Jean-Baptiste Durand
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Jean-Baptiste Durand has a total of 108 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Benoit R. Cottereau
Univ. Toulouse, CNRS, CerCo, Toulouse, France
8 shared publications Yves Trotter
Centre de Recherche Cerveau et Cognition, Université de Toulouse, Toulouse, France
8 shared publications- Franck-Emmanuel Roux
INSERM 825 et Service de Neurochirurgie, Hôpital Purpan, F-31059 Toulouse, France
6 shared publications - Samy Rima
Universite de Toulouse, Centre de Recherche Cerveau et Cognition, Toulouse, France
6 shared publications - Guy A. Orban
Department of Medicine and Surgery, University of Parma, Parma, Italy
5 shared publications - Nathalie Vayssière
Université de Toulouse, CNRS, CerCo, Toulouse, France
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 January 2026
- Published by MIT Press in Imaging Neuroscience
- Vol. 4
Cortical processing for the vestibular and visual input of egomotion in macaque monkeys: Separate networks with targeted convergence
The integration of visual and vestibular inputs during egomotion is fundamental for both postural and navigational control. In the present study, we used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) in four macaque monkeys to investigate cortical activation in response to galvanic vestibular stimulation (GVS), applied through transmastoid electrodes, and egomotion-compatible (EC) optic flow patterns. Visual and vestibular stimulations activate two largely independent cortical networks: the vestibular network encompasses the insular cortex, superior parietal lobule, frontal lobe, and cingulate cortex, while optic flow primarily activates regions in the superior temporal sulcus, temporo-parietal junction, inferior parietal lobule, and restricted portions of the cingulate and frontal cortices. Despite this segregation, several areas exhibit visuo-vestibular convergence: ventral posterior suprasylvian (VPS) in the temporo-parietal junction, area 7 in the inferior parietal lobule, ventral intraparietal area (VIP) and LIP in the intraparietal sulcus, MSTd in the superior temporal sulcus, CSv in the cingulate sulcus, and FEFsem in the frontal cortex. These findings demonstrate that visual and vestibular signals generated by egomotion are processed in extended and distinct cortical networks with several narrow convergence sites, consistent with the idea that multisensory integration during self-motion is achieved through selective convergence rather than general network overlap.
- 12 January 2026
- Published by MIT Press in Imaging Neuroscience
- Vol. 4
Open AccessCortical processing for the vestibular and visual input of egomotion in macaque monkeys: Separate networks with targeted convergence
The integration of visual and vestibular inputs during egomotion is fundamental for both postural and navigational control. In the present study, we used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) in four macaque monkeys to investigate cortical activation in response to galvanic vestibular stimulation (GVS), applied through transmastoid electrodes, and egomotion-compatible (EC) optic flow patterns. Visual and vestibular stimulations activate two largely independent cortical networks: the vestibular network encompasses the insular cortex, superior parietal lobule, frontal lobe, and cingulate cortex, while optic flow primarily activates regions in the superior temporal sulcus, temporo-parietal junction, inferior parietal lobule, and restricted portions of the cingulate and frontal cortices. Despite this segregation, several areas exhibit visuo-vestibular convergence: ventral posterior suprasylvian (VPS) in the temporo-parietal junction, area 7 in the inferior parietal lobule, ventral intraparietal area (VIP) and LIP in the intraparietal sulcus, MSTd in the superior temporal sulcus, CSv in the cingulate sulcus, and FEFsem in the frontal cortex. These findings demonstrate that visual and vestibular signals generated by egomotion are processed in extended and distinct cortical networks with several narrow convergence sites, consistent with the idea that multisensory integration during self-motion is achieved through selective convergence rather than general network overlap.
- Open Access
Cortical Processing for the Vestibular and Visual Input of Egomotion in Macaque Monkeys: Separate Networks with Targeted Convergence
The integration of visual and vestibular inputs during egomotion is fundamental for both postural and navigational control. In the present study, we used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) in four macaque monkeys to investigate cortical activation in response to galvanic vestibular stimulation (GVS), applied through transmastoid electrodes, and egomotion-compatible (EC) optic flow patterns. Visual and vestibular stimulations activate two largely independent cortical networks: the vestibular network encompasses the insular cortex, superior parietal lobule, frontal lobe, and cingulate cortex, while optic flow primarily activates regions in the superior temporal sulcus, temporo-parietal junction, inferior parietal lobule, and restricted portions of the cingulate and frontal cortices. Despite this segregation, several areas exhibit visuo-vestibular convergence: VPS in the temporo-parietal junction, area 7 in the inferior parietal lobule, VIP and LIP in the intraparietal sulcus, MSTd in the superior temporal sulcus, CSv in the cingulate sulcus, and FEFsem in the frontal cortex. These findings demonstrate that visual and vestibular signals generated by egomotion are processed in extended and distinct cortical networks with several narrow convergence sites, consistent with the idea that multisensory integration during self-motion is achieved through selective convergence rather than general network overlap.
Open AccessCortical Processing for the Vestibular and Visual Input of Egomotion in Macaque Monkeys: Separate Networks with Targeted Convergence
The integration of visual and vestibular inputs during egomotion is fundamental for both postural and navigational control. In the present study, we used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) in four macaque monkeys to investigate cortical activation in response to galvanic vestibular stimulation (GVS), applied through transmastoid electrodes, and egomotion-compatible (EC) optic flow patterns. Visual and vestibular stimulations activate two largely independent cortical networks: the vestibular network encompasses the insular cortex, superior parietal lobule, frontal lobe, and cingulate cortex, while optic flow primarily activates regions in the superior temporal sulcus, temporo-parietal junction, inferior parietal lobule, and restricted portions of the cingulate and frontal cortices. Despite this segregation, several areas exhibit visuo-vestibular convergence: VPS in the temporo-parietal junction, area 7 in the inferior parietal lobule, VIP and LIP in the intraparietal sulcus, MSTd in the superior temporal sulcus, CSv in the cingulate sulcus, and FEFsem in the frontal cortex. These findings demonstrate that visual and vestibular signals generated by egomotion are processed in extended and distinct cortical networks with several narrow convergence sites, consistent with the idea that multisensory integration during self-motion is achieved through selective convergence rather than general network overlap.
- Open Access
- 23 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Experimental Brain Research
- Vol. 243 (6) , 1-15
Visuo-vestibular integration for self-motion: human cortical area V6 prefers forward and congruent stimuli
The integration of visual and vestibular input is crucial for self-motion. Information from both sensory systems merges early in the central nervous system. Among the numerous cortical areas involved in processing this information, some (V6 and the ventral intraparietal area –VIP) respond specifically to vestibular anteroposterior information. A series of experiments were carried out to further understand the involvement of these and other areas in self-motion processing when vestibular and visual information are combined with varying congruence and direction parameters. Fifteen subjects underwent an MRI session while receiving visual (optic flow patterns) and galvanic vestibular stimuli, mimicking six conditions: (1) visual forward, (2) visual backward, visual forward with (3) congruent or (4) incongruent vestibular information, visual backward with (5) congruent or (6) incongruent vestibular information. At the voxel-wise level, adding vestibular stimulation to optic flow stimulation activated several bilateral areas located predominantly in the insular cortex. However, the region of interest (ROI) analysis of these areas indicated that none of them exhibits any specificity for the forward/backward direction or for the visuo-vestibular congruency. By extending the ROI approach to other well-known visuo-vestibular areas, we found that the parieto-occipital area V6 is unique in showing not only an increased level of activation for concurrent visual and vestibular stimulation, but also a marked preference when these signals are congruent and specify forward motion. Since area V6 is the only region more active when both visual and vestibular signals specify the most common self-motion direction (i.e. forward self-motion), our results support the view that this area plays a crucial role in visuo-vestibular integration during locomotion. This could be the first step towards the construction of a conscious perception of self-motion, possibly involving other areas.
- 23 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Experimental Brain Research
- Vol. 243 (6) , 1-15
Open AccessVisuo-vestibular integration for self-motion: human cortical area V6 prefers forward and congruent stimuli
The integration of visual and vestibular input is crucial for self-motion. Information from both sensory systems merges early in the central nervous system. Among the numerous cortical areas involved in processing this information, some (V6 and the ventral intraparietal area –VIP) respond specifically to vestibular anteroposterior information. A series of experiments were carried out to further understand the involvement of these and other areas in self-motion processing when vestibular and visual information are combined with varying congruence and direction parameters. Fifteen subjects underwent an MRI session while receiving visual (optic flow patterns) and galvanic vestibular stimuli, mimicking six conditions: (1) visual forward, (2) visual backward, visual forward with (3) congruent or (4) incongruent vestibular information, visual backward with (5) congruent or (6) incongruent vestibular information. At the voxel-wise level, adding vestibular stimulation to optic flow stimulation activated several bilateral areas located predominantly in the insular cortex. However, the region of interest (ROI) analysis of these areas indicated that none of them exhibits any specificity for the forward/backward direction or for the visuo-vestibular congruency. By extending the ROI approach to other well-known visuo-vestibular areas, we found that the parieto-occipital area V6 is unique in showing not only an increased level of activation for concurrent visual and vestibular stimulation, but also a marked preference when these signals are congruent and specify forward motion. Since area V6 is the only region more active when both visual and vestibular signals specify the most common self-motion direction (i.e. forward self-motion), our results support the view that this area plays a crucial role in visuo-vestibular integration during locomotion. This could be the first step towards the construction of a conscious perception of self-motion, possibly involving other areas.
- Open Access
Visuo-Vestibular Integration for Self-Motion: Human Cortical Area V6 Prefers Forward and Congruent Stimuli
BACKGROUND: The integration of visual and vestibular input is crucial for self-motion. Information from both sensory systems merges early in the central nervous system. Among the numerous cortical areas involved in processing this information, some (V6 and VIP) respond specifically to vestibular anteroposterior information. OBJECTIVE: To further understand the involvement of these and other areas in self-motion processing when vestibular and visual information are combined with varying congruence and direction parameters. METHODS: Fifteen subjects underwent an MRI session while receiving visual (optic flow patterns) and galvanic vestibular stimuli mimicking six conditions: (1) visual forward, (2) visual backward, visual forward with (3) congruent or (4) incongruent vestibular information, visual backward with (5) congruent or (6) incongruent vestibular information. RESULTS: The combination of concurrent vestibular stimulation and fully consistant optic flow patterns activated several bilateral cortical areas found predominantly in the insula. Among these vestibular areas and those previously defined in our initial study, the large majority do not show any specifity for the forward/backward direction or for the visuo-vestibular congruency. A notable exception was the parieto-occipital area V6, which showed a marked preference for congruent visuo-vestibular signals and for cues signaling forward motion. CONCLUSIONS: By showing that V6 is more active when visuo-vestibular signals are more ecological ( i.e. when both signals specify the most common self-motion direction), our results support the view that this area plays a crucial role in visuo-vestibular integration during self-motion.
Open AccessVisuo-Vestibular Integration for Self-Motion: Human Cortical Area V6 Prefers Forward and Congruent Stimuli
BACKGROUND: The integration of visual and vestibular input is crucial for self-motion. Information from both sensory systems merges early in the central nervous system. Among the numerous cortical areas involved in processing this information, some (V6 and VIP) respond specifically to vestibular anteroposterior information. OBJECTIVE: To further understand the involvement of these and other areas in self-motion processing when vestibular and visual information are combined with varying congruence and direction parameters. METHODS: Fifteen subjects underwent an MRI session while receiving visual (optic flow patterns) and galvanic vestibular stimuli mimicking six conditions: (1) visual forward, (2) visual backward, visual forward with (3) congruent or (4) incongruent vestibular information, visual backward with (5) congruent or (6) incongruent vestibular information. RESULTS: The combination of concurrent vestibular stimulation and fully consistant optic flow patterns activated several bilateral cortical areas found predominantly in the insula. Among these vestibular areas and those previously defined in our initial study, the large majority do not show any specifity for the forward/backward direction or for the visuo-vestibular congruency. A notable exception was the parieto-occipital area V6, which showed a marked preference for congruent visuo-vestibular signals and for cues signaling forward motion. CONCLUSIONS: By showing that V6 is more active when visuo-vestibular signals are more ecological ( i.e. when both signals specify the most common self-motion direction), our results support the view that this area plays a crucial role in visuo-vestibular integration during self-motion.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2024
- Published by Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology (ARVO) in Journal of Vision
- Vol. 24 (7) , 14
Illusory light drives pupil responses in primates
In humans, the eye pupils respond to both physical light sensed by the retina and mental representations of light produced by the brain. Notably, our pupils constrict when a visual stimulus is illusorily perceived brighter, even if retinal illumination is constant. However, it remains unclear whether such perceptual penetrability of pupil responses is an epiphenomenon unique to humans or whether it represents an adaptive mechanism shared with other animals to anticipate variations in retinal illumination between successive eye fixations. To address this issue, we measured the pupil responses of both humans and macaque monkeys exposed to three chromatic versions (cyan, magenta, and yellow) of the Asahi brightness illusion. We found that the stimuli illusorily perceived brighter or darker trigger differential pupil responses that are very similar in macaques and human participants. Additionally, we show that this phenomenon exhibits an analogous cyan bias in both primate species. Beyond evincing the macaque monkey as a relevant model to study the perceptual penetrability of pupil responses, our results suggest that this phenomenon is tuned to ecological conditions because the exposure to a “bright cyan-bluish sky” may be associated with increased risks of dazzle and retinal damages.
- 2 July 2024
- Published by Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology (ARVO) in Journal of Vision
- Vol. 24 (7) , 14
Open AccessIllusory light drives pupil responses in primates
In humans, the eye pupils respond to both physical light sensed by the retina and mental representations of light produced by the brain. Notably, our pupils constrict when a visual stimulus is illusorily perceived brighter, even if retinal illumination is constant. However, it remains unclear whether such perceptual penetrability of pupil responses is an epiphenomenon unique to humans or whether it represents an adaptive mechanism shared with other animals to anticipate variations in retinal illumination between successive eye fixations. To address this issue, we measured the pupil responses of both humans and macaque monkeys exposed to three chromatic versions (cyan, magenta, and yellow) of the Asahi brightness illusion. We found that the stimuli illusorily perceived brighter or darker trigger differential pupil responses that are very similar in macaques and human participants. Additionally, we show that this phenomenon exhibits an analogous cyan bias in both primate species. Beyond evincing the macaque monkey as a relevant model to study the perceptual penetrability of pupil responses, our results suggest that this phenomenon is tuned to ecological conditions because the exposure to a “bright cyan-bluish sky” may be associated with increased risks of dazzle and retinal damages.
- Open Access
ILLUSORY LIGHT DRIVES PUPIL RESPONSES IN PRIMATES
In humans, the eye pupils respond to both physical light sensed by the retina and mental representations of light produced by the brain. Notably, our pupils constrict when a visual stimulus is illusorily perceived brighter, even if retinal illumination is constant. Yet, it remains unclear whether such perceptual penetrability of pupil responses is an epiphenomenon unique to humans or whether it represents an adaptive mechanism shared with other animals to anticipate variations in retinal illumination between successive eye fixations. To address this issue, we measured the pupil responses of both humans and macaque monkeys exposed to three chromatic versions (cyan, magenta, and yellow) of the Asahi brightness illusion. We found that the stimuli illusorily perceived brighter or darker trigger differential pupil responses that are very similar in macaques and human participants. Additionally, we show that this phenomenon exhibits an analogous cyan bias in both primate species. Beyond evincing the macaque monkey as a relevant model to study the perceptual penetrability of pupil responses, our results suggest that this phenomenon is tuned to ecological conditions since the exposure to a “bright cyan-bluish sky” may be associated with increased risks of dazzle and retinal damages.
Open AccessILLUSORY LIGHT DRIVES PUPIL RESPONSES IN PRIMATES
In humans, the eye pupils respond to both physical light sensed by the retina and mental representations of light produced by the brain. Notably, our pupils constrict when a visual stimulus is illusorily perceived brighter, even if retinal illumination is constant. Yet, it remains unclear whether such perceptual penetrability of pupil responses is an epiphenomenon unique to humans or whether it represents an adaptive mechanism shared with other animals to anticipate variations in retinal illumination between successive eye fixations. To address this issue, we measured the pupil responses of both humans and macaque monkeys exposed to three chromatic versions (cyan, magenta, and yellow) of the Asahi brightness illusion. We found that the stimuli illusorily perceived brighter or darker trigger differential pupil responses that are very similar in macaques and human participants. Additionally, we show that this phenomenon exhibits an analogous cyan bias in both primate species. Beyond evincing the macaque monkey as a relevant model to study the perceptual penetrability of pupil responses, our results suggest that this phenomenon is tuned to ecological conditions since the exposure to a “bright cyan-bluish sky” may be associated with increased risks of dazzle and retinal damages.
- Open Access
- 21 February 2023
- Published by Elsevier in NeuroImage
- Vol. 270, 119959
Towards an optimization of functional localizers in non-human primate neuroimaging with (fMRI) frequency-tagging
- 21 February 2023
- Published by Elsevier in NeuroImage
- Vol. 270, 119959
Open AccessTowards an optimization of functional localizers in non-human primate neuroimaging with (fMRI) frequency-tagging
- Open Access
- 13 June 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Brain Structure and Function
- Vol. 226 (9) , 2897-2909
An egocentric straight-ahead bias in primate’s vision
As we plan to reach or manipulate objects, we generally orient our body so as to face them. Other objects occupying the same portion of space will likely represent potential obstacles for the intended action. Thus, either as targets or as obstacles, the objects located straight in front of us are often endowed with a special behavioral status. Here, we review a set of recent electrophysiological, imaging and behavioral studies bringing converging evidence that the objects which lie straight-ahead are subject to privileged visual processing. More precisely, these works collectively demonstrate that when gaze steers central vision away from the straight-ahead direction, the latter is still prioritized in peripheral vision. Straight-ahead objects evoke (1) stronger neuronal responses in macaque peripheral V1 neurons, (2) stronger EEG and fMRI activations across the human visual cortex and (3) faster reactive hand and eye movements. Here, we discuss the functional implications and underlying mechanisms behind this phenomenon. Notably, we propose that it can be considered as a new type of visuospatial attentional mechanism, distinct from the previously documented classes of endogenous and exogenous attention.
- 13 June 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Brain Structure and Function
- Vol. 226 (9) , 2897-2909
Open AccessAn egocentric straight-ahead bias in primate’s vision
As we plan to reach or manipulate objects, we generally orient our body so as to face them. Other objects occupying the same portion of space will likely represent potential obstacles for the intended action. Thus, either as targets or as obstacles, the objects located straight in front of us are often endowed with a special behavioral status. Here, we review a set of recent electrophysiological, imaging and behavioral studies bringing converging evidence that the objects which lie straight-ahead are subject to privileged visual processing. More precisely, these works collectively demonstrate that when gaze steers central vision away from the straight-ahead direction, the latter is still prioritized in peripheral vision. Straight-ahead objects evoke (1) stronger neuronal responses in macaque peripheral V1 neurons, (2) stronger EEG and fMRI activations across the human visual cortex and (3) faster reactive hand and eye movements. Here, we discuss the functional implications and underlying mechanisms behind this phenomenon. Notably, we propose that it can be considered as a new type of visuospatial attentional mechanism, distinct from the previously documented classes of endogenous and exogenous attention.
- Open Access
- 17 October 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Cerebral Cortex
- Vol. 31 (2) , 1347-1364
Connectivity of the Cingulate Sulcus Visual Area (CSv) in Macaque Monkeys
In humans, the posterior cingulate cortex contains an area sensitive to visual cues to self-motion. This cingulate sulcus visual area (CSv) is structurally and functionally connected with several (multi)sensory and (pre)motor areas recruited during locomotion. In nonhuman primates, electrophysiology has shown that the cingulate cortex is also related to spatial navigation. Recently, functional MRI in macaque monkeys identified a cingulate area with similar visual properties to human CSv. In order to bridge the gap between human and nonhuman primate research, we examined the structural and functional connectivity of putative CSv in three macaque monkeys adopting the same approach as in humans based on diffusion MRI and resting-state functional MRI. The results showed that putative monkey CSv connects with several visuo-vestibular areas (e.g., VIP/FEFsem/VPS/MSTd) as well as somatosensory cortex (e.g., dorsal aspects of areas 3/1/2), all known to process sensory signals that can be triggered by self-motion. Additionally, strong connections are observed with (pre)motor areas located in the dorsal prefrontal cortex (e.g., F3/F2/F1) and within the anterior cingulate cortex (e.g., area 24). This connectivity pattern is strikingly reminiscent of that described for human CSv, suggesting that the sensorimotor control of locomotion relies on similar organizational principles in human and nonhuman primates.
- 17 October 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Cerebral Cortex
- Vol. 31 (2) , 1347-1364
Open AccessConnectivity of the Cingulate Sulcus Visual Area (CSv) in Macaque Monkeys
In humans, the posterior cingulate cortex contains an area sensitive to visual cues to self-motion. This cingulate sulcus visual area (CSv) is structurally and functionally connected with several (multi)sensory and (pre)motor areas recruited during locomotion. In nonhuman primates, electrophysiology has shown that the cingulate cortex is also related to spatial navigation. Recently, functional MRI in macaque monkeys identified a cingulate area with similar visual properties to human CSv. In order to bridge the gap between human and nonhuman primate research, we examined the structural and functional connectivity of putative CSv in three macaque monkeys adopting the same approach as in humans based on diffusion MRI and resting-state functional MRI. The results showed that putative monkey CSv connects with several visuo-vestibular areas (e.g., VIP/FEFsem/VPS/MSTd) as well as somatosensory cortex (e.g., dorsal aspects of areas 3/1/2), all known to process sensory signals that can be triggered by self-motion. Additionally, strong connections are observed with (pre)motor areas located in the dorsal prefrontal cortex (e.g., F3/F2/F1) and within the anterior cingulate cortex (e.g., area 24). This connectivity pattern is strikingly reminiscent of that described for human CSv, suggesting that the sensorimotor control of locomotion relies on similar organizational principles in human and nonhuman primates.
- 1 October 2020
- Published by Journal of Neurosurgery Publishing Group (JNSPG) in Journal of Neurosurgery
- Vol. 133 (4) , 1191-1201
Intraoperative electrostimulation for awake brain mapping: how many positive interference responses are required for reliability?
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to characterize the reproducibility of language trials within and between brain mapping sessions.METHODS: Brain mapping and baseline testing data from 200 adult patients who underwent resection of left-hemisphere tumors were evaluated. Data from 11 additional patients who underwent a second resection for recurrence were analyzed separately to investigate reproducibility over time. In all cases, a specific protocol of electrostimulation brain mapping with a controlled naming task was used to detect language areas, and the results were statistically compared with preoperative and intraoperative baseline naming error rates. All patients had normal preoperative error rates, controlled for educational level and age (mean 8.92%, range 0%–16.25%). Intraoperative baseline error rates within the normal range were highly correlated with preoperative ones (r = 0.74, p < 10−10), although intraoperative rates were usually higher (mean 13.30%, range 0%–26.67%). Initially, 3 electrostimulation trials were performed in each cortical area. If 2 of 3 trials showed language interference, 1 or 2 additional trials were performed (depending on results).RESULTS: In the main group of 200 patients, there were 82 single interferences (i.e., positive results in 1 of 3 trials), 227 double interferences (2/3), and 312 full interferences (3/3). Binomial statistics revealed that full interferences were statistically significant (vs intraoperative baseline) in 92.7% of patients, while double interferences were significant only in 38.5% of patients, those with the lowest error rates. On further testing, one-third of the 2/3 trials became 2/4 trials, which was significant in only one-quarter of patients. Double interference could be considered significant for most patients (> 90%) when confirmed by 2 subsequent positive trials (4/5). In the 11 patients who were operated on twice, only 26% of areas that tested positive in the initial operation tested positive in the second and showed the same type of interference and the same current threshold (i.e., met all 3 criteria).CONCLUSIONS: Electrostimulation trials in awake brain mapping produced graded patterns of positive reproducibility levels, and their significance varied with the baseline error rates. The results suggest that caution is warranted when 2 of 3 trials are positive, although the need for additional trials depends on the individual patients’ baseline error rates. Reproducibility issues should be considered in the interpretation of data from awake brain mapping.
- 1 October 2020
- Published by Journal of Neurosurgery Publishing Group (JNSPG) in Journal of Neurosurgery
- Vol. 133 (4) , 1191-1201
Intraoperative electrostimulation for awake brain mapping: how many positive interference responses are required for reliability?
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to characterize the reproducibility of language trials within and between brain mapping sessions.METHODS: Brain mapping and baseline testing data from 200 adult patients who underwent resection of left-hemisphere tumors were evaluated. Data from 11 additional patients who underwent a second resection for recurrence were analyzed separately to investigate reproducibility over time. In all cases, a specific protocol of electrostimulation brain mapping with a controlled naming task was used to detect language areas, and the results were statistically compared with preoperative and intraoperative baseline naming error rates. All patients had normal preoperative error rates, controlled for educational level and age (mean 8.92%, range 0%–16.25%). Intraoperative baseline error rates within the normal range were highly correlated with preoperative ones (r = 0.74, p < 10−10), although intraoperative rates were usually higher (mean 13.30%, range 0%–26.67%). Initially, 3 electrostimulation trials were performed in each cortical area. If 2 of 3 trials showed language interference, 1 or 2 additional trials were performed (depending on results).RESULTS: In the main group of 200 patients, there were 82 single interferences (i.e., positive results in 1 of 3 trials), 227 double interferences (2/3), and 312 full interferences (3/3). Binomial statistics revealed that full interferences were statistically significant (vs intraoperative baseline) in 92.7% of patients, while double interferences were significant only in 38.5% of patients, those with the lowest error rates. On further testing, one-third of the 2/3 trials became 2/4 trials, which was significant in only one-quarter of patients. Double interference could be considered significant for most patients (> 90%) when confirmed by 2 subsequent positive trials (4/5). In the 11 patients who were operated on twice, only 26% of areas that tested positive in the initial operation tested positive in the second and showed the same type of interference and the same current threshold (i.e., met all 3 criteria).CONCLUSIONS: Electrostimulation trials in awake brain mapping produced graded patterns of positive reproducibility levels, and their significance varied with the baseline error rates. The results suggest that caution is warranted when 2 of 3 trials are positive, although the need for additional trials depends on the individual patients’ baseline error rates. Reproducibility issues should be considered in the interpretation of data from awake brain mapping.