RSRachel A. Searston

Rachel A. Searston

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Rachel A. Searston has a total of 689 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Identity in the spotlight: Matching faces without overlapping features

    by Rachel A. Searston, Daniel J. Carragher

    One-to-one face matching is widely used for identity verification yet becomes difficult with unfamiliar faces or when parts of the face are covered. We investigated whether observers could accurately verify identity from different nonoverlapping facial fragments. Each stimulus of our novel face-matching task had the appearance of a single face image as revealed through four circular ‘spotlights,’ one from each quadrant of the face. Observers judged whether the designated target spotlight (from Image A) depicted the same identity as the three reference spotlights sampled from a different image (all from Image B). Across three experiments, we examined observers’ matching performance for familiar and unfamiliar faces under Baseline (Experiment 1), Scrambled (Experiment 2), and Inverted (Experiment 3) spotlight arrangements. Accuracy reliably exceeded chance across all but one condition: familiar inverted faces. A familiar-face advantage emerged under baseline conditions, disappeared when the spatial layout was scrambled, and reversed under inversion—while unfamiliar-face accuracy remained robust to these manipulations. These findings demonstrate that observers can exploit latent identity information without direct feature correspondence to achieve above-chance accuracy in identification and reveal an unexpected dissociation between familiar-face and unfamiliar-face matching when spatial orientation is disrupted in these highly challenging conditions.

  • Open Access

    Identity in the Spotlight: Matching Faces Without Overlapping Features

    by Rachel A Searston, Daniel James Carragher

    One-to-one face matching is widely used for identity verification yet becomes difficult with unfamiliar faces or when parts of the face are covered. We investigated whether observers could accurately verify identity from different non-overlapping facial fragments. Each stimulus of our novel face matching task had the appearance of a single face image as revealed through four circular 'spotlights,' one from each quadrant of the face. Observers judged whether the designated target spotlight (from image A) depicted the same identity as the three reference spotlights sampled from a different image (all from image B). Across three experiments, we examined observers' matching performance for familiar and unfamiliar faces under Baseline (Experiment 1), Scrambled (Experiment 2), and Inverted (Experiment 3) spotlight arrangements. Accuracy reliably exceeded chance across all but one condition: familiar inverted faces. A familiar-face advantage emerged under baseline conditions, disappeared when the spatial layout was scrambled, and reversed under inversion —while unfamiliar face accuracy remained robust to these manipulations. These findings demonstrate that observers can exploit latent identity information without direct feature correspondence to achieve above chance accuracy in identification and reveal an unexpected dissociation between familiar and unfamiliar face matching when spatial orientation is disrupted in these highly challenging conditions.

  • Open Access

    Towards cumulative forensic science: A commentary on ‘Methodological problems in every black-box study of forensic firearm comparisons’

    by Jason Chin, Bethany Growns, Kylie Hunter, Adele Quigley-McBride, Rachel A Searston, Stephanie Summersby, Matthew B Thompson, Alice Towler

    Cuellar et al. (2024) recently found that methodological flaws in black-box studies of forensic firearms analysis mean that validity cannot be determined from those studies. Their paper can also be read to indicate that the presence of some of these flaws means that the associated study is so unsound that it can only be used to plan future properly designed validation studies. We seek to clarify that each of the identified flaws, taken individually, does not necessarily prevent studies from contributing to a strong, cumulative research basis for forensic practices. That said, we agree that the overall body of research must avoid the flaws identified by Cuellar and colleagues, and based on their analysis, it appears the overall body of research has not avoided these flaws. We go on to suggest practices that can help ensure forensic science studies can efficiently and safely build on each other.

  • Open Access

    Beyond minutiae: inferring missing details from global structure in fingerprints

    by Rachel A. Searston, Matthew B. Thompson, Samuel G. Robson, Jason M. Tangen

    Visual inference involves using prior knowledge and contextual cues to make educated guesses about incomplete or ambiguous information. This study explores the role of visual inference as a function of expertise in the context of fingerprint examination, where professional examiners need to determine whether two fingerprints were left by the same person, or not, often based on limited or impoverished visual information. We compare expert and novice performance on two tasks: inferring the missing details of a print at an artificial blank spot (Experiment 1) and identifying the missing surrounds of a print given only a small fragment of visual detail (Experiment 2). We hypothesized that experts would demonstrate superior performance by leveraging their extensive experience with global fingerprint patterns. Consistent with our predictions, we found that while both experts and novices performed above chance, experts consistently outperformed novices. These findings suggest that expertise in fingerprint examination involves a heightened sensitivity to gist, or global image properties within a print, enabling experts to make more accurate inferences about missing details. These results align with prior research on perceptual expertise in other expert domains, such as radiology, and extend our understanding of scene and face recognition to fingerprint examination. Our findings show that expertise emerges from an ability to combine local and global visual information—experts skillfully process both the fine details and overall patterns in fingerprints. This research provides insight into how perceptual expertise supports accurate visual discrimination in a high-stakes, real-world task with broader implications for theoretical models of visual cognition.


  • Open Access

    Beyond Minutiae: Inferring Missing Details from Global Structure in Fingerprints

    by Rachel A Searston, Matthew B Thompson, Samuel Gebhard Robson, Jason Marcus Tangen

    Visual inference involves using prior knowledge and contextual cues to make educated guesses about incomplete or ambiguous information. This study explores the role of visual inference as a function of expertise in the context of fingerprint examination, where professional examiners need to determine whether two fingerprints were left by the same person, or not, often based on limited or impoverished visual information. We compare expert and novice performance on two tasks: inferring the missing details of a print at an artificial blank spot (Experiment 1) and identifying the missing surrounds of a print given only a small fragment of visual detail (Experiment 2). We hypothesized that experts would demonstrate superior performance by leveraging their extensive experience with global fingerprint patterns. Consistent with our predictions, we found that while both experts and novices performed above chance, experts consistently outperformed novices. These findings suggest that expertise in fingerprint examination involves a heightened sensitivity to gist, or global image properties within a print, enabling experts to make more accurate inferences about missing details. These results align with prior research on perceptual expertise in other expert domains, such as radiology, and extend our understanding of scene and face recognition to fingerprint examination. Our findings show that expertise emerges from an ability to combine local and global visual information—experts skillfully process both the fine details and overall patterns in fingerprints. This research provides insight into how perceptual expertise supports accurate visual discrimination in a high-stakes, real-world task with broader implications for theoretical models of visual cognition.

  • Open Access

    A plan for systematic reviews for high-need areas in forensic science

    by Jason Chin, Anna-Maria Arabia, Merryn McKinnon, Matthew James Page, Rachel A Searston

    Forensic scientific practitioners and researchers must navigate a rapidly growing body of research. This makes it difficult to both inform courts about the state of the field and to keep track of questions that need to be researched. When similar challenges have arisen in other fields, they have turned to systematic reviews, which are research reviews that use formal, articulated methods to provide a comprehensive summary of the literature on a specific research question. Systematic reviews allow users to evaluate how the authors identified research and synthesised its findings, making them more transparent than informal literature reviews. This article lays out a justification and plan for systematic reviews in forensic science.

  • Open Access

    Understanding ‘error’ in the forensic sciences: A primer

    by Kristy A. Martire, Jason M. Chin, Carolyn Davis, Gary Edmond, Bethany Growns, Stacey Gorski, Richard I. Kemp, Zara Lee, Christopher M. Verdon, Gabrielle Jansen, et al.


  • Open Access

    Navigating Scientific Disagreement: The Effect of Expertise, Interestedness, and Scientific Literacy on Trust in Scientists and Belief in Science Claims

    by Natasha van Antwerpen, Estelle Green, Daniel Sturman, Rachel A Searston

    Media disagreements about science can blur distinctions between experts and non-experts, potentially eroding public trust in scientific claims. We explore how trust in scientific claims and experts is affected by the expertise and vested interests of dissenting voices, and scientific literacy’s role. In an experiment, participants (N = 105) read science news articles featuring disagreement between experts. The dissenting expert's expertise and potential conflicts of interest were varied. Results show scientists were deemed more trustworthy when disagreeing experts had vested interests or lacked domain expertise. Furthermore, those with higher scientific literacy better assessed claims and trustworthiness based on these factors.

  • Open Access

    Medical AI for Radiology: The Lost Cognitive Perspective

    by Lana Tikhomirov, Carolyn Semmler, Rachel A Searston

    The development and commercialisation of medical artificial intelligence (AI) decision-systems far outpaces our understanding of their value for clinicians. Although applicable across many forms of medicine, we focus on characterising the diagnostic decisions of radiologists, review the differences between clinician decision-making and medical AI model decision-making, and reveal how these differences pose fundamental challenges for integrating AI into radiology. We argue that clinicians are contextually motivated, mentally resourceful decision-makers, whereas AI models are contextually stripped, correlational decision-makers, and discuss misconceptions about clinician-AI interaction stemming from this misalignment of capabilities. We outline a series of recommendations for future research to enhance the safety and usability of AI models in high-risk medical decision-making contexts.


  • Open Access

    Clear thinking in deep space: A guide by cognitive scientists

    by Anastasia Ejova, Rachel A Searston, Rachel Gloria Stephens, Carolyn Semmler

    This is a preprint of a chapter published in "Human Uses of Outer Space" - edited by Melissa de Zwart, John Culton, Stacey Henderson, Amit Srivastava, and Deborah Turnbull.