Maria Müller-Staub
Research Subjects
Maria Müller-Staub has a total of 71 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Ian Needham
Nursing Research, Center of Education & Research (COEUR), Wil, Switzerland
11 shared publicationsMary Ann Lavin
Saint Louis University School of Nursing, St. Louis, MO, USA
6 shared publicationsMatthias Odenbreit
SoH Bürgerspital Solothurn, Solothurn, Schweiz
6 shared publicationsTheo van Achterberg
Nursing Science, Centre for Quality of Care Research, University Medical Centre, St Radboud, Nijmegen, Niederlande
5 shared publications- Hanna Mayer
Department of Nursing Science with focus on Person‐Centred Care Research, Faculty of Health Sciences Karl Landsteiner University Krems Austria
4 shared publications - Ilaria Marcomini
Center for Nursing Research and Innovation, Faculty of Medicine and Surgery, Vita-Salute San Raffaele University, 20132 Milan, Italy
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 37 (2) , 165-175
Investigating nursing documentation quality using Q-DIO: A multilevel regression analysis
Purpose: To investigate the factors influencing the completion quality of nursing documentation (NDoc) in Romania using multilevel modeling. Design: Retrospective descriptive study. Method: A mixed-effect logistic regression analysis was conducted to identify factors affecting the completion of NDoc by using the Q-DIO instrument. A total of 395 NDocs were selected by probabilistic sampling. Findings: The study identified significant correlations among the Q-DIO sub-concepts. Specifically, “Nursing Diagnoses as Process” was significantly correlated with both “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” and “Nursing-Sensitive Patient Outcomes.” Additionally, “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” is correlated with “Nursing Interventions.” Among the external factors, the number of nurses involved in documentation was significantly linked to the completeness of both “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” and “Nursing Interventions.” Documentation quality also varied by hospital specialty, whereas the length of stay did not show any significant correlation with the Q-DIO sub-concepts. Conclusions: The relationships between Q-DIO sub-concepts underscore the importance of addressing every phase of the nursing process for meaningful nursing-sensitive patient outcomes. External factors significantly affect documentation completion, requiring the consideration of organizational aspects when implementing NDoc. Implications for Nursing Practice: This study highlights the need for nurses to systematically collect and document data across all phases of the nursing process. Training and support should be provided to improve the accuracy and completeness of nursing diagnoses and their linkage to interventions and outcomes. Additionally, organizational factors, such as staffing levels and the type of hospital specialty, should be carefully considered when implementing documentation innovations, as they significantly impact the quality and completeness of NDoc.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 37 (2) , 165-175
Investigating nursing documentation quality using Q-DIO: A multilevel regression analysis
Purpose: To investigate the factors influencing the completion quality of nursing documentation (NDoc) in Romania using multilevel modeling. Design: Retrospective descriptive study. Method: A mixed-effect logistic regression analysis was conducted to identify factors affecting the completion of NDoc by using the Q-DIO instrument. A total of 395 NDocs were selected by probabilistic sampling. Findings: The study identified significant correlations among the Q-DIO sub-concepts. Specifically, “Nursing Diagnoses as Process” was significantly correlated with both “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” and “Nursing-Sensitive Patient Outcomes.” Additionally, “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” is correlated with “Nursing Interventions.” Among the external factors, the number of nurses involved in documentation was significantly linked to the completeness of both “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” and “Nursing Interventions.” Documentation quality also varied by hospital specialty, whereas the length of stay did not show any significant correlation with the Q-DIO sub-concepts. Conclusions: The relationships between Q-DIO sub-concepts underscore the importance of addressing every phase of the nursing process for meaningful nursing-sensitive patient outcomes. External factors significantly affect documentation completion, requiring the consideration of organizational aspects when implementing NDoc. Implications for Nursing Practice: This study highlights the need for nurses to systematically collect and document data across all phases of the nursing process. Training and support should be provided to improve the accuracy and completeness of nursing diagnoses and their linkage to interventions and outcomes. Additionally, organizational factors, such as staffing levels and the type of hospital specialty, should be carefully considered when implementing documentation innovations, as they significantly impact the quality and completeness of NDoc.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 37 (1) , 3-15
Utilization and psychometric properties of quality of documentation of nursing diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes (Q-DIO): A scoping review
Aims: To summarize studies using the quality of diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes (Q-DIO) and to evaluate measurement properties of different Q-DIO translations/versions. This tool assesses the quality of nursing diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes documented in nursing practice. Design: A scoping review was carried out by using the updated methodology for scoping reviews of the Joanna Briggs Institute. Methods: The characteristics of different Q-DIO versions were summarized, and the methodological quality and measurement properties of the instrument(s) were assessed using the Consensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement Instruments (COSMIN) methodology. Data sources: In May 2024, searches across five databases and sources of gray literature were performed. Results: Out of 14,192 articles, 35 were deemed relevant, with 12 studies included in the COSMIN analysis. Based on the evaluation results, six versions of the Q-DIO were recommended for immediate use, and one was identified as pending further validation studies before having potential for recommendation. Conclusions: This review underscores the extensive translation, adaptation, and validation of Q-DIO instruments across various languages and cultural contexts, emphasizing their global significance and effectiveness in nursing practice. These instruments demonstrate robust psychometric properties, especially in content validity and reliability. Impact: This scoping review sheds light on the existing knowledge, application, and validity of the Q-DIO, offering suggestions for its improvement. The results could assist nurse educators, managers, and researchers in effectively using the tool. Reporting method: This study was reported following the guidelines provided by the PRISMA-ScR. Patient or public contribution: No patient or public contribution.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 37 (1) , 3-15
Utilization and psychometric properties of quality of documentation of nursing diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes (Q-DIO): A scoping review
Aims: To summarize studies using the quality of diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes (Q-DIO) and to evaluate measurement properties of different Q-DIO translations/versions. This tool assesses the quality of nursing diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes documented in nursing practice. Design: A scoping review was carried out by using the updated methodology for scoping reviews of the Joanna Briggs Institute. Methods: The characteristics of different Q-DIO versions were summarized, and the methodological quality and measurement properties of the instrument(s) were assessed using the Consensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement Instruments (COSMIN) methodology. Data sources: In May 2024, searches across five databases and sources of gray literature were performed. Results: Out of 14,192 articles, 35 were deemed relevant, with 12 studies included in the COSMIN analysis. Based on the evaluation results, six versions of the Q-DIO were recommended for immediate use, and one was identified as pending further validation studies before having potential for recommendation. Conclusions: This review underscores the extensive translation, adaptation, and validation of Q-DIO instruments across various languages and cultural contexts, emphasizing their global significance and effectiveness in nursing practice. These instruments demonstrate robust psychometric properties, especially in content validity and reliability. Impact: This scoping review sheds light on the existing knowledge, application, and validity of the Q-DIO, offering suggestions for its improvement. The results could assist nurse educators, managers, and researchers in effectively using the tool. Reporting method: This study was reported following the guidelines provided by the PRISMA-ScR. Patient or public contribution: No patient or public contribution.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 37 (1) , 133-143
Psychometric properties of the revised quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes instrument: A validation study
Aim: The aim of this study was to evaluate the psychometric properties of the revised quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes (Q-DIO R) instrument, designed to measure the quality of nursing documentation, in an Italian healthcare setting. Methods: The study followed a multi-phase validation process that included translation and cultural adaptation of the tool, expert evaluations to assess content and face validity, and a cross-sectional study to test reliability. Data were collected from nursing documentation in two hospitals in northern Italy, with 389 patient plans analyzed. Results: The Q-DIO R demonstrated strong content validity, with experts agreeing on the importance of all items. The tool showed high reliability in assessing the quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes. Regression analyses between these components revealed that accurate nursing diagnoses were associated with improved care interventions and patient outcomes. Conclusion: The revised Q-DIO R proved to be a valid and reliable tool for assessing the quality of nursing documentation in Italy. Its use can help improve nursing practices by supporting more accurate diagnosis and better care planning, ultimately leading to enhanced patient outcomes. Further research is recommended to explore other factors that may influence the quality of nursing care planning.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 37 (1) , 133-143
Psychometric properties of the revised quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes instrument: A validation study
Aim: The aim of this study was to evaluate the psychometric properties of the revised quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes (Q-DIO R) instrument, designed to measure the quality of nursing documentation, in an Italian healthcare setting. Methods: The study followed a multi-phase validation process that included translation and cultural adaptation of the tool, expert evaluations to assess content and face validity, and a cross-sectional study to test reliability. Data were collected from nursing documentation in two hospitals in northern Italy, with 389 patient plans analyzed. Results: The Q-DIO R demonstrated strong content validity, with experts agreeing on the importance of all items. The tool showed high reliability in assessing the quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes. Regression analyses between these components revealed that accurate nursing diagnoses were associated with improved care interventions and patient outcomes. Conclusion: The revised Q-DIO R proved to be a valid and reliable tool for assessing the quality of nursing documentation in Italy. Its use can help improve nursing practices by supporting more accurate diagnosis and better care planning, ultimately leading to enhanced patient outcomes. Further research is recommended to explore other factors that may influence the quality of nursing care planning.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 36 (4) , 397-408
Content validation of the NANDA-I nursing diagnosis risk for perioperative hypothermia (00254)
Purpose: The objectives of this study were to refine and validate the NANDA-I nursing diagnosis risk for perioperative hypothermia (RPH) (00254). Methods: A quantitative, descriptive study was carried out according to the adapted diagnostic content validation model by Fehring. Data from a previously conducted literature study were triangulated with expert validation data to examine the nursing diagnosis RPH as well as potentially suggested new factors resulted from the literature review. In addition, the Wisdom of Crowds model was also considered. A nonprobability sampling technique, including purposive and snowball sampling methods, was used to recruit a panel of nurse experts. An anonymous and standardized questionnaire was developed in three languages for data collection. For validation, descriptive statistics, weighted ratios, and a one-sample T -test were used. Results: Ninety-two nurse experts from seven countries and three continents participated in this study. Fifty-eight nurse experts (63%) were female, and 33 (36%) were male, with a mean age of 42.26 years and 19.22 years of working experience. The diagnosis label, definition, 4 out of 5 risk factors (RF), 6 out of 14 at-risk populations (ARPs), and 5 out of 9 associated conditions (ACs) were classified as major. One RF, eight ARP, and four ACs were considered minor. In addition, the experts validated 1 RF, 5 ARP, and 12 ACs from a previous literature study at least minor. Conclusions: The nursing diagnosis RPH (00254) could be confirmed by specialized experts. No RF, ARP, or AC of the current nursing diagnosis needed to be rejected, and the added diagnostic indicators increased the robustness of the diagnosis. Implications for nursing practice: A precise concept of the nursing diagnosis RPH improves nurses' clinical reasoning and strengthens an individualized, evidence-based care plan.
- 21 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 36 (4) , 397-408
Open AccessContent validation of the NANDA-I nursing diagnosis risk for perioperative hypothermia (00254)
Purpose: The objectives of this study were to refine and validate the NANDA-I nursing diagnosis risk for perioperative hypothermia (RPH) (00254). Methods: A quantitative, descriptive study was carried out according to the adapted diagnostic content validation model by Fehring. Data from a previously conducted literature study were triangulated with expert validation data to examine the nursing diagnosis RPH as well as potentially suggested new factors resulted from the literature review. In addition, the Wisdom of Crowds model was also considered. A nonprobability sampling technique, including purposive and snowball sampling methods, was used to recruit a panel of nurse experts. An anonymous and standardized questionnaire was developed in three languages for data collection. For validation, descriptive statistics, weighted ratios, and a one-sample T -test were used. Results: Ninety-two nurse experts from seven countries and three continents participated in this study. Fifty-eight nurse experts (63%) were female, and 33 (36%) were male, with a mean age of 42.26 years and 19.22 years of working experience. The diagnosis label, definition, 4 out of 5 risk factors (RF), 6 out of 14 at-risk populations (ARPs), and 5 out of 9 associated conditions (ACs) were classified as major. One RF, eight ARP, and four ACs were considered minor. In addition, the experts validated 1 RF, 5 ARP, and 12 ACs from a previous literature study at least minor. Conclusions: The nursing diagnosis RPH (00254) could be confirmed by specialized experts. No RF, ARP, or AC of the current nursing diagnosis needed to be rejected, and the added diagnostic indicators increased the robustness of the diagnosis. Implications for nursing practice: A precise concept of the nursing diagnosis RPH improves nurses' clinical reasoning and strengthens an individualized, evidence-based care plan.
- 22 May 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
Investigating nursing documentation quality using Q‐DIO: A multilevel regression analysis
Purpose: To investigate the factors influencing the completion quality of nursing documentation (NDoc) in Romania using multilevel modeling. Design: Retrospective descriptive study. Methods: A mixed‐effect logistic regression analysis was conducted to identify factors affecting the completion of NDoc by using the Q‐DIO instrument. A total of 395 NDocs were selected by probabilistic sampling. Findings: The study identified significant correlations among the Q‐DIO sub‐concepts. Specifically, “Nursing Diagnoses as Process” was significantly correlated with both “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” and “Nursing‐Sensitive Patient Outcomes.” Additionally, “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” is correlated with “Nursing Interventions.” Among the external factors, the number of nurses involved in documentation was significantly linked to the completeness of both “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” and “Nursing Interventions.” Documentation quality also varied by hospital specialty, whereas the length of stay did not show any significant correlation with the Q‐DIO sub‐concepts. Conclusions: The relationships between Q‐DIO sub‐concepts underscore the importance of addressing every phase of the nursing process for meaningful nursing‐sensitive patient outcomes. External factors significantly affect documentation completion, requiring the consideration of organizational aspects when implementing NDoc. Implications for Nursing Practice: This study highlights the need for nurses to systematically collect and document data across all phases of the nursing process. Training and support should be provided to improve the accuracy and completeness of nursing diagnoses and their linkage to interventions and outcomes. Additionally, organizational factors, such as staffing levels and the type of hospital specialty, should be carefully considered when implementing documentation innovations, as they significantly impact the quality and completeness of NDoc.
- 22 May 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
Investigating nursing documentation quality using Q‐DIO: A multilevel regression analysis
Purpose: To investigate the factors influencing the completion quality of nursing documentation (NDoc) in Romania using multilevel modeling. Design: Retrospective descriptive study. Methods: A mixed‐effect logistic regression analysis was conducted to identify factors affecting the completion of NDoc by using the Q‐DIO instrument. A total of 395 NDocs were selected by probabilistic sampling. Findings: The study identified significant correlations among the Q‐DIO sub‐concepts. Specifically, “Nursing Diagnoses as Process” was significantly correlated with both “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” and “Nursing‐Sensitive Patient Outcomes.” Additionally, “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” is correlated with “Nursing Interventions.” Among the external factors, the number of nurses involved in documentation was significantly linked to the completeness of both “Nursing Diagnoses as Product” and “Nursing Interventions.” Documentation quality also varied by hospital specialty, whereas the length of stay did not show any significant correlation with the Q‐DIO sub‐concepts. Conclusions: The relationships between Q‐DIO sub‐concepts underscore the importance of addressing every phase of the nursing process for meaningful nursing‐sensitive patient outcomes. External factors significantly affect documentation completion, requiring the consideration of organizational aspects when implementing NDoc. Implications for Nursing Practice: This study highlights the need for nurses to systematically collect and document data across all phases of the nursing process. Training and support should be provided to improve the accuracy and completeness of nursing diagnoses and their linkage to interventions and outcomes. Additionally, organizational factors, such as staffing levels and the type of hospital specialty, should be carefully considered when implementing documentation innovations, as they significantly impact the quality and completeness of NDoc.
- 25 April 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 36 (2) , 125-135
Physical restraint intervention in the intensive care unit: An observational pilot study
Purpose: Physical restraint (PR) is applied for patients’ safety and to prevent the removal of inserted devices. No matter how well applied, PR causes undesired effects and discomfort to patients. Because PR-Guidelines are not yet implemented in Turkey, an observational study was performed to get baseline data on the type and number of PR-activities and on patients’ complications in intensive care unit (ICU) patients. Methods: An observational pilot study was conducted in anesthesia and reanimation adult ICUs in a midsized general hospital in Turkey. Included were 31 patients and two data collection tools: a basic form (patient demographics, medical information, and complications) and a PR observation guide on nurses’ PR-activities. Descriptive statistics (frequencies, percentages, and mean and standard deviation) were used for data evaluation. Findings: Most patients (61.3%) were male, and 74.2% were aged 60–79 years. Almost a third was unconscious (Glasgow Coma Scale <9) and at risk for falling. Of the total 33 activities of the Nursing Interventions Classification (NIC), 13 were never applied in 33% of patients. The most applied activity was “provide sufficient staff to assist with the safe application of physical restraining devices or manual restraints” (96.8%). Least applied were “explain inpatient and significant others the behaviors necessary for the termination of the intervention,” “Provide the dependent patient with a means of summoning help” (6.5%), and “Teach family the risks and benefits of restraint reduction” (3.2%). Overall, 58.1% of patients had PR complications. Conclusions: For the first time, PR NIC activities were evaluated in a Turkish ICU. Findings show low performance of NIC activities and a high complication rate. Implications for nursing practice: The findings provide the basis to implement a PR-Guideline in Turkish ICUs to enhance patients’ safety and comfort.
- 25 April 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 36 (2) , 125-135
Physical restraint intervention in the intensive care unit: An observational pilot study
Purpose: Physical restraint (PR) is applied for patients’ safety and to prevent the removal of inserted devices. No matter how well applied, PR causes undesired effects and discomfort to patients. Because PR-Guidelines are not yet implemented in Turkey, an observational study was performed to get baseline data on the type and number of PR-activities and on patients’ complications in intensive care unit (ICU) patients. Methods: An observational pilot study was conducted in anesthesia and reanimation adult ICUs in a midsized general hospital in Turkey. Included were 31 patients and two data collection tools: a basic form (patient demographics, medical information, and complications) and a PR observation guide on nurses’ PR-activities. Descriptive statistics (frequencies, percentages, and mean and standard deviation) were used for data evaluation. Findings: Most patients (61.3%) were male, and 74.2% were aged 60–79 years. Almost a third was unconscious (Glasgow Coma Scale <9) and at risk for falling. Of the total 33 activities of the Nursing Interventions Classification (NIC), 13 were never applied in 33% of patients. The most applied activity was “provide sufficient staff to assist with the safe application of physical restraining devices or manual restraints” (96.8%). Least applied were “explain inpatient and significant others the behaviors necessary for the termination of the intervention,” “Provide the dependent patient with a means of summoning help” (6.5%), and “Teach family the risks and benefits of restraint reduction” (3.2%). Overall, 58.1% of patients had PR complications. Conclusions: For the first time, PR NIC activities were evaluated in a Turkish ICU. Findings show low performance of NIC activities and a high complication rate. Implications for nursing practice: The findings provide the basis to implement a PR-Guideline in Turkish ICUs to enhance patients’ safety and comfort.
- Open Access
- 8 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 36 (1) , 3-15
“Eat Enough”—A nurse-led intervention to enhance hospitalized older adults’ protein and energy nutrition
Purpose: To develop an intervention enhancing hospitalized older adults’ nutrition. Methods: For the first time, a mixed-methods design with data triangulation was applied according to the six-step model of Corry et al. to elaborate on a complex nursing intervention in the form of a logic model. Patients who were aged ≥80 years and hospitalized for at least 5 days were included. Sample size for quantitative practice analysis was 135 older adults, whereas 22 older inpatients participated in interviews and observations for needs analysis and generated data for key principles. Findings: The intervention “Eat Enough” encompasses nursing team culture and comprises six actionable targets to deliver needs-based support and reach required protein and energy intake for hospitalized older adults by sensitizing nurses and the interprofessional team. Facilitating nutritional intake would be supported by an advanced practice nurse who considers the medical and nursing care plan and therapy. Conclusions: The intervention “Eat Enough” demonstrates that nurses play a key role in interprofessional teams to enhance older adults’ nutrition in hospital. The pipeline model displays how the actionable targets can be achieved, and how awareness raising can influence the context—leading to raised calories and protein requirement coverages and shorter length of stay. Implications for clinical practice: By identifying risk factors of malnutrition and strengthening nurses’ responsibilities, the intervention “Eat Enough” could significantly enhance nutrition among hospitalized older adults. However, the logic model should be tested and implemented in future research.
- 8 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 36 (1) , 3-15
Open Access“Eat Enough”—A nurse-led intervention to enhance hospitalized older adults’ protein and energy nutrition
Purpose: To develop an intervention enhancing hospitalized older adults’ nutrition. Methods: For the first time, a mixed-methods design with data triangulation was applied according to the six-step model of Corry et al. to elaborate on a complex nursing intervention in the form of a logic model. Patients who were aged ≥80 years and hospitalized for at least 5 days were included. Sample size for quantitative practice analysis was 135 older adults, whereas 22 older inpatients participated in interviews and observations for needs analysis and generated data for key principles. Findings: The intervention “Eat Enough” encompasses nursing team culture and comprises six actionable targets to deliver needs-based support and reach required protein and energy intake for hospitalized older adults by sensitizing nurses and the interprofessional team. Facilitating nutritional intake would be supported by an advanced practice nurse who considers the medical and nursing care plan and therapy. Conclusions: The intervention “Eat Enough” demonstrates that nurses play a key role in interprofessional teams to enhance older adults’ nutrition in hospital. The pipeline model displays how the actionable targets can be achieved, and how awareness raising can influence the context—leading to raised calories and protein requirement coverages and shorter length of stay. Implications for clinical practice: By identifying risk factors of malnutrition and strengthening nurses’ responsibilities, the intervention “Eat Enough” could significantly enhance nutrition among hospitalized older adults. However, the logic model should be tested and implemented in future research.
- 31 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
Utilization and psychometric properties of Quality of documentation of Nursing Diagnoses, Interventions, and Outcomes (Q‐DIO): A scoping review
Aims: To summarize studies using the quality of diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes (Q‐DIO) and to evaluate measurement properties of different Q‐DIO translations/versions. This tool assesses the quality of nursing diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes documented in nursing practice. Design: A scoping review was carried out by using the updated methodology for scoping reviews of the Joanna Briggs Institute. Methods: The characteristics of different Q‐DIO versions were summarized, and the methodological quality and measurement properties of the instrument(s) were assessed using the Consensus‐based Standards for the selection of health Measurement Instruments (COSMIN) methodology. Data sources: In May 2024, searches across five databases and sources of gray literature were performed. Results: Out of 14,192 articles, 35 were deemed relevant, with 12 studies included in the COSMIN analysis. Based on the evaluation results, six versions of the Q‐DIO were recommended for immediate use, and one was identified as pending further validation studies before having potential for recommendation. Conclusions: This review underscores the extensive translation, adaptation, and validation of Q‐DIO instruments across various languages and cultural contexts, emphasizing their global significance and effectiveness in nursing practice. These instruments demonstrate robust psychometric properties, especially in content validity and reliability. Impact: This scoping review sheds light on the existing knowledge, application, and validity of the Q‐DIO, offering suggestions for its improvement. The results could assist nurse educators, managers, and researchers in effectively using the tool. Reporting method: This study was reported following the guidelines provided by the PRISMA‐ScR. Patient or public contribution: No patient or public contribution.
- 31 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
Utilization and psychometric properties of Quality of documentation of Nursing Diagnoses, Interventions, and Outcomes (Q‐DIO): A scoping review
Aims: To summarize studies using the quality of diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes (Q‐DIO) and to evaluate measurement properties of different Q‐DIO translations/versions. This tool assesses the quality of nursing diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes documented in nursing practice. Design: A scoping review was carried out by using the updated methodology for scoping reviews of the Joanna Briggs Institute. Methods: The characteristics of different Q‐DIO versions were summarized, and the methodological quality and measurement properties of the instrument(s) were assessed using the Consensus‐based Standards for the selection of health Measurement Instruments (COSMIN) methodology. Data sources: In May 2024, searches across five databases and sources of gray literature were performed. Results: Out of 14,192 articles, 35 were deemed relevant, with 12 studies included in the COSMIN analysis. Based on the evaluation results, six versions of the Q‐DIO were recommended for immediate use, and one was identified as pending further validation studies before having potential for recommendation. Conclusions: This review underscores the extensive translation, adaptation, and validation of Q‐DIO instruments across various languages and cultural contexts, emphasizing their global significance and effectiveness in nursing practice. These instruments demonstrate robust psychometric properties, especially in content validity and reliability. Impact: This scoping review sheds light on the existing knowledge, application, and validity of the Q‐DIO, offering suggestions for its improvement. The results could assist nurse educators, managers, and researchers in effectively using the tool. Reporting method: This study was reported following the guidelines provided by the PRISMA‐ScR. Patient or public contribution: No patient or public contribution.
- 26 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
Psychometric properties of the revised quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes instrument: A validation study
Aim: The aim of this study was to evaluate the psychometric properties of the revised quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes (Q‐DIO R) instrument, designed to measure the quality of nursing documentation, in an Italian healthcare setting. Methods: The study followed a multi‐phase validation process that included translation and cultural adaptation of the tool, expert evaluations to assess content and face validity, and a cross‐sectional study to test reliability. Data were collected from nursing documentation in two hospitals in northern Italy, with 389 patient plans analyzed. Results: The Q‐DIO R demonstrated strong content validity, with experts agreeing on the importance of all items. The tool showed high reliability in assessing the quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes. Regression analyses between these components revealed that accurate nursing diagnoses were associated with improved care interventions and patient outcomes. Conclusion: The revised Q‐DIO R proved to be a valid and reliable tool for assessing the quality of nursing documentation in Italy. Its use can help improve nursing practices by supporting more accurate diagnosis and better care planning, ultimately leading to enhanced patient outcomes. Further research is recommended to explore other factors that may influence the quality of nursing care planning.
- 26 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
Psychometric properties of the revised quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes instrument: A validation study
Aim: The aim of this study was to evaluate the psychometric properties of the revised quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes (Q‐DIO R) instrument, designed to measure the quality of nursing documentation, in an Italian healthcare setting. Methods: The study followed a multi‐phase validation process that included translation and cultural adaptation of the tool, expert evaluations to assess content and face validity, and a cross‐sectional study to test reliability. Data were collected from nursing documentation in two hospitals in northern Italy, with 389 patient plans analyzed. Results: The Q‐DIO R demonstrated strong content validity, with experts agreeing on the importance of all items. The tool showed high reliability in assessing the quality of nursing diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes. Regression analyses between these components revealed that accurate nursing diagnoses were associated with improved care interventions and patient outcomes. Conclusion: The revised Q‐DIO R proved to be a valid and reliable tool for assessing the quality of nursing documentation in Italy. Its use can help improve nursing practices by supporting more accurate diagnosis and better care planning, ultimately leading to enhanced patient outcomes. Further research is recommended to explore other factors that may influence the quality of nursing care planning.
- 14 July 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 35 (3) , 298-307
The quality of nursing diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes in Romanian nursing documentation measured with the Q-DIO: A cross-sectional study
Purpose: To assess the quality of the nursing process in Romania by evaluating nursing documentations with the quality of diagnoses, interventions and outcomes (Q-DIO) measurement instrument. Methods: A quantitative cross-sectional research design was employed using probabilistic sampling to select nursing documentations from a Romanian university hospital. The data were analyzed using the Q-DIO measurement instrument. Findings: Low quality levels of nursing process documentation were found. The Q-DIO subscale “Nursing diagnoses as process” (assessment) revealed a mean = 1.36 (SD 0.52) of maximum 2. Nurses collected lots of data but did not use these to state nursing diagnoses. “Nursing diagnoses as product” showed inaccurate diagnoses; mean = 1.24 (SD 0.48) of maximum 4. Nursing interventions were planned and documented, but their impact on the etiology of nursing diagnoses was low; mean = 0.76 (SD 0.18). The quality of nursing outcomes mean was 0.57 (SD 0.29). Nurses failed making connections between nursing assessment, diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes, and standardized nursing languages (SNLs) were not used. Statistically significant differences were found among all Q-DIO sub-concepts except for “Nursing diagnoses as process.” Conclusions: The documentation was structured but did not support the nursing process and its documentation, and SNLs were not implemented. There was an underutilization of data to state nursing diagnoses, and nursing interventions were mostly ineffective, leading to low nursing outcomes. Implications for nursing practice: This study provides new insights on the nursing process and its documentation in Romania and a baseline for future research. Policymakers, administrators, and educators should consider educating nurses to use standardized nursing languages and apply the Advanced Nursing Process .
- 14 July 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Journal of Nursing Knowledge
- Vol. 35 (3) , 298-307
The quality of nursing diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes in Romanian nursing documentation measured with the Q-DIO: A cross-sectional study
Purpose: To assess the quality of the nursing process in Romania by evaluating nursing documentations with the quality of diagnoses, interventions and outcomes (Q-DIO) measurement instrument. Methods: A quantitative cross-sectional research design was employed using probabilistic sampling to select nursing documentations from a Romanian university hospital. The data were analyzed using the Q-DIO measurement instrument. Findings: Low quality levels of nursing process documentation were found. The Q-DIO subscale “Nursing diagnoses as process” (assessment) revealed a mean = 1.36 (SD 0.52) of maximum 2. Nurses collected lots of data but did not use these to state nursing diagnoses. “Nursing diagnoses as product” showed inaccurate diagnoses; mean = 1.24 (SD 0.48) of maximum 4. Nursing interventions were planned and documented, but their impact on the etiology of nursing diagnoses was low; mean = 0.76 (SD 0.18). The quality of nursing outcomes mean was 0.57 (SD 0.29). Nurses failed making connections between nursing assessment, diagnoses, interventions, and outcomes, and standardized nursing languages (SNLs) were not used. Statistically significant differences were found among all Q-DIO sub-concepts except for “Nursing diagnoses as process.” Conclusions: The documentation was structured but did not support the nursing process and its documentation, and SNLs were not implemented. There was an underutilization of data to state nursing diagnoses, and nursing interventions were mostly ineffective, leading to low nursing outcomes. Implications for nursing practice: This study provides new insights on the nursing process and its documentation in Romania and a baseline for future research. Policymakers, administrators, and educators should consider educating nurses to use standardized nursing languages and apply the Advanced Nursing Process .