Lyanne Brouwer
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Lyanne Brouwer has a total of 270 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Martijn van de Pol
College of Science and Engineering, James Cook University, Townsville, Australia
10 shared publications Andrew Cockburn
Division of Ecology and Evolution, Research School of Biology, The Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 2600 Australia
4 shared publications- Andrew Cockburn
Division of Ecology and Evolution, Research School of Biology The Australian National University Canberra Australian Capital Territory Australia
4 shared publications David S. Richardson
Centre for Ecology, Evolution and Conservation, School of Biological Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich, United Kingdom
3 shared publications- Debora Arlt
Department of Ecology, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden
3 shared publications Jan Komdeur
Animal Ecology Group, Centre for Ecological and Evolutionary Studies, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (3)
Artificial Shelters as a Monitoring and Conservation Tool for Terrestrial Breeding Frogs
Amphibians are among the most threatened vertebrate groups, yet monitoring cryptic, fossorial species is difficult and often risks disturbing both their microhabitats and the individuals themselves. We tested whether artificial shelters could serve as a monitoring and potential conservation tool for cryptic fossorial amphibians in natural habitats. We deployed two different artificial shelter designs (concrete and wood) in the Australian Wet Tropics and assessed the number of Austrochaperina robusta , a terrestrial‐breeding microhylid frog, using them over 2 years. Monthly shelter surveys recorded the highest frog numbers in the cooler, drier months, indicating clear seasonal trends. Sliding‐window analyses showed that frog numbers under concrete, but not wooden, shelters declined with warmer minimum temperatures over the 6 days pre‐survey. Frogs used concrete shelters more (75% of records) compared to wooden shelters. This was partly because the concrete shelters did not degrade with time, but also likely reflects thermal buffering benefits. Microclimate logging indicated that concrete shelters provided greater daytime heat storage and slower nocturnal heat release than the wooden shelters. Invertebrate presence was weakly negatively associated with frog numbers, while greater understory cover and closer shelter spacing were stronger positive predictors of frog abundance. While most observations were of adult frogs, juveniles and metamorphs were also observed under both shelter designs. Additionally, six egg clutches were recorded, all under concrete shelters. Collectively, these results show that artificial shelters, especially concrete designs, offer a robust, low‐impact method for long‐term monitoring of fossorial frogs and may contribute to conservation by providing thermally favourable refugia and protection from disturbance.
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (3)
Open AccessArtificial Shelters as a Monitoring and Conservation Tool for Terrestrial Breeding Frogs
Amphibians are among the most threatened vertebrate groups, yet monitoring cryptic, fossorial species is difficult and often risks disturbing both their microhabitats and the individuals themselves. We tested whether artificial shelters could serve as a monitoring and potential conservation tool for cryptic fossorial amphibians in natural habitats. We deployed two different artificial shelter designs (concrete and wood) in the Australian Wet Tropics and assessed the number of Austrochaperina robusta , a terrestrial‐breeding microhylid frog, using them over 2 years. Monthly shelter surveys recorded the highest frog numbers in the cooler, drier months, indicating clear seasonal trends. Sliding‐window analyses showed that frog numbers under concrete, but not wooden, shelters declined with warmer minimum temperatures over the 6 days pre‐survey. Frogs used concrete shelters more (75% of records) compared to wooden shelters. This was partly because the concrete shelters did not degrade with time, but also likely reflects thermal buffering benefits. Microclimate logging indicated that concrete shelters provided greater daytime heat storage and slower nocturnal heat release than the wooden shelters. Invertebrate presence was weakly negatively associated with frog numbers, while greater understory cover and closer shelter spacing were stronger positive predictors of frog abundance. While most observations were of adult frogs, juveniles and metamorphs were also observed under both shelter designs. Additionally, six egg clutches were recorded, all under concrete shelters. Collectively, these results show that artificial shelters, especially concrete designs, offer a robust, low‐impact method for long‐term monitoring of fossorial frogs and may contribute to conservation by providing thermally favourable refugia and protection from disturbance.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 12 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1)
Changes in phenology mediate vertebrate population responses to temperature globally
Phenotypic responses to climate affect individual fitness, but the extent to which this translates into effects on population dynamics remains poorly understood. We assemble 213 time series on phenotypes and population sizes of wild vertebrates globally and match them with local climate data. Our meta-analysis shows that morphological traits are mostly climate insensitive. However, phenology is earlier in warmer-than-average years, which contributes positively to population growth in most species. At lower latitudes, temperature has weaker effects on phenology but stronger direct negative effects on population growth, likely because these populations are less capable of tracking climate via plasticity. Variation in the phenology-mediated effect of temperature on population growth cannot be explained by latitude, generation time, migratory mode, or diet. This suggests that simple relationships between species characteristics and population responses to warming may not occur in nature. Instead, we may need to embrace ecological complexity by considering local-scale predictors that capture intra-specific variation.
- 12 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessChanges in phenology mediate vertebrate population responses to temperature globally
Phenotypic responses to climate affect individual fitness, but the extent to which this translates into effects on population dynamics remains poorly understood. We assemble 213 time series on phenotypes and population sizes of wild vertebrates globally and match them with local climate data. Our meta-analysis shows that morphological traits are mostly climate insensitive. However, phenology is earlier in warmer-than-average years, which contributes positively to population growth in most species. At lower latitudes, temperature has weaker effects on phenology but stronger direct negative effects on population growth, likely because these populations are less capable of tracking climate via plasticity. Variation in the phenology-mediated effect of temperature on population growth cannot be explained by latitude, generation time, migratory mode, or diet. This suggests that simple relationships between species characteristics and population responses to warming may not occur in nature. Instead, we may need to embrace ecological complexity by considering local-scale predictors that capture intra-specific variation.
- 3 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Climate Change
- Vol. 14 (8) , 839-844
Sea-level rise causes shorebird population collapse before habitats drown
- 3 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Climate Change
- Vol. 14 (8) , 839-844
Sea-level rise causes shorebird population collapse before habitats drown
- Open Access
- 26 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Animal Conservation
- Vol. 27 (5) , 698-709
A country‐wide examination of effects of urbanization on common birds
Urbanization forms one of the most drastic alterations of the environment and poses a major threat to wildlife. The human–induced modifications of the landscape may affect individual's fitness resulting in population declines. Research on how urbanization affects fitness traits has shown mixed results. However, studies typically contrasted data from a single species from few urban and non‐urban sites collected over short timeframes. Examining multiple species across a broad urbanization gradient enables a more robust comparison and understanding of how different species are impacted by urbanization‐knowledge crucial for generating population predictions, which are essential for conservation management. Here, we use data from a nation‐wide citizen science project to examine variation in survival and relative body mass and size (wing length) of common passerine birds, collected along an urbanization gradient in the Netherlands over an 8‐year period. Urbanization was measured as the distance from the city's border and the proportion of impervious surface area. Although the overall association between urbanization and survival was slightly negative, there was support for lower survival closer to the city in three species (chiffchaff Phylloscopus collybita, European robin Erithacus rubecula, European greenfinch Chloris chloris) and higher survival closer to the city in two (great tit Parus major and house sparrow Passer domesticus) of the 11 species examined. The contrasting survival successes among species suggest that ongoing urbanization may lead to shifts in community structure and loss of biodiversity. Impacts of urbanization on relative mass and size also exhibited varying effects, albeit less pronounced, and these effects were not correlated with the effects on survival. This implies that body mass and size cannot be used as indicators for urban‐associated patterns of survival. Our results further imply that effective conservation management targeting bird communities should involve a range of diverse actions, as focusing on single measures is unlikely to simultaneously impact multiple species due to the variation in responses to urbanization.
- 26 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in Animal Conservation
- Vol. 27 (5) , 698-709
Open AccessA country‐wide examination of effects of urbanization on common birds
Urbanization forms one of the most drastic alterations of the environment and poses a major threat to wildlife. The human–induced modifications of the landscape may affect individual's fitness resulting in population declines. Research on how urbanization affects fitness traits has shown mixed results. However, studies typically contrasted data from a single species from few urban and non‐urban sites collected over short timeframes. Examining multiple species across a broad urbanization gradient enables a more robust comparison and understanding of how different species are impacted by urbanization‐knowledge crucial for generating population predictions, which are essential for conservation management. Here, we use data from a nation‐wide citizen science project to examine variation in survival and relative body mass and size (wing length) of common passerine birds, collected along an urbanization gradient in the Netherlands over an 8‐year period. Urbanization was measured as the distance from the city's border and the proportion of impervious surface area. Although the overall association between urbanization and survival was slightly negative, there was support for lower survival closer to the city in three species (chiffchaff Phylloscopus collybita, European robin Erithacus rubecula, European greenfinch Chloris chloris) and higher survival closer to the city in two (great tit Parus major and house sparrow Passer domesticus) of the 11 species examined. The contrasting survival successes among species suggest that ongoing urbanization may lead to shifts in community structure and loss of biodiversity. Impacts of urbanization on relative mass and size also exhibited varying effects, albeit less pronounced, and these effects were not correlated with the effects on survival. This implies that body mass and size cannot be used as indicators for urban‐associated patterns of survival. Our results further imply that effective conservation management targeting bird communities should involve a range of diverse actions, as focusing on single measures is unlikely to simultaneously impact multiple species due to the variation in responses to urbanization.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 9 May 2023
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 120 (19)
The effect of climate change on avian offspring production: A global meta-analysis
Climate change affects timing of reproduction in many bird species, but few studies have investigated its influence on annual reproductive output. Here, we assess changes in the annual production of young by female breeders in 201 populations of 104 bird species (N = 745,962 clutches) covering all continents between 1970 and 2019. Overall, average offspring production has declined in recent decades, but considerable differences were found among species and populations. A total of 56.7% of populations showed a declining trend in offspring production (significant in 17.4%), whereas 43.3% exhibited an increase (significant in 10.4%). The results show that climatic changes affect offspring production through compounded effects on ecological and life history traits of species. Migratory and larger-bodied species experienced reduced offspring production with increasing temperatures during the chick-rearing period, whereas smaller-bodied, sedentary species tended to produce more offspring. Likewise, multi-brooded species showed increased breeding success with increasing temperatures, whereas rising temperatures were unrelated to reproductive success in single-brooded species. Our study suggests that rapid declines in size of bird populations reported by many studies from different parts of the world are driven only to a small degree by changes in the production of young.
- 9 May 2023
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 120 (19)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe effect of climate change on avian offspring production: A global meta-analysis
Climate change affects timing of reproduction in many bird species, but few studies have investigated its influence on annual reproductive output. Here, we assess changes in the annual production of young by female breeders in 201 populations of 104 bird species (N = 745,962 clutches) covering all continents between 1970 and 2019. Overall, average offspring production has declined in recent decades, but considerable differences were found among species and populations. A total of 56.7% of populations showed a declining trend in offspring production (significant in 17.4%), whereas 43.3% exhibited an increase (significant in 10.4%). The results show that climatic changes affect offspring production through compounded effects on ecological and life history traits of species. Migratory and larger-bodied species experienced reduced offspring production with increasing temperatures during the chick-rearing period, whereas smaller-bodied, sedentary species tended to produce more offspring. Likewise, multi-brooded species showed increased breeding success with increasing temperatures, whereas rising temperatures were unrelated to reproductive success in single-brooded species. Our study suggests that rapid declines in size of bird populations reported by many studies from different parts of the world are driven only to a small degree by changes in the production of young.
- Open Access
A country-wide examination of effects of urbanization on common birds
Urbanization forms one of the most drastic alterations of the environment and poses a major threat to wildlife. The human-induced modifications of the landscape may affect individual’s fitness and thereby result in population declines. Research on how urbanization affects fitness traits has shown mixed results, but typically contrasted data from few urban and non-urban sites collected over short time frames from single species. It thus remains unknown whether we can generalize across species, whereas such knowledge is crucial for population predictions that are needed for conservation management. Here, we use data from a nation-wide citizen science project to examine variation in survival and body mass and size of common passerine birds, collected along an urbanization gradient in the Netherlands over an 8-year period. Although the overall association between urbanization and survival was slightly negative, there was strong support for lower survival in three species, and higher survival in two of the 11 species examined. Effects of urbanization on body mass and size also varied but were far less strong and there was no evidence that they mediated the impacts on survival. Our results imply that body mass and size cannot be used as indicators for urban-associated patterns of survival. Furthermore, the species-specific survival responses indicate that care should be taken when predicting the effects of ongoing urbanization for communities, because even closely related species can show different responses. Moreover, the contrasting survival successes among species suggests that ongoing urbanization may lead to shifts in community structure and loss of biodiversity.
Open AccessA country-wide examination of effects of urbanization on common birds
Urbanization forms one of the most drastic alterations of the environment and poses a major threat to wildlife. The human-induced modifications of the landscape may affect individual’s fitness and thereby result in population declines. Research on how urbanization affects fitness traits has shown mixed results, but typically contrasted data from few urban and non-urban sites collected over short time frames from single species. It thus remains unknown whether we can generalize across species, whereas such knowledge is crucial for population predictions that are needed for conservation management. Here, we use data from a nation-wide citizen science project to examine variation in survival and body mass and size of common passerine birds, collected along an urbanization gradient in the Netherlands over an 8-year period. Although the overall association between urbanization and survival was slightly negative, there was strong support for lower survival in three species, and higher survival in two of the 11 species examined. Effects of urbanization on body mass and size also varied but were far less strong and there was no evidence that they mediated the impacts on survival. Our results imply that body mass and size cannot be used as indicators for urban-associated patterns of survival. Furthermore, the species-specific survival responses indicate that care should be taken when predicting the effects of ongoing urbanization for communities, because even closely related species can show different responses. Moreover, the contrasting survival successes among species suggests that ongoing urbanization may lead to shifts in community structure and loss of biodiversity.
- Open Access
- 8 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology
- Vol. 76 (8) , 1-12
Facultative and persistent offspring sex-ratio bias in relation to the social environment in cooperatively breeding red-winged fairy-wrens (Malurus elegans)
Females should facultatively bias offspring sex ratio when fitness returns vary among sexes. In cooperative breeders, where individuals help raise others’ young, overproducing the philopatric sex will be adaptive when helpers are absent, whereas overproducing the dispersive sex may be adaptive to reduce intrasexual competition. Thus, fitness returns are expected to vary with the social environment. However, any offspring sex-ratio biases may also result from consistent among-female differences (e.g. quality) and/or environmental variables (e.g. food availability). Yet, few studies have disentangled facultative from persistent biases. We investigated offspring sex-ratio biases in relation to the social environment in cooperatively breeding red-winged fairy-wrens (Malurus elegans). Repeated observations of the same females over nine years allowed for disentanglement of facultative from persistent biases. Females without help did not overproduce daughters, despite female helpers being associated with higher fledgling survival (resource enhancement hypothesis). Instead, females without helpers facultatively overproduced sons —the slower dispersing sex— thereby ensuring long-term helper availability. Furthermore, offspring sex ratio was not biased towards the rarer sex of helpers present in the group or population (resource competition hypothesis). However, females with sex-biased helping produced similarly skewed offspring sex ratios. This among-female association may not be surprising, because helpers are previous seasons’ offspring. Thus, in addition to facultative responses to prevailing social conditions, we found evidence for persistent biases among females. This could potentially explain previous evidence for resource competition/enhancement that have typically been interpreted as facultative responses, highlighting the need for a within-female approach to better understand the adaptiveness of sex-ratio biases. Significance statement: Under certain conditions, females may benefit from producing a biased offspring sex ratio, but evidence for such effects in vertebrates is weak and inconsistent. Here, using observations of the same females under different social conditions, we show that cooperatively breeding red-winged fairy-wrens facultatively biased offspring sex ratio towards sons when living in pairs, thereby ensuring the availability of a workforce to assist in raising future offspring. However, biased offspring sex ratio patterns may also be the result of consistent differences among females. Indeed, we also found evidence for such patterns and suggest that this could be an explanation for previous findings which are often interpreted as facultative responses.
- 8 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology
- Vol. 76 (8) , 1-12
Open AccessFacultative and persistent offspring sex-ratio bias in relation to the social environment in cooperatively breeding red-winged fairy-wrens (Malurus elegans)
Females should facultatively bias offspring sex ratio when fitness returns vary among sexes. In cooperative breeders, where individuals help raise others’ young, overproducing the philopatric sex will be adaptive when helpers are absent, whereas overproducing the dispersive sex may be adaptive to reduce intrasexual competition. Thus, fitness returns are expected to vary with the social environment. However, any offspring sex-ratio biases may also result from consistent among-female differences (e.g. quality) and/or environmental variables (e.g. food availability). Yet, few studies have disentangled facultative from persistent biases. We investigated offspring sex-ratio biases in relation to the social environment in cooperatively breeding red-winged fairy-wrens (Malurus elegans). Repeated observations of the same females over nine years allowed for disentanglement of facultative from persistent biases. Females without help did not overproduce daughters, despite female helpers being associated with higher fledgling survival (resource enhancement hypothesis). Instead, females without helpers facultatively overproduced sons —the slower dispersing sex— thereby ensuring long-term helper availability. Furthermore, offspring sex ratio was not biased towards the rarer sex of helpers present in the group or population (resource competition hypothesis). However, females with sex-biased helping produced similarly skewed offspring sex ratios. This among-female association may not be surprising, because helpers are previous seasons’ offspring. Thus, in addition to facultative responses to prevailing social conditions, we found evidence for persistent biases among females. This could potentially explain previous evidence for resource competition/enhancement that have typically been interpreted as facultative responses, highlighting the need for a within-female approach to better understand the adaptiveness of sex-ratio biases. Significance statement: Under certain conditions, females may benefit from producing a biased offspring sex ratio, but evidence for such effects in vertebrates is weak and inconsistent. Here, using observations of the same females under different social conditions, we show that cooperatively breeding red-winged fairy-wrens facultatively biased offspring sex ratio towards sons when living in pairs, thereby ensuring the availability of a workforce to assist in raising future offspring. However, biased offspring sex ratio patterns may also be the result of consistent differences among females. Indeed, we also found evidence for such patterns and suggest that this could be an explanation for previous findings which are often interpreted as facultative responses.
- Open Access
- 11 May 2022
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 18 (5) , 20210671
No evidence of immediate fitness benefits of within-season divorce in monogamous birds
Individuals of socially monogamous species can correct for suboptimal partnerships via two secondary mating strategies: divorce and extra-pair mating, with the former potentially providing both genetic and social benefits. Divorcing between breeding seasons has been shown to be generally adaptive behaviour across monogamous birds. Interestingly, some pairs also divorce during the breeding season, when constraints on finding a new partner are stronger. Despite being important for a comprehensive understanding of the evolution of social monogamy, whether within-season divorce is adaptive and how it relates to extra-pair mating remains unknown. Here, we meta-analysed 90 effect sizes on within-season divorce and breeding success, extracted from 31 studies on 24 species. We found no evidence that within-season divorce is adaptive for breeding success. However, the large heterogeneity of effect sizes and strong phylogenetic signal suggest social and environmental factors—which have rarely been considered in empirical studies—may play an important role in explaining variation among populations and species. Furthermore, we found no evidence that within-season divorce and extra-pair mating are complementary strategies. We discuss our findings within the current evidence of the adaptiveness of secondary mating strategies and their interplay that ultimately shapes the evolution of social monogamy.
- 11 May 2022
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 18 (5) , 20210671
Open AccessNo evidence of immediate fitness benefits of within-season divorce in monogamous birds
Individuals of socially monogamous species can correct for suboptimal partnerships via two secondary mating strategies: divorce and extra-pair mating, with the former potentially providing both genetic and social benefits. Divorcing between breeding seasons has been shown to be generally adaptive behaviour across monogamous birds. Interestingly, some pairs also divorce during the breeding season, when constraints on finding a new partner are stronger. Despite being important for a comprehensive understanding of the evolution of social monogamy, whether within-season divorce is adaptive and how it relates to extra-pair mating remains unknown. Here, we meta-analysed 90 effect sizes on within-season divorce and breeding success, extracted from 31 studies on 24 species. We found no evidence that within-season divorce is adaptive for breeding success. However, the large heterogeneity of effect sizes and strong phylogenetic signal suggest social and environmental factors—which have rarely been considered in empirical studies—may play an important role in explaining variation among populations and species. Furthermore, we found no evidence that within-season divorce and extra-pair mating are complementary strategies. We discuss our findings within the current evidence of the adaptiveness of secondary mating strategies and their interplay that ultimately shapes the evolution of social monogamy.
- Open Access
Sperm Numbers as a Paternity Guard in a Wild Bird
Sperm competition is thought to impose strong selection on males to produce competitive ejaculates to outcompete rival males under competitive mating conditions. Our understanding of how different sperm traits influence fertilization success, however, remains limited, especially in wild populations. Recent literature highlights the importance of incorporating multiple ejaculate traits and pre-copulatory sexually selected traits in analyses aimed at understanding how selection acts on sperm traits. However, variation in a male’s ability to gain fertilization success may also depend upon a range of social and ecological factors that determine the opportunity for mating events both within and outside of the social pair-bond. Here, we test for an effect of sperm quantity and sperm size on male reproductive success in the red-back fairy-wren (Malurus melanocephalus) while simultaneously accounting for pre-copulatory sexual selection and potential socio-ecological correlates of male mating success. We found that sperm number (i.e., cloacal protuberance volume), but not sperm morphology, was associated with reproductive success in male red-backed fairy-wrens. Most notably, males with large numbers of sperm available for copulation achieved greater within-pair paternity success. Our results suggest that males use large sperm numbers as a defensive strategy to guard within-pair paternity success in a system where there is a high risk of sperm competition and female control of copulation. Finally, our work highlights the importance of accounting for socio-ecological factors that may influence male mating opportunities when examining the role of sperm traits in determining male reproductive success.
Open AccessSperm Numbers as a Paternity Guard in a Wild Bird
Sperm competition is thought to impose strong selection on males to produce competitive ejaculates to outcompete rival males under competitive mating conditions. Our understanding of how different sperm traits influence fertilization success, however, remains limited, especially in wild populations. Recent literature highlights the importance of incorporating multiple ejaculate traits and pre-copulatory sexually selected traits in analyses aimed at understanding how selection acts on sperm traits. However, variation in a male’s ability to gain fertilization success may also depend upon a range of social and ecological factors that determine the opportunity for mating events both within and outside of the social pair-bond. Here, we test for an effect of sperm quantity and sperm size on male reproductive success in the red-back fairy-wren (Malurus melanocephalus) while simultaneously accounting for pre-copulatory sexual selection and potential socio-ecological correlates of male mating success. We found that sperm number (i.e., cloacal protuberance volume), but not sperm morphology, was associated with reproductive success in male red-backed fairy-wrens. Most notably, males with large numbers of sperm available for copulation achieved greater within-pair paternity success. Our results suggest that males use large sperm numbers as a defensive strategy to guard within-pair paternity success in a system where there is a high risk of sperm competition and female control of copulation. Finally, our work highlights the importance of accounting for socio-ecological factors that may influence male mating opportunities when examining the role of sperm traits in determining male reproductive success.
- Open Access
- 30 July 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 90 (10) , 2234-2253
Cross‐lags and the unbiased estimation of life‐history and demographic parameters
Biological processes exhibit complex temporal dependencies due to the sequential nature of allocation decisions in organisms' life cycles, feedback loops and two‐way causality. Consequently, longitudinal data often contain cross‐lags: the predictor variable depends on the response variable of the previous time step. Although statisticians have warned that regression models that ignore such covariate endogeneity in time series are likely to be inappropriate, this has received relatively little attention in biology. Furthermore, the resulting degree of estimation bias remains largely unexplored. We use a graphical model and numerical simulations to understand why and how regression models that ignore cross‐lags can be biased, and how this bias depends on the length and number of time series. Ecological and evolutionary examples are provided to illustrate that cross‐lags may be more common than is typically appreciated and that they occur in functionally different ways. We show that routinely used regression models that ignore cross‐lags are asymptotically unbiased. However, this offers little relief, as for most realistically feasible lengths of time‐series conventional methods are biased. Furthermore, collecting time series on multiple subjects—such as populations, groups or individuals—does not help to overcome this bias when the analysis focusses on within‐subject patterns (often the pattern of interest). Simulations, a literature search and a real‐world empirical example together suggest that approaches that ignore cross‐lags are likely biased in the direction opposite to the sign of the cross‐lag (e.g. towards detecting density dependence of vital rates and against detecting life‐history trade‐offs and benefits of group living). Next, we show that multivariate (e.g. structural equation) models can dynamically account for cross‐lags, and simultaneously address additional bias induced by measurement error, but only if the analysis considers multiple time series. We provide guidance on how to identify a cross‐lag and subsequently specify it in a multivariate model, which can be far from trivial. Our tutorials with data and R code of the worked examples provide step‐by‐step instructions on how to perform such analyses. Our study offers insights into situations in which cross‐lags can bias analysis of ecological and evolutionary time series and suggests that adopting dynamical models can be important, as this directly affects our understanding of population regulation, the evolution of life histories and cooperation, and possibly many other topics. Determining how strong estimation bias due to ignoring covariate endogeneity has been in the ecological literature requires further study, also because it may interact with other sources of bias.
- 30 July 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Ecology
- Vol. 90 (10) , 2234-2253
Open AccessCross‐lags and the unbiased estimation of life‐history and demographic parameters
Biological processes exhibit complex temporal dependencies due to the sequential nature of allocation decisions in organisms' life cycles, feedback loops and two‐way causality. Consequently, longitudinal data often contain cross‐lags: the predictor variable depends on the response variable of the previous time step. Although statisticians have warned that regression models that ignore such covariate endogeneity in time series are likely to be inappropriate, this has received relatively little attention in biology. Furthermore, the resulting degree of estimation bias remains largely unexplored. We use a graphical model and numerical simulations to understand why and how regression models that ignore cross‐lags can be biased, and how this bias depends on the length and number of time series. Ecological and evolutionary examples are provided to illustrate that cross‐lags may be more common than is typically appreciated and that they occur in functionally different ways. We show that routinely used regression models that ignore cross‐lags are asymptotically unbiased. However, this offers little relief, as for most realistically feasible lengths of time‐series conventional methods are biased. Furthermore, collecting time series on multiple subjects—such as populations, groups or individuals—does not help to overcome this bias when the analysis focusses on within‐subject patterns (often the pattern of interest). Simulations, a literature search and a real‐world empirical example together suggest that approaches that ignore cross‐lags are likely biased in the direction opposite to the sign of the cross‐lag (e.g. towards detecting density dependence of vital rates and against detecting life‐history trade‐offs and benefits of group living). Next, we show that multivariate (e.g. structural equation) models can dynamically account for cross‐lags, and simultaneously address additional bias induced by measurement error, but only if the analysis considers multiple time series. We provide guidance on how to identify a cross‐lag and subsequently specify it in a multivariate model, which can be far from trivial. Our tutorials with data and R code of the worked examples provide step‐by‐step instructions on how to perform such analyses. Our study offers insights into situations in which cross‐lags can bias analysis of ecological and evolutionary time series and suggests that adopting dynamical models can be important, as this directly affects our understanding of population regulation, the evolution of life histories and cooperation, and possibly many other topics. Determining how strong estimation bias due to ignoring covariate endogeneity has been in the ecological literature requires further study, also because it may interact with other sources of bias.