AVAndrew P. Valentine

Andrew P. Valentine

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Andrew P. Valentine has a total of 75 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    CoFI - A Common Framework for Inference

    by Jiawen He, Kit Chaivannacoopt, Juerg Hauser, Michael Conrad Koch, Fabrizio Magrini, Augustin Marignier, Malcolm Sambridge, Andrew Valentine

    Geophysical inversion often involves choices and assumptions. Which combination of forward model, noise model, regularisation, and solution algorithm is best suited to a given dataset is rarely obvious in advance. Practitioners typically design inversion schemes, and software, around a single class of method based on their choices. In these circumstances, moving from a parameter estimation approach to an ensemble or Bayesian one requires substantial recoding effort. This discourages cross-fertilization of methods between sub-fields that share a common mathematical structure.With these issues in mind we present CoFI, the Common Framework for Inference, an open source Python package that separates inverse problem definition from algorithm selection. CoFI provides three objects (classes): BaseProblem, which captures the forward model, data, noise model, and any regularization or prior; InversionOptions, which specifies the algorithm; and Inversion, which executes the inversion. Because problem and algorithm are held separately, switching between solvers requires only a change to InversionOptions, with BaseProblem unchanged. CoFI connects user-written forward models to existing solver tools and software, including SciPy, emcee and BayesBay, without re-implementing inference methods.We illustrate CoFI through three worked examples. For the educator, a polynomial regression and sea-level change-point problem introduces three solution styles, from direct matrix solvers through trans-dimensional Bayesian sampling, within a single teaching sequence. For those who carry out inversion studies, an ambient-noise surface-wave tomography of Australia demonstrates progression from regularised linear inversion through nonlinear iterative methods to Bayesian uncertainty quantification. For those who develop inference methods, a Himmelblau function example shows how to register a new inference algorithm and integrate it into the standard CoFI interface.CoFI is accompanied by a growing library of worked examples and tutorials. We invite contributions from researchers, developers, and teachers, and hope that the framework will become a shared resource for the geoscientific community.

  • Open Access

    Seismic Super-resolution Leveraging Machine Learning Techniques

    by Mukthar Opeyemi Mahmud, Andrew P. Valentine, Anne K. Reinarz, Jeroen van Hunen

    Earth imaging is central to our ability to understand our planet and is important for exploration of critical minerals, geothermal energy resources detection, and mitigation of natural hazards such as earthquakes and the study of plate tectonics. As a result, there is a need for more precise images of the earth’s interior. However, as this imaging process is ill-posed and lossy, the images obtained are inevitably a blurry version of the truth. This makes it challenging to robustly interpret results and draw inferences about geophysical systems. The full waveform inversion (FWI) has been the state-of -the-art for high-fidelity and physically consistent subsurface imaging, however, its computational expense has driven exploration into machine learning (ML) techniques. These data-driven ML techniques can perform seismic inversion, directly mapping seismic data to subsurface properties without executing the iterative physics modelling loop of FWI. While their success is highly dependent on the availability of comprehensive, high-quality training data, they have proven capable of delivering subsurface predictions orders of magnitude faster than traditional methods. In our attempt to obtain physically consistent subsurface images while ensuring cheap inferences, we will explore opportunities for ‘seismic super-resolution’: generation of higher-resolution images by combining observed data with prior knowledge about likely structures and the physics of wave propagation. Our approach involves the combination of machine learning techniques for numerical upscaling and physics – informed neural networks ensuring that the underlying laws of physics are embedded within results. In this presentation, we will highlight some of the challenges and opportunities in this approach and present some early results from numerical experiments.

  • Open Access

    Toward integrated geodynamic-petrological modelling: coupling ASPECT with thermodynamic calculations

    by Arijit Chakraborty, Jeroen van Hunen, Andrew Valentine, Sergio Zlotnik, Alberto García González

    The concentration of critical minerals and metals occurs within 200 km of the transition between thick and thin lithosphere(Hoggard et al., 2020). Understanding the mechanisms behind this distribution requires characterizing a variety of deep Earth processes of different scales and nature. Among these processes, mantle melting is a critical initial step, controlling compositions of early melts and to the stability of cratonic lithosphere. These melting processes are governed by complex phase equilibria which determines proportions and compositions of mineral assemblages, depending on pressure, temperature and bulk composition. We investigate computational strategies for coupling mantle convection codes such as ASPECT with thermodynamic equilibrium calculations tools like MAGEMin. While a direct coupling would provide accurate phase equilibria predictions, it comes at a significant computational cost for large-scale geodynamic models. Our research explores developing surrogate models using machine learning and neural network techniques to approximate these thermodynamic calculations more efficiently. We present our preliminary research involving methodological approaches and discuss the computational trade-offs involved in different coupling strategies. A simplified geodynamic model demonstrates potential workflows for this approach. This research is a step towards a more integrated computational framework for a thermo-chemical geodynamic model, which will have important implications for modelling critical mineral formation in complex geodynamic settings. References:Hoggard, Mark J., Karol Czarnota, Fred D. Richards, David L. Huston, A. Lynton Jaques, and Sia Ghelichkhan. “Global Distribution of Sediment-Hosted Metals Controlled by Craton Edge Stability.” Nature Geoscience 13, no. 7 (July 2020):504–10.https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-020-0593-2

  • Open Access

    Trans-Conceptual Inversion: Bayesian Inference with Competing Assumptions

    by Malcolm Sambridge, Andrew Valentine, Juerg Hauser

    Over the past several decades Trans-dimensional Bayesian sampling has been widely applied in the geosciences. Most implementations have used the Reversible-jump Markov chain Monte Carlo (Rj-McMC) algorithm. This approach allows sampling across variably dimensioned model parameterizations and hierarchical noise models. Due to practical limitations Reversible-Jump is restricted to cases where the number of free parameters changes in a regular sequence, usually by addition or subtraction of a single variable. Furthermore, jumps between model dimensions rely on bespoke mathematical transformations that are only valid within a particular parametrization class. As a result, the range of model classes that can be practically considered is limited, and McMC balance conditions must be rederived for each class of problem. A framework for Trans-conceptual Bayesian sampling, which is a generalization of trans-dimensional sampling, is presented. Trans-C Bayesian inversion allows exploration across a finite, but arbitrary, set of conceptual models, i.e. ones where the number of variables, the type of model basis function, nature of the forward problem, and even assumptions on the class of measurement noise statistics, may all vary independently.A key feature of the new framework is that it avoids parameter transformations and thereby lends itself to development of automatic McMC algorithms, i.e. where the details of the sampler do not require knowledge of the parameterization details. Algorithms implementing Bayesian conceptual model sampling are illustrated with examples drawn from geophysics, using real and synthetic data. Comparison with reversible-jump illustrates that trans-C sampling produces statistically identical results for situations where the former is applicable, but also allows sampling in situations where trans-D would be impractical, including asking the data to choose between competing forward models.

  • Open Access

    CoFI - The Common Framework for Inference: A software platform for experimentation, education and application of geophysical inversion tools

    by Malcolm Sambridge, Jiawen He, Kit Chaivannacoopt, Juerg Hauser, Michael Koch, Fabrizio Magrini, Augustin Marignier, Andrew Valentine

    Inference problems within the geosciences vary considerably in terms of size and scope, ranging from the detection of changepoints in 1D time/depth models, to the construction of complex 3D or 4D models of the Earth. Solving an inverse problem typically requires fusing various classes of data, each associated with its own forward model. The choice of an appropriate inference method is itself not obvious. An investment of much time effort and is required in software development and education. Many researchers have developed bespoke inversion and parameter estimation algorithms tailored to their specific needs. Associated software is then typically bespoke to the particular application, often requiring significant investment by new researchers to master with minimal documentation. This is entirely understandable as generalisation and ongoing support of inference codes requires significant time and effort that is frequently beyond the primary objectives of the research. As a result the all important experimentation often required to choose an appropriate inversion method for a new data set or domain, is often not practical. Furthermore design choices made in existing software implementations often dictate those by subsequent researchers and influence the scientific direction taken. The Common Framework for Inference, CoFI, is an open source project which aims to capture inherent commonalities present in all types of inverse problems, independent of the specific methods employed to solve them. CoFl is codifies the definition of an inference problem and then provides an interface to reliable and sophisticated third-party packages, such as SciPy and PyTorch, to tackle inverse problems across a broad range. The modular and object-oriented design of CoFI, supplemented by a comprehensive suite of tutorials and practical examples, ensures its accessibility to users of all skill levels, from experts to novices. This not only has the potential to streamline research and promote best practice but also to support education and STEM training. This poster gives an overview of CoFl through domain relevant examples, from optimisation to probabilistic sampling. With a focus on CoFI’s modular approach we hope to foster collaboration centred around interaction by expanding the set of inference algorithms and domain-relevant examples.

  • Open Access

    Trans‐Conceptual Sampling: Bayesian Inference With Competing Assumptions

    by Malcolm Sambridge, Andrew P. Valentine, Juerg Hauser

    Trans‐dimensional Bayesian sampling has been applied to subsurface imaging and other inference problems across the Earth Sciences. A particular style of Markov chain Monte Carlo (McMC) method, known as reversible‐jump has been used almost universally in such studies. This algorithm allows sampling across variably dimensioned model parameterizations. However, for practical reasons, it is limited to cases where the number of free parameters differ in a regular sequence between alternate models, usually by addition or subtraction of a single variable. Furthermore, jumps between model dimensions rely on bespoke mathematical transformations, which are bespoke to each class of application. As a result, implementations are dependent on the choice of model parameterization employed. A framework for Trans‐conceptual Bayesian sampling, which is a generalization of trans‐dimensional sampling, is presented. Trans‐C Bayesian sampling allows exploration across a finite, but arbitrary, set of conceptual models, that is ones where the number of variables, the type of model basis function, nature of the forward problem, and assumptions on the measurement noise statistics, may all vary independently. The new framework avoids parameter transformations and thereby lends itself to development of automatic McMC algorithms, that is where the details of the sampler do not require knowledge of the parameterization. Algorithms implementing Bayesian conceptual model sampling are presented and illustrated with examples drawn from geophysics, using real and synthetic data. Comparison with reversible‐jump illustrates that trans‐C sampling produces statistically identical results for situations where the former is applicable, but also allows sampling in situations where trans‐D would be impractical to implement.


  • Open Access

    Investigating Craton Dynamics and Ore Deposit Formation 

    by Arijit Chakraborty, Jeroen van Hunen, Andrew Valentine, Poulami Roy

    The concentration of critical minerals and metals occurs within 200 km of the transition between thick and thin lithosphere or cratonic edges1. These cratons are regions comprising thicker lithosphere, which has remained stable for billions of years. The critical minerals are initially sourced from the mantle by a range of deep Earth geophysical, geochemical, and tectonic processes, to be further concentrated near the Earth’s surface via hydrothermal processes. These deep Earth processes involving mantle melting also play a crucial role in cratonic stability, and therefore, the improved understanding of these will help unravel intricate connections between craton dynamics and ore deposit formations. The formation and evolution of cratons play a crucial role in the development of those critical minerals. Cratons formed under different scenarios have different internal structures, which, in turn, influence subsequent tectonics and melting scenarios. One of the challenges is how to deal with the vastly different time and length scales in these processes (e.g. between mantle dynamics and melt processes). Preliminary results regarding the best way to capture the processes of craton formation and stability under different geologic scenarios using numerical models developed with the ASPECT geodynamical software tool (REF) will be presented. References: Hoggard, Mark J., Karol Czarnota, Fred D. Richards, David L. Huston, A. Lynton Jaques, and Sia Ghelichkhan. “Global Distribution of Sediment-Hosted Metals Controlled by Craton Edge Stability.” Nature Geoscience 13, no. 7 (July 2020):504–10.https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-020-0593-2

  • Open Access

    CoFI - Linking geoscience inference problems with tools for their solution

    by Jiawen He, Juerg Hauser, Malcolm Sambridge, Fabrizio Magrini, Andrew Valentine, Augustin Marignier

    Inference problems within the geosciences vary significantly in size and scope, ranging from the detection of data trends through simple linear regressions, to the construction of complex 3D models representing the Earth’s interior structure. Successfully solving an inverse problem typically requires combining various types of data sets, each associated with its own forward solver. In the absence of established software, many researchers and practitioners resort to developing bespoke inversion and parameter estimation algorithms tailored to their specific needs. However, this practice does not promote reproducibility and necessitates a substantial amount of work that is frequently beyond the primary objectives of the research.Our aim with CoFI (pronounced: coffee), the Common Framework for Inference, is to capture inherent commonalities present in all types of inverse problems, independent of the specific methods employed to solve them. CoFI is an open-source Python package that provides a link to reliable and sophisticated third-party packages, such as SciPy and PyTorch, to tackle inverse problems of a broad range. The modular and object-oriented design of CoFI, supplemented by our comprehensive suite of tutorials and practical examples, ensures its accessibility to users of all skill levels, from experts to novices. This not only has the potential to streamline research but also to support education and STEM training.This poster presentation aims to give an overview of CoFI’s main features and usage through practical examples. Moreover, we hope to foster collaboration and invite contributions on inference algorithms and domain-relevant examples.

  • Open Access

    Dynamics of Plateau Growth: Geodynamic Modeling of the East AnatolianPlateau Uplift Through Double Subduction Processes

    by Uğurcan Çetiner, Jeroen van Hunen, Andrew P. Valentine, Oğuz H. Göğüş, Mark B. Allen

    The Turkish–Iranian Plateau was formed by the collision between the Arabian andEurasian plates, commencing along the Bitlis-Zagros suture in the Late Eocene (~30-35 Ma). This region, commonly partitioned into the East Anatolian Plateau and theIranian Plateau, is associated with significant differences in terms of lithosphericstructure despite an overall average of ~2 km. The geodynamic evolution of EastAnatolia is represented by a double subduction system, where the two branches ofNeo-Tethys were subducting beneath Eurasia, constantly accumulating accretionarymaterial that forms the bulk of the plateau today (i.e., East Anatolian AccretionaryComplex). Seismic evidence demonstrates that the region has unusually thin MOHO(~35 km around Lake Van region) while the whole area is formed mostly by oceanic(accretionary) material and is underlain by no or very thin mantle lithosphere. Theuplift of East Anatolia is attributed to slab break-off and slab peelback (delamination),combined with crustal shortening. However, the intricate plate dynamics arising fromsuch a double subduction system, controlling plateau formation remains unclear.Here, we conducted 2D numerical experiments and comparative model sets indicatethat, in a double subduction system like Eastern Anatolia, the mechanisms of slabbreak-off and peelback heavily depend on the rheology of the subducting plates andthe coupling between the overlying and subducting plate along the trenches. In casesof strong coupling between subducting and overlying plates, we observed anamalgamation of the two subducting plates as they converge, potentially resulting ina break-off as a single blob, depending on plate rheology. Conversely, in models withweaker coupling along the trenches, peelback along the northern slab creates a thinlithosphere along the accretionary prism, such as in the evolution of the EasternAnatolian Plateau. Our results highlight the important interaction between thesubduction systems where rheological constraints of the lithosphere, among othermodel parameters, exert a first-order control for plateau formation.

  • Open Access

    An Independent State sampler for Trans-dimensional Bayesian Inference

    by Malcolm Sambridge, Andrew Valentine, Juerg Hauser

    Over the past twenty years, Trans-dimensional Bayesian Inference has become a popular approach for Bayesian sampling. It has been applied widely in the geosciences when the best class of model representation, e.g. of the subsurface, is not obvious in advance, or the number of free variables undecided. Making arbitrary choices in these areas may result in sub-optimal inferences from data. In trans-D, one typically defines a finite number of model states, with differing numbers of unknowns, over which Bayesian Inference is to be performed using the data.A key attraction of Trans-D Bayesian Inference is that it is designed to let the data decide which state, as well as which configurations of parameters within each state, are preferred by the data, in a probabilistic manner. Trans-D algorithms may hence be viewed as a combination of fixed dimensional within-state sampling and simultaneous between-state sampling where Markov chains visit each state in proportion to their support from the data.In theory, each state may be completely independent, involving different classes of model parameterization, with different numbers of unknowns, data noise levels, and even different assumptions about the data-model relationship. Practical considerations, such as convergence of the finite length Markov chains between states, usually mean that each state must be closely related to each other, e.g. differing by a single layer in a 1-D seismic Earth model. In addition, since the form of the necessary Metropolis-Hastings balance condition depends on the mathematical relationship between the unknowns in each state, then implementations are often bespoke to each class of model parameterization and data type. To our knowledge there exists no automatic trans-D sampler where one can define arbitrary independent states, together with a prior and Likelihood, and simply pass to a generalised sampling algorithm, as is common with many fixed dimensional MCMC algorithms and software packages. A second limitation in trans-D sampling is that since implementations are bespoke within a class of model parameterizations, within-state sampling is typically performed with simplistic and often dated algorithms, e.g. Metropolis-Hastings or Gibbs samplers, thereby limiting convergence rates. Over the past 30 years fixed dimensional sampling has advanced considerably with numerous efficient algorithms available and many conveniently translated into user friendly software packages, almost all of which have not been used within a trans-D framework due to a lack of a way to conveniently deploy them in a trans-D setting.In this presentation we will address all of these issues by describing the theory under-pinning an ‘Independent State’ (IS) Trans-D sampler, together with some illustrative examples. In this algorithm class, sampling may be performed across states that are completely independent, containing arbitrary numbers of unknowns and parameter classes. In addition, the IS-sampler can conveniently take advantage of any fixed dimensional sampler without the need to derive and re-code bespoke Markov chain balance conditions, or specify mechanisms for transitions between model parameters within different states. In this sense it represents a general purpose automatic trans-D sampler.