Mark Hubbe
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Mark Hubbe has a total of 250 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Walter A. Neves
Laboratório de Estudos Evolutivos e Ecológicos Humanos, Instituto de Biociências, Departamento de Genética e Biologia Evolutiva, Universidade de São Paulo
13 shared publications- Walter Alves Neves
Universidade de São Paulo
8 shared publications - André Strauss
Museu de Arqueologia e Etnologia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil
7 shared publications - Danilo Vicensotto Bernardo
Universidade Federal de Rio Grande
7 shared publications Alex Hubbe
6 shared publicationsKaterina Harvati
Institute for Archaeological Sciences, Palaeoanthropology and Senckenberg Centre for Human Evolution and Palaeoenvironment, University of Tuebingen, Tübingen 72070, Germany; DFG Center for Advanced Studies, "Words, Bones, Genes, Tools," University of Tübingen, Tübingen 72070, Germany
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 December 2025
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 11 (50) , eadd1047
Geochemical tales of individual lives in the industrial revolution: Untangling the impact of pollutant exposure in two English towns
England’s Industrial Revolution transformed natural environments. However, studies of this period are often limited to broad generalizations that neglect individuals’ lived experiences. Here, we explore industrialization’s impact at the individual scale by analyzing skeletal concentrations of pollutants (arsenic, barium, and lead) and evaluating biogenic versus diagenetic contributions. Analysis of the skeletal remains of 94 individuals from two 18th/19th century English towns, South Shields and Barton-upon-Humber, showed biogenic exposure to contaminants and variation in exposure by environment and biosocial identity. South Shields individuals showed higher concentrations of arsenic ( P < 0.001) and barium ( P = 0.013), while Barton-upon-Humber individuals showed higher concentrations of lead ( P = 0.020). Skeletal lead isotope ratios match geologic samples from throughout the United Kingdom, suggesting a wide network of anthropogenic lead consistent with widespread industrial activities. These findings reveal a spectrum of realities and lived experiences hidden between the dichotomy of rural versus urban industrial England.
- 12 December 2025
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 11 (50) , eadd1047
Open AccessGeochemical tales of individual lives in the industrial revolution: Untangling the impact of pollutant exposure in two English towns
England’s Industrial Revolution transformed natural environments. However, studies of this period are often limited to broad generalizations that neglect individuals’ lived experiences. Here, we explore industrialization’s impact at the individual scale by analyzing skeletal concentrations of pollutants (arsenic, barium, and lead) and evaluating biogenic versus diagenetic contributions. Analysis of the skeletal remains of 94 individuals from two 18th/19th century English towns, South Shields and Barton-upon-Humber, showed biogenic exposure to contaminants and variation in exposure by environment and biosocial identity. South Shields individuals showed higher concentrations of arsenic ( P < 0.001) and barium ( P = 0.013), while Barton-upon-Humber individuals showed higher concentrations of lead ( P = 0.020). Skeletal lead isotope ratios match geologic samples from throughout the United Kingdom, suggesting a wide network of anthropogenic lead consistent with widespread industrial activities. These findings reveal a spectrum of realities and lived experiences hidden between the dichotomy of rural versus urban industrial England.
- Open Access
- 3 December 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (12) , e0336484
Testing the taxonomy of Dmanisi hominin fossils through dental crown area
The Dmanisi paleoanthropological assemblage from Georgia is among the most debated collections of hominin fossils due to its early age and extreme morphological diversity relative to other Homo assemblages. This variability has been interpreted as a result of sexual dimorphism in the Homo erectus clade, in which Dmanisi hominins were traditionally classified. However, this hypothesis has been challenged by the proposal that the Dmanisi fossils represent more than one Homo species. Taxonomic assessments of the Pleistocene Georgian hominins have focused primarily on craniometric analyses, with fewer studies addressing dental morphology through metric approaches. Considering the value of dental crown area in reconstructing evolutionary relationships, a comparative sample of fossil hominins, consisting of 51 maxillary and 71 mandibular specimens (583 teeth in total), was analyzed using Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) to evaluate the diversity in the Dmanisi fossil assemblage. Morphological affinities were examined visually through the first two discriminant functions, and taxonomic relationships were tested via classification analyses based on posterior probabilities. The analyses show a strong association of the D4500-D2600 specimen with australopiths, and of the D2282-D211 and D2700-D2735 specimens with Homo species. The sexual dimorphism hypothesis was tested by comparing the ratios of mandibular postcanine dentition of Dmanisi specimens with male and female gorillas and chimpanzees, which suggests that dental crown area of the Pleistocene Georgian hominins could be the product of sexual dimorphism only if they came from species with similar levels of dimorphism than these great apes. We conclude that differences in crown dimensions support the hypothesis of two distinct taxa coexistent at the Dmanisi site, previously proposed to be Homo georgicus and Homo caucasi . This proposal has important implications for the dispersal of Homo out of Africa at the beginning of Pleistocene.
- 3 December 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (12) , e0336484
Open AccessTesting the taxonomy of Dmanisi hominin fossils through dental crown area
The Dmanisi paleoanthropological assemblage from Georgia is among the most debated collections of hominin fossils due to its early age and extreme morphological diversity relative to other Homo assemblages. This variability has been interpreted as a result of sexual dimorphism in the Homo erectus clade, in which Dmanisi hominins were traditionally classified. However, this hypothesis has been challenged by the proposal that the Dmanisi fossils represent more than one Homo species. Taxonomic assessments of the Pleistocene Georgian hominins have focused primarily on craniometric analyses, with fewer studies addressing dental morphology through metric approaches. Considering the value of dental crown area in reconstructing evolutionary relationships, a comparative sample of fossil hominins, consisting of 51 maxillary and 71 mandibular specimens (583 teeth in total), was analyzed using Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) to evaluate the diversity in the Dmanisi fossil assemblage. Morphological affinities were examined visually through the first two discriminant functions, and taxonomic relationships were tested via classification analyses based on posterior probabilities. The analyses show a strong association of the D4500-D2600 specimen with australopiths, and of the D2282-D211 and D2700-D2735 specimens with Homo species. The sexual dimorphism hypothesis was tested by comparing the ratios of mandibular postcanine dentition of Dmanisi specimens with male and female gorillas and chimpanzees, which suggests that dental crown area of the Pleistocene Georgian hominins could be the product of sexual dimorphism only if they came from species with similar levels of dimorphism than these great apes. We conclude that differences in crown dimensions support the hypothesis of two distinct taxa coexistent at the Dmanisi site, previously proposed to be Homo georgicus and Homo caucasi . This proposal has important implications for the dispersal of Homo out of Africa at the beginning of Pleistocene.
- Open Access
- 11 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 188 (3) , e70160
Toward a Biocultural Synthesis of the Peopling of the Americas: Introduction to the Special Issue
This article introduces the special issue Toward a Biocultural Synthesis of the Peopling of the Americas , which brings together contributions that explore the origins and diversity of Indigenous populations across North, Central, and South America and the Caribbean. The volume grew out of an invited symposium held at the 90th Annual Meeting of the American Association of Biological Anthropologists and reflects a shared commitment to methodological pluralism, regional specificity, and ethical collaboration. By integrating genetic, skeletal, linguistic, and archaeological data with Indigenous perspectives and regional histories, the papers assembled here challenge overly linear and homogenizing models of human dispersion. They highlight the value of explanatory dissonance—tensions between datasets, temporal scales, and epistemic traditions—as a productive resource for understanding the complexity of human history. The issue's contributions range from simulation models and morphometric analyses to isotopic reconstructions and linguistic typology, offering complementary insights into population continuity, interaction, and diversification across the Americas. Commentaries by María Nieves‐Colón and Rolando González‐José situate these studies within broader disciplinary and epistemic debates, emphasizing the need for integrative, decolonial, and collaborative approaches. Together, the articles and commentaries demonstrate that the most meaningful advances in the study of the peopling of the Americas now emerge from explicitly biocultural frameworks that link biological variation, cultural history, and ethical engagement in the production of anthropological knowledge.
- 11 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 188 (3) , e70160
Open AccessToward a Biocultural Synthesis of the Peopling of the Americas: Introduction to the Special Issue
This article introduces the special issue Toward a Biocultural Synthesis of the Peopling of the Americas , which brings together contributions that explore the origins and diversity of Indigenous populations across North, Central, and South America and the Caribbean. The volume grew out of an invited symposium held at the 90th Annual Meeting of the American Association of Biological Anthropologists and reflects a shared commitment to methodological pluralism, regional specificity, and ethical collaboration. By integrating genetic, skeletal, linguistic, and archaeological data with Indigenous perspectives and regional histories, the papers assembled here challenge overly linear and homogenizing models of human dispersion. They highlight the value of explanatory dissonance—tensions between datasets, temporal scales, and epistemic traditions—as a productive resource for understanding the complexity of human history. The issue's contributions range from simulation models and morphometric analyses to isotopic reconstructions and linguistic typology, offering complementary insights into population continuity, interaction, and diversification across the Americas. Commentaries by María Nieves‐Colón and Rolando González‐José situate these studies within broader disciplinary and epistemic debates, emphasizing the need for integrative, decolonial, and collaborative approaches. Together, the articles and commentaries demonstrate that the most meaningful advances in the study of the peopling of the Americas now emerge from explicitly biocultural frameworks that link biological variation, cultural history, and ethical engagement in the production of anthropological knowledge.
- Open Access
- 15 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 186 (4) , e70041
Early Life Stress and Long‐Term Survival in the Hamann‐Todd Collection
Objectives: The impact of physiological stress during growth and development on mortality has been a topic of intense interest in bioarchaeology and other disciplines. In this study, we analyze the association between survival and two markers of physiological stress, linear enamel hypoplasia (LEH) and adult stature, in a sample of 296 individuals from the Hamann‐Todd Osteological Collection (HTOC).Materials and Methods: The HTOC is among the most well‐known osteological collections in the discipline, representing low socioeconomic status individuals from early 20th century Cleveland, Ohio. Ages‐at‐death and demographic identifiers (sex and socially ascribed race) were known for all individuals in the sample. The association between the skeletal and dental markers of early life stress and survival was evaluated through Kaplan–Meier survival analysis, using log rank tests to analyze the significance of differences in survival among demographic groups.Results: Significant differences in survival were observed between demographic groups, regardless of LEH status or stature. However, there were no significant differences in survivorship by LEH presence in this sample, despite the expectation that periods of physiological stress during key stages of development contribute to long‐term health consequences such as suppressed immune function. For females, shorter statures were associated with a higher probability of survival, while there were no significant differences in survival for males based on stature.Discussion: It is likely that differences in survival observed in this sample of the HTOC are the consequence of other factors, most likely related to adult environmental quality, as opposed to early life stress.
- 15 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 186 (4) , e70041
Open AccessEarly Life Stress and Long‐Term Survival in the Hamann‐Todd Collection
Objectives: The impact of physiological stress during growth and development on mortality has been a topic of intense interest in bioarchaeology and other disciplines. In this study, we analyze the association between survival and two markers of physiological stress, linear enamel hypoplasia (LEH) and adult stature, in a sample of 296 individuals from the Hamann‐Todd Osteological Collection (HTOC).Materials and Methods: The HTOC is among the most well‐known osteological collections in the discipline, representing low socioeconomic status individuals from early 20th century Cleveland, Ohio. Ages‐at‐death and demographic identifiers (sex and socially ascribed race) were known for all individuals in the sample. The association between the skeletal and dental markers of early life stress and survival was evaluated through Kaplan–Meier survival analysis, using log rank tests to analyze the significance of differences in survival among demographic groups.Results: Significant differences in survival were observed between demographic groups, regardless of LEH status or stature. However, there were no significant differences in survivorship by LEH presence in this sample, despite the expectation that periods of physiological stress during key stages of development contribute to long‐term health consequences such as suppressed immune function. For females, shorter statures were associated with a higher probability of survival, while there were no significant differences in survival for males based on stature.Discussion: It is likely that differences in survival observed in this sample of the HTOC are the consequence of other factors, most likely related to adult environmental quality, as opposed to early life stress.
- Open Access
- 8 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 186 (1)
The relationship between cause of death and skeletal markers of physiological stress in the Hamann‐Todd collection
Objectives: Socioeconomic status, past stress events, and other factors may contribute to the cumulative burden of physiological stress, which influences an individual's susceptibility to mortality and cause of death (COD). Here, we explore the association between skeletal evidence of stress and COD in the Hamann‐Todd Osteological Collection (HTOC), a predominantly low socioeconomic status sample from the late 19th and early 20th century.Materials and Methods: Skeletal markers of stress including linear enamel hypoplasia (LEH), stature, and antemortem tooth loss (AMTL) were analyzed in 298 individuals in the HTOC. Recorded CODs were grouped into six broad categories and contrasted with stress indicators, ages‐at‐death, and demographic variables, using various parametric and non‐parametric statistical tests.Results: COD varied by socially ascribed race and sex within the sample. Overall, infectious diseases were more prevalent than degenerative diseases. Individuals that died of infectious diseases had significantly lower ages‐at‐death compared to degenerative diseases (p < 0.001). There was no association between LEH and COD (χ2 = 4.449, p = 0.487). Stature varied significantly across COD categories for males (F = 2.534, p = 0.032), but not females (F = 1.733, p = 0.132). Controlling for age‐at‐death, AMTL prevalence was associated with COD (H = 18.53, p = 0.002), with cardiovascular disease being associated with higher prevalence of AMTL.Discussion: These findings show that some skeletal stress indicators are associated with COD in the HTOC, but the causal pathways of these relationships are not clear. This study adds to growing bodies of literature exploring relationships between past stress events and susceptibility to mortality and long‐term consequences of poor living conditions for past individuals.
- 8 November 2024
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 186 (1)
Open AccessThe relationship between cause of death and skeletal markers of physiological stress in the Hamann‐Todd collection
Objectives: Socioeconomic status, past stress events, and other factors may contribute to the cumulative burden of physiological stress, which influences an individual's susceptibility to mortality and cause of death (COD). Here, we explore the association between skeletal evidence of stress and COD in the Hamann‐Todd Osteological Collection (HTOC), a predominantly low socioeconomic status sample from the late 19th and early 20th century.Materials and Methods: Skeletal markers of stress including linear enamel hypoplasia (LEH), stature, and antemortem tooth loss (AMTL) were analyzed in 298 individuals in the HTOC. Recorded CODs were grouped into six broad categories and contrasted with stress indicators, ages‐at‐death, and demographic variables, using various parametric and non‐parametric statistical tests.Results: COD varied by socially ascribed race and sex within the sample. Overall, infectious diseases were more prevalent than degenerative diseases. Individuals that died of infectious diseases had significantly lower ages‐at‐death compared to degenerative diseases (p < 0.001). There was no association between LEH and COD (χ2 = 4.449, p = 0.487). Stature varied significantly across COD categories for males (F = 2.534, p = 0.032), but not females (F = 1.733, p = 0.132). Controlling for age‐at‐death, AMTL prevalence was associated with COD (H = 18.53, p = 0.002), with cardiovascular disease being associated with higher prevalence of AMTL.Discussion: These findings show that some skeletal stress indicators are associated with COD in the HTOC, but the causal pathways of these relationships are not clear. This study adds to growing bodies of literature exploring relationships between past stress events and susceptibility to mortality and long‐term consequences of poor living conditions for past individuals.
- Open Access
- 19 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 185 (4) , e25034
Hidden in plain text: Uncovering hidden heterogeneity and social stratification in Ireland AD 1150–1800
Objectives: Between the Irish late medieval (AD 1150–c.1550) (LMP) and post‐medieval (AD c.1550–1800) (PMP) periods, colonial practices changed land ownership. Contextualizing these periods within a biocultural political economy framework supports increasing social inequality in the PMP, which we expect to be reflected in different skeletal markers of longevity and stress. Therefore, we hypothesized that widespread exposure to stressors and resource deprivation contributed to lower longevity in the PMP compared to the LMP, and that there would be greater variation between sites in the frequency of linear enamel hypoplasias (LEH) in the PMP.Materials and Methods: We estimated age and counted matched pairs of LEH on 526 adult skeletons from the Irish counties of Dublin, Kildare, Louth, and Meath. Age‐at‐death was compared through Kaplan–Meier survival functions and non‐parametric tests. Linear enamel hypoplasias prevalences were analyzed with Mann–Whitney U tests and Generalized Linear Models.Results: Age‐at‐death distribution changed between the LMP and PMP for males, with males experiencing an increase in median‐age‐at‐death. The same was untrue for females, who show no changes in median age‐at‐death. Analysis of LEH frequency per individual showed that variation between sites was significant in the post‐medieval period but not in the late medieval period.Conclusion: These results suggest that social organization contributed to embodied health experiences that varied across time periods. Specifically, populations from the PMP appear to have embodied greater social inequality in their more varied susceptibility to stress. Our work demonstrates the strength of pairing historical texts with the analysis of skeletal remains to evaluate the impact of social structures on biological frailty.
- 19 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 185 (4) , e25034
Open AccessHidden in plain text: Uncovering hidden heterogeneity and social stratification in Ireland AD 1150–1800
Objectives: Between the Irish late medieval (AD 1150–c.1550) (LMP) and post‐medieval (AD c.1550–1800) (PMP) periods, colonial practices changed land ownership. Contextualizing these periods within a biocultural political economy framework supports increasing social inequality in the PMP, which we expect to be reflected in different skeletal markers of longevity and stress. Therefore, we hypothesized that widespread exposure to stressors and resource deprivation contributed to lower longevity in the PMP compared to the LMP, and that there would be greater variation between sites in the frequency of linear enamel hypoplasias (LEH) in the PMP.Materials and Methods: We estimated age and counted matched pairs of LEH on 526 adult skeletons from the Irish counties of Dublin, Kildare, Louth, and Meath. Age‐at‐death was compared through Kaplan–Meier survival functions and non‐parametric tests. Linear enamel hypoplasias prevalences were analyzed with Mann–Whitney U tests and Generalized Linear Models.Results: Age‐at‐death distribution changed between the LMP and PMP for males, with males experiencing an increase in median‐age‐at‐death. The same was untrue for females, who show no changes in median age‐at‐death. Analysis of LEH frequency per individual showed that variation between sites was significant in the post‐medieval period but not in the late medieval period.Conclusion: These results suggest that social organization contributed to embodied health experiences that varied across time periods. Specifically, populations from the PMP appear to have embodied greater social inequality in their more varied susceptibility to stress. Our work demonstrates the strength of pairing historical texts with the analysis of skeletal remains to evaluate the impact of social structures on biological frailty.
- Open Access
- 26 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Anatomy
- Vol. 245 (5) , 699-724
Disparate and parallel craniofacial climatic adaptations in native populations of Asia, North America, and South America
Understanding the impact that climate had in shaping cranial variation is critical for inferring the evolutionary mechanisms that played a role in human diversification. Here, we provide a comprehensive study aiming to analyze the association between climate and cranial variation of high latitude populations living in temperate to cold environments of Asia, North America, and South America. For this, we compiled a large morphometric dataset (N = 2633), which was combined with climatic and genomic data. We tested the influence of climate on the facial skeleton, nasal protrusion, and cranial vault and through multiple statistical tests at two geographical scales: intracontinental and intercontinental. We show that populations living in cold areas share a morphological pattern characterized by an increase in nasal height, facial and orbital heights and widths, a decrease in facial protrusion, and larger, longer, and lower cranial vaults. There are also distinctive features; populations from north Asia present the tallest noses, largest faces, and cranial vaults of the whole sample. Nasal breadth dimensions show small values in Asians, large values in South Americans, and non‐significant changes in arctic North America. The morphological pattern in populations living at high latitude may be the result of parallel adaptation, as supported by physiological, morphometric, ecological, and genetic explanations, while the differences in magnitude and phenotypic expression could be due to the diverse population histories, severity of climate, and cultural strategies. Overall, our study shows that climate is a relevant factor shaping modern human morphology and it should be considered when studying modern human evolution and diversification.
- 26 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Anatomy
- Vol. 245 (5) , 699-724
Open AccessDisparate and parallel craniofacial climatic adaptations in native populations of Asia, North America, and South America
Understanding the impact that climate had in shaping cranial variation is critical for inferring the evolutionary mechanisms that played a role in human diversification. Here, we provide a comprehensive study aiming to analyze the association between climate and cranial variation of high latitude populations living in temperate to cold environments of Asia, North America, and South America. For this, we compiled a large morphometric dataset (N = 2633), which was combined with climatic and genomic data. We tested the influence of climate on the facial skeleton, nasal protrusion, and cranial vault and through multiple statistical tests at two geographical scales: intracontinental and intercontinental. We show that populations living in cold areas share a morphological pattern characterized by an increase in nasal height, facial and orbital heights and widths, a decrease in facial protrusion, and larger, longer, and lower cranial vaults. There are also distinctive features; populations from north Asia present the tallest noses, largest faces, and cranial vaults of the whole sample. Nasal breadth dimensions show small values in Asians, large values in South Americans, and non‐significant changes in arctic North America. The morphological pattern in populations living at high latitude may be the result of parallel adaptation, as supported by physiological, morphometric, ecological, and genetic explanations, while the differences in magnitude and phenotypic expression could be due to the diverse population histories, severity of climate, and cultural strategies. Overall, our study shows that climate is a relevant factor shaping modern human morphology and it should be considered when studying modern human evolution and diversification.
- Open Access
- 30 July 2024
- Published by Universidad Nacional de La Plata in Revista Argentina de Antropología Biológica
- Vol. 26 (2) , 082
Craniofacial morphological diversity of North, Central, and South America: Implications for discussions about oral biology and health
Craniofacial morphology plays an important role in many aspects of the masticatory function and the oral health of individuals, and as such should be considered a baseline for studies that aim to integrate anthropological and dentistry practices that can improve oral health, dental hygiene, and care practices in populations from different biological and cultural backgrounds. This article presents a synthesis of our current understanding of the craniofacial and dental variation among native populations of North, Central, and South America, as part of the special volume on “Anthropology meets Dentistry in Central America: Research and education in oral biology”. The article presents an overview of the history of the human occupation of the American continents, with special focus on how early and recent past events have contributed to the craniofacial morphological diversity observed in these continents. However, there is limited information about native Central American populations, and current inferences about them depend largely on extrapolating from what is known about North and South America. Given the current state of knowledge, this article argues that modern Central Americans share a facial morphological pattern distinct from other populations worldwide, which means that applying models developed for other groups may not be appropriate in this context. Therefore, understanding regional variation in craniofacial morphological patterns is an important priority of study, which must consider the different cumulative factors (genetics, developmental, cultural, and historical) that have differently influenced the biological and cultural history of the populations in the region.
- 30 July 2024
- Published by Universidad Nacional de La Plata in Revista Argentina de Antropología Biológica
- Vol. 26 (2) , 082
Open AccessCraniofacial morphological diversity of North, Central, and South America: Implications for discussions about oral biology and health
Craniofacial morphology plays an important role in many aspects of the masticatory function and the oral health of individuals, and as such should be considered a baseline for studies that aim to integrate anthropological and dentistry practices that can improve oral health, dental hygiene, and care practices in populations from different biological and cultural backgrounds. This article presents a synthesis of our current understanding of the craniofacial and dental variation among native populations of North, Central, and South America, as part of the special volume on “Anthropology meets Dentistry in Central America: Research and education in oral biology”. The article presents an overview of the history of the human occupation of the American continents, with special focus on how early and recent past events have contributed to the craniofacial morphological diversity observed in these continents. However, there is limited information about native Central American populations, and current inferences about them depend largely on extrapolating from what is known about North and South America. Given the current state of knowledge, this article argues that modern Central Americans share a facial morphological pattern distinct from other populations worldwide, which means that applying models developed for other groups may not be appropriate in this context. Therefore, understanding regional variation in craniofacial morphological patterns is an important priority of study, which must consider the different cumulative factors (genetics, developmental, cultural, and historical) that have differently influenced the biological and cultural history of the populations in the region.
- Open Access
- 30 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in The Anatomical Record
- Vol. 307 (11) , 3519-3528
Systemic versus local patterns of limb joint articular morphology inferred from relative distances from morphological centroid
Joint morphogenesis is a complex process known to require the interaction of developmental cascades and mechanical loading, yet many details of this interaction are incompletely understood. While prior work has established populational patterns of joint morphological (co)variance, exploring how these patterns manifest within the individual provides information on the deployment of morphogenic processes as either systemic or local influences on joint shape. To better identify the patterns of variance‐generating morphogenic processes, this study investigates the degree to which individual joint shapes deviate from population averages systematically across the body. Using three‐dimensional landmark data from 200 adult skeletons, we ranked individuals based on their distances from morphological centroids for eight major joints. Spearman correlations assessed associations between ranks across various articular pairings, testing hypotheses regarding systemic versus localized variance. Results reveal low coordination between deviations observed in conarticular surfaces, functional analogs, and same‐bone surfaces; however strong associations exist between antimeres, suggesting the left–right deployment of variance‐generating morphogenic patterns is highly consistent. These results support a model of localized rather than systemic processes driving variation in joint shape. While more remains to be elucidated about the specifics of articular surface morphogenesis, these findings advance our understanding of the systems of variance generation at play during development and growth of our definitive joint morphology.
- 30 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in The Anatomical Record
- Vol. 307 (11) , 3519-3528
Open AccessSystemic versus local patterns of limb joint articular morphology inferred from relative distances from morphological centroid
Joint morphogenesis is a complex process known to require the interaction of developmental cascades and mechanical loading, yet many details of this interaction are incompletely understood. While prior work has established populational patterns of joint morphological (co)variance, exploring how these patterns manifest within the individual provides information on the deployment of morphogenic processes as either systemic or local influences on joint shape. To better identify the patterns of variance‐generating morphogenic processes, this study investigates the degree to which individual joint shapes deviate from population averages systematically across the body. Using three‐dimensional landmark data from 200 adult skeletons, we ranked individuals based on their distances from morphological centroids for eight major joints. Spearman correlations assessed associations between ranks across various articular pairings, testing hypotheses regarding systemic versus localized variance. Results reveal low coordination between deviations observed in conarticular surfaces, functional analogs, and same‐bone surfaces; however strong associations exist between antimeres, suggesting the left–right deployment of variance‐generating morphogenic patterns is highly consistent. These results support a model of localized rather than systemic processes driving variation in joint shape. While more remains to be elucidated about the specifics of articular surface morphogenesis, these findings advance our understanding of the systems of variance generation at play during development and growth of our definitive joint morphology.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by FapUNIFESP (SciELO) in Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências
- Vol. 96 (3) , e20230680
The taxonomy of Sahelanthropus tchadensis from a craniometric perspective
Sahelanthropus tchadensis has raised much debate since its initial discovery in Chad in 2001, given its controversial classification as the earliest representative of the hominin lineage. This debate extends beyond the phylogenetic position of the species, and includes several aspects of its habitual behavior, especially in what regards its locomotion. The combination of ancestral and derived traits observed in the fossils associated with the species has been used to defend different hypotheses related to its relationship to hominins. Here, the cranial morphology of Sahelanthropus tchadensis was assessed through 16 linear craniometric measurements, and compared to great apes and hominins through Principal Component Analysis based on size and shape and shape information alone. The results show that S. tchadensis share stronger morphological affinities with hominins than with apes for both the analysis that include size information and the one that evaluates shape alone. Since TM 266-01-060-1 shows a strong morphological affinity with the remaining hominins represented in the analysis, our results support the initial interpretations that S. tchadensis represents an early specimen of our lineage or a stem basal lineage more closely related to hominins than to Panini.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by FapUNIFESP (SciELO) in Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências
- Vol. 96 (3) , e20230680
Open AccessThe taxonomy of Sahelanthropus tchadensis from a craniometric perspective
Sahelanthropus tchadensis has raised much debate since its initial discovery in Chad in 2001, given its controversial classification as the earliest representative of the hominin lineage. This debate extends beyond the phylogenetic position of the species, and includes several aspects of its habitual behavior, especially in what regards its locomotion. The combination of ancestral and derived traits observed in the fossils associated with the species has been used to defend different hypotheses related to its relationship to hominins. Here, the cranial morphology of Sahelanthropus tchadensis was assessed through 16 linear craniometric measurements, and compared to great apes and hominins through Principal Component Analysis based on size and shape and shape information alone. The results show that S. tchadensis share stronger morphological affinities with hominins than with apes for both the analysis that include size information and the one that evaluates shape alone. Since TM 266-01-060-1 shows a strong morphological affinity with the remaining hominins represented in the analysis, our results support the initial interpretations that S. tchadensis represents an early specimen of our lineage or a stem basal lineage more closely related to hominins than to Panini.