Elina Inkeri Hartikainen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Elina Inkeri Hartikainen has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Andrew Graan
University of Helsinki
1 shared publication- Matti Eräsaari
University of Helsinki
1 shared publication - Pekka Tuominen
University of Helsinki
1 shared publication Timo Kallinen
University of Eastern Finland
1 shared publication- Tuomas Tammisto
Tampere University
1 shared publication Ville Laakkonen
University of Tampere
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 November 2026
- Published by Helsinki University Press
- p. 175-201
Active citizenship and big people: Multiple social orders and the politics of scale-making in Brazil
In the first decade of the 2000s, governments across Brazil adopted new policy-based approaches to remedy longstanding patterns of racial inequality and prejudice. While these programs were often welcomed by their targets, the political analyses they relied on did not always correspond to those of the populations they intended to help. This was particularly the case for efforts that were directed at practitioners of the African origin religious tradition Candomblé in Salvador. This chapter traces the tensions inherent to these efforts to a disconnect between the scalar analyses that grounded the political imaginaries of government institutions and Candomblé practitioners. The first equated democratic politics with unmediated engagements between citizens and states. The second was committed to a relational analysis of politics that understood access to state power and resources for the “little people” and “small temple communities” (that is, those not directly connected to state institutions) to depend on “big people” (that is, those with socially productive connections to these institutions). As I show, the close parallels between the scalar analyses that organized these models made their intersections particularly tense but, on occasion, also conducive to strategic manipulation.
- 12 November 2026
- Published by Helsinki University Press
- p. 175-201
Open AccessActive citizenship and big people: Multiple social orders and the politics of scale-making in Brazil
In the first decade of the 2000s, governments across Brazil adopted new policy-based approaches to remedy longstanding patterns of racial inequality and prejudice. While these programs were often welcomed by their targets, the political analyses they relied on did not always correspond to those of the populations they intended to help. This was particularly the case for efforts that were directed at practitioners of the African origin religious tradition Candomblé in Salvador. This chapter traces the tensions inherent to these efforts to a disconnect between the scalar analyses that grounded the political imaginaries of government institutions and Candomblé practitioners. The first equated democratic politics with unmediated engagements between citizens and states. The second was committed to a relational analysis of politics that understood access to state power and resources for the “little people” and “small temple communities” (that is, those not directly connected to state institutions) to depend on “big people” (that is, those with socially productive connections to these institutions). As I show, the close parallels between the scalar analyses that organized these models made their intersections particularly tense but, on occasion, also conducive to strategic manipulation.
- Open Access
- 28 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Studies in Religion/Sciences Religieuses
Narrating religious intolerance, constructing secularism: Chronotopes of raced secularism and abnormal religious violence at a parliamentary commission in Brazil
This article examines how narrative chronotopes that organize state efforts to govern religion and religious violence contribute to the racialization of secularism in Brazil. Through an analysis of the chronotopes that structured conversations between legislators and invited government representatives at the Parliamentary Commission for Inquiry into Religious Intolerance convened by the Legislative Assembly of the State of Rio de Janeiro in 2021, the author shows how these narrative constructions conditioned the commission’s analysis of religious violence in the state. On one level, it produced a powerful critique of the racial organization of secularism in Brazil; on another, it construed the attacks the commission had been tasked with investigating as social aberrations that were beyond the purview of “normal” governance of religion. The end result was a consolidation of the very forms of raced secularism that the commission otherwise critiqued.
- 28 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Studies in Religion/Sciences Religieuses
Open AccessNarrating religious intolerance, constructing secularism: Chronotopes of raced secularism and abnormal religious violence at a parliamentary commission in Brazil
This article examines how narrative chronotopes that organize state efforts to govern religion and religious violence contribute to the racialization of secularism in Brazil. Through an analysis of the chronotopes that structured conversations between legislators and invited government representatives at the Parliamentary Commission for Inquiry into Religious Intolerance convened by the Legislative Assembly of the State of Rio de Janeiro in 2021, the author shows how these narrative constructions conditioned the commission’s analysis of religious violence in the state. On one level, it produced a powerful critique of the racial organization of secularism in Brazil; on another, it construed the attacks the commission had been tasked with investigating as social aberrations that were beyond the purview of “normal” governance of religion. The end result was a consolidation of the very forms of raced secularism that the commission otherwise critiqued.
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Asia Pacific Journal of Anthropology
- Vol. 27 (2) , 166-169
What Do Modernist Imaginaries of Circulation Do, and Where Do They Come From?
- 17 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Asia Pacific Journal of Anthropology
- Vol. 27 (2) , 166-169
What Do Modernist Imaginaries of Circulation Do, and Where Do They Come From?
- Open Access
- 26 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in History and Anthropology
- Vol. 36 (5) , 905-928
Chronotopes of law and “dark minds”: Judicial constructions of historicity in the Brazilian supreme court
- 26 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in History and Anthropology
- Vol. 36 (5) , 905-928
Open AccessChronotopes of law and “dark minds”: Judicial constructions of historicity in the Brazilian supreme court
- Open Access
- 30 January 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Signs and Society
- Vol. 13 (1) , 78-101
Religious Intolerance and the Semiotics of Secular Indeterminacy in Brazil
The functioning of the liberal order relies on the semiotic indeterminacy of its key concepts—they need to be broad enough to encompass multiple, and at times conflicting articulations—but the denotational open-endedness of these concepts also renders them particularly useful for efforts to unsettle liberal political projects. In Brazil, state institutions’ secularist commitments to retaining “religion” and its derivates as denotationally indeterminant both constrain efforts to combat Evangelical Christian “religious intolerance” against African origin religious traditions and enable Evangelical Christian graftings of the discourse of “religious intolerance” onto claims that frame the efforts to curb their attacks on religious and sexual minorities as a form of religious persecution. These effects are, however, rendered invisible by the state emphasis on the denotational open-endedness of “religious intolerance,” which obscures the different forms of enregisterment that organize the entextualization of the term in religious activist and government spaces in Brazil.
- 30 January 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Signs and Society
- Vol. 13 (1) , 78-101
Open AccessReligious Intolerance and the Semiotics of Secular Indeterminacy in Brazil
The functioning of the liberal order relies on the semiotic indeterminacy of its key concepts—they need to be broad enough to encompass multiple, and at times conflicting articulations—but the denotational open-endedness of these concepts also renders them particularly useful for efforts to unsettle liberal political projects. In Brazil, state institutions’ secularist commitments to retaining “religion” and its derivates as denotationally indeterminant both constrain efforts to combat Evangelical Christian “religious intolerance” against African origin religious traditions and enable Evangelical Christian graftings of the discourse of “religious intolerance” onto claims that frame the efforts to curb their attacks on religious and sexual minorities as a form of religious persecution. These effects are, however, rendered invisible by the state emphasis on the denotational open-endedness of “religious intolerance,” which obscures the different forms of enregisterment that organize the entextualization of the term in religious activist and government spaces in Brazil.
- Open Access
- 9 March 2022
- Published by Linhas Críticas in Abya-yala: Revista sobre Acesso à Justiça e Direitos nas Américas
- Vol. 6 (1) , 48 a 86
RELIGIOUS INTOLERANCE, ETHNORACIAL LAW AND THE SHIFTING LANDSCAPE OF AFRO-BRAZILIAN RELIGIOUS RIGHTS IN 21ST CENTURY BRAZIL
The legal status of Afro-Brazilian religions has changed dramatically in the past few decades. For much of the 20th century, Afro-Brazilian religions lacked legal recognition as religions. Over the past twenty years, they have become targets and beneficiaries of ethnoracial laws and government institutions fostered by Brazil’s 1988 “Citizens’ Constitution.” Still, most acts of violence on Afro-Brazilian religions fail to reach courts and even fewer are tried using the legal frameworks provided by ethnoracial law. This article examines the structural obstacles that the legal remediation of discrimination against Afro-Brazilian religions has faced over the past two decades. It argues that although religious activists' efforts have contributed to beneficial changes in the legal landscape surrounding religious intolerance, current legal understandings of religious prejudice and discrimination continue to curtail the application of anti-discriminatory law to most attacks on Afro-Brazilian religions. Looking ahead to the 2020s, these obstacles can be expected to be aggravated further by the growing influence of conservative Evangelical Christian agendas on the executive, legislative and judiciary branches of the Brazilian government. Palabras clave: ley contra la discriminación, activismo legal, intolerancia religiosa, religiones afrobrasileñas El estatus legal de las religiones afrobrasileñas ha cambiado dramáticamente en las últimas décadas. Durante gran parte del siglo XX, las religiones afrobrasileñas carecieron de reconocimiento legal como religiones. Durante los últimos veinte años, se han convertido en objeto y beneficiarias de las leyes etnico-raciales y las instituciones gubernamentales impulsadas por la constitución ciudadana de Brasil de 1988. Aún así, la mayoría de los actos de violencia contra las religiones afrobrasileñas no llegan a los tribunales y aún menos son juzgados utilizando los marcos legales proporcionados por las leyes étnico-raciales. Este artículo examina los obstáculos estructurales que ha enfrentado la resolución legal de la discriminación contra las religiones afrobrasileñas durante las últimas dos décadas. Sostiene que, aunque los esfuerzos de los activistas religiosos han contribuido a cambios beneficiosos en el panorama legal que rodea a la intolerancia religiosa, la comprensión legal actual del prejuicio religioso y la discriminación continúa restringiendo la aplicación de la ley antidiscriminatoria a la mayoría de los ataques contra las religiones afrobrasileñas. De cara a la década de los 2020s, se puede esperar que estos obstáculos se agraven aún más por la creciente influencia de las agendas cristianas evangélicas conservadoras en los poderes ejecutivo, legislativo y judicial del gobierno brasileño. Palabras clave: ley contra la discriminación, activismo legal, intolerancia religiosa, religiones afrobrasileñas O status legal das religiões afro-brasileiras mudou dramaticamente nas últimas décadas. Durante grande parte do século XX, elas não foram reconhecidas legalmente como religiões. Nos últimos vinte anos, elas se tornaram alvos e beneficiários das leis étnico-raciais e instituições governamentais promovidas pela Constituição Cidadã de 1988. Ainda assim, a maioria dos atos de violência contra religiões afro-brasileiras não chega aos tribunais e menos ainda são julgados usando os marcos legais fornecidos pelas leis étnico-raciais. Este artigo examina os obstáculos estruturais enfrentados pela remediação legal da discriminação contra as religiões afro-brasileiras nas últimas duas décadas. O artigo argumenta que embora os esforços dos ativistas religiosos tenham contribuído para mudanças benéficas no cenário legal em torno da intolerância religiosa, os atuais entendimentos legais de preconceito e discriminação religioso continuam a restringir a aplicação das leis antidiscriminatórias aos ataques às religiões afro-brasileiras. A perspectiva para a década de 2020, é que esses obstáculos sejam agravados pela crescente influência das agendas cristãs evangélicas conservadoras nos poderes executivo, legislativo e judiciário. Palavras-chave: lei antidiscriminatória, ativismo legal, intolerância religiosa, religiões afro-brasileiras.
- 9 March 2022
- Published by Linhas Críticas in Abya-yala: Revista sobre Acesso à Justiça e Direitos nas Américas
- Vol. 6 (1) , 48 a 86
Open AccessRELIGIOUS INTOLERANCE, ETHNORACIAL LAW AND THE SHIFTING LANDSCAPE OF AFRO-BRAZILIAN RELIGIOUS RIGHTS IN 21ST CENTURY BRAZIL
The legal status of Afro-Brazilian religions has changed dramatically in the past few decades. For much of the 20th century, Afro-Brazilian religions lacked legal recognition as religions. Over the past twenty years, they have become targets and beneficiaries of ethnoracial laws and government institutions fostered by Brazil’s 1988 “Citizens’ Constitution.” Still, most acts of violence on Afro-Brazilian religions fail to reach courts and even fewer are tried using the legal frameworks provided by ethnoracial law. This article examines the structural obstacles that the legal remediation of discrimination against Afro-Brazilian religions has faced over the past two decades. It argues that although religious activists' efforts have contributed to beneficial changes in the legal landscape surrounding religious intolerance, current legal understandings of religious prejudice and discrimination continue to curtail the application of anti-discriminatory law to most attacks on Afro-Brazilian religions. Looking ahead to the 2020s, these obstacles can be expected to be aggravated further by the growing influence of conservative Evangelical Christian agendas on the executive, legislative and judiciary branches of the Brazilian government. Palabras clave: ley contra la discriminación, activismo legal, intolerancia religiosa, religiones afrobrasileñas El estatus legal de las religiones afrobrasileñas ha cambiado dramáticamente en las últimas décadas. Durante gran parte del siglo XX, las religiones afrobrasileñas carecieron de reconocimiento legal como religiones. Durante los últimos veinte años, se han convertido en objeto y beneficiarias de las leyes etnico-raciales y las instituciones gubernamentales impulsadas por la constitución ciudadana de Brasil de 1988. Aún así, la mayoría de los actos de violencia contra las religiones afrobrasileñas no llegan a los tribunales y aún menos son juzgados utilizando los marcos legales proporcionados por las leyes étnico-raciales. Este artículo examina los obstáculos estructurales que ha enfrentado la resolución legal de la discriminación contra las religiones afrobrasileñas durante las últimas dos décadas. Sostiene que, aunque los esfuerzos de los activistas religiosos han contribuido a cambios beneficiosos en el panorama legal que rodea a la intolerancia religiosa, la comprensión legal actual del prejuicio religioso y la discriminación continúa restringiendo la aplicación de la ley antidiscriminatoria a la mayoría de los ataques contra las religiones afrobrasileñas. De cara a la década de los 2020s, se puede esperar que estos obstáculos se agraven aún más por la creciente influencia de las agendas cristianas evangélicas conservadoras en los poderes ejecutivo, legislativo y judicial del gobierno brasileño. Palabras clave: ley contra la discriminación, activismo legal, intolerancia religiosa, religiones afrobrasileñas O status legal das religiões afro-brasileiras mudou dramaticamente nas últimas décadas. Durante grande parte do século XX, elas não foram reconhecidas legalmente como religiões. Nos últimos vinte anos, elas se tornaram alvos e beneficiários das leis étnico-raciais e instituições governamentais promovidas pela Constituição Cidadã de 1988. Ainda assim, a maioria dos atos de violência contra religiões afro-brasileiras não chega aos tribunais e menos ainda são julgados usando os marcos legais fornecidos pelas leis étnico-raciais. Este artigo examina os obstáculos estruturais enfrentados pela remediação legal da discriminação contra as religiões afro-brasileiras nas últimas duas décadas. O artigo argumenta que embora os esforços dos ativistas religiosos tenham contribuído para mudanças benéficas no cenário legal em torno da intolerância religiosa, os atuais entendimentos legais de preconceito e discriminação religioso continuam a restringir a aplicação das leis antidiscriminatórias aos ataques às religiões afro-brasileiras. A perspectiva para a década de 2020, é que esses obstáculos sejam agravados pela crescente influência das agendas cristãs evangélicas conservadoras nos poderes executivo, legislativo e judiciário. Palavras-chave: lei antidiscriminatória, ativismo legal, intolerância religiosa, religiões afro-brasileiras.
- Open Access
- 23 October 2019
- Published by Approaching Religion in Approaching Religion
- Vol. 9 (1–2) , 41–56
Evaluating faith after conversion
In 2017, the Finnish Immigration Service received approximately 1,000 asylum applications and appeals based on conversion from Islam to Christianity. The applications claimed that converted asylum seekers would face mortal danger if returned to their countries of origin. The applications posed an unprecedented dilemma for the Finnish Immigration Service: how was it, as a secular state institution, to evaluate these claims of conversion? This question also became an object of significant public and media debate. In this article, I examine how journalists writing for a religious media publication, Kirkko ja kaupunki, the newspaper of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in the Helsinki region, sought to intervene in the debate on asylum seekers’ conversions. I focus my analysis on one central line of argument in their reporting: a call for the better- inclusion of and engagement with religious expertise on Christianity by the Finnish Immigration Service when evaluating conversion-based asylum applications and appeals. I show that this call both positioned religious expertise as an antidote to the challenges that efforts to evaluate conversion-based asylum appeals posed to Finnish Immigration Service employees in this time period, and constituted expertise as a site for negotiations over the ‘proper’ relationship between religion and state.
- 23 October 2019
- Published by Approaching Religion in Approaching Religion
- Vol. 9 (1–2) , 41–56
Open AccessEvaluating faith after conversion
In 2017, the Finnish Immigration Service received approximately 1,000 asylum applications and appeals based on conversion from Islam to Christianity. The applications claimed that converted asylum seekers would face mortal danger if returned to their countries of origin. The applications posed an unprecedented dilemma for the Finnish Immigration Service: how was it, as a secular state institution, to evaluate these claims of conversion? This question also became an object of significant public and media debate. In this article, I examine how journalists writing for a religious media publication, Kirkko ja kaupunki, the newspaper of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in the Helsinki region, sought to intervene in the debate on asylum seekers’ conversions. I focus my analysis on one central line of argument in their reporting: a call for the better- inclusion of and engagement with religious expertise on Christianity by the Finnish Immigration Service when evaluating conversion-based asylum applications and appeals. I show that this call both positioned religious expertise as an antidote to the challenges that efforts to evaluate conversion-based asylum appeals posed to Finnish Immigration Service employees in this time period, and constituted expertise as a site for negotiations over the ‘proper’ relationship between religion and state.
- Open Access
- 20 September 2019
- Published by Suomen Antropologi: Journal of the Finnish Anthropological Society in Suomen Antropologi: Journal of the Finnish Anthropological Society
- Vol. 44 (1) , 1-2
Editor's Note
- 20 September 2019
- Published by Suomen Antropologi: Journal of the Finnish Anthropological Society in Suomen Antropologi: Journal of the Finnish Anthropological Society
- Vol. 44 (1) , 1-2
Open AccessEditor's Note
- Open Access
- 1 September 2019
- Published by Berghahn Books in Religion and Society
- Vol. 10 (1) , 92-110
Adjudicating Religious Intolerance
Allegations of religious intolerance push courts to deliberate on questions that are constitutive of the problem space of secularism. In addition to legal opinions on the character and scope of religious freedom vis-à-vis conflicting rights, these arbitrations result in authoritative statements on what constitutes religion, how it may inhabit public space, and, ultimately, what interests and values underpin the national collective. This article analyzes three high-profile court cases alleging religious intolerance against Afro-Brazilian religions that were tried in Brazil during the first two decades of the 2000s. It demonstrates how at this time of rapid religious transformation the adjudication of such cases acted as a key site for the Brazilian legal establishment to redefine the place of religion in the broader context of rights and laws that regulate religion in public spaces.
- 1 September 2019
- Published by Berghahn Books in Religion and Society
- Vol. 10 (1) , 92-110
Open AccessAdjudicating Religious Intolerance
Allegations of religious intolerance push courts to deliberate on questions that are constitutive of the problem space of secularism. In addition to legal opinions on the character and scope of religious freedom vis-à-vis conflicting rights, these arbitrations result in authoritative statements on what constitutes religion, how it may inhabit public space, and, ultimately, what interests and values underpin the national collective. This article analyzes three high-profile court cases alleging religious intolerance against Afro-Brazilian religions that were tried in Brazil during the first two decades of the 2000s. It demonstrates how at this time of rapid religious transformation the adjudication of such cases acted as a key site for the Brazilian legal establishment to redefine the place of religion in the broader context of rights and laws that regulate religion in public spaces.
- Open Access
- 14 May 2019
- Published by Wiley in American Anthropologist
- Vol. 121 (4) , 815-829
Candomblé and the Academic's Tools: Religious Expertise and the Binds of Recognition in Brazil
- 14 May 2019
- Published by Wiley in American Anthropologist
- Vol. 121 (4) , 815-829
Open AccessCandomblé and the Academic's Tools: Religious Expertise and the Binds of Recognition in Brazil