Niels Linnemann
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Niels Linnemann has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- James Read
Faculty of Philosophy, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
15 shared publications - Emily Adlam
Philosophy Department and Institute for Quantum Studies, Chapman University, Orange, USA
9 shared publications - Salim Hirèche
Université de Genève, Geneva, Switzerland
3 shared publications - Chris Smeenk
Department of Philosophy and Rotman Institute of Philosophy, University of Western Ontario, London, ON N6A 5BY, Canada
2 shared publications - Christian Wüthrich
University of Geneva
2 shared publications - Juliusz Doboszewski
Jagiellonian University
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 19 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal for General Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 57 (4) , 759-777
The Momentum of the Medium: General Covariance alla Donatello
- 19 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal for General Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 57 (4) , 759-777
The Momentum of the Medium: General Covariance alla Donatello
- Open Access
- 18 May 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Vol. 43 (17) , 177001
A demonstration that classical gravity does not produce entanglement
Once again, dispute has arisen over the interpretation of proposed quantum information theory experiments to probe the quantum nature of gravity by testing for gravitationally induced entanglement (GIE) between two spatially separated massive particles ([2] vs. [16, 17]; further contributions in [11, 13]). The confusion appears to reside in interpreting applications of a Hamiltonian formalism. But classical gravity cannot mediate entanglement on independent grounds. A Newton-Cartan analysis shows that if gravity is classical, a mediator, and entanglement is observed as an outcome of performing a GIE experiment, something other than gravity must have supplied the (virtual) force needed during the experiment to produce the effect.
- 18 May 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Vol. 43 (17) , 177001
Open AccessA demonstration that classical gravity does not produce entanglement
Once again, dispute has arisen over the interpretation of proposed quantum information theory experiments to probe the quantum nature of gravity by testing for gravitationally induced entanglement (GIE) between two spatially separated massive particles ([2] vs. [16, 17]; further contributions in [11, 13]). The confusion appears to reside in interpreting applications of a Hamiltonian formalism. But classical gravity cannot mediate entanglement on independent grounds. A Newton-Cartan analysis shows that if gravity is classical, a mediator, and entanglement is observed as an outcome of performing a GIE experiment, something other than gravity must have supplied the (virtual) force needed during the experiment to produce the effect.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal for Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 16 (1) , 20
Can the non-identity theory answer the original criticisms of causal theories of spacetime?
Recently, Baron and Le Bihan (2023) have suggested revisiting the causal theory of spacetime, noting that advancements in physics, particularly causal set theory, and metaphysics offer new counters to the criticisms of Smart (1969) and Earman (1972)—criticisms that, they say, defeated the original causal theory of spacetime. Baron and Le Bihan propose that, while the traditional identity causal theory, which seeks to equate spacetime relations with causal relations, is still inadequate, a revised approach could succeed if identity is replaced by grounding and if the grounding base is that of causal set theory. This non-identity causal theory of spacetime posits, in other words, that spatiotemporal relations are grounded in the fundamental causal relations associated with causal sets—in alleged line with the original aim of understanding spacetime through causality. In this paper, we argue that the new arguments put forward by Baron and Le Bihan do little to meet the challenges of Smart and Earman with the result that their non-identity theory does not fare better in addressing these original criticisms than the identity theory. To this end, we will demonstrate that their new arguments make assumptions that (1) are not shared in these historical criticisms of causal theories of spacetime, and, at the same time, (2) are either indecisive or false. Furthermore, we argue that, even with these assumptions, the identity theory can still do just as well as the non-identity theory.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal for Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 16 (1) , 20
Open AccessCan the non-identity theory answer the original criticisms of causal theories of spacetime?
Recently, Baron and Le Bihan (2023) have suggested revisiting the causal theory of spacetime, noting that advancements in physics, particularly causal set theory, and metaphysics offer new counters to the criticisms of Smart (1969) and Earman (1972)—criticisms that, they say, defeated the original causal theory of spacetime. Baron and Le Bihan propose that, while the traditional identity causal theory, which seeks to equate spacetime relations with causal relations, is still inadequate, a revised approach could succeed if identity is replaced by grounding and if the grounding base is that of causal set theory. This non-identity causal theory of spacetime posits, in other words, that spatiotemporal relations are grounded in the fundamental causal relations associated with causal sets—in alleged line with the original aim of understanding spacetime through causality. In this paper, we argue that the new arguments put forward by Baron and Le Bihan do little to meet the challenges of Smart and Earman with the result that their non-identity theory does not fare better in addressing these original criticisms than the identity theory. To this end, we will demonstrate that their new arguments make assumptions that (1) are not shared in these historical criticisms of causal theories of spacetime, and, at the same time, (2) are either indecisive or false. Furthermore, we argue that, even with these assumptions, the identity theory can still do just as well as the non-identity theory.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 56-104
Constructive Axiomatics in Context
We provide a comprehensive appraisal of the potential—but also the limitations—of the constructive axiomatic methodology as exhibited by EPS. For this, we take stock of the plethora of variants on the causal-inertial methods, and related constructive approaches to spacetime theories. We focus on constructive approaches to general relativity, but some of the results pertain to neighbouring or generalized theories of general relativity just as well. In fact, our undertaking can be read as a case study on the merits of a constructive approach to a physical theory more generally.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 56-104
Constructive Axiomatics in Context
We provide a comprehensive appraisal of the potential—but also the limitations—of the constructive axiomatic methodology as exhibited by EPS. For this, we take stock of the plethora of variants on the causal-inertial methods, and related constructive approaches to spacetime theories. We focus on constructive approaches to general relativity, but some of the results pertain to neighbouring or generalized theories of general relativity just as well. In fact, our undertaking can be read as a case study on the merits of a constructive approach to a physical theory more generally.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
Dedication
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 4-55
Walkthrough to the Ehlers–Pirani–Schild Axiomatization
The 1972 constructive axiomatisation of general relativity due to Ehlers, Pirani and Schild (‘EPS’) remains by far the most famous and comprehensive such axiomatisation in the history of physics. However, the work is notoriously difficult to understand. In this chapter, we provide a comprehensive walkthrough to the EPS axiomatisation: the reasoning is streamlined, proofs are explained, alternative avenues are explored, and conceptual subtleties regarding premises are identified. In this way, the reader gains a much-elevated understanding of the scope and the limitations both of the EPS approach, and of the constructive axiomatic methodology in general.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 4-55
Walkthrough to the Ehlers–Pirani–Schild Axiomatization
The 1972 constructive axiomatisation of general relativity due to Ehlers, Pirani and Schild (‘EPS’) remains by far the most famous and comprehensive such axiomatisation in the history of physics. However, the work is notoriously difficult to understand. In this chapter, we provide a comprehensive walkthrough to the EPS axiomatisation: the reasoning is streamlined, proofs are explained, alternative avenues are explored, and conceptual subtleties regarding premises are identified. In this way, the reader gains a much-elevated understanding of the scope and the limitations both of the EPS approach, and of the constructive axiomatic methodology in general.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 182-184
Conclusions
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 1-8
Introduction
The programme of ‘Constructive Axiomatics’, ‘promulgated by Hans Reichenbach in 1924, seeks to build up the architecture of our best theories of physics from basic axioms supposedly imbued with immediate and indubitable empirical content. Taking inspiration from Reichenbach, Hermann Weyl proposed his own ‘causal-inertial’ approach to the constructive axiomatization of Einstein’s general relativity, according to which a relativistic spacetime can be constructed solely from the trajectories of light rays and free-falling particles; this project, however, came to fruition only in 1972, with the constructive axiomatization of general relativity due to Ehlers, Pirani, and Schild (‘EPS’). One century since Reichenbach, and fifty years since EPS, this book is a celebration of the constructive axiomatic methodology. It achieves four main tasks. First, it provides a thoroughgoing presentation of the EPS axiomatization, closing missing loopholes, identifying problematic axioms, and so forth—in this way, one gains a much-improved appreciation of the extent to which a causal-inertial approach to general relativity might succeed, and of what such an approach might offer. Second, it synthesies and assesses the vast but disparate literature on Constructive Axiomatics which has arisen over the past century and sets the methodology in its proper philosophical context. Third, it generalizes the approach to apply to quantum spacetimes. And fourth, it applies the approach to the context of non-relativistic spacetime physics. All in all, the book demonstrates that Constructive Axiomatics is alive and kicking; the book aims to become the go-to resource for this way of philosophising about the nature of space and time.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 1-8
Introduction
The programme of ‘Constructive Axiomatics’, ‘promulgated by Hans Reichenbach in 1924, seeks to build up the architecture of our best theories of physics from basic axioms supposedly imbued with immediate and indubitable empirical content. Taking inspiration from Reichenbach, Hermann Weyl proposed his own ‘causal-inertial’ approach to the constructive axiomatization of Einstein’s general relativity, according to which a relativistic spacetime can be constructed solely from the trajectories of light rays and free-falling particles; this project, however, came to fruition only in 1972, with the constructive axiomatization of general relativity due to Ehlers, Pirani, and Schild (‘EPS’). One century since Reichenbach, and fifty years since EPS, this book is a celebration of the constructive axiomatic methodology. It achieves four main tasks. First, it provides a thoroughgoing presentation of the EPS axiomatization, closing missing loopholes, identifying problematic axioms, and so forth—in this way, one gains a much-improved appreciation of the extent to which a causal-inertial approach to general relativity might succeed, and of what such an approach might offer. Second, it synthesies and assesses the vast but disparate literature on Constructive Axiomatics which has arisen over the past century and sets the methodology in its proper philosophical context. Third, it generalizes the approach to apply to quantum spacetimes. And fourth, it applies the approach to the context of non-relativistic spacetime physics. All in all, the book demonstrates that Constructive Axiomatics is alive and kicking; the book aims to become the go-to resource for this way of philosophising about the nature of space and time.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 155-181
Non-relativistic Constructive Axiomatics
We consider how the EPS axioms might be modified so as to be suited to non-relativistic inputs. Further, we show that by modifying the notion of relativistic conformal structure to be appropriate for the non-relativistic context, and by building up said structure from elementary and empirically informed axioms à la EPS, one can arrive at the structure of a non-relativistic spacetime (a ‘classical spacetime’, to use philosophers’ terminology) and (thereby) set this spacetime on more secure empirical footing.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 155-181
Non-relativistic Constructive Axiomatics
We consider how the EPS axioms might be modified so as to be suited to non-relativistic inputs. Further, we show that by modifying the notion of relativistic conformal structure to be appropriate for the non-relativistic context, and by building up said structure from elementary and empirically informed axioms à la EPS, one can arrive at the structure of a non-relativistic spacetime (a ‘classical spacetime’, to use philosophers’ terminology) and (thereby) set this spacetime on more secure empirical footing.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 105-154
A Constructive Axiomatic Approach to Quantum Spacetime
We aim to understand the extent to which something resembling the EPS approach can be applied when the inputs are quantum mechanical rather than classical. That is, we consider versions of EPS with all classical light ray signals replaced by quantum light signals, and all particle signals replaced by quantum particles. In making these substitutions and applying the EPS approach, one ultimately derives a superposition of metric structures as the relevant kinematical structure for quantum spacetime; moreover, as we will see, there is a way of interpreting these outputs in terms of branching spacetime structures.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 105-154
A Constructive Axiomatic Approach to Quantum Spacetime
We aim to understand the extent to which something resembling the EPS approach can be applied when the inputs are quantum mechanical rather than classical. That is, we consider versions of EPS with all classical light ray signals replaced by quantum light signals, and all particle signals replaced by quantum particles. In making these substitutions and applying the EPS approach, one ultimately derives a superposition of metric structures as the relevant kinematical structure for quantum spacetime; moreover, as we will see, there is a way of interpreting these outputs in terms of branching spacetime structures.