Meredith A. Holgerson
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Meredith A. Holgerson has a total of 169 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nicholas E. Ray
School of Marine Science and Policy University of Delaware Lewes Delaware USA
9 shared publications - David C. Richardson
Biology Department State University of New York at New Paltz New Paltz New York USA
5 shared publications - Lauren E. Bortolotti
Institute for Wetland and Waterfowl Research Ducks Unlimited Canada Stonewall Manitoba Canada
5 shared publications - Bridget R. Deemer
U.S. Geological Survey, Southwest Biological Science Center, Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center, Flagstaff, USA
3 shared publications - Daniel J. Hornbach
Macalester College
3 shared publications - David Bastviken
Department of Thematic Studies – Environmental Change, Linköping University, 58183 Linköping, Sweden
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography Letters
- Vol. 11 (5)
Higher methanotroph abundance and bottom‐water methane in ponds with floating photovoltaic arrays
Floating photovoltaic (FPV) arrays alter the methane (CH 4 ) cycling dynamics of waterbodies on which they are deployed. Here, we investigated dissolved CH 4 dynamics and associated CH 4 cycling microbial communities (methanogens and methanotrophs) in the 2 nd year of FPV deployment (70% aerial coverage) in experimental ponds. We found that bottom‐water CH 4 concentrations were twice as high in ponds with FPV compared to those without, while surface water CH 4 concentrations were orders of magnitude lower than bottom waters but did not differ between treatments. There was no change in the relative abundances of putative sediment methanogens or methanotrophs, but FPV restructured methanogen communities. Floating photovoltaics promoted late‐summer methanotroph blooms in the water column, with abundances surpassing 500,000 cells mL −1 . We conclude that prolonged periods of CH 4 production in low‐oxygen FPV ponds favored blooms of methanotrophs that may mitigate diffusive CH 4 emissions to the atmosphere by consuming dissolved CH 4 .
- 16 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography Letters
- Vol. 11 (5)
Open AccessHigher methanotroph abundance and bottom‐water methane in ponds with floating photovoltaic arrays
Floating photovoltaic (FPV) arrays alter the methane (CH 4 ) cycling dynamics of waterbodies on which they are deployed. Here, we investigated dissolved CH 4 dynamics and associated CH 4 cycling microbial communities (methanogens and methanotrophs) in the 2 nd year of FPV deployment (70% aerial coverage) in experimental ponds. We found that bottom‐water CH 4 concentrations were twice as high in ponds with FPV compared to those without, while surface water CH 4 concentrations were orders of magnitude lower than bottom waters but did not differ between treatments. There was no change in the relative abundances of putative sediment methanogens or methanotrophs, but FPV restructured methanogen communities. Floating photovoltaics promoted late‐summer methanotroph blooms in the water column, with abundances surpassing 500,000 cells mL −1 . We conclude that prolonged periods of CH 4 production in low‐oxygen FPV ponds favored blooms of methanotrophs that may mitigate diffusive CH 4 emissions to the atmosphere by consuming dissolved CH 4 .
- Open Access
- 16 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography Letters
- Vol. 11 (5) , e70182
The fate of methane in ponds: Drivers of production, storage, oxidation, and emissions
Ponds are disproportionately large contributors to global carbon cycling, with substantial but variable emissions of methane (CH 4 ) to the atmosphere relative to their global surface area. Efforts to upscale pond CH 4 emissions have focused on broad‐scale correlates of emissions, yet mechanisms underlying the variability in emissions remain poorly constrained. In this study, we quantified total CH 4 production in 15 ponds across New York State (USA) using a mass‐balance approach, and partitioned CH 4 production into its major pathways: storage, oxidation, and emissions. We found that total CH 4 production was strongly regulated by metrics of ecosystem productivity ( R 2 = 0.77), while CH 4 storage accumulation rates and emissions were both controlled by pond morphology, stratification, and sheltering. Oxidation greatly influenced emissions, but remained difficult to predict. By quantifying all CH 4 pathways, our study clarifies drivers of CH 4 production, transport, and ultimately emissions, which can improve the accuracy of upscaling efforts.
- 16 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography Letters
- Vol. 11 (5) , e70182
Open AccessThe fate of methane in ponds: Drivers of production, storage, oxidation, and emissions
Ponds are disproportionately large contributors to global carbon cycling, with substantial but variable emissions of methane (CH 4 ) to the atmosphere relative to their global surface area. Efforts to upscale pond CH 4 emissions have focused on broad‐scale correlates of emissions, yet mechanisms underlying the variability in emissions remain poorly constrained. In this study, we quantified total CH 4 production in 15 ponds across New York State (USA) using a mass‐balance approach, and partitioned CH 4 production into its major pathways: storage, oxidation, and emissions. We found that total CH 4 production was strongly regulated by metrics of ecosystem productivity ( R 2 = 0.77), while CH 4 storage accumulation rates and emissions were both controlled by pond morphology, stratification, and sheltering. Oxidation greatly influenced emissions, but remained difficult to predict. By quantifying all CH 4 pathways, our study clarifies drivers of CH 4 production, transport, and ultimately emissions, which can improve the accuracy of upscaling efforts.
- Open Access
- 30 May 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
- Vol. 76 (7) , 601-615
Anoximixis: Mixing of anoxic bottom waters influences biogeochemical and ecological processes in lakes
Climate change is reshaping lake ecosystems globally, notably through alterations to thermal stratification and mixing regimes. This synthesis describes “anoximixis,” the complete mixing of a stratified waterbody with anoxic bottom waters, and reviews the biogeochemical and ecological implications of anoximixis outside of seasonal turnover events. We posit that climate-driven changes to temperature, wind patterns, and storm events may lead to increased frequency of anoximixis in freshwater ecosystems, which could in turn alter biogeochemical cycling, flux, and sequestration of nutrients, contaminants, and C. Anoximixis may also reorganize lake trophic structure, favoring fast-growing phytoplankton species and cyanobacteria, which will alter energy and C transfer to higher trophic levels. Current lake management strategies do not fully address anoximixis-driven water quality degradation, and some may even unintentionally promote anoximixis. Finally, we recommend that future research needs to test the predictions presented here to expand our understanding and management of anoximixis.
- 30 May 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
- Vol. 76 (7) , 601-615
Open AccessAnoximixis: Mixing of anoxic bottom waters influences biogeochemical and ecological processes in lakes
Climate change is reshaping lake ecosystems globally, notably through alterations to thermal stratification and mixing regimes. This synthesis describes “anoximixis,” the complete mixing of a stratified waterbody with anoxic bottom waters, and reviews the biogeochemical and ecological implications of anoximixis outside of seasonal turnover events. We posit that climate-driven changes to temperature, wind patterns, and storm events may lead to increased frequency of anoximixis in freshwater ecosystems, which could in turn alter biogeochemical cycling, flux, and sequestration of nutrients, contaminants, and C. Anoximixis may also reorganize lake trophic structure, favoring fast-growing phytoplankton species and cyanobacteria, which will alter energy and C transfer to higher trophic levels. Current lake management strategies do not fully address anoximixis-driven water quality degradation, and some may even unintentionally promote anoximixis. Finally, we recommend that future research needs to test the predictions presented here to expand our understanding and management of anoximixis.
- 29 May 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences
- Vol. 131 (6)
Global Warming Potential of CH 4 and N 2 O Sources Is Offset by CO 2 Sinks Across an Experimental Pond Trophic Gradient
Nutrient fertilization of freshwater systems can influence greenhouse gases (GHGs) by altering carbon and nutrient cycling. Increases in productivity and organic matter availability may drive CO 2 and CH 4 , while nitrogen (N) availability may impact N 2 O concentrations and emissions. While the impact of nutrient concentrations on GHGs individually in lakes and ponds has been well described, we have less information on how increases in nutrient concentration impact the relative influence of CO 2 , CH 4 , and N 2 O on total GHG concentrations and emissions and the total impact on global warming potential (GWP) from these systems. We used experimental mesocosms (limnocorrals) to establish replicated treatments of increasing N:phosphorus (P) across a wide gradient of N loads and measured the concentration and emissions of CO 2 , CH 4 , and N 2 O as well as GWP in total CO 2 equivalents. With increasing TN concentrations, we observed declines in emissions and concentrations of CO 2 (−17.01 vs. 11.31 mm m −2 d −1 with greater N load treatment) and increases in N 2 O (mean of 56.77 vs. −0.36 μmol m −2 d −1 with greater N load treatment). We did not observe any systematic pattern between nutrient concentrations and CH 4 . Interestingly, nutrient loads did not alter GWP due to greater CO 2 uptake offsetting increased N 2 O under high TN concentrations and variable CH 4 across the treatments. Our study suggests that increases in N 2 O from even extreme N loading may not necessarily increase the total warming impact from these systems, as higher productivity and greater CO 2 influx may override increased N 2 O emissions as a result of fertilization.
- 29 May 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences
- Vol. 131 (6)
Global Warming Potential of CH 4 and N 2 O Sources Is Offset by CO 2 Sinks Across an Experimental Pond Trophic Gradient
Nutrient fertilization of freshwater systems can influence greenhouse gases (GHGs) by altering carbon and nutrient cycling. Increases in productivity and organic matter availability may drive CO 2 and CH 4 , while nitrogen (N) availability may impact N 2 O concentrations and emissions. While the impact of nutrient concentrations on GHGs individually in lakes and ponds has been well described, we have less information on how increases in nutrient concentration impact the relative influence of CO 2 , CH 4 , and N 2 O on total GHG concentrations and emissions and the total impact on global warming potential (GWP) from these systems. We used experimental mesocosms (limnocorrals) to establish replicated treatments of increasing N:phosphorus (P) across a wide gradient of N loads and measured the concentration and emissions of CO 2 , CH 4 , and N 2 O as well as GWP in total CO 2 equivalents. With increasing TN concentrations, we observed declines in emissions and concentrations of CO 2 (−17.01 vs. 11.31 mm m −2 d −1 with greater N load treatment) and increases in N 2 O (mean of 56.77 vs. −0.36 μmol m −2 d −1 with greater N load treatment). We did not observe any systematic pattern between nutrient concentrations and CH 4 . Interestingly, nutrient loads did not alter GWP due to greater CO 2 uptake offsetting increased N 2 O under high TN concentrations and variable CH 4 across the treatments. Our study suggests that increases in N 2 O from even extreme N loading may not necessarily increase the total warming impact from these systems, as higher productivity and greater CO 2 influx may override increased N 2 O emissions as a result of fertilization.
- Open Access
- 21 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography Letters
- Vol. 11 (3) , e70134
Ponds are neither dimictic nor polymictic: A variable transition season between stratified summers and mixed autumns
Autumn is an important transition time for seasonally stratified lakes where summertime stratification shifts to cooler, mixed periods. While ponds can also experience prolonged summertime stratification, their relatively low water volume accelerates mixing, suggesting they could have distinctly different autumn mixing dynamics compared to lakes. This study examined the mixing dynamics of mostly temperate, small, shallow, and summertime stratified waterbodies. We show that, in contrast to most lakes, ponds have long and distinctive stratified to mixing transition seasons, characterized by repeated mixing and restratification, which can occur for days to months, before sustained isothermal conditions. Transition season mixing starts earlier in shallower and low‐nutrient ponds, with most ponds having at least one continuous week of restratification in autumn. Ultimately, describing pond transition seasons provides an important update to established turnover paradigms for lakes and indicates that these periods have the potential for high biogeochemical and ecological activity.
- 21 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography Letters
- Vol. 11 (3) , e70134
Open AccessPonds are neither dimictic nor polymictic: A variable transition season between stratified summers and mixed autumns
Autumn is an important transition time for seasonally stratified lakes where summertime stratification shifts to cooler, mixed periods. While ponds can also experience prolonged summertime stratification, their relatively low water volume accelerates mixing, suggesting they could have distinctly different autumn mixing dynamics compared to lakes. This study examined the mixing dynamics of mostly temperate, small, shallow, and summertime stratified waterbodies. We show that, in contrast to most lakes, ponds have long and distinctive stratified to mixing transition seasons, characterized by repeated mixing and restratification, which can occur for days to months, before sustained isothermal conditions. Transition season mixing starts earlier in shallower and low‐nutrient ponds, with most ponds having at least one continuous week of restratification in autumn. Ultimately, describing pond transition seasons provides an important update to established turnover paradigms for lakes and indicates that these periods have the potential for high biogeochemical and ecological activity.
- Open Access
- 21 April 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Ecosystems
- Vol. 29 (3)
Organic Carbon Burial Rates in Artificial Ponds Driven by Age and Catchment Land Cover
- 21 April 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Ecosystems
- Vol. 29 (3)
Open AccessOrganic Carbon Burial Rates in Artificial Ponds Driven by Age and Catchment Land Cover
- Open Access
- 20 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Carbon burial outweighs the climate impact of methane emissions across global aquatic ecosystems
Different aquatic ecosystems may have opposing effects on global climate acting as sources and/or sinks of greenhouse gases. The conversion of sediment organic carbon to the powerful greenhouse gas methane is a key indicator of the potential climate impact of a given ecosystem. Here, we assess the lifetime climatic role of aquatic ecosystems by contrasting methane (CH 4 ) emissions with long-term organic carbon burial. Global compilations revealed that the ecosystem-specific ratio of organic carbon burial (kg CO 2 ) to CH 4 emissions (kg CH 4 ) ranged from 20:1 in lakes to 2500:1 in continental shelves. Using 100-year sustained-flux global warming potential and a radiative balance model, we show that most ecosystems currently exhibit a net negative radiative balance (i.e., net cooling or a CO 2 -equivalent sink). The lifetime cooling effect per area was strongest in the coastal ocean and fjords. Freshwater ponds, lakes, and inland wetlands had lowest organic carbon burial to CH 4 emission ratios, requiring ~ 0-700 years after their establishment to shift from a positive to net negative radiative balance. All aquatic ecosystems gradually increase their net climate benefit via long-term enhancement of the ratio of carbon sequestration to CH 4 emissions. Most aquatic ecosystems will thus achieve negative radiative balance over their lifetime.
- 20 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessCarbon burial outweighs the climate impact of methane emissions across global aquatic ecosystems
Different aquatic ecosystems may have opposing effects on global climate acting as sources and/or sinks of greenhouse gases. The conversion of sediment organic carbon to the powerful greenhouse gas methane is a key indicator of the potential climate impact of a given ecosystem. Here, we assess the lifetime climatic role of aquatic ecosystems by contrasting methane (CH 4 ) emissions with long-term organic carbon burial. Global compilations revealed that the ecosystem-specific ratio of organic carbon burial (kg CO 2 ) to CH 4 emissions (kg CH 4 ) ranged from 20:1 in lakes to 2500:1 in continental shelves. Using 100-year sustained-flux global warming potential and a radiative balance model, we show that most ecosystems currently exhibit a net negative radiative balance (i.e., net cooling or a CO 2 -equivalent sink). The lifetime cooling effect per area was strongest in the coastal ocean and fjords. Freshwater ponds, lakes, and inland wetlands had lowest organic carbon burial to CH 4 emission ratios, requiring ~ 0-700 years after their establishment to shift from a positive to net negative radiative balance. All aquatic ecosystems gradually increase their net climate benefit via long-term enhancement of the ratio of carbon sequestration to CH 4 emissions. Most aquatic ecosystems will thus achieve negative radiative balance over their lifetime.
- Open Access
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Wiley
Diverging Carbon Dynamics in Engineered Ecosystems: Comparing Greenhouse Gases and DOM in Stormwater and Natural Ponds
Urban stormwater ponds (SWPs) are increasingly recognized as critical hotspots for carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) cycling, driven by high external inputs and elevated internal productivity. In developed watersheds, SWPs often replace natural aquatic ecosystems at equal or greater densities, but direct comparisons of the C and N dynamics between these engineered and natural ecosystems remain scarce. During distinct wet and dry seasons (Florida, USA), we compared the diffusive air-water flux and hypolimnetic saturation of carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O), as well as the composition of dissolved organic matter (DOM) between SWPs (n = 15) and naturally occurring clear (n=3) and dark colored (n=3) ponds in undisturbed watersheds. SWPs had similar CO2 and lower CH4 fluxes compared to natural-dark ponds, and higher fluxes than natural-clear ponds. Both natural pond types (clear and dark) were more stratified than SWPs, resulting in a greater CH4 buildup in the natural ponds. N2O fluxes were negligible across all pond types, with dark ponds being N2O sinks. N2O fluxes were negligible, and negative in natural-dark ponds. SWPs contained 1) identical humic-like, 2) similar microbially derived, and 3) unique humic DOM compared to natural ponds. Our study underscores that SWPs differ from natural ponds in greenhouse gas production and DOM composition, providing evidence that these rapidly emerging ecosystems alter C forms and greenhouse gas fluxes in developed landscapes.
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessDiverging Carbon Dynamics in Engineered Ecosystems: Comparing Greenhouse Gases and DOM in Stormwater and Natural Ponds
Urban stormwater ponds (SWPs) are increasingly recognized as critical hotspots for carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) cycling, driven by high external inputs and elevated internal productivity. In developed watersheds, SWPs often replace natural aquatic ecosystems at equal or greater densities, but direct comparisons of the C and N dynamics between these engineered and natural ecosystems remain scarce. During distinct wet and dry seasons (Florida, USA), we compared the diffusive air-water flux and hypolimnetic saturation of carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O), as well as the composition of dissolved organic matter (DOM) between SWPs (n = 15) and naturally occurring clear (n=3) and dark colored (n=3) ponds in undisturbed watersheds. SWPs had similar CO2 and lower CH4 fluxes compared to natural-dark ponds, and higher fluxes than natural-clear ponds. Both natural pond types (clear and dark) were more stratified than SWPs, resulting in a greater CH4 buildup in the natural ponds. N2O fluxes were negligible across all pond types, with dark ponds being N2O sinks. N2O fluxes were negligible, and negative in natural-dark ponds. SWPs contained 1) identical humic-like, 2) similar microbially derived, and 3) unique humic DOM compared to natural ponds. Our study underscores that SWPs differ from natural ponds in greenhouse gas production and DOM composition, providing evidence that these rapidly emerging ecosystems alter C forms and greenhouse gas fluxes in developed landscapes.
- 29 January 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences
- Vol. 131 (2)
Carbon Dynamics in Artificial Aquatic Ecosystems: Comparing Greenhouse Gases and DOM in Stormwater and Natural Ponds
Urban stormwater ponds (SWPs) are increasingly recognized as critical hotspots for carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) cycling, driven by high external inputs and elevated internal productivity. In developed watersheds, SWPs often replace natural aquatic ecosystems at equal or greater densities, but direct comparisons of the C and N dynamics between these engineered and natural ecosystems remain scarce. During distinct wet and dry seasons (Florida, USA), we compared the diffusive air‐water flux and hypolimnetic saturation of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ), methane (CH 4 ), and nitrous oxide (N 2 O), as well as the composition of dissolved organic matter (DOM) between SWPs ( n = 15) and naturally occurring clear ( n = 3) and dark colored ( n = 3) ponds in undisturbed watersheds. SWPs had similar CO 2 and lower CH 4 fluxes compared with natural‐dark ponds, and higher fluxes than natural‐clear ponds. Both natural pond types (clear and dark) were more stratified than SWPs, resulting in a greater CH 4 buildup in the natural ponds. N 2 O fluxes were negligible across all pond types, with dark ponds being N 2 O sinks. SWPs contained unique humic DOM not found in natural ponds, as well as microbially derived DOM that was similar to, and humic DOM that was identical to, that of natural ponds. Our study underscores that SWPs differ from natural ponds in greenhouse gas production and DOM composition, providing evidence that these rapidly emerging ecosystems alter C forms and greenhouse gas fluxes in developed landscapes.
- 29 January 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences
- Vol. 131 (2)
Carbon Dynamics in Artificial Aquatic Ecosystems: Comparing Greenhouse Gases and DOM in Stormwater and Natural Ponds
Urban stormwater ponds (SWPs) are increasingly recognized as critical hotspots for carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) cycling, driven by high external inputs and elevated internal productivity. In developed watersheds, SWPs often replace natural aquatic ecosystems at equal or greater densities, but direct comparisons of the C and N dynamics between these engineered and natural ecosystems remain scarce. During distinct wet and dry seasons (Florida, USA), we compared the diffusive air‐water flux and hypolimnetic saturation of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ), methane (CH 4 ), and nitrous oxide (N 2 O), as well as the composition of dissolved organic matter (DOM) between SWPs ( n = 15) and naturally occurring clear ( n = 3) and dark colored ( n = 3) ponds in undisturbed watersheds. SWPs had similar CO 2 and lower CH 4 fluxes compared with natural‐dark ponds, and higher fluxes than natural‐clear ponds. Both natural pond types (clear and dark) were more stratified than SWPs, resulting in a greater CH 4 buildup in the natural ponds. N 2 O fluxes were negligible across all pond types, with dark ponds being N 2 O sinks. SWPs contained unique humic DOM not found in natural ponds, as well as microbially derived DOM that was similar to, and humic DOM that was identical to, that of natural ponds. Our study underscores that SWPs differ from natural ponds in greenhouse gas production and DOM composition, providing evidence that these rapidly emerging ecosystems alter C forms and greenhouse gas fluxes in developed landscapes.
- 26 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography
- Vol. 71 (1)
Carbon fluxes in two temperate ponds are mediated by stratification and primary producers
Ponds influence global carbon (C) cycling due to high rates of organic C (OC) burial and carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) and methane (CH 4 ) emissions. Here, we quantified OC burial rates and CO 2 and CH 4 concentrations and fluxes in two ponds that were similar in size and gross primary production, but differed in depth and dominant primary producers. The deeper (3.9 m) Texas Hollow Pond was phytoplankton dominated with stronger and longer (143 d) stratification compared to the shallower (2.7 m) macrophyte‐dominated Mud Pond (85 d). Both ponds exhibited high CO 2 and CH 4 emissions and high OC burial, yet C pathways differed. Strong stratification in Texas Hollow Pond led to anoxic bottom waters, benthic CO 2 and CH 4 accumulation, and limited OC decomposition, whereas Mud Pond remained oxygenated with similar gas concentrations across the water column. Texas Hollow Pond had 2.6 times higher CO 2 emissions than Mud Pond, perhaps related to greater wetland C inputs in Texas Hollow. Despite similar diffusive CH 4 emissions between ponds, the weakly stratified Mud Pond had twice as much CH 4 ebullition, likely due to warmer waters and macrophyte‐derived OC fueling methanogenesis. In summary, slight differences in depth and light attenuation can regulate stratification, plant communities, oxygen availability, and C processing in ponds. Given that ponds are hotspots for C cycling and are sensitive to climate‐driven changes in stratification, understanding the mechanisms behind C processing is critical for local management and predicting global C budgets.
- 26 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Limnology and Oceanography
- Vol. 71 (1)
Carbon fluxes in two temperate ponds are mediated by stratification and primary producers
Ponds influence global carbon (C) cycling due to high rates of organic C (OC) burial and carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) and methane (CH 4 ) emissions. Here, we quantified OC burial rates and CO 2 and CH 4 concentrations and fluxes in two ponds that were similar in size and gross primary production, but differed in depth and dominant primary producers. The deeper (3.9 m) Texas Hollow Pond was phytoplankton dominated with stronger and longer (143 d) stratification compared to the shallower (2.7 m) macrophyte‐dominated Mud Pond (85 d). Both ponds exhibited high CO 2 and CH 4 emissions and high OC burial, yet C pathways differed. Strong stratification in Texas Hollow Pond led to anoxic bottom waters, benthic CO 2 and CH 4 accumulation, and limited OC decomposition, whereas Mud Pond remained oxygenated with similar gas concentrations across the water column. Texas Hollow Pond had 2.6 times higher CO 2 emissions than Mud Pond, perhaps related to greater wetland C inputs in Texas Hollow. Despite similar diffusive CH 4 emissions between ponds, the weakly stratified Mud Pond had twice as much CH 4 ebullition, likely due to warmer waters and macrophyte‐derived OC fueling methanogenesis. In summary, slight differences in depth and light attenuation can regulate stratification, plant communities, oxygen availability, and C processing in ponds. Given that ponds are hotspots for C cycling and are sensitive to climate‐driven changes in stratification, understanding the mechanisms behind C processing is critical for local management and predicting global C budgets.