Paul L. Schechter
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Paul L. Schechter has a total of 231 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jose Maza
University of Chile
6 shared publications - Joshua N. Winn
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
6 shared publications - Nicholas D. Morgan
Department of Physics Massachusetts Institute of Technology 02139 Cambridge MA
6 shared publications - Richard L. White
Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
5 shared publications Robert H. Becker
Institute of Geophysics and Planetary Physics, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, L-413, 7000 East Avenue, Livermore, CA 94550
5 shared publications- Robert P. Kirshner
Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 14 August 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in Research Notes of the AAS
- Vol. 10 (8) , 235
Confirmation of the Finch Flatter–Fainter Relation for the Quadruple Images of Lensed Point Sources
T. K. Finch et al. derived relations for the summed absolute magnifications of quadruply lensed images that vary inversely with flattening in two alternative isothermal gravitational potential models. However, they did not elaborate on the selection effects this “flatter–fainter” relation induces in actual lensed systems. We test the relation against the R. Luhtaru et al. sample of 39 quadruply lensed quasars (38 of which we model successfully), using predicted rather than observed magnifications to avoid the complication of microlensing. We found that the summed predicted magnification decreases by a factor of ten over the observed range of flattening.
- 14 August 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in Research Notes of the AAS
- Vol. 10 (8) , 235
Open AccessConfirmation of the Finch Flatter–Fainter Relation for the Quadruple Images of Lensed Point Sources
T. K. Finch et al. derived relations for the summed absolute magnifications of quadruply lensed images that vary inversely with flattening in two alternative isothermal gravitational potential models. However, they did not elaborate on the selection effects this “flatter–fainter” relation induces in actual lensed systems. We test the relation against the R. Luhtaru et al. sample of 39 quadruply lensed quasars (38 of which we model successfully), using predicted rather than observed magnifications to avoid the complication of microlensing. We found that the summed predicted magnification decreases by a factor of ten over the observed range of flattening.
- Open Access
A Forward, Analytic, Differentiable, Geometric (but Inflexible) Lens Model
We anticipate that hundreds of thousands of distant, strongly gravitationally lensed sources will be detectable with European Space Agency’s (ESA) Euclid mission and the Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time. We consider the virtues and shortcomings of the Singular Isothermal Elliptical Potential () with Parallel External Shear () for these systems. Its principal virtue is that it admits an analytic forward model that gives image positions and magnifications as functions of the source position (and shape for extended sources). Preliminary experiments suggest a speed-up of a factor in excess of 10,000 compared with conventional models that instead map from the image plane to the source plane and require iteration to converge upon a unique source. A second virtue is that the Witt–Wynne geometric representation of permits the quick visual verification of the model’s adequacy for a particular lensed system. Unfortunately, the model’s strictly elliptical lens equipotential is inconsistent with strictly elliptical surface mass density contours.The Witt–Wynne construction might nonetheless yield a sufficiently good first approximation to accelerate convergence to one’s preferred lens model.Open AccessA Forward, Analytic, Differentiable, Geometric (but Inflexible) Lens Model
We anticipate that hundreds of thousands of distant, strongly gravitationally lensed sources will be detectable with European Space Agency’s (ESA) Euclid mission and the Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time. We consider the virtues and shortcomings of the Singular Isothermal Elliptical Potential () with Parallel External Shear () for these systems. Its principal virtue is that it admits an analytic forward model that gives image positions and magnifications as functions of the source position (and shape for extended sources). Preliminary experiments suggest a speed-up of a factor in excess of 10,000 compared with conventional models that instead map from the image plane to the source plane and require iteration to converge upon a unique source. A second virtue is that the Witt–Wynne geometric representation of permits the quick visual verification of the model’s adequacy for a particular lensed system. Unfortunately, the model’s strictly elliptical lens equipotential is inconsistent with strictly elliptical surface mass density contours.The Witt–Wynne construction might nonetheless yield a sufficiently good first approximation to accelerate convergence to one’s preferred lens model. - Open Access
- 29 September 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 170 (4) , 241
The DELVE Quadruple Quasar Search. I. A Lensed Low-luminosity Active Galactic Nucleus
A quadruply lensed source, J125856.3–031944, has been discovered using the DELVE survey and Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer W1–W2 colors. Follow-up direct imaging carried out with the Magellan Baade 6.5 m telescope is analyzed, as is spectroscopy from the 2.5 m Nordic Optical Telescope. The lensed image configuration is kite-like, with the major axis of the lensing galaxy along the symmetry axis of the kite, and with the faintest image at its tail. Redward of 6000 Å, the tail image is strongly blended with the lensing galaxy. The Sloan g direct imaging carried out with Magellan permits deblending. As the lensed image configuration is nearly circular, simple models give high predicted magnifications for all four images. The source’s narrow emission lines at redshift z = 2.225 and low intrinsic luminosity qualify it as a type 2 active galactic nucleus. The Magellan image shows a substantial residual that suggests a second lensing galaxy.
- 29 September 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 170 (4) , 241
Open AccessThe DELVE Quadruple Quasar Search. I. A Lensed Low-luminosity Active Galactic Nucleus
A quadruply lensed source, J125856.3–031944, has been discovered using the DELVE survey and Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer W1–W2 colors. Follow-up direct imaging carried out with the Magellan Baade 6.5 m telescope is analyzed, as is spectroscopy from the 2.5 m Nordic Optical Telescope. The lensed image configuration is kite-like, with the major axis of the lensing galaxy along the symmetry axis of the kite, and with the faintest image at its tail. Redward of 6000 Å, the tail image is strongly blended with the lensing galaxy. The Sloan g direct imaging carried out with Magellan permits deblending. As the lensed image configuration is nearly circular, simple models give high predicted magnifications for all four images. The source’s narrow emission lines at redshift z = 2.225 and low intrinsic luminosity qualify it as a type 2 active galactic nucleus. The Magellan image shows a substantial residual that suggests a second lensing galaxy.
- Open Access
- 30 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Space Science Reviews
- Vol. 221 (4) , 1-24
Basic Elements of Strong Gravitational Lensing
Even when used to describe the same phenomenon, equations, graphics and words each give different perspectives and lead to complementary insights. The basic elements of strong gravitational lensing are introduced here favoring words and graphics over equations whenever possible. Fermat’s principle is the fundamental driver of strong lensing. Three “D’s” encapsulate the essential effects of lensing: Delay, Deflection and Distortion. Gravity and geometry both contribute to the delay of photons from a lensed source. Their interplay determines how the images of a source are deflected and how they are stretched or compressed. Caustics and critical curves are explained. Images of doubly, triply, quadruply and quintuply lensed sources are displayed. A table of symbols, their definitions and distinctions provides a summary of the basic elements of strong lensing.
- 30 May 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Space Science Reviews
- Vol. 221 (4) , 1-24
Open AccessBasic Elements of Strong Gravitational Lensing
Even when used to describe the same phenomenon, equations, graphics and words each give different perspectives and lead to complementary insights. The basic elements of strong gravitational lensing are introduced here favoring words and graphics over equations whenever possible. Fermat’s principle is the fundamental driver of strong lensing. Three “D’s” encapsulate the essential effects of lensing: Delay, Deflection and Distortion. Gravity and geometry both contribute to the delay of photons from a lensed source. Their interplay determines how the images of a source are deflected and how they are stretched or compressed. Caustics and critical curves are explained. Images of doubly, triply, quadruply and quintuply lensed sources are displayed. A table of symbols, their definitions and distinctions provides a summary of the basic elements of strong lensing.
- Open Access
Basic Elements of Strong Gravitational Lensing
Even when used to describe the same phenomenon, equations, graphics and words each give different perspectives and lead to complementary insights. The basic elements of strong gravitational lensing are introduced here favoring words and graphics over equations whenever possible. Fermat's principle is the fundamental driver of strong lensing. Three "D's'' encapsulate the essential effects of lensing: Delay, Deflection and Distortion. Gravity and geometry both contribute to the delay of photons from a lensed source. Their interplay determines how the images of a source are deflected and how they are stretched or compressed. Caustics and critical curves are explained. Images of doubly, triply, quadruply and quintuply lensed sources are displayed. A table of symbols, their definitions and distinctions provides a summary of the basic elements of strong lensing.
Open AccessBasic Elements of Strong Gravitational Lensing
Even when used to describe the same phenomenon, equations, graphics and words each give different perspectives and lead to complementary insights. The basic elements of strong gravitational lensing are introduced here favoring words and graphics over equations whenever possible. Fermat's principle is the fundamental driver of strong lensing. Three "D's'' encapsulate the essential effects of lensing: Delay, Deflection and Distortion. Gravity and geometry both contribute to the delay of photons from a lensed source. Their interplay determines how the images of a source are deflected and how they are stretched or compressed. Caustics and critical curves are explained. Images of doubly, triply, quadruply and quintuply lensed sources are displayed. A table of symbols, their definitions and distinctions provides a summary of the basic elements of strong lensing.
- Open Access
- 29 October 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 975 (1) , 62
Witt’s Hyperbola Is Both Predicted and Observed to Pass Close to the Lensing Galaxies in Quadruple Quasars
When a rectangular hyperbola is constructed from the image positions of a quadruply lensed quasar, as proposed by Witt, it passes very close to the lensing galaxy. The median measured perpendicular offset between the observed light center of the lens and Witt’s hyperbola is 0.″013 for a sample for 39 systems lensed by a relatively isolated galaxy. The family of lens models adopted by Witt predicts that the lens lies on the hyperbola, but its position is not used for its construction. The median offset corresponds to roughly 1% of the Einstein ring radius and suggests that the centers of the lensing potential are close to the light centers of the lens. By putting a restrictive prior on the perpendicular distance to Witt’s hyperbola (or on the distance between the galaxy and the potential), one reduces by one the dimensionality of a model space when fitting data. Taking the brightest pixel of a lensing galaxy as its center avoids a shortcoming of using the average light center for a constraint.
- 29 October 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 975 (1) , 62
Open AccessWitt’s Hyperbola Is Both Predicted and Observed to Pass Close to the Lensing Galaxies in Quadruple Quasars
When a rectangular hyperbola is constructed from the image positions of a quadruply lensed quasar, as proposed by Witt, it passes very close to the lensing galaxy. The median measured perpendicular offset between the observed light center of the lens and Witt’s hyperbola is 0.″013 for a sample for 39 systems lensed by a relatively isolated galaxy. The family of lens models adopted by Witt predicts that the lens lies on the hyperbola, but its position is not used for its construction. The median offset corresponds to roughly 1% of the Einstein ring radius and suggests that the centers of the lensing potential are close to the light centers of the lens. By putting a restrictive prior on the perpendicular distance to Witt’s hyperbola (or on the distance between the galaxy and the potential), one reduces by one the dimensionality of a model space when fitting data. Taking the brightest pixel of a lensing galaxy as its center avoids a shortcoming of using the average light center for a constraint.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 962 (2) , 108
A Malmquist-like Bias in the Inferred Areas of Diamond Caustics and Consequences for the Inferred Time Delays of Gravitationally Lensed Quasars
Quasars are quadruply lensed only when they lie within the diamond caustic of a lensing galaxy. This precondition produces a Malmquist-like selection effect in observed populations of quadruply lensed quasars, overestimating the true caustic area. The bias toward high values of the inferred logarithmic area, ln A inf , is proportional to the square of the error in that area, σ ln A 2 . In effect, Malmquist’s correction compensates posthoc for a failure to incorporate a prior into parameter optimization. Inferred time delays are proportional to the square root of the inferred caustic area of the lensing galaxy. Model time delays are biased long, leading to overestimates of the Hubble constant. Crude estimates of σ ln A for a sample of 13 quadruple systems give a median value of 0.16. We identify a second effect, an “inferred magnification bias,” resulting from the combination of selection by apparent magnitude and errors in model magnification. It is strongly anticorrelated with caustic area bias, and almost always leads to underestimates of the Hubble constant. Malmquist’s scheme can be adapted to priors on multiple parameters, but for quad lenses, the negative covariances between caustic area and absolute magnitude are poorly known. Inferred magnification bias may even cancel out caustic area bias, depending upon (among other things) the slope of the number–magnitude relation for the sample. Proper correction for these combined effects can, in principle, be built into Bayesian modeling schemes as priors, eliminating the need for a Malmquist-style approximation, but is likely to be challenging in practice.
- 1 February 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 962 (2) , 108
Open AccessA Malmquist-like Bias in the Inferred Areas of Diamond Caustics and Consequences for the Inferred Time Delays of Gravitationally Lensed Quasars
Quasars are quadruply lensed only when they lie within the diamond caustic of a lensing galaxy. This precondition produces a Malmquist-like selection effect in observed populations of quadruply lensed quasars, overestimating the true caustic area. The bias toward high values of the inferred logarithmic area, ln A inf , is proportional to the square of the error in that area, σ ln A 2 . In effect, Malmquist’s correction compensates posthoc for a failure to incorporate a prior into parameter optimization. Inferred time delays are proportional to the square root of the inferred caustic area of the lensing galaxy. Model time delays are biased long, leading to overestimates of the Hubble constant. Crude estimates of σ ln A for a sample of 13 quadruple systems give a median value of 0.16. We identify a second effect, an “inferred magnification bias,” resulting from the combination of selection by apparent magnitude and errors in model magnification. It is strongly anticorrelated with caustic area bias, and almost always leads to underestimates of the Hubble constant. Malmquist’s scheme can be adapted to priors on multiple parameters, but for quad lenses, the negative covariances between caustic area and absolute magnitude are poorly known. Inferred magnification bias may even cancel out caustic area bias, depending upon (among other things) the slope of the number–magnitude relation for the sample. Proper correction for these combined effects can, in principle, be built into Bayesian modeling schemes as priors, eliminating the need for a Malmquist-style approximation, but is likely to be challenging in practice.
- Open Access
A Malmquist-like bias in the inferred areas of diamond caustics and consequences for inferred time delays of gravitationally lensed quasars
Quasars are quadruply lensed only when they lie within the diamond caustic of a lensing galaxy. This precondition produces a Malmquist-like selection effect in observed populations of quadruply lensed quasars, overestimating the true caustic area. The bias toward high values of the inferred logarithmic area, $\ln A_{inf}$, is proportional to the square of the error in that area, $\sigma^2_{\ln{A}}$. In effect, Malmquist's correction compensates post-hoc for a failure to incorporate a prior into parameter optimization. Inferred time delays are proportional to the square root of the inferred caustic area of the lensing galaxy. Model time delays are biased long, leading to overestimates of the Hubble constant. Crude estimates of $\sigma_{\ln A}$ for a sample of 13 quadruple systems give a median value of 0.16. We identify a second effect, "inferred magnification bias,'' resulting from the combination of selection by apparent magnitude and errors in model magnification. It is strongly anti-correlated with caustic area bias, and almost always leads to underestimates of the Hubble constant. Malmquist's scheme can be adapted to priors on multiple parameters, but for quad lenses, the negative covariances between caustic area and absolute magnitude are poorly known. Inferred magnification bias may even cancel out caustic area bias, depending upon (among other things) the slope of the number magnitude relation for the sample. Proper correction for these combined effects can, in principle, be built into Bayesian modeling schemes as priors, eliminating the need for Malmquist-style approximation, but is likely to be challenging in practice.Open AccessA Malmquist-like bias in the inferred areas of diamond caustics and consequences for inferred time delays of gravitationally lensed quasars
Quasars are quadruply lensed only when they lie within the diamond caustic of a lensing galaxy. This precondition produces a Malmquist-like selection effect in observed populations of quadruply lensed quasars, overestimating the true caustic area. The bias toward high values of the inferred logarithmic area, $\ln A_{inf}$, is proportional to the square of the error in that area, $\sigma^2_{\ln{A}}$. In effect, Malmquist's correction compensates post-hoc for a failure to incorporate a prior into parameter optimization. Inferred time delays are proportional to the square root of the inferred caustic area of the lensing galaxy. Model time delays are biased long, leading to overestimates of the Hubble constant. Crude estimates of $\sigma_{\ln A}$ for a sample of 13 quadruple systems give a median value of 0.16. We identify a second effect, "inferred magnification bias,'' resulting from the combination of selection by apparent magnitude and errors in model magnification. It is strongly anti-correlated with caustic area bias, and almost always leads to underestimates of the Hubble constant. Malmquist's scheme can be adapted to priors on multiple parameters, but for quad lenses, the negative covariances between caustic area and absolute magnitude are poorly known. Inferred magnification bias may even cancel out caustic area bias, depending upon (among other things) the slope of the number magnitude relation for the sample. Proper correction for these combined effects can, in principle, be built into Bayesian modeling schemes as priors, eliminating the need for Malmquist-style approximation, but is likely to be challenging in practice. - 20 December 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 520 (3) , 3305-3328
Gravitationally lensed quasars in Gaia – IV. 150 new lenses, quasar pairs, and projected quasars
We report the spectroscopic follow-up of 175 lensed quasar candidates selected using Gaia Data Release 2 observations following Lemon et al. 2019. Systems include 86 confirmed lensed quasars and a further 17 likely lensed quasars based on imaging and/or similar spectra. We also confirm 11 projected quasar pairs and 11 physical quasar pairs, while 25 systems are left as unclassified quasar pairs – pairs of quasars at the same redshift, which could be either distinct quasars or potential lensed quasars. Especially interesting objects include 8 quadruply imaged quasars of which two have BAL sources, an apparent triple, and a doubly lensed LoBaL quasar. The source redshifts and image separations of these new lenses range between 0.65–3.59 and 0.78–6.23″ respectively. We compare the known population of lensed quasars to an updated mock catalogue at image separations between 1 and 4 arcseconds, showing a very good match at z < 1.5. At z > 1.5, only 47% of the predicted number are known, with 56% of these missing lenses at image separations below 1.5″. The missing higher-redshift, small-separation systems will have fainter lensing galaxies, and are partially explained by the unclassified quasar pairs and likely lenses presented in this work, which require deeper imaging. Of the 11 new reported projected quasar pairs, 5 have impact parameters below 10 kpc, almost tripling the number of such systems, which can probe the innermost regions of quasar host galaxies through absorption studies. We also report four new lensed galaxies discovered through our searches, with source redshifts ranging from 0.62 to 2.79.
- 20 December 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 520 (3) , 3305-3328
Gravitationally lensed quasars in Gaia – IV. 150 new lenses, quasar pairs, and projected quasars
We report the spectroscopic follow-up of 175 lensed quasar candidates selected using Gaia Data Release 2 observations following Lemon et al. 2019. Systems include 86 confirmed lensed quasars and a further 17 likely lensed quasars based on imaging and/or similar spectra. We also confirm 11 projected quasar pairs and 11 physical quasar pairs, while 25 systems are left as unclassified quasar pairs – pairs of quasars at the same redshift, which could be either distinct quasars or potential lensed quasars. Especially interesting objects include 8 quadruply imaged quasars of which two have BAL sources, an apparent triple, and a doubly lensed LoBaL quasar. The source redshifts and image separations of these new lenses range between 0.65–3.59 and 0.78–6.23″ respectively. We compare the known population of lensed quasars to an updated mock catalogue at image separations between 1 and 4 arcseconds, showing a very good match at z < 1.5. At z > 1.5, only 47% of the predicted number are known, with 56% of these missing lenses at image separations below 1.5″. The missing higher-redshift, small-separation systems will have fainter lensing galaxies, and are partially explained by the unclassified quasar pairs and likely lenses presented in this work, which require deeper imaging. Of the 11 new reported projected quasar pairs, 5 have impact parameters below 10 kpc, almost tripling the number of such systems, which can probe the innermost regions of quasar host galaxies through absorption studies. We also report four new lensed galaxies discovered through our searches, with source redshifts ranging from 0.62 to 2.79.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2022
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 164 (4) , 120
The Quadruple Image Configurations of Asymptotically Circular Gravitational Lenses
The quadruple image configurations of gravitational lenses with vanishing ellipticity are examined. Even though such lenses asymptotically approach circularity, the configurations are stable if the position of the source relative to the vanishing diamond caustic is held constant. The configurations are the solutions of a quartic equation, an “asymptotically circular lens equation,” parameterized by a single complex quantity. Several alternative parameterizations are examined. Relative magnifications of the images are derived. When a nonvanishing quadrupole, in the form of an external shear (XS), is added to the singular isothermal sphere (SIS), its configurations emerge naturally as stretched and squeezed versions of the circular configurations. And as the SIS+XS model is a good first approximation for most quadruply lensed quasars, their configurations likewise have only 2 + 1 salient dimensions. The asymptotically circular configurations can easily be adapted to the problem of solar system “occultation flashes.”
- 1 September 2022
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 164 (4) , 120
Open AccessThe Quadruple Image Configurations of Asymptotically Circular Gravitational Lenses
The quadruple image configurations of gravitational lenses with vanishing ellipticity are examined. Even though such lenses asymptotically approach circularity, the configurations are stable if the position of the source relative to the vanishing diamond caustic is held constant. The configurations are the solutions of a quartic equation, an “asymptotically circular lens equation,” parameterized by a single complex quantity. Several alternative parameterizations are examined. Relative magnifications of the images are derived. When a nonvanishing quadrupole, in the form of an external shear (XS), is added to the singular isothermal sphere (SIS), its configurations emerge naturally as stretched and squeezed versions of the circular configurations. And as the SIS+XS model is a good first approximation for most quadruply lensed quasars, their configurations likewise have only 2 + 1 salient dimensions. The asymptotically circular configurations can easily be adapted to the problem of solar system “occultation flashes.”