HKHelen Kruuse

Helen Kruuse

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Helen Kruuse has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Lawyers’ ethics in Anglophone Africa: ex Africa semper aliquid novi

    by Helen Kruuse, Tafadzwa Mavindidze, Charlotte Kabaseke

  • Open Access

    Legal ethics and the lawyer-client relationship in South Africa: a proposal for reform using local values

    by Helen Julia Kruuse

    This thesis develops an approach to ethical decision-making for legal practitioners in South Africa that, it is argued, meets the ends and values of its relatively new constitutional democracy. The thesis starts by identifying that neutral partisanship was, and continues to be, the prevailing conception of role for legal practitioners in South Africa. The study focuses on how this approach is problematic for a number of reasons, the most important of which are: (1) because neutral partisanship allows lawyers to become ethically disengaged, and (2) the approach does not fit with the values of South Africa’s Constitution. The study proceeds to consider alternatives to the neutral partisanship model, analysing their underlying premises and ‘fit’ with the South African context. The study argues that the work of William Simon, a US scholar, is the most suitable approach to adopt in South Africa. This is because of its emphasis on the need for legal practitioners to exercise discretion in ethical decision-making, to take responsibility for their actions, and ultimately to seek justice as understood within the legal system in which they operate. The study then shifts to a consideration of how Simon’s approach needs to be contextualised given that it has been developed from a western/Global North perspective. To do this, I consider the content of the indigenous value of Ubuntu and its incorporation into the South African legal system. I then consider how Ubuntu could assist in the development of legal practitioners’ understanding, purpose and execution of their duties within a transformative constitutional democracy. In doing this, I develop inward- and outward-looking factors based on traditional and constitutional values directing legal practitioners in their ethical decision-making. Finally, the study closes with a consideration of how the approach can be institutionalised. The study proposes certain ways in which code regulation and education can support the success of the approach.

  • Open Access

    Recognising form through function in the context of integrating the bride requirement in customary marriages in South Africa

    by Helen Kruuse, Lea Mwambene

    In previous scholarship we argued how the state and courts have tended to favour a formal or definitional approach to customary marriages in South Africa, leaving vulnerable parties, particularly women, not adequately protected. In this article we focus on a new approach emerging from the courts, particularly relating to the integration of the bride as a requirement for the validity of a customary marriage. While we affirm the courts' emerging approach regarding integration, we take issue with the language used by the courts, particularly that relating to the word 'waiver'. In considering the recent South African Supreme Court of Appeal decisions on integration, and the High Court decisions that have followed, we believe the courts are in fact not waiving the requirement, but recognising that the requirement of integration may be met in another way. In considering these cases, although the court does not explicitly rely on Ramose's 'social acceptance' thesis as to the validity of law, we believe that adopting this approach will do much to assuage concerns about courts ignoring custom. More importantly, Ramose's 'social acceptance' theory gives credit to living customary law as a legal system which, as widely observed, promotes the very values on which the Constitution is founded. We also believe that Ramose's approach is a much more balanced approach in this context than a typically Western approach that promotes certainty over the protection of vulnerable parties, and represents the very evolving nature of living customary marriage laws and practices.


  • Transforming litigation in customary marriage disputes: Ubuntu and the responsibility of legal practitioners

    by Helen Kruuse

    This contribution recognises different areas of Himonga’s scholarship, particularly her work on the recognition of customary marriages, ubuntu and dispute resolution. In bringing this work together, I suggest that her research on ubuntu – translated into the context of litigation – might provide insights on customary marriage recognition in ways that have not yet been properly explored. This insight is that the way in which legal practitioners have displayed ubuntu (or not) in litigating customary marriage disputes materially affects the ability of the courts to recognise living customary law. Having considered case law, the contribution suggests then that ubuntu should be used, not only as an interpretative tool, but also as a legal principle in guiding the procedure in which disputes are settled. isiXhosa: Eli galelo liqonda imimandla eyahlukeneyo kwinkxasomali yokufunda kaHimonga, ingakumbi umsebenzi wakhe ekuqondweni kwemitshato yesintu, ubuntu kunye nokusonjululwa kweembambano. Ukuhlanganisa lo msebenzi, ndicebisa ukuba uphando lwakhe ku-ubuntu – oluguqulelwe ngomxholo womangalelwano – lungabonakalisa imibono ekuqondweni komtshato wesintu ngeendlela ezingekaphicothwa ngokwaneleyo. Lo mbono kukuba indlela amagosa ezomthetho abonakalisa ngayo ubuntu (okanye akunjalo) ekufakeni isimangalo ngeembambano zomtshato wesintu ngokubonakalayo kuchaphazela isakhono seenkundla ekuqondeni umthetho wesintu okhoyo ekuphileni. Xa kuthathelwa ingqalelo umthetho osekelwe kwimithetho yangaphambili, ngokuphathelele kwigalelo kucetyiswa ukuba kusetyenziswe ubuntu, hayi nje kuphela njengesixhobo sokutolika, kodwa kwakhona njengomgaqo ekukhokeleni inkqubo ekusonjululwa ngayo iimbambano.

  • The thin edge of the wedge: ukuthwala, alienation and consent

    by Lea Mwambene, Helen Kruuse

    Ukuthwala, a mock abduction of a girl for the purpose of a customary marriage, has been subject to debate at both local and national level. This debate culminated into a South African Law Reform Commission Report on the practice of ukuthwala. However, the case of Jezile v S brings theory into reality, putting in stark relief the issues that surround this custom in a constitutional democracy. The Jezile case highlights the disjuncture between communities’ lived realities and the constitutional imperatives of the right to practice one’s culture, as well as the rights to equality and dignity, specifically for women and the girl child in the context of ukuthwala. Based on field research conducted in September 2015 and April 2016 in Engcobo (where the ukuthwala was alleged to take place in Jezile), this article sets out the community’s views in the aftermath of the case. Highlighting the alienation of the community from the law, and the complexities in understanding consent, the article posits that much more needs to be done from the ‘bottom up’ to ensure gender equality and protection of the girl child from harm.


  • Legal ethics education in South Africa: possibilities, challenges and opportunities

    by Michael Robertson, Helen Kruuse

    The South African legal profession has been subject to harsh criticism in the last few years, leading to what some have called ‘an ethical crisis.’ Although this perception may or may not be warranted, there have been numerous calls for improved ethical legal practices by South African lawyers. This article seeks to contribute to a discussion about the importance of implementing legal ethics education in South African law schools. The authors (a) explore the meaning of ‘ethical legal practice’ by reference to the international literature; (b) examine the way in which legal ethics has so far been presented in the limited South African literature on the topic; (c) argue the need for a more thorough and critical literature on South African lawyers’ ethics, coupled with a commitment to developing a stronger legal ethics culture within the profession and the legal academia; and (d) suggest a possible approach for South African legal ethics education in the future, with reference to recent developments in other countries.


  • Unfulfilled Promises? The Implementation of the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act in South Africa

    by Lea Mwambene, Helen Kruuse

    The Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 1998 (the Act) regulates all matters in relation to customary marriages in South Africa. The Act was specifically enacted to recognize customary marriages as valid, but was also passed to address gender inequality by regulating various customary marriage aspects, the most important being registration and proprietary consequences. This article reflects on the findings of a qualitative study on the registration and proprietary consequences of customary marriages conducted in two rural sites in the Eastern Cape (the former Ciskei and Transkei) and one urban site in the Western Cape (Khayelitsha). These findings show two important issues. First, that access to resources upon death of a spouse or divorce is often premised on successful registration of the marriage, which seldom occurs. Secondly, that the continued patriarchal nature of customary marriages stands in the way of realizing gender equality, particularly in relation to the proprietary consequences of a marriage. As a result, we make possible recommendations of how the Act’s objectives can be met.