Jason S. McCarley
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jason S. McCarley has a total of 143 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Arthur F. Kramer
University of Illinois
27 shared publications - Megan Louise Bartlett
School of Psychology, University of Adelaide
12 shared publications David E. Irwin
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign , IL, USA
8 shared publicationsMatthew S. Peterson
George Mason University , Fairfax, VA, USA
8 shared publicationsArthur F. Kramer
7 shared publicationsChristopher D. Wickens
Department of Psychology, Colorado State University
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 3 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
How to Recognize Your Pachyderm in a Hurry: Morphological Trait Diagnosticity for the Identification of Adult Asian Elephants
The ability to track individual animals facilitates elephant conservation. Here, we test a measure of morphological trait diagnosticity to improve the identification of individual Asian elephants. Data were archival trait-list descriptions of 72 adult elephants, extracted from camera trap videos by trained coders. Twenty-four traits were coded for each individual. We calculated the entropy of each trait as a measure of diagnosticity, then performed Monte Carlo simulations to produce point and interval estimates of the number of trait checks needed to identify a randomly selected individual elephant. Highest entropy traits were depigmentation on the body, ear folds, ear tears, and brush type. Simulations confirmed that checking traits in order of entropy allowed faster and more robust identification as compared to control conditions. Results imply that trait rankings based on entropy might be used to train novice coders to identify elephants.
- 3 November 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
How to Recognize Your Pachyderm in a Hurry: Morphological Trait Diagnosticity for the Identification of Adult Asian Elephants
The ability to track individual animals facilitates elephant conservation. Here, we test a measure of morphological trait diagnosticity to improve the identification of individual Asian elephants. Data were archival trait-list descriptions of 72 adult elephants, extracted from camera trap videos by trained coders. Twenty-four traits were coded for each individual. We calculated the entropy of each trait as a measure of diagnosticity, then performed Monte Carlo simulations to produce point and interval estimates of the number of trait checks needed to identify a randomly selected individual elephant. Highest entropy traits were depigmentation on the body, ear folds, ear tears, and brush type. Simulations confirmed that checking traits in order of entropy allowed faster and more robust identification as compared to control conditions. Results imply that trait rankings based on entropy might be used to train novice coders to identify elephants.
- 6 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Examining Personality and Decision-Making Style as Predictors of Automated Aid Efficiency
Automated diagnostic aids can improve decision making, yet operators often fail to use them effectively. This study examined whether personality traits and decision-making styles predict aid-use efficiency in a signal detection task. One hundred seventy-five undergraduate participants completed a signal detection task with and without a 93% reliable automated decision aid and completed measures of conscientiousness, neuroticism, satisficing, and decision difficulty. After preregistered exclusions, Bayesian analyses examined whether individual differences predicted aid-use efficiency, quantified as the ratio between observed and optimal aided performance. The aid significantly improved sensitivity, providing evidence of its diagnostic value. However, Bayesian correlations provided evidence against relationships between aid-use efficiency and conscientiousness, neuroticism, satisficing, or decision difficulty. Additional analyses showed that neuroticism was associated with greater decision difficulty, whereas conscientiousness was associated with lower decision difficulty. These findings suggest that individual differences in personality and decision style may not explain inefficiencies in automation use.
- 6 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Examining Personality and Decision-Making Style as Predictors of Automated Aid Efficiency
Automated diagnostic aids can improve decision making, yet operators often fail to use them effectively. This study examined whether personality traits and decision-making styles predict aid-use efficiency in a signal detection task. One hundred seventy-five undergraduate participants completed a signal detection task with and without a 93% reliable automated decision aid and completed measures of conscientiousness, neuroticism, satisficing, and decision difficulty. After preregistered exclusions, Bayesian analyses examined whether individual differences predicted aid-use efficiency, quantified as the ratio between observed and optimal aided performance. The aid significantly improved sensitivity, providing evidence of its diagnostic value. However, Bayesian correlations provided evidence against relationships between aid-use efficiency and conscientiousness, neuroticism, satisficing, or decision difficulty. Additional analyses showed that neuroticism was associated with greater decision difficulty, whereas conscientiousness was associated with lower decision difficulty. These findings suggest that individual differences in personality and decision style may not explain inefficiencies in automation use.
- 9 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics
- Vol. 88 (5)
Deconstructing the vigilance decrement: Changes in bias, lapse rate, and guess rate, but not sensitivity
The vigilance decrement-a gradual decline in performance over the course of a sustained attention task-has been studied extensively, but its underlying mechanisms remain the subject of debate. We analyzed psychometric curves from a vigilant monitoring task to isolate the contributions of response bias, sensitivity, mental lapses, and guesses to the effect. Stimuli were pairs of small visual probes that varied in their spatial separation from trial to trial. Participants (N = 366) performed a psychophysical task that required them to report occasional trials on which the separation between probes exceeded a criterion value. Stimuli were embedded in dynamic noise, and trials occurred at a forced pace of 40 per minute, conditions designed to elevate processing demands and encourage sensitivity losses. Model comparisons revealed decisive evidence for conservative bias shifts, increases in mental lapse rates, and decreases in positive guess rate over time, but gave evidence against a loss of sensitivity. A reanalysis of data from an earlier study indicated that apparent evidence for a sensitivity loss in that report was the result of model misspecification. Results in total suggest that the vigilance decrement most generally reflects changes of response bias and increases in the frequency of mindless responses, not a fundamental loss of signal-noise discriminability. Open Practices Statement: Data and code are available at https://osf.io/3np2v/ . Experiment was preregistered at https://osf.io/2b58e and https://osf.io/zynx9 .
- 9 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics
- Vol. 88 (5)
Deconstructing the vigilance decrement: Changes in bias, lapse rate, and guess rate, but not sensitivity
The vigilance decrement-a gradual decline in performance over the course of a sustained attention task-has been studied extensively, but its underlying mechanisms remain the subject of debate. We analyzed psychometric curves from a vigilant monitoring task to isolate the contributions of response bias, sensitivity, mental lapses, and guesses to the effect. Stimuli were pairs of small visual probes that varied in their spatial separation from trial to trial. Participants (N = 366) performed a psychophysical task that required them to report occasional trials on which the separation between probes exceeded a criterion value. Stimuli were embedded in dynamic noise, and trials occurred at a forced pace of 40 per minute, conditions designed to elevate processing demands and encourage sensitivity losses. Model comparisons revealed decisive evidence for conservative bias shifts, increases in mental lapse rates, and decreases in positive guess rate over time, but gave evidence against a loss of sensitivity. A reanalysis of data from an earlier study indicated that apparent evidence for a sensitivity loss in that report was the result of model misspecification. Results in total suggest that the vigilance decrement most generally reflects changes of response bias and increases in the frequency of mindless responses, not a fundamental loss of signal-noise discriminability. Open Practices Statement: Data and code are available at https://osf.io/3np2v/ . Experiment was preregistered at https://osf.io/2b58e and https://osf.io/zynx9 .
- 1 June 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
- Vol. 32 (2) , 229-239
Leaving money on the table: As diagnostic aids become more useful, operators use them less efficiently.
Diagnostic aids can assist human operators in everyday and high-stakes decision tasks, but performance typically falls short of best possible levels, reflecting a tendency toward disuse. To mitigate disuse, it is important to understand how task context influences aid dependence. The present study tested the prediction that aid use will become less efficient either as the aid becomes more reliable or the decision maker's task becomes more difficult. Participants (N = 127; data collected in 2023) performed a signal detection task with and without support from a diagnostic aid, where task difficulty and aid reliability varied between subjects. Analyses compared observed levels of aided performance with the predictions of an optimal strategy. Aided performance was consistently suboptimal but fell furthest from optimal when the aid was most reliable and when the task was most difficult. Costs of disuse to decision accuracy were substantial. Findings replicate and extend earlier patterns of suboptimal use, indicating that a mechanism of disuse is a failure to increase aid dependence appropriately in response to increases in aid quality or task demand. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 June 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
- Vol. 32 (2) , 229-239
Leaving money on the table: As diagnostic aids become more useful, operators use them less efficiently.
Diagnostic aids can assist human operators in everyday and high-stakes decision tasks, but performance typically falls short of best possible levels, reflecting a tendency toward disuse. To mitigate disuse, it is important to understand how task context influences aid dependence. The present study tested the prediction that aid use will become less efficient either as the aid becomes more reliable or the decision maker's task becomes more difficult. Participants (N = 127; data collected in 2023) performed a signal detection task with and without support from a diagnostic aid, where task difficulty and aid reliability varied between subjects. Analyses compared observed levels of aided performance with the predictions of an optimal strategy. Aided performance was consistently suboptimal but fell furthest from optimal when the aid was most reliable and when the task was most difficult. Costs of disuse to decision accuracy were substantial. Findings replicate and extend earlier patterns of suboptimal use, indicating that a mechanism of disuse is a failure to increase aid dependence appropriately in response to increases in aid quality or task demand. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).
- 28 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
- Vol. 69 (1) , 656-660
A Computational Cognitive Model of the Vigilance Decrement
The vigilance decrement is a central topic in human factors research but has not yet given way to a clear theoretical understanding. Resource depletion theory, the most popular account of the effect, provides at best a qualitative and vague model of vigilance performance. More precise predictions are necessary for strong theory testing. The current study developed a computational account of the vigilance decrement, building on a quantitative, dynamic cognitive model of signal detection. The model reproduces supposed hallmark patterns of resource depletion, without incorporating a depletion process. Results suggest that a stronger emphasis on computational modeling can provide more concrete theories of the vigilance decrement and help resolve lingering points of disagreement in theories of sustained attention.
- 28 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
- Vol. 69 (1) , 656-660
A Computational Cognitive Model of the Vigilance Decrement
The vigilance decrement is a central topic in human factors research but has not yet given way to a clear theoretical understanding. Resource depletion theory, the most popular account of the effect, provides at best a qualitative and vague model of vigilance performance. More precise predictions are necessary for strong theory testing. The current study developed a computational account of the vigilance decrement, building on a quantitative, dynamic cognitive model of signal detection. The model reproduces supposed hallmark patterns of resource depletion, without incorporating a depletion process. Results suggest that a stronger emphasis on computational modeling can provide more concrete theories of the vigilance decrement and help resolve lingering points of disagreement in theories of sustained attention.
- Open Access
- 15 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 68 (1) , 5-27
Adaptable Automation Transparency: Should Humans Be Provided Flexibility to Self-Select Transparency Information?
Objective: We examined whether allowing operators to self-select automation transparency level (adaptable transparency) could improve accuracy of automation use compared to nonadaptable (fixed) low and high transparency. We examined factors underlying higher transparency selection (decision risk, perceived difficulty). Background: Increased fixed transparency typically improves automation use accuracy but can increase bias toward agreeing with automated advice. Adaptable transparency may further improve automation use if it increases the perceived expected value of high transparency information. Methods: Across two studies, participants completed an uninhabited vehicle (UV) management task where they selected the optimal UV to complete missions. Automation advised the optimal UV but was not always correct. Automation transparency (fixed low, fixed high, adaptable) and decision risk were manipulated within-subjects. Results: With adaptable transparency, participants selected higher transparency on 41% of missions and were more likely to select it for missions perceived as more difficult. Decision risk did not impact transparency selection. Increased fixed transparency (low to high) did not benefit automation use accuracy, but reduced decision times. Adaptable transparency did not improve automation use compared to fixed transparency. Conclusion: We found no evidence that adaptable transparency improved automation use. Despite a lack of fixed transparency effects in the current study, an aggregated analysis of our work to date using the UV management paradigm indicated that higher fixed transparency improves automation use accuracy, reduces decision time and perceived workload, and increases trust in automation. Application: The current study contributes to the emerging evidence-base regarding optimal automation transparency design in the modern workplace.
- 15 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 68 (1) , 5-27
Open AccessAdaptable Automation Transparency: Should Humans Be Provided Flexibility to Self-Select Transparency Information?
Objective: We examined whether allowing operators to self-select automation transparency level (adaptable transparency) could improve accuracy of automation use compared to nonadaptable (fixed) low and high transparency. We examined factors underlying higher transparency selection (decision risk, perceived difficulty). Background: Increased fixed transparency typically improves automation use accuracy but can increase bias toward agreeing with automated advice. Adaptable transparency may further improve automation use if it increases the perceived expected value of high transparency information. Methods: Across two studies, participants completed an uninhabited vehicle (UV) management task where they selected the optimal UV to complete missions. Automation advised the optimal UV but was not always correct. Automation transparency (fixed low, fixed high, adaptable) and decision risk were manipulated within-subjects. Results: With adaptable transparency, participants selected higher transparency on 41% of missions and were more likely to select it for missions perceived as more difficult. Decision risk did not impact transparency selection. Increased fixed transparency (low to high) did not benefit automation use accuracy, but reduced decision times. Adaptable transparency did not improve automation use compared to fixed transparency. Conclusion: We found no evidence that adaptable transparency improved automation use. Despite a lack of fixed transparency effects in the current study, an aggregated analysis of our work to date using the UV management paradigm indicated that higher fixed transparency improves automation use accuracy, reduces decision time and perceived workload, and increases trust in automation. Application: The current study contributes to the emerging evidence-base regarding optimal automation transparency design in the modern workplace.
- 6 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Computational Brain & Behavior
- Vol. 8 (2) , 361-376
Computational Modeling Reveals Minimal Vigilance Changes in a Cognitive Monitoring Task
The ability to monitor for rare critical events tends to deteriorate over time on task, an effect termed the vigilance decrement. Although the decrement has been replicated many times, it has generally been studied with sensory discrimination tasks. Research using cognitive vigilance tasks, which require judgments of symbolic stimulus characteristics, has produced less consistent results. To test the robustness and nature of the cognitive vigilance decrement, the current study developed a computational performance model of a novel monitoring task. Participants monitored for critical events in a task that required them to estimate the central tendency of a set of three-digit readings each trial. For analysis, data from the first and last 4-min blocks of trials were fit with a model based on signal detection theory. The model assumed that participants could either perform the task in an attentive state, in which decisions were stimulus-driven, or could lapse into an inattentive state, in which decisions were guessed. Parameter estimates indicated an increase in attentional lapse rate and a decrease in positive guess rate over time, coupled with a decrease in internal processing noise. The effects of these latent changes on observable response rates, however, were modest and partially offsetting. Results suggest that attention lapses and a tendency toward negative guesses are common causes of vigilance loss across sensory and cognitive tasks, but can have small effects on observed responses.
- 6 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Computational Brain & Behavior
- Vol. 8 (2) , 361-376
Computational Modeling Reveals Minimal Vigilance Changes in a Cognitive Monitoring Task
The ability to monitor for rare critical events tends to deteriorate over time on task, an effect termed the vigilance decrement. Although the decrement has been replicated many times, it has generally been studied with sensory discrimination tasks. Research using cognitive vigilance tasks, which require judgments of symbolic stimulus characteristics, has produced less consistent results. To test the robustness and nature of the cognitive vigilance decrement, the current study developed a computational performance model of a novel monitoring task. Participants monitored for critical events in a task that required them to estimate the central tendency of a set of three-digit readings each trial. For analysis, data from the first and last 4-min blocks of trials were fit with a model based on signal detection theory. The model assumed that participants could either perform the task in an attentive state, in which decisions were stimulus-driven, or could lapse into an inattentive state, in which decisions were guessed. Parameter estimates indicated an increase in attentional lapse rate and a decrease in positive guess rate over time, coupled with a decrease in internal processing noise. The effects of these latent changes on observable response rates, however, were modest and partially offsetting. Results suggest that attention lapses and a tendency toward negative guesses are common causes of vigilance loss across sensory and cognitive tasks, but can have small effects on observed responses.
- Open Access
- 3 September 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 67 (4) , 285-300
Selective Access to Decision Support as a Function of Event Uncertainty
Objective: We investigate the impact of event uncertainty, decision support (DS) display format, and DS sensitivity on participants’ behavior, performance, subjective workload, and perception of DS usefulness and performance in a classification task. Background: DS systems can positively and negatively affect decision accuracy, performance time, and workload. The ability to access DS selectively, based on informational needs, might improve DS effectiveness. Method: Participants performed a sensory classification task in which they were allowed to request DS on a trial-by-trial basis. DS was presented in separated-binary (SB), separated-likelihood (SL), or integrated-likelihood (IL) formats. Access preferences, task performance, performance time, subjective workload, and perceived DS usefulness and performance were recorded. Results: Participants accessed DS more often when it was highly sensitive, stimulus information was highly uncertain, or the DS cue and stimulus information were perceptually integrated. Effective sensitivity was highest with the integrated likelihood DS. Although the separated likelihood DS provided more information than the binary likelihood DS, it was accessed less often, leading to lower sensitivity. Conclusion: Participants are most likely to access DS when raw stimulus information is highly uncertain and appear to make effective use of likelihood DS only when DS cues are integrated with raw stimulus information within a display. Application: Results suggest that DS use will be most effective when likelihood DS cues and raw stimulus information are perceptually integrated. When DS cues and raw stimuli cannot be perceptually integrated, binary cues from the DS will be more effective than likelihood cues.
- 3 September 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 67 (4) , 285-300
Open AccessSelective Access to Decision Support as a Function of Event Uncertainty
Objective: We investigate the impact of event uncertainty, decision support (DS) display format, and DS sensitivity on participants’ behavior, performance, subjective workload, and perception of DS usefulness and performance in a classification task. Background: DS systems can positively and negatively affect decision accuracy, performance time, and workload. The ability to access DS selectively, based on informational needs, might improve DS effectiveness. Method: Participants performed a sensory classification task in which they were allowed to request DS on a trial-by-trial basis. DS was presented in separated-binary (SB), separated-likelihood (SL), or integrated-likelihood (IL) formats. Access preferences, task performance, performance time, subjective workload, and perceived DS usefulness and performance were recorded. Results: Participants accessed DS more often when it was highly sensitive, stimulus information was highly uncertain, or the DS cue and stimulus information were perceptually integrated. Effective sensitivity was highest with the integrated likelihood DS. Although the separated likelihood DS provided more information than the binary likelihood DS, it was accessed less often, leading to lower sensitivity. Conclusion: Participants are most likely to access DS when raw stimulus information is highly uncertain and appear to make effective use of likelihood DS only when DS cues are integrated with raw stimulus information within a display. Application: Results suggest that DS use will be most effective when likelihood DS cues and raw stimulus information are perceptually integrated. When DS cues and raw stimuli cannot be perceptually integrated, binary cues from the DS will be more effective than likelihood cues.
- Open Access
- 8 August 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Ergonomics
- Vol. 121, 104364
Benchmarking automation-aided performance in a forensic face matching task
- 8 August 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Applied Ergonomics
- Vol. 121, 104364
Open AccessBenchmarking automation-aided performance in a forensic face matching task
- 7 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Ergonomics
- Vol. 68 (7) , 1011-1024
Decision support improves information integration and criterion placement in a multi-cue signal-identification task
Identifying contacts in a military context can require operators to integrate multiple cues and to adjust response criteria to event base rates. The current experiment tested whether support from a decision aid would improve these processes. Participants performed a signal identification task that required them to integrate cues displayed as visual scale readings. In a static condition, participants saw a single set of readings each trial. In dynamic conditions, readings were updated over time. Base rates of signal categories were unequal, requiring participants to adopt biased response criteria to maximise response accuracy. Participants worked with or without an aid that combined cues and base rate information in an ideal manner. Support from the aid pushed participants' response criteria towards optimal and improved integration of dynamic cues. Decision aids may be especially useful when task demands require biased response criteria and when cues are sampled over time.
- 7 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Ergonomics
- Vol. 68 (7) , 1011-1024
Decision support improves information integration and criterion placement in a multi-cue signal-identification task
Identifying contacts in a military context can require operators to integrate multiple cues and to adjust response criteria to event base rates. The current experiment tested whether support from a decision aid would improve these processes. Participants performed a signal identification task that required them to integrate cues displayed as visual scale readings. In a static condition, participants saw a single set of readings each trial. In dynamic conditions, readings were updated over time. Base rates of signal categories were unequal, requiring participants to adopt biased response criteria to maximise response accuracy. Participants worked with or without an aid that combined cues and base rate information in an ideal manner. Support from the aid pushed participants' response criteria towards optimal and improved integration of dynamic cues. Decision aids may be especially useful when task demands require biased response criteria and when cues are sampled over time.