Rahul Telang
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Rahul Telang has a total of 88 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Michael D. Smith
School of Information Systems and Management, Heinz College, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15213
15 shared publications - Tridas Mukhopadhyay
Tepper School of Business, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15213
7 shared publications - Ashish Arora
Fuqua School of Business, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina 27708; and National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138
5 shared publications Brett Danaher
Chapman University, Orange, CA
4 shared publications- Muhammad Zia Hydari
School of Business, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15260
4 shared publications Pedro Ferreira
H. John Heinz III College and Engineering and Public Policy Department, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15213
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 35 (11) , 3895-3913
Merchants of vulnerabilities: How bug bounty programs benefit software vendors
We study how bug bounty programs (BBPs) shape software vendors’ security and release choices. Vendors invest in internal assurance before release to reduce residual vulnerabilities, and after launch they must manage vulnerability discovery, disclosure, and remediation. We develop a game-theoretic model in which a vendor chooses release timing and severity-contingent bounties, anticipating effort by ethical and malicious hackers in a winner-take-all discovery race. The model highlights two linked mechanisms: an incentive channel that shifts first discovery of severe vulnerabilities away from malicious exploitation and toward ethical reporting, and a governance channel in which coordinated disclosure changes how vulnerability information is managed while remediation is underway. We derive closed-form optimal bounties and characterize a feasibility region that sustains positive bounties and interior success probabilities. Within this region, a BBP strictly increases the vendor’s expected profit by reallocating first-discovery probability on severe vulnerabilities from malicious to ethical hackers and by converting part of severe-loss exposure into bounded, pay-for-results expenditures. For private programs, we also solve for the optimal invited set of ethical hackers and show that this optimal set is strictly smaller than the expected number of malicious attackers. Higher bounties raise ethical hackers’ effort and first-discovery probabilities but also increase program cost, and they interact with reputational (non-monetary) incentives. Finally, in the baseline model, BBP adoption conditionally reduces the marginal value of additional pre-release delay and therefore conditionally implies earlier release relative to the no-BBP benchmark. This timing result is a within-model conditional implication; its practical relevance depends on operational readiness, triage throughput, and the vendor’s ability to validate and safely deploy fixes once a valid report arrives. Managerially, BBPs should be viewed as a post-release governance layer that complements strong internal assurance rather than as a substitute for it. Policymakers can support responsible use of BBPs by encouraging timely remediation, transparent post-patch disclosure, and reporting standards that reduce information asymmetry and triage frictions.
- 26 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 35 (11) , 3895-3913
Open AccessMerchants of vulnerabilities: How bug bounty programs benefit software vendors
We study how bug bounty programs (BBPs) shape software vendors’ security and release choices. Vendors invest in internal assurance before release to reduce residual vulnerabilities, and after launch they must manage vulnerability discovery, disclosure, and remediation. We develop a game-theoretic model in which a vendor chooses release timing and severity-contingent bounties, anticipating effort by ethical and malicious hackers in a winner-take-all discovery race. The model highlights two linked mechanisms: an incentive channel that shifts first discovery of severe vulnerabilities away from malicious exploitation and toward ethical reporting, and a governance channel in which coordinated disclosure changes how vulnerability information is managed while remediation is underway. We derive closed-form optimal bounties and characterize a feasibility region that sustains positive bounties and interior success probabilities. Within this region, a BBP strictly increases the vendor’s expected profit by reallocating first-discovery probability on severe vulnerabilities from malicious to ethical hackers and by converting part of severe-loss exposure into bounded, pay-for-results expenditures. For private programs, we also solve for the optimal invited set of ethical hackers and show that this optimal set is strictly smaller than the expected number of malicious attackers. Higher bounties raise ethical hackers’ effort and first-discovery probabilities but also increase program cost, and they interact with reputational (non-monetary) incentives. Finally, in the baseline model, BBP adoption conditionally reduces the marginal value of additional pre-release delay and therefore conditionally implies earlier release relative to the no-BBP benchmark. This timing result is a within-model conditional implication; its practical relevance depends on operational readiness, triage throughput, and the vendor’s ability to validate and safely deploy fixes once a valid report arrives. Managerially, BBPs should be viewed as a post-release governance layer that complements strong internal assurance rather than as a substitute for it. Policymakers can support responsible use of BBPs by encouraging timely remediation, transparent post-patch disclosure, and reporting standards that reduce information asymmetry and triage frictions.
- 19 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 35 (7) , 2700-2717
Brave New Telemedicine: Cognitive Bias and the Anticoagulant Gap in Atrial Fibrillation Care
Telemedicine has transformed healthcare delivery, yet its impact on the quality and consistency of clinical decision-making remains underexplored in operations management. While heralded for efficiency and access, it is unclear whether virtual care systematically alters adherence to clinical practice guidelines. This study investigates whether the mode of care, telemedicine versus in-person, affects clinicians’ guideline-recommended prescribing of anticoagulants for atrial fibrillation, where treatment adherence is crucial to prevent severe outcomes. Using electronic medical record data from 16,603 patient encounters at a major academic health system in the United States (2020–2023), we employ a two-way fixed-effects linear probability model to compare prescribing patterns. We find that telemedicine visits are associated with a 5.2-percentage-point lower probability of guideline-recommended anticoagulant prescription than in-person visits. The gap is driven by clinicians with historically lower adherence; top-quartile clinicians show no difference across modalities, exhibiting behavioral robustness (adherence resilient to modality). We propose that telemedicine’s leaner information channel heightens perceived uncertainty, activating cognitive biases: For some clinicians, telemedicine exacerbates ambiguity aversion and omission bias , favoring inaction in virtual settings. Linking service design to variation in professional judgment, we show how operational context moderates decision quality. Practically, healthcare organizations should not treat telemedicine as a simple substitute for in-person care; they should implement targeted operational interventions, such as enhanced decision support and training on cognitive biases, to maintain high standards of care so efficiency and access gains do not come at the cost of adherence. In a supplementary analysis, we estimate that, at the population level in the United States, a 5.2-percentage-point telemedicine-related gap in anticoagulant prescribing could result in more than 150 preventable strokes and roughly $50 million in avoidable lifetime costs annually for each newly diagnosed cohort, underscoring its substantial clinical and economic significance.
- 19 January 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 35 (7) , 2700-2717
Brave New Telemedicine: Cognitive Bias and the Anticoagulant Gap in Atrial Fibrillation Care
Telemedicine has transformed healthcare delivery, yet its impact on the quality and consistency of clinical decision-making remains underexplored in operations management. While heralded for efficiency and access, it is unclear whether virtual care systematically alters adherence to clinical practice guidelines. This study investigates whether the mode of care, telemedicine versus in-person, affects clinicians’ guideline-recommended prescribing of anticoagulants for atrial fibrillation, where treatment adherence is crucial to prevent severe outcomes. Using electronic medical record data from 16,603 patient encounters at a major academic health system in the United States (2020–2023), we employ a two-way fixed-effects linear probability model to compare prescribing patterns. We find that telemedicine visits are associated with a 5.2-percentage-point lower probability of guideline-recommended anticoagulant prescription than in-person visits. The gap is driven by clinicians with historically lower adherence; top-quartile clinicians show no difference across modalities, exhibiting behavioral robustness (adherence resilient to modality). We propose that telemedicine’s leaner information channel heightens perceived uncertainty, activating cognitive biases: For some clinicians, telemedicine exacerbates ambiguity aversion and omission bias , favoring inaction in virtual settings. Linking service design to variation in professional judgment, we show how operational context moderates decision quality. Practically, healthcare organizations should not treat telemedicine as a simple substitute for in-person care; they should implement targeted operational interventions, such as enhanced decision support and training on cognitive biases, to maintain high standards of care so efficiency and access gains do not come at the cost of adherence. In a supplementary analysis, we estimate that, at the population level in the United States, a 5.2-percentage-point telemedicine-related gap in anticoagulant prescribing could result in more than 150 preventable strokes and roughly $50 million in avoidable lifetime costs annually for each newly diagnosed cohort, underscoring its substantial clinical and economic significance.
- 10 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 2743-2747
Vulnerability Disclosure Economics
- 23 April 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 34 (10) , 3119-3137
Mitigating Churn After Online Financial Fraud: The Value of Blame Attribution
The financial industry is plagued with account-based fraudulent transactions in which perpetrators surreptitiously siphon away money from customer accounts. To address this recurrent problem, service operations teams at financial institutions (e.g., the fraud detection and mitigation teams) spend millions yearly identifying perpetrators, attributing blame, and averting customer churn. However, in the vast majority of cases, the service operations teams cannot trace fraudulent transactions back to the perpetrators, and hence, it remains unclear whether they should continue to expend significant resources into investigating account-based fraud and attributing blame. Employing a wide range of econometric and machine learning techniques on a rich dataset from a US bank and an experiment, we attempt to offer the first empirical assessment of the association between blame attribution, or lack of it, in response to customer-identified account-based fraud and customer churn. The results indicate that relative to the customers that did not experience fraud, those that did and received a resolution lacking blame attribution have 40.69 %Lift (95% confidence interval (CI) = [24.41 %Lift , 56.97 %Lift ]) in churn rate. However, customers that experienced fraud and received a resolution involving blame attribution have −62.45 %Lift (95% CI = [−31.22 %Lift , −93.68 %Lift ]) in churn rate, making them less likely to churn than those that did not experience fraud. The latter result offers one of the first field evidence of the well-known service recovery paradox. Additionally, we observe significant heterogeneity in the findings based on customer tenure and the number of customer-firm interactions and document the long-term effects of attributing and not attributing blame. These insights can assist service operations teams in their postservice failure efforts to mend customer-firm relationships. Overall, the results underscore the importance of blame attribution during service recovery for service operations teams and inform a topical debate on a banking reform proposed by the US Department of Treasury.
- 23 April 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 34 (10) , 3119-3137
Mitigating Churn After Online Financial Fraud: The Value of Blame Attribution
The financial industry is plagued with account-based fraudulent transactions in which perpetrators surreptitiously siphon away money from customer accounts. To address this recurrent problem, service operations teams at financial institutions (e.g., the fraud detection and mitigation teams) spend millions yearly identifying perpetrators, attributing blame, and averting customer churn. However, in the vast majority of cases, the service operations teams cannot trace fraudulent transactions back to the perpetrators, and hence, it remains unclear whether they should continue to expend significant resources into investigating account-based fraud and attributing blame. Employing a wide range of econometric and machine learning techniques on a rich dataset from a US bank and an experiment, we attempt to offer the first empirical assessment of the association between blame attribution, or lack of it, in response to customer-identified account-based fraud and customer churn. The results indicate that relative to the customers that did not experience fraud, those that did and received a resolution lacking blame attribution have 40.69 %Lift (95% confidence interval (CI) = [24.41 %Lift , 56.97 %Lift ]) in churn rate. However, customers that experienced fraud and received a resolution involving blame attribution have −62.45 %Lift (95% CI = [−31.22 %Lift , −93.68 %Lift ]) in churn rate, making them less likely to churn than those that did not experience fraud. The latter result offers one of the first field evidence of the well-known service recovery paradox. Additionally, we observe significant heterogeneity in the findings based on customer tenure and the number of customer-firm interactions and document the long-term effects of attributing and not attributing blame. These insights can assist service operations teams in their postservice failure efforts to mend customer-firm relationships. Overall, the results underscore the importance of blame attribution during service recovery for service operations teams and inform a topical debate on a banking reform proposed by the US Department of Treasury.
- Open Access
- 7 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Cultural Economics
- Vol. 49 (2) , 301-326
Movie sentiment and home entertainment revenue
This study examines the impact of box office reviews on home entertainment (HE) sales predictions, a key for movie revenue. Accurate predictions are crucial for estimating potential losses when licensing films to streaming platforms like Netflix or developing promotional strategies. Our findings indicate that, while the average rating and sentiment score of box office reviews do not directly influence sales predictions, extreme negative sentiments significantly affect consumer behavior. Specifically, consumers are less likely to purchase electronic sell-through (EST) and video on demand (VOD) options when confronted with strong negative sentiments in reviews. This suggests that consumers detect and react to negative sentiments in reviews.
- 7 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Cultural Economics
- Vol. 49 (2) , 301-326
Open AccessMovie sentiment and home entertainment revenue
This study examines the impact of box office reviews on home entertainment (HE) sales predictions, a key for movie revenue. Accurate predictions are crucial for estimating potential losses when licensing films to streaming platforms like Netflix or developing promotional strategies. Our findings indicate that, while the average rating and sentiment score of box office reviews do not directly influence sales predictions, extreme negative sentiments significantly affect consumer behavior. Specifically, consumers are less likely to purchase electronic sell-through (EST) and video on demand (VOD) options when confronted with strong negative sentiments in reviews. This suggests that consumers detect and react to negative sentiments in reviews.
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
- Vol. 27 (2) , 408-424
The Impact of Digitization on Print Book Sales: Analysis Using Genre Exposure Heterogeneity
Problem definition: The rise of digital channels has led to significant media market transformations. This paper studies whether and how digitization, sparked by the launch of Amazon Kindle in late 2007, affected print book sales. Methodology/results: To estimate the impact, we exploit the quasiexperimental variation in the popularity of digital books across different genres or subgenres. We employ difference-in-differences and other identification strategies, and we use print sales data on a large representative sample of book titles published in the United States from 2004 to 2015 across a variety of genres. Using various empirical specifications, we find that digitization significantly reduced print sales of adult fiction (the most popular genre in the e-book format) while having a much smaller impact on adult nonfiction and juvenile fiction. We further find that the effect for adult fiction is higher after the launch of the iPad (in 2010) and stronger for smaller publishers, the paperback version, and low-selling books. Managerial implications: Our findings provide book publishers with key inputs for optimal pricing and release strategies of different book formats. Our study also extends the vast yet growing academic literature on the impact of digital distribution channels on existing sales channels and can inform the policy debate concerning third-party digitization and its effect on physical sales. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2022.0594 .
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
- Vol. 27 (2) , 408-424
The Impact of Digitization on Print Book Sales: Analysis Using Genre Exposure Heterogeneity
Problem definition: The rise of digital channels has led to significant media market transformations. This paper studies whether and how digitization, sparked by the launch of Amazon Kindle in late 2007, affected print book sales. Methodology/results: To estimate the impact, we exploit the quasiexperimental variation in the popularity of digital books across different genres or subgenres. We employ difference-in-differences and other identification strategies, and we use print sales data on a large representative sample of book titles published in the United States from 2004 to 2015 across a variety of genres. Using various empirical specifications, we find that digitization significantly reduced print sales of adult fiction (the most popular genre in the e-book format) while having a much smaller impact on adult nonfiction and juvenile fiction. We further find that the effect for adult fiction is higher after the launch of the iPad (in 2010) and stronger for smaller publishers, the paperback version, and low-selling books. Managerial implications: Our findings provide book publishers with key inputs for optimal pricing and release strategies of different book formats. Our study also extends the vast yet growing academic literature on the impact of digital distribution channels on existing sales channels and can inform the policy debate concerning third-party digitization and its effect on physical sales. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2022.0594 .
- Open Access
Merchants of Vulnerabilities: How Bug Bounty Programs Benefit Software Vendors
Software vulnerabilities enable exploitation by malicious hackers, compromising systems and data security. This paper examines bug bounty programs (BBPs) that incentivize ethical hackers to discover and responsibly disclose vulnerabilities to software vendors. Using game-theoretic models, we capture the strategic interactions between software vendors, ethical hackers, and malicious hackers. First, our analysis shows that software vendors can increase expected profits by participating in BBPs, explaining their growing adoption and the success of BBP platforms. Second, we find that vendors with BBPs will release software earlier, albeit with more potential vulnerabilities, as BBPs enable coordinated vulnerability disclosure and mitigation. Third, the optimal number of ethical hackers to invite to a BBP depends solely on the expected number of malicious hackers seeking exploitation. This optimal number of ethical hackers is lower than but increases with the expected malicious hacker count. Finally, higher bounties incentivize ethical hackers to exert more effort, thereby increasing the probability that they will discover severe vulnerabilities first while reducing the success probability of malicious hackers. These findings highlight BBPs' potential benefits for vendors beyond profitability. Earlier software releases are enabled by managing risks through coordinated disclosure. As cybersecurity threats evolve, BBP adoption will likely gain momentum, providing vendors with a valuable tool for enhancing security posture and stakeholder trust. Moreover, BBPs envelop vulnerability identification and disclosure into new market relationships and transactions, impacting software vendors' incentives regarding product security choices like release timing.
Open AccessMerchants of Vulnerabilities: How Bug Bounty Programs Benefit Software Vendors
Software vulnerabilities enable exploitation by malicious hackers, compromising systems and data security. This paper examines bug bounty programs (BBPs) that incentivize ethical hackers to discover and responsibly disclose vulnerabilities to software vendors. Using game-theoretic models, we capture the strategic interactions between software vendors, ethical hackers, and malicious hackers. First, our analysis shows that software vendors can increase expected profits by participating in BBPs, explaining their growing adoption and the success of BBP platforms. Second, we find that vendors with BBPs will release software earlier, albeit with more potential vulnerabilities, as BBPs enable coordinated vulnerability disclosure and mitigation. Third, the optimal number of ethical hackers to invite to a BBP depends solely on the expected number of malicious hackers seeking exploitation. This optimal number of ethical hackers is lower than but increases with the expected malicious hacker count. Finally, higher bounties incentivize ethical hackers to exert more effort, thereby increasing the probability that they will discover severe vulnerabilities first while reducing the success probability of malicious hackers. These findings highlight BBPs' potential benefits for vendors beyond profitability. Earlier software releases are enabled by managing risks through coordinated disclosure. As cybersecurity threats evolve, BBP adoption will likely gain momentum, providing vendors with a valuable tool for enhancing security posture and stakeholder trust. Moreover, BBPs envelop vulnerability identification and disclosure into new market relationships and transactions, impacting software vendors' incentives regarding product security choices like release timing.
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 May 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
- Vol. 25 (3) , 862-883
The Impact of Ride-Hailing Services on Congestion: Evidence from Indian Cities
Problem definition: Early research has documented significant growth in ride-hailing services worldwide and allied benefits. However, growing evidence of their negative externalities is leading to significant policy scrutiny. Despite demonstrated socioeconomic benefits and consumer surplus worth billions of dollars, cities are choosing to curb these services in a bid to mitigate first order urban mobility problems. Existing studies on the congestion effects of ride-hailing are limited, report mixed evidence, and exclusively focus on the United States, where the supply consists primarily of part-time drivers. Methodology/results: We study how the absence of ride-hailing services affects congestion levels in three major cities in India, a market where most ride-hailing drivers participate full time. Using rich real-time traffic and route trajectory data from Google Maps, we show that in, all three cities, periods of ride-hailing unavailability due to driver strikes see a discernible drop in travel time. The effects are largest for the most congested regions during the busiest hours, which see 10.1%–14.8% reduction in travel times. Additionally, we provide suggestive evidence for some of the mechanisms behind the observed effects, including deadheading elimination, substitution with public transit, and opening up of shorter alternative routes. Managerial implications: These results suggest that despite their paltry modal share, ride-hailing vehicles are substituting more sustainable means of transport and are contributing significantly to congestion in the cities studied. The reported effect sizes quantify the maximum travel time gains that can be expected on curbing them. Funding: This work was supported by the Srini Raju Center for Information Technology and the Networked Economy at Indian School of Business. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2022.1158 .
- 1 May 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
- Vol. 25 (3) , 862-883
Top Cited PapersThe Impact of Ride-Hailing Services on Congestion: Evidence from Indian Cities
Problem definition: Early research has documented significant growth in ride-hailing services worldwide and allied benefits. However, growing evidence of their negative externalities is leading to significant policy scrutiny. Despite demonstrated socioeconomic benefits and consumer surplus worth billions of dollars, cities are choosing to curb these services in a bid to mitigate first order urban mobility problems. Existing studies on the congestion effects of ride-hailing are limited, report mixed evidence, and exclusively focus on the United States, where the supply consists primarily of part-time drivers. Methodology/results: We study how the absence of ride-hailing services affects congestion levels in three major cities in India, a market where most ride-hailing drivers participate full time. Using rich real-time traffic and route trajectory data from Google Maps, we show that in, all three cities, periods of ride-hailing unavailability due to driver strikes see a discernible drop in travel time. The effects are largest for the most congested regions during the busiest hours, which see 10.1%–14.8% reduction in travel times. Additionally, we provide suggestive evidence for some of the mechanisms behind the observed effects, including deadheading elimination, substitution with public transit, and opening up of shorter alternative routes. Managerial implications: These results suggest that despite their paltry modal share, ride-hailing vehicles are substituting more sustainable means of transport and are contributing significantly to congestion in the cities studied. The reported effect sizes quantify the maximum travel time gains that can be expected on curbing them. Funding: This work was supported by the Srini Raju Center for Information Technology and the Networked Economy at Indian School of Business. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2022.1158 .
- 1 March 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 69 (3) , 1665-1686
Incentive Misalignments in Programmatic Advertising: Evidence from a Randomized Field Experiment
In programmatic advertising, firms outsource the bidding for ad impressions to ad platforms. Although firms are interested in targeting consumers that respond positively to advertising, ad platforms are usually rewarded for targeting consumers with high overall purchase probability. We develop a theoretical model that shows if consumers with high baseline purchase probability respond more positively to advertising, then firms and ad platforms agree on which consumers to target. If, conversely, consumers with low baseline purchase probability are the ones for which ads work best, then ad platforms target consumers that firms do not want to target—the incentives are misaligned. We conduct a large-scale randomized field experiment, targeting 208,538 individual consumers, in a display retargeting campaign. Our unique data set allows us to both causally identify advertising effectiveness and estimate the degree of incentive misalignments between the firm and ad platform. In accordance with the contracted incentives, the ad platform targets consumers that are more likely to purchase. Importantly, we find no evidence that ads are more effective for consumers with higher baseline purchase probability, rendering the ad platform’s bidding suboptimal for the firm. A welfare analysis suggests that the ad platform’s bidding optimization leads to a loss in profit for the firm and an overall decline in welfare. To remedy the incentive misalignment, we propose a solution in which the firm restricts the ad platform to target only consumers that are profitable based on individual consumer-level estimates for baseline purchase probability and ad effectiveness. This paper was accepted by Anandhi Bharadwaj, information systems. Funding: This work was funded by Vereniging Trustfonds Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam [Grant 97090/17.16/741/oe], Fundacão para a Ciência e a Tecnologia [UID/ECO/00124/2019, UIDB/00124/2020, UIDP/00124/2020, and Social Sciences DataLab - PINFRA/22209/2016], POR Lisboa, and POR Norte [Social Sciences DataLab, PINFRA/22209/2016]. Supplemental Material: The online appendices are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.4438 .
- 1 March 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 69 (3) , 1665-1686
Incentive Misalignments in Programmatic Advertising: Evidence from a Randomized Field Experiment
In programmatic advertising, firms outsource the bidding for ad impressions to ad platforms. Although firms are interested in targeting consumers that respond positively to advertising, ad platforms are usually rewarded for targeting consumers with high overall purchase probability. We develop a theoretical model that shows if consumers with high baseline purchase probability respond more positively to advertising, then firms and ad platforms agree on which consumers to target. If, conversely, consumers with low baseline purchase probability are the ones for which ads work best, then ad platforms target consumers that firms do not want to target—the incentives are misaligned. We conduct a large-scale randomized field experiment, targeting 208,538 individual consumers, in a display retargeting campaign. Our unique data set allows us to both causally identify advertising effectiveness and estimate the degree of incentive misalignments between the firm and ad platform. In accordance with the contracted incentives, the ad platform targets consumers that are more likely to purchase. Importantly, we find no evidence that ads are more effective for consumers with higher baseline purchase probability, rendering the ad platform’s bidding suboptimal for the firm. A welfare analysis suggests that the ad platform’s bidding optimization leads to a loss in profit for the firm and an overall decline in welfare. To remedy the incentive misalignment, we propose a solution in which the firm restricts the ad platform to target only consumers that are profitable based on individual consumer-level estimates for baseline purchase probability and ad effectiveness. This paper was accepted by Anandhi Bharadwaj, information systems. Funding: This work was funded by Vereniging Trustfonds Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam [Grant 97090/17.16/741/oe], Fundacão para a Ciência e a Tecnologia [UID/ECO/00124/2019, UIDB/00124/2020, UIDP/00124/2020, and Social Sciences DataLab - PINFRA/22209/2016], POR Lisboa, and POR Norte [Social Sciences DataLab, PINFRA/22209/2016]. Supplemental Material: The online appendices are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.4438 .
- 28 February 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP)
- p. 498-530
The Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights in a Digital Era
Trade in Knowledge - March 2022
- 28 February 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP)
- p. 498-530
The Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights in a Digital Era
Trade in Knowledge - March 2022