Mark Dyble
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Mark Dyble has a total of 135 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Abigail Emma Page
Department of Anthropology, University College London, London WC1H 0BW, UK
17 shared publications - Daniel Major-Smith
Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol
15 shared publications - Gul Deniz Salali
Department of Anthropology, University College London, London, UK
14 shared publications - Nikhil Chaudhary
University College London
13 shared publications - Andrea Bamberg Migliano
Human Evolutionary Ecology Group, Department of Evolutionary Anthropology, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
12 shared publications - Ruth Mace
Department of Anthropology, University College London, London, UK
8 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 July 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 13 (7)
The role of second-order punishers and non-participants in the evolution of altruism through punishment
Altruistic punishment has been hypothesized to be important in the evolution of human cooperative behaviour. Although theoretical models have sought to establish the plausibility of this hypothesis, the empirical validity and robustness of such models remains largely untested. Here, we replicate and extend a prominent deterministic model of the evolution of altruism through punishment by Fowler (Fowler 2005 Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 102, 7047–7049. (doi:10.1073/pnas.0500938102)), exploring parameter sensitivity and varying key assumptions. We find that the evolution of cooperation depends critically on the possibility of voluntary non-participation as a strategy, allowing agents to survive while opting out of the public goods game altogether, as well as the presence of strong second-order punishment, where all first-order punishers are also second-order punishers. Although further modifications to the model allow cooperation to evolve with a low frequency of second-order punishers, the possibility of non-participation remains necessary for altruism to evolve. These results call into question the robustness and empirical validity of this model and stress the importance of exploring the key assumptions of theoretical models.
- 22 July 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 13 (7)
Open AccessThe role of second-order punishers and non-participants in the evolution of altruism through punishment
Altruistic punishment has been hypothesized to be important in the evolution of human cooperative behaviour. Although theoretical models have sought to establish the plausibility of this hypothesis, the empirical validity and robustness of such models remains largely untested. Here, we replicate and extend a prominent deterministic model of the evolution of altruism through punishment by Fowler (Fowler 2005 Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 102, 7047–7049. (doi:10.1073/pnas.0500938102)), exploring parameter sensitivity and varying key assumptions. We find that the evolution of cooperation depends critically on the possibility of voluntary non-participation as a strategy, allowing agents to survive while opting out of the public goods game altogether, as well as the presence of strong second-order punishment, where all first-order punishers are also second-order punishers. Although further modifications to the model allow cooperation to evolve with a low frequency of second-order punishers, the possibility of non-participation remains necessary for altruism to evolve. These results call into question the robustness and empirical validity of this model and stress the importance of exploring the key assumptions of theoretical models.
- Open Access
- 18 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Animal Behaviour
- Vol. 237
The ecology and evolution of cues and signals in animal interspecies cooperation
- 18 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Animal Behaviour
- Vol. 237
Open AccessThe ecology and evolution of cues and signals in animal interspecies cooperation
- Open Access
- 29 April 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 293 (2069)
Inbreeding avoidance in the Raute hunter–gatherers from Nepal
Inbreeding can reduce fitness and genetic diversity, posing significant challenges for small human populations. While mobility and exogamy are known mechanisms of inbreeding avoidance among hunter–gatherers, the effects of cultural systems in mitigating these risks have not been studied in detail. Here, we investigate inbreeding patterns and avoidance strategies in the Raute of Nepal in comparison with two other contemporary hunter–gatherer populations, the Agta of the Philippines and the Mbendjele BaYaka of the Republic of Congo, using genome-wide single nucleotide polymorphism data and kinship analysis. We find evidence for heightened levels of homozygosity and a general preference towards genetically dissimilar mates among these populations, despite wide variation in population structure and connectivity. In addition, our simulations also show that the Raute’s patrilineal clan-based exogamic marriage system reduces expected offspring inbreeding more effectively than random mating or close-kin avoidance. These results suggest that the Raute’s cultural rules may be a compensatory strategy for their demographic isolation. Our findings highlight the importance of social structure in shaping genetic outcomes and demonstrate how cultural practices can evolve as adaptive responses to the constraints of small population size.
- 29 April 2026
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 293 (2069)
Open AccessInbreeding avoidance in the Raute hunter–gatherers from Nepal
Inbreeding can reduce fitness and genetic diversity, posing significant challenges for small human populations. While mobility and exogamy are known mechanisms of inbreeding avoidance among hunter–gatherers, the effects of cultural systems in mitigating these risks have not been studied in detail. Here, we investigate inbreeding patterns and avoidance strategies in the Raute of Nepal in comparison with two other contemporary hunter–gatherer populations, the Agta of the Philippines and the Mbendjele BaYaka of the Republic of Congo, using genome-wide single nucleotide polymorphism data and kinship analysis. We find evidence for heightened levels of homozygosity and a general preference towards genetically dissimilar mates among these populations, despite wide variation in population structure and connectivity. In addition, our simulations also show that the Raute’s patrilineal clan-based exogamic marriage system reduces expected offspring inbreeding more effectively than random mating or close-kin avoidance. These results suggest that the Raute’s cultural rules may be a compensatory strategy for their demographic isolation. Our findings highlight the importance of social structure in shaping genetic outcomes and demonstrate how cultural practices can evolve as adaptive responses to the constraints of small population size.
- Open Access
- 10 December 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2060)
Human monogamy in mammalian context
Monogamy has been argued to have played an important role in human evolution and, across animals more generally, evolutionary transitions to highly cooperative societies have been far more likely to occur in monogamous species, raising the possibility that this may have also been the case for humans. However, the extent to which we can consider monogamy to be the typical human mating system is subject to debate. Here, I provide comparative context on human mating behaviour by comparing the distribution of sibling types (full siblings versus half-siblings) across more than 100 human societies with equivalent data from 34 non-human mammal species. While cross-culturally variable, rates of full siblings in humans cluster closely with rates seen among socially monogamous mammals and fall consistently above the range seen in non-monogamous mammals. Although the human data is demonstrative of considerable cross-cultural diversity in marriage and mating practices, the overall high frequency of full siblings is consistent with the characterization of monogamy as the modal mating system for humans.
- 10 December 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2060)
Open AccessHuman monogamy in mammalian context
Monogamy has been argued to have played an important role in human evolution and, across animals more generally, evolutionary transitions to highly cooperative societies have been far more likely to occur in monogamous species, raising the possibility that this may have also been the case for humans. However, the extent to which we can consider monogamy to be the typical human mating system is subject to debate. Here, I provide comparative context on human mating behaviour by comparing the distribution of sibling types (full siblings versus half-siblings) across more than 100 human societies with equivalent data from 34 non-human mammal species. While cross-culturally variable, rates of full siblings in humans cluster closely with rates seen among socially monogamous mammals and fall consistently above the range seen in non-monogamous mammals. Although the human data is demonstrative of considerable cross-cultural diversity in marriage and mating practices, the overall high frequency of full siblings is consistent with the characterization of monogamy as the modal mating system for humans.
- Open Access
- 27 October 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Evolutionary Human Sciences
- Vol. 7, 1-37
The fitness costs and benefits of hunter-gatherer locomotor engagement
Bipedalism is a distinguishing feature of our species and, as such, there has been much interest in the energetic costs and foraging returns of walking and running, especially among hunter-gatherer societies. However, humans routinely exhibit extensive locomotor versatility, with hunter-gatherers consistently also swimming, diving, and climbing. Additionally, the fitness costs and benefits of locomotion extend well beyond energy income and expenditure. Here, we review evidence from over 900 ethnographic documents across a worldwide sample of more than 50 hunter-gatherer societies to examine the fitness costs and benefits of walking, running, climbing, swimming, and diving. We show that the fitness costs and benefits of locomotor engagement consistently extend well beyond energetics to include, for example, currencies of status, protection from hazards, and risks of injury or death. These fitness factors differ in significance between locomotor modalities, with implications for the comparison of bipedal and non-bipedal locomotion. For example, while energetic demands represent the major cost of most bipedal engagements, the fitness implications of potential fall injuries may outweigh those of energetics in tree climbing. These results inform existing debates relating to hominin locomotor evolution and hunter-gatherer behavioural ecology.
- 27 October 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Evolutionary Human Sciences
- Vol. 7, 1-37
Open AccessThe fitness costs and benefits of hunter-gatherer locomotor engagement
Bipedalism is a distinguishing feature of our species and, as such, there has been much interest in the energetic costs and foraging returns of walking and running, especially among hunter-gatherer societies. However, humans routinely exhibit extensive locomotor versatility, with hunter-gatherers consistently also swimming, diving, and climbing. Additionally, the fitness costs and benefits of locomotion extend well beyond energy income and expenditure. Here, we review evidence from over 900 ethnographic documents across a worldwide sample of more than 50 hunter-gatherer societies to examine the fitness costs and benefits of walking, running, climbing, swimming, and diving. We show that the fitness costs and benefits of locomotor engagement consistently extend well beyond energetics to include, for example, currencies of status, protection from hazards, and risks of injury or death. These fitness factors differ in significance between locomotor modalities, with implications for the comparison of bipedal and non-bipedal locomotion. For example, while energetic demands represent the major cost of most bipedal engagements, the fitness implications of potential fall injuries may outweigh those of energetics in tree climbing. These results inform existing debates relating to hominin locomotor evolution and hunter-gatherer behavioural ecology.
- Open Access
Human monogamy in mammalian context
Monogamy has been argued to have played an important role in human evolution 1–5 and, across animals more generally, evolutionary transitions to highly cooperative societies have been far more likely to occur in monogamous species 6–8 , raising the possibility that this may also have been the case for humans. However, the extent to which we can consider monogamy to be the species-typical human mating system is subject to debate 9–11 . Here, I provide comparative context on human mating behaviour by comparing the distribution of sibling types (full siblings versus half-siblings) across >100 human societies with equivalent data from 35 nonhuman mammal species. While cross-culturally variable, rates of full siblings in humans cluster closely with rates seen among socially monogamous mammals and fall consistently above the range seen in non-monogamous mammals. Although the human data is demonstrative of cross-cultural diversity in marriage and mating practices, the overall high frequency of full siblings is consistent with the characterisation of monogamy as the modal mating system for humans.
Open AccessHuman monogamy in mammalian context
Monogamy has been argued to have played an important role in human evolution 1–5 and, across animals more generally, evolutionary transitions to highly cooperative societies have been far more likely to occur in monogamous species 6–8 , raising the possibility that this may also have been the case for humans. However, the extent to which we can consider monogamy to be the species-typical human mating system is subject to debate 9–11 . Here, I provide comparative context on human mating behaviour by comparing the distribution of sibling types (full siblings versus half-siblings) across >100 human societies with equivalent data from 35 nonhuman mammal species. While cross-culturally variable, rates of full siblings in humans cluster closely with rates seen among socially monogamous mammals and fall consistently above the range seen in non-monogamous mammals. Although the human data is demonstrative of cross-cultural diversity in marriage and mating practices, the overall high frequency of full siblings is consistent with the characterisation of monogamy as the modal mating system for humans.
- Open Access
- 14 May 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2046) , 20250385
Demography of grandmothering: a case study in Agta foragers
Grandmothers are often presented as key carers due to low costs and high inclusive fitness returns. Empirically, however, grandmothers are not consistently important. Understanding the factors that promote, or hinder, grandmothering is an important next step. We explore the demographic predictors of the low levels of grandmothering in Agta hunter–gatherers (78 children with 29 grandmothers). Due to generational reproductive timing, grandmothers still had dependent children until, on average 52, creating reproductive overlap. The minimal levels of grandmaternal investment after the age of 60 are explained by declining health and high mortality. This means the ‘helping window’ for grandmothering only spans 7 years. Yet grandmothers are still limited by multiple dependent grandchildren in this period, given high fertility. We suggest then that Agta grandmothering is constrained by (i) reproductive overlap and (ii) grandchildren competition. Accordingly, we tested how (i) the number of children and (ii) grandchildren associated with grandmothering using Bayesian mixed-effect models. We found moderate to strong evidence that more children/grandchildren reduced investment in each grandchild. Consequently, whether Agta grandmothers help appears dependent on demographic schedules, which vary widely both within and between populations. Future formal demographic modelling will then help shed light on the evolution of grandmothering in humans.
- 14 May 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2046) , 20250385
Open AccessDemography of grandmothering: a case study in Agta foragers
Grandmothers are often presented as key carers due to low costs and high inclusive fitness returns. Empirically, however, grandmothers are not consistently important. Understanding the factors that promote, or hinder, grandmothering is an important next step. We explore the demographic predictors of the low levels of grandmothering in Agta hunter–gatherers (78 children with 29 grandmothers). Due to generational reproductive timing, grandmothers still had dependent children until, on average 52, creating reproductive overlap. The minimal levels of grandmaternal investment after the age of 60 are explained by declining health and high mortality. This means the ‘helping window’ for grandmothering only spans 7 years. Yet grandmothers are still limited by multiple dependent grandchildren in this period, given high fertility. We suggest then that Agta grandmothering is constrained by (i) reproductive overlap and (ii) grandchildren competition. Accordingly, we tested how (i) the number of children and (ii) grandchildren associated with grandmothering using Bayesian mixed-effect models. We found moderate to strong evidence that more children/grandchildren reduced investment in each grandchild. Consequently, whether Agta grandmothers help appears dependent on demographic schedules, which vary widely both within and between populations. Future formal demographic modelling will then help shed light on the evolution of grandmothering in humans.
- Open Access
Predicting the Patterns of Kinship Dynamics in Human Societies
By shaping the inclusive fitness effects of behaviours, kinship environments have important implications for social evolution, and studies across non-human animal societies have shown that the patterns of kinship dynamics individuals experience as they age can be predicted by simple demographic parameters relating to sex-specific dispersal patterns, the extent of extra-group mating, and the age-specific patterns of mortality and fertility. However, it remains unclear whether these insights apply within our own species, where we see both extended lifespans in which kinship dynamics can play out, and remarkable variations in cultural practices relating to marriage and residence that influence the patterns of inter-individual relatedness. Here, using a newly developed model of kinship dynamics, we explore how marriage practices and post-marital residence rules, along with the typical survival and fertility schedules of our own species, can predict the emergent patterns of female and male kinship dynamics in human societies. By showing evidence that the model successfully captures the patterns of female and male kinship dynamics underlying human societies, we demonstrate that, despite the diversity in human social organisation, a relatively simple set of parameters relating to male and female rates of dispersal and the prevalence of extra-group mating suffices to capture the qualitative patterns of human kinship dynamics. Given the inclusive fitness implications kinship dynamics have for sex- and age-linked variations in behaviours, our study thus generates new insights into human social evolution.
Open AccessPredicting the Patterns of Kinship Dynamics in Human Societies
By shaping the inclusive fitness effects of behaviours, kinship environments have important implications for social evolution, and studies across non-human animal societies have shown that the patterns of kinship dynamics individuals experience as they age can be predicted by simple demographic parameters relating to sex-specific dispersal patterns, the extent of extra-group mating, and the age-specific patterns of mortality and fertility. However, it remains unclear whether these insights apply within our own species, where we see both extended lifespans in which kinship dynamics can play out, and remarkable variations in cultural practices relating to marriage and residence that influence the patterns of inter-individual relatedness. Here, using a newly developed model of kinship dynamics, we explore how marriage practices and post-marital residence rules, along with the typical survival and fertility schedules of our own species, can predict the emergent patterns of female and male kinship dynamics in human societies. By showing evidence that the model successfully captures the patterns of female and male kinship dynamics underlying human societies, we demonstrate that, despite the diversity in human social organisation, a relatively simple set of parameters relating to male and female rates of dispersal and the prevalence of extra-group mating suffices to capture the qualitative patterns of human kinship dynamics. Given the inclusive fitness implications kinship dynamics have for sex- and age-linked variations in behaviours, our study thus generates new insights into human social evolution.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 291 (2036) , 20242553
Extensive locomotor versatility across a global sample of hunter–gatherer societies
Studies of hunter–gatherer locomotion inform a wide range of academic fields, from human behavioural ecology and hominin evolution to sports science and evolutionary health. Despite celebrated ethnographic examples of hunter–gatherer locomotor proficiency in running, climbing, swimming and diving, there has been limited systematic analysis of cross-cultural variation in hunter–gatherer locomotor versatility. We conducted a systematic cross-cultural analysis of hunter–gatherer locomotion, coding locomotor behaviour from over 900 ethnographic documents. Our results indicated that high levels of locomotor versatility are common among hunter–gatherers, and that proficiency of running, climbing, swimming and diving is found in societies across the geographical and ecological breadth of the sample. Each locomotor modality was found to be relevant not only to food acquisition but also in leisure, ritual and violent conflict. Our results also indicated the prevalence of both male and female engagement within each locomotor modality, with climbing being the only modality to possess a notable bias towards male engagement in a substantial proportion of societies. The widespread habituality and functional significance of diverse locomotor proficiency in hunter–gatherers suggests that locomotor versatility represents a dimension of human adaptive lability, playing a major role in the ability of hunter–gatherers to thrive in almost every global ecology.
- 4 December 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 291 (2036) , 20242553
Open AccessExtensive locomotor versatility across a global sample of hunter–gatherer societies
Studies of hunter–gatherer locomotion inform a wide range of academic fields, from human behavioural ecology and hominin evolution to sports science and evolutionary health. Despite celebrated ethnographic examples of hunter–gatherer locomotor proficiency in running, climbing, swimming and diving, there has been limited systematic analysis of cross-cultural variation in hunter–gatherer locomotor versatility. We conducted a systematic cross-cultural analysis of hunter–gatherer locomotion, coding locomotor behaviour from over 900 ethnographic documents. Our results indicated that high levels of locomotor versatility are common among hunter–gatherers, and that proficiency of running, climbing, swimming and diving is found in societies across the geographical and ecological breadth of the sample. Each locomotor modality was found to be relevant not only to food acquisition but also in leisure, ritual and violent conflict. Our results also indicated the prevalence of both male and female engagement within each locomotor modality, with climbing being the only modality to possess a notable bias towards male engagement in a substantial proportion of societies. The widespread habituality and functional significance of diverse locomotor proficiency in hunter–gatherers suggests that locomotor versatility represents a dimension of human adaptive lability, playing a major role in the ability of hunter–gatherers to thrive in almost every global ecology.
- 29 May 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Evolution and Human Behavior
- Vol. 45 (4)
Bargaining between the sexes: outside options and leisure time in hunter-gatherer households
- 29 May 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Evolution and Human Behavior
- Vol. 45 (4)
Bargaining between the sexes: outside options and leisure time in hunter-gatherer households