Judit Sonkoly
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Judit Sonkoly has a total of 640 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Péter Török
Department of Ecology, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
42 shared publications - Béla Tóthmérész
University of Debrecen
20 shared publications - Orsolya Valkó
Lendület Seed Ecology Research Group, Institute of Ecology and Botany, HUN-REN Centre for Ecological Research, Vácrátót, Hungary
16 shared publications Katalin Tóth
Department of Ecology, University of Debrecen , Debrecen 4032
14 shared publications- Balázs Deák
HUN‐REN Centre for Ecological Research, Institute of Ecology and Botany, ‘Lendület’ Seed Ecology Research Group Vácrátót Hungary
10 shared publications Béla Tóthmérész
MTA-DE
8 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
The ‘false transience’ hypothesis: Do we need to reconsider the seed persistence classifications of soil seed bank studies?
Background and Aims: Seed bank persistence data is typically indirect, inferred from the presence and distribution of seeds in the soil. However, this approach frequently underestimates seed longevity, because dormant and low-abundance seeds can remain undetected. Here, we introduce and test the ’false transience’ hypothesis which proposes that a subset of species classified as having transient seeds based on soil seed bank (SSB) studies actually possess the capacity for long-term persistence. Their perceived transience stems from methodological limitations and ecological filters, rather than physiological constraints. We also aimed to assess how the seed mass and seed production of ‘false transient’ species compare to the full range of tested species. Methods: We focused on species considered to have transient seeds based on SSB studies. We conducted a germination experiment with 103 species using dry-stored seeds aged 10-29 years. We then assessed how the seed mass and seed number of germinating species relate to the full range of tested species. Key Results: From the 103 tested species, eight species (∼8%) germinated. The majority of species germinating after >10 years had large seeds and low seed numbers compared to the full range of species, and all germinating species had seed numbers below the median of the tested species. Conclusions: Our results provide partial support for the proposed ‘false transience’ hypothesis, showing that nearly 10% of supposedly transient species can persist after more than a decade of ex situ storage. Our results also suggest that ’false transients’ are frequently large-seeded with low seed production, therefore being more likely to be missed in SSB studies and erroneously classified as transient. We can conclude that relying solely on field SSB data to infer seed persistence can be misleading, suggesting that the widely observed negative relationship between seed size and persistence may also require reconsideration.
Open AccessThe ‘false transience’ hypothesis: Do we need to reconsider the seed persistence classifications of soil seed bank studies?
Background and Aims: Seed bank persistence data is typically indirect, inferred from the presence and distribution of seeds in the soil. However, this approach frequently underestimates seed longevity, because dormant and low-abundance seeds can remain undetected. Here, we introduce and test the ’false transience’ hypothesis which proposes that a subset of species classified as having transient seeds based on soil seed bank (SSB) studies actually possess the capacity for long-term persistence. Their perceived transience stems from methodological limitations and ecological filters, rather than physiological constraints. We also aimed to assess how the seed mass and seed production of ‘false transient’ species compare to the full range of tested species. Methods: We focused on species considered to have transient seeds based on SSB studies. We conducted a germination experiment with 103 species using dry-stored seeds aged 10-29 years. We then assessed how the seed mass and seed number of germinating species relate to the full range of tested species. Key Results: From the 103 tested species, eight species (∼8%) germinated. The majority of species germinating after >10 years had large seeds and low seed numbers compared to the full range of species, and all germinating species had seed numbers below the median of the tested species. Conclusions: Our results provide partial support for the proposed ‘false transience’ hypothesis, showing that nearly 10% of supposedly transient species can persist after more than a decade of ex situ storage. Our results also suggest that ’false transients’ are frequently large-seeded with low seed production, therefore being more likely to be missed in SSB studies and erroneously classified as transient. We can conclude that relying solely on field SSB data to infer seed persistence can be misleading, suggesting that the widely observed negative relationship between seed size and persistence may also require reconsideration.
- Open Access
High-intensity sheep grazing impoverishes soil seed banks in sand grasslands
The effects of the selection of livestock type (e.g., sheep or cattle) and grazing intensity on the soil seed bank of sand grasslands of conservation interest were studied. 25 grazed grassland sites classified into four grazing intensity categories were studied. The soil seed bank was analysed by seedling emergence; germinated seedlings were classified into morpho-functional, social behaviour type (SBT) and CSR strategy groups. The following hypotheses were tested: i) Diversity and density of soil seed banks are lower in sheep-grazed sites than in cattle-grazed ones. ii) The species composition, diversity, and density of the soil seed banks are more strongly affected by grazing intensity than by the livestock type. iii) Leaf traits, SBT and CSR strategy composition are highly affected both by livestock type and grazing intensity. The main effect of livestock type only affected seed bank density, while that of grazing intensity had a significant effect on most of the variables. Most of the studied variables were affected by the interaction of grazing intensity and livestock type. Total seed bank density was lower at all grazing intensity levels in sheep-grazed sites than in cattle-grazed ones, especially close to frequently visited places. We found that sheep grazing sustained a much lower total seed bank density and lower density of species of natural and semi-natural habitats regardless to the grazing intensity. Thus, livestock type must be carefully selected and high-intensity sheep grazing should be avoided in the long-run when managing sand grasslands.
Open AccessHigh-intensity sheep grazing impoverishes soil seed banks in sand grasslands
The effects of the selection of livestock type (e.g., sheep or cattle) and grazing intensity on the soil seed bank of sand grasslands of conservation interest were studied. 25 grazed grassland sites classified into four grazing intensity categories were studied. The soil seed bank was analysed by seedling emergence; germinated seedlings were classified into morpho-functional, social behaviour type (SBT) and CSR strategy groups. The following hypotheses were tested: i) Diversity and density of soil seed banks are lower in sheep-grazed sites than in cattle-grazed ones. ii) The species composition, diversity, and density of the soil seed banks are more strongly affected by grazing intensity than by the livestock type. iii) Leaf traits, SBT and CSR strategy composition are highly affected both by livestock type and grazing intensity. The main effect of livestock type only affected seed bank density, while that of grazing intensity had a significant effect on most of the variables. Most of the studied variables were affected by the interaction of grazing intensity and livestock type. Total seed bank density was lower at all grazing intensity levels in sheep-grazed sites than in cattle-grazed ones, especially close to frequently visited places. We found that sheep grazing sustained a much lower total seed bank density and lower density of species of natural and semi-natural habitats regardless to the grazing intensity. Thus, livestock type must be carefully selected and high-intensity sheep grazing should be avoided in the long-run when managing sand grasslands.
- Open Access
- 7 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Biological Invasions
- Vol. 28 (1) , 25
Establishment of most grassland species was not more suppressed by invasive Sporobolus cryptandrus litter than by native grass litter
Sporobolus cryptandrus , a North American C4 grass, has recently invaded European sandy grasslands, particularly in Central Europe (Hungary), where it threatens native plant communities. As allelopathy has been documented for other Sporobolus species, we tested whether litter from S. cryptandru s has a different effect on the germination and seedling emergence of native grassland species compared to native grass litter. We examined nine native grassland species and S. cryptandrus under three treatments: no litter (control), native litter and S. cryptandru s litter. We hypothesized the followings: (i) Litter addition can hinder germination compared to no-litter control because litter imposes physicochemical barriers. (ii) Following the Novel Weapons Hypothesis, Sporobolus litter may exert a stronger negative effect on native species than native grass litter. (iii) Litter effects are likely species-specific due to interspecific differences in traits and sensitivity to microenvironmental changes. Litter presence did not have a consistent negative effect across species, Sporobolus litter negatively affected germination only in Bromus tectorum . For most other species, the effects of native and Sporobolus litter were highly similar, suggesting that Sporobolus litter did not introduce physicochemical characteristics sufficiently different from native litter to produce distinct effects on native species. However, the suppression of B. tectorum germination by Sporobolus litter may indicate potential allelopathic effects. These findings suggest species-specific litter effects and highlight that Sporobolus litter could offer novel insights for managing B. tectorum , a problematic invader in North America. Future research should explore the long-term effects of Sporobolus litter in guiding restoration actions and invasive species management.
- 7 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Biological Invasions
- Vol. 28 (1) , 25
Open AccessEstablishment of most grassland species was not more suppressed by invasive Sporobolus cryptandrus litter than by native grass litter
Sporobolus cryptandrus , a North American C4 grass, has recently invaded European sandy grasslands, particularly in Central Europe (Hungary), where it threatens native plant communities. As allelopathy has been documented for other Sporobolus species, we tested whether litter from S. cryptandru s has a different effect on the germination and seedling emergence of native grassland species compared to native grass litter. We examined nine native grassland species and S. cryptandrus under three treatments: no litter (control), native litter and S. cryptandru s litter. We hypothesized the followings: (i) Litter addition can hinder germination compared to no-litter control because litter imposes physicochemical barriers. (ii) Following the Novel Weapons Hypothesis, Sporobolus litter may exert a stronger negative effect on native species than native grass litter. (iii) Litter effects are likely species-specific due to interspecific differences in traits and sensitivity to microenvironmental changes. Litter presence did not have a consistent negative effect across species, Sporobolus litter negatively affected germination only in Bromus tectorum . For most other species, the effects of native and Sporobolus litter were highly similar, suggesting that Sporobolus litter did not introduce physicochemical characteristics sufficiently different from native litter to produce distinct effects on native species. However, the suppression of B. tectorum germination by Sporobolus litter may indicate potential allelopathic effects. These findings suggest species-specific litter effects and highlight that Sporobolus litter could offer novel insights for managing B. tectorum , a problematic invader in North America. Future research should explore the long-term effects of Sporobolus litter in guiding restoration actions and invasive species management.
- Open Access
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Annals of Botany
- Vol. 137 (4) , 1026-1035
Inconsistent relationships detected between seed size, shape and persistence for different plant functional groups in the Pannonian flora
Background and Aims: Knowledge on seed persistence is vital from both theoretical and practical considerations but directly collecting persistence data for many species is unfeasible. Therefore, there is a need to identify traits associated with seed persistence, but studies about the effects of seed size and shape on persistence have yielded results varying across regions. We studied 392 species of the Pannonian flora (Central Europe) to assess (1) how seed mass and shape are related to seed persistence, (2) whether this relationship is consistent across plant functional groups, and (3) whether seed mass and shape are correlated in different functional groups. Methods: We collected data on the seed mass and persistence of species and performed measurements to calculate their seed shape index, with higher values indicating greater deviation from sphericity. To account for phylogenetic non-independence, we analysed how seed mass and seed shape index affect persistence in all 392 herbaceous species and separately in four plant functional groups using phylogenetic logistic regressions. To test how seed mass and shape are related to each other in these groups, we applied phylogenetic generalized least squares regression. Key Results: Across all species, both seed mass and seed shape index were negatively related to persistence, with seed mass having a stronger association. The same relationship was observed in forbs and short-lived species, but only seed shape was related to persistence in graminoid species. The relationship between seed mass and seed shape also varied between functional groups. Conclusions: Consistent with many studies in other floras, both seed mass and shape were negatively related to persistence in the Pannonian flora after accounting for phylogeny. However, only seed shape was associated with persistence in graminoid species, suggesting that different factors may be at play in forbs and graminoids. Therefore, future studies of this relationship may need to treat and analyse graminoids separately.
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Annals of Botany
- Vol. 137 (4) , 1026-1035
Open AccessInconsistent relationships detected between seed size, shape and persistence for different plant functional groups in the Pannonian flora
Background and Aims: Knowledge on seed persistence is vital from both theoretical and practical considerations but directly collecting persistence data for many species is unfeasible. Therefore, there is a need to identify traits associated with seed persistence, but studies about the effects of seed size and shape on persistence have yielded results varying across regions. We studied 392 species of the Pannonian flora (Central Europe) to assess (1) how seed mass and shape are related to seed persistence, (2) whether this relationship is consistent across plant functional groups, and (3) whether seed mass and shape are correlated in different functional groups. Methods: We collected data on the seed mass and persistence of species and performed measurements to calculate their seed shape index, with higher values indicating greater deviation from sphericity. To account for phylogenetic non-independence, we analysed how seed mass and seed shape index affect persistence in all 392 herbaceous species and separately in four plant functional groups using phylogenetic logistic regressions. To test how seed mass and shape are related to each other in these groups, we applied phylogenetic generalized least squares regression. Key Results: Across all species, both seed mass and seed shape index were negatively related to persistence, with seed mass having a stronger association. The same relationship was observed in forbs and short-lived species, but only seed shape was related to persistence in graminoid species. The relationship between seed mass and seed shape also varied between functional groups. Conclusions: Consistent with many studies in other floras, both seed mass and shape were negatively related to persistence in the Pannonian flora after accounting for phylogeny. However, only seed shape was associated with persistence in graminoid species, suggesting that different factors may be at play in forbs and graminoids. Therefore, future studies of this relationship may need to treat and analyse graminoids separately.
- Open Access
Unintentional seed dispersal via container-grown garden plants: Seed density and composition vary among exporter countries
The global ornamental plant trade is well-known as an important source of alien plants, but the unintentional dispersal of seeds as contaminants of this trade is rarely considered and largely understudied. We sampled the substrate of imported container-grown plants in several garden centres in Hungary to answer the following questions: (i) What species’ seeds are present in the substrate of imported garden plants and in what quantity? (ii) Do the substrates of plants imported from different countries contain seeds in different density and composition? (iii) Do characteristics of the host garden plants affect the number and diversity of seeds found in their substrate? We detected altogether 2,181 seeds of 80 taxa in the substrates. On average, 1 litre of substrate contained 36 seeds of five species. Most species were alien in Hungary and considered invasive in Europe. The majority of samples contained at least one seed of a species invasive in Europe. We found that the substrate of plants imported from different countries contained seeds in different number, diversity, and composition. Thus, the structure of the horticultural trade network can shape the alien flora of importing countries. Furthermore, the substrate of needle-leaved ornamental species contained more seeds than the substrate of broad-leaved ornamentals. Our findings demonstrate that the ornamental plant trade can disperse a large number of seeds of numerous species and introduce alien species into the importing countries. We conclude that this introduction pathway deserves greater attention in invasion biology and more studies of this phenomenon are urgently needed.
Open AccessUnintentional seed dispersal via container-grown garden plants: Seed density and composition vary among exporter countries
The global ornamental plant trade is well-known as an important source of alien plants, but the unintentional dispersal of seeds as contaminants of this trade is rarely considered and largely understudied. We sampled the substrate of imported container-grown plants in several garden centres in Hungary to answer the following questions: (i) What species’ seeds are present in the substrate of imported garden plants and in what quantity? (ii) Do the substrates of plants imported from different countries contain seeds in different density and composition? (iii) Do characteristics of the host garden plants affect the number and diversity of seeds found in their substrate? We detected altogether 2,181 seeds of 80 taxa in the substrates. On average, 1 litre of substrate contained 36 seeds of five species. Most species were alien in Hungary and considered invasive in Europe. The majority of samples contained at least one seed of a species invasive in Europe. We found that the substrate of plants imported from different countries contained seeds in different number, diversity, and composition. Thus, the structure of the horticultural trade network can shape the alien flora of importing countries. Furthermore, the substrate of needle-leaved ornamental species contained more seeds than the substrate of broad-leaved ornamentals. Our findings demonstrate that the ornamental plant trade can disperse a large number of seeds of numerous species and introduce alien species into the importing countries. We conclude that this introduction pathway deserves greater attention in invasion biology and more studies of this phenomenon are urgently needed.
- Open Access
- 25 July 2025
- Published by Wiley
Establishment of most grassland species was not more suppressed by invasive Sporobolus cryptandrus litter than by native grass litter
Sporobolus cryptandrus, a North American C4 grass, is a recent invader in some European sandy grasslands, particularly in Central Europe (Hungary), where it severely threatens native plant communities. As allelopathy has been documented for other Sporobolus species, we tested whether litter from S. cryptandrus has a different effect on the germination and seedling emergence of native grassland species compared to native grass litter. The germination and seedling growth of nine native grassland species and S. cryptandrus were examined in three treatments: without litter (control), with native litter and with S. cryptandrus litter. We hypothesized that: (i) litter has an overall negative effect on seedling germination and establishment compared to no litter; (ii) Sporobolus litter has a significantly more negative effect compared to native grass litter on seedling germination and establishment; and that (iii) the effect of litter type is highly species-specific. Our results showed that the presence of litter did not negatively affect germination and establishment across species, in fact, seedling length even increased in the presence of litter. Contrary to our expectation, Sporobolus litter negatively affected the germination and seedling growth only in the case of Bromus tectorum. For most of the other species, the effects of native and Sporobolus litter were highly similar, suggesting that litter influenced seedlings primarily through physical rather than chemical mechanisms, such as allelopathy. However, the clear suppression of B. tectorum by Sporobolus litter also suggests a potential allelopathic effect. According to our findings, litter effects are species-specific. Moreover, the suppression of B. tectorum by Sporobolus litter could offer novel insights for managing B. tectorum, a problematic invader in North America. Future research should explore the long-term effects of the litter of Sporobolus species in guiding restoration actions and invasive species management.
- 25 July 2025
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessEstablishment of most grassland species was not more suppressed by invasive Sporobolus cryptandrus litter than by native grass litter
Sporobolus cryptandrus, a North American C4 grass, is a recent invader in some European sandy grasslands, particularly in Central Europe (Hungary), where it severely threatens native plant communities. As allelopathy has been documented for other Sporobolus species, we tested whether litter from S. cryptandrus has a different effect on the germination and seedling emergence of native grassland species compared to native grass litter. The germination and seedling growth of nine native grassland species and S. cryptandrus were examined in three treatments: without litter (control), with native litter and with S. cryptandrus litter. We hypothesized that: (i) litter has an overall negative effect on seedling germination and establishment compared to no litter; (ii) Sporobolus litter has a significantly more negative effect compared to native grass litter on seedling germination and establishment; and that (iii) the effect of litter type is highly species-specific. Our results showed that the presence of litter did not negatively affect germination and establishment across species, in fact, seedling length even increased in the presence of litter. Contrary to our expectation, Sporobolus litter negatively affected the germination and seedling growth only in the case of Bromus tectorum. For most of the other species, the effects of native and Sporobolus litter were highly similar, suggesting that litter influenced seedlings primarily through physical rather than chemical mechanisms, such as allelopathy. However, the clear suppression of B. tectorum by Sporobolus litter also suggests a potential allelopathic effect. According to our findings, litter effects are species-specific. Moreover, the suppression of B. tectorum by Sporobolus litter could offer novel insights for managing B. tectorum, a problematic invader in North America. Future research should explore the long-term effects of the litter of Sporobolus species in guiding restoration actions and invasive species management.
- Open Access
Inconsistent relationships detected between seed size, shape, and persistence for different plant functional groups in the Pannonian flora
Background and Aims: Knowledge on seed persistence is vital from both theoretical and practical considerations but directly collecting seed persistence data for many species is rather unfeasible. Therefore, there is a need to identify traits that can predict seed persistence, but studies about the effects of seed size and shape on persistence yielded results varying across regions. We studied 392 species of the Pannonian flora (Central Europe) to asses (i) how seed mass and shape affect seed persistence, (ii) whether this effect is consistent across plant functional groups, and (iii) whether seed mass and shape are correlated in different functional groups? Methods: We collected data on the seed mass and persistence of species and we performed measurements to calculate their Seed Shape Index, which quantifies deviation from sphericity. We analysed how seed mass and Seed Shape Index affect persistence in all herbaceous species and separately in four plant functional groups. We also tested whether and how seed mass and shape are related to each other in these groups. Key Results: Across all species, both seed mass and Seed Shape Index negatively affected seed persistence. The same relationship was observed separately for perennials, short-lived species, and forbs, but only seed shape affected persistence in the graminoid group. Larger seeds also tended to be less spherical in graminoid species, in contrast to all studied species and to other functional groups, where we observed inverse or no relationship between seed mass and shape. Conclusions: Consistent with many studies in other floras, both seed mass and shape negatively affected seed persistence in the Pannonian flora. However, only seed shape influenced persistence in graminoid species, suggesting that different factors may be at play in forbs and graminoids. Therefore, future studies of this relationship may need to treat and analyse graminoids separately.
Open AccessInconsistent relationships detected between seed size, shape, and persistence for different plant functional groups in the Pannonian flora
Background and Aims: Knowledge on seed persistence is vital from both theoretical and practical considerations but directly collecting seed persistence data for many species is rather unfeasible. Therefore, there is a need to identify traits that can predict seed persistence, but studies about the effects of seed size and shape on persistence yielded results varying across regions. We studied 392 species of the Pannonian flora (Central Europe) to asses (i) how seed mass and shape affect seed persistence, (ii) whether this effect is consistent across plant functional groups, and (iii) whether seed mass and shape are correlated in different functional groups? Methods: We collected data on the seed mass and persistence of species and we performed measurements to calculate their Seed Shape Index, which quantifies deviation from sphericity. We analysed how seed mass and Seed Shape Index affect persistence in all herbaceous species and separately in four plant functional groups. We also tested whether and how seed mass and shape are related to each other in these groups. Key Results: Across all species, both seed mass and Seed Shape Index negatively affected seed persistence. The same relationship was observed separately for perennials, short-lived species, and forbs, but only seed shape affected persistence in the graminoid group. Larger seeds also tended to be less spherical in graminoid species, in contrast to all studied species and to other functional groups, where we observed inverse or no relationship between seed mass and shape. Conclusions: Consistent with many studies in other floras, both seed mass and shape negatively affected seed persistence in the Pannonian flora. However, only seed shape influenced persistence in graminoid species, suggesting that different factors may be at play in forbs and graminoids. Therefore, future studies of this relationship may need to treat and analyse graminoids separately.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 2 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 641 (8064) , 917-924
Global impoverishment of natural vegetation revealed by dark diversity
Anthropogenic biodiversity decline threatens the functioning of ecosystems and the many benefits they provide to humanity1. As well as causing species losses in directly affected locations, human influence might also reduce biodiversity in relatively unmodified vegetation if far-reaching anthropogenic effects trigger local extinctions and hinder recolonization. Here we show that local plant diversity is globally negatively related to the level of anthropogenic activity in the surrounding region. Impoverishment of natural vegetation was evident only when we considered community completeness: the proportion of all suitable species in the region that are present at a site. To estimate community completeness, we compared the number of recorded species with the dark diversity-ecologically suitable species that are absent from a site but present in the surrounding region2. In the sampled regions with a minimal human footprint index, an average of 35% of suitable plant species were present locally, compared with less than 20% in highly affected regions. Besides having the potential to uncover overlooked threats to biodiversity, dark diversity also provides guidance for nature conservation. Species in the dark diversity remain regionally present, and their local populations might be restored through measures that improve connectivity between natural vegetation fragments and reduce threats to population persistence.
- 2 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 641 (8064) , 917-924
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessGlobal impoverishment of natural vegetation revealed by dark diversity
Anthropogenic biodiversity decline threatens the functioning of ecosystems and the many benefits they provide to humanity1. As well as causing species losses in directly affected locations, human influence might also reduce biodiversity in relatively unmodified vegetation if far-reaching anthropogenic effects trigger local extinctions and hinder recolonization. Here we show that local plant diversity is globally negatively related to the level of anthropogenic activity in the surrounding region. Impoverishment of natural vegetation was evident only when we considered community completeness: the proportion of all suitable species in the region that are present at a site. To estimate community completeness, we compared the number of recorded species with the dark diversity-ecologically suitable species that are absent from a site but present in the surrounding region2. In the sampled regions with a minimal human footprint index, an average of 35% of suitable plant species were present locally, compared with less than 20% in highly affected regions. Besides having the potential to uncover overlooked threats to biodiversity, dark diversity also provides guidance for nature conservation. Species in the dark diversity remain regionally present, and their local populations might be restored through measures that improve connectivity between natural vegetation fragments and reduce threats to population persistence.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Vegetation Science
- Vol. 36 (2)
Enemy Behind the Gates? Predicted Climate Change and Land‐Use Intensification Likely Speed Up C4 Grass Invasions in Europe
Aims: Climate change is expected to bolster opportunities for alien species' establishment and spread. In Europe, alien C4 grass species have the potential to benefit from a changing climate, being better adapted to higher temperatures and heat stress. Our aim was to compile an up‐to‐date inventory of alien C4 grass species in Europe, to find information about their distribution and country‐ and region‐wise statuses, to identify the most widespread and high‐risk species, and the most invaded habitat types, and to draw the temporal trends of their European establishment.Location: Europe.Methods: We used the standard systematic literature review methodology to identify relevant publications and online plant distribution databases to get an up‐to‐date list of alien C4 grass species in Europe. We aimed also to gather information on (1) their current country‐ and region‐wise distribution; (2) alien status in each country (casual, naturalised, invasive); (3) the most widespread and high‐risk species; (4) native climatic zones and habitat preferences of each species in European countries; and (5) temporal distribution patterns of the identified species.Results: We detected 133 alien C4 grass species across Europe, with the highest number of species in western European countries (103 species) and the lowest in northern Europe (69 species), with considerable overlap amongst regions. Southern Europe stands out with the highest number of naturalised (55) and invasive (21) species compared to other regions, while northern Europe has the highest number of casual species (53). We identified the most widespread and high‐risk species, including those from tropical and subtropical climatic zones, which pose the highest invasion risks. These species predominantly occur in ruderal and anthropogenic habitat types, but also in natural habitat types, especially in grasslands. Regarding temporal trends, we detected an alarming increase in the establishment of tropical C4 grasses in Europe in recent decades.Conclusions: Many European countries already harbour a high number of C4 grass species, but with different alien statuses. Besides climate and invasion potential, human activities are also important factors in the ongoing invasion process of alien C4 grass species. Collective actions are required to halt this alarming biodiversity problem.
- 13 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Vegetation Science
- Vol. 36 (2)
Open AccessEnemy Behind the Gates? Predicted Climate Change and Land‐Use Intensification Likely Speed Up C4 Grass Invasions in Europe
Aims: Climate change is expected to bolster opportunities for alien species' establishment and spread. In Europe, alien C4 grass species have the potential to benefit from a changing climate, being better adapted to higher temperatures and heat stress. Our aim was to compile an up‐to‐date inventory of alien C4 grass species in Europe, to find information about their distribution and country‐ and region‐wise statuses, to identify the most widespread and high‐risk species, and the most invaded habitat types, and to draw the temporal trends of their European establishment.Location: Europe.Methods: We used the standard systematic literature review methodology to identify relevant publications and online plant distribution databases to get an up‐to‐date list of alien C4 grass species in Europe. We aimed also to gather information on (1) their current country‐ and region‐wise distribution; (2) alien status in each country (casual, naturalised, invasive); (3) the most widespread and high‐risk species; (4) native climatic zones and habitat preferences of each species in European countries; and (5) temporal distribution patterns of the identified species.Results: We detected 133 alien C4 grass species across Europe, with the highest number of species in western European countries (103 species) and the lowest in northern Europe (69 species), with considerable overlap amongst regions. Southern Europe stands out with the highest number of naturalised (55) and invasive (21) species compared to other regions, while northern Europe has the highest number of casual species (53). We identified the most widespread and high‐risk species, including those from tropical and subtropical climatic zones, which pose the highest invasion risks. These species predominantly occur in ruderal and anthropogenic habitat types, but also in natural habitat types, especially in grasslands. Regarding temporal trends, we detected an alarming increase in the establishment of tropical C4 grasses in Europe in recent decades.Conclusions: Many European countries already harbour a high number of C4 grass species, but with different alien statuses. Besides climate and invasion potential, human activities are also important factors in the ongoing invasion process of alien C4 grass species. Collective actions are required to halt this alarming biodiversity problem.
- Open Access
Origin of plant trait data matters: Shared species of Northwestern Europe and the Pannonian Ecoregion have different trait values in the two regions
Trait-based ecology considerably increased our comprehension of various fields related to ecology and evolution. As measuring traits can be time-consuming and costly, analyses regularly gather trait data from databases instead of carrying out new measurements. However, intraspecific trait variability can cause considerable differences between the trait values of different population and regions. Here we evaluated whether intraspecific trait variability causes considerable differences in trait values measured in two different regions of Europe. We tested whether regionally measured trait data from the Pannonian Ecoregion differ from trait data of the same species originating from Northwestern Europe, by comparing data from the Pannonian Database of Plant Traits (PADAPT) and the LEDA Traitbase. We evaluated six traits of the same set of species: thousand-seed mass (TSM), seed bank persistence index (SBPI), leaf area (LA), leaf dry matter content (LDMC), specific leaf area (SLA), and leaf dry mass. We found that trait data from the two databases significantly differed for TSM, SBPI, SLA, and LDMC. Our results indicate that the markedly different climate of the two regions can cause substantial intraspecific trait variation, therefore, the geographical origin of trait data matters in trait-based analyses. The findings corroborate the assumption that regionally measured trait data and building regional databases are essential for reliable regional-scale trait-based studies. We conclude that for studies analysing traits in the Pannonian Ecoregion (and possibly in Easter and Central Europe in general), it is advisable to use PADAPT instead of databases compiling data from regions with markedly different climatic conditions.
Open AccessOrigin of plant trait data matters: Shared species of Northwestern Europe and the Pannonian Ecoregion have different trait values in the two regions
Trait-based ecology considerably increased our comprehension of various fields related to ecology and evolution. As measuring traits can be time-consuming and costly, analyses regularly gather trait data from databases instead of carrying out new measurements. However, intraspecific trait variability can cause considerable differences between the trait values of different population and regions. Here we evaluated whether intraspecific trait variability causes considerable differences in trait values measured in two different regions of Europe. We tested whether regionally measured trait data from the Pannonian Ecoregion differ from trait data of the same species originating from Northwestern Europe, by comparing data from the Pannonian Database of Plant Traits (PADAPT) and the LEDA Traitbase. We evaluated six traits of the same set of species: thousand-seed mass (TSM), seed bank persistence index (SBPI), leaf area (LA), leaf dry matter content (LDMC), specific leaf area (SLA), and leaf dry mass. We found that trait data from the two databases significantly differed for TSM, SBPI, SLA, and LDMC. Our results indicate that the markedly different climate of the two regions can cause substantial intraspecific trait variation, therefore, the geographical origin of trait data matters in trait-based analyses. The findings corroborate the assumption that regionally measured trait data and building regional databases are essential for reliable regional-scale trait-based studies. We conclude that for studies analysing traits in the Pannonian Ecoregion (and possibly in Easter and Central Europe in general), it is advisable to use PADAPT instead of databases compiling data from regions with markedly different climatic conditions.