JBJo Bates

Jo Bates

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Jo Bates has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Feeding the machine: Practitioner experiences of efforts to overcome AI's data dilemma

    by Jo Bates, Monika Fratczak, Helen Kennedy, Itzelle Medina Perea, Erinma Ochu

    This paper examines the human implications of AI's ‘data dilemma' in three different and contrasting sectors: pharmaceuticals, higher education, and the arts. The ‘data dilemma' refers to the challenge of obtaining sufficient and suitable data to effectively train AI algorithms. The research, conducted in the UK, involved interviews, focus groups, and observations with 65 practitioners employed across these three sectors. The findings reveal that addressing the data dilemma often involves practitioners being pressured to generate data for AI, either passively in the context of data extractivism or actively by engaging in new forms of data production. We explore how this pressure to ‘feed the machine’ manifests differently in each sector, and how modes of resistance to these emergent data practices vary across sectors. We observe that the push to resolve the data dilemma is fundamentally driven by capitalist and technological solutionist values; values that often conflict with those of practitioners who are expected to adapt their practices in the service of AI-driven capitalism. We conclude with a call for exploring different approaches to AI development that align with alternative value systems.


  • Open Access

    How people connect fairness and equity when they talk about data uses

    by Helen Kennedy, Hannah Ditchfield, Susan Oman, Jo Bates, Itzelle Medina Perea, Monika Fratczak, Mark Taylor

    As a mechanism for addressing data-related harms, fairness has been subjected to considerable criticism, seen as failing to acknowledge the power relationships that produce said harms, or as a ‘floating signifier’ devoid of specific meaning. In contrast to fairness, it is argued that equity does a better job of recognising data-related harms. Criticisms such as these emerge in specific cultural contexts and rarely acknowledge everyday understandings of terms and concepts. This paper engages with these criticisms, drawing on research exploring how 112 UK residents perceive data uses in specific public service organisations. We found that participants perceive fairness and equity to be interwoven with each other, a finding which shows that who gets to define what is fair matters and which challenges assumptions about what does and does not constitute thinking and talking data politics. We conclude by proposing that linking fairness with equity can be seen as a kind of everyday data solidarity.


  • Open Access

    What ifs: The role of imagining in people’s reflections on data uses

    by Hannah Ditchfield, Susan Oman, Helen Kennedy, Monika Frątczak, Jo Bates, Mark Taylor, Itzelle Medina-Perea

    This paper explores how non-experts reflect on and come to understand ‘data uses’, a phrase we used to refer to data collection, analysis and sharing. In recent years, research into what people think and feel about data uses has proliferated, whereas this paper focuses on how they do their thinking and feeling. We argue that imagining – that is, building or creating a mental image of something that is not present – is an important aspect of reflecting on data uses. We challenge the proposition that imagining takes place when there is a gap in knowledge or a lack of information, arguing instead that imagining plays an agentic role in reflection, enabling critical questioning of data uses. We draw on qualitative research carried out in the UK, in which we provided information about specific public sector data uses and asked participants how they felt about them. We found that imaginings, or ‘what ifs’, exist in a complex entanglement with different knowledges, including experiential knowledge.


  • Open Access

    ‘Data saves lives’: Ideational-material drivers of health data journeys in the UK

    by Itzelle Medina-Perea, Jo Bates, Andrew Cox

    In this paper, we bring together the concepts of data valences and data journeys to examine how ideational and material factors work together to shape the movement of health data from the UK healthcare sector to universities for reuse in research. Specifically, we focus on the interaction of university-based researchers’ constructs about data with the material conditions of health data circulation in the UK and how these dynamics drive greater circulation of health data through the data sharing infrastructure. Building on our empirical research, we identify four data valences or expectations about data present in the discourses of university-based researchers – vanguard, discovery, truthiness and actionability – and three material factors – investment in data, infrastructure and labour. We argue that the interaction of these factors has created a favourable environment for making data flow from the healthcare sector into the hands of university-based researchers. This work contributes to a better understanding of why health data reuse practices are expanding and being sustained, and it challenges previous health data reuse research that treats the drivers shaping data flows as self-evident or already determined.


  • Open Access

    BELIEFS, VALUES AND EMOTIONS IN PRACTITIONERS’ ENGAGEMENTS WITH LEARNING ANALYTICS IN HIGHER EDUCATION

    by Itzelle Medina Perea, Jo Bates, Monika Fratczak, Helen Kennedy, Erinma Ochu

    Internet entrepreneurs, EdTech companies, AI enthusiasts, and other powerful stakeholders around the world have promoted the idea that big data and learning analytics (LA) have the potential to revolutionise education. LA, defined as the continuous measurement, collection, analysis and reporting of data about learners and their context (Gašević et al., 2015, p. 1), is increasingly being used to track and evaluate what students do in internet-mediated environments. A growing body of literature has questioned the benefits attributed to the use of AI-based solutions and raised a number of concerns about the current developments in the education sector. Despite this growing interest among researchers, we know little about how the beliefs, values and feelings of different groups of educational practitioners shape how they engage with AI-driven learning analytics technologies and influence the evolution of the cultures of practice shaping the adoption of learning analytics. In this paper, we report on research that asks: how do culturally situated beliefs, values and emotions shape practitioners’ engagements with narrow AI in different contexts of practice? The research project as a whole examines these cultures of practice across three contrasting contexts. Here we will discuss early findings from one of these contexts – learning analytics in higher education. With insights from this research, we aim to contribute to empower practitioners in higher education and relevant stakeholders to foster the development of critical and reflective data cultures that are able to exploit the possibilities of learning analytics while being critically responsive to their societal implications and limitations.

  • Open Access

    Worker Perspectives on Designs for a Crowdwork Co-operative

    by Jo Bates, Alessandro Checco, Elli Gerakopoulou

    Crowdwork platforms such as Amazon Mechanical Turk (AMT) are a crucial infrastructural component of our global data assemblage. Through these platforms, low-paid crowdworkers perform the vital labour of manually labelling large-scale and complex datasets, labels that are needed to train machine learning and AI models (Tubaro et al., Big Data & Society, 7(1), 2020) and which enable the functioning of much digital technology, from niche applications to global platforms such as Google, Amazon and Facebook.In this chapter, we reflect on how a ‘design justice’ approach might be valuable to build on insights gained from a series of exploratory discussions we have engaged in with US-based crowdworkers about how a crowdworker co-operative might work in practice, and begin to sketch out a potential software architecture that could form the basis of future participative approaches to the design and development of a crowdworker co-operative.We begin by describing and reflecting on our own evolving methodology and how it fits with the ‘design justice’ lens we propose for future work. Following this, we present findings from our discussions with crowdworkers about how a crowdwork co-operative might work in practice, including what values workers would like to see embedded in the design. We then finish with the outline of a prototype software architecture for a crowdworker co-operative that could be used as a starting point in future design work in collaboration with crowdworkers.


  • Everyday activism:

    by Katherine Quinn, Jo Bates

  • Community participation in the management of palm leaf manuscripts as Lanna cultural material in Thailand

    by Piyapat Jarusawat, Andrew Cox, Jo Bates

    Purpose: The cultural heritage of the Lanna region of upper Northern Thailand is unique. One of its distinctive features is palm leaf manuscripts (PLMs), which are viewed simultaneously as examples of sacred writing and religious symbols, means of transferring cultural knowledge, artefacts of beauty and fragile historical documents. Local people still care about these objects, and speak the language but knowledge of the script is limited. The purpose of this paper is to explore the views of community members and experts about the value and management of PLMs as the basis for developing a model of community-based collection management. Design/methodology/approach: Because the purpose was to explore differing perceptions and beliefs around PLMs the study adopted an interpretivist worldview. Data were collected through interviews with local people with an interest in PLMs and experts who advised on organising them. In addition, observation and a photo inventory method was used to collect data. Data were analysed thematically. Findings: The results showed that while both groups saw the value of the knowledge PLMs contained, the community placed particular importance on the earning of “merit” through activities related to them as Buddhist objects. Experts gave particular emphasis to the knowledge of herbal medicine contained in the PLMs. The community valued indigenous storage and preservation practices. Experts were particularly pre-occupied with the intellectual property issue around medical knowledge and convenient storage and digitisation. Research limitations/implications: Existing theory around libraries, archives and museums suggest some starting points for how community participation might be managed, but the unique circumstances of Lanna PLMs calls for a distinctive approach. Practical implications: The paper identifies a pathway suitable to the Lanna context that can build on current local practices, to enhance community participation in the management of PLMs, including a consideration of the role of information professionals. Originality/value: This paper is one of the first to extend thinking about participatory practices in the library, archive and museum literature to the context of Thailand and specifically to the case of PLMs, in the Lanna region. Rigorous data analysis of a substantial body of evidence has enhanced the understanding of the different types of value placed on PLMs. It identifies an important but not unbridgeable tension between how local people and experts view PLMs. It builds on previous library, archive and museum theory to propose a realistic model of how communities and experts (including librarians) can work together to protect the rich cultural resource represented by PLMs.