ARAnandaroop Ray

Anandaroop Ray

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Anandaroop Ray has a total of 45 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    A Decade of Airborne Electromagnetic Surveying Lake Menindee (Australia) Under Varying Water Levels

    by A. Ray, A. McPherson, R. C. Brodie, A. Y. Ley‐Cooper, K. P. Tan, M. Hatch, R. N. Deo, S. Wong, F. Dauti, W. Cook, et al.

    Time domain airborne electromagnetic (AEM) surveying is a mature geophysical tool for imaging the Earth's shallow subsurface. It produces images of the electromagnetic conductivity structure of the earth, down to depths of a few hundred metres. The AEM method is fast, with rotary‐wing or fixed‐wing aircraft acquiring data at speeds of 100–300 km/h, making it an ideal near‐surface reconnaissance tool. The physics of the AEM method is sensitive primarily to the subsurface conductivity, which is influenced by a range of geological factors such as mineral content, porosity, and water content and chemistry. In addition, the inferred subsurface conductivity depends on the accurate measurement and modelling of airborne transmitter and receiver geometries – a challenging task given the speed of acquisition and variability of wind conditions during an acquisition flight. In this work, we present inferences of the subsurface conductivity over Lake Menindee, New South Wales, Australia, using data from test flights and various AEM systems over a 10‐year period (2014–2024). The lake storage has varied dramatically over this time, and the test flights have coincided with both high and low water levels. While this difference in storage volume undoubtedly influences the near‐surface conductivity, a remarkably consistent interpretation of the regional geology is possible regardless of the hydrologic conditions. While the upper 10 m of the modelled depth sections exhibit the greatest time‐variability in inferred electromagnetic conductivity, the hypothesis that lakebed near‐surface conductivity is significantly correlated with the lake water volume cannot robustly be established. We also provide some information‐theoretic calculations for each inversion result to aid in their quantitative comparison. The implications of our study are that subtle, shallow, hydrogeological changes are difficult to image with repeat AEM overflights from different systems. Conversely, we establish that different AEM systems with minimal extra processing robustly image the regional geo‐electric structure of the near surface, validated by known stratigraphy and associated geological information, as well as borehole conductivity logs.

  • Open Access

    Estimating noise for airborne electromagnetic data from repeat flight lines or inversion residuals

    by Tim Scarr, Anandaroop Ray, Ross C Brodie

    Characterizing the noise of an airborne electromagnetic (AEM) system is critical in correctly imaging the earth’s subsurface conductivity. Deterministic and probabilistic geophysical inversion algorithms require foreknowledge of the system noise to specify stopping criteria or a valid model likelihood. Repeat flight lines provide a way for geophysicists to calculate the statistical variability in AEM data acquired over the same ground, and therefore estimate the levels of noise to propagate into the inversion. The total noise can be separated into multiplicative and additive components. The multiplicative noise is derived by repeat lines at survey altitude. The method to calculate the multiplicative noise is scarcely documented and usual methods for height correcting acquired data require a linear trend removal. This study will outline the algorithm used to estimate multiplicative noise of an AEM system, and non-linearly correct for varying altitudes during repeat flights. Additionally, this paper details a methodology to Gaussianize the data noise and provide a statistically valid Gaussian data misfit or likelihood function. Significantly, we provide methods for estimating the off-diagonal elements in the data covariance matrix used within the misfit function, taking into account the time-channel data correlation that is usually neglected. While our methodology is general, our study of a rotary-wing system leads us to conclude that for regularized time-domain AEM imaging, a diagonal data covariance suffices – an important implication for rigorous yet practical AEM inversion.

  • An information theoretic Bayesian uncertainty analysis of AEM systems over Menindee Lake, Australia

    by Anandaroop Ray, Yusen Ley-Cooper, Ross C Brodie, Richard Taylor, Neil Symington, Negin F Moghaddam

    SUMMARY: Long-range, active-source airborne electromagnetic (AEM) systems for near-surface conductivity imaging fall into two categories: helicopter (rotary-wing) borne or fixed-wing aircraft borne. A multitude of factors such as flying height, transmitter loop area and current, source waveforms, aerodynamic stability and data stacking times contribute to the geological resolvability of the subsurface. A comprehensive comparison of the relative merits of each system considering all such factors is difficult, but test flights over well-constrained subsurface geology with downhole induction logs are extremely useful for resolution studies. However, given the non-linear nature of the electromagnetic inverse problem, handling transmitter–receiver geometries in fixed-wing aircraft is especially challenging. As a consequence of this non-linearity, inspecting the closeness of downhole conductivities to deterministic inversion results is not sufficient for studying resolvability. A more comprehensive picture is provided by examining the variation in probability mass of the depth-wise Bayesian posterior conductivity distributions for each kind of AEM system within an information theoretic framework. For this purpose, probabilistic inversions of data must be carried out. Each acquiring system should fly over the same geology, survey noise levels must be measured and the same prior probabilities on conductivity must be used. With both synthetic models as well as real data from over the Menindee calibration range in New South Wales, Australia, we shed new light on the matter of AEM inverse model uncertainty. We do this using two information theoretic attributes derived from different Kullback–Leibler divergences—Bayesian information gain, and a strictly proper scoring rule, to assess posterior probabilities estimated by a novel Bayesian inversion scheme. The inversion marginalizes fixed-wing geometry attributes as generic nuisance parameters during Markov chain sampling. This is the first time-domain AEM study we know of, that compares nuisance marginalized subsurface posterior conductivities from a fixed-wing system, with rotary-wing derived posterior conductivities. We also compare field results with induction log data where available. Finally, we estimate the information gain in each case via a covariate shift adaptation technique that has not been used before in geophysical work. Our findings have useful implications in AEM system selection, as well as in the design of better deterministic AEM inversion algorithms.


  • A plume origin for hydrous melt at the lithosphere–asthenosphere boundary

    by Daniel Blatter, Samer Naif, Kerry Key, Anandaroop Ray

    Plate tectonics requires a low-viscosity layer beneath the lithosphere–asthenosphere boundary (LAB), yet the origin of this ductile transition remains debated1,2. Explanations include the weakening effects of increasing temperature3,4, mineral hydration5 or partial melt6. Electrical resistivity is sensitive to all three effects7, including melt volatile content8, but previous LAB constraints from magnetotelluric soundings did not simultaneously consider the thermodynamic stability of the inferred amount of melt and the effect of uncertainty in the estimated resistivity8,9,10,11,12,13,14. Here we couple an experimentally constrained parameterization of mantle melting in the presence of volatiles15,16 with Bayesian resistivity inversion17 and apply this to magnetotelluric data sensitive to a LAB channel beneath the Cocos Plate9. Paradoxically, we find that the conductive channel requires either anomalously large melt fractions with moderate volatile contents or moderate melt fractions with anomalously large volatile contents, depending on the assumed mantle temperature. Large melt fractions are unlikely to be mechanically stable and conflict with melt-migration models18. As large volatile contents require a highly enriched mantle source inconsistent with mid-ocean-ridge estimates19, our results indicate that a mantle plume emplaced volatile-rich melts in the LAB channel. This requires the presence of a previously undetected nearby plume or the influence of the distant Galápagos hotspot. Plumes that feed thin, hydrous melt channels9,14,20 may be an unrecognized source of LAB anomalies globally.


  • Open Access

    AEGC 2021: Workshop on frontiers of AEM inversion and interpretation for minerals, energy and groundwater applications

    by Alan Yusen Ley-Cooper, Anandaroop Ray

    As part of the recent AEGC 2021 conference, we held a virtual workshop focusing on the state-of-the-art in airborne electromagnetics (AEM) and its uses, entitled “Frontiers of AEM inversion and int...


  • Open Access

    Bayesian inversion using nested trans-dimensional Gaussian processes

    by Anandaroop Ray

    To understand earth processes, geoscientists infer subsurface earth properties such as electromagnetic resistivity or seismic velocity from surface observations of electromagnetic or seismic data. These properties are used to populate an earth model vector, and the spatial variation of properties across this vector sheds light on the underlying earth structure or physical phenomenon of interest, from groundwater aquifers to plate tectonics. However, to infer these properties the spatial characteristics of these properties need to be known in advance. Typically, assumptions are made about the length scales of earth properties, which are encoded a priori in a Bayesian probabilistic setting. In an optimization setting, appeals are made to promote model simplicity together with constraints which keep models close to a preferred model. All of these approaches are valid, though they can lead to unintended features in the resulting inferred geophysical models owing to inappropriate prior assumptions, constraints or even the nature of the solution basis functions. In this work it will be shown that in order to make accurate inferences about earth properties, inferences can first be made about the underlying length scales of these properties in a very general solution basis. From a mathematical point of view, these spatial characteristics of earth properties can be conveniently thought of as ‘properties’ of the earth properties. Thus, the same machinery used to infer earth properties can be used to infer their length scales. This can be thought of as an ‘infer to infer’ paradigm analogous to the ‘learning to learn’ paradigm which is now commonplace in the machine learning literature. However, it must be noted that (geophysical) inference is not the same as (machine) learning, though there are many common elements which allow for cross-pollination of useful ideas from one field to the other, as is shown here. A non-stationary trans-dimensional Gaussian Process (TDGP) is used to parametrize earth properties, and a multichannel stationary TDGP is used to parametrize the length scales associated with the earth property in question. Using non-stationary kernels, that is kernels with spatially variable length scales, models with sharp discontinuities can be represented within this framework. As GPs are multidimensional interpolators, the same theory and computer code can be used to solve geophysical problems in 1-D, 2-D and 3-D. This is demonstrated through a combination of 1-D and 2-D non-linear regression examples and a controlled source electromagnetic field example. The key difference between this and previous work using TDGP is generalized nested inference and the marginalization of prior length scales for better posterior subsurface property characterization.


  • Two-dimensional Bayesian inversion of magnetotelluric data using trans-dimensional Gaussian processes

    by Daniel Blatter, Anandaroop Ray, Kerry Key

    SUMMARY: Bayesian inversion of electromagnetic data produces crucial uncertainty information on inferred subsurface resistivity. Due to their high computational cost, however, Bayesian inverse methods have largely been restricted to computationally expedient 1-D resistivity models. In this study, we successfully demonstrate, for the first time, a fully 2-D, trans-dimensional Bayesian inversion of magnetotelluric (MT) data. We render this problem tractable from a computational standpoint by using a stochastic interpolation algorithm known as a Gaussian process (GP) to achieve a parsimonious parametrization of the model vis-a-vis the dense parameter grids used in numerical forward modelling codes. The GP links a trans-dimensional, parallel tempered Markov chain Monte Carlo sampler, which explores the parsimonious model space, to MARE2DEM, an adaptive finite element forward solver. MARE2DEM computes the model response using a dense parameter mesh with resistivity assigned via the GP model. We demonstrate the new trans-dimensional GP sampler by inverting both synthetic and field MT data for 2-D models of electrical resistivity, with the field data example converging within 10 d on 148 cores, a non-negligible but tractable computational cost. For a field data inversion, our algorithm achieves a parameter reduction of over 32× compared to the fixed parameter grid used for the MARE2DEM regularized inversion. Resistivity probability distributions computed from the ensemble of models produced by the inversion yield credible intervals and interquartile plots that quantitatively show the non-linear 2-D uncertainty in model structure. This uncertainty could then be propagated to other physical properties that impact resistivity including bulk composition, porosity and pore-fluid content.


  • Bayesian joint inversion of controlled source electromagnetic and magnetotelluric data to infer presence of a freshwater aquifer offshore New Jersey

    by Daniel Blatter, Kerry Key, Anandaroop Ray, Chloe Gustaffson, Rob Evans

    To evaluate the extent of a low salinity aquifer within the continental shelf offshore New Jersey, USA, we adapt a Bayesian trans-dimensional Markov chain Monte Carlo (McMC) algorithm for jointly inverting surface towed controlled source electromagnetic (CSEM) and seafloor magnetotelluric (MT) data. Owing to the relatively flat seafloor topography and layered underlying geology, our inversion is parametrized to produce an ensemble of 1D models at each site along the tow line. The results identify a high probability region of high resistivity of varying depth and thickness in the upper 500 m of the continental shelf, corroborating results from a previous study that used a regularized, gradient-based 2D inversion method. Using a combination of synthetic studies and real data we also evaluate the joint model parameter uncertainty in comparison to the uncertainty obtained from the individual data sets and demonstrate quantitatively that joint inversion offers reduced uncertainty. In addition, we show with a Monte Carlo scheme, how the Bayesian model ensemble can subsequently be used to derive quantitative uncertainty estimates of pore water salinity within the low salinity aquifer. The ability to produce meaningful non-linear uncertainty estimates on both conductivity as well as related parameters is a strong motivator for the use of Bayesian inversion methods when computationally feasible.

  • Open Access

    Bayesian geophysical inversion with Gaussian process machine learning and trans-D Markov chain Monte Carlo

    by Anandaroop Ray, David Myer

    A key aspect of geophysical inversion is the ability to model the earth with a low dimensional representation. There exist various approaches to solve the inverse problem. However, most methods do not automatically adapt inverse model complexity or the number of active model parameters as dictated by data noise and sparse receiver coverage, do not quantify inverse model uncertainty or do not work equally well for 1D, 2D or 3D earth models. Low frequency electromagnetic (EM) inversion for example, can require for 3D problems upward of 106 cells to forward model. Only a small fraction of these cells is effectively resolvable and there are significant trade-offs between them. To address these limitations, we present a novel approach to earth model parametrization by using a Gaussian Processes (GP) machine learning (ML) technique, coupled with a parsimonious Bayesian trans-dimensional (trans-D) Markov chain Monte Carlo (McMC) sampling scheme. One aspect that sets our approach apart from recent spatial dimension agnostic algorithms in the trans-D or ML literature is the ability to specify inversion property priors directly, as opposed to doing so in a transform domain of the property. Finally, we note that our method falls in the category of ML approaches that do not attempt to learn the physics of the process, but instead learn the representation of parameter values through a misfit function. We apply the trans-D-GP method to a 1D controlled source electromagnetic (CSEM) and 2D non-linear regression problem, using actual field data from the Northwest Australian Shelf for the former. The key advantages in using our method are the simplicity of prior specification, parsimonious low dimensional representations, and ease of representing large-scale models in 1D, 2D or even 3D with the same parametrization and computer code.


  • Open Access

    Bayesian joint inversion of controlled source electromagnetic and magnetotelluric data to image freshwater aquifer offshore New Jersey

    by Daniel Blatter, Kerry Key, Anandaroop Ray, Chloe Gustafson, Rob Evans

    SUMMARY: Joint inversion of multiple electromagnetic data sets, such as controlled source electromagnetic and magnetotelluric data, has the potential to significantly reduce uncertainty in the inverted electrical resistivity when the two data sets contain complementary information about the subsurface. However, evaluating quantitatively the model uncertainty reduction is made difficult by the fact that conventional inversion methods—using gradients and model regularization—typically produce just one model, with no associated estimate of model parameter uncertainty. Bayesian inverse methods can provide quantitative estimates of inverted model parameter uncertainty by generating an ensemble of models, sampled proportional to data fit. The resulting posterior distribution represents a combination of a priori assumptions about the model parameters and information contained in field data. Bayesian inversion is therefore able to quantify the impact of jointly inverting multiple data sets by using the statistical information contained in the posterior distribution. We illustrate, for synthetic data generated from a simple 1-D model, the shape of parameter space compatible with controlled source electromagnetic and magnetotelluric data, separately and jointly. We also demonstrate that when data sets contain complementary information about the model, the region of parameter space compatible with the joint data set is less than or equal to the intersection of the regions compatible with the individual data sets. We adapt a trans-dimensional Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm for jointly inverting multiple electromagnetic data sets for 1-D earth models and apply it to surface-towed controlled source electromagnetic and magnetotelluric data collected offshore New Jersey, USA, to evaluate the extent of a low salinity aquifer within the continental shelf. Our inversion results identify a region of high resistivity of varying depth and thickness in the upper 500 m of the continental shelf, corroborating results from a previous study that used regularized, gradient-based inversion methods. We evaluate the joint model parameter uncertainty in comparison to the uncertainty obtained from the individual data sets and demonstrate quantitatively that joint inversion offers reduced uncertainty. In addition, we show how the Bayesian model ensemble can subsequently be used to derive uncertainty estimates of pore water salinity within the low salinity aquifer.