Catherine Mackay
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Catherine Mackay has a total of 1000 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gautier Hamel de Monchenault
Université Paris-Saclay
268 shared publications - Giuseppe Della Ricca
INFN Sezione di Trieste
263 shared publications - William T. Ford
University of Colorado Boulder
262 shared publications - Crisostomo Sciacca
INFN Sezione di Napoli
259 shared publications A. Khan
227 shared publicationsA. Ryd
227 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Reply on RC2
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- 9 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Open AccessReply on RC2
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- Open Access
- 9 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Reply on RC1
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- 9 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Open AccessReply on RC1
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- Open Access
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Comment on egusphere-2026-2887
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- 29 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2887
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- Open Access
- 8 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Comment on egusphere-2026-2887
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- 8 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2887
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Towards quantifying contrails of fuel cell powered aircraft: first in-flight measurements of a fuel cell exhaust emulator
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- 24 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-36
Open AccessTowards quantifying contrails of fuel cell powered aircraft: first in-flight measurements of a fuel cell exhaust emulator
Aviation forces the climate via multiple pathways: The emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) from conventional propulsion technologies has a warming effect, but also non-CO2 effects like contrail cirrus play a crucial role. For new hydrogen (H2) based propulsion concepts there are no direct CO2 and soot emissions, but higher water vapor emissions, which can affect the formation, micro-physical properties and the climate impact of contrails. In-flight measurements of relevant contrail and emission parameters of fuel cell propulsion systems are non-existent. In order to study contrail formation in the wake of fuel cell powered aircraft, a fuel cell exhaust emulator (FCEE) was designed by Airbus to produce the low temperature and high humidity exhaust conditions expected from these systems. Due to their unique exhaust composition and thermodynamic emission characteristic, processes such as plume mixing with ambient air are crucial to understand contrail formation. Further, to compare engine and fuel-dependent contrail properties, in situ methods derive a dilution corrected apparent ice emission index (AEI) using conservative tracers, like CO2 or nitrogen oxides (NOX). As the FCEE emits no such inert trace gas, a newly developed artificial dilution tracer system was used. The design and characterization of this system, as well as the significance and application for exhaust dilution and emission index assessment of fuel cell-powered aircraft in flight, are described. As part of the Nephele flight test campaign, in December 2023 in Minnesota, USA, the prototype FCEE and artificial dilution tracer release system were installed on board a Convair C131. The sampling system was installed on a Piper Cheyenne 400LS chaser aircraft, together with instrumentation for emission and contrail measurement, both aircraft operated by AV Experts LLC. A proof-of-concept of the artificial tracer system was demonstrated in contrail and emission flights. Contrails formed on aerosol particles emitted by the FCEE near the homogeneous freezing threshold (at ambient temperatures around 230 K) were sampled at 400 hPa in distances between 50 and 1500 m behind the aircraft. An increase of AEI from 1.4·1013 to 4·1015 kg-1H2 with increasing temperature difference of 3 to 5 K below the homogeneous freezing temperature was observed. As contrails from fuel cell systems already form at higher ambient temperatures compared to conventional propulsion systems, these are the first contrail measurements in this temperature range. Complementary model simulations suggest that droplet freezing is responsible for the evolution of ice crystal numbers in this temperature range.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
HYDEA Project Work Package 6: Contrail formation pathways for hydrogen combustion
Aviation’s contribution to climate change stems from both CO2 and non-CO2 emissions. Among the latter, the warming effect generated by contrail-cirrus is recognised as a major contributor, albeit large uncertainties remain (Lee et al. 2021). A condensation trail - or contrail - is composed of ice crystals which form behind an aircraft at high altitudes in sufficiently cold air. The formation is also influenced by engine technology, operating conditions and the fuel type. On the other hand, contrails are persistent in Ice Super-Saturated Regions (ISSRs) and their transition into contrail-cirrus depends on many atmospheric parameters and also on early contrail properties. ISSRs are local atmospheric air masses characterised by low temperatures and a high humidity level that is saturated versus ice. In order to reduce aviation’s climate impact, hydrogen propulsion has been considered as one promising alternative, in line with the European Green Deal and Clean Aviation Strategic Research and Innovation Agenda (SRIA). In this context, the EU-funded HYDEA project was launched in 2023. The advantage of a hydrogen-powered aircraft compared to kerosene is that the former combustion is free of carbon-dioxide emissions as well as soot particles and sulphur oxides, classical pathways to ice formation. However, H2 combustion also produces NOx and approximately 2.6 times more water-vapour than kerosene combustion. In this case, a need for modelling new ice crystal formation pathways is required to understand how ice crystals are formed and what properties they would have in order to ultimately understand their climate impacts. Consequently in HYDEA WP6, we investigate several aspects of ice crystal formation modelling for a hydrogen-powered engine. Three distinct ice crystal (IC) formation pathways were considered and investigated. On one hand ONERA uses their 3D CFD model, CEDRE, to perform high-fidelity simulations and their box model MOMIE to investigate the potential role of NOx to act as condensation nuclei. On the other hand, DLR uses their Lagrangian Cloud Module (LCM) box model approach to investigate the role of background aerosols and that of lubrication oil on IC formation. However, they need dilution information from an engine exhaust in order to perform such a study. Several simulations were performed using ANSYS CFX solver by GEAP and FLUSEPA solver by AIRBUS to “feed” DLR’s box model. The use of two distinct solvers allows for an inter-model comparison and their potential impact on the IC formation. The use of the Common Research Model (engine and aircraft) allows comparison of isolated versus installed configurations. Three configurations were considered: an isolated engine, an engine-pylon and a full aircraft configuration. While we limit our simulations to the “jet regime” (approx. 300 m downstream of the exhaust), these configurations should provide insights on their influence on the mixing process in the plume.References:Lee, David S., et al. "The contribution of global aviation to anthropogenic climate forcing for 2000 to 2018." Atmospheric environment 244 (2021): 117834.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessHYDEA Project Work Package 6: Contrail formation pathways for hydrogen combustion
Aviation’s contribution to climate change stems from both CO2 and non-CO2 emissions. Among the latter, the warming effect generated by contrail-cirrus is recognised as a major contributor, albeit large uncertainties remain (Lee et al. 2021). A condensation trail - or contrail - is composed of ice crystals which form behind an aircraft at high altitudes in sufficiently cold air. The formation is also influenced by engine technology, operating conditions and the fuel type. On the other hand, contrails are persistent in Ice Super-Saturated Regions (ISSRs) and their transition into contrail-cirrus depends on many atmospheric parameters and also on early contrail properties. ISSRs are local atmospheric air masses characterised by low temperatures and a high humidity level that is saturated versus ice. In order to reduce aviation’s climate impact, hydrogen propulsion has been considered as one promising alternative, in line with the European Green Deal and Clean Aviation Strategic Research and Innovation Agenda (SRIA). In this context, the EU-funded HYDEA project was launched in 2023. The advantage of a hydrogen-powered aircraft compared to kerosene is that the former combustion is free of carbon-dioxide emissions as well as soot particles and sulphur oxides, classical pathways to ice formation. However, H2 combustion also produces NOx and approximately 2.6 times more water-vapour than kerosene combustion. In this case, a need for modelling new ice crystal formation pathways is required to understand how ice crystals are formed and what properties they would have in order to ultimately understand their climate impacts. Consequently in HYDEA WP6, we investigate several aspects of ice crystal formation modelling for a hydrogen-powered engine. Three distinct ice crystal (IC) formation pathways were considered and investigated. On one hand ONERA uses their 3D CFD model, CEDRE, to perform high-fidelity simulations and their box model MOMIE to investigate the potential role of NOx to act as condensation nuclei. On the other hand, DLR uses their Lagrangian Cloud Module (LCM) box model approach to investigate the role of background aerosols and that of lubrication oil on IC formation. However, they need dilution information from an engine exhaust in order to perform such a study. Several simulations were performed using ANSYS CFX solver by GEAP and FLUSEPA solver by AIRBUS to “feed” DLR’s box model. The use of two distinct solvers allows for an inter-model comparison and their potential impact on the IC formation. The use of the Common Research Model (engine and aircraft) allows comparison of isolated versus installed configurations. Three configurations were considered: an isolated engine, an engine-pylon and a full aircraft configuration. While we limit our simulations to the “jet regime” (approx. 300 m downstream of the exhaust), these configurations should provide insights on their influence on the mixing process in the plume.References:Lee, David S., et al. "The contribution of global aviation to anthropogenic climate forcing for 2000 to 2018." Atmospheric environment 244 (2021): 117834.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
The prediction of Ice SuperSaturated Regions and persistent contrail formation using the modified ARPEGE weather forecast and comparison with in-flight measurements and observations.
Aviation emissions contribute to climate change, one of the key contributors being contrail cirrus clouds. The importance of the impact is strongly influenced by the conditions in which they form and evolve. A condensation trail - or contrail - is composed of ice crystals which form behind the aircraft engine exhaust at high altitudes when local weather conditions are favorable. The formation is also influenced by the engine technology and operating conditions, and by the fuel type. The contrail persists and evolves as long as it remains in an ice supersaturated region - or ISSR-, a local atmospheric air mass characterized by a low temperature and a humidity level that is saturated versus ice. Only persistent contrails are considered as having a potential climate effect.As part of the SESAR CICONIA project and in order to help the forecasting of ISSRs and hence persistent contrail regions, Météo France has implemented a modification to the cloud scheme of the ARPEGE (Action de Recherche Petite Echelle Grande Echelle) operational numerical weather prediction (NWP) model to enable the representation of ISSRs at cruise altitude. As part of the CICONIA project, Météo France provided Airbus with access to this modified version of ARPEGE to use operationally in forecasting areas where persistent contrails could be formed in flight tests.During October and November 2025 the temperature and humidity from the modified ARPEGE model was used to forecast areas of potential persistent contrail formation and the test flights were performed in these identified areas. In previous test flights the Global Forecast System (GFS) had been used and was again used for these flight tests as a comparison. In-flight humidity and temperature measurements are compared to the ARPEGE forecast by interpolating the weather data along the flight trajectories. The observation of persistent contrails is compared to their simulation along the trajectories using the Airbus in house model. These results support the verification and validation of the data from the modified ARPEGE model. In addition, for a particular day, time and area where persistent contrail coverage was forecast, the in-flight measurements from IAGOS aircraft have also been analysed to confirm where the flights were in ISSRs and if persistent contrails were formed. These results and the associated meteorological parameters were compared to the ARPEGE and GFS forecasts and the ERA5 reanalysis datasets.The stability of the forecast, which was provided as an hourly forecast for the first 48 hours and then 3 hourly up to 72 hours will be discussed. The changes to the ARPEGE model to improve the ISSR forecasts, a short description of the studies and analyses of the results for the selected flights will be presented.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessThe prediction of Ice SuperSaturated Regions and persistent contrail formation using the modified ARPEGE weather forecast and comparison with in-flight measurements and observations.
Aviation emissions contribute to climate change, one of the key contributors being contrail cirrus clouds. The importance of the impact is strongly influenced by the conditions in which they form and evolve. A condensation trail - or contrail - is composed of ice crystals which form behind the aircraft engine exhaust at high altitudes when local weather conditions are favorable. The formation is also influenced by the engine technology and operating conditions, and by the fuel type. The contrail persists and evolves as long as it remains in an ice supersaturated region - or ISSR-, a local atmospheric air mass characterized by a low temperature and a humidity level that is saturated versus ice. Only persistent contrails are considered as having a potential climate effect.As part of the SESAR CICONIA project and in order to help the forecasting of ISSRs and hence persistent contrail regions, Météo France has implemented a modification to the cloud scheme of the ARPEGE (Action de Recherche Petite Echelle Grande Echelle) operational numerical weather prediction (NWP) model to enable the representation of ISSRs at cruise altitude. As part of the CICONIA project, Météo France provided Airbus with access to this modified version of ARPEGE to use operationally in forecasting areas where persistent contrails could be formed in flight tests.During October and November 2025 the temperature and humidity from the modified ARPEGE model was used to forecast areas of potential persistent contrail formation and the test flights were performed in these identified areas. In previous test flights the Global Forecast System (GFS) had been used and was again used for these flight tests as a comparison. In-flight humidity and temperature measurements are compared to the ARPEGE forecast by interpolating the weather data along the flight trajectories. The observation of persistent contrails is compared to their simulation along the trajectories using the Airbus in house model. These results support the verification and validation of the data from the modified ARPEGE model. In addition, for a particular day, time and area where persistent contrail coverage was forecast, the in-flight measurements from IAGOS aircraft have also been analysed to confirm where the flights were in ISSRs and if persistent contrails were formed. These results and the associated meteorological parameters were compared to the ARPEGE and GFS forecasts and the ERA5 reanalysis datasets.The stability of the forecast, which was provided as an hourly forecast for the first 48 hours and then 3 hourly up to 72 hours will be discussed. The changes to the ARPEGE model to improve the ISSR forecasts, a short description of the studies and analyses of the results for the selected flights will be presented.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
HYDEA Project Work Package 6: Contrail modeling for hydrogen combustion.
Aviation emissions contribute to climate change, one of the key contributors being contrail cirrus clouds. The importance of this impact is strongly dependent on their properties . A condensation trail - or contrail - is composed of ice crystals which form behind the aircraft engine exhaust at high altitudes when local weather conditions are favorable. The formation is also influenced by the engine technology and operating conditions, and by the fuel type. The contrail persists and evolves as long as it remains in an ice supersaturated region, a local atmospheric air mass characterized by a low temperature and a humidity level that is saturated versus ice. Only persistent contrails are considered as having a climate effect.Hydrogen propulsion is considered as one promising technology to reduce aviation’s climate impact, in line with the European Green Deal and Clean Aviation Strategic Research and Innovation Agenda (SRIA). In this context, the EU-funded HYDEA project proposes a robust and efficient technology maturation plan for H2 propulsion. The formation of contrail ice crystals in an aircraft plume is mainly driven by the interaction of three physical phenomena: the dynamics in the engine exhaust, chemical transformations of effluents and microphysical processes.The main assumptions when moving from a kerosene to a H2 fueled propulsion system are that there will be no soot particles in the jet exhaust, and an increased water vapour emission compared to kerosene. New modelling chains are required to understand how, in this case, ice crystals are formed and they evolve.The models under development will be presented along with the assumptions being made. In HYDEA Work Package 6, two H2 contrail models using complementary methods are under development, using the Common Research Model [1]. The ONERA model using the 3D model CEDRE for both jet and vortex phases simulation provides a high-fidelity engine and aeroplane representation. The DLR model uses a Lagrangian Cloud Module box model approach with particle-based microphysics providing a high-fidelity microphysical representation with a simplified geometry. This ingests jet exhaust CFD data provided by Airbus and GEAP. The latest scientific developments and assumptions being incorporated in the models are discussed.[1] Development of a Common Research Model for Applied CFD Validation Studies: J. Vassberg, M. Dehaan, M. Rivers & R. Wahls. 26th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference 2012, June 2012, Hawaii, United States. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2008-6919.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessHYDEA Project Work Package 6: Contrail modeling for hydrogen combustion.
Aviation emissions contribute to climate change, one of the key contributors being contrail cirrus clouds. The importance of this impact is strongly dependent on their properties . A condensation trail - or contrail - is composed of ice crystals which form behind the aircraft engine exhaust at high altitudes when local weather conditions are favorable. The formation is also influenced by the engine technology and operating conditions, and by the fuel type. The contrail persists and evolves as long as it remains in an ice supersaturated region, a local atmospheric air mass characterized by a low temperature and a humidity level that is saturated versus ice. Only persistent contrails are considered as having a climate effect.Hydrogen propulsion is considered as one promising technology to reduce aviation’s climate impact, in line with the European Green Deal and Clean Aviation Strategic Research and Innovation Agenda (SRIA). In this context, the EU-funded HYDEA project proposes a robust and efficient technology maturation plan for H2 propulsion. The formation of contrail ice crystals in an aircraft plume is mainly driven by the interaction of three physical phenomena: the dynamics in the engine exhaust, chemical transformations of effluents and microphysical processes.The main assumptions when moving from a kerosene to a H2 fueled propulsion system are that there will be no soot particles in the jet exhaust, and an increased water vapour emission compared to kerosene. New modelling chains are required to understand how, in this case, ice crystals are formed and they evolve.The models under development will be presented along with the assumptions being made. In HYDEA Work Package 6, two H2 contrail models using complementary methods are under development, using the Common Research Model [1]. The ONERA model using the 3D model CEDRE for both jet and vortex phases simulation provides a high-fidelity engine and aeroplane representation. The DLR model uses a Lagrangian Cloud Module box model approach with particle-based microphysics providing a high-fidelity microphysical representation with a simplified geometry. This ingests jet exhaust CFD data provided by Airbus and GEAP. The latest scientific developments and assumptions being incorporated in the models are discussed.[1] Development of a Common Research Model for Applied CFD Validation Studies: J. Vassberg, M. Dehaan, M. Rivers & R. Wahls. 26th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference 2012, June 2012, Hawaii, United States. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2008-6919.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
RANS simulations for contrail formation modelling
Condensation trails (contrails) are ice clouds formed at high altitudes as a result of water-vapour condensing and freezing on soot particles and sulphate aerosols which are present in the aircraft engine plumes (case of soot-rich combustion with kerosene [1]). Under favourable atmospheric conditions such as ice supersaturated regions, i.e., low temperatures and high humidities with respect to ice, these contrails can persist for up to several hours while covering large areas. The latter is especially important when considering the climate impacts of the aviation emissions as the radiative forcing from persistent contrails and contrail-cirrus is one of the major contributors [2]. Therefore, improving the understanding of the underlying physics of contrail is of utmost importance for the development of mitigation solutions. The process of formation and early evolution of the ice crystals occurs within the first few seconds which is often referred to as the jet phase. As such, Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) serves as an important tool in studying the near-field wake of the aircraft. In this study, we use a Reynolds-Averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) CFD solver, named FLUSEPA [3], to simulate the exhaust of the Common Research Model (CRM) [4] engine up to 500 m behind the engine (focusing on the mixing of the plume and not the ice crystal formation). FLUSEPA is a solver developed by Ariane Group for launcher propulsion. Furthermore, we consider an engine powered by hydrogen combustion consequently emitting about 2.6 times more water-vapour mass than a kerosene-powered engine. Note that for a hydrogen-powered engine, depending on the design choices, ice crystals would most likely form on a combination of ambient aerosols and/or soluble NOx particles. The RANS solver is used to simulate an idealised configuration of an isolated engine. This allows us to validate the dynamics of the jet in the axial direction. We briefly describe the methodologies used so as to obtain the plume’s dilution as a function of the axial position which can then be used by an offline microphysics model to simulate ice crystal formation. Finally, we vary physical and numerical parameters relevant to contrail formation to identify their role on the dilution factor. References [1] Yu, Fangqun, et al. "Revisiting contrail ice formation: Impact of primary soot particle sizes and contribution of volatile particles." Environmental Science & Technology 58.40 (2024): 17650-17660.[2] Lee, David S., et al. "The contribution of global aviation to anthropogenic climate forcing for 2000 to 2018." Atmospheric environment 244 (2021): 117834.[3] Pont, Grégoire, and Pierre Brenner. "High order finite volume scheme and conservative grid overlapping technique for complex industrial applications." Finite Volumes for Complex Applications VIII-Hyperbolic, Elliptic and Parabolic Problems: FVCA 8, Lille, France, June 2017 8. Springer International Publishing, 2017.[4] Vassberg, John, et al. "Development of a common research model for applied CFD validation studies." 26th AIAA applied aerodynamics conference. 2008.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessRANS simulations for contrail formation modelling
Condensation trails (contrails) are ice clouds formed at high altitudes as a result of water-vapour condensing and freezing on soot particles and sulphate aerosols which are present in the aircraft engine plumes (case of soot-rich combustion with kerosene [1]). Under favourable atmospheric conditions such as ice supersaturated regions, i.e., low temperatures and high humidities with respect to ice, these contrails can persist for up to several hours while covering large areas. The latter is especially important when considering the climate impacts of the aviation emissions as the radiative forcing from persistent contrails and contrail-cirrus is one of the major contributors [2]. Therefore, improving the understanding of the underlying physics of contrail is of utmost importance for the development of mitigation solutions. The process of formation and early evolution of the ice crystals occurs within the first few seconds which is often referred to as the jet phase. As such, Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) serves as an important tool in studying the near-field wake of the aircraft. In this study, we use a Reynolds-Averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) CFD solver, named FLUSEPA [3], to simulate the exhaust of the Common Research Model (CRM) [4] engine up to 500 m behind the engine (focusing on the mixing of the plume and not the ice crystal formation). FLUSEPA is a solver developed by Ariane Group for launcher propulsion. Furthermore, we consider an engine powered by hydrogen combustion consequently emitting about 2.6 times more water-vapour mass than a kerosene-powered engine. Note that for a hydrogen-powered engine, depending on the design choices, ice crystals would most likely form on a combination of ambient aerosols and/or soluble NOx particles. The RANS solver is used to simulate an idealised configuration of an isolated engine. This allows us to validate the dynamics of the jet in the axial direction. We briefly describe the methodologies used so as to obtain the plume’s dilution as a function of the axial position which can then be used by an offline microphysics model to simulate ice crystal formation. Finally, we vary physical and numerical parameters relevant to contrail formation to identify their role on the dilution factor. References [1] Yu, Fangqun, et al. "Revisiting contrail ice formation: Impact of primary soot particle sizes and contribution of volatile particles." Environmental Science & Technology 58.40 (2024): 17650-17660.[2] Lee, David S., et al. "The contribution of global aviation to anthropogenic climate forcing for 2000 to 2018." Atmospheric environment 244 (2021): 117834.[3] Pont, Grégoire, and Pierre Brenner. "High order finite volume scheme and conservative grid overlapping technique for complex industrial applications." Finite Volumes for Complex Applications VIII-Hyperbolic, Elliptic and Parabolic Problems: FVCA 8, Lille, France, June 2017 8. Springer International Publishing, 2017.[4] Vassberg, John, et al. "Development of a common research model for applied CFD validation studies." 26th AIAA applied aerodynamics conference. 2008.