across Many Empirical Alignments
Nearly all current Bayesian phylogenetic applications rely on Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods to approximate the posterior distribution for trees and other parameters of the model. These approximations are only reliable if Markov chains adequately converge and sample from the joint posterior distribution. Although several studies of phylogenetic MCMC convergence exist, these have focused on simulated data sets or select empirical examples. Therefore, much that is considered common knowledge about MCMC in empirical systems derives from a relatively small family of analyses under ideal conditions. To address this, we present an overview of commonly applied phylogenetic MCMC diagnostics and an assessment of patterns of these diagnostics across more than 18,000 empirical analyses. Many analyses appeared to perform well and failures in convergence were most likely to be detected using the average standard deviation of split frequencies, a diagnostic that compares topologies among independent chains. Different diagnostics yielded different information about failed convergence, demonstrating that multiple diagnostics must be employed to reliably detect problems. The number of taxa and average branch lengths in analyses have clear impacts on MCMC performance, with more taxa and shorter branches leading to more difficult convergence. We show that the usage of models that include both Γ-distributed among-site rate variation and a proportion of invariable sites is not broadly problematic for MCMC convergence but is also unnecessary. Changes to heating and the usage of model-averaged substitution models can both offer improved convergence in some cases, but neither are a panacea.
- 18 October 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 45 (1) , 64-75
Pleistocene climatic fluctuations drive isolation and secondary contact in the red diamond rattlesnake (Crotalus ruber) in Baja California
Aim: Many studies have investigated the phylogeographic history of species on the Baja California Peninsula, and they often show one or more genetic breaks that are spatially concordant among many taxa. These phylogeographic breaks are commonly attributed to vicariance as a result of geological or climatic changes, followed by secondary contact when barriers are no longer present. We use restriction‐site associated DNA sequence data and a phylogeographic model selection approach to explicitly test the secondary contact hypothesis in the red diamond rattlesnake, Crotalus ruber.Location: Baja California and Southern California.Methods: We used phylogenetic and population clustering approaches to identify population structure. We then used coalescent methods to simultaneously estimate population parameters and test the fit of phylogeographic models to the data. We used ecological niche models to infer suitable habitat for C. ruber at the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM).Results: Crotalus ruber is composed of distinct northern and southern populations with a boundary near the town of Loreto in Baja California Sur. A model of isolation followed by secondary contact provides the best fit to the data, with both divergence and contact occurring in the Pleistocene. We also identify a genomic signature of northern range expansion in the northern population, consistent with LGM niche models showing that the northern‐most portion of the range of C. ruber was not suitable habitat during the LGM.Main conclusions: We provide the first explicitly model‐based test of the secondary contact model in Baja California and show that populations of C. ruber were isolated before coming back into contact near Loreto, a region that shows phylogeographic breaks for other taxa. Given the timing of divergence and contact, we suggest that climatic fluctuations have driven the observed phylogeographic structure observed in C. ruber and that they may have driven similar patterns in other taxa.
- 18 October 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 45 (1) , 64-75
Pleistocene climatic fluctuations drive isolation and secondary contact in the red diamond rattlesnake (Crotalus ruber) in Baja California
Aim: Many studies have investigated the phylogeographic history of species on the Baja California Peninsula, and they often show one or more genetic breaks that are spatially concordant among many taxa. These phylogeographic breaks are commonly attributed to vicariance as a result of geological or climatic changes, followed by secondary contact when barriers are no longer present. We use restriction‐site associated DNA sequence data and a phylogeographic model selection approach to explicitly test the secondary contact hypothesis in the red diamond rattlesnake, Crotalus ruber.Location: Baja California and Southern California.Methods: We used phylogenetic and population clustering approaches to identify population structure. We then used coalescent methods to simultaneously estimate population parameters and test the fit of phylogeographic models to the data. We used ecological niche models to infer suitable habitat for C. ruber at the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM).Results: Crotalus ruber is composed of distinct northern and southern populations with a boundary near the town of Loreto in Baja California Sur. A model of isolation followed by secondary contact provides the best fit to the data, with both divergence and contact occurring in the Pleistocene. We also identify a genomic signature of northern range expansion in the northern population, consistent with LGM niche models showing that the northern‐most portion of the range of C. ruber was not suitable habitat during the LGM.Main conclusions: We provide the first explicitly model‐based test of the secondary contact model in Baja California and show that populations of C. ruber were isolated before coming back into contact near Loreto, a region that shows phylogeographic breaks for other taxa. Given the timing of divergence and contact, we suggest that climatic fluctuations have driven the observed phylogeographic structure observed in C. ruber and that they may have driven similar patterns in other taxa.
- 17 November 2016
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 30 (2) , 313-325
Rate heterogeneity across Squamata, misleading ancestral state reconstruction and the importance of proper null model specification
The binary‐state speciation and extinction (BiSSE) model has been used in many instances to identify state‐dependent diversification and reconstruct ancestral states. However, recent studies have shown that the standard procedure of comparing the fit of the BiSSEmodel to constant‐rate birth–death models often inappropriately favours the BiSSEmodel when diversification rates vary in a state‐independent fashion. The newly developed HiSSEmodel enables researchers to identify state‐dependent diversification rates while accounting for state‐independent diversification at the same time. The HiSSEmodel also allows researchers to test state‐dependent models against appropriate state‐independent null models that have the same number of parameters as the state‐dependent models being tested. We reanalyse two data sets that originally used BiSSEto reconstruct ancestral states within squamate reptiles and reached surprising conclusions regarding the evolution of toepads within Gekkota and viviparity across Squamata. We used this new method to demonstrate that there are many shifts in diversification rates across squamates. We then fit various HiSSEsubmodels and null models to the state and phylogenetic data and reconstructed states under these models. We found that there is no single, consistent signal for state‐dependent diversification associated with toepads in gekkotans or viviparity across all squamates. Our reconstructions show limited support for the recently proposed hypotheses that toepads evolved multiple times independently in Gekkota and that transitions from viviparity to oviparity are common in Squamata. Our results highlight the importance of considering an adequate pool of models and null models when estimating diversification rate parameters and reconstructing ancestral states.
- 17 November 2016
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 30 (2) , 313-325
Rate heterogeneity across Squamata, misleading ancestral state reconstruction and the importance of proper null model specification
The binary‐state speciation and extinction (BiSSE) model has been used in many instances to identify state‐dependent diversification and reconstruct ancestral states. However, recent studies have shown that the standard procedure of comparing the fit of the BiSSEmodel to constant‐rate birth–death models often inappropriately favours the BiSSEmodel when diversification rates vary in a state‐independent fashion. The newly developed HiSSEmodel enables researchers to identify state‐dependent diversification rates while accounting for state‐independent diversification at the same time. The HiSSEmodel also allows researchers to test state‐dependent models against appropriate state‐independent null models that have the same number of parameters as the state‐dependent models being tested. We reanalyse two data sets that originally used BiSSEto reconstruct ancestral states within squamate reptiles and reached surprising conclusions regarding the evolution of toepads within Gekkota and viviparity across Squamata. We used this new method to demonstrate that there are many shifts in diversification rates across squamates. We then fit various HiSSEsubmodels and null models to the state and phylogenetic data and reconstructed states under these models. We found that there is no single, consistent signal for state‐dependent diversification associated with toepads in gekkotans or viviparity across all squamates. Our reconstructions show limited support for the recently proposed hypotheses that toepads evolved multiple times independently in Gekkota and that transitions from viviparity to oviparity are common in Squamata. Our results highlight the importance of considering an adequate pool of models and null models when estimating diversification rate parameters and reconstructing ancestral states.