RPRik Peels

Rik Peels

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Rik Peels has a total of 70 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    How to Conceptualize Religiosity in Explanations of Radicalization

    by Rik Peels

    This article is an exercise in synthetic philosophy: it synthesizes the results from empirical studies on radicalization with insights from analytic philosophy. The purpose is to better conceptualize religiosity in explanations of radicalization, as existing conceptualizations are deficient but have not been countered with better alternatives. After a few preliminary conceptual remarks on radicalization and the related notions of extremism, fanaticism, fundamentalism, radical conspiracy theorizing, and terrorism, I first briefly sketch the debate in radicalization studies and indicate how it leaves a gap for a better conceptualization of religiosity. I then provide that conceptualization, which I call the ‘Four Domains’ conceptualization of religiosity. Subsequently, I show how this conceptualization ties in with recent developments in the philosophy of religion. Finally, I lay out how first-person or emic research, particularly semi-structured interviews that are meant to construe a person’s life-story narrative, are particularly well suited to study the role of religiosity in people’s processes of radicalization.

  • Open Access

    Mapping the concept of fundamentalism: a scoping review

    by Nora Kindermann, Rik Peels, Anke I. Liefbroer, Linda Schoonmade

    This scoping review of conceptualizations of fundamentalism scrutinizes the concept's domain of application, defining characteristics, and liability to bias. We find fundamentalism in four domains of application: Christianity, other Abrahamic religions, non-Abrahamic religions, and non-religious phenomena. The defining characteristics which we identify are organized into five categories: belief, behavior, emotion, goal, and structure. We find that different kinds of fundamentalisms are defined by different characteristics, with violent and oppressive behaviors, and political beliefs and goals being emphasized for non-Christian fundamentalisms. Additionally, we find that the locus of fundamentalism studies is the Global North. Based on these findings, we conclude that the concept is prone to bias. When conceptualizing fundamentalism, three considerations deserve attention: the mutual dependency between the domain of application and the specification of defining characteristics; the question of usefulness of scientific concepts; and the connection between conceptual ambiguity and the risk of bias in the study of fundamentalism.


  • Open Access

    Introduction: Replicating John Hedley Brooke’s Work on the History of Science and Religion

    by Rik Peels, Gijsbert van Den Brink, Hans van Eyghen, Rachel S. A. Pear

    In this introduction, we first briefly describe the replication crisis as it occurred primarily in the biomedical and social sciences. We then argue for the possibility and desirability of replication in the humanities, particularly historiography. After that, we clarify why we opted for the replication of John Hedley Brooke’s 1991 book Science and Religion: Some Historical Perspectives, specifically its third chapter. We elucidate why we chose to do both a direct and a conceptual replication. Finally, we lay out the procedures we used to conduct the two replication studies and look ahead to what is to come in this thematic section.


  • Open Access

    Replication in the Humanities in Action: Reflections on a Direct and a Conceptual Replication in the History of Science and Religion

    by Rik Peels, Rachel S. A. Pear, Hans van Eyghen, Gijsbert van Den Brink

    In this article, we reflect on our direct and conceptual replications, the results of which were presented in the previous two articles in this thematic section. While those articles are primarily meant to report the findings of the replications, we here seek to explore what the process and its results mean for replication in historiography. First, we discuss what we consider the main challenges we encountered in both replication studies and how we dealt with them. Then, we present what we consider the eight main lessons learned from both replication studies. Subsequently, we return to various objections and hesitations that have been raised regarding replication in the humanities in general and historiography in particular. We explore whether our findings and reflections shed new light on how those objections and hesitations should be dealt with. Finally, we draw some conclusions.


  • Open Access

    Jewish Responses to Copernican Thought: A Conceptual Replication of John Hedley Brooke’s Chapter on Scientific and Religious Reform

    by Rachel S. A. Pear, Gijsbert van Den Brink, Rik Peels

    This article explores how replication might work in the study of history through the presentation of a test case. Specifically, chapter 3 of historian John Hedley Brooke’s seminal book Science and Religion: Some Historical Perspectives (1991) was chosen for this experiment by an interdisciplinary team, as it is a cornerstone study in the history of science and religion. This article details the “conceptual replication” undertaken, that is, a study in which the research protocol of the original study was modified while the main research question stayed the same. Brooke studied the responses of Protestants and Roman Catholics to Copernican thought to examine the widely held belief that those who had recently gone through the Protestant Reformation would be more open to the new astronomy than Catholics. Our conceptual replication investigates what historians have written about Jewish responses to Copernican thought and how these findings impact the question of the relationship between religious and scientific reform. The preliminary conclusion of this replication study is that historians of the Jewish responses to the new astronomy seem to support Brooke’s view that such responses were determined by more than just theological or denominational considerations, since other factors (e.g., social ones) played a more constitutive role.


  • Open Access

    Brooke on the Merton Thesis: A Direct Replication of John Hedley Brooke’s Chapter on Scientific and Religious Reform

    by Hans van Eyghen, Gijsbert van Den Brink, Rik Peels

    Awareness of the need for replication studies is growing in multiple disciplines. Replication in history and the humanities, however, is close to nonexistent. This article presents the results of a direct replication of John Hedley Brooke’s study into the role of Puritanism in increasing the legitimacy of (practical or applied) science. The study serves as a pilot for the possibility and feasibility of replication in history. We give an overview of both what replication studies are and Brooke’s original study. We subsequently revisit Brooke’s study. For this purpose, we reconstruct Brooke’s research protocol, revisit his sources, and include some new sources. We note minor points of divergence with the interpretation of sources on the dominance of Puritans in applied sciences. We conclude that the pilot study shows the importance of replication for history and that replication in history raises new challenges for replication studies.


  • Open Access

    Replication studies in the Netherlands: Lessons learned and recommendations for funders, publishers and editors, and universities

    by Maarten Derksen, Stephanie Meirmans, Jonna Brenninkmeijer, Jeannette Pols, Annemarijn de Boer, Hans van Eyghen, Surya Gayet, Rolf Groenwold, Dennis Hernaus, Pim Huijnen, et al.

    Drawing on our experiences conducting replications we describe the lessons we learned about replication studies and formulate recommendations for researchers, policy makers, and funders about the role of replication in science and how it should be supported and funded. We first identify a variety of benefits of doing replication studies. Next, we argue that it is often necessary to improve aspects of the original study, even if that means deviating from the original protocol. Thirdly, we argue that replication studies highlight the importance of and need for more transparency of the research process, but also make clear how difficult that is. Fourthly, we underline that it is worth trying out replication in the humanities. We finish by formulating recommendations regarding reproduction and replication research, aimed specifically at funders, editors and publishers, and universities and other research institutes.


  • Progress in Theology

    by Gijsbert van Den Brink, Rik Peels, Bethany Sollereder

    This introductory chapter starts with a brief exploration of the debate on the roots of contemporary climate change in order to highlight the continuing relevance of theology. This then leads to a consideration of theology’s contested status as an academic discipline, especially in relation to the scientistic charge that theology does not (like the sciences) make any progress. Indeed, many theologians themselves seem hesitant to adhere to progress as an ideal or norm for their discipline. These observations elicit the twofold agenda of this book: investigating whether epistemic progress is being made in theology and exploring theology’s task to critically reflect on progress as an overarching cultural ideal. In light of this, the set-up of the volume is explained and an overview of the individual contributions is provided. The chapter ends with an acknowledgements section.

  • Epistemic, Moral, and Religious Progress in Theology

    by Rik Peels

    This chapter first explores what kinds of objections related to the alleged lack of progress have been levelled against theology. It then goes on to argue that, contrary to what some might expect, there is plenty of progress along rather different dimensions in theology: epistemic, moral, and religious. These are different dimensions of progress with their own goals. But even in each of these different dimensions we encounter various ways in which such progress can be made. Moreover, the chapter argues that we can actually show that there is such progress. Objections on the basis of the alleged lack of progress miss out on the manifold dimensions of progress and the distinct nature of theology in comparison with the natural sciences. Finally, a suggestion is made about how even further progress can be made, namely when it comes to the integration of these three different dimensions of progress.