Robert Huber
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Robert Huber has a total of 89 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anusuriya Devaraju
Mineral Resources, CSIRO, Perth, WA; TERN, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD
5 shared publications - Jens Klump
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, Mineral Resources
4 shared publications Hans Lauterbach
Independent Researcher Traunreut Germany
2 shared publications- Michael Diepenbroek
University of Bremen (UniHB)
2 shared publications Robert Darga
MammutMuseum Siegsdorf Siegsdorf Germany
2 shared publications- Uwe Schindler
MARUM, Center for Marine Environmental Sciences, University of Bremen, Bremen, 28359, Germany
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 21 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (11) , 2804-2815
The craters that never were: Anthropogenic origins of alleged impact structures in the Chiemgau region
Public fascination with impact craters often drives bold speculations, but rigorous verification is critical. In southeastern Bavaria, numerous depressions have been proposed to represent impact craters associated with a catastrophic event in Celtic times (between 900 BC and 600 BC)—the so called “Chiemgau Impact.” To date, the evidence presented in support of the proposed Chiemgau Impact has not been independently validated as diagnostic of a confirmed impact event, and this interpretation has been repeatedly challenged in the scientific literature. More recently, numerous newly identified, predominantly small‐scale structures have been presented as further evidence supporting this claim. Many, however, lack precise geographic information, complicating independent verification. We localized and critically examined these structures in the field as well as using publicly available high‐resolution LIDAR data, aerial imagery (historic and recent), and development plans. The majority of these images show structures which are demonstrably anthropogenic, including gravel pits, WWII bomb craters, retention basins, and—most notably—golf course features such as bunkers and ponds. Other depressions correspond to glacial landforms characteristic of the Inn‐Chiemsee foreland. None of the structures examined exhibit characteristics that would support a formation by a cosmic impact. The repeated misinterpretation of recently constructed golf course elements as impact craters highlights a striking lack of methodological rigor and illustrates how extraordinary claims can arise from neglecting simple cross‐checks with publicly available geospatial and planning data and indicates that the postulated impact in Chiemgau belongs to the realm of myths.
- 21 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (11) , 2804-2815
Open AccessThe craters that never were: Anthropogenic origins of alleged impact structures in the Chiemgau region
Public fascination with impact craters often drives bold speculations, but rigorous verification is critical. In southeastern Bavaria, numerous depressions have been proposed to represent impact craters associated with a catastrophic event in Celtic times (between 900 BC and 600 BC)—the so called “Chiemgau Impact.” To date, the evidence presented in support of the proposed Chiemgau Impact has not been independently validated as diagnostic of a confirmed impact event, and this interpretation has been repeatedly challenged in the scientific literature. More recently, numerous newly identified, predominantly small‐scale structures have been presented as further evidence supporting this claim. Many, however, lack precise geographic information, complicating independent verification. We localized and critically examined these structures in the field as well as using publicly available high‐resolution LIDAR data, aerial imagery (historic and recent), and development plans. The majority of these images show structures which are demonstrably anthropogenic, including gravel pits, WWII bomb craters, retention basins, and—most notably—golf course features such as bunkers and ponds. Other depressions correspond to glacial landforms characteristic of the Inn‐Chiemsee foreland. None of the structures examined exhibit characteristics that would support a formation by a cosmic impact. The repeated misinterpretation of recently constructed golf course elements as impact craters highlights a striking lack of methodological rigor and illustrates how extraordinary claims can arise from neglecting simple cross‐checks with publicly available geospatial and planning data and indicates that the postulated impact in Chiemgau belongs to the realm of myths.
- Open Access
- 12 August 2026
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Data Science Journal
- Vol. 25 (1)
A Semantic Web Model for Standardizing FAIR Metrics and Assessment Results
This study proposes a web standards-based semantic model for representing FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) metrics and FAIR assessment results. Building on existing recommendations for the publication of data quality information on the Web, in particular the W3C Data Quality Vocabulary (DQV) and related ontologies, we examine to what extent these standards are applicable to FAIR assessments. Based on a comparative analysis of the output formats of existing FAIR assessment tools, we identify core requirements for a harmonized representation of FAIR metrics and results. On this basis, we propose a semantic model that integrates established vocabularies to describe both FAIR metrics and their corresponding assessment outcomes. The model is presented together with an exemplary implementation for the F-UJI assessment tool and demonstrates how web standards can support holistic, machine-actionable analyses of FAIR assessments across different tools.
- 12 August 2026
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Data Science Journal
- Vol. 25 (1)
Open AccessA Semantic Web Model for Standardizing FAIR Metrics and Assessment Results
This study proposes a web standards-based semantic model for representing FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) metrics and FAIR assessment results. Building on existing recommendations for the publication of data quality information on the Web, in particular the W3C Data Quality Vocabulary (DQV) and related ontologies, we examine to what extent these standards are applicable to FAIR assessments. Based on a comparative analysis of the output formats of existing FAIR assessment tools, we identify core requirements for a harmonized representation of FAIR metrics and results. On this basis, we propose a semantic model that integrates established vocabularies to describe both FAIR metrics and their corresponding assessment outcomes. The model is presented together with an exemplary implementation for the F-UJI assessment tool and demonstrates how web standards can support holistic, machine-actionable analyses of FAIR assessments across different tools.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Identifying the Essentials: Distributed Resilience for Safeguarding Scientific Data in Times of Uncertainty
The long-term sustainability of data repositories in the Earth and environmental sciences is increasingly influenced by evolving institutional priorities, fluctuating funding, and shifting governance frameworks. Recent events have highlighted the vulnerabilities in the continued accessibility of major US-based climate and environmental datasets, particularly in the context of political shifts, underscoring the fragility of even well-established infrastructures. Against this backdrop, we propose a multi-level, network-oriented model for strengthening the resilience of Earth and environmental data infrastructures. This model, in addition to enhancing the self-healing capabilities of individual repositories, aims to establish a common framework for cooperative stewardship.Until recently, frameworks like Core Trust Seal and the Repository Crisis Scorecards, developed by the ESIP Repositories Resilience Project, have focused on risk assessment and mitigation and some resilience, but less on recovery. Resilience is conceptualised in our approach as the coordinated interaction of several layers that collectively enhance the “rescuability” of essential scientific data. It includes networks of mutual support, in which repositories proactively coordinate to prepare for and respond to operational crises, sharing responsibilities to reduce the risk of isolated failures; harmonized technologies and standards, common protocols, and training, enabling efficient creation of rescue-ready data packages; a structured validation and stress-testing framework to assess vulnerabilities using transparent, scenario-based criteria; and a contingency layer providing shared resources, such as temporary storage or hosting, deliberately reserved to support other repositories, and enabling distributed, peer-to-peer style replication workflows that allow data to remain accessible even when local systems cannot operate fully. A further component of this approach is the prioritisation of critical or at-risk datasets, ensuring that limited rescue capacity is directed toward collections whose loss would most severely affect research continuity and societal monitoring needs.We illustrate this approach with examples from existing Earth and environmental science repositories, and argue that even small and mid-sized infrastructures can benefit from strategies that preserve core data and metadata, even if complete restoration of complex interfaces or ingestion pipelines might be impractical. Given the heterogeneity, scale, and long-term relevance of environmental data, developing tiered, distributed resilience strategies is essential for maintaining scientific continuity in an era of increasing systemic uncertainty.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessIdentifying the Essentials: Distributed Resilience for Safeguarding Scientific Data in Times of Uncertainty
The long-term sustainability of data repositories in the Earth and environmental sciences is increasingly influenced by evolving institutional priorities, fluctuating funding, and shifting governance frameworks. Recent events have highlighted the vulnerabilities in the continued accessibility of major US-based climate and environmental datasets, particularly in the context of political shifts, underscoring the fragility of even well-established infrastructures. Against this backdrop, we propose a multi-level, network-oriented model for strengthening the resilience of Earth and environmental data infrastructures. This model, in addition to enhancing the self-healing capabilities of individual repositories, aims to establish a common framework for cooperative stewardship.Until recently, frameworks like Core Trust Seal and the Repository Crisis Scorecards, developed by the ESIP Repositories Resilience Project, have focused on risk assessment and mitigation and some resilience, but less on recovery. Resilience is conceptualised in our approach as the coordinated interaction of several layers that collectively enhance the “rescuability” of essential scientific data. It includes networks of mutual support, in which repositories proactively coordinate to prepare for and respond to operational crises, sharing responsibilities to reduce the risk of isolated failures; harmonized technologies and standards, common protocols, and training, enabling efficient creation of rescue-ready data packages; a structured validation and stress-testing framework to assess vulnerabilities using transparent, scenario-based criteria; and a contingency layer providing shared resources, such as temporary storage or hosting, deliberately reserved to support other repositories, and enabling distributed, peer-to-peer style replication workflows that allow data to remain accessible even when local systems cannot operate fully. A further component of this approach is the prioritisation of critical or at-risk datasets, ensuring that limited rescue capacity is directed toward collections whose loss would most severely affect research continuity and societal monitoring needs.We illustrate this approach with examples from existing Earth and environmental science repositories, and argue that even small and mid-sized infrastructures can benefit from strategies that preserve core data and metadata, even if complete restoration of complex interfaces or ingestion pipelines might be impractical. Given the heterogeneity, scale, and long-term relevance of environmental data, developing tiered, distributed resilience strategies is essential for maintaining scientific continuity in an era of increasing systemic uncertainty.
- Open Access
- 28 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Journal of Micropalaeontology
- Vol. 44 (1) , 145-168
Community guidelines to increase the reusability of marine microfossil assemblage data
Data on marine microfossil assemblage composition have multiple applications. Initially, they were primarily used for (chrono)stratigraphy and palaeoecology, but these data are now also widely used to study evolutionary and ecological processes, such as past biodiversity and its links with environmental dynamics, or to provide a basis for conservation efforts and biomonitoring. The large range of potential applications renders microfossil abundance data ideal for reuse. However, the complexity inherent in taxonomic data, which encompass extant and extinct species, coupled with the inherent intricacies of information on biological communities extracted from sedimentary archives, poses considerable hurdles in reusing marine microfossil data, even when they are publicly available. Here, we present guidelines derived from an online survey conducted within the marine micropalaeontological community, aimed at improving the reusability of microfossil assemblage data. These guidelines advocate for clarity and transparency in the documentation of the methods and the outcome, and we outline the data attributes required for effective reuse of micropalaeontological data. These guidelines are intended for researchers who generate microfossil abundance datasets and for reviewers, editors, and data curators at repositories. A total of 113 researchers evaluated the relevance of about 50 data attributes that might be needed to enable and maximise the reuse of marine microfossil abundance datasets. Each property is ranked based on the survey results. All information is, in principle, considered “desired”. Information that improves the reusability is ranked as “recommended”, and information that is required for reuse is ranked as “essential”. Analysis of a selection of datasets available online reveals a rather large gap between data properties deemed essential by survey participants and what is actually contained in publicly available microfossil assemblage datasets. While the survey indicates that the micropalaeontological community values good data stewardship, improving data reusability still requires new efforts to incorporate all the essential information. The guidelines presented here are intended as a step in that direction. Determining the optimal forms and formats for data sharing are obvious next steps the community needs to take.
- 28 May 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Journal of Micropalaeontology
- Vol. 44 (1) , 145-168
Open AccessCommunity guidelines to increase the reusability of marine microfossil assemblage data
Data on marine microfossil assemblage composition have multiple applications. Initially, they were primarily used for (chrono)stratigraphy and palaeoecology, but these data are now also widely used to study evolutionary and ecological processes, such as past biodiversity and its links with environmental dynamics, or to provide a basis for conservation efforts and biomonitoring. The large range of potential applications renders microfossil abundance data ideal for reuse. However, the complexity inherent in taxonomic data, which encompass extant and extinct species, coupled with the inherent intricacies of information on biological communities extracted from sedimentary archives, poses considerable hurdles in reusing marine microfossil data, even when they are publicly available. Here, we present guidelines derived from an online survey conducted within the marine micropalaeontological community, aimed at improving the reusability of microfossil assemblage data. These guidelines advocate for clarity and transparency in the documentation of the methods and the outcome, and we outline the data attributes required for effective reuse of micropalaeontological data. These guidelines are intended for researchers who generate microfossil abundance datasets and for reviewers, editors, and data curators at repositories. A total of 113 researchers evaluated the relevance of about 50 data attributes that might be needed to enable and maximise the reuse of marine microfossil abundance datasets. Each property is ranked based on the survey results. All information is, in principle, considered “desired”. Information that improves the reusability is ranked as “recommended”, and information that is required for reuse is ranked as “essential”. Analysis of a selection of datasets available online reveals a rather large gap between data properties deemed essential by survey participants and what is actually contained in publicly available microfossil assemblage datasets. While the survey indicates that the micropalaeontological community values good data stewardship, improving data reusability still requires new efforts to incorporate all the essential information. The guidelines presented here are intended as a step in that direction. Determining the optimal forms and formats for data sharing are obvious next steps the community needs to take.
- Open Access
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Opportunities and limitations of applied FAIR evaluation of data sets
Since their development, the FAIR principles have been met with broad acceptance in the scientific community. Tools based on various approaches are available to assess the FAIRness of individual data sets. These range from qualitative assessments based on questionnaires to automated quantitative measurements of fairness. As the FAIR principles are rather vaguely formulated, these approaches are based on individual, often differing, interpretations of the FAIR principles. In addition, the authors of the FAIR principles explicitly recognize the different implementations of FAIR within the various specialist communities. This makes it necessary to develop community-specific metrics and tests and to adapt FAIR assessment tools accordingly.This diversity of methods for assessing FAIR is encouraging, as it sheds light on a variety of aspects of FAIR. However, this also sometimes leads to different, divergent results from these tools, which is difficult for users to work with. In addition, the measurement of FAIRness of individual datasets is heavily dependent on various technical implementations on the part of the data providers and their service providers. Numerous, possibly unintentional restrictions on the accessibility of datasets can influence or falsify FAIR measurements. In this presentation, we would like to report on our experiences with the applied FAIR assessment within this context. We will report on the further development of F-UJI, in particular our experiences with discipline-specific FAIR metrics and their implementation. Furthermore, we will discuss the limitations of FAIR measurements and try to delineate FAIR from aspects of data quality and accessibility and how to derive informative holistic assessments of datasets that include all these aspects in the future.
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessOpportunities and limitations of applied FAIR evaluation of data sets
Since their development, the FAIR principles have been met with broad acceptance in the scientific community. Tools based on various approaches are available to assess the FAIRness of individual data sets. These range from qualitative assessments based on questionnaires to automated quantitative measurements of fairness. As the FAIR principles are rather vaguely formulated, these approaches are based on individual, often differing, interpretations of the FAIR principles. In addition, the authors of the FAIR principles explicitly recognize the different implementations of FAIR within the various specialist communities. This makes it necessary to develop community-specific metrics and tests and to adapt FAIR assessment tools accordingly.This diversity of methods for assessing FAIR is encouraging, as it sheds light on a variety of aspects of FAIR. However, this also sometimes leads to different, divergent results from these tools, which is difficult for users to work with. In addition, the measurement of FAIRness of individual datasets is heavily dependent on various technical implementations on the part of the data providers and their service providers. Numerous, possibly unintentional restrictions on the accessibility of datasets can influence or falsify FAIR measurements. In this presentation, we would like to report on our experiences with the applied FAIR assessment within this context. We will report on the further development of F-UJI, in particular our experiences with discipline-specific FAIR metrics and their implementation. Furthermore, we will discuss the limitations of FAIR measurements and try to delineate FAIR from aspects of data quality and accessibility and how to derive informative holistic assessments of datasets that include all these aspects in the future.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Towards Transparent Presentation of FAIR-enabling Data Repository Functions & Characteristics
Identifying, finding and gaining a sufficient overview of the functions and characteristics of data repositories and their catalogues is essential for users of data repositories and catalogues in the environmental and geosciences, as well as in other domains. However, achieving this is not trivial within a reasonable amount of time and effort, especially for less experienced users. This lack of transparent, human- and machine-friendly exposure of essential data repository information impacts many possible stakeholders that need up to date and reliable information about data repositories to serve a broad range of users. These include, for example, search engines and registries such as GEOSS, re3data or FAIRsharing. Researchers need to be able to find FAIR enabling trustworthy repositories to deposit, curate and preserve their own digital objects, as well as to reliably find FAIR data already gathered by others in order to reuse it. Assessment bodies such as CoreTrustSeal need transparent access to data repositories’ functions and characteristics in order to facilitate their certification process. An overview of the data and metadata standards, exchange services and interfaces offered by repositories is essential to data scientists in order to effectively integrate these into their workflows. In this study we present how seemingly self-evident information about how the identity, purpose ('this is a data repository'), mandate and areas of responsibility of data repositories is exposed to humans and machines via websites and/or catalogues. Our findings are that such information is difficult to find and in many cases, machine-readable metadata is not clear, not relevant or missing altogether. We also show that despite all the efforts and successes in developing discipline specific standards over the last decades, these are insufficiently linked to from more domain agnostic standards. This absence of domain specific information in PID systems and search engines makes it to large extent invisible in the FAIR ecosystem. In particular, relevant metadata representations or links to discipline specific, standardised services, such as the Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) suite of services, are rarely exposed.In this paper, we seek to present the simple and effective methods being elaborated within the FAIR-IMPACT project to improve this situation by using existing and emerging methods and standards. To this end, we will show effective ways that repositories can expose services information and standards via typed-link-based sign-posting as currently summarised in the FAIRiCAT approach. We will evaluate the options for implementation across domain-specific metadata as well as domain-independent formats such as DCAT or schema.org and show how they can be used in combination with FAIRiCAT in practice. We will also present methods for exposing the FAIR status of digital objects and the FAIR-enabling and trustworthiness status of data repositories to improve cooperation and information exchange between data repositories, registries, assessment providers and certification authorities.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessTowards Transparent Presentation of FAIR-enabling Data Repository Functions & Characteristics
Identifying, finding and gaining a sufficient overview of the functions and characteristics of data repositories and their catalogues is essential for users of data repositories and catalogues in the environmental and geosciences, as well as in other domains. However, achieving this is not trivial within a reasonable amount of time and effort, especially for less experienced users. This lack of transparent, human- and machine-friendly exposure of essential data repository information impacts many possible stakeholders that need up to date and reliable information about data repositories to serve a broad range of users. These include, for example, search engines and registries such as GEOSS, re3data or FAIRsharing. Researchers need to be able to find FAIR enabling trustworthy repositories to deposit, curate and preserve their own digital objects, as well as to reliably find FAIR data already gathered by others in order to reuse it. Assessment bodies such as CoreTrustSeal need transparent access to data repositories’ functions and characteristics in order to facilitate their certification process. An overview of the data and metadata standards, exchange services and interfaces offered by repositories is essential to data scientists in order to effectively integrate these into their workflows. In this study we present how seemingly self-evident information about how the identity, purpose ('this is a data repository'), mandate and areas of responsibility of data repositories is exposed to humans and machines via websites and/or catalogues. Our findings are that such information is difficult to find and in many cases, machine-readable metadata is not clear, not relevant or missing altogether. We also show that despite all the efforts and successes in developing discipline specific standards over the last decades, these are insufficiently linked to from more domain agnostic standards. This absence of domain specific information in PID systems and search engines makes it to large extent invisible in the FAIR ecosystem. In particular, relevant metadata representations or links to discipline specific, standardised services, such as the Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) suite of services, are rarely exposed.In this paper, we seek to present the simple and effective methods being elaborated within the FAIR-IMPACT project to improve this situation by using existing and emerging methods and standards. To this end, we will show effective ways that repositories can expose services information and standards via typed-link-based sign-posting as currently summarised in the FAIRiCAT approach. We will evaluate the options for implementation across domain-specific metadata as well as domain-independent formats such as DCAT or schema.org and show how they can be used in combination with FAIRiCAT in practice. We will also present methods for exposing the FAIR status of digital objects and the FAIR-enabling and trustworthiness status of data repositories to improve cooperation and information exchange between data repositories, registries, assessment providers and certification authorities.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Implementing FAIR metrics and assessments for the Earth and Environmental Sciences
Although there has been great acceptance across disciplines for years to make research data FAIR (findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable), there is still no consensus in most communities on how to implement this concretely on a discipline-specific basis. Available metrics are exclusively domain agnostic, and there are few approaches to formulate binding metrics and tests specifically for particular domains (e.g. earth and environmental science disciplines) and to implement them in assessment tools.In this presentation, we will introduce new approaches being developed in the FAIR-IMPACT project, based on domain specific use case partners and their communities, including those from the earth and environmental sciences (e.g. collaboration with the communities involved in the FAIR-EASE project), to extend and thus adapt existing FAIR metrics for assessing data objects and the F-UJI FAIR Assessment Tool to more fully incorporate the disciplinary, 'geo' context. A particular focus here will be on incorporating geo-specific metadata standards, covering data formats and semantic artefacts within FAIR metrics, and the detection or verification of these standards by the F-UJI FAIR Assessment Tool. We will finally report also on the collaboration with one of the EIDA Data Centers (as part of the European Infrastructure for seismic waveform data in EPOS) where the F-UJI FAIR Assessment Tool has been further developed to be aware of the very domain specific standard data and metadata as well as services.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessImplementing FAIR metrics and assessments for the Earth and Environmental Sciences
Although there has been great acceptance across disciplines for years to make research data FAIR (findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable), there is still no consensus in most communities on how to implement this concretely on a discipline-specific basis. Available metrics are exclusively domain agnostic, and there are few approaches to formulate binding metrics and tests specifically for particular domains (e.g. earth and environmental science disciplines) and to implement them in assessment tools.In this presentation, we will introduce new approaches being developed in the FAIR-IMPACT project, based on domain specific use case partners and their communities, including those from the earth and environmental sciences (e.g. collaboration with the communities involved in the FAIR-EASE project), to extend and thus adapt existing FAIR metrics for assessing data objects and the F-UJI FAIR Assessment Tool to more fully incorporate the disciplinary, 'geo' context. A particular focus here will be on incorporating geo-specific metadata standards, covering data formats and semantic artefacts within FAIR metrics, and the detection or verification of these standards by the F-UJI FAIR Assessment Tool. We will finally report also on the collaboration with one of the EIDA Data Centers (as part of the European Infrastructure for seismic waveform data in EPOS) where the F-UJI FAIR Assessment Tool has been further developed to be aware of the very domain specific standard data and metadata as well as services.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
An automated solution for measuring the progress toward FAIR research data
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessAn automated solution for measuring the progress toward FAIR research data
- Open Access
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
F-UJI : An Automated Tool for the Assessment and Improvement of the FAIRness of Research Data
Making research data FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable) is critical to maximizing its impact. However, since the FAIR principles are designed as guidelines and do not specify implementation rules, it is difficult to verify the practice of these principles. Therefore, metrics and associated tools need to be developed to enable the assessment of FAIR compliance of services and datasets. Such practical solutions are important for many stakeholders to assess the quality of data-related services. They are important for selecting such services, but can also be used to iteratively improve data offerings, e.g., as part of FAIR advisory processes. With the increasing number of published datasets and the need to test them repeatedly, there is a growing body of literature that recognizes this importance of automated FAIR assessment tools. Our goal is to contribute to this area of FAIR through the development of an open source tool called F-UJI. F-UJI supports programmatic FAIR assessment of research data based on a set of core metrics against which the implementation of FAIR principles can be assessed. This paper presents the development and application of F-UJI and the underlying metrics. For each of the metrics, we have designed and implemented practical tests based on existing standards and best practices for research data. The tests are important to our expanded understanding of how to test FAIR metrics in practice that have not been fully addressed in previous work on FAIR data assessment. We demonstrate the use of the tool by assessing several multidisciplinary datasets from selected trusted digital repositories, followed by recommendations for improving the FAIRness of these datasets. We summarize the experience and lessons learned from the development and testing.
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessF-UJI : An Automated Tool for the Assessment and Improvement of the FAIRness of Research Data
Making research data FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable) is critical to maximizing its impact. However, since the FAIR principles are designed as guidelines and do not specify implementation rules, it is difficult to verify the practice of these principles. Therefore, metrics and associated tools need to be developed to enable the assessment of FAIR compliance of services and datasets. Such practical solutions are important for many stakeholders to assess the quality of data-related services. They are important for selecting such services, but can also be used to iteratively improve data offerings, e.g., as part of FAIR advisory processes. With the increasing number of published datasets and the need to test them repeatedly, there is a growing body of literature that recognizes this importance of automated FAIR assessment tools. Our goal is to contribute to this area of FAIR through the development of an open source tool called F-UJI. F-UJI supports programmatic FAIR assessment of research data based on a set of core metrics against which the implementation of FAIR principles can be assessed. This paper presents the development and application of F-UJI and the underlying metrics. For each of the metrics, we have designed and implemented practical tests based on existing standards and best practices for research data. The tests are important to our expanded understanding of how to test FAIR metrics in practice that have not been fully addressed in previous work on FAIR data assessment. We demonstrate the use of the tool by assessing several multidisciplinary datasets from selected trusted digital repositories, followed by recommendations for improving the FAIRness of these datasets. We summarize the experience and lessons learned from the development and testing.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
The I-ADOPT Interoperability Framework: a proposal for FAIRer observable property descriptions
Global environmental challenges like climate change, pollution, and biodiversity loss are complex. To understand environmental patterns and processes and address these challenges, scientists require the observations of natural phenomena at various temporal and spatial scales and across many domains. The research infrastructures and scientific communities involved in these activities are often following their own data management practices which inevitably leads to a high degree of variability and incompatibility of approaches. Consequently, a variety of metadata standards and vocabularies have been proposed to describe observations and are actively used in different communities. However, this diversity in approaches now causes severe issues regarding the interoperability across datasets and hampers their exploitation as a common data source.Projects like ENVRI-FAIR, FAIRsFAIR, FAIRplus are addressing this difficulty by working on the full integration of services across research infrastructures based on FAIR Guiding Principles supporting the EOSC vision towards an open research culture. Beyond these projects, we need collaboration and community consensus across domains to build a common framework for representing observable properties. The Research Data Alliance InteroperAble Descriptions of Observable Property Terminology Working Group (RDA I-ADOPT WG) was formed in October 2019 to address this need. Its membership covers an international representation of terminology users and terminology providers, including terminology developers, scientists, and data centre managers. The group’s overall objective is to deliver a common interoperability framework for observable property variables within its 18-month work plan. Starting with the collection of user stories from research scientists, terminology managers, and data managers or aggregators, we drafted a set of technical and content-related requirements. A survey of terminology resources and annotation practices provided us with information about almost one hundred terminologies, a subset of which was then analysed to identify existing conceptualisation practices, commonalities, gaps, and overlaps. This was then used to derive a conceptual framework to support their alignment. In this presentation, we will introduce the I-ADOPT Interoperability Framework highlighting its semantic components. These represent the building blocks for specific ontology design patterns addressing different use cases and varying degrees of complexity in describing observed properties. We will demonstrate the proposed design patterns using a number of essential climate and essential biodiversity variables. We will also show examples of how the I-ADOPT framework will support interoperability between existing representations. This work will provide the semantic foundation for the development of more user-friendly data annotation tools capable of suggesting appropriate FAIR terminologies for observable properties.
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessThe I-ADOPT Interoperability Framework: a proposal for FAIRer observable property descriptions
Global environmental challenges like climate change, pollution, and biodiversity loss are complex. To understand environmental patterns and processes and address these challenges, scientists require the observations of natural phenomena at various temporal and spatial scales and across many domains. The research infrastructures and scientific communities involved in these activities are often following their own data management practices which inevitably leads to a high degree of variability and incompatibility of approaches. Consequently, a variety of metadata standards and vocabularies have been proposed to describe observations and are actively used in different communities. However, this diversity in approaches now causes severe issues regarding the interoperability across datasets and hampers their exploitation as a common data source.Projects like ENVRI-FAIR, FAIRsFAIR, FAIRplus are addressing this difficulty by working on the full integration of services across research infrastructures based on FAIR Guiding Principles supporting the EOSC vision towards an open research culture. Beyond these projects, we need collaboration and community consensus across domains to build a common framework for representing observable properties. The Research Data Alliance InteroperAble Descriptions of Observable Property Terminology Working Group (RDA I-ADOPT WG) was formed in October 2019 to address this need. Its membership covers an international representation of terminology users and terminology providers, including terminology developers, scientists, and data centre managers. The group’s overall objective is to deliver a common interoperability framework for observable property variables within its 18-month work plan. Starting with the collection of user stories from research scientists, terminology managers, and data managers or aggregators, we drafted a set of technical and content-related requirements. A survey of terminology resources and annotation practices provided us with information about almost one hundred terminologies, a subset of which was then analysed to identify existing conceptualisation practices, commonalities, gaps, and overlaps. This was then used to derive a conceptual framework to support their alignment. In this presentation, we will introduce the I-ADOPT Interoperability Framework highlighting its semantic components. These represent the building blocks for specific ontology design patterns addressing different use cases and varying degrees of complexity in describing observed properties. We will demonstrate the proposed design patterns using a number of essential climate and essential biodiversity variables. We will also show examples of how the I-ADOPT framework will support interoperability between existing representations. This work will provide the semantic foundation for the development of more user-friendly data annotation tools capable of suggesting appropriate FAIR terminologies for observable properties.