NKNaomi Klepacz

Naomi Klepacz

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Naomi Klepacz has a total of 77 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Co‐Producing an Implementation Package for the Patient‐Directed Management of Post‐Discharge General Practice Care for Older Persons

    by Rachel Ann Spencer, Naomi Klepacz, Annabelle Long, Jeremy Dale

    Background: Interdisciplinary working for the safety improvement of older patients’ care after discharge is complex. As part of the General Practice Management After Transitions Events (GP‐MATE) study, a consensus workshop was convened bringing together patients, carers, secondary and primary care clinicians to co‐produce and prioritise recommendations for how a patient‐directed post‐discharge communication tool for older people should be implemented in the NHS. Methods: We conducted a day‐long, face‐to‐face consensus workshop involving 21 participants: 10 patients, carers and public representatives; 5 secondary care frailty leaders and 6 general practice leaders. Using Nominal Group Technique, in small groups participants generated statements based on pre‐identified key ‘tensions’ derived from the 4‐year GP‐MATE study. These were then combined and moderated by the wider group and rated for acceptability and feasibility using RAND/UCLA voting across two rounds; round 2 conducted online. Results: Participants produced 52 statements; 35 were considered acceptable and feasible. The highest‑ranked emphasised patient autonomy, clarity of purpose, and involvement of community‑based professionals (including District Nursing and Urgent Community Response teams) to reach frail or housebound patients. Complete digitisation was the only statement rated inappropriate. The importance of distinguishing GP‐MATE from current ways of working was also prioritised. Conclusion: The workshop generated a set of co‑produced, theory‑informed recommendations to guide a definitive trial of GP‑MATE and support wider implementation of patient‑held communication tools in post‑discharge care. The study also demonstrated that RAND/UCLA can be successfully adapted for co‑production with mixed Public and Patient Involvement (PPI) and professional groups. Patient or Public Contribution: The GP‐MATE study was centred on Experience‐Based Co‐Design as a method for participatory action research. We began with a patient experience film featuring patients from general practice in the West‐Midlands. Our intervention was developed by three teams of older patients and carers of older persons and is reported in the US patient‐focused journal Patient Education and Counselling. In the workshop described in this paper, patients and their carers were brought to power by working in parity of numbers with hospital professionals in smaller breakout groups. Our three breakout groups were planned to be co‐facilitated by PPI‐E contributors (but on the day, only one was well enough to undertake this role). We also included a local Healthwatch lead among our participants.

  • Open Access

    Pilot of a novel patient-led intervention for postdischarge from hospital management of older patients’ care in general practice

    by Rachel Spencer, Naomi Klepacz, Annabelle Louisa Long, Simon Edward Frank Spencer, Hema Mistry, Frances Griffiths, Jeremy Dale

    Objective: General Practice Management After Transition Events (GP-MATE) is a codesigned patient-held tool to structure a dedicated postdischarge appointment for older patients. This pilot in routine general practice evaluated its feasibility (recruitment, tool use), acceptability (staff/patient views), potential outcomes (error, harm and readmission) and healthcare cost implications. Design and setting: Seven diverse general practices in the West Midlands, England, participated in this 4-year mixed-methods National Institute for Health and Care Research-funded study. A 20-minute GP-MATE appointment was offered to all patients aged >65 recently discharged from the hospital, supported by a paper-based communication tool sent to those who accepted. Three months of free-text electronic health records were reviewed for care use, intervention coverage, error, harm and readmission. Attributable healthcare costs were assessed. Patient/carer surveys and interviews with patients, carers and healthcare professionals explored experiences of delivery and use. Participants: 40 patients (mean age 75 years; 53% female) attended GP-MATE appointments, and 29 returned surveys. 17 patient-held GP-MATE forms were retrieved and analysed. Seven patients/carers and nine healthcare professionals were interviewed. Results: Care appeared safe, with tentative signs of being two-thirds less error prone ( X 2 =3.48 on 1df, p=0.06); no harms were detected. Postdischarge general practice use was high, with 115 admission-related contacts; almost two-thirds of the cohort had already received discharge-related care before GP-MATE. Despite this, GP-MATE appointments addressed persistent gaps in discharge information, leading to meaningful changes in care (mean=2.6 per patient), including new referrals and medication changes. Intervention costs represented just over half of the total mean attributable general practice care costs. Staff and patient/carer experiences indicate acceptability, though some unwell or confused patients struggled to differentiate the GP-MATE intervention from usual care. The perceived benefits were lower for elective or less complex admissions. Practices reported mixed experiences, including administrative difficulties in booking appointments and high non-attendance rates. Conclusion: GP-MATE was feasible to deliver, acceptable to staff and patients/carers and supported postdischarge communication. Larger trials are needed to establish robust evidence of readmission reduction and error/harm reduction, equity and cost-benefit.

  • Open Access

    Decarbonising General Practice: Identifying System-Level Conditions for Sustained Change

    by Naomi Klepacz, Frederik Dahlmann, Rachel Spencer, See Pdf

    Background: Decarbonisation of healthcare is a strategic priority in the UK, yet little is known about the system-level mechanisms that enable sustainability initiatives to become embedded within non-hospital settings. This paper reports the integrative synthesis from the GPNET-0 study, explaining how decarbonisation actions are mobilised, sustained, or displaced in general practice.Methods: We conducted a theory-informed synthesis across qualitative, survey, and economic strands of a multi-level mixed-methods study. A structured analytic matrix was used to integrate 174 discrete findings. Realist logic guided development of explanatory configurations linking institutional conditions, organisational processes, and implementation outcomes. Configurations were refined into programme theory testable statements. Findings: Across 17 explanatory configurations, decarbonisation was shaped less by individual attitudes than by interacting structural mechanisms. Three mechanisms consistently underpinned implementation: legitimacy (clear policy signals and leadership endorsement), system-level alignment (coherence between national, regional, and practice-level governance), and workability (integration under constrained capacity). Actions framed as discretionary, champion-led, or additive to existing workload were repeatedly displaced. By contrast, initiatives embedded within governance expectations and aligned with routine practice processes were more likely to be sustained and normalised.Interpretation: Decarbonisation in general practice is not primarily a behavioural challenge, but a structural implementation problem. Sustained change depends on institutional embedding, governance, coherence, and operational feasibility within everyday practice environments. The programme theory presented here provides a system-level explanatory framework to inform future implementation strategies and empirical testing in general practice.

  • Open Access

    Engaging patients in the decarbonisation of primary care: findings from a cross-sectional survey in England

    by Naomi Klepacz, Olivia Geddes, Frederik Dahlmann, Abi Eccles, Jenny Earle, Michael Gregg, Florence Karaba, Rachel Spencer, Jeremy Dale, Ana Raquel Nunes

    Primary care accounts for almost a quarter of the National Health Service (NHS) carbon footprint. While general practices are expected to contribute to NHS decarbonisation efforts, little is known about how patients perceive these activities. A cross-sectional survey was conducted as part of the General Practice Net Zero (GPNET-0) study across twelve general practices in three Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) in England. Adult patients who had recently attended their general practice completed an online or paper survey assessing: awareness of climate change and health, perceptions of general practice responsibility for reducing emissions, willingness to engage in sustainability-aligned behaviours if suggested by practice staff; and perceived barriers to action. Quantitative data were analysed descriptively overall and by ICB. A total of 252 patients responded (response rate 12%). Only 6.4% agreed that their general practice has a key role in reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and 5.0% felt their general practices should take greater action. Most (82.0%) disagreed that the government should do more to incentivise practice-level decarbonisation. Few respondents felt well informed about climate change (14.0%) or its health impacts (1%). Awareness of practice-level actions such as electronic communication and medicine-return schemes was moderate, but these were rarely recognised as decarbonisation measures. Around one in four reported willingness to engage in a medication review or increase active travel if suggested by practice staff. Concerns that environmental actions might compromise the quality of their care were common (72%). Decarbonisation is not currently a core expectation that patients hold for general practice. Limited awareness and engagement highlight the need to frame sustainability as supporting, rather than competing with, care quality. Embedding decarbonisation within routine service improvement may be more acceptable than positioning it as a separate priority.


  • Open Access

    General practice follow-up after hospital discharge in older adults: Retrospective records analysis

    by Naomi Klepacz, Annabelle Long, Zakia Shariff, Simon Spencer, Hema Mistry, Frances Griffiths, Jeremy Dale, Rachel Spencer

    Background: Most hospital admissions are older patients, who are more likely to be medically complex. Primary care risks after hospital discharge and readmission trajectories are relatively unexplored. Aim: To estimate the frequency and nature of errors and harms linked to discharge summary processing in general practice for patients aged ≥65 years and explore associations with readmission and healthcare utilisation from a novel primary care data source. Design and Setting: Retrospective cohort study using electronic health records (EHRs) from seven purposively sampled general practices in the West Midlands, UK. Method: We reviewed EHRs for 263 patients aged ≥65 years discharged between October 2022-2023. Outcomes included post-discharge healthcare utilisation and costs, frequency and type of discharge actions, error rates (failures to complete requested actions), harms (severity, attribution, preventability), and 90-day readmissions. Multivariable logistic regression identified predictors of errors, harms and readmission. Results: 186/263 discharged patients (70.7%) accessed post-discharge care; with 47/263 patients 17.5% (95% CI: 13.7-23.0%) having related readmissions within 90 days. The 263 discharge summaries requested 551 actions; 21.3% were not completed, over half involving medications. 12.5% of patients experienced error, 4.4% experienced harm. Most harms were preventable and resulted in hospital readmission. Error/harm disproportionately affected patients with dementia or recorded carer. Conclusion: General practice needs to review their processes for responding to patient discharge information in order to improve patient safety post-discharge. Further research into tools to assist practice with transitions is warranted.


  • Open Access

    A Delphi Study to Develop a Core Outcome Set for Capturing and Measuring Nurse Well‐Being

    by Naomi Klepacz, David S. Baldwin, Gemma Simons

    Background: Poor nurse well‐being is a significant concern, adversely affecting patient care quality and satisfaction and contributing to poor job satisfaction, increased sickness absence and workforce retention issues. There are calls for evidence‐based policies and interventions to address poor nurse well‐being, but no consensus exists on which outcomes should be captured to assess nurse well‐being. We used a salutogenic and consensus approach to develop a Core Outcome Set (COS) for nurse well‐being. Methods: A Delphi methodology was employed. Participants were recruited from two stakeholder groups: (1) nurse well‐being professionals, identified through relevant publications, conference/meeting attendance lists and peer recommendations, and (2) registered nurses working in the UK National Health Service (NHS), recruited via social media, professional nursing bodies and practitioner networks. The stakeholder panel completed two rounds of an online Delphi survey, rating 43 previously identified well‐being outcomes on a nine‐point Likert scale, from ‘not important’ to ‘critical.’ Consensus was defined as ≥ 75% of stakeholders agreeing a well‐being outcome was critical for inclusion in the COS. Results: Fifty‐four stakeholders completed the first Delphi round, and 45 participated in both rounds. Thirteen well‐being outcomes met the a priori threshold for inclusion in the COS: general well‐being, health, sleep, positive relationships, personal safety, psychological need satisfaction, psychological safety, job satisfaction, morale, life–work balance, compassion satisfaction, satisfaction with patient care and good nursing practice. The final COS was agreed by the stakeholder panel, without amendments. Conclusion: This study establishes a COS defining the nurse well‐being outcomes that should be captured when assessing nurse well‐being. Appropriate existing measurement instruments can be selected to capture these outcomes; future research is needed to identify and evaluate the most appropriate instruments and assess the feasibility of routinely capturing all 13 outcomes. Implications for Nursing Management: The COS provides nurse managers and workforce leaders with an agreed set of outcomes to support consistent nurse well‐being measurement, benchmarking and workforce monitoring. Its use can support evaluation of well‐being interventions, evidence‐informed decision‐making and the development of strategies and workplaces that enable nurses to thrive.

  • Open Access

    Understanding why resident doctors leave the NHS and what can be done to retain them: protocol for a realist synthesis

    by Naomi Klepacz, Anna Melvin, Simon Briscoe, Daniele Carrieri, Florence Katie Lock, Priya Patel, Kevin Teoh, Geoff Wong, Karen Mattick

    Introduction The UK’s medical workforce is under increasing strain, and this is compounded by increasing numbers of resident doctors diverging from specialist training pathways, instead entering non-training roles, reducing clinical hours or leaving the profession or UK workforce entirely. These decisions are shaped by both individual motivations and wider structural conditions, including unsatisfactory working conditions, limited flexibility and a perceived lack of support or autonomy. While pursuing alternative career routes offers personal and professional benefits, they can also delay progression to senior clinical roles, contributing to workforce instability. There remains limited understanding of how best to support retention, particularly given the varied contexts, settings and career trajectories of resident doctors. This realist synthesis will examine how, why and in what contexts resident doctors leave the National Health Service, and what interventions might support their retention. Methods and analysis This realist synthesis will follow Realist And Meta-narrative Evidence Synthesis: Evolving Standards guidance and will be conducted in five iterative steps: (1) identifying existing theories to develop an initial programme theory; (2) undertaking formal and purposive searches to identify relevant UK-based literature; (3) selecting documents based on relevance and rigour; (4) extracting and coding data to support the development of explanatory insights; and (5) synthesising findings using a realist logic of analysis to develop and refine context-mechanism-outcome configurations. An advisory group will guide the review throughout. The final programme theory will inform the development of evidence-based recommendations and design principles to support resident doctor retention. Ethics and dissemination Ethical approval is not required for this synthesis of existing literature. Findings will be disseminated through academic publications, conference presentations and accessible formats, including infographics, plain English summaries and blog posts. Target audiences include resident doctors, medical educators, workforce planners and policymakers. Study registration PROSPERO, CRD420251004453.

  • Open Access

    Which outcomes should be included in a core outcome set for capturing and measuring doctor well-being? A Delphi study

    by Gemma Simons, Naomi Klepacz, David S Baldwin

    Objectives To develop a core outcome set (COS) to capture and measure the well-being of doctors working in the National Health Service (NHS). Design An online Delphi study. Setting UK NHS. Participants Participants from four stakeholder groups: (1) those who might use the COS in research, (2) organisations that measure/capture NHS staff well-being, (3) professionals with experience managing NHS staff well-being and (4) NHS doctors were identified through authorship of relevant publications, attendee lists of doctor well-being conferences and meetings, professional bodies, participation in a previous study and recommendations from others. They were recruited via email. Interventions A two-stage process: (1) creating a list of 43 well-being outcomes informed by a systematic review of well-being measurement instruments, a survey of UK doctors and two doctor engagement workshops and (2) an online Delphi study (with two rounds) to reach consensus. Outcomes were rated on a 9-point Likert scale; ‘consensus’ was reached when ≥75% agreed that an outcome was critical for inclusion in the COS. Results 52 participants completed both Delphi rounds. Seven well-being outcomes met the threshold for inclusion in the COS: general well-being, health, personal safety, job satisfaction, morale, life work balance and good clinical practice. Conclusions Use of the COS has the potential to reduce heterogeneity and standardise the capture and measurement of doctor well-being, and ensure outcomes important to all stakeholders are reported. Trial registration This study was prospectively registered with the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trial initiative at www.comet-initiative.org (Registration: 1577).


  • Open Access

    Developing a Core Outcome Set for capturing and measuring nurse wellbeing: A Delphi study

    by Naomi Klepacz, David S. Baldwin, Gemma Simons

    Background: Poor nurse wellbeing is a significant concern, adversely affecting patient care quality and satisfaction, contributing to poor job satisfaction, increased sickness absence and workforce retention issues. There are calls for evidence-based policies and interventions to address poor nurse wellbeing, but no consensus exists on how it should be captured and measured. We used a salutogenic and consensus approach to develop a core outcome set (COS) for capturing and measuring nurse wellbeing. Methods: A Delphi methodology was employed. Participants were recruited from two stakeholder groups: 1) nurse wellbeing professionals, identified through relevant publications, conference/meeting attendance lists, and peer recommendations, and 2) Registered Nurses, recruited via social media, professional nursing bodies, and practitioner networks. The stakeholder panel completed two rounds of an online Delphi survey, rating 43 previously identified wellbeing outcomes on a nine-point Likert Scale, from ‘not important’ to ‘critical’. Consensus was defined as > 75% of stakeholders agreeing a wellbeing outcome was critical for inclusion in the COS. Results: Fifty-four stakeholders completed the first Delphi Round, and 45 participated in both rounds. Thirteen wellbeing outcomes met the a-priori threshold for inclusion in the COS: General Wellbeing, Health, Sleep, Positive Relationships, Personal Safety, Psychological Needs Satisfaction, Psychological Safety, Job Satisfaction, Morale, Life Work Balance, Compassion Satisfaction, Satisfaction with Patient Care, and Good Nursing Practice. The final COS was agreed by the stakeholder panel, without amendments. Conclusion: This study establishes a COS for capturing and measuring nurse wellbeing. Implementing this COS has the potential to enable consistent data collection and evidence synthesis needed to support the development of nurse wellbeing strategies, policies and interventions. Future research will focus on identifying valid and reliable measurement tools. Trial Registration: This study was prospectively registered with the COMET initiative www.comet-initiative.org (Registration: 2433)

  • Open Access

    Which outcomes should be included in a core outcome set for capturing and measuring doctor well-being? A Delphi study

    by Gemma Simons, Naomi Klepacz, David S. Baldwin

    Objectives To develop a core outcome set (COS) to capture and measure the well-being of doctors working in the NHS. Design An online Delphi study. Setting United Kingdom National Health Service. Participants Participants from four stakeholder groups: i) those who might use the COS in research, ii) organisations that measure/capture NHS staff wellbeing, iii) professionals with experience managing NHS staff wellbeing, and iv) NHS doctors, were identified through authorship of relevant publications, attendee lists of doctor well-being conferences and meetings, professional bodies, participation in a previous study and recommendations from others. They were recruited via email. Method A two-stage process: 1) creating a list of 43 wellbeing outcomes informed by a systematic review of wellbeing measurement instruments, a survey of UK doctors and 2 doctor engagement workshops, and 2) an online modified Delphi study (with two rounds) to reach consensus. Outcomes were rated on a 9-point Likert scale; ‘consensus’ was reached when Results Fifty-two participants completed both Delphi rounds. Seven wellbeing outcomes met the threshold for inclusion in the COS: General wellbeing, Health, Personal safety, Job satisfaction, Morale, Life work balance, and Good clinical practice. Conclusion Use of the COS has the potential to reduce heterogeneity and standardise the capture and measurement of doctor well-being and ensure outcomes important to all stakeholders are reported. Trial registration This study was prospectively registered with the COMET initiative www.comet-initiative.org (Registration: 1577)