Dorothea Salo
Research Subjects
Dorothea Salo has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kyle M. L. Jones
Indiana University-Indianapolis
5 shared publications - Abigail Goben
University of Illinois at Chicago
4 shared publications - Kristin Briney
California Institute of Technology
4 shared publications - Andrew D. Asher
Indiana Univ, Bloomington, IN USA
3 shared publications - Michael R. Perry
Northwestern Univ Lib Evanston, Evanston, IL USA
3 shared publications - Mariana Regalado
CUNY, Brooklyn Coll, New York, NY USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Iowa State University in Journal of Librarianship and Scholarly Communication
- Vol. 12 (1)
Data Ethics in Library Learning Analytics
Introduction: This study examines data handling and data ethics in library learning analytics research projects involving the use of data about students as library patrons, alongside a baseline evaluation of the benefits of library learning analytics to libraries practicing it. Methods: Citations were gathered via citation chain aggregation from the original Value of Academic Libraries report, then winnowed to projects with English-language artifacts documenting them, collection and/or analysis of library data about students, and a research question about the contribution of student library use to student success. Results and Discussion: Much of this research is reaching publication despite not employing best practices nor documenting respect for human-subjects research ethics, library-specific privacy and confidentiality ethics, and student data-privacy expectations. Very few projects create direct benefits to libraries. This result would not be possible without gaps or lapses in editorial processes, peer review, and upstream research guidance and ethics reviews. Conclusion: Ethics reforms are required at all stages of research and publication to prevent further unethical exploitation of patron data.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Iowa State University in Journal of Librarianship and Scholarly Communication
- Vol. 12 (1)
Open AccessData Ethics in Library Learning Analytics
Introduction: This study examines data handling and data ethics in library learning analytics research projects involving the use of data about students as library patrons, alongside a baseline evaluation of the benefits of library learning analytics to libraries practicing it. Methods: Citations were gathered via citation chain aggregation from the original Value of Academic Libraries report, then winnowed to projects with English-language artifacts documenting them, collection and/or analysis of library data about students, and a research question about the contribution of student library use to student success. Results and Discussion: Much of this research is reaching publication despite not employing best practices nor documenting respect for human-subjects research ethics, library-specific privacy and confidentiality ethics, and student data-privacy expectations. Very few projects create direct benefits to libraries. This result would not be possible without gaps or lapses in editorial processes, peer review, and upstream research guidance and ethics reviews. Conclusion: Ethics reforms are required at all stages of research and publication to prevent further unethical exploitation of patron data.
- 1 July 2023
- Published by Project MUSE in portal: Libraries and the Academy
- Vol. 23 (3) , 485-515
Transparency and Consent: Student Perspectives on Educational Data Analytics Scenarios
Higher education data mining and analytics, like learning analytics, may improve learning experiences and outcomes. However, such practices are rife with student privacy concerns and other ethics issues. It is crucial that student privacy expectations and preferences are considered in the design of educational data analytics. This study forefronts the student perspective by researching three unique futurized scenarios rooted in real-life systems and practices. Findings highlight student acceptance of data mining and analytics with particular limitations, namely transparency about analytics and consent mechanisms. Without such limitations, institutions risk losing their students’ trust.
- 1 July 2023
- Published by Project MUSE in portal: Libraries and the Academy
- Vol. 23 (3) , 485-515
Transparency and Consent: Student Perspectives on Educational Data Analytics Scenarios
Higher education data mining and analytics, like learning analytics, may improve learning experiences and outcomes. However, such practices are rife with student privacy concerns and other ethics issues. It is crucial that student privacy expectations and preferences are considered in the design of educational data analytics. This study forefronts the student perspective by researching three unique futurized scenarios rooted in real-life systems and practices. Findings highlight student acceptance of data mining and analytics with particular limitations, namely transparency about analytics and consent mechanisms. Without such limitations, institutions risk losing their students’ trust.
- 1 April 2022
- Published by University of Chicago Press in The Library Quarterly
- Vol. 92 (2) , 151-171
Questions of Trust: A Survey of Student Expectations and Perspectives on Library Learning Analytics
Universities are developing learning analytics initiatives that include academic library participation. Libraries rarely inform their students about learning analytics projects or general l...
- 1 April 2022
- Published by University of Chicago Press in The Library Quarterly
- Vol. 92 (2) , 151-171
Questions of Trust: A Survey of Student Expectations and Perspectives on Library Learning Analytics
Universities are developing learning analytics initiatives that include academic library participation. Libraries rarely inform their students about learning analytics projects or general l...
- 22 February 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Serials Librarian
- Vol. 81 (1) , 20-34
Physical-Equivalent Privacy
This article introduces and applies the concept of “physical-equivalent privacy” to evaluate the appropriateness of data collection about library patrons’ use of library-provided e-resources. It posits that as a matter of service equity, any data collection practice that causes e-resource users to enjoy less information privacy than users of an information-equivalent print resource is to be avoided. Analysis is grounded in real-world e-resource-related phenomena: secure (HTTPS) library websites and catalogs, the Adobe Digital Editions data-leak incident of 2014, and use of web trackers on e-resource websites. Implications of physical-equivalent privacy for the SeamlessAccess single-sign-on proposal will be discussed.
- 22 February 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Serials Librarian
- Vol. 81 (1) , 20-34
Physical-Equivalent Privacy
This article introduces and applies the concept of “physical-equivalent privacy” to evaluate the appropriateness of data collection about library patrons’ use of library-provided e-resources. It posits that as a matter of service equity, any data collection practice that causes e-resource users to enjoy less information privacy than users of an information-equivalent print resource is to be avoided. Analysis is grounded in real-world e-resource-related phenomena: secure (HTTPS) library websites and catalogs, the Adobe Digital Editions data-leak incident of 2014, and use of web trackers on e-resource websites. Implications of physical-equivalent privacy for the SeamlessAccess single-sign-on proposal will be discussed.
- Top Cited Papers
- 6 April 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology
- Vol. 71 (9) , 1044-1059
“We're being tracked at all times”: Student perspectives of their privacy in relation to learning analytics in higher education
Higher education institutions are continuing to develop their capacity for learning analytics (LA), which is a sociotechnical data‐mining and analytic practice. Institutions rarely inform their students about LA practices, and there exist significant privacy concerns. Without a clear student voice in the design of LA, institutions put themselves in an ethical gray area. To help fill this gap in practice and add to the growing literature on students' privacy perspectives, this study reports findings from over 100 interviews with undergraduate students at eight U.S. higher education institutions. Findings demonstrate that students lacked awareness of educational data‐mining and analytic practices, as well as the data on which they rely. Students see potential in LA, but they presented nuanced arguments about when and with whom data should be shared; they also expressed why informed consent was valuable and necessary. The study uncovered perspectives on institutional trust that were heretofore unknown, as well as what actions might violate that trust. Institutions must balance their desire to implement LA with their obligation to educate students about their analytic practices and treat them as partners in the design of analytic strategies reliant on student data in order to protect their intellectual privacy.
- 6 April 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology
- Vol. 71 (9) , 1044-1059
Top Cited Papers“We're being tracked at all times”: Student perspectives of their privacy in relation to learning analytics in higher education
Higher education institutions are continuing to develop their capacity for learning analytics (LA), which is a sociotechnical data‐mining and analytic practice. Institutions rarely inform their students about LA practices, and there exist significant privacy concerns. Without a clear student voice in the design of LA, institutions put themselves in an ethical gray area. To help fill this gap in practice and add to the growing literature on students' privacy perspectives, this study reports findings from over 100 interviews with undergraduate students at eight U.S. higher education institutions. Findings demonstrate that students lacked awareness of educational data‐mining and analytic practices, as well as the data on which they rely. Students see potential in LA, but they presented nuanced arguments about when and with whom data should be shared; they also expressed why informed consent was valuable and necessary. The study uncovered perspectives on institutional trust that were heretofore unknown, as well as what actions might violate that trust. Institutions must balance their desire to implement LA with their obligation to educate students about their analytic practices and treat them as partners in the design of analytic strategies reliant on student data in order to protect their intellectual privacy.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- Published by American Library Association in College and Research Libraries
- Vol. 81 (3) , 570
A Comprehensive Primer to Library Learning Analytics Practices, Initiatives, and Privacy Issues
Universities are pursuing learning analytics practices to improve returns from their investments, develop behavioral and academic interventions to improve student success, and address political and financial pressures. Academic libraries are additionally undertaking learning analytics to demonstrate value to stakeholders, assess learning gains from instruction, and analyze student-library usage, et cetera. The adoption of these techniques leads to many professional ethics issues and practical concerns related to privacy. In this narrative literature review, we provide a foundational background in the field of learning analytics, library adoption of these practices, and identify ethical and practical privacy issues.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by American Library Association in College and Research Libraries
- Vol. 81 (3) , 570
Open AccessA Comprehensive Primer to Library Learning Analytics Practices, Initiatives, and Privacy Issues
Universities are pursuing learning analytics practices to improve returns from their investments, develop behavioral and academic interventions to improve student success, and address political and financial pressures. Academic libraries are additionally undertaking learning analytics to demonstrate value to stakeholders, assess learning gains from instruction, and analyze student-library usage, et cetera. The adoption of these techniques leads to many professional ethics issues and practical concerns related to privacy. In this narrative literature review, we provide a foundational background in the field of learning analytics, library adoption of these practices, and identify ethical and practical privacy issues.
- Open Access
- 8 April 2019
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Online Information Review
- Vol. 43 (2) , 182-196
A nine dimensional framework for digital cultural heritage organizational sustainability
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to report on how library and information science (LIS) as a field operationalizes the concept of organizational sustainability for managing digital resources, projects and infrastructures such as digital libraries and repositories over time. It introduces a nine dimensional framework for organizational sustainability in the digital cultural heritage community. Design/methodology/approach: Content analysis of publications from three LIS databases (2000–2015). Findings: Comparing the articles to the nine dimension framework shows that most LIS articles discuss technology, financial or management dimensions. Fewer articles describe disaster planning, assessment or policy dimensions. Research limitations/implications: Three LIS databases might not include all relevant journals, conferences, white papers and other materials. The data set also did not include books; library management textbooks might include useful material on organizational sustainability. Claims about the prevalence of themes are subject to methodological limits of content analysis. Practical implications: Organizations that steward digital collections need to be clear about what they mean when they are referring to organizational sustainability so that they can make appropriate decisions for future-proofing their collections. The analysis would also suggest for a greater need to consider the full range of dimensions of organizational sustainability. Originality/value: By introducing a new nine dimensional framework of organizational sustainability the authors hope to promote more and better conversations within the LIS community about organizational sustainability. The authors hope these conversations will lead to productive action and improvements in the arrangements of people and work necessary to keep digital projects and services going over time, given ongoing challenges.
- 8 April 2019
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Online Information Review
- Vol. 43 (2) , 182-196
Open AccessA nine dimensional framework for digital cultural heritage organizational sustainability
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to report on how library and information science (LIS) as a field operationalizes the concept of organizational sustainability for managing digital resources, projects and infrastructures such as digital libraries and repositories over time. It introduces a nine dimensional framework for organizational sustainability in the digital cultural heritage community. Design/methodology/approach: Content analysis of publications from three LIS databases (2000–2015). Findings: Comparing the articles to the nine dimension framework shows that most LIS articles discuss technology, financial or management dimensions. Fewer articles describe disaster planning, assessment or policy dimensions. Research limitations/implications: Three LIS databases might not include all relevant journals, conferences, white papers and other materials. The data set also did not include books; library management textbooks might include useful material on organizational sustainability. Claims about the prevalence of themes are subject to methodological limits of content analysis. Practical implications: Organizations that steward digital collections need to be clear about what they mean when they are referring to organizational sustainability so that they can make appropriate decisions for future-proofing their collections. The analysis would also suggest for a greater need to consider the full range of dimensions of organizational sustainability. Originality/value: By introducing a new nine dimensional framework of organizational sustainability the authors hope to promote more and better conversations within the LIS community about organizational sustainability. The authors hope these conversations will lead to productive action and improvements in the arrangements of people and work necessary to keep digital projects and services going over time, given ongoing challenges.
- Open Access
- 29 November 2018
- Published by University of Victoria Libraries in KULA: Knowledge Creation, Dissemination, and Preservation Studies
- Vol. 2 (1) , 14
Digital Reformatting and Data Rescue with RADD and the PROUD and PRAVDA Kits
Despite the short remaining time to rescue unique cultural and personal materials stored on many twentieth-and early twenty-first-century audiovisual and digital storage media, realistic rescue options are starkly limited. Building a rescue apparatus in house, especially to archival standards, requires significant expertise and expense and is often of limited continuing use. Outsourcing digital capture of these materials overwhelms the resources of even well-funded academic libraries and archives, never mind public libraries, small archives, and local historical societies. To address this problem realistically, the University of Wisconsin-Madison Information School has built and documented an in-house rescue installation called RADD (Recover Analog and Digital Data) as well as two self-contained, portable, and shippable rescue kits: PROUD (Portable Recovery of Unique Data) for digital materials and PRAVDA (Portably Reformat Audio and Video to Digital from Analog) for audio and video. All three units are actively rescuing cultural heritage materials, as well as serving training and outreach functions.
- 29 November 2018
- Published by University of Victoria Libraries in KULA: Knowledge Creation, Dissemination, and Preservation Studies
- Vol. 2 (1) , 14
Open AccessDigital Reformatting and Data Rescue with RADD and the PROUD and PRAVDA Kits
Despite the short remaining time to rescue unique cultural and personal materials stored on many twentieth-and early twenty-first-century audiovisual and digital storage media, realistic rescue options are starkly limited. Building a rescue apparatus in house, especially to archival standards, requires significant expertise and expense and is often of limited continuing use. Outsourcing digital capture of these materials overwhelms the resources of even well-funded academic libraries and archives, never mind public libraries, small archives, and local historical societies. To address this problem realistically, the University of Wisconsin-Madison Information School has built and documented an in-house rescue installation called RADD (Recover Analog and Digital Data) as well as two self-contained, portable, and shippable rescue kits: PROUD (Portable Recovery of Unique Data) for digital materials and PRAVDA (Portably Reformat Audio and Video to Digital from Analog) for audio and video. All three units are actively rescuing cultural heritage materials, as well as serving training and outreach functions.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2018
- Published by American Library Association in College and Research Libraries
- Vol. 79 (3) , 304-323
Learning Analytics and the Academic Library: Professional Ethics Commitments at a Crossroads
In this paper, the authors address learning analytics and the ways academic libraries are beginning to participate in wider institutional learning analytics initiatives. Since there are moral issues associated with learning analytics, the authors consider how data mining practices run counter to ethical principles in the American Library Association’s “Code of Ethics.” Specifically, the authors address how learning analytics implicates professional commitments to promote intellectual freedom; protect patron privacy and confidentiality; and balance intellectual property interests between library users, their institution, and content creators and vendors. The authors recommend that librarians should embed their ethical positions in technological designs, practices, and governance mechanisms.
- 1 April 2018
- Published by American Library Association in College and Research Libraries
- Vol. 79 (3) , 304-323
Open AccessLearning Analytics and the Academic Library: Professional Ethics Commitments at a Crossroads
In this paper, the authors address learning analytics and the ways academic libraries are beginning to participate in wider institutional learning analytics initiatives. Since there are moral issues associated with learning analytics, the authors consider how data mining practices run counter to ethical principles in the American Library Association’s “Code of Ethics.” Specifically, the authors address how learning analytics implicates professional commitments to promote intellectual freedom; protect patron privacy and confidentiality; and balance intellectual property interests between library users, their institution, and content creators and vendors. The authors recommend that librarians should embed their ethical positions in technological designs, practices, and governance mechanisms.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Wiley in Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
- Vol. 51 (1) , 1-4
Curation and policy issues in collaborative research data management communities: Perspectives from key stakeholders
The explosion of scientific data in recent years has resulted in the need to compile, store and globally share this research information with the multi‐disciplinary communities of science. This has resulted in research data management communities that are responsible for curating data within institutional repositories. This panel is sponsored by the SIG Scientific and Technical Information to initiate a discussion addressing data curation issues as they pertain to collaborative research data management communities within the current institutional research environment from the perspective of key stakeholders. The panel objective encompasses an examination of contemporary curation practices and data management policy issues that impact the initiation and implementation of research data management plans for scientific researchers. In addition it will explore the role that institutional repositories play in the extraction, preservation, and storage of research data while providing access to data sharing in the global scientific research communities. The panel will be comprised of key institutional stakeholders, which include university administrators, information professionals, and research scientists.
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Wiley in Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
- Vol. 51 (1) , 1-4
Open AccessCuration and policy issues in collaborative research data management communities: Perspectives from key stakeholders
The explosion of scientific data in recent years has resulted in the need to compile, store and globally share this research information with the multi‐disciplinary communities of science. This has resulted in research data management communities that are responsible for curating data within institutional repositories. This panel is sponsored by the SIG Scientific and Technical Information to initiate a discussion addressing data curation issues as they pertain to collaborative research data management communities within the current institutional research environment from the perspective of key stakeholders. The panel objective encompasses an examination of contemporary curation practices and data management policy issues that impact the initiation and implementation of research data management plans for scientific researchers. In addition it will explore the role that institutional repositories play in the extraction, preservation, and storage of research data while providing access to data sharing in the global scientific research communities. The panel will be comprised of key institutional stakeholders, which include university administrators, information professionals, and research scientists.