Jouini T Tuomisto
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Jouini T Tuomisto has a total of 147 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Jouko Tuomisto
Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare, Environmental Health Unit, P.O. Box 95, FI-70701, Kuopio, Finland
7 shared publications- Hannu Kiviranta
Department of Public Health, Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare (THL), Kuopio, Finland
6 shared publications Raimo Pohjanvirta
Department of Food and Environmental Hygiene, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
6 shared publicationsArja Asikainen
Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare, Kuopio, Finland
5 shared publicationsErkki Tukiainen
Department of Plastic Surgery, Helsinki University Hospital, Helsinki, Finland
5 shared publicationsMikko Unkila
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 23 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
- Vol. 198 (6) , 643
Temporal trends and spatial differences of trace elements in osprey eggs in Finland
Time trends and regional differences of total mercury (THg), methylmercury (MeHg), cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), lead (Pb), selenium (Se), zinc (Zn), palladium (Pd), platinum (Pt), and rhodium (Rh) concentrations were studied and toxicological significance of the observed levels was assessed in unhatched osprey ( Pandion haliaetus ) eggs collected by bird ringers in 1972–2005 from 2 to 3 areas in Finland. The study areas were Northern Quark in the Gulf of Bothnia, Baltic Sea, and eutrophic-dystrophic Lake Vanajanselkä, which is affected by industrial emissions. Significant declining trends were found for Pb (average annual decrease 6.9%), Cr (2.8%), MeHg (1.9%), and THg (1.3%), with slightly faster decrease in Northern Quark (7.5%, 3.4%, 3.1%, and 1.8%, respectively) compared to Lake Vanajanselkä (6.9%, 2.6%, 1.2%, and 0.8%, respectively). Metal concentrations in eggs did not exhibit significant regional differences. This pattern aligns with metal concentrations in prey fish from the same areas underscoring the role of long-range atmospheric deposition as the source of exposure. Among the studied metals, only a few eggs with highest THg and Pb concentrations exceeded toxicological thresholds: THg threshold for moderate injury (0.3 µg/g ww) 6.1%, high injury (0.7 µg/g ww) 0.88%, Pb tentative threshold (1.2 µg/g ww) 2.6%. These levels could have contributed to decreased reproductive success. The gradual recovery of the Finnish osprey population during the study period paralleled with declining levels of metals and persistent organic pollutants. This study highlights the value of environmental specimen collections and long-term time series in an apex predator for monitoring aquatic environments. Clinical trial number: not applicable.
- 23 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
- Vol. 198 (6) , 643
Open AccessTemporal trends and spatial differences of trace elements in osprey eggs in Finland
Time trends and regional differences of total mercury (THg), methylmercury (MeHg), cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), lead (Pb), selenium (Se), zinc (Zn), palladium (Pd), platinum (Pt), and rhodium (Rh) concentrations were studied and toxicological significance of the observed levels was assessed in unhatched osprey ( Pandion haliaetus ) eggs collected by bird ringers in 1972–2005 from 2 to 3 areas in Finland. The study areas were Northern Quark in the Gulf of Bothnia, Baltic Sea, and eutrophic-dystrophic Lake Vanajanselkä, which is affected by industrial emissions. Significant declining trends were found for Pb (average annual decrease 6.9%), Cr (2.8%), MeHg (1.9%), and THg (1.3%), with slightly faster decrease in Northern Quark (7.5%, 3.4%, 3.1%, and 1.8%, respectively) compared to Lake Vanajanselkä (6.9%, 2.6%, 1.2%, and 0.8%, respectively). Metal concentrations in eggs did not exhibit significant regional differences. This pattern aligns with metal concentrations in prey fish from the same areas underscoring the role of long-range atmospheric deposition as the source of exposure. Among the studied metals, only a few eggs with highest THg and Pb concentrations exceeded toxicological thresholds: THg threshold for moderate injury (0.3 µg/g ww) 6.1%, high injury (0.7 µg/g ww) 0.88%, Pb tentative threshold (1.2 µg/g ww) 2.6%. These levels could have contributed to decreased reproductive success. The gradual recovery of the Finnish osprey population during the study period paralleled with declining levels of metals and persistent organic pollutants. This study highlights the value of environmental specimen collections and long-term time series in an apex predator for monitoring aquatic environments. Clinical trial number: not applicable.
- Open Access
- 17 March 2026
- Published by DSRPT GbR
- Vol. 4 (1)
A Practical Tool for Sustainable Value-Focused Decision-Making: A Case Study on Climate Actions of Municipalities from the Global North
Research has highlighted the importance of values in sustainability transitions but has not provided practical tools for incorporating them into decision-making. This paper addresses that gap by examining how municipal experts view a digital decision-support tool designed to visualise and communicate the co-benefits and values of climate actions. Through a case study methodology, the research utilises interviews with experts from four municipalities across Australia, Finland, and the United States. The study demonstrates that integrating value-focused thinking and open policy practice can lead to more transparent, inclusive, and context-specific sustainability decision-making. This approach contributes to gradual yet meaningful progress towards circular and sustainable society.
- 17 March 2026
- Published by DSRPT GbR
- Vol. 4 (1)
Open AccessA Practical Tool for Sustainable Value-Focused Decision-Making: A Case Study on Climate Actions of Municipalities from the Global North
Research has highlighted the importance of values in sustainability transitions but has not provided practical tools for incorporating them into decision-making. This paper addresses that gap by examining how municipal experts view a digital decision-support tool designed to visualise and communicate the co-benefits and values of climate actions. Through a case study methodology, the research utilises interviews with experts from four municipalities across Australia, Finland, and the United States. The study demonstrates that integrating value-focused thinking and open policy practice can lead to more transparent, inclusive, and context-specific sustainability decision-making. This approach contributes to gradual yet meaningful progress towards circular and sustainable society.
- Open Access
- 31 December 2025
- Published by DSRPT GbR
- Vol. 3 (2)
Value Profiles as Tools to Understand and Guide Societal Decision Making: Applications for Circular Economy Transitions
Complex transitions toward circular economy face implementation challenges despite broad goal support, stemming from conflicting interests and difficulty making values explicit. We present a framework combining decision support methods with participatory approaches to systematically document stakeholders' factual beliefs and value judgments. The framework organizes policy-relevant information as interconnected objects: actions, scenarios, nodes, hypotheses, impacts, and value profiles. We tested this approach by analyzing 18 Finnish parliamentary candidates' responses to environmental policy questions in a voting advice application, documenting their reasoning within the framework structure. Analysis of 36 contributions produced an insight network of 23 nodes and 12 value profiles. The framework distinguished between factual disagreements and value differences, revealing that apparent conflicts often stemmed from different assumptions rather than different values. This distinction enables more focused debate and sense-making. The approach is relevant for circular economy transitions, where multiple stakeholders must coordinate across value chains and complex trade-offs exist between environmental, economic, and social impacts.
- 31 December 2025
- Published by DSRPT GbR
- Vol. 3 (2)
Open AccessValue Profiles as Tools to Understand and Guide Societal Decision Making: Applications for Circular Economy Transitions
Complex transitions toward circular economy face implementation challenges despite broad goal support, stemming from conflicting interests and difficulty making values explicit. We present a framework combining decision support methods with participatory approaches to systematically document stakeholders' factual beliefs and value judgments. The framework organizes policy-relevant information as interconnected objects: actions, scenarios, nodes, hypotheses, impacts, and value profiles. We tested this approach by analyzing 18 Finnish parliamentary candidates' responses to environmental policy questions in a voting advice application, documenting their reasoning within the framework structure. Analysis of 36 contributions produced an insight network of 23 nodes and 12 value profiles. The framework distinguished between factual disagreements and value differences, revealing that apparent conflicts often stemmed from different assumptions rather than different values. This distinction enables more focused debate and sense-making. The approach is relevant for circular economy transitions, where multiple stakeholders must coordinate across value chains and complex trade-offs exist between environmental, economic, and social impacts.
- Open Access
- 3 September 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (9) , e0308227
Temporal trends (1972–2017) and spatial differences of persistent halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons in osprey eggs in Finland
Time trends and regional differences of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and -furans (PCDD/Fs), polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), polychlorinated naphthalenes (PCNs), DDTs, polybrominated biphenyls (PBBs) and polybrominated diphenylethers (BDEs) were studied in unhatched osprey eggs collected by bird ringers in 1972–2017 from four areas in Finland. Two study areas were from Baltic Sea, Northern Quark and Finnish Archipelago Sea, while the two others were inland lake areas, eutrophicated Lake Vanajanselkä affected by industrial emissions, and Pristine SW Lake Area. The highest concentrations of most compound groups were in Lake Vanajanselkä consistent with high emissions, the predominance of bream as a prey, and higher concentrations in bream compared to other prey fish. Concentrations of all chlorinated compounds decreased significantly in all study areas. Average annual decreases were ∑PCDD/F 2.3–4.9%, ∑PCB 2.2–4.2%, ∑PCN 2.6–7.0% and ∑DDT 7.1–9.5%, primarily in line with decreased levels in prey fish. From 1972 PBBs and BDEs increased significantly until 1990s declining rapidly thereafter. PCDD/F congener profile was dominated by 2,3,4,7,8-PeCDF, except in Lake Vanajanselkä by 1,2,3,6,7,8-HxCDD. PCB congener profile was dominated by PCB 153 in all study areas, followed by PCB 180 and PCB 138. Among dioxin-like compounds PCBs contributed 82%, PCDDs 14% and PCDFs 4% to toxic equivalent quantity (∑TEQ). PCB 126 contributed most to ∑TEQ, followed by 1,2,3,7,8-PeCDD. BDE 47 being the dominant BDE congener, followed by BDE 100. ∑DDT concentrations were relatively similar across all study areas, with DDE contributing about 90%. Productivity of chicks per active nest was significantly decreased in Lake Vanajanselkä, and the likely explanation is embryotoxicity of dioxin-like compounds. It is plausible that dioxin-like compounds influenced embryonic survival among highly exposed ospreys prior to 2010, especially in Lake Vanajanselkä and Northern Quark. However, decreased survival due to DDE-induced eggshell thinning seems unlikely after 1985, and BDE levels were below those potentially causing adverse effects.
- 3 September 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (9) , e0308227
Open AccessTemporal trends (1972–2017) and spatial differences of persistent halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons in osprey eggs in Finland
Time trends and regional differences of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and -furans (PCDD/Fs), polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), polychlorinated naphthalenes (PCNs), DDTs, polybrominated biphenyls (PBBs) and polybrominated diphenylethers (BDEs) were studied in unhatched osprey eggs collected by bird ringers in 1972–2017 from four areas in Finland. Two study areas were from Baltic Sea, Northern Quark and Finnish Archipelago Sea, while the two others were inland lake areas, eutrophicated Lake Vanajanselkä affected by industrial emissions, and Pristine SW Lake Area. The highest concentrations of most compound groups were in Lake Vanajanselkä consistent with high emissions, the predominance of bream as a prey, and higher concentrations in bream compared to other prey fish. Concentrations of all chlorinated compounds decreased significantly in all study areas. Average annual decreases were ∑PCDD/F 2.3–4.9%, ∑PCB 2.2–4.2%, ∑PCN 2.6–7.0% and ∑DDT 7.1–9.5%, primarily in line with decreased levels in prey fish. From 1972 PBBs and BDEs increased significantly until 1990s declining rapidly thereafter. PCDD/F congener profile was dominated by 2,3,4,7,8-PeCDF, except in Lake Vanajanselkä by 1,2,3,6,7,8-HxCDD. PCB congener profile was dominated by PCB 153 in all study areas, followed by PCB 180 and PCB 138. Among dioxin-like compounds PCBs contributed 82%, PCDDs 14% and PCDFs 4% to toxic equivalent quantity (∑TEQ). PCB 126 contributed most to ∑TEQ, followed by 1,2,3,7,8-PeCDD. BDE 47 being the dominant BDE congener, followed by BDE 100. ∑DDT concentrations were relatively similar across all study areas, with DDE contributing about 90%. Productivity of chicks per active nest was significantly decreased in Lake Vanajanselkä, and the likely explanation is embryotoxicity of dioxin-like compounds. It is plausible that dioxin-like compounds influenced embryonic survival among highly exposed ospreys prior to 2010, especially in Lake Vanajanselkä and Northern Quark. However, decreased survival due to DDE-induced eggshell thinning seems unlikely after 1985, and BDE levels were below those potentially causing adverse effects.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Elsevier in Science of The Total Environment
- Vol. 753, 142185
Spatial aspects of the dioxin risk formation in the Baltic Sea: A systematic review
- 1 January 2021
- Published by Elsevier in Science of The Total Environment
- Vol. 753, 142185
Open AccessSpatial aspects of the dioxin risk formation in the Baltic Sea: A systematic review
- 22 May 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Chemosphere
- Vol. 257, 127137
Estimated PCDD/F TEQ and total TEQ concentrations in the serum of 7–10 year old Finnish children
- 22 May 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Chemosphere
- Vol. 257, 127137
Estimated PCDD/F TEQ and total TEQ concentrations in the serum of 7–10 year old Finnish children
- Open Access
An agent-based epidemic model REINA for COVID-19 to identify destructive policies
Background: Countries have adopted disparate policies in tackling the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. For example, South Korea started a vigorous campaign to suppress the virus by testing patients with respiratory symptoms and tracing and isolating all their contacts, and many European countries are trying to slow down the spread of the virus with varying degrees of shutdowns. There is clearly a need for a model that can realistically simulate different policy actions and their impacts on the disease and health care capacity in a country or a region. Specifically, there is a need to identify destructive policies , i.e. policies that are, based on scientific knowledge, worse than an alternative and should not be implemented. Methods: We developed an agent-based model (REINA) using Python and accelerated it by the Cython optimising static compiler. It follows a population over time at individual level at different stages of the disease and estimates the number of patients in hospitals and in intensive care. It estimates death rates and counts based on the treatment available. Any number of interventions can be added on the timeline from a selection including e.g. physical isolation, testing and tracing, and controlling the amount of cases entering the area. The model has open source code and runs online. Results: The model uses the demographics of the Helsinki University Hospital region (1.6 million inhabitants). A mitigation strategy aims to slow down the spread of the epidemic to maintain the hospital capacity by implementing mobility restrictions. A suppression strategy initially consists of the same restrictions but also aggressive testing, tracing, and isolating all coronavirus positive patients and their contacts. The modelling starting point is 2020-02-18. The strategies follow the actual situation until 2020-04-06 and then diverge. The default mitigation scenario with variable 30–40% mobility reduction appears to delay the peak of the epidemic (as intended) but not suppress the disease. In the suppression strategy, active testing and tracing of patients with symptoms and their contacts is implemented in addition to 20–25% mobility reduction. This results in a reduction of the cumulative number of infected individuals from 820 000 to 80 000 and the number of deaths from 6000 to only 640, when compared with the mitigation strategy (during the first year of the epidemic). Discussion: The agent-based model (REINA) can be used to simulate epidemic outcomes for various types of policy actions on a timeline. Our results lend support to the strategy of combining comprehensive testing, contact tracing and targeted isolation measures with social isolation measures. While social isolation is important in the early stages to prevent explosive growth, relying on social isolation alone (the mitigation strategy) appears to be a destructive policy. The open-source nature of the model facilitates rapid further development. The flexibility of the modelling logic supports the future implementation of several already identified refinements in terms of more realistic population models and new types of more specific policy interventions. Improving estimates of epidemic parameters will make it possible to improve modelling accuracy further.
Open AccessAn agent-based epidemic model REINA for COVID-19 to identify destructive policies
Background: Countries have adopted disparate policies in tackling the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. For example, South Korea started a vigorous campaign to suppress the virus by testing patients with respiratory symptoms and tracing and isolating all their contacts, and many European countries are trying to slow down the spread of the virus with varying degrees of shutdowns. There is clearly a need for a model that can realistically simulate different policy actions and their impacts on the disease and health care capacity in a country or a region. Specifically, there is a need to identify destructive policies , i.e. policies that are, based on scientific knowledge, worse than an alternative and should not be implemented. Methods: We developed an agent-based model (REINA) using Python and accelerated it by the Cython optimising static compiler. It follows a population over time at individual level at different stages of the disease and estimates the number of patients in hospitals and in intensive care. It estimates death rates and counts based on the treatment available. Any number of interventions can be added on the timeline from a selection including e.g. physical isolation, testing and tracing, and controlling the amount of cases entering the area. The model has open source code and runs online. Results: The model uses the demographics of the Helsinki University Hospital region (1.6 million inhabitants). A mitigation strategy aims to slow down the spread of the epidemic to maintain the hospital capacity by implementing mobility restrictions. A suppression strategy initially consists of the same restrictions but also aggressive testing, tracing, and isolating all coronavirus positive patients and their contacts. The modelling starting point is 2020-02-18. The strategies follow the actual situation until 2020-04-06 and then diverge. The default mitigation scenario with variable 30–40% mobility reduction appears to delay the peak of the epidemic (as intended) but not suppress the disease. In the suppression strategy, active testing and tracing of patients with symptoms and their contacts is implemented in addition to 20–25% mobility reduction. This results in a reduction of the cumulative number of infected individuals from 820 000 to 80 000 and the number of deaths from 6000 to only 640, when compared with the mitigation strategy (during the first year of the epidemic). Discussion: The agent-based model (REINA) can be used to simulate epidemic outcomes for various types of policy actions on a timeline. Our results lend support to the strategy of combining comprehensive testing, contact tracing and targeted isolation measures with social isolation measures. While social isolation is important in the early stages to prevent explosive growth, relying on social isolation alone (the mitigation strategy) appears to be a destructive policy. The open-source nature of the model facilitates rapid further development. The flexibility of the modelling logic supports the future implementation of several already identified refinements in terms of more realistic population models and new types of more specific policy interventions. Improving estimates of epidemic parameters will make it possible to improve modelling accuracy further.
- Open Access
- 3 April 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Research Policy and Systems
- Vol. 18 (1) , 1-24
From insight network to open policy practice: practical experiences
Background: Evidence-informed decision-making and better use of scientific information in societal decisions has been an area of development for decades but is still topical. Decision support work can be viewed from the perspective of information collection, synthesis and flow between decision-makers, experts and stakeholders. Open policy practice is a coherent set of methods for such work. It has been developed and utilised mostly in Finnish and European contexts.Methods: An overview of open policy practice is given, and theoretical and practical properties are evaluated based on properties of good policy support. The evaluation is based on information from several assessments and research projects developing and applying open policy practice and the authors’ practical experiences. The methods are evaluated against their capability of producing quality of content, applicability and efficiency in policy support as well as how well they support close interaction among participants and understanding of each other’s views.Results: The evaluation revealed that methods and online tools work as expected, as demonstrated by the assessments and policy support processes conducted. The approach improves the availability of information and especially of relevant details. Experts are ambivalent about the acceptability of openness – it is an important scientific principle, but it goes against many current research and decision-making practices. However, co-creation and openness are megatrends that are changing science, decision-making and the society at large. Against many experts’ fears, open participation has not caused problems in performing high-quality assessments. On the contrary, a key challenge is to motivate and help more experts, decision-makers and citizens to participate and share their views. Many methods within open policy practice have also been widely used in other contexts.Conclusions: Open policy practice proved to be a useful and coherent set of methods. It guided policy processes toward a more collaborative approach, whose purpose was wider understanding rather than winning a debate. There is potential for merging open policy practice with other open science and open decision process tools. Active facilitation, community building and improving the user-friendliness of the tools were identified as key solutions for improving the usability of the method in the future.
- 3 April 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Research Policy and Systems
- Vol. 18 (1) , 1-24
Open AccessFrom insight network to open policy practice: practical experiences
Background: Evidence-informed decision-making and better use of scientific information in societal decisions has been an area of development for decades but is still topical. Decision support work can be viewed from the perspective of information collection, synthesis and flow between decision-makers, experts and stakeholders. Open policy practice is a coherent set of methods for such work. It has been developed and utilised mostly in Finnish and European contexts.Methods: An overview of open policy practice is given, and theoretical and practical properties are evaluated based on properties of good policy support. The evaluation is based on information from several assessments and research projects developing and applying open policy practice and the authors’ practical experiences. The methods are evaluated against their capability of producing quality of content, applicability and efficiency in policy support as well as how well they support close interaction among participants and understanding of each other’s views.Results: The evaluation revealed that methods and online tools work as expected, as demonstrated by the assessments and policy support processes conducted. The approach improves the availability of information and especially of relevant details. Experts are ambivalent about the acceptability of openness – it is an important scientific principle, but it goes against many current research and decision-making practices. However, co-creation and openness are megatrends that are changing science, decision-making and the society at large. Against many experts’ fears, open participation has not caused problems in performing high-quality assessments. On the contrary, a key challenge is to motivate and help more experts, decision-makers and citizens to participate and share their views. Many methods within open policy practice have also been widely used in other contexts.Conclusions: Open policy practice proved to be a useful and coherent set of methods. It guided policy processes toward a more collaborative approach, whose purpose was wider understanding rather than winning a debate. There is potential for merging open policy practice with other open science and open decision process tools. Active facilitation, community building and improving the user-friendliness of the tools were identified as key solutions for improving the usability of the method in the future.
- Open Access
- 25 March 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Public Health
- Vol. 20 (1) , 1
Correction to: Health effects of nutrients and environmental pollutants in Baltic herring and salmon: a quantitative benefit-risk assessment
It was highlighted that the original article [1] contained a formatting error in the equations.
- 25 March 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Public Health
- Vol. 20 (1) , 1
Open AccessCorrection to: Health effects of nutrients and environmental pollutants in Baltic herring and salmon: a quantitative benefit-risk assessment
It was highlighted that the original article [1] contained a formatting error in the equations.
- Open Access
- 15 January 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Public Health
- Vol. 20 (1) , 1-18
Health effects of nutrients and environmental pollutants in Baltic herring and salmon: a quantitative benefit-risk assessment
Background: Health risks linked with dioxin in fish remain a complex policy issue. Fatty Baltic fish contain persistent pollutants, but they are otherwise healthy food. We studied the health benefits and risks associated with Baltic herring and salmon in four countries to identify critical uncertainties and to facilitate an evidence-based discussion. Methods: We performed an online survey investigating consumers’ fish consumption and its motivation in Denmark, Estonia, Finland, and Sweden. Dioxin and methylmercury concentrations were estimated based on Finnish studies. Exposure-response functions for several health endpoints were evaluated and quantified based on the scientific literature. We also quantified the infertility risk of men based on a recent European risk assessment estimating childhood dioxin exposure and its effect on sperm concentration later in life. Results: Baltic herring and salmon contain omega-3 fatty acids and vitamin D, and the beneficial impact of these fishes on cardiovascular diseases, mortality, and the risk of depression and cancer clearly outweighs risks of dioxins and methylmercury in people older than 45 years of age and in young men. Young women may expose their children to pollutants during pregnancy and breast feeding. This study suggests that even in this critical subgroup, the risks are small and the health benefits are greater than or at least similar to the health risks. Value of information analysis demonstrated that the remaining scientific uncertainties are not large. In contrast, there are several critical uncertainties that are inherently value judgements, such as whether exceeding the tolerable weekly intake is an adverse outcome as such; and whether or not subgroup-specific restrictions are problematic. Conclusions: The potential health risks attributable to dioxins in Baltic fish have more than halved in the past 10 years. The new risk assessment issued by the European Food Safety Authority clearly increases the fraction of the population exceeding the tolerable dioxin intake, but nonetheless, quantitative estimates of net health impacts change only marginally. Increased use of small herring (which have less pollutants) is a no-regret option. A more relevant value-based policy discussion rather than research is needed to clarify official recommendations related to dioxins in fish.
- 15 January 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Public Health
- Vol. 20 (1) , 1-18
Open AccessHealth effects of nutrients and environmental pollutants in Baltic herring and salmon: a quantitative benefit-risk assessment
Background: Health risks linked with dioxin in fish remain a complex policy issue. Fatty Baltic fish contain persistent pollutants, but they are otherwise healthy food. We studied the health benefits and risks associated with Baltic herring and salmon in four countries to identify critical uncertainties and to facilitate an evidence-based discussion. Methods: We performed an online survey investigating consumers’ fish consumption and its motivation in Denmark, Estonia, Finland, and Sweden. Dioxin and methylmercury concentrations were estimated based on Finnish studies. Exposure-response functions for several health endpoints were evaluated and quantified based on the scientific literature. We also quantified the infertility risk of men based on a recent European risk assessment estimating childhood dioxin exposure and its effect on sperm concentration later in life. Results: Baltic herring and salmon contain omega-3 fatty acids and vitamin D, and the beneficial impact of these fishes on cardiovascular diseases, mortality, and the risk of depression and cancer clearly outweighs risks of dioxins and methylmercury in people older than 45 years of age and in young men. Young women may expose their children to pollutants during pregnancy and breast feeding. This study suggests that even in this critical subgroup, the risks are small and the health benefits are greater than or at least similar to the health risks. Value of information analysis demonstrated that the remaining scientific uncertainties are not large. In contrast, there are several critical uncertainties that are inherently value judgements, such as whether exceeding the tolerable weekly intake is an adverse outcome as such; and whether or not subgroup-specific restrictions are problematic. Conclusions: The potential health risks attributable to dioxins in Baltic fish have more than halved in the past 10 years. The new risk assessment issued by the European Food Safety Authority clearly increases the fraction of the population exceeding the tolerable dioxin intake, but nonetheless, quantitative estimates of net health impacts change only marginally. Increased use of small herring (which have less pollutants) is a no-regret option. A more relevant value-based policy discussion rather than research is needed to clarify official recommendations related to dioxins in fish.