Frank Lad
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Frank Lad has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Giuseppe Sanfilippo
University of Palermo
2 shared publications - Patrizio Frederic
Department of Economics “Marco Biagi”, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy
2 shared publications - Gianna Agrò
DSEAS, University of Palermo
1 shared publication - Mario Di Bacco
Polo universitario di Asti
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 March 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in AppliedMath
- Vol. 2 (1) , 159-169
Resurrecting the Prospect of Supplementary Variableswith the Principle of Local Realism
I produce a coherent mathematical formulation of the supplementary variables structure for Aspect’s experimental test of Bell’s inequality as devised by Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt, a formalization which has been widely considered to be impossible. Contrary to Aspect’s understanding, it is made clear that a supplementary variable formulation can represent any tendered probability distribution whatsoever. This includes both the QM distribution and the “naive distribution”, which he had suggested as a foil. It has long been known that quantum theory does not support a complete distribution for the components of the thought experiment that underlies the inequality. However, further than that, here I identify precisely the bounding polytope of distributions that do cohere with both its explicit premises and with the prospect of supplementary variables. In this context, it is found once again that every distribution within this polytope respects the conditions of Bell’s inequality, and that the famous evaluation of the gedankenexpectation defying it as is mistaken. The argument is relevant to all subsequent embellishments of experimental methodology post Aspect, designed to block seven declared possible loopholes. The probabilistic prognostications of quantum theory are not denied, nor are the experimental observations. However, their inferential implications have been misrepresented.- 16 March 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in AppliedMath
- Vol. 2 (1) , 159-169
Open AccessResurrecting the Prospect of Supplementary Variableswith the Principle of Local Realism
I produce a coherent mathematical formulation of the supplementary variables structure for Aspect’s experimental test of Bell’s inequality as devised by Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt, a formalization which has been widely considered to be impossible. Contrary to Aspect’s understanding, it is made clear that a supplementary variable formulation can represent any tendered probability distribution whatsoever. This includes both the QM distribution and the “naive distribution”, which he had suggested as a foil. It has long been known that quantum theory does not support a complete distribution for the components of the thought experiment that underlies the inequality. However, further than that, here I identify precisely the bounding polytope of distributions that do cohere with both its explicit premises and with the prospect of supplementary variables. In this context, it is found once again that every distribution within this polytope respects the conditions of Bell’s inequality, and that the famous evaluation of the gedankenexpectation defying it as is mistaken. The argument is relevant to all subsequent embellishments of experimental methodology post Aspect, designed to block seven declared possible loopholes. The probabilistic prognostications of quantum theory are not denied, nor are the experimental observations. However, their inferential implications have been misrepresented. - Open Access
The GHSZ argument: a gedankenexperiment requiring more denken
I reassess the gedankenexperiment of Greenberger, Horne, Shimony and Zeilinger after twenty-five years, finding their influential claim to discovery of an inconsistency inherent in high dimensional formulations of local realism to arise from a fundamental error of logic. They manage this by presuming contradictory premises: that a specific linear combination of four angles involved in their proposed parallel experiments on two pairs of electrons equals both $\pi$ and $0$ at the same time. Ignoring this while presuming the contradictory implications of these two conditions, they introduce the contradiction themselves. The notation they use in their "derivation" is not sufficiently ornate to represent the entanglement in the double electron spin pair problem they design, confounding their error. The situation they propose actually motivates only an understanding of the full array of symmetries involved in their problem. In tandem with the error now recognized in the supposed defiance of Bell's inequality by quantum probabilities, my reassessment of their work should motivate a reevaluation of the current consensus outlook regarding the principle of local realism and the proposition of hidden variables.Open AccessThe GHSZ argument: a gedankenexperiment requiring more denken
I reassess the gedankenexperiment of Greenberger, Horne, Shimony and Zeilinger after twenty-five years, finding their influential claim to discovery of an inconsistency inherent in high dimensional formulations of local realism to arise from a fundamental error of logic. They manage this by presuming contradictory premises: that a specific linear combination of four angles involved in their proposed parallel experiments on two pairs of electrons equals both $\pi$ and $0$ at the same time. Ignoring this while presuming the contradictory implications of these two conditions, they introduce the contradiction themselves. The notation they use in their "derivation" is not sufficiently ornate to represent the entanglement in the double electron spin pair problem they design, confounding their error. The situation they propose actually motivates only an understanding of the full array of symmetries involved in their problem. In tandem with the error now recognized in the supposed defiance of Bell's inequality by quantum probabilities, my reassessment of their work should motivate a reevaluation of the current consensus outlook regarding the principle of local realism and the proposition of hidden variables. - Open Access
Quantum Violation of Bell's Inequality: a misunderstanding based on a mathematical error of neglect
The fabled violation of Bell's inequality by the probabilistic specifications of quantum mechanics is shown to derive from a mathematical error. The inequality, designed to assess consequences of Einstein's principle of local realism, pertains to four polarization products on the same pair of photons arising in a gedankenexperiment. The summands of the CHSH quantity $s(\lambda)$ inhere four symmetric functional relations which have long been neglected in analytic considerations. Its expectation $E[s(\lambda)]$ is not the sum of four ``marginal'' expectations from a joint distribution, as quantum theory explicitly avoids such a specification. Rather, $E[s(\lambda)]$ has four distinct representations as the sum of three expectations of polarization products plus the expectation of a fourth which is restricted to equal a function value determined by the other three. Analysis using Bruno de Finetti's fundamental theorem of prevision (FTP) yields only a bound for $E(s)$ within $(1.1213, 2]$, surely not $2\sqrt{2}$ at all. The 4-D polytope of cohering joint $P_{++}$ probabilities at the four stipulated angle settings are displayed as passing through 3-D space. Aspect's ``estimation'' is based on polarization products from different photon pairs that do not have embedded within them the inhering functional relations. When you do actively embed the restrictions into Aspect's estimation procedure, it yields an estimate of 1.7667, although this is not and cannot be definitive.Open AccessQuantum Violation of Bell's Inequality: a misunderstanding based on a mathematical error of neglect
The fabled violation of Bell's inequality by the probabilistic specifications of quantum mechanics is shown to derive from a mathematical error. The inequality, designed to assess consequences of Einstein's principle of local realism, pertains to four polarization products on the same pair of photons arising in a gedankenexperiment. The summands of the CHSH quantity $s(\lambda)$ inhere four symmetric functional relations which have long been neglected in analytic considerations. Its expectation $E[s(\lambda)]$ is not the sum of four ``marginal'' expectations from a joint distribution, as quantum theory explicitly avoids such a specification. Rather, $E[s(\lambda)]$ has four distinct representations as the sum of three expectations of polarization products plus the expectation of a fourth which is restricted to equal a function value determined by the other three. Analysis using Bruno de Finetti's fundamental theorem of prevision (FTP) yields only a bound for $E(s)$ within $(1.1213, 2]$, surely not $2\sqrt{2}$ at all. The 4-D polytope of cohering joint $P_{++}$ probabilities at the four stipulated angle settings are displayed as passing through 3-D space. Aspect's ``estimation'' is based on polarization products from different photon pairs that do not have embedded within them the inhering functional relations. When you do actively embed the restrictions into Aspect's estimation procedure, it yields an estimate of 1.7667, although this is not and cannot be definitive. - Open Access
The GHSZ Argument: A Gedankenexperiment Requiring More Denken
I reassess the gedankenexperiment of Greenberger, Horne, Shimony, and Zeilinger after twenty-five years, finding their influential claim to the discovery of an inconsistency inherent in high dimensional formulations of local realism to arise from a fundamental error of logic. They manage this by presuming contradictory premises: that a specific linear combination of four angles involved in their proposed parallel experiments on two pairs of electrons equals both and 0 at the same time. Ignoring this while presuming the contradictory implications of these two conditions, they introduce the contradiction themselves. The notation they use in their “derivation” is not sufficiently ornate to represent the entanglement in the double electron spin pair problem they design, confounding their error. The situation they propose actually motivates only an understanding of the full array of symmetries involved in their problem. In tandem with the error now recognised in the supposed defiance of Bell’s inequality by quantum probabilities, my reassessment of their work should motivate a reevaluation of the current consensus outlook regarding the principle of local realism and the proposition of hidden variables.Open AccessThe GHSZ Argument: A Gedankenexperiment Requiring More Denken
I reassess the gedankenexperiment of Greenberger, Horne, Shimony, and Zeilinger after twenty-five years, finding their influential claim to the discovery of an inconsistency inherent in high dimensional formulations of local realism to arise from a fundamental error of logic. They manage this by presuming contradictory premises: that a specific linear combination of four angles involved in their proposed parallel experiments on two pairs of electrons equals both and 0 at the same time. Ignoring this while presuming the contradictory implications of these two conditions, they introduce the contradiction themselves. The notation they use in their “derivation” is not sufficiently ornate to represent the entanglement in the double electron spin pair problem they design, confounding their error. The situation they propose actually motivates only an understanding of the full array of symmetries involved in their problem. In tandem with the error now recognised in the supposed defiance of Bell’s inequality by quantum probabilities, my reassessment of their work should motivate a reevaluation of the current consensus outlook regarding the principle of local realism and the proposition of hidden variables. - 11 May 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Decisions in Economics and Finance
- Vol. 43 (1) , 17-41
Predictive distributions that mimic frequencies over a restricted subdomain
- 11 May 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Decisions in Economics and Finance
- Vol. 43 (1) , 17-41
Predictive distributions that mimic frequencies over a restricted subdomain
- Open Access
The Duality of Entropy/Extropy, and Completion of the Kullback Information Complex
The refinement axiom for entropy has been provocative in providing foundations of information theory, recognised as thoughtworthy in the writings of both Shannon and Jaynes. A resolution to their concerns has been provided recently by the discovery that the entropy measure of a probability distribution has a dual measure, a complementary companion designated as “extropy”. We report here the main results that identify this fact, specifying the dual equations and exhibiting some of their structure. The duality extends beyond a simple assessment of entropy, to the formulation of relative entropy and the Kullback symmetric distance between two forecasting distributions. This is defined by the sum of a pair of directed divergences. Examining the defining equation, we notice that this symmetric measure can be generated by two other explicable pairs of functions as well, neither of which is a Bregman divergence. The Kullback information complex is constituted by the symmetric measure of entropy/extropy along with one of each of these three function pairs. It is intimately related to the total logarithmic score of two distinct forecasting distributions for a quantity under consideration, this being a complete proper score. The information complex is isomorphic to the expectations that the two forecasting distributions assess for their achieved scores, each for its own score and for the score achieved by the other. Analysis of the scoring problem exposes a Pareto optimal exchange of the forecasters’ scores that both are willing to engage. Both would support its evaluation for assessing the relative quality of the information they provide regarding the observation of an unknown quantity of interest. We present our results without proofs, as these appear in source articles that are referenced. The focus here is on their content, unhindered. The mathematical syntax of probability we employ relies upon the operational subjective constructions of Bruno de Finetti.
Open AccessThe Duality of Entropy/Extropy, and Completion of the Kullback Information Complex
The refinement axiom for entropy has been provocative in providing foundations of information theory, recognised as thoughtworthy in the writings of both Shannon and Jaynes. A resolution to their concerns has been provided recently by the discovery that the entropy measure of a probability distribution has a dual measure, a complementary companion designated as “extropy”. We report here the main results that identify this fact, specifying the dual equations and exhibiting some of their structure. The duality extends beyond a simple assessment of entropy, to the formulation of relative entropy and the Kullback symmetric distance between two forecasting distributions. This is defined by the sum of a pair of directed divergences. Examining the defining equation, we notice that this symmetric measure can be generated by two other explicable pairs of functions as well, neither of which is a Bregman divergence. The Kullback information complex is constituted by the symmetric measure of entropy/extropy along with one of each of these three function pairs. It is intimately related to the total logarithmic score of two distinct forecasting distributions for a quantity under consideration, this being a complete proper score. The information complex is isomorphic to the expectations that the two forecasting distributions assess for their achieved scores, each for its own score and for the score achieved by the other. Analysis of the scoring problem exposes a Pareto optimal exchange of the forecasters’ scores that both are willing to engage. Both would support its evaluation for assessing the relative quality of the information they provide regarding the observation of an unknown quantity of interest. We present our results without proofs, as these appear in source articles that are referenced. The focus here is on their content, unhindered. The mathematical syntax of probability we employ relies upon the operational subjective constructions of Bruno de Finetti.
- 14 July 2012
- Published by Springer Nature in Theory and Decision
- Vol. 73 (4) , 605-619
Combining expert probabilities using the product of odds
- 14 July 2012
- Published by Springer Nature in Theory and Decision
- Vol. 73 (4) , 605-619
Combining expert probabilities using the product of odds
- 1 August 2008
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Communications in Statistics - Simulation and Computation
- Vol. 37 (7) , 1263-1269
Two Moments of the Logitnormal Distribution
We display the first two moment functions of the Logitnormal(μ, σ2) family of distributions, conveniently described in terms of the Normal mean, μ, and the Normal signal-to-noise ratio, μ/σ, parameters that generate the family. Long neglected on account of the numerical integrations required to compute them, awareness of these moment functions should aid the sensible interpretation of logistic regression statistics and the specification of “diffuse” prior distributions in hierarchical models, which can be deceiving. We also use numerical integration to compare the correlation between bivariate Logitnormal variables with the correlation between the bivariate Normal variables from which they are transformed.
- 1 August 2008
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Communications in Statistics - Simulation and Computation
- Vol. 37 (7) , 1263-1269
Two Moments of the Logitnormal Distribution
We display the first two moment functions of the Logitnormal(μ, σ2) family of distributions, conveniently described in terms of the Normal mean, μ, and the Normal signal-to-noise ratio, μ/σ, parameters that generate the family. Long neglected on account of the numerical integrations required to compute them, awareness of these moment functions should aid the sensible interpretation of logistic regression statistics and the specification of “diffuse” prior distributions in hierarchical models, which can be deceiving. We also use numerical integration to compare the correlation between bivariate Logitnormal variables with the correlation between the bivariate Normal variables from which they are transformed.
- 1 January 2004
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 153-187
An Example of the Subjectivist Statistical Method for Learning from Data: Why do Whales Strand when They do?
- 1 January 2004
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 153-187
An Example of the Subjectivist Statistical Method for Learning from Data: Why do Whales Strand when They do?