LCLicia Cianetti

Licia Cianetti

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Licia Cianetti has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Here we go again! Repetition and the Politics of Inclusive Institutional Reform

    by Licia Cianetti

    This article introduces repetition as a sui generis temporal pattern that is central to the politics of inclusive institutional reform. Pushed by crises or leadership changes, inclusive reform initiatives spring up in moments of high salience only to die back again and be relaunched later, in a seemingly endless cycle. Drawing from public policy, historical and feminist institutionalist scholarships and the in-depth case studies of Birmingham and Turin city governments’ equalities offices, this article identifies (a) four drivers of repetition, to do with the nature of the problem, the nature of the institution, the nature of the change agents, and repetition’s self-reinforcing nature, and (b) two sets of effects (sedimentation and erosion) which follow concurrent logics of increasing and decreasing returns. Understanding repetition as a specific, non-linear pattern of change eschews teleologies of hope or doom, advancing theories of institutional change and serving as a useful guide for action for equity-driven reformers. It invites other scholars to engage with a new research agenda to systematically identify alternative types of temporal sequence and study their distinct logics and effects.


  • Open Access

    The end of the backsliding paradigm? Avoiding reverse “transitology” in Central and Eastern Europe

    by Licia Cianetti, Sean Hanley

    This paper critiques some of the underlying assumptions of what we call the “backsliding paradigm”. Mirroring Thomas Carothers’s (2002a) famous critique of the “transition paradigm”, we argue that the current debate on democratic regression in Central and Eastern Europe runs the risk of becoming a “reverse transition paradigm” as it presents some of the same limitations. We discuss five such limitations as an invitation for other scholars to engage in debate on how we can study (un) democratic developments in the region in a broader way, accounting for the range of different, complex and even paradoxical trajectories its countries display.


  • Governing the multicultural city: Europe’s ‘great urban expectations’ facing austerity and resurgent nativism

    by Licia Cianetti

    This article analyses European discourses on ‘optimal’ urban inclusion policies, as they are embodied in EU-sponsored city networking initiatives. Drawing from the scholarships on multiculturalism and urban austerity, it builds an inclusion agendas matrix that identifies four ideal-typical agendas for ethnic and racial inclusion: multicultural, diversity inclusion, community cohesion and neoliberalised diversity. It identifies a shift from group-based to individual-based concerns (mainstreaming) and from a politicised to a depoliticised approach to inclusion (depoliticising). It argues that (a) this double shift should be understood as the result of the mutually reinforcing pressures of nativism and austerity, and (b) inconsistencies in network discourses and policy advice suggest a pragmatic-adaptive logic that challenges simplistic understandings of cities as either (only) sites of resistance or (only) sites of full-blown accommodation of nativist and austerity imperatives.


  • Open Access

    The Crisis of Multiculturalism in Europe: A History, by Rita Chin, Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 2017, $34.78 (hardcover), ISBN 9780691164267

    by Licia Cianetti

    The question of what happened to the European dream of harmonious multicultural societies is not new, but has acquired a special urgency in recent years. With nativist and xenophobic rhetoric sweeping through European societies-north and south, east and west-this has become a vital question for European democracy. Rita Chin's history of the crisis of multiculturalism in Europe provides solid bases to start answering it. In a period in which analyses of the rise of far-right populism risk being overly focused on the present, The Crisis of Multiculturalism in Europe provides a much-needed historical account of the longer-term contestations around the idea of multiculturalism and the ways in which the widespread consensus on multiculturalism's "failure" came to dominate European public debate. By giving us a clearer understanding of the past, Chin's historical perspective provides essential clues to interpret the predicaments of the present. The Crisis of Multiculturalism in Europe recounts the debates about immigration and multiculturalism in the UK, France, Germany, and to a lesser extent the Netherlands and Switzerland from the postwar years up to recent years-but short of encompassing the "refugee crisis" and the rise of far-right populism beyond some general references. As hinted above, the book's main strength lies in its longerterm take on the debate on multiculturalism. Rather than starting from 9/11 or the widely publicized speeches by several European leaders announcing the failure of multiculturalism, Chin shows the more complex and contested history of multiculturalism from the time of postwar migrations. She discusses how resistance and backlash against migrants and the racialized "others" were present throughout the period, gained steam from the 1980s, and then converged into a widely taken-for-granted new consensus that multiculturalism has failed in the 2000s. The 9/11 terrorist attacks and the war on terror (not discussed much in the book) as well as the Rushdie affair in the UK and the debates about headscarves in France (both discussed in detail) accelerated anti-multiculturalist processes whose seeds were already present in the policies and public debates of previous decades. This focus on continuities allows Chin to tell a more nuanced history of how multiculturalism as an objective fact came to be in (Western) Europe and how multiculturalism as a policy aspiration was applied, misapplied, and resisted in different Western European countries. This long-historical approach overcomes the strictures of the more common "integration models" approach to discussing how different European countries have dealt with their diverse societies. Instead, Chin tells a story of convergence. Although the starting points and the policy approaches might have been different, similar debates took place in countries that are usually categorized as having different integration models, and they culminated in recent years in remarkably similar public debates on diversity. Rather than different models, Chin's book reveals the consolidation of a European anti-multiculturalist consensus. As The Crisis of Multiculturalism in Europe is mostly based on secondary literature, where it shines is not necessarily in the uncovering of new material or an entirely novel interpretation of existing material, but in weaving together strands of events, debates, and policies that many readers would already be familiar with, into a concise and convincing account of how multiculturalism came to be widely reviled in European public discourse. Chapter 1 looks at the first substantial waves of immigration to the case-study countries, focusing on how they were interlinked with colonial histories and labor shortages. Chapter 2 proceeds to look at the issues that emerged with managing multicultural societies, especially after the end of the postwar economic boom in the 1970s. As this is mostly a top-down history of multiculturalism, the focus is on policies and party politics. Chapter 3 evidences the discursive shift from genetic racism to cultural nationalism as the main exclusionary discourse emerging in Europe. While racism remained strong, it was increasingly coated with the respectability of the nation, and in the process a lot of the focus was shifted on Muslims as Europe's main "other." Chapter 4 continues on this topic by looking more in detail at "sexual democracy" and how arguments for women (and in several cases LGBT+) rights were leveraged to demonstrate Islam's incompatibility with European democracy and further marginalize European Muslims.

  • Open Access

    The Quality of Divided Democracies

    by Licia Cianetti

    The Quality of Divided Democracies contemplates how democracy works, or fails to work, in ethno-culturally divided societies. It advances a new theoretical approach to assessing the quality of democracy in divided societies, and puts it into practice with the focused comparison of two divided...


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Rethinking “democratic backsliding” in Central and Eastern Europe – looking beyond Hungary and Poland

    by Licia Cianetti, James Dawson, Seán Hanley

    This essay introduces contributions to a special issue of East European Politics on “Rethinking democratic backsliding in Central and Eastern Europe”, which seeks to expand the study of democratic regression in CEE beyond the paradigmatic cases of Hungary and Poland. Reviewing these contributions, we identify several directions for research: 1) the need to critique “democratic backsliding”, not simply as a label, but also as an assumed regional trend; 2) a need to better integrate the role of illiberal socio-economic structures such as oligarchical structures or corrupt networks; and 3) a need to (re-)examine the trade-offs between democratic stability and democratic quality. We also note how insights developed researching post-communist regions such as Western Balkans or the post-Soviet space could usefully inform work on CEE backsliding. We conclude by calling for the study of CEE democracy to become more genuinely interdisciplinary, moving beyond some narrowly institutionalist comparative political science assumptions.


  • Consolidated technocratic and ethnic hollowness, but no backsliding: reassessing Europeanisation in Estonia and Latvia

    by Licia Cianetti

    This article contributes to the growing debate on democratic backsliding in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), by expanding on Béla Greskovits’s distinction between backsliding and hollowness, suggesting ways to broaden and specify the concept of hollowness, and discussing the relationship between hollowness and backsliding. Estonia and Latvia provide illustrations of two stable democracies, which nevertheless have consolidated tendencies for an elite-driven and ethnic-majority-driven democratic process hollowed out of its democratic contestation. This is what I call “technocratic” and “ethnic” hollowness. This double hollowness consolidated during EU accession, which created a favourable context for well-positioned ethnic majority elites to push forward ethnocentric and neoliberal agendas while restricting the space for debating them. However, far from a symptom of backsliding in the sense of a regression into authoritarianism, double hollowness is in fact central to these democracies’ stability. Such stability will have to be destabilised in order to improve their democratic quality.