Liza S. Comita
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Liza S. Comita has a total of 299 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Stephen P. Hubbell
Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute Panama Ancón Panama
10 shared publications- Simon A. Queenborough
Yale School of the Environment Yale University New Haven Connecticut USA
9 shared publications Jess K. Zimmerman
Department of Environmental Sciences Universidad de Puerto Rico San Juan Puerto Rico
7 shared publications- Jill Thompson
UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, Bush Estate, Penicuik, UK
7 shared publications - Stuart Joseph Wright
Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute Apartado 0843‐03092 Balboa Panama
7 shared publications Nathan G. Swenson
Department of Biological Sciences University of Notre Dame Notre Dame Indiana USA
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Vegetation Science
- Vol. 37 (4)
Herbaceous Plants in Forest Ecosystems: One Hundred Fundamental and Applied Questions
Aims: Herbaceous plants (herbs) found in the understory of forests contribute substantially to the biodiversity of these ecosystems, as well as being important socio‐culturally, economically, and for advancing ecological theory. However, the ecology of herbs is less well understood compared with woody plants, despite evidence that herbs are physiologically and ecologically different. Similarly, herb research has focused on north temperate forests, with less information from forests in the tropics and Global South. Understanding this knowledge gap, and recognizing the critical importance of expanding and streamlining the scope of research on forest herbs, we set out to identify 100 fundamental and applied questions related to the ecology of this distinct plant group. Methods: We first conducted a survey shared widely online with the ecological community, which generated a total of 130 questions. We then held a 3‐day workshop involving invited herb researchers with expertise in various forest ecosystems, during which the questions were narrowed down through multiple rounds of discussion, revision, and rewording. For conceptual clarity, we then grouped the questions into 19 subject areas, although some questions are relevant to multiple subject areas. Conclusions: These questions serve as a road map for future research in fundamental and applied herbaceous ecology in forested ecosystems. A common theme that emerged from this exercise was the need for standardized protocols to generate comparable data on terrestrial herbs from forests across the planet, including all forest types, biomes, and types of anthropogenic impacts. Research to address these questions will yield knowledge critical for advancing fundamental understanding of this ecologically important group of plants as well as the vital ecosystem services they provide, especially under global change, thus aiding better conservation and restoration policy and practice for forest ecosystems.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Vegetation Science
- Vol. 37 (4)
Open AccessHerbaceous Plants in Forest Ecosystems: One Hundred Fundamental and Applied Questions
Aims: Herbaceous plants (herbs) found in the understory of forests contribute substantially to the biodiversity of these ecosystems, as well as being important socio‐culturally, economically, and for advancing ecological theory. However, the ecology of herbs is less well understood compared with woody plants, despite evidence that herbs are physiologically and ecologically different. Similarly, herb research has focused on north temperate forests, with less information from forests in the tropics and Global South. Understanding this knowledge gap, and recognizing the critical importance of expanding and streamlining the scope of research on forest herbs, we set out to identify 100 fundamental and applied questions related to the ecology of this distinct plant group. Methods: We first conducted a survey shared widely online with the ecological community, which generated a total of 130 questions. We then held a 3‐day workshop involving invited herb researchers with expertise in various forest ecosystems, during which the questions were narrowed down through multiple rounds of discussion, revision, and rewording. For conceptual clarity, we then grouped the questions into 19 subject areas, although some questions are relevant to multiple subject areas. Conclusions: These questions serve as a road map for future research in fundamental and applied herbaceous ecology in forested ecosystems. A common theme that emerged from this exercise was the need for standardized protocols to generate comparable data on terrestrial herbs from forests across the planet, including all forest types, biomes, and types of anthropogenic impacts. Research to address these questions will yield knowledge critical for advancing fundamental understanding of this ecologically important group of plants as well as the vital ecosystem services they provide, especially under global change, thus aiding better conservation and restoration policy and practice for forest ecosystems.
- 9 April 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Forest Ecology and Management
- Vol. 613
Demographic groups do not explain variation in tropical seedling performance with secondary forest age
- 9 April 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Forest Ecology and Management
- Vol. 613
Demographic groups do not explain variation in tropical seedling performance with secondary forest age
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Applied Vegetation Science
- Vol. 29 (2)
Experimental Assessment of Natural Enemy Impacts on Palm Regeneration at Forest Edge Versus Interior
Aims: Forest fragmentation induces edge effects that alter the abiotic environment and plant–enemy interactions, with potential consequences for the regeneration of shade‐tolerant species. Importantly, plant–enemy interactions are context‐dependent, suggesting that fragmentation can differentially modify natural enemy pressure along edge‐interior gradients, weakening some interactions while intensifying others. However, experiments quantifying how multiple natural enemies differentially affect seed germination and seedling establishment at forest edges versus interiors remain scarce. To provide a biotic mechanistic understanding of edge effects in plant regeneration, we experimentally evaluated how natural enemies (vertebrates, insects, and fungi) influence seed germination and seedling establishment of two shade‐tolerant palm species, Prestoea decurrens and Synechanthus warscewiczianus , in forest edges and interiors within a highly fragmented landscape. Location: Choco Forest in northwestern Ecuador. Methods: In an enemy‐exclusion experiment, we manipulated access by natural enemies using wire cages and pesticides and established control plots at 13 paired edge (0–10 m) and interior forest (90–100 m) sites. We monitored seed germination (radicle emergence) and seedling establishment (development of epicotyl and roots) weekly over 5 months. Results: Germination and establishment were consistently higher in the forest interior for both species, highlighting strong negative edge effects on early recruitment. Insects emerged as the primary natural enemies; they negatively impacted the regeneration of P. decurrens in both edge and interior habitats, whereas for S. warscewiczianus , the impact was restricted to the forest interior. Conversely, fungi and vertebrates had no detectable effects. Conclusions: Our findings demonstrate that forest edges and biotic filtering through insect predation limited the regeneration of the two understory palm species evaluated, reducing their regeneration potential in forest remnants within fragmented landscapes. Conservation strategies should prioritize maintaining interior forest conditions, minimizing edges when possible, and preventing seed and seedling damage by insects in restoration programs.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Applied Vegetation Science
- Vol. 29 (2)
Experimental Assessment of Natural Enemy Impacts on Palm Regeneration at Forest Edge Versus Interior
Aims: Forest fragmentation induces edge effects that alter the abiotic environment and plant–enemy interactions, with potential consequences for the regeneration of shade‐tolerant species. Importantly, plant–enemy interactions are context‐dependent, suggesting that fragmentation can differentially modify natural enemy pressure along edge‐interior gradients, weakening some interactions while intensifying others. However, experiments quantifying how multiple natural enemies differentially affect seed germination and seedling establishment at forest edges versus interiors remain scarce. To provide a biotic mechanistic understanding of edge effects in plant regeneration, we experimentally evaluated how natural enemies (vertebrates, insects, and fungi) influence seed germination and seedling establishment of two shade‐tolerant palm species, Prestoea decurrens and Synechanthus warscewiczianus , in forest edges and interiors within a highly fragmented landscape. Location: Choco Forest in northwestern Ecuador. Methods: In an enemy‐exclusion experiment, we manipulated access by natural enemies using wire cages and pesticides and established control plots at 13 paired edge (0–10 m) and interior forest (90–100 m) sites. We monitored seed germination (radicle emergence) and seedling establishment (development of epicotyl and roots) weekly over 5 months. Results: Germination and establishment were consistently higher in the forest interior for both species, highlighting strong negative edge effects on early recruitment. Insects emerged as the primary natural enemies; they negatively impacted the regeneration of P. decurrens in both edge and interior habitats, whereas for S. warscewiczianus , the impact was restricted to the forest interior. Conversely, fungi and vertebrates had no detectable effects. Conclusions: Our findings demonstrate that forest edges and biotic filtering through insect predation limited the regeneration of the two understory palm species evaluated, reducing their regeneration potential in forest remnants within fragmented landscapes. Conservation strategies should prioritize maintaining interior forest conditions, minimizing edges when possible, and preventing seed and seedling damage by insects in restoration programs.
- 21 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Plant and Soil
- Vol. 521 (2) , 1903-1914
Feedbacks in a mixed mycorrhizal rainforest in Sri Lanka are more stabilizing in the field than in the shadehouse
- 21 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Plant and Soil
- Vol. 521 (2) , 1903-1914
Feedbacks in a mixed mycorrhizal rainforest in Sri Lanka are more stabilizing in the field than in the shadehouse
- Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Applications
- Vol. 36 (1) , e70180
Timber and trails: Low‐intensity selective logging and elephant trails shape seedling dynamics in an Afrotropical forest
Very low‐intensity selective logging can be a compromise between strict conservation and income‐generating land use in tropical forests. Investigating how selective logging influences the understory environment and seedling dynamics as the forest regenerates offers insights into whether logging alters forest dynamics, influencing the composition and structure of future forests. We explored how very low‐intensity logging (−1 ) influences understory factors and seedling dynamics across a logging chronosequence (unlogged forest vs. actively logged forest and forest logged 4 and 14 years prior). To do this, we assessed (1) how canopy openness, prevalence of vegetation damage, and elephant trails differ in logged forests at different recovery stages compared to unlogged forest; (2) how these understory factors influence seedling dynamics; (3) how seedling dynamics differ across the logging chronosequence; and (4) how logging impacts liana vs. tree seedlings across the chronosequence. We observed greater canopy openness and vegetation damage in logged forests up to 4 years after logging and higher elephant trail prevalence 14 years after logging compared to unlogged forests. Seedling survival was lower in plots with higher canopy openness, more vegetation damage, and on elephant trails, while growth and recruitment were not affected by these variables. Actively logged forests initially had lower seedling survival and recruitment, but higher growth rates compared to unlogged forests. However, 14 years after logging, seedling dynamics were mostly similar to unlogged forests. Liana seedlings had a slight growth advantage over tree seedlings in all logged forests compared to unlogged forests. Results from our study suggest that very low‐intensity selective logging causes temporary shifts in understory dynamics rather than long‐term shifts in forest recovery trajectories. These managed areas have potential as land that can contribute to OECM targets—functioning as mixed‐use corridors, connecting protected areas across a landscape and contributing to biodiversity and wildlife conservation—especially in countries with high forest cover and low deforestation.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Applications
- Vol. 36 (1) , e70180
Open AccessTimber and trails: Low‐intensity selective logging and elephant trails shape seedling dynamics in an Afrotropical forest
Very low‐intensity selective logging can be a compromise between strict conservation and income‐generating land use in tropical forests. Investigating how selective logging influences the understory environment and seedling dynamics as the forest regenerates offers insights into whether logging alters forest dynamics, influencing the composition and structure of future forests. We explored how very low‐intensity logging (−1 ) influences understory factors and seedling dynamics across a logging chronosequence (unlogged forest vs. actively logged forest and forest logged 4 and 14 years prior). To do this, we assessed (1) how canopy openness, prevalence of vegetation damage, and elephant trails differ in logged forests at different recovery stages compared to unlogged forest; (2) how these understory factors influence seedling dynamics; (3) how seedling dynamics differ across the logging chronosequence; and (4) how logging impacts liana vs. tree seedlings across the chronosequence. We observed greater canopy openness and vegetation damage in logged forests up to 4 years after logging and higher elephant trail prevalence 14 years after logging compared to unlogged forests. Seedling survival was lower in plots with higher canopy openness, more vegetation damage, and on elephant trails, while growth and recruitment were not affected by these variables. Actively logged forests initially had lower seedling survival and recruitment, but higher growth rates compared to unlogged forests. However, 14 years after logging, seedling dynamics were mostly similar to unlogged forests. Liana seedlings had a slight growth advantage over tree seedlings in all logged forests compared to unlogged forests. Results from our study suggest that very low‐intensity selective logging causes temporary shifts in understory dynamics rather than long‐term shifts in forest recovery trajectories. These managed areas have potential as land that can contribute to OECM targets—functioning as mixed‐use corridors, connecting protected areas across a landscape and contributing to biodiversity and wildlife conservation—especially in countries with high forest cover and low deforestation.
- Open Access
Intraspecific Leaf Trait Responses to Habitat Heterogeneity in a Tropical Rainforest
Functional traits provide key insights into plant ecological strategies and responses to environmental heterogeneity, yet the role of intraspecific trait variability (ITV) in tropical rainforests remains underexplored. We examined ITV in six leaf traits—leaf thickness (LT), leaf area (LA), specific leaf area (SLA), leaf dry matter content (LDMC), leaf nitrogen content (LNC), and stomatal density (SD)—in saplings of 15 dominant tree species across ridge and valley habitats in a Sri Lankan tropical lowland rainforest. We compared interspecific and intraspecific variation and quantified trait plasticity using the plasticity index. Significant ITV was observed for LT, LA, and SD, with ridge individuals showing smaller, thicker leaves with lower SD. SLA, LDMC, and LNC exhibited no overall habitat-level differences, though species-specific divergent responses were detected. Interspecific variation exceeded ITV for most traits, except for LNC, where ITV accounted for 55% of total variation. Trait plasticity varied among traits, with LNC showing the highest plasticity. These results indicate that individuals adjust leaf traits in response to fine-scale habitat heterogeneity, reflecting shifts in resource-use strategies. Overall, ITV is ecologically meaningful and should be incorporated into community-level studies and ecosystem models to improve predictions of plant community dynamics and ecosystem functioning under environmental change.
Open AccessIntraspecific Leaf Trait Responses to Habitat Heterogeneity in a Tropical Rainforest
Functional traits provide key insights into plant ecological strategies and responses to environmental heterogeneity, yet the role of intraspecific trait variability (ITV) in tropical rainforests remains underexplored. We examined ITV in six leaf traits—leaf thickness (LT), leaf area (LA), specific leaf area (SLA), leaf dry matter content (LDMC), leaf nitrogen content (LNC), and stomatal density (SD)—in saplings of 15 dominant tree species across ridge and valley habitats in a Sri Lankan tropical lowland rainforest. We compared interspecific and intraspecific variation and quantified trait plasticity using the plasticity index. Significant ITV was observed for LT, LA, and SD, with ridge individuals showing smaller, thicker leaves with lower SD. SLA, LDMC, and LNC exhibited no overall habitat-level differences, though species-specific divergent responses were detected. Interspecific variation exceeded ITV for most traits, except for LNC, where ITV accounted for 55% of total variation. Trait plasticity varied among traits, with LNC showing the highest plasticity. These results indicate that individuals adjust leaf traits in response to fine-scale habitat heterogeneity, reflecting shifts in resource-use strategies. Overall, ITV is ecologically meaningful and should be incorporated into community-level studies and ecosystem models to improve predictions of plant community dynamics and ecosystem functioning under environmental change.
- 2 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology Letters
- Vol. 28 (4) , e70019
Seed Production and 22 Years of Climatic Changes in an Everwet Neotropical Forest
Examining the cues and drivers influencing seed production is crucial to better understand forest resilience to climate change. We explored the effects of five climatic variables on seed production over 22 years in an everwet Amazonian forest, by separating direct effects of these variables from indirect effects mediated through flower production. We observed a decline in seed production over the study period, which was primarily explained by direct effects of rising nighttime temperatures and declining average vapour pressure deficits. Higher daytime temperatures were positively related to seed output, mainly through a flower‐mediated effect, while rainfall effects on seed production were more nuanced, showing either positive or negative relationships depending on the seasonal timing of rains. If these trends continue, they are likely to lead to significant changes in forest dynamics, potentially impacting both forest structure and species composition.
- 2 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology Letters
- Vol. 28 (4) , e70019
Seed Production and 22 Years of Climatic Changes in an Everwet Neotropical Forest
Examining the cues and drivers influencing seed production is crucial to better understand forest resilience to climate change. We explored the effects of five climatic variables on seed production over 22 years in an everwet Amazonian forest, by separating direct effects of these variables from indirect effects mediated through flower production. We observed a decline in seed production over the study period, which was primarily explained by direct effects of rising nighttime temperatures and declining average vapour pressure deficits. Higher daytime temperatures were positively related to seed output, mainly through a flower‐mediated effect, while rainfall effects on seed production were more nuanced, showing either positive or negative relationships depending on the seasonal timing of rains. If these trends continue, they are likely to lead to significant changes in forest dynamics, potentially impacting both forest structure and species composition.
- Open Access
Putting seedlings on the map: Trade‐offs in demographic rates between ontogenetic size classes in five tropical forests
All species must partition resources among the processes that underly growth, survival, and reproduction. The resulting demographic trade‐offs constrain the range of viable life‐history strategies and are hypothesized to promote local coexistence. Tropical forests pose ideal systems to study demographic trade‐offs as they have a high diversity of coexisting tree species whose life‐history strategies tend to align along two orthogonal axes of variation: a growth–survival trade‐off that separates species with fast growth from species with high survival and a stature–recruitment trade‐off that separates species that achieve large stature from species with high recruitment. As these trade‐offs have typically been explored for trees ≥1 cm dbh, it is unclear how species' growth and survival during earliest seedling stages are related to the trade‐offs for trees ≥1 cm dbh. Here, we used principal components and correlation analyses to (1) determine the main demographic trade‐offs among seed‐to‐seedling transition rates and growth and survival rates from the seedling to overstory size classes of 1188 tree species from large‐scale forest dynamics plots in Panama, Puerto Rico, Ecuador, Taiwan, and Malaysia and (2) quantify the predictive power of maximum dbh, wood density, seed mass, and specific leaf area for species' position along these demographic trade‐off gradients. In four out of five forests, the growth–survival trade‐off was the most important demographic trade‐off and encompassed growth and survival of both seedlings and trees ≥1 cm dbh. The second most important trade‐off separated species with relatively fast growth and high survival at the seedling stage from species with relatively fast growth and high survival ≥1 cm dbh. The relationship between seed‐to‐seedling transition rates and these two trade‐off aces differed between sites. All four traits were significant predictors for species' position along the two trade‐off gradients, albeit with varying importance. We concluded that, after accounting for the species' position along the growth–survival trade‐off, tree species tend to trade off growth and survival at the seedling with later life stages. This ontogenetic trade‐off offers a mechanistic explanation for the stature–recruitment trade‐off that constitutes an additional ontogenetic dimension of life‐history variation in species‐rich ecosystems.
Open AccessPutting seedlings on the map: Trade‐offs in demographic rates between ontogenetic size classes in five tropical forests
All species must partition resources among the processes that underly growth, survival, and reproduction. The resulting demographic trade‐offs constrain the range of viable life‐history strategies and are hypothesized to promote local coexistence. Tropical forests pose ideal systems to study demographic trade‐offs as they have a high diversity of coexisting tree species whose life‐history strategies tend to align along two orthogonal axes of variation: a growth–survival trade‐off that separates species with fast growth from species with high survival and a stature–recruitment trade‐off that separates species that achieve large stature from species with high recruitment. As these trade‐offs have typically been explored for trees ≥1 cm dbh, it is unclear how species' growth and survival during earliest seedling stages are related to the trade‐offs for trees ≥1 cm dbh. Here, we used principal components and correlation analyses to (1) determine the main demographic trade‐offs among seed‐to‐seedling transition rates and growth and survival rates from the seedling to overstory size classes of 1188 tree species from large‐scale forest dynamics plots in Panama, Puerto Rico, Ecuador, Taiwan, and Malaysia and (2) quantify the predictive power of maximum dbh, wood density, seed mass, and specific leaf area for species' position along these demographic trade‐off gradients. In four out of five forests, the growth–survival trade‐off was the most important demographic trade‐off and encompassed growth and survival of both seedlings and trees ≥1 cm dbh. The second most important trade‐off separated species with relatively fast growth and high survival at the seedling stage from species with relatively fast growth and high survival ≥1 cm dbh. The relationship between seed‐to‐seedling transition rates and these two trade‐off aces differed between sites. All four traits were significant predictors for species' position along the two trade‐off gradients, albeit with varying importance. We concluded that, after accounting for the species' position along the growth–survival trade‐off, tree species tend to trade off growth and survival at the seedling with later life stages. This ontogenetic trade‐off offers a mechanistic explanation for the stature–recruitment trade‐off that constitutes an additional ontogenetic dimension of life‐history variation in species‐rich ecosystems.
- Open Access
- 22 November 2024
- Published by Smithsonian Institution
Long-Term Census of Seedlings and Small Saplings in the Barro Colorado Island 50-ha Forest Dynamics Plot, Panama
Dynamics at early life stages play a critical role in shaping the composition and diversity of tropical tree communities. To better understand spatial and temporal patterns of recruitment, growth, and survival at early life stages, we established a long-term census of woody seedlings and small saplings in the Barro Colorado Island 50-ha Forest Dynamics Plot. Individuals ≥20 cm tall and <1cm diameter at breast height (dbh) were censused in 18,434 1-m 2 seedling plots every one to two years between 2001 and 2018, resulting in a dataset of 1,002,400 observations of 185,693 individuals of more than 400 tree, shrub, and liana species. Here, we present patterns of seedling density and diversity from this long-term census and review the main findings of published studies that have used this dataset.
- 22 November 2024
- Published by Smithsonian Institution
Open AccessLong-Term Census of Seedlings and Small Saplings in the Barro Colorado Island 50-ha Forest Dynamics Plot, Panama
Dynamics at early life stages play a critical role in shaping the composition and diversity of tropical tree communities. To better understand spatial and temporal patterns of recruitment, growth, and survival at early life stages, we established a long-term census of woody seedlings and small saplings in the Barro Colorado Island 50-ha Forest Dynamics Plot. Individuals ≥20 cm tall and <1cm diameter at breast height (dbh) were censused in 18,434 1-m 2 seedling plots every one to two years between 2001 and 2018, resulting in a dataset of 1,002,400 observations of 185,693 individuals of more than 400 tree, shrub, and liana species. Here, we present patterns of seedling density and diversity from this long-term census and review the main findings of published studies that have used this dataset.
- Open Access
Liana versus tree seedling responses to spatial and temporal variation in dry season severity
Lianas are key components of tropical forests, particularly at sites with more severe dry seasons. In contrast, trees are more abundant and speciose in wetter areas. The seasonal growth advantage (SGA) hypothesis postulates that such contrasting distributions are produced by higher liana growth relative to trees during seasonal droughts. The SGA has been investigated for larger size classes (e.g., ≥5 cm diameter at 1.3 m, dbh), but rarely for seedlings. Using eight annual censuses of >12,000 seedlings of 483 tree and liana species conducted at eight 1‐ha plots spanning a strong rainfall gradient in central Panama, we evaluated whether liana seedlings had higher growth and/or survival rates than tree seedlings at sites with stronger droughts. We also tested whether an extreme El Niño drought during the study period had a more negative effect on tree compared to liana seedlings. The absolute density of liana seedlings was similar across the rainfall gradient, ranging from 0.32 individuals/m2 (0.20–0.49, 95% credible interval [CI]) at the driest end of the gradient and 0.27 individuals/m2 (0.13–0.51 95% CI) at the wettest end of the gradient. The relative density of liana seedlings compared to tree seedlings was higher at sites with stronger dry seasons (0.27, 0.21–0.33, 95% CI), compared to wetter sites (0.12, 0.04–0.20 95% CI), due to lower tree seedling densities at drier sites. However, liana seedlings did not grow or survive better than tree seedlings in drier sites compared to wetter sites. Tree seedlings were more negatively impacted in terms of mortality by the extreme El Niño drought than liana seedlings, with an increase in annual mortality rate of 0.013 (0.003–0.025 95% CI) compared to lianas of −0.009 (−0.028 to 0.008 95% CI), but not growth. Our results indicate that lianas do not have a SGA over trees at the seedling stage. Instead, higher survival of liana versus tree seedlings during severe droughts or differences in liana versus tree fecundity or germination across the rainfall gradient likely explain why liana seedlings have higher relative densities at drier sites.
Open AccessLiana versus tree seedling responses to spatial and temporal variation in dry season severity
Lianas are key components of tropical forests, particularly at sites with more severe dry seasons. In contrast, trees are more abundant and speciose in wetter areas. The seasonal growth advantage (SGA) hypothesis postulates that such contrasting distributions are produced by higher liana growth relative to trees during seasonal droughts. The SGA has been investigated for larger size classes (e.g., ≥5 cm diameter at 1.3 m, dbh), but rarely for seedlings. Using eight annual censuses of >12,000 seedlings of 483 tree and liana species conducted at eight 1‐ha plots spanning a strong rainfall gradient in central Panama, we evaluated whether liana seedlings had higher growth and/or survival rates than tree seedlings at sites with stronger droughts. We also tested whether an extreme El Niño drought during the study period had a more negative effect on tree compared to liana seedlings. The absolute density of liana seedlings was similar across the rainfall gradient, ranging from 0.32 individuals/m2 (0.20–0.49, 95% credible interval [CI]) at the driest end of the gradient and 0.27 individuals/m2 (0.13–0.51 95% CI) at the wettest end of the gradient. The relative density of liana seedlings compared to tree seedlings was higher at sites with stronger dry seasons (0.27, 0.21–0.33, 95% CI), compared to wetter sites (0.12, 0.04–0.20 95% CI), due to lower tree seedling densities at drier sites. However, liana seedlings did not grow or survive better than tree seedlings in drier sites compared to wetter sites. Tree seedlings were more negatively impacted in terms of mortality by the extreme El Niño drought than liana seedlings, with an increase in annual mortality rate of 0.013 (0.003–0.025 95% CI) compared to lianas of −0.009 (−0.028 to 0.008 95% CI), but not growth. Our results indicate that lianas do not have a SGA over trees at the seedling stage. Instead, higher survival of liana versus tree seedlings during severe droughts or differences in liana versus tree fecundity or germination across the rainfall gradient likely explain why liana seedlings have higher relative densities at drier sites.