Tamara Hervey
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Tamara Hervey has a total of 161 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mark L. Flear
School of Law, Queen’s University Belfast
7 shared publications - Martin McKee
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine
7 shared publications - Anniek de Ruijter
Faculty of Law, University of Amsterdam Nieuwe Achtergracht 166, 1018 WV Amsterdam The Netherlands
6 shared publications - Aurélie Mahalatchimy
International, Comparative and European Laws, CNRS, Aix-Marseille University, Aix-en-Provence, France, France
3 shared publications - Jean V. McHale
University of Birmingham
3 shared publications - Scott L. Greer
University of Michigan
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 July 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
When Coordinators Legislate: The HTA Coordination Group’s Guiding Principles on Data Transparency and the Limits of Institutional Self-Empowerment
On 14 May 2026, the Member State Coordination Group on Health Technology Assessment (HTA Coordination Group) adopted Guiding Principles on Data Transparency under Article 3(7), points (c) and (h), of Regulation (EU) 2021/2282. The document opens with a disclaimer of legal force; its operational architecture, a self-authored definition of ‘commercially confidential information’, a categorical declaration that broad classes of clinical data are in general non-confidential, and a recourse procedure run by the same family of actors that produced the rule, has consequences that the disclaimer cannot dissolve. We argue that the Guiding Principles sit uneasily with EU lex specialis on commercial confidentiality and with case-by-case jurisprudence on disclosure; that, in producing them, the HTA Coordination Group has concentrated rulemaking, executive and quasi-judicial functions in a manner that engages the principle of conferred powers, the Meroni doctrine, and Articles 41 and 47 of the Charter; and that the corrective is institutional rather than substantive: the problem lies in how the rules were made and by whom, not only in their content.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessWhen Coordinators Legislate: The HTA Coordination Group’s Guiding Principles on Data Transparency and the Limits of Institutional Self-Empowerment
On 14 May 2026, the Member State Coordination Group on Health Technology Assessment (HTA Coordination Group) adopted Guiding Principles on Data Transparency under Article 3(7), points (c) and (h), of Regulation (EU) 2021/2282. The document opens with a disclaimer of legal force; its operational architecture, a self-authored definition of ‘commercially confidential information’, a categorical declaration that broad classes of clinical data are in general non-confidential, and a recourse procedure run by the same family of actors that produced the rule, has consequences that the disclaimer cannot dissolve. We argue that the Guiding Principles sit uneasily with EU lex specialis on commercial confidentiality and with case-by-case jurisprudence on disclosure; that, in producing them, the HTA Coordination Group has concentrated rulemaking, executive and quasi-judicial functions in a manner that engages the principle of conferred powers, the Meroni doctrine, and Articles 41 and 47 of the Charter; and that the corrective is institutional rather than substantive: the problem lies in how the rules were made and by whom, not only in their content.
- Open Access
- 4 June 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Health Economics, Policy and Law
- Vol. 21 (3) , 1-16
Tobacco end-game policies and the intrinsic connection of health and EU market law
This article explores the relationship between EU internal market law and ambitious tobacco end-game policies, using the United Kingdom’s proposed smoke-free generation measure and its application to Northern Ireland under the Windsor Framework as a focal case. Responding to objections raised by EU Member States through the Technical Regulations Information System (TRIS), the article develops an interpretative framework that situates free movement rules within the EU’s broader constitutional commitment to public health protection. Drawing on a doctrinal analysis of EU primary law, the Tobacco Products Directive, EU Court of Justice case law, and the TRIS submissions themselves, the article challenges claims that generational sales bans are inherently incompatible with EU law. It argues that such claims rely on narrow and selective readings of internal market doctrine that overlook the extent to which health protection is embedded in EU market regulation. The analysis demonstrates that EU law leaves significant regulatory space for national authorities to pursue proportionate, evidence-based tobacco control measures, including end-game strategies. Beyond the immediate UK–Northern Ireland context, the findings have broader implications for innovative public health regulation within the EU, contributing to ongoing debates at the intersection of health policy, regulatory governance, and economic integration.
- 4 June 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Health Economics, Policy and Law
- Vol. 21 (3) , 1-16
Open AccessTobacco end-game policies and the intrinsic connection of health and EU market law
This article explores the relationship between EU internal market law and ambitious tobacco end-game policies, using the United Kingdom’s proposed smoke-free generation measure and its application to Northern Ireland under the Windsor Framework as a focal case. Responding to objections raised by EU Member States through the Technical Regulations Information System (TRIS), the article develops an interpretative framework that situates free movement rules within the EU’s broader constitutional commitment to public health protection. Drawing on a doctrinal analysis of EU primary law, the Tobacco Products Directive, EU Court of Justice case law, and the TRIS submissions themselves, the article challenges claims that generational sales bans are inherently incompatible with EU law. It argues that such claims rely on narrow and selective readings of internal market doctrine that overlook the extent to which health protection is embedded in EU market regulation. The analysis demonstrates that EU law leaves significant regulatory space for national authorities to pursue proportionate, evidence-based tobacco control measures, including end-game strategies. Beyond the immediate UK–Northern Ireland context, the findings have broader implications for innovative public health regulation within the EU, contributing to ongoing debates at the intersection of health policy, regulatory governance, and economic integration.
- Open Access
- 5 May 2026
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in European Journal of Health Law
- Vol. -1 (aop) , 1-23
Understanding European Union Substances of Human Origin Case Law through Defragmentation and Fragmentation
Regulation of Substances of Human Origin (SoHO) is an important topic of Union health law both in the context of research and in the context of healthcare services and treatment of patients. When we observe Union SoHO law, we do not only observe a linear movement towards greater harmonisation and less differentiation between national laws. At the same time as the ‘expected’ harmonisation processes of an inexorable process of greater Union law coverage of a field, and less space for national difference, we also observe counter-processes in the opposite direction. Focusing on the role of the Court of Justice of the Union to understand the dynamics of Union regulation of the sector through the analysis of 19 SoHO cases, this article proposes two new legal analytical concepts to explain these processes: ‘defragmentation’ and ‘fragmentation’ which provide an explanatory model as a tool of legal science to use to promote greater understanding of Union law.
- 5 May 2026
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in European Journal of Health Law
- Vol. -1 (aop) , 1-23
Open AccessUnderstanding European Union Substances of Human Origin Case Law through Defragmentation and Fragmentation
Regulation of Substances of Human Origin (SoHO) is an important topic of Union health law both in the context of research and in the context of healthcare services and treatment of patients. When we observe Union SoHO law, we do not only observe a linear movement towards greater harmonisation and less differentiation between national laws. At the same time as the ‘expected’ harmonisation processes of an inexorable process of greater Union law coverage of a field, and less space for national difference, we also observe counter-processes in the opposite direction. Focusing on the role of the Court of Justice of the Union to understand the dynamics of Union regulation of the sector through the analysis of 19 SoHO cases, this article proposes two new legal analytical concepts to explain these processes: ‘defragmentation’ and ‘fragmentation’ which provide an explanatory model as a tool of legal science to use to promote greater understanding of Union law.
- Open Access
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in European Journal of Health Law
- Vol. 33 (4) , 1-33
Conceptualising European Union Health Law
A collectively authored article, which (unusually in legal scholarship) makes explicit the processes and methodologies by which ‘European Union health law’ is conceptualised; the implications; and the strengths and weaknesses of the approach taken. Strengths include implied structural and systemic coherence; and the breadth of analysis that having a large team of authors permits, through holding their positionalities in creative interplay with each other. The authors argue that European Union health law — defined as transversal and distinctively European Union law that either directly or indirectly affects human health, in a broad sense — should be understood through a metaphor of growth and connectedness, specifically a ‘tree’. The article seeks to initiate a discussion not only about European Union health law, but also about European law and health law.
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in European Journal of Health Law
- Vol. 33 (4) , 1-33
Open AccessConceptualising European Union Health Law
A collectively authored article, which (unusually in legal scholarship) makes explicit the processes and methodologies by which ‘European Union health law’ is conceptualised; the implications; and the strengths and weaknesses of the approach taken. Strengths include implied structural and systemic coherence; and the breadth of analysis that having a large team of authors permits, through holding their positionalities in creative interplay with each other. The authors argue that European Union health law — defined as transversal and distinctively European Union law that either directly or indirectly affects human health, in a broad sense — should be understood through a metaphor of growth and connectedness, specifically a ‘tree’. The article seeks to initiate a discussion not only about European Union health law, but also about European law and health law.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2024
- Vol. 26 (2) , 91-104
Securing the Right to Health of Asylum Seekers
Deploying legal analysis and a small-scale qualitative dataset, this paper considers the right to health of asylum seekers, as a subgroup of distress migrants, in Greece in the years preceding the COVID-19 pandemic and thereafter. The public health care system in Greece is operating under significant constraints stemming from austerity policies. We analyze the legal entitlements of asylum seekers as found in Greek and international law and confirm a significant gap between the right to health in theory and the right to health in practice. While some administrative matters have improved, in general, widespread human rights failures to provide the right to health for vulnerable asylum seekers arriving in Greece continue. In particular, shortcomings in the health care system’s capacity and structure, as well as poor arrangements to secure the underlying conditions for good health, affect the practical realization of the right to health of asylum seekers, many of whom have complex health needs.
- 1 December 2024
- Vol. 26 (2) , 91-104
Open AccessSecuring the Right to Health of Asylum Seekers
Deploying legal analysis and a small-scale qualitative dataset, this paper considers the right to health of asylum seekers, as a subgroup of distress migrants, in Greece in the years preceding the COVID-19 pandemic and thereafter. The public health care system in Greece is operating under significant constraints stemming from austerity policies. We analyze the legal entitlements of asylum seekers as found in Greek and international law and confirm a significant gap between the right to health in theory and the right to health in practice. While some administrative matters have improved, in general, widespread human rights failures to provide the right to health for vulnerable asylum seekers arriving in Greece continue. In particular, shortcomings in the health care system’s capacity and structure, as well as poor arrangements to secure the underlying conditions for good health, affect the practical realization of the right to health of asylum seekers, many of whom have complex health needs.
- Open Access
- 15 October 2024
- Published by McMaster University Library in International Journal for Students as Partners
- Vol. 8 (2) , 241-259
Voices from the field
- 15 October 2024
- Published by McMaster University Library in International Journal for Students as Partners
- Vol. 8 (2) , 241-259
Open AccessVoices from the field
- Open Access
- 4 October 2024
- Published by School of Law, Queen's University Belfast in Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly
- Vol. 75 (3) , 522-549
Social Rights under Article 2(1) of the Protocol on Ireland and Northern Ireland
The impact of Brexit upon the protection of social rights has received comparatively little attention, both in the public media and the academic literature. Social progress achieved on the island of Ireland since the conclusion of the Good Friday/Belfast Agreement can be seen as a product of that Agreement and Irish and British European Union (EU) membership – the former has generated the stability necessary for citizens to enjoy the opportunities and protection afforded by the latter. Brexit has put this social progress at risk and has already led to rights backsliding in social contexts. However, the mechanism created by the Protocol on Ireland and Northern Ireland to address diminutions of rights flowing from Brexit – article 2(1) – is not, we contend, suitable for preventing diminutions in social rights. We demonstrate in this article that the test for breach of article 2(1) focuses on specific breaches of individual rights and therefore does not cover situations in which regression in rights protection cannot be tied empirically to individual circumstances. The enjoyment of social rights on the island of Ireland is often facilitated by horizontally applicable EU law, and changes in levels of protection of social rights are often best observed at the population level over time. Using several case studies, we demonstrate how social rights backsliding on the island of Ireland that is attributable wholly or mainly to Brexit likely cannot be litigated through the application of article 2(1) of the Protocol, and we reflect upon the inadequacy of this situation.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by School of Law, Queen's University Belfast in Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly
- Vol. 75 (3) , 522-549
Open AccessSocial Rights under Article 2(1) of the Protocol on Ireland and Northern Ireland
The impact of Brexit upon the protection of social rights has received comparatively little attention, both in the public media and the academic literature. Social progress achieved on the island of Ireland since the conclusion of the Good Friday/Belfast Agreement can be seen as a product of that Agreement and Irish and British European Union (EU) membership – the former has generated the stability necessary for citizens to enjoy the opportunities and protection afforded by the latter. Brexit has put this social progress at risk and has already led to rights backsliding in social contexts. However, the mechanism created by the Protocol on Ireland and Northern Ireland to address diminutions of rights flowing from Brexit – article 2(1) – is not, we contend, suitable for preventing diminutions in social rights. We demonstrate in this article that the test for breach of article 2(1) focuses on specific breaches of individual rights and therefore does not cover situations in which regression in rights protection cannot be tied empirically to individual circumstances. The enjoyment of social rights on the island of Ireland is often facilitated by horizontally applicable EU law, and changes in levels of protection of social rights are often best observed at the population level over time. Using several case studies, we demonstrate how social rights backsliding on the island of Ireland that is attributable wholly or mainly to Brexit likely cannot be litigated through the application of article 2(1) of the Protocol, and we reflect upon the inadequacy of this situation.
- Open Access
- 13 September 2024
- Published by Elsevier in The Lancet Regional Health - Europe
- Vol. 46, 101047
Solidarity and trust in European Union health governance: three ways forward
- 13 September 2024
- Published by Elsevier in The Lancet Regional Health - Europe
- Vol. 46, 101047
Open AccessSolidarity and trust in European Union health governance: three ways forward
- Open Access
- 6 February 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 65-78
Management of the European Union's (Internal and External) Borders during the COVID-19 Pandemic
Free movement of persons is a core ‘constitutional’ value of the EU. Yet in March 2020, EU Member States closed their borders, restricting free movement of persons. These diverging national measures triggered an EU-level response—mainly through soft law—aiming to coordinate travel restrictions and facilitate the free movement of EU citizens where possible. Over time, the administrative practicalities of reopening borders led to a ‘hardening’ of soft law, including through digital vaccination ‘passports’. EU measures focused on openness/freedom and lifting restrictions on cross-border movements, rather than on a preventative/population health focus on containment as a public health response. Further, roles for law were diminished, meaning that scrutiny of executive power deployed to control borders within and at the edges of the EU was also diminished. Effective public health governance should be subject to the rule of law: the EU’s Covid-19 border law and policy was insufficiently so.
- 6 February 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 65-78
Open AccessManagement of the European Union's (Internal and External) Borders during the COVID-19 Pandemic
Free movement of persons is a core ‘constitutional’ value of the EU. Yet in March 2020, EU Member States closed their borders, restricting free movement of persons. These diverging national measures triggered an EU-level response—mainly through soft law—aiming to coordinate travel restrictions and facilitate the free movement of EU citizens where possible. Over time, the administrative practicalities of reopening borders led to a ‘hardening’ of soft law, including through digital vaccination ‘passports’. EU measures focused on openness/freedom and lifting restrictions on cross-border movements, rather than on a preventative/population health focus on containment as a public health response. Further, roles for law were diminished, meaning that scrutiny of executive power deployed to control borders within and at the edges of the EU was also diminished. Effective public health governance should be subject to the rule of law: the EU’s Covid-19 border law and policy was insufficiently so.
- 21 March 2023
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 374-393
Abortion law in Europe: the promise and pitfalls of human rights and transnational trade law in the face of criminalization with exceptions
The fairly general consensus position on abortion law across Europe is that of partial decriminalization or, more accurately, criminalization with exceptions. Women in most European countries are able to access abortion, but currently there is no broad individual right to abortion on request. By contrast, abortion is generally a criminal offence. However, the law in each country offers various exceptions to that rule. The specific conditions of decriminalization and consequent access to lawful abortion vary substantially among European countries. These usually establish exceptions (rape, fetal abnormalities, risk to life or health of the woman, emergency/necessity) and other alternative requirements, such as a gestational term, mandatory counselling and waiting periods, parental and/or judicial consent in the case of minors, and limitations related to the type and number of healthcare professionals who need to be involved in the procedure. We show that this position is vulnerable to worrying indications that the direction of travel in Europe is away from liberalization, autonomy or human rights protection, and towards greater restrictions on women’s access to abortion. We consider possible legal and other strategies for women’s empowerment, including cross-border provision of abortion services in Europe.
- 21 March 2023
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 374-393
Abortion law in Europe: the promise and pitfalls of human rights and transnational trade law in the face of criminalization with exceptions
The fairly general consensus position on abortion law across Europe is that of partial decriminalization or, more accurately, criminalization with exceptions. Women in most European countries are able to access abortion, but currently there is no broad individual right to abortion on request. By contrast, abortion is generally a criminal offence. However, the law in each country offers various exceptions to that rule. The specific conditions of decriminalization and consequent access to lawful abortion vary substantially among European countries. These usually establish exceptions (rape, fetal abnormalities, risk to life or health of the woman, emergency/necessity) and other alternative requirements, such as a gestational term, mandatory counselling and waiting periods, parental and/or judicial consent in the case of minors, and limitations related to the type and number of healthcare professionals who need to be involved in the procedure. We show that this position is vulnerable to worrying indications that the direction of travel in Europe is away from liberalization, autonomy or human rights protection, and towards greater restrictions on women’s access to abortion. We consider possible legal and other strategies for women’s empowerment, including cross-border provision of abortion services in Europe.