Karen Sepucha
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Karen Sepucha has a total of 450 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kathrene Diane Valentine
Massachusetts General Hospital Division of General Internal Medicine, Boston, MA, USA; Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA
16 shared publications Yuchiao Chang
13 shared publicationsLauren Leavitt
Massachusetts General Hospital , Division of General Internal Medicine, Department of Medicine, Boston, MA 02114
10 shared publicationsHa Vo
Health Decision Sciences Center, Division of General Internal Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, USA
9 shared publications- Michael John Barry
Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA
9 shared publications - Leigh H. Simmons
Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston MA, USA
8 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 23 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Medical Screening
Patient preferences and prostate-specific antigen screening
- 23 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Medical Screening
Patient preferences and prostate-specific antigen screening
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing
- Vol. 25 (7) , 1455-1456
Shared decision making: moving from studying it to doing it
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing
- Vol. 25 (7) , 1455-1456
Shared decision making: moving from studying it to doing it
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Family Practice
- Vol. 43 (6)
Moving from a clinical trial to routine care: a qualitative analysis of primary care physicians’ experiences with interventions to promote shared decision making for colorectal cancer screening in older adults
Background: The Promoting Informed Decisions About Colorectal Cancer Screening in Older Adults (PRIMED) cluster randomized trial found that 2-hour online training combined with a pre-visit reminder for primary care physicians (PCPs) increased shared decision making (SDM) among patients aged 76–85 years who were due for colorectal cancer screening (CRC) screening discussions. However, the best way to translate findings from the clinical trial setting into routine primary care remains unclear. Objective: To explore PCPs’ experiences with the PRIMED SDM training and reminders, and to identify barriers, facilitators, and recommendations for implementation in routine primary care. Methods: A qualitative study using semi-structured interviews was conducted. 59 PCPs from 35 primary care practices affiliated with five hospitals in Massachusetts and Maine who participated in the PRIMED trial were invited to be interviewed. Interviews were conducted between April and July 2021, transcribed verbatim, and analyzed by two independent researchers using a Framework Analysis-informed approach. Results: Of 59 PCPs, 43 participated. Themes included: (i) Training and Reminders Supported SDM; (ii) Real-World Constraints Challenged SDM Implementation, but PCPs Made Efforts to Adapt despite challenges such as time pressures, competing priorities, and the COVID-19 pandemic; and (iii) Scaling and Sustaining SDM Requires a System-Level Approach, such as automated reminders, patient decision aids, concise training, and interprofessional SDM. Conclusions: Overall, PCPs perceived the SDM training and reminders as supporting a more nuanced and individualized approach to CRC screening conversations with older adults. To enable broader scale-up in primary care, these interventions should minimize burden on PCPs by streamlining integration into existing workflows.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Family Practice
- Vol. 43 (6)
Moving from a clinical trial to routine care: a qualitative analysis of primary care physicians’ experiences with interventions to promote shared decision making for colorectal cancer screening in older adults
Background: The Promoting Informed Decisions About Colorectal Cancer Screening in Older Adults (PRIMED) cluster randomized trial found that 2-hour online training combined with a pre-visit reminder for primary care physicians (PCPs) increased shared decision making (SDM) among patients aged 76–85 years who were due for colorectal cancer screening (CRC) screening discussions. However, the best way to translate findings from the clinical trial setting into routine primary care remains unclear. Objective: To explore PCPs’ experiences with the PRIMED SDM training and reminders, and to identify barriers, facilitators, and recommendations for implementation in routine primary care. Methods: A qualitative study using semi-structured interviews was conducted. 59 PCPs from 35 primary care practices affiliated with five hospitals in Massachusetts and Maine who participated in the PRIMED trial were invited to be interviewed. Interviews were conducted between April and July 2021, transcribed verbatim, and analyzed by two independent researchers using a Framework Analysis-informed approach. Results: Of 59 PCPs, 43 participated. Themes included: (i) Training and Reminders Supported SDM; (ii) Real-World Constraints Challenged SDM Implementation, but PCPs Made Efforts to Adapt despite challenges such as time pressures, competing priorities, and the COVID-19 pandemic; and (iii) Scaling and Sustaining SDM Requires a System-Level Approach, such as automated reminders, patient decision aids, concise training, and interprofessional SDM. Conclusions: Overall, PCPs perceived the SDM training and reminders as supporting a more nuanced and individualized approach to CRC screening conversations with older adults. To enable broader scale-up in primary care, these interventions should minimize burden on PCPs by streamlining integration into existing workflows.
- Open Access
Development of a core outcome set for the evaluation of shared decision-making interventions in healthcare: a study protocol
Introduction: Shared decision-making (SDM) is a process whereby patients are supported to reach decisions about their healthcare in collaboration with healthcare professionals. Despite decades of SDM research, the impact of using SDM interventions (eg, patient decision aids, decision coaching, question prompt lists, training and feedback or service changes) on clinical and health service outcomes remains uncertain. This is partly because synthesis of the existing literature is hindered by substantial heterogeneity in the evaluation of interventions to facilitate SDM. A core outcome set (COS) is an agreed standardised set of outcomes that should be measured and reported in all effectiveness studies. The aim of this study is to develop a generic COS for evaluating the impact of SDM interventions (COS-SDMi). Methods and analysis: This study will follow Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials (COMET) handbook and Core Outcome Set-STAndards for Development (COS-STAD) and reporting (COS-STAR). Relevant key interest holder groups include health professionals, patients, academic experts in SDM, representatives from policy/guideline development, journal editors and research funders. The scope of the COS was agreed through consultation with experts from key interest holder groups. The study will consist of three steps. In Step 1, we will produce a ‘long’ (comprehensive) list of candidate outcome domains using multiple data sources. Relevant outcomes will be extracted from a COS developed in the context of rheumatology, a synthesis of existing reviews of SDM interventions and qualitative interviews with a minimum of 20 representatives of key interest holder groups internationally. In Step 2, we will agree on a shorter list of outcome domains using a Delphi survey. A sequential two-round international online Delphi survey with two panels (professionals, public/patients) will be used to agree on the outcomes, seeking responses from a minimum of 150 international participants representing key interest groups. In Step 3, we will reach consensus on the final COS using consensus meetings. Consensus meetings with key interest holder group participants internationally will be held, applying modified nominal group techniques. The total project period will be from June 2025 until September 2026. Ethics and dissemination: Research ethics approval has been granted in the UK for undertaking qualitative interviews (University of Exeter Faculty Ethics Committee, ref: 8207624) and the Delphi survey and consensus meeting activities (University of Bristol Faculty Ethics Committee, ref: 7741). Written informed consent will be obtained digitally from all participants in the qualitative interviews, the Delphi surveys and the consensus meetings. The final COS will be disseminated through presentations at international conferences, briefing notes to key organisations and publication in a peer-reviewed journal. Further dissemination is planned through our patient/public advisory group, professional networks and executive group channels, as well as publications to patient groups, funders, journal editors, international regulatory bodies and health technology assessment boards. Study registration: COMET Database ( www.comet-initiative.org/Studies/Details/3586 ).
Open AccessDevelopment of a core outcome set for the evaluation of shared decision-making interventions in healthcare: a study protocol
Introduction: Shared decision-making (SDM) is a process whereby patients are supported to reach decisions about their healthcare in collaboration with healthcare professionals. Despite decades of SDM research, the impact of using SDM interventions (eg, patient decision aids, decision coaching, question prompt lists, training and feedback or service changes) on clinical and health service outcomes remains uncertain. This is partly because synthesis of the existing literature is hindered by substantial heterogeneity in the evaluation of interventions to facilitate SDM. A core outcome set (COS) is an agreed standardised set of outcomes that should be measured and reported in all effectiveness studies. The aim of this study is to develop a generic COS for evaluating the impact of SDM interventions (COS-SDMi). Methods and analysis: This study will follow Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials (COMET) handbook and Core Outcome Set-STAndards for Development (COS-STAD) and reporting (COS-STAR). Relevant key interest holder groups include health professionals, patients, academic experts in SDM, representatives from policy/guideline development, journal editors and research funders. The scope of the COS was agreed through consultation with experts from key interest holder groups. The study will consist of three steps. In Step 1, we will produce a ‘long’ (comprehensive) list of candidate outcome domains using multiple data sources. Relevant outcomes will be extracted from a COS developed in the context of rheumatology, a synthesis of existing reviews of SDM interventions and qualitative interviews with a minimum of 20 representatives of key interest holder groups internationally. In Step 2, we will agree on a shorter list of outcome domains using a Delphi survey. A sequential two-round international online Delphi survey with two panels (professionals, public/patients) will be used to agree on the outcomes, seeking responses from a minimum of 150 international participants representing key interest groups. In Step 3, we will reach consensus on the final COS using consensus meetings. Consensus meetings with key interest holder group participants internationally will be held, applying modified nominal group techniques. The total project period will be from June 2025 until September 2026. Ethics and dissemination: Research ethics approval has been granted in the UK for undertaking qualitative interviews (University of Exeter Faculty Ethics Committee, ref: 8207624) and the Delphi survey and consensus meeting activities (University of Bristol Faculty Ethics Committee, ref: 7741). Written informed consent will be obtained digitally from all participants in the qualitative interviews, the Delphi surveys and the consensus meetings. The final COS will be disseminated through presentations at international conferences, briefing notes to key organisations and publication in a peer-reviewed journal. Further dissemination is planned through our patient/public advisory group, professional networks and executive group channels, as well as publications to patient groups, funders, journal editors, international regulatory bodies and health technology assessment boards. Study registration: COMET Database ( www.comet-initiative.org/Studies/Details/3586 ).
- Open Access
Updated International Patient Decision Aid Standards (IPDAS version 5.0): modified Delphi, evidence informed consensus process
Patient decision aids (PDAs) are evidence informed tools designed to support patients in the process of making decisions about their health. The International Patient Decision Aid Standards (IPDAS) Collaboration last updated the standards in 2013 and the evidence about patient decision aids has expanded substantially. In this article, we report on an update to IPDAS that used a modified Delphi process with two rounds of voting to reach consensus on evidence informed changes to the criteria. The 202 participants were from 26 countries, and included patients/consumers, policy makers, researchers, and clinician researchers. IPDAS 5.0 includes seven qualifying criteria (necessary to be a patient decision aid), 10 essential criteria (necessary to reduce biased decisions), and 54 enhancing criteria (additional criteria that might improve the quality of a patient decision aid). The updated standards reflect the IPDAS Collaboration’s founding goal of providing high quality patient decision aids for patients that minimise potential biases in the decisions made about potential healthcare options.
Open AccessUpdated International Patient Decision Aid Standards (IPDAS version 5.0): modified Delphi, evidence informed consensus process
Patient decision aids (PDAs) are evidence informed tools designed to support patients in the process of making decisions about their health. The International Patient Decision Aid Standards (IPDAS) Collaboration last updated the standards in 2013 and the evidence about patient decision aids has expanded substantially. In this article, we report on an update to IPDAS that used a modified Delphi process with two rounds of voting to reach consensus on evidence informed changes to the criteria. The 202 participants were from 26 countries, and included patients/consumers, policy makers, researchers, and clinician researchers. IPDAS 5.0 includes seven qualifying criteria (necessary to be a patient decision aid), 10 essential criteria (necessary to reduce biased decisions), and 54 enhancing criteria (additional criteria that might improve the quality of a patient decision aid). The updated standards reflect the IPDAS Collaboration’s founding goal of providing high quality patient decision aids for patients that minimise potential biases in the decisions made about potential healthcare options.
- 21 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
- Vol. 46 (6) , 757-766
Exploring the Lack of Concordance between the Preferred and Actual Approach to Colorectal Cancer Screening in Older Adults: A Qualitative Study
Background: Concordance, or alignment of care with patients’ preferences, is a key component of high-quality decision making. Some patients may not have a clear preference, and others may not receive care aligned with their preference—both situations indicating a lack of concordance. The reasons behind these situations remain poorly understood. This study explores the reasons for lack of concordance in colorectal cancer screening among older adults. Methods: Interviews were conducted with 160 older adults from the Promoting Informed Decisions About Colorectal Cancer Screening in Older Adults trial (NCT03959696) who did not meet the criteria for concordance. A thematic analysis of 152 analyzable interviews was performed to explore reasons for lack of concordance. Results: Four themes summarize the different reasons for the lack of concordance: 1) provider discussion and the need for more guidance (e.g., patients reported very limited discussion and desire for more information), 2) age-related considerations (e.g., patients acknowledge that at their age, screening may no longer be needed), 3) changes in health condition (e.g., patients report other health issues that take priority over screening), and 4) the impact of COVID-19 and practical barriers (e.g., patients report a desire to avoid hospitals and procedures). Conclusions: The lack of concordance stemming from limited discussion, guidance, or lack of clear preference signal low decision quality, whereas the lack of concordance from changing patient preferences over time has implications for timing of measurement. To improve concordance, patients need support to clarify their preferences as well as support to implement their preferred approach. Highlights: Limited provider discussion, age-related factors, changing health priorities, and COVID-19–related or practical challenges were identified as key contributors to lack of concordance. Achieving high concordance will require helping patients clarify their preferences, strengthening shared decision making, and providing implementation support. Researchers also need to be aware of evolving preferences and implications for timing of preference measurements.
- 21 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
- Vol. 46 (6) , 757-766
Exploring the Lack of Concordance between the Preferred and Actual Approach to Colorectal Cancer Screening in Older Adults: A Qualitative Study
Background: Concordance, or alignment of care with patients’ preferences, is a key component of high-quality decision making. Some patients may not have a clear preference, and others may not receive care aligned with their preference—both situations indicating a lack of concordance. The reasons behind these situations remain poorly understood. This study explores the reasons for lack of concordance in colorectal cancer screening among older adults. Methods: Interviews were conducted with 160 older adults from the Promoting Informed Decisions About Colorectal Cancer Screening in Older Adults trial (NCT03959696) who did not meet the criteria for concordance. A thematic analysis of 152 analyzable interviews was performed to explore reasons for lack of concordance. Results: Four themes summarize the different reasons for the lack of concordance: 1) provider discussion and the need for more guidance (e.g., patients reported very limited discussion and desire for more information), 2) age-related considerations (e.g., patients acknowledge that at their age, screening may no longer be needed), 3) changes in health condition (e.g., patients report other health issues that take priority over screening), and 4) the impact of COVID-19 and practical barriers (e.g., patients report a desire to avoid hospitals and procedures). Conclusions: The lack of concordance stemming from limited discussion, guidance, or lack of clear preference signal low decision quality, whereas the lack of concordance from changing patient preferences over time has implications for timing of measurement. To improve concordance, patients need support to clarify their preferences as well as support to implement their preferred approach. Highlights: Limited provider discussion, age-related factors, changing health priorities, and COVID-19–related or practical challenges were identified as key contributors to lack of concordance. Achieving high concordance will require helping patients clarify their preferences, strengthening shared decision making, and providing implementation support. Researchers also need to be aware of evolving preferences and implications for timing of preference measurements.
- Open Access
- 24 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
- Vol. 46 (4) , 448-460
Patient Decision Aids into Routine Orthopedic Care: Results from an Implementation Study at 12 Sites
Background: Decision aids (DAs) are evidence-based tools to improve patient-centered care, but their use in routine care is limited. The purpose of this project was to work with orthopedic practices to deliver DAs. Methods: Eligible sites needed to identify an administrative and clinical champion and have access to DAs for treatment of hip, knee, and/or spine conditions. The implementation strategies included an Orthopaedic Learning Collaborative (OLC), external facilitation, and audit and feedback. The project was conducted over 15 mo with 5 OLC sessions, individual monthly meetings, and monthly data reports. Clinicians and staff completed a baseline survey prior to the start of the project. Sites provided details on their DA workflow and number of DAs delivered. We calculated adoption (the number of specialists who used DAs) and estimated reach (percentage of eligible patients who received DAs). We calculated descriptive statistics and explored predictors of reach. Results: Twelve participating sites had an average annual orthopedic surgical volume of 550, half were academic medical centers, and some (4/13, 30.7%) had prior experience with orthopedic DAs. Adoption was 76% (60/79 physicians). Sites distributed 9,626 DAs and reached 44% of eligible patients (range 7%–100%). Sites that indicated at baseline that DA delivery was a high priority for staff had higher reach (60% reach for high v. 47% for moderate v. 9% for low priority, P = 0.21). Sites with no prior experience with DAs had higher reach than those with prior experience did (60% v. 38%, P = 0.26, d = 0.71). Conclusions: Participating sites were able to implement workflows that reached about half of eligible patients. Establishing DA delivery as a priority for staff at the outset appears important for reach, while prior experience does not. Highlights: The 12 sites were able to reach, on average, 44% of eligible patients with decision aids in routine care demonstrating feasibility of distribution. The study and associated implementation toolkit provide concrete examples of workflows for orthopedic practices interested in incorporating decision aids into routine care. A bundle of implementation strategies, including a learning collaborative, external facilitation, and audit and feedback, helped most sites meet targets for decision aid implementation.
- 24 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
- Vol. 46 (4) , 448-460
Open AccessPatient Decision Aids into Routine Orthopedic Care: Results from an Implementation Study at 12 Sites
Background: Decision aids (DAs) are evidence-based tools to improve patient-centered care, but their use in routine care is limited. The purpose of this project was to work with orthopedic practices to deliver DAs. Methods: Eligible sites needed to identify an administrative and clinical champion and have access to DAs for treatment of hip, knee, and/or spine conditions. The implementation strategies included an Orthopaedic Learning Collaborative (OLC), external facilitation, and audit and feedback. The project was conducted over 15 mo with 5 OLC sessions, individual monthly meetings, and monthly data reports. Clinicians and staff completed a baseline survey prior to the start of the project. Sites provided details on their DA workflow and number of DAs delivered. We calculated adoption (the number of specialists who used DAs) and estimated reach (percentage of eligible patients who received DAs). We calculated descriptive statistics and explored predictors of reach. Results: Twelve participating sites had an average annual orthopedic surgical volume of 550, half were academic medical centers, and some (4/13, 30.7%) had prior experience with orthopedic DAs. Adoption was 76% (60/79 physicians). Sites distributed 9,626 DAs and reached 44% of eligible patients (range 7%–100%). Sites that indicated at baseline that DA delivery was a high priority for staff had higher reach (60% reach for high v. 47% for moderate v. 9% for low priority, P = 0.21). Sites with no prior experience with DAs had higher reach than those with prior experience did (60% v. 38%, P = 0.26, d = 0.71). Conclusions: Participating sites were able to implement workflows that reached about half of eligible patients. Establishing DA delivery as a priority for staff at the outset appears important for reach, while prior experience does not. Highlights: The 12 sites were able to reach, on average, 44% of eligible patients with decision aids in routine care demonstrating feasibility of distribution. The study and associated implementation toolkit provide concrete examples of workflows for orthopedic practices interested in incorporating decision aids into routine care. A bundle of implementation strategies, including a learning collaborative, external facilitation, and audit and feedback, helped most sites meet targets for decision aid implementation.
- Open Access
Protocol for the development of a core outcome set for the evaluation of shared decision-making interventions in healthcare
Introduction: Shared decision-making (SDM) is a process whereby patients are supported to reach decisions about their healthcare in collaboration with healthcare professionals. International policy and clinical guidelines highlight the ethical imperative of SDM and recommend SDM for many healthcare decisions and contexts. However, despite decades of SDM research, the impact of implementing SDM interventions within health care remains uncertain. High-quality health technology assessment (HTA) requires an understanding of how interventions to facilitate the adoption and implementation of SDM (e.g., through the use of patient decision aids, decision coaching, question prompt lists, training and feedback, or service changes) impact clinical and health service outcomes. Yet, synthesis of the existing literature is hindered by substantial heterogeneity in the evaluation of interventions to facilitate SDM. A core outcome set (COS) is an agreed standardised set of outcomes that should be measured and reported in all effectiveness studies. There is a COS for SDM in the context of rheumatology (rheuCOS-SDM), designed for use in research studies (e.g., clinical trials or observational studies) evaluating the impact of SDM interventions on clinical outcomes for patients. It is unclear, however, whether the outcome domains identified within a rheumatology context are relevant, comprehensive, or comprehensible when applied to a variety of SDM interventions tailored to and interacting with a range of patient populations, healthcare settings and contexts. The aim of this study is to develop a generic COS for evaluating the impact of SDM interventions on various outcomes. Outcomes for consideration may include assessments of the behaviours and experiences of patients, important others (e.g., carers or relatives) and health professionals, the dynamics within patient-professional interactions, health outcomes for individuals and for the wider population, and the cost-effectiveness of care. The broad scope of the COS will ensure its applicability and utility within diverse healthcare contexts and enable the synthesis of evidence to draw clear conclusions about the impact of SDM interventions, to influence healthcare policy. We define this new, comprehensive COS as the COS-SDM. Methods and Analysis: Through engagement with key interest holders (including patients and members of the public, clinicians and academics), we agreed on the scope of the COS and to adhere to the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials (COMET) handbook and Core Outcome Set-STAndards for Development (COS-STAD) guidelines. This will involve production of a ‘long’ (comprehensive) list of candidate outcome domains (using evidence synthesis, a COS developed in the context of Rheumatology, and qualitative interviews with interest holders internationally), prioritisation of a ‘short’ (refined) list of core outcome domains (utilising a sequential two-round international online Delphi), and reaching consensus on the final outcome set (through international meetings, applying modified nominal group techniques and predefined criteria for agreement). Ethics and Dissemination: Research ethics approval has been granted in the UK (University of Bristol Faculty Ethics Committee, ref: 7741; University of Exeter Faculty Ethics Committee, ref: 8207624). The final COS will be disseminated by presentation at international conferences and publication in a peer-reviewed journal. Further dissemination is planned through our patient/public advisory group, professional networks, and executive group channels, to publicise the COS to patient groups, funders, journal editors, international regulatory bodies and HTA boards. Registration: This project has been registered in the COMET database ( www.comet-initiative.org/Studies/Details/3586 ).
Open AccessProtocol for the development of a core outcome set for the evaluation of shared decision-making interventions in healthcare
Introduction: Shared decision-making (SDM) is a process whereby patients are supported to reach decisions about their healthcare in collaboration with healthcare professionals. International policy and clinical guidelines highlight the ethical imperative of SDM and recommend SDM for many healthcare decisions and contexts. However, despite decades of SDM research, the impact of implementing SDM interventions within health care remains uncertain. High-quality health technology assessment (HTA) requires an understanding of how interventions to facilitate the adoption and implementation of SDM (e.g., through the use of patient decision aids, decision coaching, question prompt lists, training and feedback, or service changes) impact clinical and health service outcomes. Yet, synthesis of the existing literature is hindered by substantial heterogeneity in the evaluation of interventions to facilitate SDM. A core outcome set (COS) is an agreed standardised set of outcomes that should be measured and reported in all effectiveness studies. There is a COS for SDM in the context of rheumatology (rheuCOS-SDM), designed for use in research studies (e.g., clinical trials or observational studies) evaluating the impact of SDM interventions on clinical outcomes for patients. It is unclear, however, whether the outcome domains identified within a rheumatology context are relevant, comprehensive, or comprehensible when applied to a variety of SDM interventions tailored to and interacting with a range of patient populations, healthcare settings and contexts. The aim of this study is to develop a generic COS for evaluating the impact of SDM interventions on various outcomes. Outcomes for consideration may include assessments of the behaviours and experiences of patients, important others (e.g., carers or relatives) and health professionals, the dynamics within patient-professional interactions, health outcomes for individuals and for the wider population, and the cost-effectiveness of care. The broad scope of the COS will ensure its applicability and utility within diverse healthcare contexts and enable the synthesis of evidence to draw clear conclusions about the impact of SDM interventions, to influence healthcare policy. We define this new, comprehensive COS as the COS-SDM. Methods and Analysis: Through engagement with key interest holders (including patients and members of the public, clinicians and academics), we agreed on the scope of the COS and to adhere to the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials (COMET) handbook and Core Outcome Set-STAndards for Development (COS-STAD) guidelines. This will involve production of a ‘long’ (comprehensive) list of candidate outcome domains (using evidence synthesis, a COS developed in the context of Rheumatology, and qualitative interviews with interest holders internationally), prioritisation of a ‘short’ (refined) list of core outcome domains (utilising a sequential two-round international online Delphi), and reaching consensus on the final outcome set (through international meetings, applying modified nominal group techniques and predefined criteria for agreement). Ethics and Dissemination: Research ethics approval has been granted in the UK (University of Bristol Faculty Ethics Committee, ref: 7741; University of Exeter Faculty Ethics Committee, ref: 8207624). The final COS will be disseminated by presentation at international conferences and publication in a peer-reviewed journal. Further dissemination is planned through our patient/public advisory group, professional networks, and executive group channels, to publicise the COS to patient groups, funders, journal editors, international regulatory bodies and HTA boards. Registration: This project has been registered in the COMET database ( www.comet-initiative.org/Studies/Details/3586 ).
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 10, e82306
Development of a user-informed decision aid for adolescents and young adults’ contraceptive care (Preprint)
Background: Adolescents and young adults seeking contraceptive care face many considerations related to differences in contraceptive indications and knowledge, which are often overlooked and can lead to contraceptive nonadherence or nonuse as well as adverse health outcomes. Objective: This study aimed to develop a digital decision aid that meets the contraceptive decisional needs of adolescents and young adults from diverse backgrounds. Methods: We developed a web-based decision aid using a user-centered design framework and the International Patient Decision Aid Standards. The design and development process was informed by a literature review and consultations with scientific experts, health informatics specialists, clinicians experienced in adolescent reproductive health, and a diverse group of adolescent and young adult advisors. We gathered feedback on the decision aid’s content and functionality from clinicians, adolescents, and young adult stakeholders during focus group interviews conducted across 2 user testing cycles. Each focus group was recorded and transcribed, and the data were analyzed using a focus group guide to identify key attributes, patterns, and perspectives among users. Two qualitative researchers used rapid qualitative analysis to explore and summarize findings across 4 key domains, which contributed to the refinement of the decision aid content and the improvement of its functionality. Results: Twenty-four clinicians, adolescents, and young adult participants from diverse backgrounds shared their perspectives on the decision aid’s content, relevance, design, and usability across 2 user testing cycles conducted from February 2023 to June 2024. The decision aid includes a survey, a decision algorithm that generates a summary of contraceptive method recommendations, infographics, and a health care provider summary view. The decision algorithm applies a weighted scoring system ranging from +1 or −1 to +10 or −10 for each method, reflecting the user’s primary indication for seeking contraception, contraceptive use preferences, and relevant health history. Conclusions: This approach allowed us to capture rich perspectives from a diverse group of stakeholders that accounted for the unique contraceptive decision-making needs of adolescents and young adults, resulting in a functional, youth-informed decision aid prototype, MyPlanMyChoice, ready for pilot and feasibility evaluation in a clinical setting.
- 12 August 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 10, e82306
Open AccessDevelopment of a user-informed decision aid for adolescents and young adults’ contraceptive care (Preprint)
Background: Adolescents and young adults seeking contraceptive care face many considerations related to differences in contraceptive indications and knowledge, which are often overlooked and can lead to contraceptive nonadherence or nonuse as well as adverse health outcomes. Objective: This study aimed to develop a digital decision aid that meets the contraceptive decisional needs of adolescents and young adults from diverse backgrounds. Methods: We developed a web-based decision aid using a user-centered design framework and the International Patient Decision Aid Standards. The design and development process was informed by a literature review and consultations with scientific experts, health informatics specialists, clinicians experienced in adolescent reproductive health, and a diverse group of adolescent and young adult advisors. We gathered feedback on the decision aid’s content and functionality from clinicians, adolescents, and young adult stakeholders during focus group interviews conducted across 2 user testing cycles. Each focus group was recorded and transcribed, and the data were analyzed using a focus group guide to identify key attributes, patterns, and perspectives among users. Two qualitative researchers used rapid qualitative analysis to explore and summarize findings across 4 key domains, which contributed to the refinement of the decision aid content and the improvement of its functionality. Results: Twenty-four clinicians, adolescents, and young adult participants from diverse backgrounds shared their perspectives on the decision aid’s content, relevance, design, and usability across 2 user testing cycles conducted from February 2023 to June 2024. The decision aid includes a survey, a decision algorithm that generates a summary of contraceptive method recommendations, infographics, and a health care provider summary view. The decision algorithm applies a weighted scoring system ranging from +1 or −1 to +10 or −10 for each method, reflecting the user’s primary indication for seeking contraception, contraceptive use preferences, and relevant health history. Conclusions: This approach allowed us to capture rich perspectives from a diverse group of stakeholders that accounted for the unique contraceptive decision-making needs of adolescents and young adults, resulting in a functional, youth-informed decision aid prototype, MyPlanMyChoice, ready for pilot and feasibility evaluation in a clinical setting.
- 28 May 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
Clinical Notes Contain Limited Documentation of Shared Decision Making for Colorectal Cancer Screening Decisions
Background: Effective shared decision making (SDM) in health care involves thorough discussions of options, pros, cons, and patient preferences. While SDM is recommended for engaging adults aged 76 to 85 y in colorectal cancer (CRC) screening decisions, the extent of SDM documentation in clinical notes remains unclear. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the current state of SDM documentation in clinical notes regarding CRC screening discussions for adults aged 76 to 85 y. It also sought to assess the impact of an SDM training intervention on documentation quality and compare documented SDM elements with physician- and patient-reported SDM. Methods: Data from 465 patient participants and 58 primary care physicians in a multisite cluster randomized trial were analyzed. Physicians in the intervention arm underwent a 2-h SDM skills training and received support tools, including an electronic health record SmartPhrase. Coders analyzed clinical notes using content analysis to identify SDM elements. Linear multilevel models and multilevel partial correlations were used for analysis. Results: Overall, SDM Note scores were low ( x ¯ = 0.80, s = 0.99). The intervention arm exhibited higher SDM Note scores than the comparator arm did (adjusted mean 1.02 v. 0.66; P = 0.006), with more frequent documentation of stool-based tests (52% v. 33%; P = 0.02) and colonoscopy cons (28% v. 8%; P = 0.001). No significant differences were observed in patient preference documentation. SDM Note scores correlated moderately with patient- and physician-reported SDM. Conclusion: Documentation of CRC screening discussions with older adults lacks comprehensive SDM elements. The intervention improved SDM documentation, particularly regarding alternative screening options and potential cons. Given the limited documentation of SDM even after a training intervention, attention to more robust SDM documentation, including patient preferences and discussion of stopping CRC screening, is needed. Highlights: Shared decision-making (SDM) documentation in clinical notes is limited for discussions on colon cancer screening among older adults. SDM training improves SDM documentation of screening options for colorectal cancer, specifically documentation of stool-based testing and the downsides of screening options. SDM documentation in clinical notes is related to patient and provider reports of SDM.
- 28 May 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
Clinical Notes Contain Limited Documentation of Shared Decision Making for Colorectal Cancer Screening Decisions
Background: Effective shared decision making (SDM) in health care involves thorough discussions of options, pros, cons, and patient preferences. While SDM is recommended for engaging adults aged 76 to 85 y in colorectal cancer (CRC) screening decisions, the extent of SDM documentation in clinical notes remains unclear. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the current state of SDM documentation in clinical notes regarding CRC screening discussions for adults aged 76 to 85 y. It also sought to assess the impact of an SDM training intervention on documentation quality and compare documented SDM elements with physician- and patient-reported SDM. Methods: Data from 465 patient participants and 58 primary care physicians in a multisite cluster randomized trial were analyzed. Physicians in the intervention arm underwent a 2-h SDM skills training and received support tools, including an electronic health record SmartPhrase. Coders analyzed clinical notes using content analysis to identify SDM elements. Linear multilevel models and multilevel partial correlations were used for analysis. Results: Overall, SDM Note scores were low ( x ¯ = 0.80, s = 0.99). The intervention arm exhibited higher SDM Note scores than the comparator arm did (adjusted mean 1.02 v. 0.66; P = 0.006), with more frequent documentation of stool-based tests (52% v. 33%; P = 0.02) and colonoscopy cons (28% v. 8%; P = 0.001). No significant differences were observed in patient preference documentation. SDM Note scores correlated moderately with patient- and physician-reported SDM. Conclusion: Documentation of CRC screening discussions with older adults lacks comprehensive SDM elements. The intervention improved SDM documentation, particularly regarding alternative screening options and potential cons. Given the limited documentation of SDM even after a training intervention, attention to more robust SDM documentation, including patient preferences and discussion of stopping CRC screening, is needed. Highlights: Shared decision-making (SDM) documentation in clinical notes is limited for discussions on colon cancer screening among older adults. SDM training improves SDM documentation of screening options for colorectal cancer, specifically documentation of stool-based testing and the downsides of screening options. SDM documentation in clinical notes is related to patient and provider reports of SDM.