SCSierd Cloetingh

Sierd Cloetingh

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Sierd Cloetingh has a total of 185 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Linking Deep Carbon to Surface Emission in the Carpathian–Pannonian Region: Isotope Systematics of Fluid Inclusions and Groundwater

    by Tamás Spránitz, Thomas Pieter Lange, Alexander Koptev, Csaba Szabó, István János Kovács, Sierd Cloetingh, Mátyás Hencz, Kristóf Porkoláb, Orsolya Gelencsér, Ákos Kővágó, et al.

    CO 2 degassing from the deep Earth provides important insights into the global carbon cycle. CO 2 ‐rich fluid inclusions in mantle xenoliths record fluid sources and migrations in the deep lithosphere, while the contribution of mantle components in groundwater can be traced via dissolved gas geochemistry. Here, we integrate basin‐scale geochemical observations with thermo‐kinematic modeling to reconstruct CO 2 release in the Neogene Carpathian–Pannonian continental back‐arc system. He‐Ne isotope ratios were determined from mantle xenoliths studied in detail by fluid inclusion analyses, collected from the Styrian Basin ( R c / R a = 5.8–6.8), Bakony–Balaton Highland ( R c / R a = 6.1–7.3) and Perşani Mountains Volcanic Fields ( R c / R a = 2.3–5.3). This was compared with groundwater data from the same areas using previous studies and new data from the Bakony–Balaton Highland ( R c / R a = 1.0–2.1 and δ 13 C = −9.60‰ to −6.24‰). Considering the inferred genetic connection of deep fluids and groundwater, the results on mantle degassing can be extrapolated and modeled to recent times owing to the same geodynamic setting prevailed during xenolith transport to the surface. Continuous crystallization of CO 2 ‐bearing, non‐extractable melts within the asthenosphere results in gradual release of CO 2 during post‐rift lithospheric thickening. This mechanism is supported by numerical analysis of melting, melt extraction and mantle degassing over time, demonstrating that persistent post‐rift CO 2 release until today is physically plausible. This mechanism provides a reasonable explanation for the widespread occurrence and longevity of non‐volcanic CO 2 emissions far from areas of active volcanism in the Carpathian–Pannonian region and in analogous post‐rift tectonic environments worldwide.

  • Open Access

    The Dense MORB Fraction Controls the Dynamic Stability and Hydration Potential of the Mantle Transition Zone

    by Zhensheng Wang, Sierd Cloetingh, Alexander Koptev, Qin Wang, Alessio Lavecchia, István Kovács, Timothy Kusky

    The mantle transition zone (MTZ; ∼410–660 km depth) is a major reservoir of water and mid‐ocean ridge basalt (MORB)‐like materials, yet how composition and hydration regulate its physical stability remains unclear. Using geodynamical modeling, we examine the joint effect of water content and dense MORB fraction on the density, viscosity, and dynamics of the MTZ. We find that the MTZ remains dynamically stable only within a narrow range of MORB‐to‐water ratios; outside this window, buoyancy‐driven instabilities and dehydration occur. Combining this stability constraint with global MORB fraction estimates, we evaluate the theoretical hydration potential of the MTZ, which is strongly laterally heterogeneous and controlled not only by intrinsic mineralogical capacity but also by dynamic stability. Our results align with observed water distributions and suggest that most of the MTZ resides in stable or slowly dehydrating regimes, supporting a sustained deep water cycle and long‐term lithospheric stability.

  • Open Access

    Reply to Comment by Hetényi and Cattin on: “Raising the Roof of the World: Intra‐Crustal Asian Mantle Supports the Himalayan‐Tibetan Orogen”

    by P. Sternai, S. Pilia, S. Ghelichkhan, P. Bouilhol, A. Menant, L. Ostorero, B. Vaes, R. Esposito, E. Garzanti, S. Cloetingh, et al.

    We welcome the critique of Hetényi and Cattin (2026, https://doi.org/10.1029/2025tc009214 ) on Sternai et al. (2025, https://doi.org/10.1029/2025tc009057 ), as it brings to light evaluative issues that require clarification and offers an opportunity to articulate more clearly how our work advances understanding of Himalayan‐Tibetan geodynamics. In this Reply, we clarify that most of the criticism arises from evaluating our process‐oriented geodynamic models as if they were intended to reproduce present‐day lithospheric structures, rather than to test the mechanical plausibility of Paleogene crustal‐doubling mechanisms. Moreover, non‐unique interpretations of present‐day geophysical data are treated in the Comment as definitive constraints and used as benchmarks to dismiss alternative physically viable scenarios, leading to circular reasoning. When the content and objectives of our study are correctly considered, the critiques do not invalidate our results or conclusions. More broadly, this Reply underscores the importance of reassessing established models when fundamental limitations are identified, as a constructive pathway toward progress in Earth sciences.

  • Open Access

    Neotectonic vertical motions based on syn-volcanic palaeosurfaces and geochronological data: inferences for crustal and mantle processes (Pannonian Basin, Central Europe)

    by László Fodor, Gábor Csillag, Károly Németh, Zsófia Ruszkiczay-Rüdiger, Krisztina Sebe, Tamás Telbisz, Gábor Kovács, Sierd Cloetingh

    Rate and timing of neotectonic vertical motions represent an ongoing research topic in inverted sedimentary basins. This presentation offers new data concerning the uplift history of the western part of the Miocene Pannonian Basin system, (Central Europe) which is bordering the Alpine orogenic belt. After the syn-rift phase of ~21–15Ma, the area underwent the post-rift phase which involved differential subsidence reaching several kilometres in basin centres. Parallel to post-rift subsidence process, the basin inversion started during the Late Miocene and resulted in differential uplift, fluvial and aeolian denudation, and river incision.The late post-rift and the early neotectonic phases were accompanied by extensive basalt volcanism, resulting in the activity of two distinct phreatomagmatic monogenetic volcanic fields, the Bakony-Balaton Highland and Little Hungarian Plain Volcanic Fields (BBHVF and LHPVF) through the Late Miocene to earliest Quaternary (7.96–2.61 Ma). The volcanic fields comprise diverse volcanic landforms, including shield volcanoes, maar diatremes, volcanic plugs and erosional remnants of scoria and spatter cones.Detailed analysis of volcanic facies was used to reconstruct the topographic position of the syn-volcanic palaeosurface upon which the volcanoes developed. Using the previously published ages of the volcanic rocks and the palaeo-elevations of the volcanic surfaces, averaged uplift rates were derived for all observation points. In addition, previously published exposure age data and geomorphological data were used to constrain the uplift rates.The reconstructed palaeosurfaces and the calculated rock uplift rates show spatial and temporal variations from ~20 to ~100 m/Ma. Before ~3.5 Ma the two volcanic fields showed opposite differential vertical motions having been positive in the eastern basin margin (Transdanubian Range) and negative in the neighbouring basin centre (Kisalföld/Danube Basin); variations were due to differential post-rift subsidence and the onset of minor neotectonic uplift. After ~3.5 Ma all the studied areas underwent uplift, but the south-western part of the volcanic fields exhibits larger uplift values than the north-eastern one triggering a regional drainage pattern reorganisation. Moving west from the volcanic areas, toward the foothills of the Alps, the uplift rates increased even more and approximating values obtained in the Alpine orogenic belt.This variable differential vertical motion history points to the interplay of complex governing processes. These could involve the intraplate compressional stress related to neotectonic basin inversion, lower-crustal flow of the weakened crust, and more importantly, mantle processes at depth. This latter could involve lithospheric folding, mantle convection-induced development of a dynamic topography, and the eventual effect of secondary plumes. In addition, uplift could be coupled with surface processes like variable unloading by denudation and loading by sedimentation in the axial and marginal parts of the area, respectively.The research was supported by the Hungarian National Research, Development and Innovation Office, project 134873 and the HUN-REN Research Grant Hungary project RGH531001.

  • Open Access

    Numerical modelling of plume-induced craton delamination: the role of the Mid-Lithospheric Discontinuity

    by Alessio Lavecchia, Istvan Kovacs, Alexander Koptev, Sierd Cloetingh

    The Mid-Lithospheric Discontinuity (MLD) is a region of marked scattering of seismic waves which, according to several studies, is caused by mechanical weakness. It is located at an approximate depth of 100 km and has become a subject of intense research since it was identified through active-source seismology. The nature of the MLD is still a topic of intense debate. However, its contribution in destabilizing the continental lithosphere has often been invoked, and particularly in the destruction of cratons. Such a role is further enhanced when combined with other factors that may weaken the lithospheric mantle. Here we show the results of a 2D thermo-mechanical model, where we investigated the role of the MLD in the scenario of the interaction between long-lived mantle plumes and cratonic lithosphere. In this model, we implemented thermal and/or compositional plumes, with subsequent effects on their relative buoyancy with respect to the surrounding sublithospheric mantle. Our findings suggest that the combined effects of mantle plumes and MLD can effectively cause the destabilization and extensive delamination of cratonic lithosphere. However, mantle plumes must reach the MLD to trigger craton destabilization. For such a scenario, the presence of a weakened lithospheric mantle beneath the MLD is pivotal. This weak zone may be tectonic suture zone(s), or regions of melt and/or fluids percolation due to P-T variations in the plume during its ascent. We have verified that when plumes receive a constant material input from lower regions of the mantle, craton delamination can occur with very thin MLDs (< 10 km), and can be induced by cold and small compositional plumes, which are characterized by relatively low buoyancy.

  • Open Access

    Numerical Modeling of Purely Active (Plume‐Produced) Continental Rifting and Break‐Up

    by Alexander Koptev, Alessio Lavecchia, Sierd Cloetingh, Michaël Pons, Enrico Marzotto, Sascha Brune, István Kovács, Magdala Tesauro, Fred Beekman, Qin Wang, et al.

    In contrast to the traditional mechanism of passive continental rifting (driven by far‐field tectonic forces), the active rifting‐to‐break‐up processes (caused by rising mantle plumes) are still poorly understood. However, most episodes of fragmentation of the last supercontinent Pangea were relatively shortly preceded (within ∼10 Myr) by the emplacement of Large Igneous Provinces, indicating that a link between lithospheric ruptures and mantle plumes is very close and frequent. In this study, we present a systematic numerical modeling of purely active continental rifting and break‐up, that is, without far‐field extension, examining the following parameters: (a) the thermo‐rheological structure of the lithosphere, (b) the buoyancy of the thermo‐chemical mantle plume anomaly, and (c) the duration of the incoming plume flux. Thermo‐mechanical experiments show that a classic active rifting scenario, involving the complete break‐up of the lithosphere within less than 10 Myr following the arrival of a mantle plume, is achievable, though only under specific conditions. These include: (a) a continuously fed plume with an elevated thermal and/or compositional density deficit ( ≤ −30 kg m −3 ) and (b) a relatively warm overlying continental plate, characterized by an above‐average Moho temperature ( = 750°C). Although both prerequisites do not seem entirely unrealistic, their simultaneous occurrence in the Phanerozoic Earth is unlikely. We therefore conclude that for a successful transition to lithospheric break‐up, plume‐activated continental rifting events in the Mesozoic–Cenozoic time must be accompanied by external tectonic stresses.

  • Open Access

    Raising the Roof of the World: Intra‐Crustal Asian Mantle Supports the Himalayan‐Tibetan Orogen

    by P. Sternai, S. Pilia, S. Ghelichkhan, P. Bouilhol, A. Menant, D. R. Davies, L. Ostorero, B. Vaes, R. Esposito, E. Garzanti, et al.

    The Himalayan‐Tibetan orogen formed via the ongoing collision of India and Asia. Its colossal elevations stem from buoyant crustal roots that doubled in thickness during continental collision, widely believed to result from Indian crust under‐thrusting its Asian counterpart and Asian crustal thickening. However, a single crustal layer of up to ∼70–80 km thickness conflicts with experimental‐rheological and observational constraints, especially if related to the vertical juxtaposition of Indian and Asian crusts. For instance, crustal thickness above ∼40 km implies reduced strength of the continental lithosphere, which may become unable to sustain a plateau the size of Tibet throughout much of the Cenozoic. In addition, the geochemistry and association of ultramafic xenoliths and K‐rich magmas from Southern Tibet indicates the presence of mantle material between ∼50 and 80 km depths. The mechanisms controlling the rise and persistence of Earth's highest orogen, therefore, remain enigmatic. Here, new fully‐coupled numerical petrological‐thermomechanical geodynamic models reconcile the wealth of available structural and petrological constraints through viscous underplating of Indian crust beneath Asian lithosphere, which together supply buoyancy and strength to raise and support the Himalayas and Tibet. We further convert our geodynamic models into receiver functions and shear waves velocity maps that match, to a first order, the available geophysical data from the Himalayas and southern Tibet. We propose that viscous underplating of Indian crust beneath Asian lithosphere, not crust, forms the overall architecture of the Himalayan‐Tibetan orogen.


  • Open Access

    Plume–Lithosphere Interaction and the Role of the Mid‐Lithospheric Discontinuity in Craton Delamination

    by Alessio Lavecchia, István Kovács, Alexander Koptev, Sierd Cloetingh

    We present results from thermo‐mechanical numerical modeling of interactions between thermal, thermo‐compositional, and purely compositional (hydrous) mantle plumes, and a rheologically layered lithosphere containing a mid‐lithospheric discontinuity (MLD). Our simulations show that mantle plume impact can effectively destabilize and delaminate cold, mature continental lithosphere. However, for the plume head to penetrate the lithosphere and initiate removal of the lower lithospheric mantle, a deep‐seated zone of weakness beneath the MLD is required. This vertically oriented zone could be an inherited tectonic suture and/or a domain of pervasive percolation of plume‐derived melts and/or fluids. In the context explored here, where a long‐lived plume is continuously fed from below, the conditions for plume‐induced craton destabilization appear to be less stringent than earlier assumed, as it can occur even with a thin MLD (≤10 km) and a purely hydrous plume lacking an initial thermal component.


  • Open Access

    Migration of deformation, basin subsidence, magmatism in extensional basins: comparative constraints from numerical models and observations (Pannonian Basin)

    by László Fodor, Attila Balázs, Éva Oravecz, Szabolcs Harangi, Sierd A.P.L. Cloetingh, Taras Gerya, Réka Lukács

    Numerical models are essential tools for investigating a variety of Earth phenomena, providing insights into the role of different surface to deep Earth processes. As with many laboratory approaches the effectiveness of the models can be assessed by comparing their results with natural case studies of the same phenomenon, which helps to constrain the large number of model parameters.This presentation will take the example of the Pannonian Basin system having been formed within the Alpine–Carpathian–Dinaric orogenic belt, where geological data are abundant, and the temporal resolution of basin evolution including magmatic events are very good and in the range of the numerical modelling results.We used 3D coupled thermo-mechanical and surface processes numerical models (I3ELVIS-FDSPM code) to simulate continental rifting and to shed light on the temporal evolution of the entire rift system. Namely, the extensional deformation starts than migrates from the (western) basin margins, from inherited lithospheric weakness zones towards the basin centre, but an early jump from the western margin toward the opposite basin part is also present in some experiments. This is followed by a second jump of basin formation toward the basin centre, between the first and second generations of basins. This is in good agreement with the compilation of the ages for the onset of basin subsidence and migration of activity of some major bounding faults including low-angle detachments of metamorphic core complexes. This migration is driven and supported by mantle flow and asthenospheric upwelling, eventually affected by thermal relaxation. Based on detailed geological and geophysical mapping, we point out the role of inherited weakness zone(s) – mostly former suture zones – within the crust and mantle lithosphere. Consequences are contrasting subsidence and uplift patterns and a variable heat flow evolution in different sub-basins.The migration of basin formation shows remarkably similar migration of the magmatic activity. This started with granodioritic–dacitic products around 18.6 Ma along the western basin margin, then jumped toward the opposite basin part around 17.3–16.8 Ma and stepped back toward the basin centre around 15.3 Ma with a change toward andesitic volcanism. Geochemical characteristics indicate increasing mantle component in the melts during the continuing extension until ca. 14.4 Ma. The magma generation in the lower crust and mantle (by decompressional melting) is predicted by numerical models.The evolution of basin formation and magmatism between ~14.9 and ~11.5 Ma is marked by the migration from the basin centre toward the eastern margin and is probably due to subduction roll-back, steepening of the slab and its detachment. This process is combined with self-consistent evolution of mantle processes deriving from the rifting of the overriding lithosphere.The research was supported by the National Research, Development and Innovation Office project number K134873 granted to László Fodor and no. 145905 granted to Réka Lukács and MTA–HUN-REN CSFK Lendület "Momentum" PannonianVolcano Research Group

  • Open Access

    TRANSCAUCASUS: Record of 200 My plume activity

    by Nino Sadradze, Shota Adamia, Sierd Cloetingh, Alexander Koptev, Guga Sadradze

    Transcaucasus - the westernmost part of the southern Caucasus, represents an area where the Tethys Ocean was closed in the Late Cenozoic because of Eurasian and Africa-Arabian plate convergence. The lithosphere of the region represents a collage of Tethyan, Eurasian, and Gondwanan terranes. During the Late Proterozoic–Early Cenozoic a system of island arc and back-arc basins existed within the convergence zone. Geological and palaeogeographical data supported by paleomagnetic studies indicate the presence of several tectonic units in the regions that have distinctive geological histories.The region comprises a 30-55 km thick continental crust with significant lateral variations in thickness of the overlying sediments (0-25 km). The travel times velocity anomalies of the P- and S-waves are interpreted as high-velocity bodies down to about 100 km depth, where the mantle lithosphere is thin or even missing.The Mesozoic-Cenozoic magmatic assemblages reflect a diversity of paleogeographic -paleotectonic environments. They are indicative of a west Pacific-type oceanic basin setting under which the mature continental North Transcaucasian arc developed with zones of rifting and alkaline basaltic volcanism on the active margins of the oceanic domain.Within-plate magmatic activity in the North Transcaucasus is represented by volcanic and plutonic complexes, including Late Triassic to Early Jurassic subaerial alkali basalts and alkali gabbro; the Late Bathonian-Late Jurassic high titanium alkali basalts and minor trachytes with coal-bearing shales and evaporites intercalations; Albian alkali basalts alternating with redeposited volcaniclastics and shallow marine carbonates.The Late Cretaceous volcanics are associated with intraplate-type titanium rich alkali basalts and basanites with minor trachytes and phonolites, while the Eocene volcanics are associated with highly potassic to ultrapotassic basalts and basanites. The Late Miocene-Pleistocene volcanism is represented by alkaline basalt-trachytes as well.The Great Caucasus, a NW–SE-directed mountain range, extends westwards along the pre-Caucasian strip of the Eastern Black Sea and is bounded to the south by the Transcaucasian Massif. The shoreline of the Eastern Black Sea Basin cuts off the Colchis intermontane trough formed over the rigid Georgian Block, the Achara–Trialeti trough and the Artvin–Bolnisi rigid block.Onshore and offshore data confirm that the subaerial structures have immediate submarine prolongations. Deep drilling conducted within the onshore zone of the Transcaucasus, in the immediate vicinity of the shoreline, revealed that the volcanic formations below the modern sea level extend further into the Eastern Black Sea basin.Recent data on structure and evolution of the Transcaucasus and adjacent area provide new constraints on the geological history of the lithosphere of the region, particularly on the Eastern Black Sea basin located in the collision zone between Eurasian and Africa-Arabian lithosphere plates, proximal to ancient sutures.