CBCraig F. Barrett

Craig F. Barrett

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Craig F. Barrett has a total of 123 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:

  • Brandon T. Sinn

    Department of Biology, West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV

    11 shared publications
  • Cameron W. Corbett

    Department of Biology West Virginia University 53 Campus Drive Morgantown 26506 WV USA

    7 shared publications
  • Nicole M. Fama

    Department of Biology, West Virginia University, 53 Campus Drive, Morgantown, West Virginia, USA 26506

    6 shared publications
  • Brandon T. Sinn

    Department of Biology and Earth Science, Otterbein University, 1 South Grove Street, Westerville, Ohio, USA 43801

    5 shared publications
  • Mathilda V. Santee

    Department of Biology West Virginia University 53 Campus Drive Morgantown West Virginia 26506 USA

    5 shared publications
  • John V. Freudenstein

    Ohio State University Herbarium, Department of Evolution, Ecology and Organismal Biology, The Ohio State University 1315 Kinnear Road Columbus 43214 OH USA

    4 shared publications

Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Unexpected excess heterozygosity in a threatened, mycoheterotrophic, self-pollinating orchid

    by Craig F. Barrett, Nicole M. Fama, John V. Freudenstein, Gerardo Salazar, Sandra J. Simon, Brandon T. Sinn

    Self-fertilization results in reduction of heterozygosity over time, accelerated by small population sizes, restricted ranges, and fragmented habitats. Yet some species maintain heterozygosity despite these factors. One is Corallorhiza bentleyi , a threatened, mycoheterotrophic, self-pollinating orchid restricted to Virginia and West Virginia, USA. Reduced representation sequencing was employed across five of the ∼12 known localities of C . bentleyi , including representatives of sister species C. involuta from Mexico, to quantify patterns of population structure and genomic diversity. Surveys of C. bentleyi revealed a predominance of the cleistogamous (closed-flowered) growth form. Differentiation was observed between the two species but with weak population structure in C. bentleyi . Surprisingly, excess heterozygosity and negative inbreeding were recovered in both species, counter to expectations. Analyses provided evidence against bioinformatic artifacts (collapsed paralogs), small-sample bias (Robertson effect), and accumulation of mutations along chromosomes due to low recombination associated with selfing (Meselson effect) as explanations for excess heterozygosity. Demographic analyses favored a model of post-glacial divergence among C. bentleyi and C. involuta lacking bottlenecks. Finally, simulations under alternative selection scenarios favored models of overdominance vs. those of negative frequency dependent selection. It was concluded that overdominance, namely selection against selfed homozygotes, is the most likely explanation for elevated heterozygosity in C. bentleyi . Conservation concerns are discussed in light of these findings and the threats of extinction for one of North America’s most vulnerable orchid species.

  • Open Access

    Corallorhiza striata is the first example of a pseudocopulatory orchid in North America and an instance of “double deception” in fully mycoheterotrophic plants

    by John V. Freudenstein, Craig F. Barrett

    Premise: Orchids have many pollination strategies, from highly species‐specific mutualisms with insects to deceit pollination, including sexual deception. The family also has the most leafless, parasitic species (mycoheterotrophs) of any plant family. The occurrence of two types of deception simultaneously in individuals of a single species previously has been suggested to be highly improbable. Methods: We studied Corallorhiza striata in the field, documenting the behavior of pollinators on the plants. We compared structural features of C. striata flowers to those of other species in the genus and tested for the presence of nectar. We also examined over 6000 iNaturalist photo records of C. striata to expand our pollinator search. Results: The only pollinators for which we found clear evidence were males of the ichneumonid wasp Pimpla pedalis , which visited the nectarless flowers and exhibited mating‐type behavior. The floral structure of C. striata , especially with respect to the labellum, is distinct from that of bee‐ and fly‐pollinated species of Corallorhiza . We demonstrated that wasps were attracted to flowers in the absence of visual cues. Conclusions: Corallorhiza striata is the first example of a pseudocopulatory orchid from North America, and Corallorhiza is only the second genus known to deceive an ichneumonid. It is trophically and reproductively deceptive in the same life stage. Four other fully mycoheterotrophic species and three partial mycoheterotrophs also are known to engage in both deceptions indicating that, although rare, simultaneous deception can be a successful strategy. Such parasitic plants provide opportunities to study unusual evolutionary and ecological phenomena.


  • Open Access

    Mycoheterotrophy and plastid genome evolution in the early-diverging epidendroid orchid tribe Nervilieae: independent transitions in Epipogium and Stereosandra

    by Craig F Barrett, Cameron W Corbett, Samuel V Skibicki, Vincent S F T Merckx, Matthew C Pace, Paul M Peterson

    Parasitic organisms are of interest in evolutionary biology, often displaying drastic modifications in morphology, physiology, genomes, and ecology. These properties, however, make them challenging from a systematics perspective. Mycoheterotrophy, in which plants become non-photosynthetic parasites on fungi, is an excellent example, and this unique life history has evolved numerous times in the orchid family. Here, we focused on Stereosandra, a genus of mycoheterotrophic orchid comprising a single species, S. javanica, about which little is known. Stereosandra has been placed in the orchid tribe Nervilieae, along with the leafy, autotrophic Nervilia, and the leafless, mycoheterotrophic Epipogium. We characterized the first complete plastid genome for Stereosandra and used nuclear sequence capture to determine its relationships within Nervilieae. This study presents the first genetic data ever produced for Stereosandra. The plastid genome exhibits rampant gene losses, pseudogenes, and reduced size relative to Nervilia but not to the extent seen in Epipogium. There is evidence of relaxed negative selection in six genes in Stereosandra, including matK, which functions in Group IIA intron removal of seven plastid genes, four of which have been lost or pseudogenized in this species. Applying mixture models, plastid genomes provided weak support for a sister position of Stereosandra to a clade of Epipogium + Nervilia. Nuclear phylogenomic analyses provided strong support for the same relationships. Ancestral state reconstruction revealed clear evidence that mycoheterotrophy evolved multiple times in the tribe from leafy ancestors. This study provides a previously unidentified, convergent instance of the evolution of full mycoheterotrophy in plants. We discuss the results in the context of proposed models of reductive plastid genome evolution and the genomic and evolutionary consequences of radical life history shifts in heterotrophic plants.

  • Nuclear Phylogenomic Insights into Relationships, Support, and Conflict Among the Early Diverging Lineages of the Megadiverse Epidendroid Orchids

    by Craig F Barrett, John V Freudenstein, Samuel V Skibicki, Cameron W Corbett, Brandon T Sinn, Hana L Thixton-Nolan, William J Baker, Vincent S F T Merckx, Oscar Alejandro Pérez-Escobar, Matthew C Pace, et al.

    Parasites present fascinating examples of evolutionary modification that simultaneously pose challenges for systematics. This is exemplified by fully mycoheterotrophic orchids, which are completely dependent on fungi, constituting nearly half of all fully mycoheterotrophic plant species. A large concentration of mycoheterotrophic lineages is found among the eight tribes comprising the base of the megadiverse orchid subfamily Epidendroideae, here referred to as the Early Diverging Epidendroideae (EDE). To date, relationships among the EDE have been problematic. Previous analyses have suffered from sparse taxon sampling, weak support from limited loci, or long branch attraction in plastid-based analyses. We conducted the most comprehensive nuclear phylogenomic analysis of the EDE to date, using Angiosperms353 loci, coalescent analyses, and deep exploration of support, conflict, saturation, and introgression. Our study is the first to include phylogenomic data from all eight EDE tribes, with 22 of 26 EDE genera represented. We took a novel approach selecting best-fit mixture model configurations at the individual locus level, which provided significantly better fit overall and required fewer parameters than all other models, with implications for clades characterized by lineage-specific rate heterogeneity. We recovered strong support for monophyly of all EDE tribes except for Neottieae, which were inferred to be paraphyletic. Based on quartet sampling analysis, information content was generally rich for deep relationships among the EDE tribes, but overall support was weak. We found evidence of saturation and putative introgression, with two inferred reticulation events. We conclude that short internal branches associated with rapid diversification, incomplete lineage sorting, and putative introgression resulted in low concordant signal among EDE tribes, underscoring the continued difficulty in resolving their relationships. Nonetheless, we provide the first strongly supported phylogenetic hypothesis for the five genera of Gastrodieae, representing the largest known diversification of fully mycoheterotrophic plants. We discuss our findings considering recent phylogenomic studies, taxonomy, morphology, and biogeographic implications.


  • Pre‐Miocene evolutionary dynamics of tropical rainforests from a dated phylogeny of the palm family

    by Gang Yao, Bine Xue, Wei Wang, Craig Barrett, Tong‐Jian Liu, Marinoli Rivas‐Chamorro, Betty Millán, Xue‐Jun Ge

    Summary: Tropical rainforests (TRFs) are the most species‐rich terrestrial biome on Earth, which experienced a series of global climate fluctuations since the mid‐Cretaceous. However, the relationship between the evolutionary dynamics of TRFs and global climate changes is poorly understood. As an important element of the TRF biome, the palm family Arecaceae provides an ideal model to study the evolutionary history of TRFs. We present a new palm phylogeny based on combined next‐generation and Sanger sequence data, covering 181/184 genera and 604 of the 2500 accepted species, and calibrated it with 12 fossils to infer the pre‐Miocene temporal evolutionary dynamics of the family. Results show that Arecaceae started to diversify at c. 108.3 million years ago (Ma) during the mid‐Cretaceous, and the diversification rate of the family generally increased during global warming periods and decreased during cooling periods from the mid‐Cretaceous to the end of the Oligocene. The extinction rate of palms increased lastingly since the Oligocene when global temperature was relatively low. Our data for palms in combination with those from other taxa suggest that marked species turnover might have occurred in the accumulation of species diversity of TRFs during different geological eras under the context of global climate changes.


  • Phylogenomics and intergenomic conflict in a challenging orchid clade (Calypsoinae): monophyly of Corallorhiza , paraphyly of Oreorchis , and resurrection of Kitigorchis

    by Craig F Barrett, John V Freudenstein, Samuel V Skibicki, Brandon T Sinn, Shih-Wen Chung, Tian-Chuan Hsu, Wenbo Liao, Shiou Yih Lee, Yi-Bo Luo, Tomohisa Yukawa, et al.

    Heterotrophic plants are among the most recalcitrant from a systematics perspective because of reduced morphological and genomic features, and often extreme substitution rate heterogeneity. The orchid subtribe Calypsoinae exemplifies this, containing several lineages that have lost leaves and photosynthesis. In particular, relationships of the leafy Asian Oreorchis and the leafless American Corallorhiza have been contentious. Here we used nuclear sequence capture to resolve relationships within Calypsoinae and addressed the monophyly of Corallorhiza and Oreorchis, for which previous studies have highlighted conflicting patterns of monophyly or paraphyly, depending on the data analysed. Nuclear analyses provided strong support for a monophyletic Corallorhiza and paraphyletic Oreorchis, the latter with two strongly supported clades. As in previous studies, plastid analyses recovered strongly supported paraphyletic assemblages for both genera. Topology tests using plastid and nuclear relationships and data rejected the constrained topologies, further revealing strong cytonuclear conflict. Network-based analyses revealed a lack of evidence for hybridization, suggesting incomplete lineage sorting associated with biological and historical factors have driven intergenomic conflict. Additionally, we found that loci identified as putatively lost in holomycotrophic Corallorhiza species are functionally enriched for organellar functions. The study provides a strong case for the resurrection of Kitigorchis as the sister of Corallorhiza, with two species, Kitigorchis erythrochrysea and Kitigorchis indica, and highlights the challenges associated with phylogenetics of lineages containing mycoheterotrophs.


  • Phylogenetics, Taxonomy, and Chromosome Number Analysis of Sanvitalia (Asteraceae-Heliantheae-Zinniinae)

    by Samuel V. Skibicki, Tina J. Ayers, Randall W. Scott, Craig F. Barrett

    Abstract— Sanvitalia (Asteraceae), a New World endemic, is poorly understood from a phylogenetic perspective. While chromosome number variation is well documented for the genus, previous studies lack a phylogenetic context for chromosome number evolution, with one species, S. fruticosa, lacking a published chromosome count. We collected molecular sequence data from the nuclear ribosomal ITS region and three plastid loci from multiple individuals of each species of Sanvitalia and additional members of the Zinniinae to create phylogenetic trees and study the evolutionary history of the clade. A complete taxonomic treatment was produced as well as a dichotomous key to species. The first chromosome count for S. fruticosa was rendered (2n = 16) and a chromosome number analysis was completed using maximum likelihood methods that account for different modes of chromosome number change. Support for two separate whole genome duplication events in the genus is presented here. This study resulted in deeper understanding of the relationships within Sanvitalia and closely related genera, chromosome number evolution and genome duplication in Zinniinae, and the closest relative (S. ocymoides) of the enigmatic and amphiequatorial disjunct S. versicolor. We also provide support for the prior transfer of S. tenuis to Zinnia, and two new sections within Sanvitalia.


  • Open Access

    Molecular and Taxonomic Reevaluation of the Digitaria filiformis Complex (Poaceae), Including a Globally Extinct, Single-Site Endemic from New Hampshire, USA, and a New Species from Mexico

    by William F. Nichols, Craig F. Barrett, Joseph K. Wipff, Jorge Gabriel Sánchez-Ken, Wesley M. Knapp, Erin M. Sigel, Lauren Kosslow, Cameron Corbett

    Abstract— We examine the Digitaria filiformis complex to determine the proper taxonomic rank and conservation status of each member. The taxonomy of the D. filiformis complex is debated and includes two widespread taxa, D. filiformis var. filiformis and D. filiformis var. villosa; a rare taxon of southern Florida and the West Indies, D. filiformis var. dolichophylla; and a possibly extinct taxon that supposedly is a single-site endemic in New Hampshire, USA, D. filiformis var. laeviglumis. We conducted molecular analyses and morphologic comparisons of the four members of the D. filiformis complex, together with specimens from Venezuela (morphology only) and Mexico purportedly identified as D. filiformis var. laeviglumis. Based on results of phylogenetic analyses of plastid and nuclear ITS sequences and morphologic comparisons, we elevated taxonomic ranks, recognizing four species in the D. filiformis complex, and circumscribe the Mexican species D. glabrifloris (sp. nov.). Digitaria dolichophylla is much rarer than previously recognized, moving from Secure Globally to Imperiled with extinction (G2). After research and field investigations, we changed the global rank of D. laeviglumis from Globally Historical (GH) to Globally Extinct (GX), as there is virtually no likelihood of rediscovery.


  • Plastid genome evolution in leafless members of the orchid subfamily Orchidoideae, with a focus on Degranvillea dermaptera

    by Craig F. Barrett, Matthew C. Pace, Cameron W. Corbett

    Premise: Leafless, heterotrophic plants are prime examples of organismal modification, the genomic consequences of which have received considerable interest. In particular, plastid genomes (plastomes) are being sequenced at a high rate, allowing continual refinement of conceptual models of reductive evolution in heterotrophs. However, numerous sampling gaps exist, hindering the ability to conduct comprehensive phylogenomic analyses in these plants.Methods: Using floral tissue from an herbarium specimen, we sequenced and analyzed the plastome of Degranvillea dermaptera, a rarely collected, leafless orchid species from South America about which little is known, including its phylogenetic affinities.Results: The plastome is the most reduced of those sequenced among the orchid subfamily Orchidoideae. In Degranvillea, it has lost the majority of genes found in leafy autotrophic species, is structurally rearranged, and has similar gene content to the most reduced plastomes among the orchids. We found strong evidence for the placement of Degranvillea within the subtribe Spiranthinae using models that explicitly account for heterotachy, or lineage‐specific evolutionary rate variation over time. We further found evidence of relaxed selection on several genes and of correlations among substitution rates and several other “traits” of the plastome among leafless members of orchid subfamily Orchidoideae.Conclusions: Our findings advance knowledge on the phylogenetic relationships and paths of plastid genome evolution among the orchids, which have experienced more independent transitions to heterotrophy than any other plant family. This study demonstrates the importance of herbarium collections in comparative genomics of poorly known species of conservation concern.


  • Organellar phylogenomics at the epidendroid orchid base, with a focus on the mycoheterotrophic Wullschlaegelia

    by Craig F Barrett, Matthew C Pace, Cameron W Corbett, Aaron H Kennedy, Hana L Thixton-Nolan, John V Freudenstein

    Heterotrophic plants have long been a challenge for systematists, exemplified by the base of the orchid subfamily Epidendroideae, which contains numerous mycoheterotrophic species. Here we address the utility of organellar genomes in resolving relationships at the epidendroid base, specifically employing models of heterotachy, or lineage-specific rate variation over time. We further conduct comparative analyses of plastid genome evolution in heterotrophs and structural variation in matK. We present the first complete plastid genomes (plastomes) of Wullschlaegelia, the sole genus of the tribe Wullschlaegelieae, revealing a highly reduced genome of 37 kilobases, which retains a fraction of the genes present in related autotrophs. Plastid phylogenomic analyses recovered a strongly supported clade composed exclusively of mycoheterotrophic species with long branches. We further analyzed mitochondrial gene sets, which recovered similar relationships to those in other studies using nuclear data, but the placement of Wullschlaegelia remains uncertain. We conducted comparative plastome analyses among Wullschlaegelia and other heterotrophic orchids, revealing a suite of correlated substitutional and structural changes relative to autotrophic species. Lastly, we investigated evolutionary and structural variation in matK, which is retained in Wullschlaegelia and a few other ‘late stage’ heterotrophs and found evidence for structural conservation despite rapid substitution rates in both Wullschlaegelia and the leafless Gastrodia. Our analyses reveal the limits of what the plastid genome can tell us on orchid relationships in this part of the tree, even when applying parameter-rich heterotachy models. Our study underscores the need for increased taxon sampling across all three genomes at the epidendroid base, and illustrates the need for further research on addressing heterotachy in phylogenomic analyses.