Luke Chamandy
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Luke Chamandy has a total of 66 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Eric G. Blackman
University of Rochester
23 shared publications - Anvar Shukurov
Newcastle University
11 shared publications Jonathan Carroll-Nellenback
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Rochester , Rochester NY 14627 , USA
11 shared publicationsAdam Frank
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Rochester , Rochester NY 14627 , USA
10 shared publicationsYisheng Tu
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Rochester , Rochester NY 14627 , USA
10 shared publicationsJason Nordhaus
Center for Computational Relativity and Gravitation, Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester, NY, USA
9 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 September 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1009 (2) , 208
Effect of Neutron Star Jets on Common Envelope Evolution
The common envelope (CE) phase is a key stage in binary star evolution that is still not very well understood. Once engulfed by the giant star, the binary companion may accrete envelope material. For neutron star (NS) companions, such accretion may in principle occur at mass rates several orders of magnitude above the Eddington limit and may result in outflows dominated by powerful bipolar jets with mass-loss rates similar to the accretion rates. Such jets would impact the morphology of the system and the rate of envelope unbinding, which affect the duration and outcome of the CE event. Employing 3D global hydrodynamic simulations, we study the role of such NS jets in a CE event involving a red giant branch star. The jets eventually drill through and break out of the envelope, producing prominent low-density bipolar lobes. The jets cause about twice as much envelope mass to be unbound (∼20% of the envelope) as compared to simulations of the same duration without NS jets (∼10%). However, the rate of mass unbinding due to the jets decreases towards the ends of the simulations as the jets break out and energetically decouple from the envelope. Moreover, jet activity leads to slightly reduced drag on the binary, decreasing the rate of orbital energy transfer to the envelope. Hence, while such powerful jets can play an important role, negative feedback effects tend to prevent them from dominating envelope unbinding and dictating CE outcomes.
- 29 September 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1009 (2) , 208
Open AccessEffect of Neutron Star Jets on Common Envelope Evolution
The common envelope (CE) phase is a key stage in binary star evolution that is still not very well understood. Once engulfed by the giant star, the binary companion may accrete envelope material. For neutron star (NS) companions, such accretion may in principle occur at mass rates several orders of magnitude above the Eddington limit and may result in outflows dominated by powerful bipolar jets with mass-loss rates similar to the accretion rates. Such jets would impact the morphology of the system and the rate of envelope unbinding, which affect the duration and outcome of the CE event. Employing 3D global hydrodynamic simulations, we study the role of such NS jets in a CE event involving a red giant branch star. The jets eventually drill through and break out of the envelope, producing prominent low-density bipolar lobes. The jets cause about twice as much envelope mass to be unbound (∼20% of the envelope) as compared to simulations of the same duration without NS jets (∼10%). However, the rate of mass unbinding due to the jets decreases towards the ends of the simulations as the jets break out and energetically decouple from the envelope. Moreover, jet activity leads to slightly reduced drag on the binary, decreasing the rate of orbital energy transfer to the envelope. Hence, while such powerful jets can play an important role, negative feedback effects tend to prevent them from dominating envelope unbinding and dictating CE outcomes.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1009 (1) , 2
Radio Continuum Emission from Evolving Star-forming Galaxies. I. Correlations Involving the Total Synchrotron Luminosity
Synchrotron radiation dominates the continuum emission of star-forming galaxies in the frequency range from a few MHz to about 30 GHz. We model the total synchrotron emission of a large population of evolving star-forming galaxies using the semianalytic galaxy formation model galform combined with the dynamo simulation code magnetizer . Assuming local energy equipartition between cosmic rays and magnetic fields, we calculate the specific synchrotron luminosity L ν for each simulated galaxy at various frequencies and find strong positive correlations between L ν and both the star formation rate (SFR) and characteristic galaxy rotation speed V rot for redshifts up to z ≃ 3. At low redshifts, the turbulent magnetic field is found to dominate in the synchrotron luminosity, but the contribution of the large-scale magnetic field increases with redshift and becomes important for z ≳ 1. The correlation between L ν and SFR arises from the tight correlation between the disk gas mass M gas and SFR, and the correlation between L ν and V rot is additionally a consequence of the stellar mass Tully–Fisher relation for main-sequence galaxies. At low redshifts, the model predictions and observational data compiled for this work show remarkable agreement, but a discrepancy arises at higher redshifts, where modelled SFR values are systematically smaller than those previously inferred from observations. These theoretical models will aid the interpretation of next-generation radio surveys with the Square Kilometre Array and other telescopes.
- 10 September 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1009 (1) , 2
Open AccessRadio Continuum Emission from Evolving Star-forming Galaxies. I. Correlations Involving the Total Synchrotron Luminosity
Synchrotron radiation dominates the continuum emission of star-forming galaxies in the frequency range from a few MHz to about 30 GHz. We model the total synchrotron emission of a large population of evolving star-forming galaxies using the semianalytic galaxy formation model galform combined with the dynamo simulation code magnetizer . Assuming local energy equipartition between cosmic rays and magnetic fields, we calculate the specific synchrotron luminosity L ν for each simulated galaxy at various frequencies and find strong positive correlations between L ν and both the star formation rate (SFR) and characteristic galaxy rotation speed V rot for redshifts up to z ≃ 3. At low redshifts, the turbulent magnetic field is found to dominate in the synchrotron luminosity, but the contribution of the large-scale magnetic field increases with redshift and becomes important for z ≳ 1. The correlation between L ν and SFR arises from the tight correlation between the disk gas mass M gas and SFR, and the correlation between L ν and V rot is additionally a consequence of the stellar mass Tully–Fisher relation for main-sequence galaxies. At low redshifts, the model predictions and observational data compiled for this work show remarkable agreement, but a discrepancy arises at higher redshifts, where modelled SFR values are systematically smaller than those previously inferred from observations. These theoretical models will aid the interpretation of next-generation radio surveys with the Square Kilometre Array and other telescopes.
- Open Access
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 545 (2)
The fine structure of the mean magnetic field in M31
To explore the spatial variations of the regular (mean) magnetic field of the Andromeda galaxy (M31), we use Fourier analysis in azimuthal angle along four rings in the galaxy’s plane. The Fourier coefficients give a quantitative measure of strength of the modes, enabling us to compare expectations from mean-field dynamo models of spiral galaxies. Earlier analyses indicated that the axisymmetric magnetic field (azimuthal Fourier mode $m=0$) is sufficient to fit the observed polarization angles in a wide range of galactocentric distances. We apply a Bayesian inference approach to new, more sensitive radio continuum data at $\lambda \lambda 3.59$, 6.18, and $11.33\, \text{cm}$ and the earlier data at $\lambda 20.46\, \text{cm}$ to reveal subdominant contributions from the modes $m=1$, 2, and 3 along with a dominant axisymmetric mode. Magnetic lines of the axisymmetric mode are close to trailing logarithmic spirals which are significantly more open than the spiral arms detectable in the interstellar dust and neutral hydrogen. The form of the $m=0$ mode is consistent with galactic dynamo theory. Both the amplitudes and the pitch angles of the higher azimuthal modes ($m>1$) vary irregularly with r reflecting local variations in the magnetic field structure. The maximum strength of the mean magnetic field of $1.8\!-\!2.7\, \mu\text{G}$ (for the axisymmetric part of the field) occurs at $10\!-\!14\, \text{kpc}$ but we find that its strength varies strongly along the azimuth; this variation gives rise to the $m=1$ mode. We suggest a procedure of Bayesian inference which is independent of the specific nature of the depolarization and applies when the magneto-ionic layer observable in polarized emission is not symmetric along the line of sight because emission from its far side is completely depolarized.- 21 November 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 545 (2)
Open AccessThe fine structure of the mean magnetic field in M31
To explore the spatial variations of the regular (mean) magnetic field of the Andromeda galaxy (M31), we use Fourier analysis in azimuthal angle along four rings in the galaxy’s plane. The Fourier coefficients give a quantitative measure of strength of the modes, enabling us to compare expectations from mean-field dynamo models of spiral galaxies. Earlier analyses indicated that the axisymmetric magnetic field (azimuthal Fourier mode $m=0$) is sufficient to fit the observed polarization angles in a wide range of galactocentric distances. We apply a Bayesian inference approach to new, more sensitive radio continuum data at $\lambda \lambda 3.59$, 6.18, and $11.33\, \text{cm}$ and the earlier data at $\lambda 20.46\, \text{cm}$ to reveal subdominant contributions from the modes $m=1$, 2, and 3 along with a dominant axisymmetric mode. Magnetic lines of the axisymmetric mode are close to trailing logarithmic spirals which are significantly more open than the spiral arms detectable in the interstellar dust and neutral hydrogen. The form of the $m=0$ mode is consistent with galactic dynamo theory. Both the amplitudes and the pitch angles of the higher azimuthal modes ($m>1$) vary irregularly with r reflecting local variations in the magnetic field structure. The maximum strength of the mean magnetic field of $1.8\!-\!2.7\, \mu\text{G}$ (for the axisymmetric part of the field) occurs at $10\!-\!14\, \text{kpc}$ but we find that its strength varies strongly along the azimuth; this variation gives rise to the $m=1$ mode. We suggest a procedure of Bayesian inference which is independent of the specific nature of the depolarization and applies when the magneto-ionic layer observable in polarized emission is not symmetric along the line of sight because emission from its far side is completely depolarized. - Open Access
- 24 July 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 988 (2) , 197
Galactic Magnetic Fields. II. Applying the Model to Nearby Galaxies
Many spiral galaxies host magnetic fields with energy densities comparable to those of the turbulent and thermal motions of their interstellar gas. However, quantitative comparison between magnetic field properties inferred from observation and those obtained from theoretical modeling has been lacking. In L. Chamandy et al. (Paper I), we developed a simple, axisymmetric galactic dynamo model that uses various observational data as input. Here, we apply our model to calculate radial profiles of azimuthally and vertically averaged magnetic field strength and pitch angle, gas velocity dispersion and scale height, turbulent correlation time and length, and the sizes of supernova remnants for the galaxies M31, M33, M51, and NGC 6946, using input data collected from the literature. Scaling factors are introduced to account for a lack of precision in both theory and observation. Despite the simplicity of our model, its outputs agree fairly well with galaxy properties inferred from observation. Additionally, we find that most of the parameter values are similar between galaxies. We extend the model to predict the magnetic field pitch angles arising from a combination of mean-field dynamo action and the winding up of the random small-scale field owing to the large-scale radial shear. We find their magnitudes to be much smaller than those of the pitch angles measured in polarized radio and far-infrared emission. This suggests that effects not included in our model, such as effects associated with spiral arms, are needed to explain the pitch angle values.
- 24 July 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 988 (2) , 197
Open AccessGalactic Magnetic Fields. II. Applying the Model to Nearby Galaxies
Many spiral galaxies host magnetic fields with energy densities comparable to those of the turbulent and thermal motions of their interstellar gas. However, quantitative comparison between magnetic field properties inferred from observation and those obtained from theoretical modeling has been lacking. In L. Chamandy et al. (Paper I), we developed a simple, axisymmetric galactic dynamo model that uses various observational data as input. Here, we apply our model to calculate radial profiles of azimuthally and vertically averaged magnetic field strength and pitch angle, gas velocity dispersion and scale height, turbulent correlation time and length, and the sizes of supernova remnants for the galaxies M31, M33, M51, and NGC 6946, using input data collected from the literature. Scaling factors are introduced to account for a lack of precision in both theory and observation. Despite the simplicity of our model, its outputs agree fairly well with galaxy properties inferred from observation. Additionally, we find that most of the parameter values are similar between galaxies. We extend the model to predict the magnetic field pitch angles arising from a combination of mean-field dynamo action and the winding up of the random small-scale field owing to the large-scale radial shear. We find their magnitudes to be much smaller than those of the pitch angles measured in polarized radio and far-infrared emission. This suggests that effects not included in our model, such as effects associated with spiral arms, are needed to explain the pitch angle values.
- Open Access
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia
- Vol. 42, e027
Second-generation planet formation after tidal disruption from common envelope evolution
We propose that certain white dwarf (WD) planets, such as WD 1856+534 b, may form out of material from a stellar companion that tidally disrupts from common envelope evolution with the WD progenitor star. The disrupted companion shreds into an accretion disc, out of which a gas giant protoplanet forms due to gravitational instability. To explore this scenario, we make use of detailed stellar evolution models consistent with WD 1856+534. The minimum mass companion that produces a gravitationally unstable disc after tidal disruption is $\sim$ $0.15\,\mathrm{M_\odot}$ . In this scenario, WD 1856+534 b might have formed at or close to its present separation, in contrast to other proposed scenarios where it would have migrated in from a much larger separation. Planet formation from tidal disruption is a new channel for producing second-generation planets around WDs.- 25 February 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia
- Vol. 42, e027
Open AccessSecond-generation planet formation after tidal disruption from common envelope evolution
We propose that certain white dwarf (WD) planets, such as WD 1856+534 b, may form out of material from a stellar companion that tidally disrupts from common envelope evolution with the WD progenitor star. The disrupted companion shreds into an accretion disc, out of which a gas giant protoplanet forms due to gravitational instability. To explore this scenario, we make use of detailed stellar evolution models consistent with WD 1856+534. The minimum mass companion that produces a gravitationally unstable disc after tidal disruption is $\sim$ $0.15\,\mathrm{M_\odot}$ . In this scenario, WD 1856+534 b might have formed at or close to its present separation, in contrast to other proposed scenarios where it would have migrated in from a much larger separation. Planet formation from tidal disruption is a new channel for producing second-generation planets around WDs. - Open Access
- 17 June 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 532 (2) , 1504-1521
Understanding the radio luminosity function of star-forming galaxies and its cosmological evolution
We explore the redshift evolution of the radio luminosity function (RLF) of star-forming galaxies using galform, a semi-analytic model of galaxy formation and a dynamo model of the magnetic field evolving in a galaxy. Assuming energy equipartition between the magnetic field and cosmic rays, we derive the synchrotron luminosity of each sample galaxy. In a model where the turbulent speed is correlated with the star formation rate, the RLF is in fair agreement with observations in the redshift range 0 ≤ z ≤ 2. At larger redshifts, the structure of galaxies, their interstellar matter and turbulence appear to be rather different from those at z ≲ 2, so that the turbulence and magnetic field models applicable at low redshifts become inadequate. The strong redshift evolution of the RLF at 0 ≤ z ≤ 2 can be attributed to an increased number, at high redshift, of galaxies with large disc volumes and strong magnetic fields. On the other hand, in models where the turbulent speed is a constant or an explicit function of z, the observed redshift evolution of the RLF is poorly captured. The evolution of the interstellar turbulence and outflow parameters appear to be major (but not the only) drivers of the RLF changes. We find that both the small- and large-scale magnetic fields contribute to the RLF but the small-scale field dominates at high redshifts. Polarisation observations will therefore be important to distinguish these two components and understand better the evolution of galaxies and their nonthermal constituents.
- 17 June 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 532 (2) , 1504-1521
Open AccessUnderstanding the radio luminosity function of star-forming galaxies and its cosmological evolution
We explore the redshift evolution of the radio luminosity function (RLF) of star-forming galaxies using galform, a semi-analytic model of galaxy formation and a dynamo model of the magnetic field evolving in a galaxy. Assuming energy equipartition between the magnetic field and cosmic rays, we derive the synchrotron luminosity of each sample galaxy. In a model where the turbulent speed is correlated with the star formation rate, the RLF is in fair agreement with observations in the redshift range 0 ≤ z ≤ 2. At larger redshifts, the structure of galaxies, their interstellar matter and turbulence appear to be rather different from those at z ≲ 2, so that the turbulence and magnetic field models applicable at low redshifts become inadequate. The strong redshift evolution of the RLF at 0 ≤ z ≤ 2 can be attributed to an increased number, at high redshift, of galaxies with large disc volumes and strong magnetic fields. On the other hand, in models where the turbulent speed is a constant or an explicit function of z, the observed redshift evolution of the RLF is poorly captured. The evolution of the interstellar turbulence and outflow parameters appear to be major (but not the only) drivers of the RLF changes. We find that both the small- and large-scale magnetic fields contribute to the RLF but the small-scale field dominates at high redshifts. Polarisation observations will therefore be important to distinguish these two components and understand better the evolution of galaxies and their nonthermal constituents.
- Open Access
- 26 April 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 966 (1) , 78
Galactic Magnetic Fields. I. Theoretical Model and Scaling Relations
Galactic dynamo models have generally relied on input parameters that are very challenging to constrain. We address this problem by developing a model that uses observable quantities as input: the galaxy rotation curve, the surface densities of the gas, stars and star formation rate, and the gas temperature. The model can be used to estimate parameters of the random and mean components of the magnetic field, as well as the gas scale height, root-mean-square velocity and the correlation length and time of the interstellar turbulence, in terms of the observables. We use our model to derive theoretical scaling relations for the quantities of interest, finding reasonable agreement with empirical scaling relations inferred from observation. We assess the dependence of the results on different assumptions about turbulence driving, finding that agreement with observations is improved by explicitly modeling the expansion and energetics of supernova remnants. The model is flexible enough to include alternative prescriptions for the physical processes involved, and we provide links to two open-source python programs that implement it.
- 26 April 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 966 (1) , 78
Open AccessGalactic Magnetic Fields. I. Theoretical Model and Scaling Relations
Galactic dynamo models have generally relied on input parameters that are very challenging to constrain. We address this problem by developing a model that uses observable quantities as input: the galaxy rotation curve, the surface densities of the gas, stars and star formation rate, and the gas temperature. The model can be used to estimate parameters of the random and mean components of the magnetic field, as well as the gas scale height, root-mean-square velocity and the correlation length and time of the interstellar turbulence, in terms of the observables. We use our model to derive theoretical scaling relations for the quantities of interest, finding reasonable agreement with empirical scaling relations inferred from observation. We assess the dependence of the results on different assumptions about turbulence driving, finding that agreement with observations is improved by explicitly modeling the expansion and energetics of supernova remnants. The model is flexible enough to include alternative prescriptions for the physical processes involved, and we provide links to two open-source python programs that implement it.
- Open Access
Galactic magnetic fields I. Theoretical model and scaling relations
Galactic dynamo models have generally relied on input parameters that are very challenging to constrain. We address this problem by developing a model that uses observable quantities as input: the galaxy rotation curve, the surface densities of the gas, stars and star formation rate, and the gas temperature. The model can be used to estimate parameters of the random and mean components of the magnetic field, as well as the gas scale height, root-mean-square velocity and the correlation length and time of the interstellar turbulence, in terms of the observables. We use our model to derive theoretical scaling relations for the quantities of interest, finding reasonable agreement with empirical scaling relations inferred from observation. We assess the dependence of the results on different assumptions about turbulence driving, finding that agreement with observations is improved by explicitly modeling the expansion and energetics of supernova remnants. The model is flexible enough to include alternative prescriptions for the physical processes involved, and we provide links to two open-source PYTHON programs that implement it.
Open AccessGalactic magnetic fields I. Theoretical model and scaling relations
Galactic dynamo models have generally relied on input parameters that are very challenging to constrain. We address this problem by developing a model that uses observable quantities as input: the galaxy rotation curve, the surface densities of the gas, stars and star formation rate, and the gas temperature. The model can be used to estimate parameters of the random and mean components of the magnetic field, as well as the gas scale height, root-mean-square velocity and the correlation length and time of the interstellar turbulence, in terms of the observables. We use our model to derive theoretical scaling relations for the quantities of interest, finding reasonable agreement with empirical scaling relations inferred from observation. We assess the dependence of the results on different assumptions about turbulence driving, finding that agreement with observations is improved by explicitly modeling the expansion and energetics of supernova remnants. The model is flexible enough to include alternative prescriptions for the physical processes involved, and we provide links to two open-source PYTHON programs that implement it.
- Open Access
- 8 January 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 528 (1) , 234-254
How negative feedback and the ambient environment limit the influence of recombination in common envelope evolution
We perform 3D hydrodynamical simulations to study recombination and ionization during the common envelope (CE) phase of binary evolution, and develop techniques to track the ionic transitions in time and space. We simulate the interaction of a $2\, \mathrm{M_\odot }$ red giant branch primary and a $1\, \mathrm{M_\odot }$ companion modelled as a particle. We compare a run employing a tabulated equation of state (EOS) that accounts for ionization and recombination, with a run employing an ideal gas EOS. During the first half of the simulations, ∼15 per cent more mass is unbound in the tabulated EOS run due to the release of recombination energy, but by simulation end the difference has become negligible. We explain this as being a consequence of (i) the tabulated EOS run experiences a shallower inspiral and hence smaller orbital energy release at late times because recombination energy release expands the envelope and reduces drag, and (ii) collision and mixing between expanding envelope gas, ejecta and circumstellar ambient gas assists in unbinding the envelope, but does so less efficiently in the tabulated EOS run where some of the energy transferred to bound envelope gas is used for ionization. The rate of mass unbinding is approximately constant in the last half of the simulations and the orbital separation steadily decreases at late times. A simple linear extrapolation predicts a CE phase duration of ${\sim}2\, {\rm yr}$, after which the envelope would be unbound.- 8 January 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 528 (1) , 234-254
Open AccessHow negative feedback and the ambient environment limit the influence of recombination in common envelope evolution
We perform 3D hydrodynamical simulations to study recombination and ionization during the common envelope (CE) phase of binary evolution, and develop techniques to track the ionic transitions in time and space. We simulate the interaction of a $2\, \mathrm{M_\odot }$ red giant branch primary and a $1\, \mathrm{M_\odot }$ companion modelled as a particle. We compare a run employing a tabulated equation of state (EOS) that accounts for ionization and recombination, with a run employing an ideal gas EOS. During the first half of the simulations, ∼15 per cent more mass is unbound in the tabulated EOS run due to the release of recombination energy, but by simulation end the difference has become negligible. We explain this as being a consequence of (i) the tabulated EOS run experiences a shallower inspiral and hence smaller orbital energy release at late times because recombination energy release expands the envelope and reduces drag, and (ii) collision and mixing between expanding envelope gas, ejecta and circumstellar ambient gas assists in unbinding the envelope, but does so less efficiently in the tabulated EOS run where some of the energy transferred to bound envelope gas is used for ionization. The rate of mass unbinding is approximately constant in the last half of the simulations and the orbital separation steadily decreases at late times. A simple linear extrapolation predicts a CE phase duration of ${\sim}2\, {\rm yr}$, after which the envelope would be unbound. - Open Access
How negative feedback and the ambient environment limit the influence of recombination in common envelope evolution
We perform 3D hydrodynamical simulations to study recombination and ionization during the common envelope (CE) phase of binary evolution, and develop techniques to track the ionic transitions in time and space. We simulate the interaction of a $2\,M_\odot$ red giant branch primary and a $1\,M_\odot$ companion modeled as a particle. We compare a run employing a tabulated equation of state (EOS) that accounts for ionization and recombination, with a run employing an ideal gas EOS. During the first half of the simulations, $\sim15$ per cent more mass is unbound in the tabulated EOS run due to the release of recombination energy, but by simulation end the difference has become negligible. We explain this as being a consequence of (i) the tabulated EOS run experiences a shallower inspiral and hence smaller orbital energy release at late times because recombination energy release expands the envelope and reduces drag, and (ii) collision and mixing between expanding envelope gas, ejecta and circumstellar ambient gas assists in unbinding the envelope, but does so less efficiently in the tabulated EOS run where some of the energy transferred to bound envelope gas is used for ionization. The rate of mass unbinding is approximately constant in the last half of the simulations and the orbital separation steadily decreases at late times. A simple linear extrapolation predicts a CE phase duration of $\sim2\,\mathrm{yr}$, after which the envelope would be unbound.Open AccessHow negative feedback and the ambient environment limit the influence of recombination in common envelope evolution
We perform 3D hydrodynamical simulations to study recombination and ionization during the common envelope (CE) phase of binary evolution, and develop techniques to track the ionic transitions in time and space. We simulate the interaction of a $2\,M_\odot$ red giant branch primary and a $1\,M_\odot$ companion modeled as a particle. We compare a run employing a tabulated equation of state (EOS) that accounts for ionization and recombination, with a run employing an ideal gas EOS. During the first half of the simulations, $\sim15$ per cent more mass is unbound in the tabulated EOS run due to the release of recombination energy, but by simulation end the difference has become negligible. We explain this as being a consequence of (i) the tabulated EOS run experiences a shallower inspiral and hence smaller orbital energy release at late times because recombination energy release expands the envelope and reduces drag, and (ii) collision and mixing between expanding envelope gas, ejecta and circumstellar ambient gas assists in unbinding the envelope, but does so less efficiently in the tabulated EOS run where some of the energy transferred to bound envelope gas is used for ionization. The rate of mass unbinding is approximately constant in the last half of the simulations and the orbital separation steadily decreases at late times. A simple linear extrapolation predicts a CE phase duration of $\sim2\,\mathrm{yr}$, after which the envelope would be unbound.