Carlos Gomez-Garibello
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Carlos Gomez-Garibello has a total of 36 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Meredith Young
Institute of Health Sciences Education, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences McGill University Montreal Québec Canada
4 shared publications - Beth-Ann Cummings
Centre for Medical Education, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
3 shared publications - Valérie Dory
Undergraduate Medical Education and Centre for Medical Education, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
3 shared publications Maryam Wagner
Department of Surgery, McGill University, Montreal, Canada
2 shared publications- Victoria Talwar
McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
2 shared publications Adam Szulewski
Queen's University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 4 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Surgical Endoscopy
- Vol. 40 (10) , 9081-9091
Video-based assessment for laparoscopic cholecystectomy: development of a rubric for summative evaluation of intraoperative performance
- 4 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Surgical Endoscopy
- Vol. 40 (10) , 9081-9091
Video-based assessment for laparoscopic cholecystectomy: development of a rubric for summative evaluation of intraoperative performance
- 29 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Surgical Endoscopy
- Vol. 37 (7) , 5335-5339
The entrustable professional activities of laparoscopic surgery: moving toward an integrated training model
Background Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) provide the opportunity to integrate multiple competencies into meaningful units that facilitate curriculum development and assessment design. As part of the process of reviewing and enhancing the Fundamentals of Laparoscopic of Surgery (FLS) program, we used the concept of EPAs to create a framework of reference that articulates a contemporary definition of Laparoscopic Surgery (LS). Methods The framework of reference of LS was created with data gathered from a literature review and during series of educational retreats with subject matter experts (SMEs). Various activities were implemented during these retreats to develop the LS EPAs, their constitutive competencies, and related observable behaviors. Results Ten EPAs and associated competency descriptors (articulated as observable behaviors) specific to LS were identified. In addition, knowledge areas were associated to each EPA. Discussion A comprehensive list of EPAs for LS were identified. These EPAs will be used in the development and update of the FLS program. Further, they can be used to guide the development of curriculum, clinical teaching, and assessment in any surgical program with a laparoscopic training component. They are applicable to any level of training by defining the expected observable behaviors associated with a given level of expertise. These fundamental aspects of LS provide a common framework of reference across different surgical specialties.
- 29 March 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Surgical Endoscopy
- Vol. 37 (7) , 5335-5339
The entrustable professional activities of laparoscopic surgery: moving toward an integrated training model
Background Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) provide the opportunity to integrate multiple competencies into meaningful units that facilitate curriculum development and assessment design. As part of the process of reviewing and enhancing the Fundamentals of Laparoscopic of Surgery (FLS) program, we used the concept of EPAs to create a framework of reference that articulates a contemporary definition of Laparoscopic Surgery (LS). Methods The framework of reference of LS was created with data gathered from a literature review and during series of educational retreats with subject matter experts (SMEs). Various activities were implemented during these retreats to develop the LS EPAs, their constitutive competencies, and related observable behaviors. Results Ten EPAs and associated competency descriptors (articulated as observable behaviors) specific to LS were identified. In addition, knowledge areas were associated to each EPA. Discussion A comprehensive list of EPAs for LS were identified. These EPAs will be used in the development and update of the FLS program. Further, they can be used to guide the development of curriculum, clinical teaching, and assessment in any surgical program with a laparoscopic training component. They are applicable to any level of training by defining the expected observable behaviors associated with a given level of expertise. These fundamental aspects of LS provide a common framework of reference across different surgical specialties.
- Open Access
- 21 December 2022
- Published by The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada in Canadian Medical Education Journal
- Vol. 14 (1) , 58-62
Clinical Reasoning in CanMEDS 2025
- 21 December 2022
- Published by The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada in Canadian Medical Education Journal
- Vol. 14 (1) , 58-62
Open AccessClinical Reasoning in CanMEDS 2025
- Open Access
- 18 August 2020
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 9 (5) , 294-301
Learner handover: Perspectives and recommendations from the front-line
Introduction Current medical education models increasingly rely on longitudinal assessments to document learner progress over time. This longitudinal focus has re-kindled discussion regarding learner handover—where assessments are shared across supervisors, rotations, and educational phases, to support learner growth and ease transitions. The authors explored the opinions of, experiences with, and recommendations for successful implementation of learner handover among clinical supervisors. Methods Clinical supervisors from five postgraduate medical education programs at one institution completed an online questionnaire exploring their views regarding learner handover, specifically: potential benefits, risks, and suggestions for implementation. Survey items included open-ended and numerical responses. The authors used an inductive content analysis approach to analyze the open-ended questionnaire responses, and descriptive and correlational analyses for numerical data. Results Seventy-two participants completed the questionnaire. Their perspectives varied widely. Suggested benefits of learner handover included tailored learning, improved assessments, and enhanced patient safety. The main reported risk was the potential for learner handover to bias supervisors’ perceptions of learners, thereby affecting the validity of future assessments and influencing the learner’s educational opportunities and well-being. Participants’ suggestions for implementation focused on who should be involved, when and for whom it should occur, and the content that should be shared. Discussion The diverse opinions of, and recommendations for, learner handover highlight the necessity for handover to maximize learning potential while minimizing potential harms. Supervisors’ suggestions for handover implementation reveal tensions between assessment-of and for-learning.
- 18 August 2020
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 9 (5) , 294-301
Open AccessLearner handover: Perspectives and recommendations from the front-line
Introduction Current medical education models increasingly rely on longitudinal assessments to document learner progress over time. This longitudinal focus has re-kindled discussion regarding learner handover—where assessments are shared across supervisors, rotations, and educational phases, to support learner growth and ease transitions. The authors explored the opinions of, experiences with, and recommendations for successful implementation of learner handover among clinical supervisors. Methods Clinical supervisors from five postgraduate medical education programs at one institution completed an online questionnaire exploring their views regarding learner handover, specifically: potential benefits, risks, and suggestions for implementation. Survey items included open-ended and numerical responses. The authors used an inductive content analysis approach to analyze the open-ended questionnaire responses, and descriptive and correlational analyses for numerical data. Results Seventy-two participants completed the questionnaire. Their perspectives varied widely. Suggested benefits of learner handover included tailored learning, improved assessments, and enhanced patient safety. The main reported risk was the potential for learner handover to bias supervisors’ perceptions of learners, thereby affecting the validity of future assessments and influencing the learner’s educational opportunities and well-being. Participants’ suggestions for implementation focused on who should be involved, when and for whom it should occur, and the content that should be shared. Discussion The diverse opinions of, and recommendations for, learner handover highlight the necessity for handover to maximize learning potential while minimizing potential harms. Supervisors’ suggestions for handover implementation reveal tensions between assessment-of and for-learning.
- 21 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Teacher
- Vol. 42 (3) , 291-298
Teachers’ mindsets in medical education: A pilot survey of clinical supervisors
Purpose: Current medical education models maintain that competencies such as professionalism and communication can be taught; however, some argue that certain attributes that make up these competencies, such as empathy, are fixed. Teachers’ implicit theories, or mindsets (beliefs about the fixed versus learnable nature of human attributes) have been shown to impact their teaching and assessment practices; but little work has explored mindsets in medical education. We examined clinical supervisors’ mindsets of two cognitive attributes (intelligence and clinical reasoning) and two affective attributes (moral character and empathy). Methods: Clinical supervisors (n = 40) from three specialities completed a survey designed to measure mindsets using two existing instruments for intelligence and moral character and 18 new items for clinical reasoning and empathy. Participants completed the survey twice for test-retest reliability (n = 25). Results: New items had satisfactory psychometric properties. Clinical supervisors’ mindsets were mixed. Only 8% of participants saw clinical reasoning as fixed while more saw empathy (45%), intelligence (53%), and moral character (53%) as fixed – running counter to current educational models that characterize these attributes as learnable. Conclusion: This study provides evidence supporting the use of these new tools to measure mindsets that may help to better understand the impact of mindsets on medical education.
- 21 October 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Teacher
- Vol. 42 (3) , 291-298
Teachers’ mindsets in medical education: A pilot survey of clinical supervisors
Purpose: Current medical education models maintain that competencies such as professionalism and communication can be taught; however, some argue that certain attributes that make up these competencies, such as empathy, are fixed. Teachers’ implicit theories, or mindsets (beliefs about the fixed versus learnable nature of human attributes) have been shown to impact their teaching and assessment practices; but little work has explored mindsets in medical education. We examined clinical supervisors’ mindsets of two cognitive attributes (intelligence and clinical reasoning) and two affective attributes (moral character and empathy). Methods: Clinical supervisors (n = 40) from three specialities completed a survey designed to measure mindsets using two existing instruments for intelligence and moral character and 18 new items for clinical reasoning and empathy. Participants completed the survey twice for test-retest reliability (n = 25). Results: New items had satisfactory psychometric properties. Clinical supervisors’ mindsets were mixed. Only 8% of participants saw clinical reasoning as fixed while more saw empathy (45%), intelligence (53%), and moral character (53%) as fixed – running counter to current educational models that characterize these attributes as learnable. Conclusion: This study provides evidence supporting the use of these new tools to measure mindsets that may help to better understand the impact of mindsets on medical education.
- 14 November 2018
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 52 (12) , 1259-1270
The challenges of detecting progress in generic competencies in the clinical setting
Context: Competency‐based medical education has spurred the implementation of longitudinal workplace‐based assessment (WBA) programmes to track learners’ development of competencies. These hinge on the appropriate use of assessment instruments by assessors. This study aimed to validate our assessment programme and specifically to explore whether assessors’ beliefs and behaviours rendered the detection of progress possible. Methods: We implemented a longitudinal WBA programme in the third year of a primarily rotation‐based clerkship. The programme used the professionalism mini‐evaluation exercise (P‐ MEX ) to detect progress in generic competencies. We used mixed methods: a retrospective psychometric examination of student assessment data in one academic year, and a prospective focus group and interview study of assessors’ beliefs and reported behaviours related to the assessment. Results: We analysed 1662 assessment forms for 186 students. We conducted interviews and focus groups with 21 assessors from different professions and disciplines. Scores were excellent from the outset (3.5–3.7/4), with no meaningful increase across blocks (average overall scores: 3.6 in block 1 versus 3.7 in blocks 2 and 3; F = 8.310, d.f. 2, p < 0.001). The main source of variance was the forms (47%) and only 1% of variance was attributable to students, which led to low generalisability across forms ( E ρ 2 = 0.18). Assessors reported using multiple observations to produce their assessments and were reluctant to harm students by consigning anything negative to writing. They justified the use of a consistent benchmark across time by citing the basic nature of the form or a belief that the ‘competencies’ assessed were in fact fixed attributes that were unlikely to change. Conclusions: Assessors may purposefully deviate from instructions in order to meet their ethical standards of good assessment. Furthermore, generic competencies may be viewed as intrinsic and fixed rather than as learnable. Implementing a longitudinal WBA programme is complex and requires careful consideration of assessors’ beliefs and values.
- 14 November 2018
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 52 (12) , 1259-1270
The challenges of detecting progress in generic competencies in the clinical setting
Context: Competency‐based medical education has spurred the implementation of longitudinal workplace‐based assessment (WBA) programmes to track learners’ development of competencies. These hinge on the appropriate use of assessment instruments by assessors. This study aimed to validate our assessment programme and specifically to explore whether assessors’ beliefs and behaviours rendered the detection of progress possible. Methods: We implemented a longitudinal WBA programme in the third year of a primarily rotation‐based clerkship. The programme used the professionalism mini‐evaluation exercise (P‐ MEX ) to detect progress in generic competencies. We used mixed methods: a retrospective psychometric examination of student assessment data in one academic year, and a prospective focus group and interview study of assessors’ beliefs and reported behaviours related to the assessment. Results: We analysed 1662 assessment forms for 186 students. We conducted interviews and focus groups with 21 assessors from different professions and disciplines. Scores were excellent from the outset (3.5–3.7/4), with no meaningful increase across blocks (average overall scores: 3.6 in block 1 versus 3.7 in blocks 2 and 3; F = 8.310, d.f. 2, p < 0.001). The main source of variance was the forms (47%) and only 1% of variance was attributable to students, which led to low generalisability across forms ( E ρ 2 = 0.18). Assessors reported using multiple observations to produce their assessments and were reluctant to harm students by consigning anything negative to writing. They justified the use of a consistent benchmark across time by citing the basic nature of the form or a belief that the ‘competencies’ assessed were in fact fixed attributes that were unlikely to change. Conclusions: Assessors may purposefully deviate from instructions in order to meet their ethical standards of good assessment. Furthermore, generic competencies may be viewed as intrinsic and fixed rather than as learnable. Implementing a longitudinal WBA programme is complex and requires careful consideration of assessors’ beliefs and values.
- Open Access
- 9 November 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 52 (3) , 254-262
Emotions and assessment: considerations for rater‐based judgements of entrustment
Context: Assessment is subject to increasing scrutiny as medical education transitions towards a competency‐based medical education ( CBME ) model. Traditional perspectives on the roles of assessment emphasise high‐stakes, summative assessment, whereas CBME argues for formative assessment. Revisiting conceptualisations about the roles and formats of assessment in medical education provides opportunities to examine understandings and expectations of the assessment of learners. The act of the rater generating scores might be considered as an exclusively cognitive exercise; however, current literature has drawn attention to the notion of raters as measurement instruments, thereby attributing additional factors to their decision‐making processes, such as social considerations and intuition. However, the literature has not comprehensively examined the influence of raters’ emotions during assessment. In this narrative review, we explore the influence of raters’ emotions in the assessment of learners. Methods: We summarise existing literature that describes the role of emotions in assessment broadly, and rater‐based assessment specifically, across a variety of fields. The literature related to emotions and assessment is examined from different perspectives, including those of educational context, decision making and rater cognition. We use the concept of entrustable professional activities ( EPA s) to contextualise a discussion of the ways in which raters’ emotions may have meaningful impacts on the decisions they make in clinical settings. This review summarises findings from different perspectives and identifies areas for consideration for the role of emotion in rater‐based assessment, and areas for future research. Conclusions: We identify and discuss three different interpretations of the influence of raters’ emotions during assessments: (i) emotions lead to biased decision making; (ii) emotions contribute random noise to assessment, and (iii) emotions constitute legitimate sources of information that contribute to assessment decisions. We discuss these three interpretations in terms of areas for future research and implications for assessment.
- 9 November 2017
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 52 (3) , 254-262
Open AccessEmotions and assessment: considerations for rater‐based judgements of entrustment
Context: Assessment is subject to increasing scrutiny as medical education transitions towards a competency‐based medical education ( CBME ) model. Traditional perspectives on the roles of assessment emphasise high‐stakes, summative assessment, whereas CBME argues for formative assessment. Revisiting conceptualisations about the roles and formats of assessment in medical education provides opportunities to examine understandings and expectations of the assessment of learners. The act of the rater generating scores might be considered as an exclusively cognitive exercise; however, current literature has drawn attention to the notion of raters as measurement instruments, thereby attributing additional factors to their decision‐making processes, such as social considerations and intuition. However, the literature has not comprehensively examined the influence of raters’ emotions during assessment. In this narrative review, we explore the influence of raters’ emotions in the assessment of learners. Methods: We summarise existing literature that describes the role of emotions in assessment broadly, and rater‐based assessment specifically, across a variety of fields. The literature related to emotions and assessment is examined from different perspectives, including those of educational context, decision making and rater cognition. We use the concept of entrustable professional activities ( EPA s) to contextualise a discussion of the ways in which raters’ emotions may have meaningful impacts on the decisions they make in clinical settings. This review summarises findings from different perspectives and identifies areas for consideration for the role of emotion in rater‐based assessment, and areas for future research. Conclusions: We identify and discuss three different interpretations of the influence of raters’ emotions during assessments: (i) emotions lead to biased decision making; (ii) emotions contribute random noise to assessment, and (iii) emotions constitute legitimate sources of information that contribute to assessment decisions. We discuss these three interpretations in terms of areas for future research and implications for assessment.
- Open Access
Children’s Spiritual Lives: The Development of a Children’s Spirituality Measure
Previous researchers who have studied children’s spirituality have often used narrow measures that do not account for the rich spiritual experiences of children within a multi-faith context. In the current study, we describe the initial stages of development of a children’s spirituality measure, in which items were derived from children’s spiritual narratives. An exploratory factor analysis of the items revealed three main factors, including Comfort (Factor 1), Omnipresence (Factor 2), and Duality (Factor 3). As rated by their parents, children from families that were more spiritual and religious had higher scores on the newly-developed measure. Limitations and future directions are discussed.
Open AccessChildren’s Spiritual Lives: The Development of a Children’s Spirituality Measure
Previous researchers who have studied children’s spirituality have often used narrow measures that do not account for the rich spiritual experiences of children within a multi-faith context. In the current study, we describe the initial stages of development of a children’s spirituality measure, in which items were derived from children’s spiritual narratives. An exploratory factor analysis of the items revealed three main factors, including Comfort (Factor 1), Omnipresence (Factor 2), and Duality (Factor 3). As rated by their parents, children from families that were more spiritual and religious had higher scores on the newly-developed measure. Limitations and future directions are discussed.
- 5 January 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of School Violence
- Vol. 15 (4) , 503-522
Face-to-Face and Online: An Investigation of Children’s and Adolescents’ Bullying Behavior Through the Lens of Moral Emotions and Judgments
The current study investigated the influence of type of aggression (cyberbullying or traditional bullying) and participant role (bystander or perpetrator) on children and adolescents’ self-attribution of moral emotions and judgments, while examining the influence of chronological age. Participants (N = 122, 8–16 years) evaluated vignettes and were asked to self-attribute the emotions they would feel in the role of the perpetrator or bystander. Results revealed that participants were more likely to self-attribute morally responsible emotions compared to morally disengaged emotions across contexts. A significant moderation model revealed that the effect of morally disengaged emotions on moral evaluations depends on participants’ chronological age, while controlling for social desirability. The findings are discussed in terms of implications for school violence and victimization.
- 5 January 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of School Violence
- Vol. 15 (4) , 503-522
Face-to-Face and Online: An Investigation of Children’s and Adolescents’ Bullying Behavior Through the Lens of Moral Emotions and Judgments
The current study investigated the influence of type of aggression (cyberbullying or traditional bullying) and participant role (bystander or perpetrator) on children and adolescents’ self-attribution of moral emotions and judgments, while examining the influence of chronological age. Participants (N = 122, 8–16 years) evaluated vignettes and were asked to self-attribute the emotions they would feel in the role of the perpetrator or bystander. Results revealed that participants were more likely to self-attribute morally responsible emotions compared to morally disengaged emotions across contexts. A significant moderation model revealed that the effect of morally disengaged emotions on moral evaluations depends on participants’ chronological age, while controlling for social desirability. The findings are discussed in terms of implications for school violence and victimization.