Philip Wiseman
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Philip Wiseman has a total of 1000 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mark Sullivan
School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton , Southampton SO17 1BJ
30 shared publications D Brooks
University College London Department of Physics & Astronomy Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT
28 shared publications- Llu'Is Galbany
Institute of Space Sciences (ICE, CSIC), Campus UAB, Carrer de Can Magrans, s/n
28 shared publications - Tamara M. Davis
School of Mathematics and Physics, University of Queensland , Brisbane, QLD 4072
28 shared publications D J James
Australian Astronomical Optics, Macquarie University , North Ryde, NSW 2113
27 shared publicationsG Tarle
University of Michigan Department of Physics Ann Arbor, MI 48109
27 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 April 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1002 (1) , 95
Dimensional Reduction for Sampled Priors and Application to Photometric Redshift Distributions
A typical Bayesian inference on the values of some parameters of interest q from some data D involves running a Markov Chain (MC) to sample from the posterior p ( q , n ∣ D ) ∝ L ( D ∣ q , n ) p ( q ) p ( n ) , where n are some nuisance parameters with a separable prior. In some cases, the nuisance parameters are high-dimensional, and their prior p ( n ) is itself defined only by a set of samples that have been drawn from some other MC. The MC for the posterior will typically require evaluation of p ( n ) at arbitrary values of n , i.e., one needs to provide a density estimator over the full n space from the provided samples. But the high dimensionality of n hinders both the density estimation and the efficiency of the MC for the posterior. We describe a solution to this problem: a linear compression of the n space into a much lower-dimensional space u , which projects away directions in n space that cannot appreciably alter L . The algorithm for doing so is a slight modification to principal components analysis, and is less restrictive on p ( n ) than other proposed solutions to this issue. We demonstrate this “mode projection” technique using the analysis of 2-point correlation functions of weak lensing fields and galaxy density in the Dark Energy Survey, where n is a binned representation of the redshift distribution n ( z ) of the galaxies.
- 28 April 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1002 (1) , 95
Open AccessDimensional Reduction for Sampled Priors and Application to Photometric Redshift Distributions
A typical Bayesian inference on the values of some parameters of interest q from some data D involves running a Markov Chain (MC) to sample from the posterior p ( q , n ∣ D ) ∝ L ( D ∣ q , n ) p ( q ) p ( n ) , where n are some nuisance parameters with a separable prior. In some cases, the nuisance parameters are high-dimensional, and their prior p ( n ) is itself defined only by a set of samples that have been drawn from some other MC. The MC for the posterior will typically require evaluation of p ( n ) at arbitrary values of n , i.e., one needs to provide a density estimator over the full n space from the provided samples. But the high dimensionality of n hinders both the density estimation and the efficiency of the MC for the posterior. We describe a solution to this problem: a linear compression of the n space into a much lower-dimensional space u , which projects away directions in n space that cannot appreciably alter L . The algorithm for doing so is a slight modification to principal components analysis, and is less restrictive on p ( n ) than other proposed solutions to this issue. We demonstrate this “mode projection” technique using the analysis of 2-point correlation functions of weak lensing fields and galaxy density in the Dark Energy Survey, where n is a binned representation of the redshift distribution n ( z ) of the galaxies.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
The Dark Energy Survey Supernova Program: A Reanalysis Of Cosmology Results And Evidence For Evolving Dark Energy With An Updated Type Ia Supernova Calibration
We present improved cosmological constraints from a re-analysis of the Dark Energy Survey (DES) 5-year sample of Type Ia supernovae (DES-SN5YR). This re-analysis includes an improved photometric cross-calibration, recent white dwarf observations to cross-calibrate between DES and low redshift surveys, retraining the SALT3 light curve model and fixing a numerical approximation in the host galaxy colour law. Our fully recalibrated sample, which we call DES-Dovekie, comprises ∼1600 likely Type Ia SNe from DES and ∼200 low-redshift SNe from other surveys. With DES-Dovekie, we obtain Ωm = 0.330 ± 0.015 in Flat ΛCDM which changes Ωm by −0.022 compared to DES-SN5YR. Combining DES-Dovekie with CMB data from Planck, ACT and SPT and the DESI DR2 measurements in a Flat w0waCDM cosmology, we find w0 = −0.803 ± 0.054, wa = −0.72 ± 0.21. Our results hold a significance of 3.2σ, reduced from 4.2σ for DES-SN5YR, to reject the null hypothesis that the data are compatible with the cosmological constant. This significance is equivalent to a Bayesian model preference odds of approximately 5:1 in favour of the Flat w0waCDM model. Using generally accepted thresholds for model preference, our updated data exhibits only a weak preference for evolving dark energy.
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe Dark Energy Survey Supernova Program: A Reanalysis Of Cosmology Results And Evidence For Evolving Dark Energy With An Updated Type Ia Supernova Calibration
We present improved cosmological constraints from a re-analysis of the Dark Energy Survey (DES) 5-year sample of Type Ia supernovae (DES-SN5YR). This re-analysis includes an improved photometric cross-calibration, recent white dwarf observations to cross-calibrate between DES and low redshift surveys, retraining the SALT3 light curve model and fixing a numerical approximation in the host galaxy colour law. Our fully recalibrated sample, which we call DES-Dovekie, comprises ∼1600 likely Type Ia SNe from DES and ∼200 low-redshift SNe from other surveys. With DES-Dovekie, we obtain Ωm = 0.330 ± 0.015 in Flat ΛCDM which changes Ωm by −0.022 compared to DES-SN5YR. Combining DES-Dovekie with CMB data from Planck, ACT and SPT and the DESI DR2 measurements in a Flat w0waCDM cosmology, we find w0 = −0.803 ± 0.054, wa = −0.72 ± 0.21. Our results hold a significance of 3.2σ, reduced from 4.2σ for DES-SN5YR, to reject the null hypothesis that the data are compatible with the cosmological constant. This significance is equivalent to a Bayesian model preference odds of approximately 5:1 in favour of the Flat w0waCDM model. Using generally accepted thresholds for model preference, our updated data exhibits only a weak preference for evolving dark energy.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 708, A139
Infrared observations reveal the reprocessing envelope in the tidal disruption event AT 2019azh
Context. Tidal disruption events (TDEs) are expected to release much of their energy in the far-ultraviolet (UV), which we do not observe directly. However, infrared (IR) observations can observe re-radiation of the optical/UV emission from dust, and if this dust is observed in the process of sublimation, we can infer the un-observed UV radiated energy. Tidal disruption events have also been predicted to show spectra shallower than a blackbody in the IR, but this has not yet been observed. Aims. We present IR observations of the TDE AT 2019azh that span from −3 d before the peak until > 1750 d after. We evaluate these observations for consistency with dust emission or direct emission from the TDE. Methods. We fitted the IR data with a modified blackbody associated with dust emission. We compared the UV+optical+IR data with simulated spectra produced from general relativistic radiation magnetohydrodynamics simulations of super-Eddington accretion. We modelled the data at later times (> 200 d) as an IR echo. Results. The IR data at the maximum light cannot be self-consistently fitted with dust emission. Instead, the data can be better fitted with a reprocessing model, with the IR excess arising due to the absorption opacity being dominated by free-free processes in the dense reprocessing envelope. We infer a large viewing angle of ∼60°, which is consistent with previously reported X-ray observations, and a tidally disrupted star with a mass > 2 M ⊙ . The IR emission at later times is consistent with cool dust emission. We modelled these data as an IR echo and found that the dust is distant (0.65 pc) and clumpy, with a low covering factor. We show that TDEs can have an IR excess that does not arise from dust and that IR observations at early times can constrain the viewing angle for the TDE in the unified model. Near-IR observations are therefore essential to distinguish between hot dust and a non-thermal IR excess.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 708, A139
Open AccessInfrared observations reveal the reprocessing envelope in the tidal disruption event AT 2019azh
Context. Tidal disruption events (TDEs) are expected to release much of their energy in the far-ultraviolet (UV), which we do not observe directly. However, infrared (IR) observations can observe re-radiation of the optical/UV emission from dust, and if this dust is observed in the process of sublimation, we can infer the un-observed UV radiated energy. Tidal disruption events have also been predicted to show spectra shallower than a blackbody in the IR, but this has not yet been observed. Aims. We present IR observations of the TDE AT 2019azh that span from −3 d before the peak until > 1750 d after. We evaluate these observations for consistency with dust emission or direct emission from the TDE. Methods. We fitted the IR data with a modified blackbody associated with dust emission. We compared the UV+optical+IR data with simulated spectra produced from general relativistic radiation magnetohydrodynamics simulations of super-Eddington accretion. We modelled the data at later times (> 200 d) as an IR echo. Results. The IR data at the maximum light cannot be self-consistently fitted with dust emission. Instead, the data can be better fitted with a reprocessing model, with the IR excess arising due to the absorption opacity being dominated by free-free processes in the dense reprocessing envelope. We infer a large viewing angle of ∼60°, which is consistent with previously reported X-ray observations, and a tidally disrupted star with a mass > 2 M ⊙ . The IR emission at later times is consistent with cool dust emission. We modelled these data as an IR echo and found that the dust is distant (0.65 pc) and clumpy, with a low covering factor. We show that TDEs can have an IR excess that does not arise from dust and that IR observations at early times can constrain the viewing angle for the TDE in the unified model. Near-IR observations are therefore essential to distinguish between hot dust and a non-thermal IR excess.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 February 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series
- Vol. 282 (2) , 62
Dark Energy Survey Year 6 Results: Photometric Dataset for Cosmology
We describe the photometric dataset assembled from the full 6 yr of observations by the Dark Energy Survey (DES) in support of static-sky cosmology analyses. DES Y6 Gold is a curated dataset derived from DES Data Release 2 (DR2) that incorporates improved measurement, photometric calibration, object classification and value-added information. Y6 Gold comprises nearly 5000 deg 2 of grizY imaging in the south Galactic cap and includes 669 million objects with a depth of i AB ∼ 23.4 mag at a signal-to-noise ratio ∼ 10 for extended objects and a top-of-the-atmosphere photometric uniformity i AB < 22.5. Additionally, it includes per-object quality information, and accompanying maps of the footprint coverage, masked regions, imaging depth, survey conditions, and astrophysical foregrounds that are used for cosmology analyses. After quality selections, benchmark samples contain 448 million galaxies and 120 million stars. This publication is complemented by data access and documentation.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series
- Vol. 282 (2) , 62
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessDark Energy Survey Year 6 Results: Photometric Dataset for Cosmology
We describe the photometric dataset assembled from the full 6 yr of observations by the Dark Energy Survey (DES) in support of static-sky cosmology analyses. DES Y6 Gold is a curated dataset derived from DES Data Release 2 (DR2) that incorporates improved measurement, photometric calibration, object classification and value-added information. Y6 Gold comprises nearly 5000 deg 2 of grizY imaging in the south Galactic cap and includes 669 million objects with a depth of i AB ∼ 23.4 mag at a signal-to-noise ratio ∼ 10 for extended objects and a top-of-the-atmosphere photometric uniformity i AB < 22.5. Additionally, it includes per-object quality information, and accompanying maps of the footprint coverage, masked regions, imaging depth, survey conditions, and astrophysical foregrounds that are used for cosmology analyses. After quality selections, benchmark samples contain 448 million galaxies and 120 million stars. This publication is complemented by data access and documentation.
- Open Access
- 10 October 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 992 (1) , 158
TiDES: The 4MOST Time Domain Extragalactic Survey
The Time Domain Extragalactic Survey (TiDES) conducted on the 4 m Multi-Object Spectroscopic Telescope will perform spectroscopic follow-up of extragalactic transients discovered in the era of the NSF-DOE Vera C. Rubin Observatory. TiDES will conduct a 5 yr survey, covering > 14 , 000 square degrees , and use around 250,000 fibre hours to address three main science goals: (i) spectroscopic observations of >30,000 live transients, (ii) comprehensive follow-up of >200,000 host galaxies to obtain redshift measurements, and (iii) repeat spectroscopic observations of active galactic nuclei to enable reverberation mapping studies. The live spectra from TiDES will be used to reveal the diversity and astrophysics of both normal and exotic supernovae across the luminosity-timescale plane. The extensive host-galaxy redshift campaign will allow exploitation of the larger sample of supernovae and improve photometric classification, providing the largest-ever sample of SNe Ia, capable of a sub-2% measurement of the equation-of-state of dark energy. Finally, the TiDES reverberation mapping experiment of 700–1000 AGN will complement the SN Ia sample and extend the Hubble diagram to z ∼ 2.5.
- 10 October 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 992 (1) , 158
Open AccessTiDES: The 4MOST Time Domain Extragalactic Survey
The Time Domain Extragalactic Survey (TiDES) conducted on the 4 m Multi-Object Spectroscopic Telescope will perform spectroscopic follow-up of extragalactic transients discovered in the era of the NSF-DOE Vera C. Rubin Observatory. TiDES will conduct a 5 yr survey, covering > 14 , 000 square degrees , and use around 250,000 fibre hours to address three main science goals: (i) spectroscopic observations of >30,000 live transients, (ii) comprehensive follow-up of >200,000 host galaxies to obtain redshift measurements, and (iii) repeat spectroscopic observations of active galactic nuclei to enable reverberation mapping studies. The live spectra from TiDES will be used to reveal the diversity and astrophysics of both normal and exotic supernovae across the luminosity-timescale plane. The extensive host-galaxy redshift campaign will allow exploitation of the larger sample of supernovae and improve photometric classification, providing the largest-ever sample of SNe Ia, capable of a sub-2% measurement of the equation-of-state of dark energy. Finally, the TiDES reverberation mapping experiment of 700–1000 AGN will complement the SN Ia sample and extend the Hubble diagram to z ∼ 2.5.
- Open Access
- 17 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 543 (3) , 2180-2203
The dependence of the Type Ia Supernova colour–luminosity relation on their host galaxy properties
Using the Dark Energy Survey 5-yr sample, we determine the properties of type Ia supernova (SN Ia) host galaxies across a wide multiwavelength range – from the optical to far-infrared – including data from the Herschel and Spitzer space telescopes. We categorize the SNe Ia into three distinct groups according to the distribution of their host galaxies on the star formation rate (SFR) – stellar mass ($M_\star$) plane. Each region comprises host galaxies at distinct stages in their evolutionary pathways: Region 1 – low-mass hosts; Region 2 – high-mass, star-forming hosts and Region 3 – high-mass, passive hosts. We find SNe Ia in host galaxies located in Region 1 have the steepest slope (quantified by $\beta$) between their colours and luminosities, with $\beta _{\mathrm{R_1}} = 3.51 \pm 0.16$. This differs at the ${\sim }6\sigma$ significance level to SNe Ia in Region 3, which have the shallowest colour–luminosity slope with $\beta _{\mathrm{R_3}} = 2.12 \pm 0.16$. After correcting SNe Ia in each subsample by their respective $\beta$, events in Region 3 (high-mass, passive hosts) are $0.07 - 0.12$ mag ($>3\sigma$) brighter, post-standardization. We conclude that future cosmological analyses should apply standardization relations to SNe Ia based upon the region in which the SN host galaxy lies in the SFR–$M_\star$ plane. Alternatively, cosmological analyses should restrict the SN Ia sample to events whose host galaxies occupy a single region of this plane.- 17 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 543 (3) , 2180-2203
Open AccessThe dependence of the Type Ia Supernova colour–luminosity relation on their host galaxy properties
Using the Dark Energy Survey 5-yr sample, we determine the properties of type Ia supernova (SN Ia) host galaxies across a wide multiwavelength range – from the optical to far-infrared – including data from the Herschel and Spitzer space telescopes. We categorize the SNe Ia into three distinct groups according to the distribution of their host galaxies on the star formation rate (SFR) – stellar mass ($M_\star$) plane. Each region comprises host galaxies at distinct stages in their evolutionary pathways: Region 1 – low-mass hosts; Region 2 – high-mass, star-forming hosts and Region 3 – high-mass, passive hosts. We find SNe Ia in host galaxies located in Region 1 have the steepest slope (quantified by $\beta$) between their colours and luminosities, with $\beta _{\mathrm{R_1}} = 3.51 \pm 0.16$. This differs at the ${\sim }6\sigma$ significance level to SNe Ia in Region 3, which have the shallowest colour–luminosity slope with $\beta _{\mathrm{R_3}} = 2.12 \pm 0.16$. After correcting SNe Ia in each subsample by their respective $\beta$, events in Region 3 (high-mass, passive hosts) are $0.07 - 0.12$ mag ($>3\sigma$) brighter, post-standardization. We conclude that future cosmological analyses should apply standardization relations to SNe Ia based upon the region in which the SN host galaxy lies in the SFR–$M_\star$ plane. Alternatively, cosmological analyses should restrict the SN Ia sample to events whose host galaxies occupy a single region of this plane. - Open Access
- 28 August 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 543 (1) , 247-272
Testing and combining transient spectral classification tools on 4MOST-like blended spectra
With the 4-metre Multi-Object Spectroscopic Telescope (4MOST) expected to provide an influx of transient spectra when it begins observations in early 2026 we consider the potential for real-time classification of these spectra. We investigate three extant spectroscopic transient classifiers: the Deep Automated Supernova and Host classifier (dash), Next Generation SuperFit (ngsf), and SuperNova IDentification (snid), with a focus on comparing the completeness and purity of the transient samples they produce. We manually simulate fibre losses critical for accurately determining host contamination and use the 4MOST Exposure Time Calculator to produce realistic, 4MOST-like, host-galaxy contaminated spectra. We investigate the three classifiers individually and in all possible combinations. We find that a combination of dash and ngsf can produce a supernova (SN) Ia sample with a purity of 99.9 per cent, while successfully classifying 70 per cent of SNe Ia. However, it struggles to classify non-SN Ia transients. We investigate photometric cuts to transient magnitude and the transient’s fraction of total fibre flux, finding that both can be used to improve non-SN Ia transient classification completeness by 8–44 per cent with SNe Ibc benefitting the most and superluminous (SL) SNe the least. Finally, we present an example classification plan for live classification and the predicted purities and completeness across five transient classes: Ia, Ibc, II, SL, and non-SN transients. We find that it is possible to classify 75 per cent of input spectra with $>$70 per cent purity in all classes except non-SN transients. Precise values can be varied using different classifiers and photometric cuts to suit the needs of a given study.
- 28 August 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 543 (1) , 247-272
Open AccessTesting and combining transient spectral classification tools on 4MOST-like blended spectra
With the 4-metre Multi-Object Spectroscopic Telescope (4MOST) expected to provide an influx of transient spectra when it begins observations in early 2026 we consider the potential for real-time classification of these spectra. We investigate three extant spectroscopic transient classifiers: the Deep Automated Supernova and Host classifier (dash), Next Generation SuperFit (ngsf), and SuperNova IDentification (snid), with a focus on comparing the completeness and purity of the transient samples they produce. We manually simulate fibre losses critical for accurately determining host contamination and use the 4MOST Exposure Time Calculator to produce realistic, 4MOST-like, host-galaxy contaminated spectra. We investigate the three classifiers individually and in all possible combinations. We find that a combination of dash and ngsf can produce a supernova (SN) Ia sample with a purity of 99.9 per cent, while successfully classifying 70 per cent of SNe Ia. However, it struggles to classify non-SN Ia transients. We investigate photometric cuts to transient magnitude and the transient’s fraction of total fibre flux, finding that both can be used to improve non-SN Ia transient classification completeness by 8–44 per cent with SNe Ibc benefitting the most and superluminous (SL) SNe the least. Finally, we present an example classification plan for live classification and the predicted purities and completeness across five transient classes: Ia, Ibc, II, SL, and non-SN transients. We find that it is possible to classify 75 per cent of input spectra with $>$70 per cent purity in all classes except non-SN transients. Precise values can be varied using different classifiers and photometric cuts to suit the needs of a given study.
- Open Access
- 8 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 541 (4) , 3837-3850
First joint absorption and Te-based metallicity measured in a GRB host galaxy at z = 4.28 using JWST/NIRSpec
We present the first gamma-ray burst (GRB) host galaxy with a measured absorption line and electron temperature (T$_e$) based metallicity, using the temperature sensitive [O iii]$\lambda$4363 auroral line detected in the JWST/NIRSpec spectrum of the host of GRB 050505 at redshift $z=4.28$. We find that the metallicity of the cold interstellar gas, derived from the absorption lines in the GRB afterglow, of 12 + log(O/H) $\sim 7.7$ is in reasonable agreement with the temperature-based emission line metallicity in the warm gas of the GRB host galaxy, which has values of 12 + log(O/H) = 7.80$\pm$0.19 and 7.96$\pm$0.21 for two common indicators. When using strong emission line diagnostics appropriate for high-z galaxies and sensitive to ionization parameter, we find good agreement between the strong emission line metallicity and the other two methods. Our results imply that, for the host of GRB050505, mixing between the warm and the cold interstellar medium along the line of sight to the GRB is efficient, and that GRB afterglow absorption lines can be a reliable tracer of the metallicity of the galaxy. If confirmed with a large sample, this suggest that metallicities determined via GRB afterglow spectroscopy can be used to trace cosmic chemical evolution to the earliest cosmic epochs and in galaxies far too faint for emission line spectroscopy, even for JWST.- 8 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 541 (4) , 3837-3850
Open AccessFirst joint absorption and Te-based metallicity measured in a GRB host galaxy at z = 4.28 using JWST/NIRSpec
We present the first gamma-ray burst (GRB) host galaxy with a measured absorption line and electron temperature (T$_e$) based metallicity, using the temperature sensitive [O iii]$\lambda$4363 auroral line detected in the JWST/NIRSpec spectrum of the host of GRB 050505 at redshift $z=4.28$. We find that the metallicity of the cold interstellar gas, derived from the absorption lines in the GRB afterglow, of 12 + log(O/H) $\sim 7.7$ is in reasonable agreement with the temperature-based emission line metallicity in the warm gas of the GRB host galaxy, which has values of 12 + log(O/H) = 7.80$\pm$0.19 and 7.96$\pm$0.21 for two common indicators. When using strong emission line diagnostics appropriate for high-z galaxies and sensitive to ionization parameter, we find good agreement between the strong emission line metallicity and the other two methods. Our results imply that, for the host of GRB050505, mixing between the warm and the cold interstellar medium along the line of sight to the GRB is efficient, and that GRB afterglow absorption lines can be a reliable tracer of the metallicity of the galaxy. If confirmed with a large sample, this suggest that metallicities determined via GRB afterglow spectroscopy can be used to trace cosmic chemical evolution to the earliest cosmic epochs and in galaxies far too faint for emission line spectroscopy, even for JWST. - Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 7 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 541 (3) , 2585-2593
Comparing the DES-SN5YR and Pantheon+ SN cosmology analyses: investigation based on ‘evolving dark energy or supernovae systematics’?
Recent cosmological analyses measuring distances of type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) and baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) have all given similar hints at time-evolving dark energy. To examine whether underestimated SN Ia systematics might be driving these results, Efstathiou (2025) compared overlapping SN events between Pantheon+ and DES-SN5YR (20 per cent SNe are in common), and reported evidence for an $\sim$0.04 mag offset between the low- and high-redshift distance measurements of this subsample of events. If this offset is arbitrarily subtracted from the entire DES-SN5YR sample, the preference for evolving dark energy is reduced. In this paper, we show that this offset is mostly due to different corrections for Malmquist bias between the two samples; therefore, an object-to-object comparison can be misleading. Malmquist bias corrections differ between the two analyses for several reasons. First, DES-SN5YR used an improved model of SN Ia luminosity scatter compared to Pantheon+ but the associated scatter-model uncertainties are included in the error budget. Secondly, improvements in host mass estimates in DES-SN5YR also affected SN standardized magnitudes and their bias corrections. Thirdly, and most importantly, the selection functions of the two compilations are significantly different, hence the inferred Malmquist bias corrections. Even if the original scatter model and host properties from Pantheon+ are used instead, the evidence for evolving dark energy from CMB, DESI BAO Year 1 and DES-SN5YR is only reduced from 3.9$\sigma$ to 3.3$\sigma$, consistent with the error budget. Finally, in this investigation, we identify an underestimated systematic uncertainty related to host galaxy property uncertainties, which could increase the final DES-SN5YR error budget by 3 per cent. In conclusion, we confirm the validity of the published DES-SN5YR results.- 7 July 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 541 (3) , 2585-2593
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessComparing the DES-SN5YR and Pantheon+ SN cosmology analyses: investigation based on ‘evolving dark energy or supernovae systematics’?
Recent cosmological analyses measuring distances of type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) and baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) have all given similar hints at time-evolving dark energy. To examine whether underestimated SN Ia systematics might be driving these results, Efstathiou (2025) compared overlapping SN events between Pantheon+ and DES-SN5YR (20 per cent SNe are in common), and reported evidence for an $\sim$0.04 mag offset between the low- and high-redshift distance measurements of this subsample of events. If this offset is arbitrarily subtracted from the entire DES-SN5YR sample, the preference for evolving dark energy is reduced. In this paper, we show that this offset is mostly due to different corrections for Malmquist bias between the two samples; therefore, an object-to-object comparison can be misleading. Malmquist bias corrections differ between the two analyses for several reasons. First, DES-SN5YR used an improved model of SN Ia luminosity scatter compared to Pantheon+ but the associated scatter-model uncertainties are included in the error budget. Secondly, improvements in host mass estimates in DES-SN5YR also affected SN standardized magnitudes and their bias corrections. Thirdly, and most importantly, the selection functions of the two compilations are significantly different, hence the inferred Malmquist bias corrections. Even if the original scatter model and host properties from Pantheon+ are used instead, the evidence for evolving dark energy from CMB, DESI BAO Year 1 and DES-SN5YR is only reduced from 3.9$\sigma$ to 3.3$\sigma$, consistent with the error budget. Finally, in this investigation, we identify an underestimated systematic uncertainty related to host galaxy property uncertainties, which could increase the final DES-SN5YR error budget by 3 per cent. In conclusion, we confirm the validity of the published DES-SN5YR results. - 16 June 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 111 (12)
Improving galaxy cluster selection with the outskirt stellar mass of galaxies
- 16 June 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 111 (12)
Improving galaxy cluster selection with the outskirt stellar mass of galaxies