Vojtěch Barták
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Vojtěch Barták has a total of 161 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Vítězslav Moudrý
Czech University of Life Sciences Prague
15 shared publications - Marco Malavasi
Department of Chemistry, Physics, Mathematics and Natural Sciences University of Sassari Sassari Italy
11 shared publications - Duccio Rocchini
BIOME Lab, Department of Biological, Geological and Environmental Sciences Alma Mater Studiorum University of Bologna Bologna Italy
9 shared publications - Kateřina Gdulová
Department of Spatial Sciences Faculty of Environmental Sciences Czech University of Life Sciences Prague Praha Czech Republic
9 shared publications - Lukáš Gábor
Department of Spatial Sciences, Faculty of Environmental Sciences, Czech University of Life Sciences Prague Praha‐Suchdol Czech Republic
7 shared publications - Petra Šímová
Department of Spatial Sciences, Faculty of Environmental Sciences, Czech University of Life Sciences Prague Praha‐Suchdol Czech Republic
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Archaeological Prospection
Deciphering the Palimpsest: Chronological Uncertainty and the Interpretation of Mining Landscapes at Písečný vrch (Czech Republic)
We investigated the Písečný vrch (Czech Republic), a site exploited for quartz mining in both prehistoric times and the 20th century. Due to their morphological similarity across all mining periods, the differentiation between pits with archaeological potential and recent ones is challenging. To reconstruct the recent mining component and provide a basis for non‐destructive pit prioritization, we combined airborne laser scanning, historical aerial photographs and field survey. MaxEnt modelling was then applied to derive a relative Recency Index, expressing the similarity of each pit to independently confirmed recent extraction features. The model achieved a cross‐validated AUC value of 0.691, indicating moderate but practically useful discriminatory ability. Rather than providing definitive chronological classification, the model outputs provide a relative basis for prioritizing pits for further archaeological verification, especially those that are less similar to confirmed recent extraction features and therefore have higher archaeological potential. Using Youden Index optimization, we applied an operational threshold of 0.441 and identified 293 lower‐Recency candidates with higher archaeological potential for future verification. Our results demonstrate the value of this approach for the non‐invasive prioritization of morphologically similar anthropogenic relics and for supporting their heritage protection.
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Archaeological Prospection
Open AccessDeciphering the Palimpsest: Chronological Uncertainty and the Interpretation of Mining Landscapes at Písečný vrch (Czech Republic)
We investigated the Písečný vrch (Czech Republic), a site exploited for quartz mining in both prehistoric times and the 20th century. Due to their morphological similarity across all mining periods, the differentiation between pits with archaeological potential and recent ones is challenging. To reconstruct the recent mining component and provide a basis for non‐destructive pit prioritization, we combined airborne laser scanning, historical aerial photographs and field survey. MaxEnt modelling was then applied to derive a relative Recency Index, expressing the similarity of each pit to independently confirmed recent extraction features. The model achieved a cross‐validated AUC value of 0.691, indicating moderate but practically useful discriminatory ability. Rather than providing definitive chronological classification, the model outputs provide a relative basis for prioritizing pits for further archaeological verification, especially those that are less similar to confirmed recent extraction features and therefore have higher archaeological potential. Using Youden Index optimization, we applied an operational threshold of 0.441 and identified 293 lower‐Recency candidates with higher archaeological potential for future verification. Our results demonstrate the value of this approach for the non‐invasive prioritization of morphologically similar anthropogenic relics and for supporting their heritage protection.
- Open Access
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Ecological Informatics
- Vol. 97
Evaluating the reliability of the 1-meter resolution meta-estimated global canopy height map for estimating forest structural metrics in Alpine environment
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Ecological Informatics
- Vol. 97
Open AccessEvaluating the reliability of the 1-meter resolution meta-estimated global canopy height map for estimating forest structural metrics in Alpine environment
- Open Access
Segmentation and profile-based classification of movement strategies from animal tracking data
Classifying animal movement strategies from GPS tracking data is essential for understanding space use, population dynamics and conservation planning. However, existing approaches either require strong parametric assumptions about trajectory shape, large labelled datasets (i.e. expert-annotated) for machine learning, or lack formal uncertainty quantification. These limitations create barriers for researchers working with novel species or limited sample sizes. We present a profile-based classification framework consisting of three steps. First, trajectories are segmented using breakpoint detection applied to Net Squared Displacement (NSD) time series. Movement metrics are then extracted from each segment and classified by comparing them to empirically derived behavioural profiles via Z-score distances transformed to softmax probabilities. Bootstrap resampling quantifies uncertainty in the resulting classifications from both training and test data. We validated the framework through simulation experiments and applied it to GPS tracking data from two ecologically contrasting species: gray wolf (Canis lupus;43 individuals) and northern lapwing (Vanellus vanellus;15 individuals). Simulations showed that 5–10 training segments per movement strategy suffice for reliable classification, with overall accuracy of 91.1%across residential, floating and dispersal strategies. Segment duration of 30–60 days was required for confident discrimination of residential and floating behaviour. For wolves, the framework clearly distinguished residency, floating or dispersal (91.2%of segments classified with >50%probability). For lapwings, migration was identified with high confidence, while residential–floating discrimination reflected genuine ecological ambiguity confirmed by domain experts, with bootstrap confidence intervals transparently flagging uncertain cases. The profile-based framework provides an accessible, interpretable alternative to parametric NSD fitting and machine learning approach, requiring modest training data while delivering probabilistic classifications with honest uncertainty estimates. An R package (moveprofile) implementing the complete workflow is freely available. The framework is applicable to any tracked species where distinct movement strategies can be identified by experts’ knowledge.
Open AccessSegmentation and profile-based classification of movement strategies from animal tracking data
Classifying animal movement strategies from GPS tracking data is essential for understanding space use, population dynamics and conservation planning. However, existing approaches either require strong parametric assumptions about trajectory shape, large labelled datasets (i.e. expert-annotated) for machine learning, or lack formal uncertainty quantification. These limitations create barriers for researchers working with novel species or limited sample sizes. We present a profile-based classification framework consisting of three steps. First, trajectories are segmented using breakpoint detection applied to Net Squared Displacement (NSD) time series. Movement metrics are then extracted from each segment and classified by comparing them to empirically derived behavioural profiles via Z-score distances transformed to softmax probabilities. Bootstrap resampling quantifies uncertainty in the resulting classifications from both training and test data. We validated the framework through simulation experiments and applied it to GPS tracking data from two ecologically contrasting species: gray wolf (Canis lupus;43 individuals) and northern lapwing (Vanellus vanellus;15 individuals). Simulations showed that 5–10 training segments per movement strategy suffice for reliable classification, with overall accuracy of 91.1%across residential, floating and dispersal strategies. Segment duration of 30–60 days was required for confident discrimination of residential and floating behaviour. For wolves, the framework clearly distinguished residency, floating or dispersal (91.2%of segments classified with >50%probability). For lapwings, migration was identified with high confidence, while residential–floating discrimination reflected genuine ecological ambiguity confirmed by domain experts, with bootstrap confidence intervals transparently flagging uncertain cases. The profile-based framework provides an accessible, interpretable alternative to parametric NSD fitting and machine learning approach, requiring modest training data while delivering probabilistic classifications with honest uncertainty estimates. An R package (moveprofile) implementing the complete workflow is freely available. The framework is applicable to any tracked species where distinct movement strategies can be identified by experts’ knowledge.
- Open Access
- 16 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Global Ecology and Biogeography
- Vol. 35 (3) , e70221
Spatial Autocorrelation of Species Diversity and Distributions in Time and Across Spatial Scales
Aim: Spatial autocorrelation (SAC), also known as aggregation or clumping, reflects species niche and dispersal, has conservation significance, and affects ecological models. Yet, we know little about the spatial and temporal patterns of SAC in empirical data. Here, we quantify the magnitude, spatial scaling, and temporal change of SAC in both species distributions and richness across multiple regions. Location: Czechia, Europe, New York State, Japan. Time Period: 1972–2017. Major Taxa Studied: Birds. Methods: We analysed four temporally replicated bird atlases, each aggregated to multiple spatial grains. We used Moran's I to quantify the SAC of richness and the Join count statistic (JC) for species distributions. We assessed changes in SAC across time and spatial scales, the relationship between temporal changes in SAC and occupancy, and whether habitat association, trophic level, or dispersal ability influenced temporal SAC dynamics. Results: Species distributions and diversity consistently showed positive SAC across all regions, periods, and grain sizes, with its magnitude declining at coarser grains. SAC showed no overall temporal trend, despite varying responses across species. However, joint temporal changes in JC and occupancy revealed systematic patterns: declining species became more aggregated (clumped) while expanding species became more fragmented (disjoint) than expected from occupancy change alone. Trait effects were overall weak—dispersal ability showed no influence, whereas the ranges of open‐habitat species in Japan and herbivores in Japan and Europe became slightly more fragmented than expected. Main Conclusions: Stronger SAC at finer grains suggests greater predictability of diversity and distributions at these scales. Despite zero average change in occupancy or SAC, their coupled shifts highlight the importance of considering both jointly. We found that non‐adjacent colonisations and extirpations are major drivers of range dynamics in temperate birds. The limited role of traits suggests that extrinsic environmental and spatial factors dominate large‐scale SAC dynamics.
- 16 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Global Ecology and Biogeography
- Vol. 35 (3) , e70221
Open AccessSpatial Autocorrelation of Species Diversity and Distributions in Time and Across Spatial Scales
Aim: Spatial autocorrelation (SAC), also known as aggregation or clumping, reflects species niche and dispersal, has conservation significance, and affects ecological models. Yet, we know little about the spatial and temporal patterns of SAC in empirical data. Here, we quantify the magnitude, spatial scaling, and temporal change of SAC in both species distributions and richness across multiple regions. Location: Czechia, Europe, New York State, Japan. Time Period: 1972–2017. Major Taxa Studied: Birds. Methods: We analysed four temporally replicated bird atlases, each aggregated to multiple spatial grains. We used Moran's I to quantify the SAC of richness and the Join count statistic (JC) for species distributions. We assessed changes in SAC across time and spatial scales, the relationship between temporal changes in SAC and occupancy, and whether habitat association, trophic level, or dispersal ability influenced temporal SAC dynamics. Results: Species distributions and diversity consistently showed positive SAC across all regions, periods, and grain sizes, with its magnitude declining at coarser grains. SAC showed no overall temporal trend, despite varying responses across species. However, joint temporal changes in JC and occupancy revealed systematic patterns: declining species became more aggregated (clumped) while expanding species became more fragmented (disjoint) than expected from occupancy change alone. Trait effects were overall weak—dispersal ability showed no influence, whereas the ranges of open‐habitat species in Japan and herbivores in Japan and Europe became slightly more fragmented than expected. Main Conclusions: Stronger SAC at finer grains suggests greater predictability of diversity and distributions at these scales. Despite zero average change in occupancy or SAC, their coupled shifts highlight the importance of considering both jointly. We found that non‐adjacent colonisations and extirpations are major drivers of range dynamics in temperate birds. The limited role of traits suggests that extrinsic environmental and spatial factors dominate large‐scale SAC dynamics.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 7 January 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Earth and Space Science
- Vol. 13 (1)
Spaceborne Canopy Height Products Should Be Complemented With Airborne Laser Scanning Data: Toward a European Canopy Height Model
Measuring and mapping vegetation structure is essential for understanding the functioning of terrestrial ecosystems and for informing environmental policies. Recent years have seen a growing demand for high‐resolution data on vegetation structure, driving their prediction at fine resolutions (1–30 m) at state, continental, and global spatial extents by combining satellite data with machine learning. As these initiatives expand, it is crucial to actively discuss the quality and usability of these products. Here, we briefly summarize current efforts to map vegetation structure and show that continental‐to‐global canopy height models (CHMs) exhibit significant errors in canopy heights compared to national airborne laser scanning (ALS) data. We recommend that regions with abundant ALS data, such as Europe, prioritize using ALS‐based canopy height metrics rather than relying on less accurate predictions from satellite products. Despite variations in ALS data characteristics, such as temporal inconsistencies and differences in acquisition characteristics and classification accuracy, the generation of spatially contiguous canopy height products in raster format at fine spatial resolution is necessary and feasible. This requires coordinating efforts for data and survey harmonization, developing standardized processing pipelines and continent‐wide ALS products, and ensuring free access for research and environmental policy. We show that ALS data now cover most of Europe, with newer surveys achieving higher point densities, improving their suitability for vegetation mapping. Beyond numerous applications in forestry, ecology, and conservation, such data sets are crucial for calibrating future Earth Observation missions, making them essential for producing reliable and accurate global, fine‐resolution vegetation structure data.
- 7 January 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Earth and Space Science
- Vol. 13 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessSpaceborne Canopy Height Products Should Be Complemented With Airborne Laser Scanning Data: Toward a European Canopy Height Model
Measuring and mapping vegetation structure is essential for understanding the functioning of terrestrial ecosystems and for informing environmental policies. Recent years have seen a growing demand for high‐resolution data on vegetation structure, driving their prediction at fine resolutions (1–30 m) at state, continental, and global spatial extents by combining satellite data with machine learning. As these initiatives expand, it is crucial to actively discuss the quality and usability of these products. Here, we briefly summarize current efforts to map vegetation structure and show that continental‐to‐global canopy height models (CHMs) exhibit significant errors in canopy heights compared to national airborne laser scanning (ALS) data. We recommend that regions with abundant ALS data, such as Europe, prioritize using ALS‐based canopy height metrics rather than relying on less accurate predictions from satellite products. Despite variations in ALS data characteristics, such as temporal inconsistencies and differences in acquisition characteristics and classification accuracy, the generation of spatially contiguous canopy height products in raster format at fine spatial resolution is necessary and feasible. This requires coordinating efforts for data and survey harmonization, developing standardized processing pipelines and continent‐wide ALS products, and ensuring free access for research and environmental policy. We show that ALS data now cover most of Europe, with newer surveys achieving higher point densities, improving their suitability for vegetation mapping. Beyond numerous applications in forestry, ecology, and conservation, such data sets are crucial for calibrating future Earth Observation missions, making them essential for producing reliable and accurate global, fine‐resolution vegetation structure data.
- Open Access
The time of acquisition of multispectral predictors matters: the role of seasonality in bird species distribution models
Species distribution models (SDMs) analyse the relationships between species occurrences and environmental predictors. Their efficacy largely depends on the selection of ecologically relevant predictors, with remote sensing (RS) data being one of the most commonly used sources. The usability of multispectral predictors is influenced by temporal changes in vegetation and environmental conditions. However, the impact of seasonality is often overlooked, despite its potential to affect model accuracy. This study aims to assess the influence of seasonality in RS predictors on SDM performance for bird species. The study was conducted for an area of the Czech Republic, using presence–absence data from the Breeding Bird Survey (2018–2021) covering 147 survey squares and 104 bird species. We used Sentinel‐2 satellite imagery to derive monthly and full‐season composites of vegetation indices and reflectance bands from March to September (hereafter ‘periods'). Precipitation, terrain, and vegetation structure were also included. SDMs were constructed using Lasso‐regularized logistic regression, and model performance was assessed through area under the ROC curve (AUC) and R². Linear mixed‐effects models were employed to evaluate model performance, temporal prediction stability, and predictor importance stability across all species. Our results show that model performance depends on the period from which the predictors were derived. This dependence varies significantly among species and is partially associated with habitat preferences and prevalence, with forest species exhibiting greater stability. Differences in model performance across periods aligned with shifts in predictor importance, causing different RS predictors to become significant with seasonal changes. In conclusion, seasonal changes in vegetation, as reflected in the temporal variability of RS predictors, significantly affect SDM performance and predictor selection. Although species' ecological characteristics played a role, the effects remained species‐dependent, making it difficult to develop universal recommendations. Nevertheless, accounting for seasonal variations in RS predictors can enhance model accuracy for many species.
Open AccessThe time of acquisition of multispectral predictors matters: the role of seasonality in bird species distribution models
Species distribution models (SDMs) analyse the relationships between species occurrences and environmental predictors. Their efficacy largely depends on the selection of ecologically relevant predictors, with remote sensing (RS) data being one of the most commonly used sources. The usability of multispectral predictors is influenced by temporal changes in vegetation and environmental conditions. However, the impact of seasonality is often overlooked, despite its potential to affect model accuracy. This study aims to assess the influence of seasonality in RS predictors on SDM performance for bird species. The study was conducted for an area of the Czech Republic, using presence–absence data from the Breeding Bird Survey (2018–2021) covering 147 survey squares and 104 bird species. We used Sentinel‐2 satellite imagery to derive monthly and full‐season composites of vegetation indices and reflectance bands from March to September (hereafter ‘periods'). Precipitation, terrain, and vegetation structure were also included. SDMs were constructed using Lasso‐regularized logistic regression, and model performance was assessed through area under the ROC curve (AUC) and R². Linear mixed‐effects models were employed to evaluate model performance, temporal prediction stability, and predictor importance stability across all species. Our results show that model performance depends on the period from which the predictors were derived. This dependence varies significantly among species and is partially associated with habitat preferences and prevalence, with forest species exhibiting greater stability. Differences in model performance across periods aligned with shifts in predictor importance, causing different RS predictors to become significant with seasonal changes. In conclusion, seasonal changes in vegetation, as reflected in the temporal variability of RS predictors, significantly affect SDM performance and predictor selection. Although species' ecological characteristics played a role, the effects remained species‐dependent, making it difficult to develop universal recommendations. Nevertheless, accounting for seasonal variations in RS predictors can enhance model accuracy for many species.
- Open Access
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 62 (7) , 1659-1673
Habitat heterogeneity from lidar and hyperspectral data: Implications for bird guilds and restoration management of coal mines
A global transition of energy production is underway. Coal‐based power production is gradually being replaced by renewable energies, leading to the decommissioning of coal‐mining sites. In Europe, this presents an opportunity for restoring degraded habitats, in alignment with the goals of the Nature Restoration Law. However, systematic approaches to monitoring restoration of mining sites are lacking as current practices are often labour‐intensive and (both spatially and temporally) constrained. In this study, we evaluated the suitability of habitat heterogeneity metrics derived through airborne remote sensing for monitoring the restoration of coal‐mining sites. Specifically, we tested the response of guild‐specific bird species richness to various metrics of habitat heterogeneity, both at and around a restored coal‐mining site. We (i) examined differences in habitat heterogeneity, including terrain characteristics, vegetation structure and senescent vegetation, between restored and surrounding areas; (ii) documented key aspects of habitat heterogeneity that influence bird richness and different bird guilds; and (iii) tested for significant differences among bird responses between restored and surrounding areas. Generalised additive models explained between 19% and 78% of the variability in guild richness. Canopy cover, understory cover, the standard deviation of vegetation height, and senescent vegetation positively affected overall bird richness, while terrain characteristics significantly influenced some guilds (e.g. ground‐nesting birds). The effects of evaluated variables on guild diversity were generally similar in both restored and surrounding areas, with the standard deviation of vegetation height being the only exception. Increasing standard deviation of vegetation height positively affected the richness of understory nesters and foragers in the restored area but had no (or slightly negative) effect in the surrounding area. Synthesis and applications. This study underscores the need to design a mosaic of habitats with complex vertical structures, emphasising the critical role of senescent vegetation and unaltered terrain features in supporting biodiversity. Finally, it provides evidence that integrating habitat heterogeneity metrics derived from airborne remote sensing data into restoration success assessment can support biodiversity‐promoting management measures.
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 62 (7) , 1659-1673
Open AccessHabitat heterogeneity from lidar and hyperspectral data: Implications for bird guilds and restoration management of coal mines
A global transition of energy production is underway. Coal‐based power production is gradually being replaced by renewable energies, leading to the decommissioning of coal‐mining sites. In Europe, this presents an opportunity for restoring degraded habitats, in alignment with the goals of the Nature Restoration Law. However, systematic approaches to monitoring restoration of mining sites are lacking as current practices are often labour‐intensive and (both spatially and temporally) constrained. In this study, we evaluated the suitability of habitat heterogeneity metrics derived through airborne remote sensing for monitoring the restoration of coal‐mining sites. Specifically, we tested the response of guild‐specific bird species richness to various metrics of habitat heterogeneity, both at and around a restored coal‐mining site. We (i) examined differences in habitat heterogeneity, including terrain characteristics, vegetation structure and senescent vegetation, between restored and surrounding areas; (ii) documented key aspects of habitat heterogeneity that influence bird richness and different bird guilds; and (iii) tested for significant differences among bird responses between restored and surrounding areas. Generalised additive models explained between 19% and 78% of the variability in guild richness. Canopy cover, understory cover, the standard deviation of vegetation height, and senescent vegetation positively affected overall bird richness, while terrain characteristics significantly influenced some guilds (e.g. ground‐nesting birds). The effects of evaluated variables on guild diversity were generally similar in both restored and surrounding areas, with the standard deviation of vegetation height being the only exception. Increasing standard deviation of vegetation height positively affected the richness of understory nesters and foragers in the restored area but had no (or slightly negative) effect in the surrounding area. Synthesis and applications. This study underscores the need to design a mosaic of habitats with complex vertical structures, emphasising the critical role of senescent vegetation and unaltered terrain features in supporting biodiversity. Finally, it provides evidence that integrating habitat heterogeneity metrics derived from airborne remote sensing data into restoration success assessment can support biodiversity‐promoting management measures.
- Open Access
- 12 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Landscape Ecology
- Vol. 40 (1) , 1-18
A complex interplay between natural and anthropogenic factors shapes plant diversity patterns in Mediterranean coastal dunes
- 12 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Landscape Ecology
- Vol. 40 (1) , 1-18
Open AccessA complex interplay between natural and anthropogenic factors shapes plant diversity patterns in Mediterranean coastal dunes
- Open Access
- 27 November 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Earth and Space Science
- Vol. 11 (12)
Choosing the Optimal Global Digital Elevation Model for Stream Network Delineation: Beyond Vertical Accuracy
Satellite‐derived global digital elevation models (DEMs) are essential for providing the topographic information needed in a wide range of hydrological applications. However, their use is limited by spatial resolution and vertical bias due to sensor limitations in observing bare terrain. Significant efforts have been made to improve the resolution of global DEMs (e.g., TanDEM‐X) and create bare‐earth DEMs (e.g., FABDEM, MERIT, CEDTM). We evaluated the vertical accuracy of bare‐earth and global DEMs in Central European mountains and submontane regions, and assessed how DEM resolution, vegetation offset removal, land cover, and terrain slope affect stream network delineation. Using lidar‐derived DTM and national stream networks as references, we found that: (a) bare‐earth DEMs outperform global DEMs across all land cover types. RMSEs increased with increasing slope for all DEMs in non‐forest areas. In forests, however, the negative effect of the slope was outweighed by the vegetation offset even for bare‐earth DTMs; (b) the accuracy of derived stream networks was affected by terrain slope and land cover more than by the vertical accuracy of DEMs. Stream network delineation performed poorly in non‐forest areas and relatively well in forests. Increasing slope improved the streams delineation performance; (c) using DEMs with higher resolution (e.g., 12 m TanDEM‐X) improved stream network delineation, but increasing resolution also increased the need for effective vegetation bias removal. Our results indicate that vertical accuracy alone does not reflect how well DEMs perform in stream network delineation. This underscores the need to include stream network performance in DEM quality rankings.
- 27 November 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Earth and Space Science
- Vol. 11 (12)
Open AccessChoosing the Optimal Global Digital Elevation Model for Stream Network Delineation: Beyond Vertical Accuracy
Satellite‐derived global digital elevation models (DEMs) are essential for providing the topographic information needed in a wide range of hydrological applications. However, their use is limited by spatial resolution and vertical bias due to sensor limitations in observing bare terrain. Significant efforts have been made to improve the resolution of global DEMs (e.g., TanDEM‐X) and create bare‐earth DEMs (e.g., FABDEM, MERIT, CEDTM). We evaluated the vertical accuracy of bare‐earth and global DEMs in Central European mountains and submontane regions, and assessed how DEM resolution, vegetation offset removal, land cover, and terrain slope affect stream network delineation. Using lidar‐derived DTM and national stream networks as references, we found that: (a) bare‐earth DEMs outperform global DEMs across all land cover types. RMSEs increased with increasing slope for all DEMs in non‐forest areas. In forests, however, the negative effect of the slope was outweighed by the vegetation offset even for bare‐earth DTMs; (b) the accuracy of derived stream networks was affected by terrain slope and land cover more than by the vertical accuracy of DEMs. Stream network delineation performed poorly in non‐forest areas and relatively well in forests. Increasing slope improved the streams delineation performance; (c) using DEMs with higher resolution (e.g., 12 m TanDEM‐X) improved stream network delineation, but increasing resolution also increased the need for effective vegetation bias removal. Our results indicate that vertical accuracy alone does not reflect how well DEMs perform in stream network delineation. This underscores the need to include stream network performance in DEM quality rankings.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
Comparison of three global canopy height maps and their applicability to biodiversity modeling: Accuracy issues revealed
Global mapping of forest height is an extremely important task for estimating habitat quality and modeling biodiversity. Recently, three global canopy height maps have been released, the global forest canopy height map (GFCH), the high‐resolution canopy height model of the Earth (HRCH), and the global map of tree canopy height (GMTCH). Here, we assessed their accuracy and usability for biodiversity modeling. We examined their accuracy by comparing them with the reference canopy height models derived from airborne laser scanning (ALS). Our results show considerable differences between the evaluated maps. The root mean square error ranged between 10 and 18 m for GFCH, 9–11 m for HRCH, and 10–17 m for GMTCH, respectively. GFCH and GMTCH consistently underestimated the height of all canopies regardless of their height, while HRCH tended to overestimate the height of low canopies and underestimate tall canopies. Biodiversity models using predicted global canopy height maps as input data are sufficient for estimating simple relationships between species occurrence and canopy height, but their use leads to a considerable decrease in the discrimination ability of the models and to mischaracterization of species niches where derived indices (e.g., canopy height heterogeneity) are concerned. We showed that canopy height heterogeneity is considerably underestimated in the evaluated global canopy height maps. We urge that for temperate areas rich in ALS data, activities should concentrate on harmonizing ALS canopy height maps rather than relying on modeled global products.
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessComparison of three global canopy height maps and their applicability to biodiversity modeling: Accuracy issues revealed
Global mapping of forest height is an extremely important task for estimating habitat quality and modeling biodiversity. Recently, three global canopy height maps have been released, the global forest canopy height map (GFCH), the high‐resolution canopy height model of the Earth (HRCH), and the global map of tree canopy height (GMTCH). Here, we assessed their accuracy and usability for biodiversity modeling. We examined their accuracy by comparing them with the reference canopy height models derived from airborne laser scanning (ALS). Our results show considerable differences between the evaluated maps. The root mean square error ranged between 10 and 18 m for GFCH, 9–11 m for HRCH, and 10–17 m for GMTCH, respectively. GFCH and GMTCH consistently underestimated the height of all canopies regardless of their height, while HRCH tended to overestimate the height of low canopies and underestimate tall canopies. Biodiversity models using predicted global canopy height maps as input data are sufficient for estimating simple relationships between species occurrence and canopy height, but their use leads to a considerable decrease in the discrimination ability of the models and to mischaracterization of species niches where derived indices (e.g., canopy height heterogeneity) are concerned. We showed that canopy height heterogeneity is considerably underestimated in the evaluated global canopy height maps. We urge that for temperate areas rich in ALS data, activities should concentrate on harmonizing ALS canopy height maps rather than relying on modeled global products.