Thomas M. Evans
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Thomas M. Evans has a total of 60 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Lars G. Rudstam
Cornell University
3 shared publications - David M. Warner
U.S. Geological Survey, Great Lakes Science Center
2 shared publications - Hannah B. Blair
Cornell University, Department of Natural Resources and the Environment, Ithaca, United States
2 shared publications James E. Bauer
Aquatic Biogeochemistry Laboratory, Department of Evolution, Ecology and Organismal Biology The Ohio State University Columbus Ohio
2 shared publications- James M. Watkins
Cornell Biological Field Station at Shackelton Point, Ashley School of Global Development and the Environment, Cornell University, Bridgeport, USA
2 shared publications - Karin E. Limburg
Department of Environmental Biology, State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry, Syracuse (New York), US
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 83, 1-13
Availability of dark daytime refuge may limit mysid abundance in the Laurentian Great Lakes
The zooplankton Mysis diluviana is a major component of the Laurentian Great Lakes food web and has recently declined in abundance in both lakes Michigan and Huron. The drivers of these declines are not well understood. Here, we explore the hypothesis that recent increases in water clarity have contributed to the decline of M. diluviana (mysids) by limiting the availability of daytime dark refuge from visual predators. Using Secchi depth data from 1996-2021, we estimate that dark refuge has decreased substantially in lakes Michigan and Huron where mysids have declined, but dark refuge has remained more stable in Ontario and Superior where mysid populations did not decline. Results from a 2021 uncrewed surface vessel hydroacoustic survey and lake-wide net-based sampling in lakes Michigan and Huron revealed significantly more mysids in areas with dark refuge, such as Lake Michigan's northern basin. Conversely, Lake Huron contains sparse dark refuge consistent with low mysid densities in that lake. Higher water clarity leading to increased predation may be a primary driver of mysid declines in the Great Lakes.
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 83, 1-13
Open AccessAvailability of dark daytime refuge may limit mysid abundance in the Laurentian Great Lakes
The zooplankton Mysis diluviana is a major component of the Laurentian Great Lakes food web and has recently declined in abundance in both lakes Michigan and Huron. The drivers of these declines are not well understood. Here, we explore the hypothesis that recent increases in water clarity have contributed to the decline of M. diluviana (mysids) by limiting the availability of daytime dark refuge from visual predators. Using Secchi depth data from 1996-2021, we estimate that dark refuge has decreased substantially in lakes Michigan and Huron where mysids have declined, but dark refuge has remained more stable in Ontario and Superior where mysid populations did not decline. Results from a 2021 uncrewed surface vessel hydroacoustic survey and lake-wide net-based sampling in lakes Michigan and Huron revealed significantly more mysids in areas with dark refuge, such as Lake Michigan's northern basin. Conversely, Lake Huron contains sparse dark refuge consistent with low mysid densities in that lake. Higher water clarity leading to increased predation may be a primary driver of mysid declines in the Great Lakes.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 81 (12) , 1740-1751
Paired comparisons with quiet surface drones show evidence of fish behavioral response to motorized vessels during acoustic surveys in Lake Superior
Acoustic surveys are important for fish stock assessments, but fish responses to survey vessels can bias acoustic estimates. We leveraged quiet uncrewed surface vessels (USVs) to characterize potential bias in acoustic surveys. Five conventional motorized ships overtook USVs from astern over 2 km transects at night in Lake Superior in 2022. We examined the difference in acoustic backscatter, average target depth, and average target strength (TS) between USV and motorized vessels. Although sound level measurements from the motorized vessels sometimes exceeded recommendations for scientific vessels, we did not detect differences in acoustic measures among survey vessels. However, the USVs recorded 2 dB higher acoustic backscatter and TS than motorized vessels, leading to ∼15% higher fish densities with drones when using in situ TS and echo integration. Differences in fish density would increase to 30%–60% if a standard TS value was applied. Target depth did not differ between USVs and motorized ships. These results are consistent with a change in orientation but not depth of insonified fish and limited horizontal avoidance of motorized survey vessels.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 81 (12) , 1740-1751
Open AccessPaired comparisons with quiet surface drones show evidence of fish behavioral response to motorized vessels during acoustic surveys in Lake Superior
Acoustic surveys are important for fish stock assessments, but fish responses to survey vessels can bias acoustic estimates. We leveraged quiet uncrewed surface vessels (USVs) to characterize potential bias in acoustic surveys. Five conventional motorized ships overtook USVs from astern over 2 km transects at night in Lake Superior in 2022. We examined the difference in acoustic backscatter, average target depth, and average target strength (TS) between USV and motorized vessels. Although sound level measurements from the motorized vessels sometimes exceeded recommendations for scientific vessels, we did not detect differences in acoustic measures among survey vessels. However, the USVs recorded 2 dB higher acoustic backscatter and TS than motorized vessels, leading to ∼15% higher fish densities with drones when using in situ TS and echo integration. Differences in fish density would increase to 30%–60% if a standard TS value was applied. Target depth did not differ between USVs and motorized ships. These results are consistent with a change in orientation but not depth of insonified fish and limited horizontal avoidance of motorized survey vessels.
- 11 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Biology of Fishes
- Vol. 107 (10) , 1155-1169
Peering into the eye of the sea lamprey: what can stable isotopes in lamprey eye lenses reveal about their life history?
- 11 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Biology of Fishes
- Vol. 107 (10) , 1155-1169
Peering into the eye of the sea lamprey: what can stable isotopes in lamprey eye lenses reveal about their life history?
- Open Access
- 11 January 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (1) , e0286535
Are lipids always depleted? Comparison of hydrogen, carbon, and nitrogen isotopic values in the muscle and lipid of larval lampreys
Stable isotope ratios in organisms can be used to estimate dietary source contributions, but lipids must first be accounted for to interpret values meaningfully. Lipids are depleted in heavy isotopes because during lipid synthesis light isotopes of carbon (12C) and hydrogen (1H) are preferentially incorporated. Prior work in larval lampreys has noted unusual lipid effects, which suggest lipids are enriched in the heavy isotope of carbon (13C), but still depleted in the heavy isotope of hydrogen (deuterium; 2H); nitrogen, a relatively rare element in lipids, has not been identified as being as sensitive to lipid content. Our objective was to determine if stable isotope ratios of hydrogen, carbon, and nitrogen behaved as expected in larval lampreys, or if their lipids presented different isotopic behavior. The δ2H, δ13C, and δ15N were measured from the muscle of four lamprey species before and after lipid extraction. In addition, muscle of least brook lamprey (Lampetra aepyptera) was collected every three months for a year from two streams in Maryland. Isotopic ratios were measured in bulk and lipid-extracted muscles, as well as in extracted lipids. The difference between muscle samples before and after lipid extraction (Δδ2H, Δδ13C, Δδ15N) was positively related to lipid proxy (%H or C:N ratio) and were fit best by linear models for Δδ2H and Δδ15N, and by a non-linear model for Δδ13C. The difference between lipid-extracted muscle and lipid δ13C (ΔMLδ13C) was negative and varied between months (ANOVA, F3,53 = 5.05, p < 0.005). Our work suggests that while lipids are often depleted in 13C, this is not a universal rule; however, the depletion of 2H in lipid synthesis appears broadly true.
- 11 January 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (1) , e0286535
Open AccessAre lipids always depleted? Comparison of hydrogen, carbon, and nitrogen isotopic values in the muscle and lipid of larval lampreys
Stable isotope ratios in organisms can be used to estimate dietary source contributions, but lipids must first be accounted for to interpret values meaningfully. Lipids are depleted in heavy isotopes because during lipid synthesis light isotopes of carbon (12C) and hydrogen (1H) are preferentially incorporated. Prior work in larval lampreys has noted unusual lipid effects, which suggest lipids are enriched in the heavy isotope of carbon (13C), but still depleted in the heavy isotope of hydrogen (deuterium; 2H); nitrogen, a relatively rare element in lipids, has not been identified as being as sensitive to lipid content. Our objective was to determine if stable isotope ratios of hydrogen, carbon, and nitrogen behaved as expected in larval lampreys, or if their lipids presented different isotopic behavior. The δ2H, δ13C, and δ15N were measured from the muscle of four lamprey species before and after lipid extraction. In addition, muscle of least brook lamprey (Lampetra aepyptera) was collected every three months for a year from two streams in Maryland. Isotopic ratios were measured in bulk and lipid-extracted muscles, as well as in extracted lipids. The difference between muscle samples before and after lipid extraction (Δδ2H, Δδ13C, Δδ15N) was positively related to lipid proxy (%H or C:N ratio) and were fit best by linear models for Δδ2H and Δδ15N, and by a non-linear model for Δδ13C. The difference between lipid-extracted muscle and lipid δ13C (ΔMLδ13C) was negative and varied between months (ANOVA, F3,53 = 5.05, p < 0.005). Our work suggests that while lipids are often depleted in 13C, this is not a universal rule; however, the depletion of 2H in lipid synthesis appears broadly true.
- Open Access
- 24 April 2023
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 18 (4) , e0284933
Round goby (Neogobius melanostomus) δ13C/δ15N discrimination values and comparisons of diets from gut content and stable isotopes in Oneida Lake
Gut content analyses have found that round gobies (Neogobius melanostomus) are highly dependent on dreissenid mussels but stable isotope analysis has often suggested that the dreissenid contribution is lower. However, estimation of dietary contributions with stable isotopes relies on accurate discrimination factors (fractionation factors). To test if discrimination values commonly used in aquatic food web studies are suitable for round gobies, we collected round gobies from Oneida Lake, raised them for 63 days under four different diets (Chironomus plumosus, Mytilus chilensis, Dreissenia spp., Euphausia superba) and measured the change in white muscle δ13C and δ15N. Gobies were also collected throughout Oneida Lake for gut content and stable isotope analysis. Diets changed as round gobies grew, with small round gobies (17-42mm) feeding mostly on cladocera and chironomids, intermediate sized gobies (43-94mm) transitioning from chironomid to dreissenid consumption, and larger gobies (95-120mm) predominantly consuming dreissenids, similar to findings in other studies. Discrimination factors were obtained by fitting a commonly used asymptotic regression equation describing changes in fish δ13C and δ15N as a function of time and diet stable isotope ratios. The discrimination factor determined for δ13C (-0.4‰ ± 0.32, SE) was lower than the “standard” value of 0.4‰, while that of δ15N (4.0‰ ± 0.32, SE) was higher than the standard value of 3.4‰. Turnover rates for both δ13C and δ15N were estimated as 0.02 ‰*day-1. The use of experimentally determined discrimination factors rather than “standard” values resulted in model estimates that agree more closely with the observed increasing importance of dreissenids in gut content of larger gobies. Our results suggest that the importance of dreissenid mussels inferred from stable isotope studies may be underestimated when using standard isotopic discrimination values.
- 24 April 2023
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 18 (4) , e0284933
Open AccessRound goby (Neogobius melanostomus) δ13C/δ15N discrimination values and comparisons of diets from gut content and stable isotopes in Oneida Lake
Gut content analyses have found that round gobies (Neogobius melanostomus) are highly dependent on dreissenid mussels but stable isotope analysis has often suggested that the dreissenid contribution is lower. However, estimation of dietary contributions with stable isotopes relies on accurate discrimination factors (fractionation factors). To test if discrimination values commonly used in aquatic food web studies are suitable for round gobies, we collected round gobies from Oneida Lake, raised them for 63 days under four different diets (Chironomus plumosus, Mytilus chilensis, Dreissenia spp., Euphausia superba) and measured the change in white muscle δ13C and δ15N. Gobies were also collected throughout Oneida Lake for gut content and stable isotope analysis. Diets changed as round gobies grew, with small round gobies (17-42mm) feeding mostly on cladocera and chironomids, intermediate sized gobies (43-94mm) transitioning from chironomid to dreissenid consumption, and larger gobies (95-120mm) predominantly consuming dreissenids, similar to findings in other studies. Discrimination factors were obtained by fitting a commonly used asymptotic regression equation describing changes in fish δ13C and δ15N as a function of time and diet stable isotope ratios. The discrimination factor determined for δ13C (-0.4‰ ± 0.32, SE) was lower than the “standard” value of 0.4‰, while that of δ15N (4.0‰ ± 0.32, SE) was higher than the standard value of 3.4‰. Turnover rates for both δ13C and δ15N were estimated as 0.02 ‰*day-1. The use of experimentally determined discrimination factors rather than “standard” values resulted in model estimates that agree more closely with the observed increasing importance of dreissenids in gut content of larger gobies. Our results suggest that the importance of dreissenid mussels inferred from stable isotope studies may be underestimated when using standard isotopic discrimination values.
- Open Access
- 29 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Are lipids always light? Lipids in larval lampreys are enriched in 13C but depleted in 2H relative to muscle
Stable isotope ratios in organisms can be used to estimate source contributions to the organism. However, during lipid synthesis light isotopes of carbon (12C) and hydrogen (1H) are preferentially incorporated into the lipids, potentially causing source contributions to be poorly estimated. Contrary to expectations and other published examples in animals, larval lampreys, which are basal vertebrates, have lipids which are enriched in heavy isotopes of carbon (13C), but still depleted in heavy hydrogen (deuterium;2H). Four lamprey species were collected and their isotopes ratios of δ2H, δ13C, δ15N were measured in their muscle before and after lipid extraction. Larval lamprey of one species was collected every three months for a year from two streams in Maryland and the isotope ratios of muscle before and after lipid extraction, as well as the extracted lipid were measured. Muscle δ13C was positively related to C:N ratios in samples when lipids were not removed and δ2H was negatively associated with the percent hydrogen in a sample. As expected, the measured difference between muscle and lipid δ2H (ΔMLδ2H) was the same for all months and was 111‰ (SE = ± 21, n = 35), but the ΔMLδ13C was different between months (ANOVA, F3,53= 5.05, p < 0.005) and was always negative. Our work suggests that while lipids are often enriched in12C relative to muscle, this is not a universal rule. The physiological mechanism(s) for generating heavy carbon-backbones in lipids remains unknown and requires exploration.
- 29 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessAre lipids always light? Lipids in larval lampreys are enriched in 13C but depleted in 2H relative to muscle
Stable isotope ratios in organisms can be used to estimate source contributions to the organism. However, during lipid synthesis light isotopes of carbon (12C) and hydrogen (1H) are preferentially incorporated into the lipids, potentially causing source contributions to be poorly estimated. Contrary to expectations and other published examples in animals, larval lampreys, which are basal vertebrates, have lipids which are enriched in heavy isotopes of carbon (13C), but still depleted in heavy hydrogen (deuterium;2H). Four lamprey species were collected and their isotopes ratios of δ2H, δ13C, δ15N were measured in their muscle before and after lipid extraction. Larval lamprey of one species was collected every three months for a year from two streams in Maryland and the isotope ratios of muscle before and after lipid extraction, as well as the extracted lipid were measured. Muscle δ13C was positively related to C:N ratios in samples when lipids were not removed and δ2H was negatively associated with the percent hydrogen in a sample. As expected, the measured difference between muscle and lipid δ2H (ΔMLδ2H) was the same for all months and was 111‰ (SE = ± 21, n = 35), but the ΔMLδ13C was different between months (ANOVA, F3,53= 5.05, p < 0.005) and was always negative. Our work suggests that while lipids are often enriched in12C relative to muscle, this is not a universal rule. The physiological mechanism(s) for generating heavy carbon-backbones in lipids remains unknown and requires exploration.
- 24 February 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in North American Journal of Fisheries Management
- Vol. 42 (2) , 455-474
Sampling Methods and Survey Designs for Larval Lampreys
Knowledge of the biology, distribution, and abundance of lampreys (Petromyzontiformes) is critical to inform conservation actions for native species and to inform control measures for the invasive Sea Lamprey Petromyzon marinus of the Laurentian Great Lakes. Lampreys have complex life cycles that include a freshwater larval stage in which they burrow into substrates consisting of fine sediment and organic matter. The larval stage is frequently targeted in research and monitoring; given this interest, a review of survey designs and methods is needed. Our review identified 12 different sampling methods for larval lampreys and focused on one common method—backpack electrofishing in wadeable habitats. Our review also identified eight research and monitoring questions that have been addressed for larval lampreys in field studies, including distribution, species identification, life stage occurrence, abundance, length frequency, habitat use, residence and movement phenology, and species status. Each question provides unique information and poses distinct challenges to data acquisition and interpretation. The objectives guide decisions about study design and scope of inference. The scope of inference is determined by the size, spatial distribution, selection method, and number of sampling units within and across habitats, which determine the spatial and temporal scales under which results can be interpreted. The sampling unit size can span orders of magnitude from microhabitats to river drainages, ultimately informing management decisions at several spatial scales. The intended scope of inference and the interaction between biological questions and the fiscal and logistical capabilities of the study are integral considerations when designing an effective larval lamprey survey.
- 24 February 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in North American Journal of Fisheries Management
- Vol. 42 (2) , 455-474
Sampling Methods and Survey Designs for Larval Lampreys
Knowledge of the biology, distribution, and abundance of lampreys (Petromyzontiformes) is critical to inform conservation actions for native species and to inform control measures for the invasive Sea Lamprey Petromyzon marinus of the Laurentian Great Lakes. Lampreys have complex life cycles that include a freshwater larval stage in which they burrow into substrates consisting of fine sediment and organic matter. The larval stage is frequently targeted in research and monitoring; given this interest, a review of survey designs and methods is needed. Our review identified 12 different sampling methods for larval lampreys and focused on one common method—backpack electrofishing in wadeable habitats. Our review also identified eight research and monitoring questions that have been addressed for larval lampreys in field studies, including distribution, species identification, life stage occurrence, abundance, length frequency, habitat use, residence and movement phenology, and species status. Each question provides unique information and poses distinct challenges to data acquisition and interpretation. The objectives guide decisions about study design and scope of inference. The scope of inference is determined by the size, spatial distribution, selection method, and number of sampling units within and across habitats, which determine the spatial and temporal scales under which results can be interpreted. The sampling unit size can span orders of magnitude from microhabitats to river drainages, ultimately informing management decisions at several spatial scales. The intended scope of inference and the interaction between biological questions and the fiscal and logistical capabilities of the study are integral considerations when designing an effective larval lamprey survey.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 79 (1) , 183-194
Size spectra analysis of a decade of Laurentian Great Lakes data
Size spectra analysis (SSA) is used to detect changes in food webs by simplifying complex community structures through abundance-versus-biomass considerations. We applied SSA to 10 years (2006–2015) of data on Great Lakes organisms ranging in size from picoplankton to macrozooplankton. Summer pelagic size spectra slopes were near the theoretical value of −1.0, but spring slopes were steeper, reflecting seasonal differences in abundance of small and large individuals. Pelagic size spectra slopes were relatively stable over the time period we examined. Height (the predicted number of organisms at the spectra midpoint) varied among lakes and was slightly higher in summer than spring in more productive basins. Including benthic data led to shallower slopes when combined with pelagic data, suggesting benthic organisms may increase food web efficiency; height was less affected by benthic data. Benthic data are not routinely included in SSA, but our results suggest they affect slopes and therefore SSA-based predictions of fish abundance. The ability of SSA to track changes in trophic energy transfer makes it a valuable ecosystem monitoring tool.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 79 (1) , 183-194
Size spectra analysis of a decade of Laurentian Great Lakes data
Size spectra analysis (SSA) is used to detect changes in food webs by simplifying complex community structures through abundance-versus-biomass considerations. We applied SSA to 10 years (2006–2015) of data on Great Lakes organisms ranging in size from picoplankton to macrozooplankton. Summer pelagic size spectra slopes were near the theoretical value of −1.0, but spring slopes were steeper, reflecting seasonal differences in abundance of small and large individuals. Pelagic size spectra slopes were relatively stable over the time period we examined. Height (the predicted number of organisms at the spectra midpoint) varied among lakes and was slightly higher in summer than spring in more productive basins. Including benthic data led to shallower slopes when combined with pelagic data, suggesting benthic organisms may increase food web efficiency; height was less affected by benthic data. Benthic data are not routinely included in SSA, but our results suggest they affect slopes and therefore SSA-based predictions of fish abundance. The ability of SSA to track changes in trophic energy transfer makes it a valuable ecosystem monitoring tool.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 77 (1) , 81-89
Multiple stable isotopes identify sediment organic matter as the primary nutritional source to American brook lamprey larvae along a stream gradient
Multiple stable isotope ratios (δ2H, δ13C, δ15N, and δ34S) of American brook lamprey (Lethenteron appendix) ammocoetes and their potential sources were measured along a stream gradient. Isotopic ratios were successful at differentiating three potential sources: terrestrial organic matter (TOM; upland plants), sediment organic matter (SOM; benthic organic material), and algae. Bayesian mixing models (MixSIAR) utilizing δ13C, δ15N, and δ34S estimated ammocoetes were highly reliant on SOM at all sites (>95%), but inclusion of δ2H increased the importance of both algae and model uncertainty. Ammocoete δ2H was more depleted than anticipated even after lipid extraction and after accounting for trophic water contributions, suggesting δ2H in consumer tissues (especially for long-lived animals) is still incompletely understood. Model sensitivity testing with trophic fractionation values did not substantially change the results. Regardless of the mixing model investigated, none indicated more algae in ammocoete diets in downstream rather than upstream sites, in contrast with expectations about river productivity. Stable isotopes suggest SOM, and not algae, is nutritionally most important to ammocoetes, even in downstream reaches of rivers.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
- Vol. 77 (1) , 81-89
Multiple stable isotopes identify sediment organic matter as the primary nutritional source to American brook lamprey larvae along a stream gradient
Multiple stable isotope ratios (δ2H, δ13C, δ15N, and δ34S) of American brook lamprey (Lethenteron appendix) ammocoetes and their potential sources were measured along a stream gradient. Isotopic ratios were successful at differentiating three potential sources: terrestrial organic matter (TOM; upland plants), sediment organic matter (SOM; benthic organic material), and algae. Bayesian mixing models (MixSIAR) utilizing δ13C, δ15N, and δ34S estimated ammocoetes were highly reliant on SOM at all sites (>95%), but inclusion of δ2H increased the importance of both algae and model uncertainty. Ammocoete δ2H was more depleted than anticipated even after lipid extraction and after accounting for trophic water contributions, suggesting δ2H in consumer tissues (especially for long-lived animals) is still incompletely understood. Model sensitivity testing with trophic fractionation values did not substantially change the results. Regardless of the mixing model investigated, none indicated more algae in ammocoete diets in downstream rather than upstream sites, in contrast with expectations about river productivity. Stable isotopes suggest SOM, and not algae, is nutritionally most important to ammocoetes, even in downstream reaches of rivers.
- 25 April 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 32 (8) , 794-805
Parasitism offers large rewards but carries high risks: Predicting parasitic strategies under different life history conditions in lampreys
The loss of parasitism in metazoan lineages is often seen as unlikely, but it has occurred in some lineages (e.g., leeches, lampreys). How and why parasitism is lost is aptly addressed by studying lampreys, because extant species include a range of feeding modes and parasitism has been lost repeatedly. An individual‐based model was developed to determine whether variations in survival and growth rates in the larval and juvenile stages could favour parasitic or nonparasitic strategies. A realization of the model for a Lampetra spp. population, a genus which includes parasitic and nonparasitic animals, indicated that both strategies could be successful. A different model realization of the nonparasitic species Lethenteron appendix also agreed with expectations, and only nonparasitic strategies were successful. Modelling anadromous Petromyzon marinus produced only parasitic animals, as expected, but suggested two different adult sizes should appear in the population, which has not been reported in the literature. Finally, a realization of an Ichthyomyzon castaneus population, known to be parasitic only, rarely selected for parasitism (c. 7% of model iterations), possibly because the population used to parameterize the model was unusual for the species. The results suggest that nonparasitic lineages in lampreys are common because parasitism, while offering better growth, also has lower survival. Additionally, nonparasitic species may be generated at different rates because growth and survival thresholds in the model favouring parasitism are close to observed estimates in some populations. Loss of parasitism can occur when life stages have different trade‐offs in growth and survivability.
- 25 April 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 32 (8) , 794-805
Parasitism offers large rewards but carries high risks: Predicting parasitic strategies under different life history conditions in lampreys
The loss of parasitism in metazoan lineages is often seen as unlikely, but it has occurred in some lineages (e.g., leeches, lampreys). How and why parasitism is lost is aptly addressed by studying lampreys, because extant species include a range of feeding modes and parasitism has been lost repeatedly. An individual‐based model was developed to determine whether variations in survival and growth rates in the larval and juvenile stages could favour parasitic or nonparasitic strategies. A realization of the model for a Lampetra spp. population, a genus which includes parasitic and nonparasitic animals, indicated that both strategies could be successful. A different model realization of the nonparasitic species Lethenteron appendix also agreed with expectations, and only nonparasitic strategies were successful. Modelling anadromous Petromyzon marinus produced only parasitic animals, as expected, but suggested two different adult sizes should appear in the population, which has not been reported in the literature. Finally, a realization of an Ichthyomyzon castaneus population, known to be parasitic only, rarely selected for parasitism (c. 7% of model iterations), possibly because the population used to parameterize the model was unusual for the species. The results suggest that nonparasitic lineages in lampreys are common because parasitism, while offering better growth, also has lower survival. Additionally, nonparasitic species may be generated at different rates because growth and survival thresholds in the model favouring parasitism are close to observed estimates in some populations. Loss of parasitism can occur when life stages have different trade‐offs in growth and survivability.