HSHeather Shaw

Heather Shaw

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Heather Shaw has a total of 57 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Mind the Research Culture Gap: Staff Perspectives on Ethical, Inclusive, and Sustainable Research Practice at a UK Research Intensive University

    by Samuel Finnerty, Yingnian Tao, Heather Shaw, Richard Philpot, Nuri Kwon, Seth Robinson, Mark Levine

    Research culture reform increasingly requires researchers to attend to ethical, inclusive, and sustainable practice, yet little is known about how staff perceive the gap between what is valued and what is enacted. This mixed-methods study surveyed 244 staff at a UK research-intensive university, comparing ratings of how important each practice should be (ideal) with perceptions of how far it is currently realised (actual) across ethics, inclusion (operationalised as community-based research), and sustainability. Ratings were collected at three actor levels, the participant, their peers, and their institution. This allowed an examination of where university staff identify the largest research culture change barriers. Paired-samples t-tests revealed significant ideal-actual gaps across all domains, with sustainability showing the largest differences and ethics the smallest. A consistent self-other narrative emerged: participants rated their own practice most favourably, with the largest gaps between their own practice and that of their peers. For ethics, the individual-level gap was negligible, consistent with the procedural formalisation of ethical review. For sustainability, gaps were substantial at every level. Open-text responses contextualised these patterns, revealing that ethical practice was framed as individually controllable, while inclusion was seen as context-dependent and collectively constrained, and sustainability practice as routinely blocked by structural barriers. These findings suggest that procedural formalisation can narrow the ideal-actual gap in research culture change but may foster surface compliance rather than reflexive engagement. We conclude that the path to research culture change, particularly in respect of sustainability and inclusion, requires structural reform as well as individual behaviour change.

  • Open Access

    Parenting or partnership? Corpus-assisted analysis of institution-people dynamics in university sustainability reporting

    by Yingnian Tao, Samuel Finnerty, Seth Robinson, Richard Philpot, Heather Shaw, Mark Levine

    Higher education institutions are increasingly required to produce formal reports on their sustainability practices. How these reports are written can tell us much about the way higher education leadership prioritises the contributions of different parts of the institution to sustainability goals. In this paper we investigate how key actors — institutions, staff, and students — are represented within these formal documents. We employ corpus-assisted discourse analysis, combining concordance and collocation analysis, to examine sustainability reports produced by UK universities included in the 2024 QS Sustainability Ranking. Findings show that universities, staff and students are the most frequently mentioned actors, but there are clear asymmetries in how they are represented. Universities are consistently portrayed as ethically, socially, and environmentally responsible leaders who provide facilities, inclusion programmes, services, and sustainability initiatives. In contrast, staff and students are more often positioned as passive recipients and beneficiaries of university affordances, often referenced in role-based terms or as components of carbon reporting rather than as agents in their own right. The findings point to a hierarchical “parenting” representational pattern that diminishes collective agency and undermines more participatory understandings of sustainability governance. Such representations are consequential because the discursive marginalisation of staff and student agency raises questions about the extent to which university sustainability governance is genuinely participatory or democratic. This study makes an original contribution to scholarship on sustainability discourse, governance and legitimacy in higher education, and demonstrates the value of corpus-assisted discourse analysis for identifying ideological patterns in institutional reporting.


  • Open Access

    The DECIDE Framework: Describing Ethical Choices in Digital-Behavioral-Data Explorations

    by Heather Shaw, Olivia Brown, Joanne Hinds, Sophie J. Nightingale, John Towse, David A. Ellis

    Behavioral sciences now routinely rely on digital data, supported by digital technologies and platforms. This has resulted in an abundance of new ethical challenges for researchers and ethical-review boards. Several contemporary high-profile cases emphasize that ethical issues often surface after the research is published, once harm has already occurred. Consequently, implementing safeguards in digital-behavioral research is often reactionary and fails to adequately prevent harm. In response, we propose the DECIDE (Describing Ethical Choices in Digital-Behavioural Data Explorations) framework, which encourages ethical reflections and discussions throughout all stages of the research process. The framework presents several questions designed to help researchers view their work from new perspectives and uncover ethical issues they might not have anticipated. We provide several resources to support researchers with their ethical reflections and discussions, including (a) the DECIDE framework spreadsheet, (b) the DECIDE desktop app, (c) information documents, and (d) flowcharts. In this article, we provide suggestions on how to use each resource to encourage proactive discussions of how ethical issues may apply to specific research contexts. By promoting continuous ethical considerations, safeguards can be put in place throughout the research project, even after research commencement. The DECIDE framework shifts ethical reflection away from being reactive toward a more proactive endeavor, reducing the risk of harm and the misuse of digital-behavioral data.


  • Open Access

    The DECIDE Framework: Describing Ethical Choices in Digital-Behavioral-Data Explorations

    by Heather Shaw, Olivia Brown, Joanne Hinds, Sophie J Nightingale, John Nicholas Towse, David Alexander Ellis

    Behavioral sciences now routinely rely on digital data, supported by digital technologies and platforms. This has resulted in an abundance of new ethical challenges for researchers and ethical review boards. Several contemporary high-profile cases emphasize that ethical issues often surface after the research is published, once harm has already occurred. Consequently, implementing safeguards in digital behavioral research is often reactionary and fails to adequately prevent harm. In response, we propose the DECIDE framework which encourages ethical reflections and discussions throughout all stages of the research process. The framework presents several questions designed to help researchers view their work from new perspectives and uncover ethical issues they might not have anticipated. We provide several resources to support researchers with their ethical reflections and discussions, including (i) The DECIDE Framework Spreadsheet, (ii) The DECIDE Desktop App, (iii) Information Documents, and (iv) Flowcharts. This article provides suggestions on how to use each resource to encourage proactive discussions of how ethical issues may apply to specific research contexts. By promoting continous ethical considerations, safeguards can be put in place throughout the research project, even after research commencement. The DECIDE framework shifts ethical reflection away from being reactive towards a more proactive endeavor, reducing the risk of harm, and the misuse of digital behavioral data.

  • Open Access

    Digital Behavioural Biometrics: A Systematic Review of Reviews

    by Charlotte Sibbons, Heather Shaw, Paul Taylor, Stacey Conchie

    The proliferation of digital data has provided new means to identify people from the way they behave and interact with technologies. This article provides the first systematic review of reviews (n = 41) on digital behavioural biometrics to ascertain what can be inferred about identity from digital sources, and “boundaries” to their applications. On October, 5, 2021, we searched for reviews in the databases PsychInfo, ACM Digital, IEEE Xplore Digital Library, Academic Search Ultimate,Web of Science, and Scopus. We included reviews of digital behavioural biometrics that inferred personal identity, excluding those focused solely on physiological identifiers, personality or health inferences without identity. The 41 reviews document a range of accuracy and error rates across and within behavioural biometric modalities including keystroke, gait, and multimodal which we document in tables and summarise narratively. The research demonstrates that identity can be inferred continuously, cheaply, and covertly, with little user effort, through the development of digital behavioural biometric systems. However, such systems need to be adaptive and consider how behaviour can change over time and context. In particular, the absence of psychological theory in development of the systems leads to suboptimal performance. The reviews also highlight issues and inconsistencies in the way biometric systems are reported alongside a lack of open data. Consequently, we propose a checklist to help researchers follow best practices and to standardise procedures.

  • Auditing AI Systems: A Metadata Approach

    by Carl Adams, Mohsen Eslamnejad, Anita Khadka, Andrew M’mAnga, Heather Shaw, Yuchen Zhao


  • Open Access

    Behavioral Consistency in the Digital Age

    by Heather Shaw, Paul J. Taylor, David A. Ellis, Stacey M. Conchie

    Efforts to infer personality from digital footprints have focused on behavioral stability at the trait level without considering situational dependency. We repeated a classic study of intraindividual consistency with secondary data (five data sets) containing 28,692 days of smartphone usage from 780 people. Using per-app measures of pickup frequency and usage duration, we found that profiles of daily smartphone usage were significantly more consistent when taken from the same user than from different users ( d > 1.46). Random-forest models trained on 6 days of behavior identified each of the 780 users in test data with 35.8% accuracy for pickup frequency and 38.5% accuracy for duration frequency. This increased to 73.5% and 75.3%, respectively, when success was taken as the user appearing in the top 10 predictions (i.e., top 1%). Thus, situation-dependent stability in behavior is present in our digital lives, and its uniqueness provides both opportunities and risks to privacy.


  • Open Access

    Behavioral consistency in the digital age

    by Heather Shaw, Paul Taylor, David Alexander Ellis, Stacey Conchie

    Efforts to infer personality from digital footprints have focused on behavioral stability at the trait level without considering situational dependency. We repeat Shoda, Mischel, and Wright’s (1994) classic study of intraindividual consistency with data on 28,692 days of smartphone usage by 780 people. Using per app measures of ‘pickup’ frequency and usage duration, we found that profiles of daily smartphone usage were significantly more consistent when taken from the same user than from different users (d > 1.46). Random forest models trained on 6 days of behavior identified each of the 780 users in test data with 35.8% / 38.5% (pickup / duration) accuracy. This increased to 73.5% / 75.3% when success was taken as the user appearing in the top 10 predictions (i.e., top 1%). Thus, situation-dependent stability in behavior is present in our digital lives and its uniqueness provides both opportunities and risks to privacy.


  • Open Access

    Supplemental Material for Quantifying Smartphone “Use”: Choice of Measurement Impacts Relationships Between “Usage” and Health

    by Heather Shaw, David A. Ellis, Kristoffer Geyer, Brittany I. Davidson, Fenja V. Ziegler, Alice Smith

    Problematic smartphone scales and duration estimates of use dominate research that considers the impact of smartphones on people and society. However, issues with conceptualization and subsequent measurement can obscure genuine associations between technology use and health. Here, we consider whether different ways of measuring “smartphone use,” notably through problematic smartphone use (PSU) scales, subjective estimates, or objective logs, lead to contrasting associations between mental and physical health. Across two samples including iPhone (n = 199) and Android (n = 46) users, we observed that measuring smartphone interactions with PSU scales produced larger associations between mental health when compared with subjective estimates or objective logs. Notably, the size of the relationship was fourfold in Study 1, and almost three times as large in Study 2, when relying on a PSU scale that measured smartphone “addiction” instead of objective use. Further, in regression models, only smartphone “addiction” scores predicted mental health outcomes, whereas objective logs or estimates were not significant predictors. We conclude that addressing people’s appraisals including worries about their technology usage is likely to have greater mental health benefits than reducing their overall smartphone use. Reducing general smartphone use should therefore not be a priority for public health interventions at this time.