RRRachel Renbarger

Rachel Renbarger

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Rachel Renbarger has a total of 56 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Unveiling Racism: A Systematic Review of Racism Survey Measures in Education

    by Wendy Castillo, Juan Cruz, Rachel Renbarger, Christen Priddie, Brein Mosely, Sasha Mejia-Bradford

    Education policy research aimed at eliminating racism necessitates methodological innovation that fosters both racial equity–centered approaches and robust empirical analysis of the systemic and structural nature of racism. Most quantitative research in educational psychology does not account for racism in its modeling, thereby obscuring the racialized environments in which students learn (DeCuir-Gunby & Schutz, 2014; Strunk & Andrzejewski, 2023). Drawing from Bronfenbrenner’s ecological systems theory and the ethos of QuantCrit, this study evaluates various scales to highlight gaps and challenges in measuring racism within school settings. This review aims to uplift measures for researchers to use in their work and advocate for more targeted resources and reparations. Reviewing 66 studies and 50 unique scales, key findings include the overreliance on scales designed to measure racial discrimination at the intrapersonal level, while systemic and structural factors are often overlooked. Most measures were self-report surveys for older students developed more than 15 years ago. The results demonstrate the need to move beyond measures of intrapersonal racism to more up-to-date, multidimensional tools. The study’s findings also underscore the necessity of constant reevaluation of the tools so they keep pace with the shifting cultural realities of how racism operates, and the specific ways it impacts racially minoritized communities. As racism continues to evolve, so too must the methods by which it is measured.

  • Open Access

    Delayed Causal Effects? An Examination of Long-Term Effects of the Broncos FIRST FYE

    by Daniel Collier, Daniel Fitzpatrick, Rachel Renbarger

    This study evaluates the long-term causal impacts of Western Michigan University's Broncos FIRST (BF) program-a targeted first-year experience (FYE) supporting socioeconomically disadvantaged students. While some trends indicate improved GPA and degree attainment, results are mixed and often not statistically significant. Notably, benefits were uneven across subgroups, raising questions about targeted program design and resource allocation. The high cost (~$2,500 per student) coupled with limited significant outcomes suggests a need for more nuanced, culturally responsive approaches. Policymakers and university leaders should consider expanding targeted supports beyond socioeconomic factors to foster equitable, sustained student success.

  • Open Access

    Critical Possibilities

    by Rachel Renbarger, Philosophy Documentation Center

    To address racial inequity, researchers have called for critical quantitative approaches that reclaim statistics. Using one critical quantitative methodological framework, QuantCrit, and one theoretical framework, intersectionality, this paper provides considerations for critical education researchers when working with a popular source of data: secondary datasets. Based on a scoping review of work from education, social science, and beyond, I provide ways for educational researchers to act for social justice starting from the beginning of a study through the dissemination of findings. These steps encourage more reflective, community-oriented, and interdisciplinary research rather than provide a prescriptive set of guidelines.


  • SHARING CAPITAL: FIRST-GENERATION, LOW-INCOME, AND STUDENTS OF COLOR WITHIN PHD PROGRAMS "LIFT WHILE THEY CLIMB"

    by Rachel Renbarger

    As doctoral programs graduate fewer students from marginalized communities (first-generation, low-income, and students of color), it is important to understand the experiences of these students. Yet few studies examine how marginalized student groups serve others as an act of persistence. The purpose of this study was to examine how marginalized doctoral students served others as an act of persistence. Using the community cultural wealth framework, this qualitative case study utilized documents and multiple interviews to understand how marginalized PhD students gave back while in graduate school and the rationale for doing so. Doctoral students served their communities within three themes: helping their specific community, benefiting professionally, and giving back to maintain their own mental health. These scholars shared multiple forms of capital, including social, resistant, and navigational capital. Findings indicate that service helps students' persistence, and this study expands the concept of equity ethic. Results suggest that all students bring assets to their programs and that these assets can contribute to individual students' success but also to the success of their cohort and future cohorts.


  • Open Access

    Improving Equitable Access to Graduate Education by Reducing Barriers to Minoritized Student Success

    by David M. Rehfeld, Rachel Renbarger, Tracey Sulak, Abby Kugler, Payton DeMeyer

    Structural inequities in graduate education perpetuate inequity for students with historically minoritized identities. This paper reviews previous reports of inequities faced by students with minoritized identities and suggests a path forward for improving equitable access to doctoral study. Specifically, this paper suggests investing in the scholarship of teaching and learning while using Gardner’s model of doctoral student development to provide targeted support at different levels of operation: the institution, the department, and the individual. Evidence for suggested supports is also provided and a call for further research on the effects of such programs for recruitment, retention, and graduation of minoritized students is made.


  • Open Access

    Roadblocks to Effective District, Family, and Community Collaboration: A Phenomenology Study of Potential Challenges and Solutions

    by Rachel Renbarger, Liza Rodler, Gabrielle Espina, Amreen Thompson, Amy Detgen, Marcia Sobers, Felix Fernandez, Risa Sackman, Patrice Williams, Eleanor Newsome


  • Open Access

    Open Science Practices in Early Childhood Special Education Research: A Systematic Review and Conceptual Replication

    by Sondra M Stegenga, Crystal Nicole Steltenpohl, Rachel Renbarger, Lindsay Ellis Lee, Laurel Standiford Reyes, Hilary Lustick, Melanie S. Meyer

    Open science practices have expanded to many fields in the natural and social sciences, though it is unclear the extent to which they have permeated early childhood special education research, particularly when looking across the range of methodologies (e.g., quantitative, qualitative, mixed methods). Before making suggestions on what researchers in this field should be doing, one must first understand what practices are currently being used and what potential barriers or supports there might be to use. To this end, we will systematically review empirical research (qualitative, mixed methods, and quantitative) in the early childhood special education literature. We will code each study for the inclusion of open science practices (e.g., preregistration; shared material, data, code; open access). We will then calculate descriptive statistics to explore the implementation rates of open science practices, including the most used practices and differences across study characteristics (e.g., journal, year) and methodologies (quantitative, qualitative, and mixed methods). We will also compare implementation rates of open science practices to a previous study on K-12 special education to begin to understand potential differences across specialization areas in education. This systematic review is a first step in identifying potential determinants for broader implementation of open science practices across a range of research and specialty areas.


  • Champions of Transparency in Education: What Journal Reviewers Can Do to Encourage Open Science Practices

    by Rachel Renbarger, Jill L. Adelson, Joshua M. Rosenberg, Sondra M. Stegenga, Olivia Lowrey, Pamela R. Buckley, Qiyang Zhang

    As the field of education, and especially gifted education, gradually moves toward open science, our research community increasingly values transparency and openness brought by open science practices. Yet, individual researchers may be reluctant to adopt open science practices due to low incentives, barriers of extra workload, or lack of support to apply these in certain areas, such as qualitative research. We encourage and give guidelines to reviewers to champion open science practices by warmly influencing authors to consider applying open science practices to quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods research and providing ample support to produce higher-quality publications. Instead of imposing open science practices on authors, we advocate reviewers suggest small, non-threatening, specific steps to support authors without making them feel overwhelmed, judged, or punished. We believe that these small steps taken by reviewers will make a difference to create a more supportive environment for researchers to adopt more open science practices.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Rethinking Transparency and Rigor from a Qualitative Open Science Perspective

    by Crystal N. Steltenpohl, Hilary Lustick, Melanie S. Meyer, Linsday Ellis Lee, Sondra M. Stegenga, Laurel Standiford Reyes, Rachel L. Renbarger

    Discussions around transparency in open science focus primarily on sharing data, materials, and coding schemes, especially as these practices relate to reproducibility. This fairly quantitative perspective of transparency does not align with all scientific methodologies. Indeed, qualitative researchers also care deeply about how knowledge is produced, what factors influence the research process, and how to share this information. Explicating a researcher’s background and role allows researchers to consider their impact on the research process and interpretation of the data, thereby increasing both transparency and rigor. Researchers may engage in positionality and reflexivity in a variety of ways, and transparently sharing these steps allows readers to draw their own informed conclusions about the results and study as a whole. Imposing a limited, quantitatively-informed set of standards on all research can cause harm to researchers and the communities they work with if researchers are not careful in considering the impact of such standards. Our paper will argue the importance of avoiding strong defaults around transparency (e.g., always share data) and build upon previous work around qualitative open science. We explore how transparency in all aspects of our research can lend itself toward projecting and confirming the rigor of our work.