LBLuciane Maria Both

Luciane Maria Both

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Luciane Maria Both has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Rethinking School Violence: Narrative and Empathic Transformation among Educators in a Psychoanalytic Group Program

    by Carlos Augusto Ferrari Filho, Luciane Both, Lucia Helena Freitas

    School violence in early childhood education poses complex challenges for educators, particularly in contexts of social vulnerability. This study presents findings from the implementation of Psychoanalytically Oriented Conversation Circles (RCOP, from the Portuguese Rodas de Conversa de Orientação Psicanalítica), a group-based continuing education method conducted through an interinstitutional partnership between the Municipal Secretariat of Education of Porto Alegre (SMED, from the Portuguese Secretaria Municipal de Educação) and the Porto Alegre Psychoanalytic Society (SPPA), in use since 2007. Adopting a naturalistic qualitative design, this study explored how a single group of early childhood educators, participating in eight weekly 90-min RCOP meetings, made sense of endemic school violence. All meetings were video-recorded with informed consent; the second through seventh meetings were transcribed verbatim and submitted to inductive thematic content analysis, following Bardin's methodological framework. Findings revealed a shift in educators' understanding of violence, from an initial, simplistic view attributing it exclusively to factors external to the classroom, toward a broader, more integrative comprehension of the phenomenon. This shift was accompanied by a progressive development of empathy toward the families, schools, and limited external resources involved, which was associated with increased self-esteem and pedagogical creativity among the educators. These findings are discussed in light of psychoanalytic and competency-based theoretical frameworks. Future research employing longitudinal designs is recommended to assess whether these narrative and empathic gains are sustained over time and translate into observable classroom practices.

  • Open Access

    Psychodynamic Functioning in Complex Trauma: a Case Study

    by Tais Cristina Favaretto, Luciane Maria Both, Luis Francisco Ramos-Lima, Lucia Helena Machado Freitas

    Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (C-PTSD) leads to problems in different areas of life, suffering and comorbidities. The aim of the research is to evaluate a female patient with C-PTSD using OPD-2, seeking to understand the psychodynamic functioning and possible changes after four months of treatment. The instruments used were Sociodemographic Questionnaire, CAPS-5, DSQ-40, SRQ-20 and OPD-2. The results follow. The patient presented slight psychological change, maintaining intense subjective suffering. In CAPS-5: 45 and 27 points, at Times 0 and 1, respectively, with reduction in symptoms but maintaining diagnosis of C-PTSD; DSQ-40: diversified use of all levels of immature, neurotic and mature defenses; SRQ-20: score decreased from 16 and then 8; OPD-2: reduction in physical symptoms, with predominance of intense subjective suffering, dependence and isolation. Change in intrapsychic conflict was observed. However, the patient continued seeking attention and demanding care. The patient’s psychic structure level shifted from low to medium, with a slight increase in the understanding of mental states. Conclusion: The patient's psychic organization underwent a small change. The complexity of the disorder and the need for treatments focused on the psychic structure are observed. OPD-2 brought relevant information for the psychodynamic assessment of the C-PTSD patient, as well as the understanding of the perpetuation of trauma in her life cycle. Furthermore, the patient presented good communication with other instruments.


  • Open Access

    Relationship between psychodynamic functioning, defensive mechanisms and trauma in patients with PTSD

    by Taís Cristina Favaretto, Luciane Maria Both, Silvia Pereira da Cruz Benetti, Lúcia Helena Machado Freitas

    Trends Psychiatry Psychother, vol.0, nAheadOfPrint, p.0-0, 2023


  • Open Access

    Understanding the psychodynamic functioning of patients with PTSD and CPTSD: qualitative analysis from the OPD 2 interview

    by Taís Cristina Favaretto, Luciane Maria Both, Sílvia Pereira da Cruz Benetti, Lúcia Helena Machado Freitas

    The traumatic event produces intolerable excitations to the psychic apparatus that searches to relief them through the production of symptoms. When established, patients with post-traumatic stress disorders (PTSD) and complex post-traumatic stress disorder (CPTSD) may experience flashbacks, somatizations, negative emotions about themselves, and difficulty in social contact. This work seeks to understand how the psychodynamic functioning of women victims of interpersonal and urban violence, diagnosed with these disorders, is organized, identifying traumatic experiences, ways of interpersonal relationships, conflicts and psychic structures and use of defense mechanisms, and for peculiarities that may differentiate these disorders. The qualitative transversal method was used through the content analysis of clinical interviews based on the Operationalized Psychodynamic Diagnosis (OPD-2). The sample of this study consisted of five women with PTSD and five with CPTSD. The following categories were created: reasons for seeking care, symptoms and desire for treatment, traumatic developmental events, and characteristics of the psychic functioning. Early trauma generates psychic organizations with greater disintegration. A new traumatic event destabilizes the psychic organization and intensifies symptoms. Relationships were marked by dependence and isolation. Participants with CPTSD presented tendency to disintegration related to the object relation regulation and the psychic conflict was of Individuation versus Dependence, with more primitive flaws in object representations, existential need for the other and direct discharge of impulses. Participants with PTSD had moderate to low level of object relation integration and the conflict was need to be care of versus self-sufficiency, with self-representations being fragile and with reduced capacity to manage impulses. Thus, it could be observed that OPD-2 is capable of assessing in a broad and deep way patients with traumatic disorders, in addition to identifying essential peculiarities to guide health professionals towards treatment in the search for better quality of life for patients.


  • Violent situations during the COVID-19 pandemic

    by Luciane Maria Both, Rafaela Silva Santi, Natália Kerber, Gustavo Zoratto, Taís Cristina Favaretto, Cleonice Zatti, Vitor Crestani Calegaro, Lúcia Helena Freitas


  • Open Access

    COVID-19 pandemic and social distancing: economic, psychological, family, and technological effects

    by Luciane Maria Both, Gustavo Zoratto, Vitor Crestani Calegaro, Luis Francisco Ramos-Lima, Bianca Lorenzi Negretto, Simone Hauck, Lúcia Helena Machado Freitas

    The concept of social isolation is currently understood as a measure of epidemiological containment that aims to reduce the speed of spread of the disease, enabling health services to prepare their resources to cope with the likely increase in demand, while also seeking to provide additional protection to groups considered to be at higher risk. The present narrative review aims to compile and synthesize the literature related to social isolation produced during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. This study is a narrative review of the literature on social isolation in the context of the COVID- 19 pandemic. 73 publications were included for full-text reading and were classified into the following categories: levels of social isolation, economic effects, family relationships, health system, mental health of the population, and use of technology. It is necessary to plan an escalation of responses to the consequences of the pandemic, especially in view of the increased demand on the health sector and social services. The negative effects of social isolation can be prevented by public policies that offer a response to the economic recession, maintenance of social work, encouragement of quality care in mental health services, and community support for vulnerable families.


  • Open Access

    Intimate partner violence against women: Operationalized Psychodynamic Diagnosis (OPD-2)

    by Luciane Maria Both, Taís Cristina Favaretto, Lúcia Helena Machado Freitas, Sílvia Pereira da Cruz Benetti, Carla Crempien

    Introduction Intimate partner violence against women is one of the most common forms of violence. Different research fields are trying to understand the cycle of violence, such as the psychological field, to understand how these women's relational patterns and intrapsychic conflict function in the cycle of violence. Objective To investigate the operationalized psychodynamic diagnosis of women victims of domestic violence, exploring the severity and experience of violence, structural functions, dysfunctional interpersonal patterns, and intrapsychic conflicts. Method We conducted a cross-sectional quantitative study using the OPD-2 Clinical Interviews, which were recorded and transcribed. The sample was composed by 56 women victims of domestic violence, mean age 30.07 (SD = +/- 9.65). Reliability was satisfactory for judges interviews(k>0,6). Results According to the OPD-2 evaluation, we found that the severity of the violence was associated with the intensity of women's subjective suffering. In the relational pattern, they stay in the relationship, leaving themselves vulnerable; perceive the partner as controlling, aggressive, offensive, and fear abandonment. As a defensive mechanism to relational discomfort and suffering victims anticipate the aggressor's desire, resulting in submissive behavior. The main psychic conflict was the "need for care versus self-sufficiency" (78.6%). And medium was the predominant structure level, in which they presented insecure internal objects, presenting difficulties in emotional regulation and perceiving reality in a distorted way. Hence, they do not recognize their limitations and needs. We found that 78.6% of the cases had some psychiatric disorder: MDD, PTSD. Conclusion This study provides empirical evidence on clinical observations on the psychological functioning of this population and the issues that make up the maintenance of domestic violence against women. The understanding of internalized patterns, structural functions, and motivational tensions are fundamental for the prevention of re-victimization and improving coping mechanisms, as well as promoting greater adherence to treatment.


  • Open Access

    Cycle of violence in women victims of domestic violence: Qualitative analysis of OPD 2 interview

    by Luciane Maria Both, Taís Cristina Favaretto, Lúcia Helena Machado Freitas

    Introduction: Domestic violence places woman as the victim and man as the aggressor in the family environment. There is limited consistent and clear information based on empirical evidence on the dynamic functioning of the victims.Objective: To further understand the psychodynamics of women in the cycle of violence taking into account the aspects of psychological trauma. It is transversal research design. The sample was composed of ten women victim of domestic violence. Data collection was based on the OPD‐2 Clinical Interview. Content analysis was performed from categories created by a posteriori: (a) Previous history; (b) Behavioral aspects; (c) Emotional aspects; (d) Reason for being in the relationship; (e) Type of violence and explanation for the reason of violence; (f) Support network and daily activities; and (g) Clinical and legal referral.Results: Constant violence causes changes in the structural functioning and psychological conflict of the victims: difficulties in mentalization, instability in relationships, emotional dependence, abandonment of her own life for her partners, difficulty in having a sense of identity. Victims presented difficulties in making significant changes in daily life to break the cycle of violence.Conclusion: The research sought to collaborate with more evidence on the subject, suggesting a reformulation on forms of encounter to break the cycle of violence.


  • Open Access

    Cross-cultural adaptation of the Module for Assessment of Domestic Violence, adapted from Axis I of the Operationalized Psychodynamic Diagnosis (OPD-2), with a sample of Brazilian women, victims of domestic violence

    by Luciane Maria Both, Taís Cristina Favaretto, Lúcia Helena Machado Freitas, Carla Crempien

    Introduction: Intimate partner domestic violence against women causes physical and psychological harm to victims. The relevance of this topic is indisputable and there is a need to identify in greater detail how these women experience violence, since these factors have considerable clinical implications. Objective: To develop a Portuguese version of the Module for Assessment of Domestic Violence, adapted from Axis I of the Operationalized Psychodynamic Diagnosis (OPD-2), considering content validity and psychometric characteristics. Method: Cross-cultural adaptation was based on guidelines for the process of cross-cultural adaptation of self-report measures. OPD clinical interviews were recorded and transcribed. These interviews were analyzed by two independent judges trained in the OPD-2. Results: The sample comprised 56 women who had been victims of domestic violence, with a mean age of 30.07 years (standard deviation = 9.65). The adapted version has content validity and good psychometric characteristics. Evaluation of semantic equivalence took into account the psychodynamic references, using the same ideas as the original instrument. Interexaminer reliability between the judges was substantial (k = 0.63) and Cronbach's alpha for the new version indicates good reliability. Conclusion: The OPD-2 offers a psychodynamic diagnosis of the victim that complements traditional nosological diagnosis, particularly in the context of domestic violence with the adaptation of Axis I. Certain biases could have been detrimental to aspects of this study, but they were controlled. The study objective was achieved and the Module was successfully adapted to Brazilian Portuguese. The results are in line with those of the original study.