Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Paul G. Higgs has a total of 158 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    How Strong Is the Case for the RNA World?

    by Paul G. Higgs

    The RNA World theory was proposed as a way to explain the origin of the DNA-RNA-Protein relationship found all current cells. It has been greatly strengthened by experimental work on ribozymes and non-enzymatic replication, and has become the most widely accepted theory for the origin of life. But how much do we really know? Within the science community there remain arguments that something else is required before RNA, or that we should not focus on RNA as a single central player. From outside, there are claims that scientists are clueless about the origin of life and that biological information can only be explained by intelligent design. Here, I review recent work showing the strength and coherence of the case for the RNA World. Science can clearly defeat the argument for intelligent design. There is substantial progress with experiments demonstrating many of the requirements for an RNA-first Origin of Life, but important issues remain to be understood.

  • Open Access

    Sequence patterns in RNA replication via the virtual circular genome mechanism

    by Paul G Higgs

    We ask whether functional RNA sequences could be stably copied nonenzymatically at the time of the origin of life. We show that random sequence mixtures spontaneously reduce to short overlapping sequence sets that have been called virtual circular genomes (VCGs). VCG patterns can be classified as irreducible sets of words. Short VCG sequences replicate stably if they cannot reduce to shorter cycles, but longer VCG sequences tend to collapse to shorter sequence patterns, a problem we call scrambling. The VCG mechanism works for relatively short sequences when the error rate is small. Using stochastic computer simulations, we demonstrate successful replication of sequences with a potentially useful function, including a hairpin capable of loop-closing ligation, and an autocatalytic ligase of length 20. However, a hammerhead ribozyme sequence of length 44 is found to be barely stable even for optimistic parameter choices, suggesting that this is an upper limit to the length that could be encoded on a VCG. The recent discovery of short polymerase ribozymes of only length 45 gives hope that nonenzymatic replication might begin to approach what is required for origin of a polymerase.


  • Open Access

    The Spread of Endogenous Retroviruses in Populations Infected by Exogenous Viruses

    by Hyunjin Park, Paul G. Higgs

    Retroviruses insert DNA copies of themselves into the chromosomes of their hosts forming proviruses that can synthesize new transmissible viruses. Exogenous retroviruses (XRVs) insert into the DNA of somatic cells and are transmitted infectiously. Endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) become inserted in the DNA of germline cells and are transmitted genetically. ERVs can spread through the genome by transposition. ERVs originate from an initial copy of an XRV inserted into the genome of an organism infected by the XRV. Many XRVs are transmitted maternally as well as horizontally; therefore, we consider the effect of maternal transmission on the evolution of virulence of an XRV. Our model shows that the XRV either evolves high virulence with low maternal transmission, or vice versa. We then consider the spread of ERV genes in conjunction with the infectious spread of an XRV. Beginning from a single copy of an ERV, we calculate the probability that it spreads to fixation (i.e., the state where all individuals contain ERV genes). This depends on its virulence and transposition rate. If the XRV is present, the fixation probability also depends on the virulence of the XRV and whether the ERV provides resistance to the XRV. An ERV with only a small deleterious effect on host fitness has a high fixation probability, particularly if it provides resistance to the XRV. We also show that, if an ERV does not spread to fixation, it can still cause elimination of the XRV, with the end result that the population is cleared of both XRV and ERV.

  • Open Access

    Autocatalytic symmetry breaking and chiral amplification in a feedback network combining amino acid synthesis and ligation

    by Paul G. Higgs, Donna G. Blackmond

    A kinetic model coupling prebiotically plausible synthesis of enantioenriched proteinogenic amino acids with catalytic peptide ligation leads to an autocatalytic network that may exhibit symmetry breaking and chiral amplification, providing a feasible route to the emergence of biological homochirality. We show that symmetry breaking leading to chiral amplification can occur in two ways: a constructive mechanism in which dimers catalyze the synthesis of monomers of the same enantiomer, and a destructive mechanism in which dimers catalyze the breakdown of monomers of the opposite enantiomer.


  • Open Access

    Protocell Dynamics: Modelling Growth and Division of Lipid Vesicles Driven by an Autocatalytic Reaction

    by Japraj Taneja, Paul G. Higgs

    We study a computational model of a protocell, in which an autocatalytic reaction sustains itself inside a lipid vesicle. The autocatalytic reaction drives volume growth via osmosis. Membrane area grows due to addition of lipids from the environment. The membrane growth rate depends on the external lipid concentration and on the tension in the membrane. In the absence of division, a cell either reaches a state of homeostasis or grows to a point where the internal reaction collapses. If a cell becomes elongated, it can divide into two smaller spherical vesicles, conserving the total volume and area. We determine when it is energetically favorable for a large vesicle to divide. Division requires the buildup of a difference between the lipid areas on the outer and inner leaflets of the membrane. Division occurs most easily when the rate of flipping of lipids between leaflets is relatively slow. If the flipping is too fast, the parent cell grows large without dividing. There is a typical size at which division occurs, producing two daughter cells of unequal sizes. The smaller and larger daughters regrow to the same typical size before the next division. Protocells with an active metabolism reach a stable state where the internal autocatalytic reaction and the membrane growth are well balanced. Active protocells can grow and divide in conditions where an inactive vesicle without an internal reaction cannot.


  • Open Access

    Principles of in vitro selection of ribozymes from random sequence libraries

    by Paul G. Higgs, Ulrich F. Muller

    In vitro selection methods are used to identify catalytic RNAs from pools of random sequences. We discuss the central concepts using experimental data and computational models. Experiments proceed in multiple rounds, each with a reaction step and a step in which reacted sequences are recovered. Sequences are enriched each round by a factor depending on combined reaction and recovery probability. In the first round, there are few functional sequences, and it is necessary to minimize the probability of losing these. In later rounds, the loss probability is negligible, and the procedure can be optimized to maximize the enrichment factor. Clusters of related sequences emerge which descend from separate sequences in the initial pool. The fitness of an RNA depends on how well it matches a structure with specified sequence and base-pair constraints. Sequences that exactly match the constraints may be rare, but sequences a few mutations away are much more common; hence it is likely that clusters descend from suboptimal sequences. There is a high probability that beneficial mutations arise during the experiment. This explains the experimental observation that there is little correlation between cluster frequencies and fitnesses, whereas correlation between enrichment factors and fitnesses is strong.


  • Open Access

    Maintaining an autocatalytic reaction system in a protocell: Nonenzymatic RNA templating and the link between replication and metabolism

    by Quentin C. C. Sanders, Alex Verbeem, Paul G. Higgs

    The first protocells must have been driven by a reaction system in which autocatalysis is maintained inside the cell while food molecules outside the cell are unreactive. We show that if there is a second-order autocatalytic mechanism, then an active state can be stable inside the cell with a high catalyst concentration while the environment remains stable in an unreactive state with no catalyst. Addition of a small amount of catalyst to the environment does not cause the initiation of the autocatalytic cycle outside the cell. In contrast, for a first-order mechanism, addition of a small amount of catalyst initiates the reaction outside the cell unless there is continual removal of the catalyst from the environment. Hence, a second-order reaction mechanism maintains the difference between the inside and outside of a protocell much better than a first-order mechanism. The formose reaction, although a prebiotically plausible autocatalytic system, is first order and therefore is unlikely as a means of support for the first protocells. We give other theoretical examples of first- and second-order reaction networks but note there are few known real-world chemical systems that fit these schemes. However, we show that nonenzymatic RNA templating constitutes a second-order autocatalytic system with the necessary properties to support a protocell. Templating is maintained inside the cell but is not initiated outside the cell. If the reaction is driven by an external supply of activated nucleotides, then templating is itself a metabolic cycle. It is not necessary to have an additional separate metabolic cycle before templating reactions can occur. In this view, templating reactions, which are usually considered as the origin of replication and heredity, are also the origin of metabolism.


  • Open Access

    Evolution of RNA Viruses: Reasons for the Existence of Separate Plus, Minus, and Double-Strand Replication Strategies

    by Hyunjin Park, Paul G. Higgs

    Plus, minus, and double-strand RNA viruses are all found in nature. We use computational models to study the relative success of these strategies. We consider translation, replication, and virion assembly inside one cell, and transmission of virions between cells. For viruses which do not incorporate a polymerase in the capsid, transmission of only plus strands is the default strategy because virions containing minus strands are not infectious. Packaging only plus strands has a significant advantage if the number of RNA strands produced per cell is larger than the number of capsids. In this case, by not packaging minus strands, the virus produces more plus-strand virions. Therefore, plus-strand viruses are selected at low multiplicity of infection. However, at high multiplicity of infection, it is preferable to package both strands because the additional minus virions produced are helpful when there are multiple infections per cell. The fact that plus-strand viruses are widespread while viruses that package both strands are not seen in nature suggests that RNA strands are indeed produced in excess over capsids, and that the multiplicity of infection is not sufficiently high to favor the production of both kinds of virions. For double-strand viruses, we show that it is advantageous to produce only plus strands from the double strand within the cell, as is observed in real viruses. The reason for the success of minus-strand viruses is more puzzling initially. For viruses that incorporate a polymerase in the virion, minus virions are infectious. However, this is not sufficient to explain the success of minus-strand viruses, because in this case, viruses that package both strands outcompete those that package only minus or only plus. Real minus-strand viruses make use of replicable strands that are coated by a nucleoprotein, and separate translatable plus strands that are uncoated. Here we show that when there are distinct replicable and translatable strands, minus-strand viruses are selected.

  • Open Access

    Equilibrium and Non‐equilibrium Reaction Schemes for Prebiotic Polymerization of Ribonucleotides

    by Varun Kitson, Quentin Sanders, Avinash V. Dass, Paul G. Higgs

    The RNA World theory for the origin of life requires polymers to be generated initially by abiotic reactions. Experiments have studied polymerization of 5′‐monophosphates, 2′,3′‐cyclic phosphates, and 5′‐triphosphates. We consider theoretical models of polymerization in solution illustrating the differences between these cases. We consider (i) a basic model where all monomers undergo reversible joining and breaking; (ii) a model where 2′,3′‐cyclic phosphates can join, and breaking regenerates the cyclic phosphate; (iii) a model where 5′‐triphosphates can join irreversibly, in addition to the joining and breaking of 2′,3′‐cyclic phosphates. In cases (i) and (ii) there is an equilibrium steady state with balance between making and breaking bonds. In case (iii) there is a circular reaction flux in which monomers are activated by an external phosphate source, activated monomers form polymers, and polymers break to release non‐activated monomers. The mean length can be calculated as a function of concentration. In case (iii), the mean length switches from a low‐concentration regime controlled by the 5′‐triphosphates to a high‐concentration regime controlled by the 2′,3′‐cyclic phosphates. The circular reaction flux is reminiscent of a metabolism. If formation of 5’‐triphosphates was already in place for RNA synthesis, ATP could subsequently been coopted for metabolism.


  • Open Access

    Evolution of Bipartite and Segmented Viruses from Monopartite Viruses

    by Hyunjin Park, Saven Denha, Paul G. Higgs

    RNA viruses may be monopartite (all genes on one strand), multipartite (two or more strands packaged separately) or segmented (two or more strands packaged together). In this article, we consider competition between a complete monopartite virus, A, and two defective viruses, D and E, that have complementary genes. We use stochastic models that follow gene translation, RNA replication, virus assembly, and transmission between cells. D and E multiply faster than A when stored in the same host as A or when together in the same host, but they cannot multiply alone. D and E strands are packaged as separate particles unless a mechanism evolves that allows assembly of D + E segmented particles. We show that if defective viruses assemble rapidly into separate particles, the formation of segmented particles is selected against. In this case, D and E spread as parasites of A, and the bipartite D + E combination eliminates A if the transmissibility is high. Alternatively, if defective strands do not assemble rapidly into separate particles, then a mechanism for assembly of segmented particles is selected for. In this case, the segmented virus can eliminate A if transmissibility is high. Conditions of excess protein resources favor bipartite viruses, while conditions of excess RNA resources favor segmented viruses. We study the error threshold behavior that arises when deleterious mutations are introduced. Relative to bipartite and segmented viruses, deleterious mutations favor monopartite viruses. A monopartite virus can give rise to either a bipartite or a segmented virus, but it is unlikely that both will originate from the same virus.